Hanna Louise Pettersson
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Hanna Louise Pettersson has a total of 54 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Chris D. Thomas
Leverhulme Centre for Anthropocene Biodiversity, Department of Biology University of York York UK
2 shared publications - Jack H. Hatfield
Leverhulme Centre for Anthropocene Biodiversity University of York York UK
2 shared publications Steven M. Sait
School of Biology, Faculty of Biological Sciences University of Leeds Leeds UK
2 shared publications- Anders Clarhäll
Formas
1 shared publication - Angela Lomba
BIOPOLIS Program in Genomics, Biodiversity and Land Planning CIBIO Research Centre in Biodiversity and Genetic Resources Vairão Portugal
1 shared publication - Brennen Fagan
Leverhulme Centre for Anthropocene Biodiversity, University of York
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 18 November 2026
- Published by The Swedish Research Council for Environment, Agricultural Sciences and Spatial Planning (Formas)
Predation effects of seals and cormorants on fish populations: Protocol for an evidence synthesis project
Background: The Swedish Government has commissioned the Swedish Research Council for Environment, Agricultural Sciences and Spatial Planning (Formas) to assess current knowledge on interactions between seals, cormorants and fish. These interactions may vary among species, populations, ecosystems and environmental conditions, and their effects therefore need to be assessed systematically. Objectives: This evidence synthesis will assess empirical evidence on (1) associations between seal and cormorant predation and changes in fish population or stock status; (2) the magnitude of predation relative to fish population or stock abundance, biomass, total mortality or fishery removals; and (3) stakeholder knowledge, experiences and perceptions concerning seal and cormorant interaction with fish, and related management strategies, regulations and interventions. The synthesis will also examine how ecological conditions, environmental context and study methods contribute to variation in findings across studies. Methods: Searches will cover all seal, cormorant and fish species, with no restrictions on geographical region, publication date or language. Web of Science Core Collection, Scopus, ProQuest Agricultural Science Collection and CAB Abstracts will be searched, supplemented by other bibliographic and grey-literature sources and reference checking. Titles and abstracts will be screened by one reviewer, with a subset checked by a second reviewer; full texts will be assessed by two reviewers. Data will be extracted using a structured, pilot-tested form. Risk of bias and transferability to Swedish conditions will be assessed using separate tools for ecological and social-science studies, with risk of bias and contextual similarity evaluated as distinct dimensions. Synthesis: The three evidence domains will be synthesised separately, with narrative synthesis as the primary approach. Differences among studies will be examined in relation to ecological, environmental and methodological factors. Random-effects meta-analysis may be undertaken where enough studies with sufficiently comparable data are available. Stakeholder evidence will be structured using the 3i framework of interest, influence and impact where the available data permit. Findings will be considered in a wider ecosystem context to inform ecosystem-based management in Swedish coastal and inland waters.
- 18 November 2026
- Published by The Swedish Research Council for Environment, Agricultural Sciences and Spatial Planning (Formas)
Predation effects of seals and cormorants on fish populations: Protocol for an evidence synthesis project
Background: The Swedish Government has commissioned the Swedish Research Council for Environment, Agricultural Sciences and Spatial Planning (Formas) to assess current knowledge on interactions between seals, cormorants and fish. These interactions may vary among species, populations, ecosystems and environmental conditions, and their effects therefore need to be assessed systematically. Objectives: This evidence synthesis will assess empirical evidence on (1) associations between seal and cormorant predation and changes in fish population or stock status; (2) the magnitude of predation relative to fish population or stock abundance, biomass, total mortality or fishery removals; and (3) stakeholder knowledge, experiences and perceptions concerning seal and cormorant interaction with fish, and related management strategies, regulations and interventions. The synthesis will also examine how ecological conditions, environmental context and study methods contribute to variation in findings across studies. Methods: Searches will cover all seal, cormorant and fish species, with no restrictions on geographical region, publication date or language. Web of Science Core Collection, Scopus, ProQuest Agricultural Science Collection and CAB Abstracts will be searched, supplemented by other bibliographic and grey-literature sources and reference checking. Titles and abstracts will be screened by one reviewer, with a subset checked by a second reviewer; full texts will be assessed by two reviewers. Data will be extracted using a structured, pilot-tested form. Risk of bias and transferability to Swedish conditions will be assessed using separate tools for ecological and social-science studies, with risk of bias and contextual similarity evaluated as distinct dimensions. Synthesis: The three evidence domains will be synthesised separately, with narrative synthesis as the primary approach. Differences among studies will be examined in relation to ecological, environmental and methodological factors. Random-effects meta-analysis may be undertaken where enough studies with sufficiently comparable data are available. Stakeholder evidence will be structured using the 3i framework of interest, influence and impact where the available data permit. Findings will be considered in a wider ecosystem context to inform ecosystem-based management in Swedish coastal and inland waters.
