ETE. Brie Thumm

E. Brie Thumm

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


E. Brie Thumm has a total of 66 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Applying the Transcreation Framework to Design the Recovery Coach Doula Role and Delivery Model to Support Individuals with Substance Use Disorder in the Perinatal Period

    by E. Brie Thumm, Britt Westmoreland, Liza M. Creel, Elizabeth G. Phillips, Sarah Lopez, Jessica L. Anderson

    Background: Treating perinatal substance use disorder is a public health priority. Social support is associated with better substance use and perinatal outcomes. Doula care and recovery coaching from peers who are in recovery themselves are two evidence-based interventions designed to provide social support. The aim was to braid doula care and peer recovery coaching into a novel healthcare personnel role and develop a delivery model for implementation in community settings. Methods: A team led by community members from the recovery and birth justice communities and perinatal clinicians, with a policy analysts, and an implementation scientist applied the Transcreation Framework guided by extant literature, theory, formative research, and existing community infrastructure in weekly or biweekly sessions over three years. Results: The team identified a strong evidentiary foundation for Recovery Coach Doula care and supportive community infrastructure. Through theory analysis and formative research, the team identified 15 core functions of the Recovery Coach Doula role and developed a delivery model. The core functions were intentionally designed to be adaptable to allow Recovery Coach Doulas to meet the needs of their clients. To deliver Recovery Coach Doula care in community settings, the team created a hub and spoke model delivery program to accommodate varying healthcare models and center the needs of the Recovery Coach Doulas, as well as the clients. The transcreation process provided structure required for rigorous co-design over an extended period time with iteration. Conclusions: Systematic application of the Transcreation Framework with community laid the foundation for implementation of Recovery Coach Doula care. Next steps include rigorously testing the effectiveness of Recovery Coach Doula care and developing implementation strategies and outcomes.

  • Open Access

    Attrition of the Midwifery Workforce: Understanding Factors Associated With Leaving the Profession

    by E. Brie Thumm, Amy H. Goh, Elizabeth G. Phillips, Zachary Giano

    Objective: To understand why advanced practice midwives (certified nurse‐midwives and certified midwives) leave the workforce. Study Setting and Design: A multi‐method, multi‐source investigation included secondary analysis of certification data of advanced practice midwives and a cross‐sectional online survey with closed‐ and open‐ended items. Advanced practice midwives' active certification data were used to compare self‐reported demographic characteristics of advanced practice midwives who reported working in the discipline of midwifery to those who did not ( n = 9704). A survey was conducted in 2022 with individuals who allowed their certification to lapse between 2017 and 2021 ( n = 303) and individuals who maintained certification but reported not working in the discipline of midwifery ( n = 1994) to understand why individuals left the workforce and the likelihood of returning. Data were analyzed with ANOVAs, chi‐squares, t ‐tests, and thematic analysis. Data Sources and Analytic Sample: Administrative data from the American Midwifery Certification Board ( n = 9704) and an online survey from a national sample of currently and previously certified nurse‐midwives and certified midwives who had left the workforce ( n = 646; response rate of 33.8%). Principal Findings: The most endorsed reasons for leaving were work‐life balance (50.3%, n = 325), unsupportive work environment (34.7%, n = 224), and schedule (32.0%, n = 207). Participants from restrictive regulation states reported lack of opportunities for career advancement, state‐level regulation restricting ability to practice, and lack of employment opportunities at higher rates. Respondents of color more frequently reported inadequate compensation, lack of opportunity for advancement, and workplace discrimination at higher rates. Themes included barriers to re‐entry to practice and compensation. Conclusions: Work‐life balance and work environment drive midwifery workforce attrition. Individuals of color and those living in states with restrictive regulation face unique challenges. Challenges re‐entering the workforce after leaving create barriers to remaining in the workforce, especially with inequitable compensation.

  • Retrospective Cohort Study on Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Cesarean Birth in a Midwifery-Integrated Health System

    by Denise C. Smith, E. Brie Thumm, Zachary Giano, Alyse Staley, Jeanelle Sheeder, Amy J. Barton, Teri L. Hernandez


  • Development of a Cocurricular Program to Prepare New Graduate Midwives for Rural Practice

    by Shannon Pirrie, E. Brie Thumm, Katherine J. Kissler, Jessica L. Anderson, Lindsey Bischoff, Denise C. Smith

    Limited maternity care access is a significant challenge affecting rural communities across the United States and Colorado, and midwives are a viable solution to closing these gaps. The Health Resources and Services Administration's MatCare grant program was designed to increase access to midwifery care for underserved populations through support for midwife trainees who will work in rural and underserved communities after graduation. We operationalized the MatCare aims to create the Colorado Rural Midwifery Workforce Expansion Program. In this program, the students follow the rural midwifery track and complete the Preparation for Rural Professional Practice (PRPP) curriculum. The PRPP is a cocurricular program that provides future rural midwives with additional didactic and clinical training opportunities, leadership development, and mentorship that will support the growth of midwifery in rural areas. A rural workforce preparation program equips midwives with specialized knowledge and skills that support their integration into rural environments. Midwives have the potential to improve access to health care when employed as primary maternity care providers.

