Joseph Barrack Kelly
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Joseph Barrack Kelly has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Robert W. Thacker
Department of Ecology and Evolution Stony Brook University Stony Brook New York USA
6 shared publications - David Carlson
Stony Brook University
4 shared publications - Lutz Becks
Aquatic Ecology and Evolution, Department of Biology, University of Konstanz
4 shared publications - Jun Siong Low
Institute for Research in Biomedicine, Università della Svizzera Italiana, 6500 Bellinzona, Switzerland
3 shared publications David E. Carlson
Department of Ecology and Evolution, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, USA
2 shared publicationsJun Siong Low
Institute of Microbiology,ETH Zürich, Zürich, Switzerland
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Convergent responses to light stress in oligohymenophorean ciliates bearing green algal symbionts
Photosymbiosis has evolved multiple times independently in ciliates. However, these associations can be antagonized by shifts in environmental parameters that impose stress on the host, necessitating the evolution of mechanisms to contend with this stress and to control the symbiont population. To investigate whether convergent strategies have evolved among algae-bearing ciliates in the class Oligohymenophorea, we imposed light stress on three host species that represent at least two independent evolutionary origins of photosymbiosis and measured their cellular responses. Under high light, all three species experienced an initial drop in host cell density which recovered to levels commensurate with those under low-light conditions as they decreased their symbiont loads. We then performed a comparative transcriptomic study to investigate whether a core set of genes exists that is involved in this response. Thirty-one gene families possess differentially expressed transcripts across all three species that included the upregulation C1 and S28 class peptidases, genes involved in ROS mitigation, and a gene with potential involvement in mitochondrial remodeling associated with changes in algal symbiont load. We additionally found downregulation in Dicer , which could mitigate the processing of algal transcripts by the hosts’ RNAi machinery that are freed upon algal digestion, and downregulation of motor proteins that may reflect changes in the host’s swimming behaviors and transport of intracellular vesicles in response to light. The 31 gene families are present and widespread in non-symbiotic oligohymenophoreans, illustrating that a pre-existing genetic toolkit exists in this clade that helps explain how it is predisposed to evolving photosymbioses.
Open AccessConvergent responses to light stress in oligohymenophorean ciliates bearing green algal symbionts
Photosymbiosis has evolved multiple times independently in ciliates. However, these associations can be antagonized by shifts in environmental parameters that impose stress on the host, necessitating the evolution of mechanisms to contend with this stress and to control the symbiont population. To investigate whether convergent strategies have evolved among algae-bearing ciliates in the class Oligohymenophorea, we imposed light stress on three host species that represent at least two independent evolutionary origins of photosymbiosis and measured their cellular responses. Under high light, all three species experienced an initial drop in host cell density which recovered to levels commensurate with those under low-light conditions as they decreased their symbiont loads. We then performed a comparative transcriptomic study to investigate whether a core set of genes exists that is involved in this response. Thirty-one gene families possess differentially expressed transcripts across all three species that included the upregulation C1 and S28 class peptidases, genes involved in ROS mitigation, and a gene with potential involvement in mitochondrial remodeling associated with changes in algal symbiont load. We additionally found downregulation in Dicer , which could mitigate the processing of algal transcripts by the hosts’ RNAi machinery that are freed upon algal digestion, and downregulation of motor proteins that may reflect changes in the host’s swimming behaviors and transport of intracellular vesicles in response to light. The 31 gene families are present and widespread in non-symbiotic oligohymenophoreans, illustrating that a pre-existing genetic toolkit exists in this clade that helps explain how it is predisposed to evolving photosymbioses.