- Open Access
- 14 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
Sharing landscapes with wildlife: Conflict and coexistence between high nature value pastoral systems and large carnivores
High nature value (HNV) pastoral systems, that is those maintained by herding, transhumance and extensive grazing practices, are recognised as cornerstones of European biodiversity, cultural heritage and ecosystem service provision. Yet these systems are currently under significant pressure from a range of economic, social and environmental drivers. The recovery of large carnivore populations across Europe, while representing a major conservation success, constitutes an additional significant pressure. Pastoral systems are predominantly located in marginal and remote areas, maintained by the grazing of extensive livestock or reindeer, and are thus both at the frontline of carnivore recovery and most vulnerable to negative impacts, such as depredation. This Special Feature, bringing together 15 interdisciplinary contributions spanning pastoral and rangeland systems across Europe, the Americas, and Central and East Asia, is published at a critical juncture in European wildlife, nature restoration and agricultural policy, while also coinciding with the UN International Year of Rangelands and Pastoralism. It aims to advance integrated and interdisciplinary knowledge of coexistence with carnivores in HNV pastoralist landscapes. This editorial discusses the joint challenges, solutions and research gaps highlighted by the contributions. Three primary and systemic drivers are identified as undermining pastoral resilience and associated coexistence capacity with large carnivores: the loss of mobility and common resources; unfavourable market and policy environments; and shifting social and institutional contexts. A central finding across contributions is that large carnivore impacts (including depredation) must not be treated as an isolated issue, but as one feature within this broader socio‐environmental context of challenges and drivers of vulnerability in pastoral landscapes. Alongside these pressures, the feature also highlights enabling conditions for coexistence, including place‐based approaches, co‐production of knowledge, participatory governance platforms, maintained local institutions and the meaningful integration of pastoralists' expertise. The feature concludes with calls for better coordination between agricultural and conservation policy, enhanced and holistic protection of pastoral systems' resilience, and for treating coexistence as an iterative, adaptive process requiring sustained institutional commitment and trusting relationships with local communities. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- 14 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
Open AccessSharing landscapes with wildlife: Conflict and coexistence between high nature value pastoral systems and large carnivores
High nature value (HNV) pastoral systems, that is those maintained by herding, transhumance and extensive grazing practices, are recognised as cornerstones of European biodiversity, cultural heritage and ecosystem service provision. Yet these systems are currently under significant pressure from a range of economic, social and environmental drivers. The recovery of large carnivore populations across Europe, while representing a major conservation success, constitutes an additional significant pressure. Pastoral systems are predominantly located in marginal and remote areas, maintained by the grazing of extensive livestock or reindeer, and are thus both at the frontline of carnivore recovery and most vulnerable to negative impacts, such as depredation. This Special Feature, bringing together 15 interdisciplinary contributions spanning pastoral and rangeland systems across Europe, the Americas, and Central and East Asia, is published at a critical juncture in European wildlife, nature restoration and agricultural policy, while also coinciding with the UN International Year of Rangelands and Pastoralism. It aims to advance integrated and interdisciplinary knowledge of coexistence with carnivores in HNV pastoralist landscapes. This editorial discusses the joint challenges, solutions and research gaps highlighted by the contributions. Three primary and systemic drivers are identified as undermining pastoral resilience and associated coexistence capacity with