Hayley Carter
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Hayley Carter has a total of 31 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Benjamin E. Smith
Physiotherapy Outpatients, Level 3, Florence Nightingale Community Hospital, Derby, UK
5 shared publications- Benjamin Edward Smith
Physiotherapy Outpatients, Florence Nightingale Community Hospital, University Hospitals of Derby and Burton NHS Foundation Trust, Derby, UK
5 shared publications Fiona Moffatt
School of Health Sciences, University of Nottingham, Queen’s Medical Centre, Nottingham, UK
5 shared publicationsPaul Leighton
School of Medicine, University of Nottingham, Queens Medical Centre, Nottingham, UK
5 shared publicationsCharlotte Dodsley
Patient Representative, The POP-ACLR Study, Derby, UK
4 shared publicationsJoshua McCallion
Patient Representative, The POP-ACLR Study, Derby, UK
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Musculoskeletal Care
- Vol. 24 (2) , e70237
Non‐Surgical Management of People With Frozen Shoulder in the National Health Service: A Review of Publicly Available Patient Information Leaflets
Background: Frozen shoulder, also known as adhesive capsulitis, is a common and disabling condition that causes shoulder pain and progressive stiffness. Patient information leaflets (PILs) are produced by UK National Health Service (NHS) Trusts to help patients understand frozen shoulder and treatment options. However, the content and consistency of these PILs and their alignment with national clinical guidance are currently unclear. Objectives: This study aimed to identify, analyse and describe the non‐surgical management recommendations presented in publicly available NHS Trust PILs for frozen shoulder and to assess their alignment with the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) Clinical Knowledge Summary and British Elbow and Shoulder Society (BESS) best practice resources. Methods: An online search was undertaken by one reviewer to identify publicly available PILs produced by NHS Trusts detailing non‐surgical management of frozen shoulder. Relevant data were extracted and analysed by one reviewer and verified by five reviewers. Descriptive statistics were used to summarise findings. Results: Thirty‐eight PILs were identified from 38 NHS Trusts with publication dates ranging from April 2013 to March 2025. Considerable variation was observed in the content, including reference to analgesia, activity modification, exercise prescription and corticosteroid injections. No single PIL reflected all key elements recommended in the NICE Clinical Knowledge Summary and BESS best practice. Conclusion: The findings demonstrate substantial variation in content, frequent misalignment with current national guidance and best practice exercise recommendations. Such variation may limit and may reduce the clarity, consistency and usefulness of information provided to patients.
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Musculoskeletal Care
- Vol. 24 (2) , e70237
Open AccessNon‐Surgical Management of People With Frozen Shoulder in the National Health Service: A Review of Publicly Available Patient Information Leaflets
Background: Frozen shoulder, also known as adhesive capsulitis, is a common and disabling condition that causes shoulder pain and progressive stiffness. Patient information leaflets (PILs) are produced by UK National Health Service (NHS) Trusts to help patients understand frozen shoulder and treatment options. However, the content and consistency of these PILs and their alignment with national clinical guidance are currently unclear. Objectives: This study aimed to identify, analyse and describe the non‐surgical management recommendations presented in publicly available NHS Trust PILs for frozen shoulder and to assess their alignment with the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) Clinical Knowledge Summary and British Elbow and Shoulder Society (BESS) best practice resources. Methods: An online search was undertaken by one reviewer to identify publicly available PILs produced by NHS Trusts detailing non‐surgical management of frozen shoulder. Relevant data were extracted and analysed by one reviewer and verified by five reviewers. Descriptive statistics were used to summarise findings. Results: Thirty‐eight PILs were identified from 38 NHS Trusts with publication dates ranging from April 2013 to March 2025. Considerable variation was observed in the content, including reference to analgesia, activity modification, exercise prescription and corticosteroid injections. No single PIL reflected all key elements recommended in the NICE Clinical Knowledge Summary and BESS best practice. Conclusion: The findings demonstrate substantial variation in content, frequent misalignment with current national guidance and best practice exercise recommendations. Such variation may limit and may reduce the clarity, consistency and usefulness of information provided to patients.