- Open Access
- 3 February 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Molecular Biology and Evolution
- Vol. 42 (2)
Genomic Signatures of Adaptation to Stress Reveal Shared Evolutionary Trends Between Tetrahymena utriculariae and Its Algal Endosymbiont, Micractinium tetrahymenae
The evolution of intracellular endosymbiosis marks a major transition in the biology of the host and endosymbiont. Yet, how adaptation manifests in the genomes of the participants remains relatively understudied. We investigated this question by sequencing the genomes of Tetrahymena utriculariae, a commensal of the aquatic carnivorous bladderwort Utricularia reflexa, and its intracellular algae, Micractinium tetrahymenae. We discovered an expansion in copy number and negative selection in a TLD domain-bearing gene family in the genome of T. utriculariae, identifying it as a candidate for being an adaptive response to oxidative stress resulting from the physiology of its endosymbionts. We found that the M. tetrahymenae genome is larger than those of other Micractinium and Chlorella and contains a greater number of rapidly expanding orthogroups. These were enriched for Gene Ontology terms relevant to the regulation of intracellular signal transduction and cellular responses to stress and stimulus. Single-exon tandem repeats were overrepresented in paralogs belonging to these rapidly expanding orthogroups, which implicates long terminal repeat retrotransposons (LTRs) as potential agents of adaptation. We additionally performed a comparative transcriptomic analysis of M. tetrahymenae in a free-living state and in endosymbiosis with T. utriculariae and discovered that the genes that are differentially expressed were enriched for pathways that evidence shifts in energy generation and storage and in cellular protection strategies. Together, our results elucidate the axes along which the participants must adapt in this young endosymbiosis and highlight evolutionary responses to stress as a shared trend.
- 3 February 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Molecular Biology and Evolution
- Vol. 42 (2)
Open AccessGenomic Signatures of Adaptation to Stress Reveal Shared Evolutionary Trends Between Tetrahymena utriculariae and Its Algal Endosymbiont, Micractinium tetrahymenae
The evolution of intracellular endosymbiosis marks a major transition in the biology of the host and endosymbiont. Yet, how adaptation manifests in the genomes of the participants remains relatively understudied. We investigated this question by sequencing the genomes of Tetrahymena utriculariae, a commensal of the aquatic carnivorous bladderwort Utricularia reflexa, and its intracellular algae, Micractinium tetrahymenae. We discovered an expansion in copy number and negative selection in a TLD domain-bearing gene family in the genome of T. utriculariae, identifying it as a candidate for being an adaptive response to oxidative stress resulting from the physiology of its endosymbionts. We found that the M. tetrahymenae genome is larger than those of other Micractinium and Chlorella and contains a greater number of rapidly expanding orthogroups. These were enriched for Gene Ontology terms relevant to the regulation of intracellular signal transduction and cellular responses to stress and stimulus. Single-exon tandem repeats were overrepresented in paralogs belonging to these rapidly expanding orthogroups, which implicates long terminal repeat retrotransposons (LTRs) as potential agents of adaptation. We additionally performed a comparative transcriptomic analysis of M. tetrahymenae in a free-living state and in endosymbiosis with T. utriculariae and discovered that the genes that are differentially expressed were enriched for pathways that evidence shifts in energy generation and storage and in cellular protection strategies. Together, our results elucidate the axes along which the participants must adapt in this young endosymbiosis and highlight evolutionary responses to stress as a shared trend.
- Open Access
Seasonal genotypic and phenotypic differentiation of a cosmopolitan freshwater diatom
Most ecosystems are characterized by seasonality, which, through biotic and abiotic changes, influences species biomass dynamics. Recent studies have shown that ecologically important traits can evolve rapidly in response to environmental changes, resulting in eco-evolutionary dynamics with consequences for population and community dynamics. Evidence for seasonal effects on intraspecific variation is still scarce and understanding eco-evolutionary dynamics in the presence of seasonal fluctuations remains a major challenge. Following the phytoplankton spring bloom in Lake Constance, we investigated how seasonal changes influence the intraspecific diversity of Asterionella formosa both at genotypic and phenotypic levels. We found a high degree of genetic and phenotypic differentiation characterizing Asterionella population, explained by a clustering of the isolates into early and late spring according to lake thermal stratification. Yet, most traits related to environmental parameters as well as fitness in different seasonal environments did not show a clear response to seasonality (i.e., temperature and nutrients), indicating that seasonal changes in biotic interactions (i.e., parasitic chytrids) were the major drivers of the observed seasonal shift in Asterionella genotypes. Our results highlight the importance of studying eco-evolutionary processes for understanding variations in population and community dynamics in response to seasonal environmental fluctuations.