large carnivores: the loss of mobility and common resources; unfavourable market and policy environments; and shifting social and institutional contexts. A central finding across contributions is that large carnivore impacts (including depredation) must not be treated as an isolated issue, but as one feature within this broader socio‐environmental context of challenges and drivers of vulnerability in pastoral landscapes. Alongside these pressures, the feature also highlights enabling conditions for coexistence, including place‐based approaches, co‐production of knowledge, participatory governance platforms, maintained local institutions and the meaningful integration of pastoralists' expertise. The feature concludes with calls for better coordination between agricultural and conservation policy, enhanced and holistic protection of pastoral systems' resilience, and for treating coexistence as an iterative, adaptive process requiring sustained institutional commitment and trusting relationships with local communities. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- Open Access
- 31 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Letters
- Vol. 19 (3)
The Paradox of Success in Conservation Performance Payments: Rising Costs and Declining Trust in Sweden's Carnivore Policy
Human–wildlife coexistence is central to global biodiversity agendas, yet can impose substantial costs on affected communities. Conservation Performance Payments (CPPs), which reward participants for wildlife presence, aim to redistribute these costs and reduce conflicts. Sweden's state‐funded CPP for Indigenous Sámi reindeer herders to share space with wolverines, lynx, and wolves is the oldest scheme of its kind and widely hailed as best practice for coexistence. Drawing on interviews, ecological data, and policy records spanning nearly three decades, we assess its operation in Norrbotten County, a hotspot for wolverines and herding communities. We show that scheme effectiveness has not been sustained: Payments do not match rising coexistence costs, monitoring methods have become unreliable under changing climate conditions, and participants’ trust in the system has eroded. The resulting loss of legitimacy coincides with a reversal of the regional wolverine recovery previously enabled by the scheme. Our findings illuminate a dilemma for results‐based payments: success increases costs, demanding sustained institutional accountability and adaptive management. Without this, pressure mounts on local communities, undermining social justice and conservation goals. We conclude that CPPs can be a valuable complementary tool for coexistence, if designed to adapt to socio‐ecological change, rising costs, and participants’ needs over time.
- 31 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Letters
- Vol. 19 (3)
Open AccessThe Paradox of Success in Conservation Performance Payments: Rising Costs and Declining Trust in Sweden's Carnivore Policy
Human–wildlife coexistence is central to global biodiversity agendas, yet can impose substantial costs on affected communities. Conservation Performance Payments (CPPs), which reward participants for wildlife presence, aim to redistribute these costs and reduce conflicts. Sweden's state‐funded CPP for Indigenous Sámi reindeer herders to share space with wolverines, lynx, and wolves is the oldest scheme of its kind and widely hailed as best practice for coexistence. Drawing on interviews, ecological data, and policy records spanning nearly three decades, we assess its operation in Norrbotten County, a hotspot for wolverines and herding communities. We show that scheme effectiveness has not been sustained: Payments do not match rising coexistence costs, monitoring methods have become unreliable under changing climate conditions, and participants’ trust in the system has eroded. The resulting loss of legitimacy coincides with a reversal of the regional wolverine recovery previously enabled by the scheme. Our findings illuminate a dilemma for results‐based payments: success increases costs, demanding sustained institutional accountability and adaptive management. Without this, pressure mounts on local communities, undermining social justice and conservation goals. We conclude that CPPs can be a valuable complementary tool for coexistence, if designed to adapt to socio‐ecological change, rising costs, and participants’ needs over time.