- Open Access
- 17 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making
- Vol. 26 (1)
Exploring implementation of a shared decision-making intervention for patients following an Anterior Cruciate Ligament rupture: a qualitative investigation
Background: Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) ruptures affect over 20,000 individuals in the UK each year. To date, three randomised controlled trials have compared the two main treatment options of surgical and non-surgical management following rupture and report conflicting findings. Recent qualitative research has also reported uncertainty and confusion among patients regarding decision-making about their choice of treatment. A theory- and evidence-based shared decision-making intervention was co-developed in a prior study to support patients to decide on treatment. The aim of this study was to understand implementation factors associated with implementing a shared decision-making intervention for patients following an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture. Methods: Individual qualitative interviews, analysed using a framework approach underpinned by the Extended Normalisation Process Theory (ENPT). Data were mapped to the four ENPT constructs: potential, capacity, capability and contribution. Conducted as part of a non-randomised feasibility study in an orthopaedic and physiotherapy service at an acute National Health Service Teaching Hospital in the Midlands, UK. Five patients with a first time ACL rupture and five physiotherapists with experience of using the shared decision-making intervention. Results: Implementation factors, including barriers and enablers to future implementation and normalisation, associated with implementing a shared decision-making intervention for patients following ACL rupture have been identified and mapped to ENPT. Both patients and physiotherapists demonstrated a clear understanding of the SDM intervention’s purpose (coherence) and individual intention to operationalise it within the pathway (potential, capacity). The intervention was further discussed to support interactional work between patients and clinicians during consultations and physiotherapists were positive about its workability and adaptability to meet patients’ needs (capability). Physiotherapists described the intervention’s role in altering the social roles of both themselves and of patients, which supported the set-up and action of SDM conversations (capacity). The communication of equipoise and context created for intervention delivery was identified to be critical to engagement (potential). The intervention was described as non-burdensome, patient participants reported they would recommend it to others following diagnosis of an ACL rupture and physiotherapist participants described utilising the intervention with patients outside the trial (contribution, capability). Conclusion: Implementation factors, explored through the lens of ENPT, have supported understanding of future normalisation of the intervention in clinical practice. Areas of focus ahead of further research, for example understanding equipoise, have also been identified. Trial registration: ISRCTN17801081. Registration date: 23.01.2024.
- 17 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making
- Vol. 26 (1)
Open AccessExploring implementation of a shared decision-making intervention for patients following an Anterior Cruciate Ligament rupture: a qualitative investigation
Background: Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) ruptures affect over 20,000 individuals in the UK each year. To date, three randomised controlled trials have compared the two main treatment options of surgical and non-surgical management following rupture and report conflicting findings. Recent qualitative research has also reported uncertainty and confusion among patients regarding decision-making about their choice of treatment. A theory- and evidence-based shared decision-making intervention was co-developed in a prior study to support patients to decide on treatment. The aim of this study was to understand implementation factors associated with implementing a shared decision-making intervention for patients following an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture. Methods: Individual qualitative interviews, analysed using a framework approach underpinned by the Extended Normalisation Process Theory (ENPT). Data were mapped to the four ENPT constructs: potential, capacity, capability and contribution. Conducted as part of a non-randomised feasibility study in an orthopaedic and physiotherapy service at an acute National Health Service Teaching Hospital in the Midlands, UK. Five patients with a first time ACL rupture and five physiotherapists with experience of using the shared decision-making intervention. Results: Implementation factors, including barriers and enablers to future implementation and normalisation, associated with implementing a shared decision-making intervention for patients following ACL rupture have been identified and mapped to ENPT. Both patients and physiotherapists demonstrated a clear understanding of the SDM intervention’s purpose (coherence) and individual intention to operationalise it within the pathway (potential, capacity). The intervention was further discussed to support interactional work between patients and clinicians during consultations and physiotherapists were positive about its workability and adaptability to meet patients’ needs (capability). Physiotherapists described the intervention’s role in altering the social roles of both themselves and of patients, which supported the set-up and action of SDM conversations (capacity). The communication of equipoise and context created for intervention delivery was identified to be critical to engagement (potential). The intervention was described as non-burdensome, patient participants reported they would recommend it to others following diagnosis of an ACL rupture and physiotherapist participants described utilising the intervention with patients outside the trial (contribution, capability). Conclusion: Implementation factors, explored through the lens of ENPT, have supported understanding of future normalisation of the intervention in clinical practice. Areas of focus ahead of further research, for example understanding equipoise, have also been identified. Trial registration: ISRCTN17801081. Registration date: 23.01.2024.