Open AccessSeasonal genotypic and phenotypic differentiation of a cosmopolitan freshwater diatom
Most ecosystems are characterized by seasonality, which, through biotic and abiotic changes, influences species biomass dynamics. Recent studies have shown that ecologically important traits can evolve rapidly in response to environmental changes, resulting in eco-evolutionary dynamics with consequences for population and community dynamics. Evidence for seasonal effects on intraspecific variation is still scarce and understanding eco-evolutionary dynamics in the presence of seasonal fluctuations remains a major challenge. Following the phytoplankton spring bloom in Lake Constance, we investigated how seasonal changes influence the intraspecific diversity of Asterionella formosa both at genotypic and phenotypic levels. We found a high degree of genetic and phenotypic differentiation characterizing Asterionella population, explained by a clustering of the isolates into early and late spring according to lake thermal stratification. Yet, most traits related to environmental parameters as well as fitness in different seasonal environments did not show a clear response to seasonality (i.e., temperature and nutrients), indicating that seasonal changes in biotic interactions (i.e., parasitic chytrids) were the major drivers of the observed seasonal shift in Asterionella genotypes. Our results highlight the importance of studying eco-evolutionary processes for understanding variations in population and community dynamics in response to seasonal environmental fluctuations.
- Open Access
- 24 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Microbiome
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1
Correction: Novel trends of genome evolution in highly complex tropical sponge microbiomes
- 24 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Microbiome
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1
Open AccessCorrection: Novel trends of genome evolution in highly complex tropical sponge microbiomes
- Open Access
- 4 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Microbiome
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-16
Novel trends of genome evolution in highly complex tropical sponge microbiomes
Background: Tropical members of the sponge genusIrciniapossess highly complex microbiomes that perform a broad spectrum of chemical processes that influence host fitness. Despite the pervasive role of microbiomes inIrciniabiology, it is still unknown how they remain in stable association across tropical species. To address this question, we performed a comparative analysis of the microbiomes of 11Irciniaspecies using whole-metagenomic shotgun sequencing data to investigate three aspects of bacterial symbiont genomes—the redundancy in metabolic pathways across taxa, the evolution of genes involved in pathogenesis, and the nature of selection acting on genes relevant to secondary metabolism.Results: A total of 424 new, high-quality bacterial metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs) were produced for 10 CaribbeanIrciniaspecies, which were evaluated alongside 113 publicly available MAGs sourced from the Pacific speciesIrcinia ramosa. Evidence of redundancy was discovered in that the core genes of several primary metabolic pathways could be found in the genomes of multiple bacterial taxa. Across hosts, the metagenomes were depleted in genes relevant to pathogenicity and enriched in eukaryotic-like proteins (ELPs) that likely mimic the hosts’ molecular patterning. Finally, clusters of steroid biosynthesis genes (CSGs), which appear to be under purifying selection and undergo horizontal gene transfer, were found to be a defining feature ofIrciniametagenomes.Conclusions: These results illustrate patterns of genome evolution within highly complex microbiomes that illuminate how associations with hosts are maintained. The metabolic redundancy within the microbiomes could help buffer the hosts from changes in the ambient chemical and physical regimes and from fluctuations in the population sizes of the individual microbial strains that make up the microbiome. Additionally, the enrichment of ELPs and depletion of LPS and cellular motility genes provide a model for how alternative strategies to virulence can evolve in microbiomes undergoing mixed-mode transmission that do not ultimately result in higher levels of damage (i.e., pathogenicity) to the host. Our last set of results provides evidence that sterol biosynthesis inIrcinia-associated bacteria is widespread and that these molecules are important for the survival of bacteria in highly complexIrciniamicrobiomes.