- Open Access
- 19 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
- Vol. 8 (5) , 1000-1006
Delivering resilience for people and nature in Anthropocene landscapes
The concept of resilience is widespread in strategies for enhancing biodiversity and ecosystem services, but, in practice, resilience means different things in different socio‐ecological and policy contexts and to different people. In this perspective, we argue that the current use of the resilience concept fails to recognise this lack of consensus, hiding underlying assumptions and values and missing opportunities to identify strategies with multiple co‐benefits. We argue that a new approach is required which directly acknowledges the political and human aspects and allows us to openly address trade‐offs and synergies. We suggest ways forward for developing solutions to these issues. We argue that resilience as a concept is most useful when defined explicitly and targeted towards socio‐ecological processes, functions and services, rather than specific outcomes based on the identity and composition of species and ecosystems. This shift facilitates inclusive engagement and co‐production of conservation aims as well as enabling appropriate monitoring and adaptive management. Clarity of targets and aims is also needed so as to maximise positive synergies and minimise negative trade‐offs between different ecological outcomes and between socio‐ecological and policy aims. This clarity is required to identify pathways that will deliver the greatest co‐benefits for nature and people. We discuss with examples the different dimensions in which trade‐offs and synergies can emerge. Efforts to improve resilience in Anthropocene landscapes must also recognise that the future will not resemble the present or the past, requiring new measures and evaluation of success, rather than comparisons to past ecological states which may not be appropriate in a rapidly changing world. Identifying pathways to improved resilience requires a transparent, science‐informed and participatory process, which specifies why a particular version of resilience is being pursued, clearly defines the intended outcomes and monitors progress towards these goals. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- 19 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
- Vol. 8 (5) , 1000-1006
Open AccessDelivering resilience for people and nature in Anthropocene landscapes
The concept of resilience is widespread in strategies for enhancing biodiversity and ecosystem services, but, in practice, resilience means different things in different socio‐ecological and policy contexts and to different people. In this perspective, we argue that the current use of the resilience concept fails to recognise this lack of consensus, hiding underlying assumptions and values and missing opportunities to identify strategies with multiple co‐benefits. We argue that a new approach is required which directly acknowledges the political and human aspects and allows us to openly address trade‐offs and synergies. We suggest ways forward for developing solutions to these issues. We argue that resilience as a concept is most useful when defined explicitly and targeted towards socio‐ecological processes, functions and services, rather than specific outcomes based on the identity and composition of species and ecosystems. This shift facilitates inclusive engagement and co‐production of conservation aims as well as enabling appropriate monitoring and adaptive management. Clarity of targets and aims is also needed so as to maximise positive synergies and minimise negative trade‐offs between different ecological outcomes and between socio‐ecological and policy aims. This clarity is required to identify pathways that will deliver the greatest co‐benefits for nature and people. We discuss with examples the different dimensions in which trade‐offs and synergies can emerge. Efforts to improve resilience in Anthropocene landscapes must also recognise that the future will not resemble the present or the past, requiring new measures and evaluation of success, rather than comparisons to past ecological states which may not be appropriate in a rapidly changing world. Identifying pathways to improved resilience requires a transparent, science‐informed and participatory process, which specifies why a particular version of resilience is being pursued, clearly defines the intended outcomes and monitors progress towards these goals. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- Open Access
- 22 January 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
- Vol. 381 (1942)
Life on New Earth: biodiversity change and humanity in a novel future
Accounting for ecological novelty, gains and past human experiences through social–ecological–technological systems (SETS) can help society navigate accelerating global biodiversity change. Popular narratives stress escalating loss of species and ecosystems, and the potential collapse of the benefits they provide to people. In the public sphere, this can present the spectre of an uninhabitable Earth and the extinction of the human species. Research suggests that these crisis narratives can raise awareness, but are counterproductive in stimulating mitigating or adaptive action. They also omit evidence of biodiversity gains and ongoing adaptation alongside losses. Archaeological evidence also highlights the human ability to take advantage of and thrive under an extremely wide range of changing and challenging ecological conditions and the provisioning opportunities these provide. This perspective provides an evidenced counterargument to claims of civilizational collapse amid environmental change. Projections show that rather than universal ecological decline, a cosmopolitan biosphere of losses and gains will probably emerge. Distilled, these insights provoke a new research agenda, centred on how we measure, frame and imagine alternative futures so that we can systematically explore pathways and scenarios for a just and thriving humanity on a climatically and ecologically transforming Earth. This article is part of the theme issue ‘The biosphere in the Anthropocene’.