- Open Access
Use of a shared decision-making intervention to support treatment decision-making for patients following an anterior cruciate ligament rupture: a mixed methods feasibility study
Objectives To understand feasibility, acceptability and indicators of effectiveness of a shared decision-making (SDM) intervention with patients following an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture. Design Non-randomised feasibility study with embedded qualitative interviews. Setting Orthopaedic and physiotherapy service at an acute National Health Service (NHS) Teaching Hospital in the Midlands, UK, between 29 January and 5 June 2024. Participants Patients diagnosed with an ACL rupture following MRI. Intervention Delivery of a SDM intervention which comprised of two components: (1) patient information leaflet and (2) option grid. Outcome measures The primary outcome was to determine feasibility for a definitive trial using four outcomes: (1) recruitment rate, (2) fidelity of intervention delivery, (3) acceptability and (4) follow-up questionnaire completion. The secondary outcome was to explore indicators of the intervention’s effectiveness using quantitative data from patient reported outcome measures (acceptability questionnaire and satisfaction with decision scale) and qualitative data from patient and clinician interviews. Results 21 patients were approached to take part in the study, 20 were recruited with a mean age of 32.2 (SD 9.7), 40% were female. The recruitment rate was 95.2%, fidelity of intervention 100%, acceptability 94% and follow-up questionnaire completion 100%. The mean overall satisfaction with decision scale score was 24.85/30 (SD 3.82). There were no adverse events. Data from qualitative interviews with patients (n=5) and physiotherapists (n=5) suggested the SDM was acceptable and appeared effective in: (1) supporting decision-making about treatment, (2) conversations between patients and clinicians, (3) improving patient knowledge, (4) providing patients with access to health language and (5) supporting patients to ask questions deemed important to them. Conclusion The novel SDM intervention is acceptable to both patients and physiotherapists. Indicators of effectiveness explored through quantitative and qualitative data suggest the intervention to be beneficial to decision-making processes for patients and clinicians deciding on treatment following an ACL rupture. All four feasibility outcomes were achieved, indicating a full trial is feasible to run in the NHS. Trial registration number ISRCTN17801081.
Open AccessUse of a shared decision-making intervention to support treatment decision-making for patients following an anterior cruciate ligament rupture: a mixed methods feasibility study
Objectives To understand feasibility, acceptability and indicators of effectiveness of a shared decision-making (SDM) intervention with patients following an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture. Design Non-randomised feasibility study with embedded qualitative interviews. Setting Orthopaedic and physiotherapy service at an acute National Health Service (NHS) Teaching Hospital in the Midlands, UK, between 29 January and 5 June 2024. Participants Patients diagnosed with an ACL rupture following MRI. Intervention Delivery of a SDM intervention which comprised of two components: (1) patient information leaflet and (2) option grid. Outcome measures The primary outcome was to determine feasibility for a definitive trial using four outcomes: (1) recruitment rate, (2) fidelity of intervention delivery, (3) acceptability and (4) follow-up questionnaire completion. The secondary outcome was to explore indicators of the intervention’s effectiveness using quantitative data from patient reported outcome measures (acceptability questionnaire and satisfaction with decision scale) and qualitative data from patient and clinician interviews. Results 21 patients were approached to take part in the study, 20 were recruited with a mean age of 32.2 (SD 9.7), 40% were female. The recruitment rate was 95.2%, fidelity of intervention 100%, acceptability 94% and follow-up questionnaire completion 100%. The mean overall satisfaction with decision scale score was 24.85/30 (SD 3.82). There were no adverse events. Data from qualitative interviews with patients (n=5) and physiotherapists (n=5) suggested the SDM was acceptable and appeared effective in: (1) supporting decision-making about treatment, (2) conversations between patients and clinicians, (3) improving patient knowledge, (4) providing patients with access to health language and (5) supporting patients to ask questions deemed important to them. Conclusion The novel SDM intervention is acceptable to both patients and physiotherapists. Indicators of effectiveness explored through quantitative and qualitative data suggest the intervention to be beneficial to decision-making processes for patients and clinicians deciding on treatment following an ACL rupture. All four feasibility outcomes were achieved, indicating a full trial is feasible to run in the NHS. Trial registration number ISRCTN17801081.