- 4 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Microbiome
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-16
Open AccessNovel trends of genome evolution in highly complex tropical sponge microbiomes
Background: Tropical members of the sponge genusIrciniapossess highly complex microbiomes that perform a broad spectrum of chemical processes that influence host fitness. Despite the pervasive role of microbiomes inIrciniabiology, it is still unknown how they remain in stable association across tropical species. To address this question, we performed a comparative analysis of the microbiomes of 11Irciniaspecies using whole-metagenomic shotgun sequencing data to investigate three aspects of bacterial symbiont genomes—the redundancy in metabolic pathways across taxa, the evolution of genes involved in pathogenesis, and the nature of selection acting on genes relevant to secondary metabolism.Results: A total of 424 new, high-quality bacterial metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs) were produced for 10 CaribbeanIrciniaspecies, which were evaluated alongside 113 publicly available MAGs sourced from the Pacific speciesIrcinia ramosa. Evidence of redundancy was discovered in that the core genes of several primary metabolic pathways could be found in the genomes of multiple bacterial taxa. Across hosts, the metagenomes were depleted in genes relevant to pathogenicity and enriched in eukaryotic-like proteins (ELPs) that likely mimic the hosts’ molecular patterning. Finally, clusters of steroid biosynthesis genes (CSGs), which appear to be under purifying selection and undergo horizontal gene transfer, were found to be a defining feature ofIrciniametagenomes.Conclusions: These results illustrate patterns of genome evolution within highly complex microbiomes that illuminate how associations with hosts are maintained. The metabolic redundancy within the microbiomes could help buffer the hosts from changes in the ambient chemical and physical regimes and from fluctuations in the population sizes of the individual microbial strains that make up the microbiome. Additionally, the enrichment of ELPs and depletion of LPS and cellular motility genes provide a model for how alternative strategies to virulence can evolve in microbiomes undergoing mixed-mode transmission that do not ultimately result in higher levels of damage (i.e., pathogenicity) to the host. Our last set of results provides evidence that sterol biosynthesis inIrcinia-associated bacteria is widespread and that these molecules are important for the survival of bacteria in highly complexIrciniamicrobiomes.
- Open Access
- 7 July 2022
- Published by Wiley in Environmental Microbiology
- Vol. 24 (12) , 5924-5935
Context‐dependent costs and benefits of endosymbiotic interactions in a ciliate–algae system
Endosymbiosis, an interaction between two species where one lives within the other, has evolved multiple times independently, but the underlying mechanisms remain unclear. Evolutionary theory suggests that for an endosymbiotic interaction to remain stable over time, births of both partners should be higher than their deaths in symbiosis and deaths of both partners should be higher than their births when living independently. However, experimentally measuring this can be difficult and conclusions tend to focus on the host. Using a ciliate–algal system ( Paramecium bursaria host and Chlorella endosymbionts), we estimated the benefits and costs of endosymbiosis for both organisms using fitness measurements in different biotic environments to test under which environmental conditions the net effects of the interaction were positive for both partners. We found that the net effects of harbouring endosymbionts were positive for the ciliate hosts as it allowed them to survive in conditions of low‐quality bacteria food. The algae benefitted by being endosymbiotic when predators such as the hosts were present, but the net effects were dependent on the total density of hosts, decreasing as hosts densities increased. Overall, we show that including context‐dependency of endosymbiosis is essential in understanding how these interactions have evolved.
