David Nicol
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
David Nicol has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Geethanjali Selvaretnam
University of Glasgow
2 shared publications - Maxine V. Swingler
School of Psychology and Neuroscience, University of Glasgow
2 shared publications - Jennifer Rose
Alliance Manchester Business School, University of Manchester
1 shared publication - Lovleen Kushwah
University of Glasgow "HUMAN BEINGS
1 shared publication Suzanne McCallum
1 shared publication- Suzanne McCallum
Adam Smith Business School, University of Glasgow
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 March 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 51 (6) , 1136-1155
Do students generate better self-feedback by comparing their work against assessment criteria or exemplars?
- 18 March 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 51 (6) , 1136-1155
Open AccessDo students generate better self-feedback by comparing their work against assessment criteria or exemplars?
- Open Access
- 16 March 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in EdArXiv
Do Students Generate Better Self-Feedback by Comparing their Work Against Assessment Criteria or Exemplars?
Research suggests that when students compare their work against different resources, they generate different inner feedback and their learning differs. Understanding these differences helps teachers scaffold students’ learning and foster student feedback agency. Previous studies show learning differences using rubrics, assessment criteria and exemplars as comparators. However, most use performance rather than feedback measures, and the link between feedback and performance is unexplored. In contrast, this study investigated the differential effects of assessment criteria and exemplars on students’ self-generated feedback and their performance grades. To make inner feedback evident, students wrote their own self-feedback comments, which were coded into task and process comments to examine their relationship to grades. Students produced a research report then one group (57 students) compared it against assessment criteria and another (56 students) against exemplars. Students using exemplars produced more high-level process-oriented comments whereas those using criteria produced more task-related comments. Also, high-level process feedback positively correlated with final grades. The findings suggest that by extending the range of comparators and by using prompts, teachers can guide students towards deeper and more differentiated learning, enhance feedback agency and reduce their own workload. Importantly, writing self-feedback provides valuable insights into learning, for students, educators and researchers.
- 16 March 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in EdArXiv
Open AccessDo Students Generate Better Self-Feedback by Comparing their Work Against Assessment Criteria or Exemplars?
Research suggests that when students compare their work against different resources, they generate different inner feedback and their learning differs. Understanding these differences helps teachers scaffold students’ learning and foster student feedback agency. Previous studies show learning differences using rubrics, assessment criteria and exemplars as comparators. However, most use performance rather than feedback measures, and the link between feedback and performance is unexplored. In contrast, this study investigated the differential effects of assessment criteria and exemplars on students’ self-generated feedback and their performance grades. To make inner feedback evident, students wrote their own self-feedback comments, which were coded into task and process comments to examine their relationship to grades. Students produced a research report then one group (57 students) compared it against assessment criteria and another (56 students) against exemplars. Students using exemplars produced more high-level process-oriented comments whereas those using criteria produced more task-related comments. Also, high-level process feedback positively correlated with final grades. The findings suggest that by extending the range of comparators and by using prompts, teachers can guide students towards deeper and more differentiated learning, enhance feedback agency and reduce their own workload. Importantly, writing self-feedback provides valuable insights into learning, for students, educators and researchers.
- Open Access
- 24 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 50 (8) , 1311-1331
Promoting learner self-regulation: is it better to give students exemplars before or after producing work?
- 24 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 50 (8) , 1311-1331
Open AccessPromoting learner self-regulation: is it better to give students exemplars before or after producing work?
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 8 October 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 49 (3) , 419-439
Shifting feedback agency to students by having them write their own feedback comments
- 8 October 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 49 (3) , 419-439
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessShifting feedback agency to students by having them write their own feedback comments
- Open Access
- 28 June 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 47 (4) , 507-522
Making internal feedback explicit: harnessing the comparisons students make during two-stage exams
In two-stage exams, students complete some academic work individually then immediately complete the same work again in small groups. Prior research shows that students perceive the dialogue they engage in at the group stage aids their individual learning. Outcome studies also suggest that engaging in dialogue benefits individual student learning. This investigation takes a different perspective. Learning during two-stage exams is conceptualised as deriving from internal feedback processes, with comparison seen as the mechanism that fuels these processes. To investigate this interpretation, students were asked to write a feedback commentary on their own learning during a two-stage exam. The intention was to make explicit the internal feedback that would naturally occur during the group stage, as students compare their earlier individual performance against the group dialogue and the unfolding group output. Analysis showed that students not only generated content and process feedback but also self-regulatory feedback, and that this feedback was of a higher quality than, and went beyond, the comments the teacher provided. This investigation yields new insights into the nature, scope and power of internal feedback processes, and into how to improve students’ learning during such two-stage sequences.