- Open Access
‘Going through the motions’; a rich account of the complexity of the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction pathway, a UK qualitative study
Objectives This study aimed to understand the lived experiences of patients on the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) pathway up to 3 months before, 3 months after and 1 year after surgery. Study objectives were to explore (1) patient experiences of preoperative and postoperative treatment, (2) views of/involvement in prehabilitation and (3) sources and consistency of healthcare advice. Design Semi-structured interviews analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. Setting Midlands, England. Participants Purposive sample of 18 participants aged 18–45. Three identified as female and 15 as male. Participants’ ethnic origin was white (n=14), Indian (n=2), British Asian (n=1) and Pakistani (n=1). 10 participants were awaiting ACLR, six were 3months postsurgery and two were 1 year postsurgery. Results Participants gave a rich account of ACLR pathway experiences discussing negative impacts of the injury, difficulties with navigating the pathway and making decisions about surgery. Interacting with healthcare professionals and managing the variety of resources, advice and opinions were also highlighted as challenges. Participants reflected on their preoperative journey accounting a wide spectrum of expectations and realities of returning to work and physical activity postoperatively. Prehabilitation was perceived to offer an advantage to recovery, mental well-being, injury knowledge, postoperative rehabilitation and supports a faster return to physical activity. Five themes were identified: Injury experience, impact and support. Navigating the treatment pathway. Sense making in the preoperative period. Uncertainty, expectations and reality of the postsurgical period. Balancing resources, advice and opinions. Conclusion This study has illuminated patient experiences of the National Health Service (NHS) ACLR pathway, novel to the evidence base. The results highlight the perceived shortcomings in patient support. They also demonstrate the difficulty patients face when navigating the NHS system, communicating with clinicians, making decisions about treatment and managing conflicting sources of healthcare advice. These problems are more prominent than previously recognised in the literature. Registration ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT05529511.
Open Access‘Going through the motions’; a rich account of the complexity of the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction pathway, a UK qualitative study
Objectives This study aimed to understand the lived experiences of patients on the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) pathway up to 3 months before, 3 months after and 1 year after surgery. Study objectives were to explore (1) patient experiences of preoperative and postoperative treatment, (2) views of/involvement in prehabilitation and (3) sources and consistency of healthcare advice. Design Semi-structured interviews analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. Setting Midlands, England. Participants Purposive sample of 18 participants aged 18–45. Three identified as female and 15 as male. Participants’ ethnic origin was white (n=14), Indian (n=2), British Asian (n=1) and Pakistani (n=1). 10 participants were awaiting ACLR, six were 3months postsurgery and two were 1 year postsurgery. Results Participants gave a rich account of ACLR pathway experiences discussing negative impacts of the injury, difficulties with navigating the pathway and making decisions about surgery. Interacting with healthcare professionals and managing the variety of resources, advice and opinions were also highlighted as challenges. Participants reflected on their preoperative journey accounting a wide spectrum of expectations and realities of returning to work and physical activity postoperatively. Prehabilitation was perceived to offer an advantage to recovery, mental well-being, injury knowledge, postoperative rehabilitation and supports a faster return to physical activity. Five themes were identified: Injury experience, impact and support. Navigating the treatment pathway. Sense making in the preoperative period. Uncertainty, expectations and reality of the postsurgical period. Balancing resources, advice and opinions. Conclusion This study has illuminated patient experiences of the National Health Service (NHS) ACLR pathway, novel to the evidence base. The results highlight the perceived shortcomings in patient support. They also demonstrate the difficulty patients face when navigating the NHS system, communicating with clinicians, making decisions about treatment and managing conflicting sources of healthcare advice. These problems are more prominent than previously recognised in the literature. Registration ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT05529511.