- 7 July 2022
- Published by Wiley in Environmental Microbiology
- Vol. 24 (12) , 5924-5935
Open AccessContext‐dependent costs and benefits of endosymbiotic interactions in a ciliate–algae system
Endosymbiosis, an interaction between two species where one lives within the other, has evolved multiple times independently, but the underlying mechanisms remain unclear. Evolutionary theory suggests that for an endosymbiotic interaction to remain stable over time, births of both partners should be higher than their deaths in symbiosis and deaths of both partners should be higher than their births when living independently. However, experimentally measuring this can be difficult and conclusions tend to focus on the host. Using a ciliate–algal system ( Paramecium bursaria host and Chlorella endosymbionts), we estimated the benefits and costs of endosymbiosis for both organisms using fitness measurements in different biotic environments to test under which environmental conditions the net effects of the interaction were positive for both partners. We found that the net effects of harbouring endosymbionts were positive for the ciliate hosts as it allowed them to survive in conditions of low‐quality bacteria food. The algae benefitted by being endosymbiotic when predators such as the hosts were present, but the net effects were dependent on the total density of hosts, decreasing as hosts densities increased. Overall, we show that including context‐dependency of endosymbiosis is essential in understanding how these interactions have evolved.
- 1 December 2021
- Published by Magnolia Press in Zootaxa
- Vol. 5072 (4) , 301-323
New shallow water species of Caribbean Ircinia Nardo, 1833 (Porifera: Irciniidae)
Seven Ircinia morphospecies were collected from three sites in the Caribbean (Bocas del Toro, Panama; the Mesoamerican Barrier Reef, Belize; and the Florida Keys, United States of America). Previous research used an integrative taxonomic framework (genome-wide SNP sampling and microbiome profiling) to delimit species boundaries among these Ircinia. Here, we present morphological descriptions for these species, six of which are new to science (Ircinia lowi sp. nov., Ircinia bocatorensis sp. nov., Ircinia radix sp. nov., Ircinia laeviconulosa sp. nov., Ircinia vansoesti sp. nov., Ircinia ruetzleri sp. nov.) in addition to one species conferre (Ircinia cf. reteplana Topsent, 1923).
- 1 December 2021
- Published by Magnolia Press in Zootaxa
- Vol. 5072 (4) , 301-323
New shallow water species of Caribbean Ircinia Nardo, 1833 (Porifera: Irciniidae)
Seven Ircinia morphospecies were collected from three sites in the Caribbean (Bocas del Toro, Panama; the Mesoamerican Barrier Reef, Belize; and the Florida Keys, United States of America). Previous research used an integrative taxonomic framework (genome-wide SNP sampling and microbiome profiling) to delimit species boundaries among these Ircinia. Here, we present morphological descriptions for these species, six of which are new to science (Ircinia lowi sp. nov., Ircinia bocatorensis sp. nov., Ircinia radix sp. nov., Ircinia laeviconulosa sp. nov., Ircinia vansoesti sp. nov., Ircinia ruetzleri sp. nov.) in addition to one species conferre (Ircinia cf. reteplana Topsent, 1923).
- Open Access
- 11 March 2021
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Microbiology
- Vol. 12
The Relationship Between Microbiomes and Selective Regimes in the Sponge Genus Ircinia
Sponges are often densely populated by microbes that benefit their hosts through nutrition and bioactive secondary metabolites; however, sponges must simultaneously contend with the toxicity of microbes and thwart microbial overgrowth. Despite these fundamental tenets of sponge biology, the patterns of selection in the host sponges’ genomes that underlie tolerance and control of their microbiomes are still poorly understood. To elucidate these patterns of selection, we performed a population genetic analysis on multiple species ofIrciniafrom Belize, Florida, and Panama using anFST-outlier approach on transcriptome-annotated RADseq loci. As part of the analysis, we delimited species boundaries among seven growth forms ofIrcinia. Our analyses identified balancing selection in immunity genes that have implications for the hosts’ tolerance of high densities of microbes. Additionally, our results support the hypothesis that each of the seven growth forms constitutes a distinctIrciniaspecies that is characterized by a unique microbiome. These results illuminate the evolutionary pathways that promote stable associations between host sponges and their microbiomes, and that potentially facilitate ecological divergence amongIrciniaspecies.