- 28 June 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 47 (4) , 507-522
Open AccessMaking internal feedback explicit: harnessing the comparisons students make during two-stage exams
In two-stage exams, students complete some academic work individually then immediately complete the same work again in small groups. Prior research shows that students perceive the dialogue they engage in at the group stage aids their individual learning. Outcome studies also suggest that engaging in dialogue benefits individual student learning. This investigation takes a different perspective. Learning during two-stage exams is conceptualised as deriving from internal feedback processes, with comparison seen as the mechanism that fuels these processes. To investigate this interpretation, students were asked to write a feedback commentary on their own learning during a two-stage exam. The intention was to make explicit the internal feedback that would naturally occur during the group stage, as students compare their earlier individual performance against the group dialogue and the unfolding group output. Analysis showed that students not only generated content and process feedback but also self-regulatory feedback, and that this feedback was of a higher quality than, and went beyond, the comments the teacher provided. This investigation yields new insights into the nature, scope and power of internal feedback processes, and into how to improve students’ learning during such two-stage sequences.
- Open Access
- 17 June 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 47 (3) , 424-443
Making internal feedback explicit: exploiting the multiple comparisons that occur during peer review
This article explores peer review through the lens of internal feedback. It investigates the internal feedback that students generate when they compare their work with the work of peers and with comments received from peers. Inner feedback was made explicit by having students write an account of what they were learning from making these different comparisons. This allowed evaluation of the extent to which students’ self-generated feedback comments would match the feedback comments a teacher might provide, and exploration of other variables hypothesized to influence inner feedback generation. Analysis revealed that students’ self-generated feedback became more elaborate from one comparison to the next and that this, and multiple simultaneous comparisons, resulted in students’ generating feedback that not only matched the teacher’s feedback but surpassed it in powerful and productive ways. Comparisons against received peer comments added little to the feedback students had already generated from comparisons against peer works. The implications are that having students make explicit the internal feedback they generate not only helps them build their metacognitive knowledge and self-regulatory abilities but can also decrease teacher workload in providing comments.
- 17 June 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 47 (3) , 424-443
Open AccessMaking internal feedback explicit: exploiting the multiple comparisons that occur during peer review
This article explores peer review through the lens of internal feedback. It investigates the internal feedback that students generate when they compare their work with the work of peers and with comments received from peers. Inner feedback was made explicit by having students write an account of what they were learning from making these different comparisons. This allowed evaluation of the extent to which students’ self-generated feedback comments would match the feedback comments a teacher might provide, and exploration of other variables hypothesized to influence inner feedback generation. Analysis revealed that students’ self-generated feedback became more elaborate from one comparison to the next and that this, and multiple simultaneous comparisons, resulted in students’ generating feedback that not only matched the teacher’s feedback but surpassed it in powerful and productive ways. Comparisons against received peer comments added little to the feedback students had already generated from comparisons against peer works. The implications are that having students make explicit the internal feedback they generate not only helps them build their metacognitive knowledge and self-regulatory abilities but can also decrease teacher workload in providing comments.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 18 October 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 46 (5) , 756-778
The power of internal feedback: exploiting natural comparison processes
Students generate internal feedback by comparing their current knowledge against some reference information. That information might be planned for by teachers – usually as comments on students’ performance – although most information is accessed by students themselves during task engagement, from their interactions with others, with resources and from memories of prior performances. Nearly all research on feedback in higher education focuses on comments as the comparison information. Ongoing and natural feedback comparisons with other information sources have been neglected: hence their potential for learning remains unexplored. To unlock the power of internal feedback, teachers need to have students turn some natural comparisons that they are making anyway, into formal and explicit comparisons and help them build the capacity to exploit their own comparison processes. To envision the possibilities, I present a new model of how students generate internal feedback as they self and co-regulate their learning, using information from multiple sources. I also synthesise two bodies of research to show how comparisons with different kinds of information, singly and in combination, can alter the nature and quality of the internal feedback that students generate. This lens of comparison changes everything. It calls for a fundamental shift in feedback practices and research.