- Open Access
- 9 August 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Brain Sciences
- Vol. 14 (8) , 797
Current Recommendations for the Use of Sound Therapy in Adults with Hyperacusis: A Scoping Review
Hyperacusis is a condition that is characterized by hypersensitivity to normal everyday sounds or reduced sound tolerance and can affect patients in distressing ways. Sound therapy is a treatment intervention that is used to desensitize patients. However, as yet, there is a lack of understanding on how it is used in clinical practice, the different types of devices, or how to use them. The aim of this scoping review was to establish the current use of sound therapy in adults with hyperacusis and identify any factors that may influence treatment. Methodology: An established methodological framework was used to formulate the research question and guide the search strategy and reporting. The inclusion criteria were studies reporting adult (>18 years) populations with hyperacusis and sound therapy treatments which were published in any language. Searches of electronic databases (CINAHL, Cochrane Library, Medline (EBSCO), Scopus, PsycINFO) identified 31 studies that met the inclusion criteria (completed in April 2024). Data from included records were collated and summarized descriptively.
- 9 August 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Brain Sciences
- Vol. 14 (8) , 797
Open AccessCurrent Recommendations for the Use of Sound Therapy in Adults with Hyperacusis: A Scoping Review
Hyperacusis is a condition that is characterized by hypersensitivity to normal everyday sounds or reduced sound tolerance and can affect patients in distressing ways. Sound therapy is a treatment intervention that is used to desensitize patients. However, as yet, there is a lack of understanding on how it is used in clinical practice, the different types of devices, or how to use them. The aim of this scoping review was to establish the current use of sound therapy in adults with hyperacusis and identify any factors that may influence treatment. Methodology: An established methodological framework was used to formulate the research question and guide the search strategy and reporting. The inclusion criteria were studies reporting adult (>18 years) populations with hyperacusis and sound therapy treatments which were published in any language. Searches of electronic databases (CINAHL, Cochrane Library, Medline (EBSCO), Scopus, PsycINFO) identified 31 studies that met the inclusion criteria (completed in April 2024). Data from included records were collated and summarized descriptively.
- Open Access
Development of an intervention for patients following an anterior cruciate ligament rupture: an online nominal group technique consensus study
Objectives (1) To develop an intervention for to support patients diagnosed with an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture with decision-making regarding treatment. (2) To define evidence-based recommendations for the treatment of patients following an ACL rupture. Design Nominal group technique consensus study. Setting Online meetings with patients and key stakeholders working and receiving treatment in the National Health Service, UK. Participants Consensus meetings composed of eight voting participants and five non-voting facilitators. Voting participants included five clinicians, one outpatient therapy manager and two patients with experience in an ACL rupture and reconstructive surgery. Non-voting facilitators supported group discussions and/or observed study procedures. This included a clinical academic expert, two methodology experts and two patient representatives. Method Two online meetings were held. Pre-elicitation material was distributed ahead of the first meeting. Premeeting voting was conducted ahead of both meetings. A draft of the shared decision-making intervention and recommendations were shared ahead of the second meeting. Components were discussed and ranked for inclusion based on a 70% agreement threshold. Results The meetings led to the development of a shared decision-making intervention to support treatment decision-making following an ACL rupture. The intervention includes two components: (1) a patient information leaflet and key questions diagram and (2) option grid. The evidence-based recommendations encompass core components of treatment reaching the 70% threshold agreed by the group. The recommendations cover: (1) advice and education, (2) exercise guidance, (3) intervention delivery, (4) outcome measure use and (5) shared decision-making. Conclusion This study has successfully developed a shared decision-making intervention to support ACL treatment decision-making, ready for testing in a future feasibility study. Evidence-based recommendations for the treatment of patients following ACL injury, ready for testing in a National Health Service (UK) setting, are also presented. Trial registration number NCT05529511.