- 11 March 2021
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Microbiology
- Vol. 12
Open AccessThe Relationship Between Microbiomes and Selective Regimes in the Sponge Genus Ircinia
Sponges are often densely populated by microbes that benefit their hosts through nutrition and bioactive secondary metabolites; however, sponges must simultaneously contend with the toxicity of microbes and thwart microbial overgrowth. Despite these fundamental tenets of sponge biology, the patterns of selection in the host sponges’ genomes that underlie tolerance and control of their microbiomes are still poorly understood. To elucidate these patterns of selection, we performed a population genetic analysis on multiple species ofIrciniafrom Belize, Florida, and Panama using anFST-outlier approach on transcriptome-annotated RADseq loci. As part of the analysis, we delimited species boundaries among seven growth forms ofIrcinia. Our analyses identified balancing selection in immunity genes that have implications for the hosts’ tolerance of high densities of microbes. Additionally, our results support the hypothesis that each of the seven growth forms constitutes a distinctIrciniaspecies that is characterized by a unique microbiome. These results illuminate the evolutionary pathways that promote stable associations between host sponges and their microbiomes, and that potentially facilitate ecological divergence amongIrciniaspecies.
- Open Access
Evolution of realized Eltonian niches acrossRajidaespecies
The notion that closely related species resemble each other in ecological niche space (i.e., phylogenetic dependence) has been a long‐standing, contentious paradigm in evolutionary biology, the incidence of which is important for predicting the ecosystem‐level effects of species loss. Despite being examined across a multitude of terrestrial taxa, many aspects of niche conservatism have yet to be explored in marine species, especially for characteristics related to resource use and trophic behavior (Eltonian niche characteristics, ENCs). We combined ENCs derived from stable isotope ratios at assemblage‐ and species‐levels with phylogenetic comparative methods, to test the hypotheses that benthic marine fishes (1) exhibit similar assemblage‐wide ENCs regardless of geographic location and (2) display phylogenetically dependent ENCs at the species level. We used a 12‐species sub‐set of the monophyletic groupRajidaesampled from three independent assemblages (Central California, Gulf of Alaska, and Northwest Atlantic), which span two ocean basins. Assemblage‐level ENCs implied low trophic diversity and high evenness, suggesting thatRajidaeassemblages may exhibit a well‐defined trophic role, a trend consistent regardless of geographic location. At the species level, we found evidence for phylogenetic dependence of ENCs relating to trophic diversity (i.e., isotopic niche width; SEAc). Whether individuals can be considered functional equivalents across assemblages is hard to ascertain because we did not detect a significant phylogenetic signal for ENCs relating to trophic function (e.g., trophic position). Thus, additional, complimentary approaches are required to further examine the phylogenetic dependence of species functionality. Our approach illustrates the potential of stable isotope‐derived niche characteristics to provide insight on macroecological processes occurring across evolutionary time, which could help predict how assemblages may respond to the effects of species loss.
Open AccessEvolution of realized Eltonian niches acrossRajidaespecies
The notion that closely related species resemble each other in ecological niche space (i.e., phylogenetic dependence) has been a long‐standing, contentious paradigm in evolutionary biology, the incidence of which is important for predicting the ecosystem‐level effects of species loss. Despite being examined across a multitude of terrestrial taxa, many aspects of niche conservatism have yet to be explored in marine species, especially for characteristics related to resource use and trophic behavior (Eltonian niche characteristics, ENCs). We combined ENCs derived from stable isotope ratios at assemblage‐ and species‐levels with phylogenetic comparative methods, to test the hypotheses that benthic marine fishes (1) exhibit similar assemblage‐wide ENCs regardless of geographic location and (2) display phylogenetically dependent ENCs at the species level. We used a 12‐species sub‐set of the monophyletic groupRajidaesampled from three independent assemblages (Central California, Gulf of Alaska, and Northwest Atlantic), which span two ocean basins. Assemblage‐level ENCs implied low trophic diversity and high evenness, suggesting thatRajidaeassemblages may exhibit a well‐defined trophic role, a trend consistent regardless of geographic location. At the species level, we found evidence for phylogenetic dependence of ENCs relating to trophic diversity (i.e., isotopic niche width; SEAc). Whether individuals can be considered functional equivalents across assemblages is hard to ascertain because we did not detect a significant phylogenetic signal for ENCs relating to trophic function (e.g., trophic position). Thus, additional, complimentary approaches are required to further examine the phylogenetic dependence of species functionality. Our approach illustrates the potential of stable isotope‐derived niche characteristics to provide insight on macroecological processes occurring across evolutionary time, which could help predict how assemblages may respond to the effects of species loss.