  • The Decision to Leave the Midwifery Workforce in the United States: A Qualitative Investigation

    by E. Brie Thumm, Amy H. Goh, Elizabeth Phillips

    Aim: To explore the experiences of and reasons for midwives leaving practice. Design: A qualitative approach applying a social constructivism interpretative framework. Methods: Twenty participants were selected for interviews based on reasons for leaving midwifery practice between October 2022 and April 2023. Thematic analysis was used to identify themes, and results were checked for trustworthiness through a third coder, community engagement and member checking with two participants. Findings: One overarching theme with six subthemes characterised the experience of leaving midwifery practice. All participants reported the overarching theme: Caring for myself and my close community became incompatible with the work of midwifery. Five subthemes reflected negative aspects of midwifery work: value incongruence; racism in midwifery; not feeling respected/valued (+compensation); high workload leading to low quality of care; negative practice climate and psychosocial safety climate. The theme of strong professional commitment and identity weighed into their decision to leave. Negative experiences working in birth centres were prominent across themes. Conclusions: Participants reported leaving the profession of midwifery when they reached an unsustainable balance between the demands of work life and personal life. The decision to leave midwifery was emotional; participants maintained a strong connection to midwifery. The leaving process supports a theoretical premise for midwifery turnover behaviour. The work life of midwives is a complex composite of challenges that are reflective of identified problems with maternity care in the United States. Implications for the Profession and/or Patient Care: Midwives are not leaving practice because they want to leave midwifery but because they are unable to meet non‐work‐related caring demands. Family‐friendly policies, such as flexible schedules and leave policies, could help retain the midwifery workforce. Patient or Public Contribution: Based on recommendations from representatives of historically marginalised groups within the midwifery community, we offered participants to be interviewed by a midwife of colour.


  • Defining Midwifery‐Led Care in the United States Using Concept Analysis

    by Katie Page, Julia Phillippi, Cathy L. Emeis, Allison Cummins, Brie Thumm

    National health policy initiatives recommend increased integration of midwifery care in the United States to improve care quality and reduce maternal health disparities. However, the service models through which midwives provide midwifery care and produce quality outcomes are poorly understood. Midwifery‐led care is a service model frequently associated with improved outcomes compared with other models. The service model has been infrequently or inconsistently studied in the Unites States and has been narrowly defined and applied to perinatal care. The purpose of this concept analysis was to evaluate the concept of midwifery‐led care and expand the definition to guide midwifery practice, research, and health policy. The analysis followed Walker and Avant's methodology. Three attributes of midwifery‐led care were identified: (1) midwife as the lead clinician; (2) person‐midwife partnership; and (3) care embodies midwifery philosophy. Antecedents were (1) license to practice as a midwife; (2) a person needing or desiring sexual, reproductive, perinatal, or newborn care; (3) a person with low‐ or moderate‐risk health status; (4) regulations and guidelines that support provision of midwifery care; and (5) reimbursement for services. Consequences of midwifery‐led care included (1) improved maternal and neonatal outcomes, (2) patient satisfaction, and (3) reduced health care costs. The presented expanded definition of midwifery‐led care is the first to use a systems level approach and explicitly center the person receiving care and the philosophical approach of midwifery care. Application of this definition is needed in theoretical and pragmatic research to classify midwifery‐led care and other service models and compare patient‐ and organization‐level outcomes.


  • The Relationship Between Restrictive Regulation of Midwives, Practice Environment, and Professional Burnout

    by E. Brie PhD Thumm, Ann Dnp Schaeffer, Alexandra PhD Michel, A. Kristienne PhD McFarland, Maryann H. PhD Long, Zachary Giano

    Purpose: The purpose of the study was to investigate the relationship between state regulation of the midwifery workforce, practice environment, and burnout. Background: Burnout threatens the US midwifery workforce, with over 40% of certified nurse-midwives meeting criteria. Burnout can lead to poorer physical and mental health and withdrawal from the workforce. Burnout in midwives has been associated with lack of control and autonomy. In the United States, midwives' autonomy is restricted through state-level regulation that limits scope of practice and professional independence. Methods: A mixed-methods study was conducted using an explanatory sequential approach. Quantitative and qualitative data were collected by online surveys and analyzed in a 2-stage process, followed by data integration. Results: State regulation was not found to be independently associated with burnout (n = 248; P = .250); however, mediation analysis showed a significant association between state regulation, practice environment, and burnout. Qualitative analysis mirrored the importance of practice environment and expanded on its features. Conclusion: For midwives, unrestrictive practice regulation may not translate to burnout prevention without supportive practice environments. Implications for practice and research: Interventions should focus on promoting job flexibility, realistic demands, and professional values. While midwives' commitment to patients and the profession can help bolster the workforce, it can also amplify negative experiences of the practice environment.