Open AccessDevelopment of an intervention for patients following an anterior cruciate ligament rupture: an online nominal group technique consensus study
Objectives (1) To develop an intervention for to support patients diagnosed with an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture with decision-making regarding treatment. (2) To define evidence-based recommendations for the treatment of patients following an ACL rupture. Design Nominal group technique consensus study. Setting Online meetings with patients and key stakeholders working and receiving treatment in the National Health Service, UK. Participants Consensus meetings composed of eight voting participants and five non-voting facilitators. Voting participants included five clinicians, one outpatient therapy manager and two patients with experience in an ACL rupture and reconstructive surgery. Non-voting facilitators supported group discussions and/or observed study procedures. This included a clinical academic expert, two methodology experts and two patient representatives. Method Two online meetings were held. Pre-elicitation material was distributed ahead of the first meeting. Premeeting voting was conducted ahead of both meetings. A draft of the shared decision-making intervention and recommendations were shared ahead of the second meeting. Components were discussed and ranked for inclusion based on a 70% agreement threshold. Results The meetings led to the development of a shared decision-making intervention to support treatment decision-making following an ACL rupture. The intervention includes two components: (1) a patient information leaflet and key questions diagram and (2) option grid. The evidence-based recommendations encompass core components of treatment reaching the 70% threshold agreed by the group. The recommendations cover: (1) advice and education, (2) exercise guidance, (3) intervention delivery, (4) outcome measure use and (5) shared decision-making. Conclusion This study has successfully developed a shared decision-making intervention to support ACL treatment decision-making, ready for testing in a future feasibility study. Evidence-based recommendations for the treatment of patients following ACL injury, ready for testing in a National Health Service (UK) setting, are also presented. Trial registration number NCT05529511.
- Open Access
- 7 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Pilot and Feasibility Studies
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-8
Implementing a shared decision-making intervention to support treatment decisions for patients following an anterior cruciate ligament rupture — a protocol for the POP-ACLR feasibility study
Background: Treatment for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture may follow a surgical or nonsurgical pathway. At present, there is uncertainty around treatment choice. Two shared decision-making tools have been codesigned to support patients to make a decision about treatment following an ACL rupture. The shared decision-making tools include a patient information leaflet and an option grid. We report the protocol for a mixed-methods feasibility study, with nested qualitative interviews, to understand feasibility, acceptability, indicators of effectiveness and implementation factors of these shared decision-making tools (combined to form one shared decision-making intervention). Methods: A single-centre non-randomised feasibility study will be conducted with 20 patients. Patients diagnosed with an ACL rupture following magnetic resonance imaging will be identified from an orthopaedic clinic. The shared decision-making intervention will be delivered during a clinical consultation with a physiotherapist. The primary feasibility outcomes include the following: recruitment rate, fidelity, acceptability and follow-up questionnaire completion. The secondary outcome is the satisfaction with decision scale. The nested qualitative interview will explore experience of using the shared decision-making intervention to understand acceptability, implementation factors and areas for further refinement. Discussion: This study will determine the feasibility of using a newly developed shared decision-making intervention designed to support patients to make a decision about treatment of their ACL rupture. The acceptability and indicators of effectiveness will also be explored. In the long term, the shared decision-making intervention may improve service and patient outcomes and ensure cost-effectiveness for the NHS; ensuring those most likely to benefit from surgical treatment proceed along this pathway. Trial registration: Pending registration on ISRCTN.
- 7 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Pilot and Feasibility Studies
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-8
Open AccessImplementing a shared decision-making intervention to support treatment decisions for patients following an anterior cruciate ligament rupture — a protocol for the POP-ACLR feasibility study
Background: Treatment for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture may follow a surgical or nonsurgical pathway. At present, there is uncertainty around treatment choice. Two shared decision-making tools have been codesigned to support patients to make a decision about treatment following an ACL rupture. The shared decision-making tools include a patient information leaflet and an option grid. We report the protocol for a mixed-methods feasibility study, with nested qualitative interviews, to understand feasibility, acceptability, indicators of effectiveness and implementation factors of these shared decision-making tools (combined to form one shared decision-making intervention). Methods: A single-centre non-randomised feasibility study will be conducted with 20 patients. Patients diagnosed with an ACL rupture following magnetic resonance imaging will be identified from an orthopaedic clinic. The shared decision-making intervention will be delivered during a clinical consultation with a physiotherapist. The primary feasibility outcomes include the following: recruitment rate, fidelity, acceptability and follow-up questionnaire completion. The secondary outcome is the satisfaction with decision scale. The nested qualitative interview will explore experience of using the shared decision-making intervention to understand acceptability, implementation factors and areas for further refinement. Discussion: This study will determine the feasibility of using a newly developed shared decision-making intervention designed to support patients to make a decision about treatment of their ACL rupture. The acceptability and indicators of effectiveness will also be explored. In the long term, the shared decision-making intervention may improve service and patient outcomes and ensure cost-effectiveness for the NHS; ensuring those most likely to benefit from surgical treatment proceed along this pathway. Trial registration: Pending registration on ISRCTN.