- 18 October 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 46 (5) , 756-778
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe power of internal feedback: exploiting natural comparison processes
Students generate internal feedback by comparing their current knowledge against some reference information. That information might be planned for by teachers – usually as comments on students’ performance – although most information is accessed by students themselves during task engagement, from their interactions with others, with resources and from memories of prior performances. Nearly all research on feedback in higher education focuses on comments as the comparison information. Ongoing and natural feedback comparisons with other information sources have been neglected: hence their potential for learning remains unexplored. To unlock the power of internal feedback, teachers need to have students turn some natural comparisons that they are making anyway, into formal and explicit comparisons and help them build the capacity to exploit their own comparison processes. To envision the possibilities, I present a new model of how students generate internal feedback as they self and co-regulate their learning, using information from multiple sources. I also synthesise two bodies of research to show how comparisons with different kinds of information, singly and in combination, can alter the nature and quality of the internal feedback that students generate. This lens of comparison changes everything. It calls for a fundamental shift in feedback practices and research.
- Open Access
- 20 September 2020
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Making Internal Feedback Explicit: Harnessing the comparisons students make during two-stage exams
In two-stage exams, students produce some academic work individually then do the same work again in small groups. Both works contribute to the individual grade. Prior research shows that students perceive that the feedback dialogue they engage in, during two-stage exams, aids their learning. Also, outcome studies show that this method benefits individual student learning. However, there is no research on the internal feedback students generate during two-stage exams, when they compare their own individual performance against the group discussion and the developing group output. To investigate this, internal feedback was made explicit, in a two-stage exam, by having students write a feedback commentary on their own learning at both the individual and group stages. Analysis showed that students not only generated content and process feedback but also self-regulatory feedback, and that this feedback was of a higher quality than and went beyond that which the teacher provided. The implications for future implementations of two stage exams are considered as well as how this research adds to the literature on internal feedback.
- 20 September 2020
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessMaking Internal Feedback Explicit: Harnessing the comparisons students make during two-stage exams
In two-stage exams, students produce some academic work individually then do the same work again in small groups. Both works contribute to the individual grade. Prior research shows that students perceive that the feedback dialogue they engage in, during two-stage exams, aids their learning. Also, outcome studies show that this method benefits individual student learning. However, there is no research on the internal feedback students generate during two-stage exams, when they compare their own individual performance against the group discussion and the developing group output. To investigate this, internal feedback was made explicit, in a two-stage exam, by having students write a feedback commentary on their own learning at both the individual and group stages. Analysis showed that students not only generated content and process feedback but also self-regulatory feedback, and that this feedback was of a higher quality than and went beyond that which the teacher provided. The implications for future implementations of two stage exams are considered as well as how this research adds to the literature on internal feedback.
- Open Access
- 28 August 2020
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Making Internal Feedback Explicit: Exploiting the Multiple Comparisons that occur during Peer Review
This article explores peer review through the lens of internal feedback. It investigates the internal feedback that students generate when they compare their work with the work of peers and with comments received from peers. Inner feedback was made explicit by having students write an account of what they were learning from making these different comparisons. This allowed evaluation of the extent to which students’ self-generated feedback comments would match the feedback comments a teacher might provide, and exploration of other variables hypothesized to influence inner feedback generation. Analysis revealed that students’ self-generated feedback became more elaborate from one comparison to the next and that this, and multiple simultaneous comparisons, resulted in students’ generating feedback that not only matched the teacher’s feedback but surpassed it in powerful and productive ways. Comparisons against received peer comments added little to the feedback students had already generated from comparisons against peer works. The implications are that having students make explicit the internal feedback they generate not only helps them build their metacognitive knowledge and self-regulatory abilities but can also decrease teacher workload in providing comments.
- 28 August 2020
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessMaking Internal Feedback Explicit: Exploiting the Multiple Comparisons that occur during Peer Review
This article explores peer review through the lens of internal feedback. It investigates the internal feedback that students generate when they compare their work with the work of peers and with comments received from peers. Inner feedback was made explicit by having students write an account of what they were learning from making these different comparisons. This allowed evaluation of the extent to which students’ self-generated feedback comments would match the feedback comments a teacher might provide, and exploration of other variables hypothesized to influence inner feedback generation. Analysis revealed that students’ self-generated feedback became more elaborate from one comparison to the next and that this, and multiple simultaneous comparisons, resulted in students’ generating feedback that not only matched the teacher’s feedback but surpassed it in powerful and productive ways. Comparisons against received peer comments added little to the feedback students had already generated from comparisons against peer works. The implications are that having students make explicit the internal feedback they generate not only helps them build their metacognitive knowledge and self-regulatory abilities but can also decrease teacher workload in providing comments.
- Open Access
- 16 May 2017
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
Session details: Paper Session 3 Performance Modeling and Simulation
- 16 May 2017
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
Open AccessSession details: Paper Session 3 Performance Modeling and Simulation