- Open Access
Microbiomes and host genetics provide evidence for ecological diversification among Caribbean members of the sponge genus Ircinia Nardo, 1833
Sponges live in symbioses with microbes that allow the hosts to exploit otherwise inaccessible resources. Given the potential of microbiomes to unlock new niche axes for the hosts, microbiomes may facilitate evolutionary innovation in the ecology of sponges. However, the hypothesis that ecological diversification evolves via the microbiome among multiple, closely related sponge species living in sympatry is yet untested. Here, we provide the first test of this hypothesis within Ircinia , a genus possessing diverse and abundant microbiomes that engage their hosts in nutritional symbioses. We used genome-wide SNP data (2bRAD) to delimit genetic species boundaries using BFD* among four Ircinia growth forms that putatively constitute distinct species and two nominal species, I. campana and I. strobilina . We also evaluated the performance of two single-locus genetic barcodes, CO1 and ITS, in resolving Ircinia species boundaries. We then used 16S rRNA metabarcoding to test whether the genetic species units uncovered by BFD* harbor microbiomes that are compositionally unique within each host lineage and distinct relative to seawater microbial communities. BFD* recovered genetic species boundaries that are generally reflected in the morphological differences of the growth forms and upheld the species designations of I. campana and I. strobilina , whereas CO1 and ITS provided comparatively little species-level phylogenetic resolution. The microbiomes were found to be compositionally distinct relative to seawater microbial communities, conserved within host lineages, and non-overlapping relative to the microbiomes of other host lineages. These results support a model by which microbiomes underly ecological divergence in resource use among closely related sponge species. This research provides insights into the roles of microbiomes in ecological speciation of sponges and sets the groundwork for further investigation of adaptive radiations in sponges.
Open AccessMicrobiomes and host genetics provide evidence for ecological diversification among Caribbean members of the sponge genus Ircinia Nardo, 1833
Sponges live in symbioses with microbes that allow the hosts to exploit otherwise inaccessible resources. Given the potential of microbiomes to unlock new niche axes for the hosts, microbiomes may facilitate evolutionary innovation in the ecology of sponges. However, the hypothesis that ecological diversification evolves via the microbiome among multiple, closely related sponge species living in sympatry is yet untested. Here, we provide the first test of this hypothesis within Ircinia , a genus possessing diverse and abundant microbiomes that engage their hosts in nutritional symbioses. We used genome-wide SNP data (2bRAD) to delimit genetic species boundaries using BFD* among four Ircinia growth forms that putatively constitute distinct species and two nominal species, I. campana and I. strobilina . We also evaluated the performance of two single-locus genetic barcodes, CO1 and ITS, in resolving Ircinia species boundaries. We then used 16S rRNA metabarcoding to test whether the genetic species units uncovered by BFD* harbor microbiomes that are compositionally unique within each host lineage and distinct relative to seawater microbial communities. BFD* recovered genetic species boundaries that are generally reflected in the morphological differences of the growth forms and upheld the species designations of I. campana and I. strobilina , whereas CO1 and ITS provided comparatively little species-level phylogenetic resolution. The microbiomes were found to be compositionally distinct relative to seawater microbial communities, conserved within host lineages, and non-overlapping relative to the microbiomes of other host lineages. These results support a model by which microbiomes underly ecological divergence in resource use among closely related sponge species. This research provides insights into the roles of microbiomes in ecological speciation of sponges and sets the groundwork for further investigation of adaptive radiations in sponges.