- Open Access
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Implementing a shared decision-making tool to support treatment decisions for patients following an Anterior Cruciate Ligament rupture – a protocol for the POP-ACLR feasibility study
Background Treatment for Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) rupture may follow a surgical or non-surgical pathway. At present, there is uncertainty around treatment choice. Two shared decision-making tools have been co-designed to support patients to make a decision about treatment following an ACL rupture. The shared decision-making tools include a patient information leaflet and an option grid. We report the protocol for a mixed methods feasibility study, with nested qualitative interviews, to understand feasibility, acceptability, indicators of effectiveness and implementation factors of these shared decision-making tools. Methods A single centre non-randomised feasibility study will be conducted with 20 patients. Patients diagnosed with an ACL rupture following magnetic resonance imaging will be identified from an orthopaedic clinic. The shared decision-making tools will be delivered during a clinical consultation with a physiotherapist. The primary feasibility outcomes include: recruitment rate, fidelity, acceptability and follow-up questionnaire completion. The secondary outcome is the satisfaction with decision scale. The nested qualitative interview will explore experience of using the shared decision-making tool to understand acceptability, implementation factors and areas for further refinement. Discussion This study will determine the feasibility of using a newly developed shared decision-making tool designed to support patients to make a decision about treatment of their ACL rupture. The acceptability and indicators of effectiveness will also be explored. In the long term, the shared decision-making tools may improve service and patient outcomes and ensure cost-effectiveness for the NHS; ensuring those most likely to benefit from surgical treatment proceed along this pathway. Trial Registration Pending registration on ISRCTN.
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessImplementing a shared decision-making tool to support treatment decisions for patients following an Anterior Cruciate Ligament rupture – a protocol for the POP-ACLR feasibility study
Background Treatment for Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) rupture may follow a surgical or non-surgical pathway. At present, there is uncertainty around treatment choice. Two shared decision-making tools have been co-designed to support patients to make a decision about treatment following an ACL rupture. The shared decision-making tools include a patient information leaflet and an option grid. We report the protocol for a mixed methods feasibility study, with nested qualitative interviews, to understand feasibility, acceptability, indicators of effectiveness and implementation factors of these shared decision-making tools. Methods A single centre non-randomised feasibility study will be conducted with 20 patients. Patients diagnosed with an ACL rupture following magnetic resonance imaging will be identified from an orthopaedic clinic. The shared decision-making tools will be delivered during a clinical consultation with a physiotherapist. The primary feasibility outcomes include: recruitment rate, fidelity, acceptability and follow-up questionnaire completion. The secondary outcome is the satisfaction with decision scale. The nested qualitative interview will explore experience of using the shared decision-making tool to understand acceptability, implementation factors and areas for further refinement. Discussion This study will determine the feasibility of using a newly developed shared decision-making tool designed to support patients to make a decision about treatment of their ACL rupture. The acceptability and indicators of effectiveness will also be explored. In the long term, the shared decision-making tools may improve service and patient outcomes and ensure cost-effectiveness for the NHS; ensuring those most likely to benefit from surgical treatment proceed along this pathway. Trial Registration Pending registration on ISRCTN.
- Open Access
- 23 January 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
Using a shared decision-making tool with adults after an anterior cruciate ligament injury
- 23 January 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
Open AccessUsing a shared decision-making tool with adults after an anterior cruciate ligament injury
- Open Access
- 18 September 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Implementation Science Communications
- Vol. 4 (1) , 1-25
Using normalisation process theory for intervention development, implementation and refinement in musculoskeletal and orthopaedic interventions: a qualitative systematic review
Background: Normalisation process theory (NPT) provides researchers with a set of tools to support the understanding of the implementation, normalisation and sustainment of an intervention in practice. Previous reviews of published research have explored NPT’s use in the implementation processes of healthcare interventions. However, its utility in intervention research, specifically in orthopaedic and musculoskeletal interventions, remains unclear. The aim of this review is to explore how NPT (including extended NPT, ENPT) has been used in orthopaedic/musculoskeletal intervention research. Methods: A qualitative systematic review was conducted. Two bibliographic databases (Scopus and Web of Science) and a search engine (Google Scholar) were searched for peer-reviewed journal articles citing key papers outlining the development of NPT, related methods, tools or the web-based toolkit. We included studies of any method, including protocols, and did not exclude based on published language. A data extraction tool was developed, and data were analysed using a framework approach. Results: Citation searches, of the 12 key studies, revealed 10,420 citations. Following duplicate removal, title, abstract and full-text screening, 14 papers from 12 studies were included. There were 8 key findings assessed against GRADE-CERQual (Confidence in Evidence from Reviews of Qualitative research). Five were of high confidence supporting NPT/ENPT’s use in the implementation process for interventions targeting a range of MSK/orthopaedic conditions. NPT/ENPT offers a useful analytical lens to focus attention and consider implementation factors robustly. There is limited evidence for the selection of NPT/ENPT and for the use of the Normalisation Measure Development instrument. Three findings of moderate confidence suggest that coherence is seen as a fundamental initial step in implementation, there is limited evidence that study population limits NPT’s utility and the application of ENPT may pose a challenge to researchers. Conclusion: This review demonstrates NPT’s utility in supporting intervention implementation for orthopaedic and musculoskeletal conditions. We have theorised the benefits ENPT offers to intervention development and refinement and recommend future researchers consider its use. We also encourage future researchers to offer clear justification for NPT’s use in their methodology. Trial registration: The review protocol is registered with PROSPERO (CRD42022358558).
- 18 September 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Implementation Science Communications
- Vol. 4 (1) , 1-25
Open AccessUsing normalisation process theory for intervention development, implementation and refinement in musculoskeletal and orthopaedic interventions: a qualitative systematic review
Background: Normalisation process theory (NPT) provides researchers with a set of tools to support the understanding of the implementation, normalisation and sustainment of an intervention in practice. Previous reviews of published research have explored NPT’s use in the implementation processes of healthcare interventions. However, its utility in intervention research, specifically in orthopaedic and musculoskeletal interventions, remains unclear. The aim of this review is to explore how NPT (including extended NPT, ENPT) has been used in orthopaedic/musculoskeletal intervention research. Methods: A qualitative systematic review was conducted. Two bibliographic databases (Scopus and Web of Science) and a search engine (Google Scholar) were searched for peer-reviewed journal articles citing key papers outlining the development of NPT, related methods, tools or the web-based toolkit. We included studies of any method, including protocols, and did not exclude based on published language. A data extraction tool was developed, and data were analysed using a framework approach. Results: Citation searches, of the 12 key studies, revealed 10,420 citations. Following duplicate removal, title, abstract and full-text screening, 14 papers from 12 studies were included. There were 8 key findings assessed against GRADE-CERQual (Confidence in Evidence from Reviews of Qualitative research). Five were of high confidence supporting NPT/ENPT’s use in the implementation process for interventions targeting a range of MSK/orthopaedic conditions. NPT/ENPT offers a useful analytical lens to focus attention and consider implementation factors robustly. There is limited evidence for the selection of NPT/ENPT and for the use of the Normalisation Measure Development instrument. Three findings of moderate confidence suggest that coherence is seen as a fundamental initial step in implementation, there is limited evidence that study population limits NPT’s utility and the application of ENPT may pose a challenge to researchers. Conclusion: This review demonstrates NPT’s utility in supporting intervention implementation for orthopaedic and musculoskeletal conditions. We have theorised the benefits ENPT offers to intervention development and refinement and recommend future researchers consider its use. We also encourage future researchers to offer clear justification for NPT’s use in their methodology. Trial registration: The review protocol is registered with PROSPERO (CRD42022358558).