- 22 January 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
- Vol. 381 (1942)
Open AccessLife on New Earth: biodiversity change and humanity in a novel future
Accounting for ecological novelty, gains and past human experiences through social–ecological–technological systems (SETS) can help society navigate accelerating global biodiversity change. Popular narratives stress escalating loss of species and ecosystems, and the potential collapse of the benefits they provide to people. In the public sphere, this can present the spectre of an uninhabitable Earth and the extinction of the human species. Research suggests that these crisis narratives can raise awareness, but are counterproductive in stimulating mitigating or adaptive action. They also omit evidence of biodiversity gains and ongoing adaptation alongside losses. Archaeological evidence also highlights the human ability to take advantage of and thrive under an extremely wide range of changing and challenging ecological conditions and the provisioning opportunities these provide. This perspective provides an evidenced counterargument to claims of civilizational collapse amid environmental change. Projections show that rather than universal ecological decline, a cosmopolitan biosphere of losses and gains will probably emerge. Distilled, these insights provoke a new research agenda, centred on how we measure, frame and imagine alternative futures so that we can systematically explore pathways and scenarios for a just and thriving humanity on a climatically and ecologically transforming Earth. This article is part of the theme issue ‘The biosphere in the Anthropocene’.
- Open Access
- 10 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
- Vol. 7 (10) , 2278-2290
Reimagining habituation: The case for a reciprocal and contextual understanding
As the frequency and intensity of human–wildlife interactions continue to rise, the process and outcomes of habituation are becoming more important. Commonly defined as ‘…a waning of response to a repeated, neutral stimuli’ or of similar wording, we argue that these conceptualisations of habituation are too simplistic in the context of direct human–wildlife interactions. We argue that much of the habituation literature has been one‐sided (i.e. focused only on the nonhuman) and detriment‐focused, failing to grasp the deep complexities of the process and its implications. We conducted a brief scoping review of the habituation literature to show how the term is being used by whom, and in what context. We sought to explore habituation from a broad disciplinary range and therefore included literature from ethology, behavioural ecology and conservation biology as well as disciplines less represented in mainstream conservation such as multispecies anthropology, political ecology and more‐than‐human geography. Supported by the scoping review, we illustrate that habituation as an outcome of human–wildlife interactions is (1) a nuanced, reciprocal process that is both understood and practised in diverse ways, with potentially negative and positive impacts for both people and wildlife and (2) is shaped by cultural, historical and political–economic contexts. We share four case examples based on our own research that justify and reinforce our arguments for reframing our understanding of habituation. Adopting more reciprocal and contextual conceptualisations of habituation will improve our collective understanding of how it occurs and how to find ways to adapt and coexist. We urge future research to explore these ideas and understandings through different geographical and species contexts and apply additional disciplinary approaches to understanding and managing human–wildlife interactions. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- 10 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
- Vol. 7 (10) , 2278-2290
Open AccessReimagining habituation: The case for a reciprocal and contextual understanding
As the frequency and intensity of human–wildlife interactions continue to rise, the process and outcomes of habituation are becoming more important. Commonly defined as ‘…a waning of response to a repeated, neutral stimuli’ or of similar wording, we argue that these conceptualisations of habituation are too simplistic in the context of direct human–wildlife interactions. We argue that much of the habituation literature has been one‐sided (i.e. focused only on the nonhuman) and detriment‐focused, failing to grasp the deep complexities of the process and its implications. We conducted a brief scoping review of the habituation literature to show how the term is being used by whom, and in what context. We sought to explore habituation from a broad disciplinary range and therefore included literature from ethology, behavioural ecology and conservation biology as well as disciplines less represented in mainstream conservation such as multispecies anthropology, political ecology and more‐than‐human geography. Supported by the scoping review, we illustrate that habituation as an outcome of human–wildlife interactions is (1) a nuanced, reciprocal process that is both understood and practised in diverse ways, with potentially negative and positive impacts for both people and wildlife and (2) is shaped by cultural, historical and political–economic contexts. We share four case examples based on our own research that justify and reinforce our arguments for reframing our understanding of habituation. Adopting more reciprocal and contextual conceptualisations of habituation will improve our collective understanding of how it occurs and how to find ways to adapt and coexist. We urge future research to explore these ideas and understandings through different geographical and species contexts and apply additional disciplinary approaches to understanding and managing human–wildlife interactions. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- Open Access
- 22 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
Who is local and what do they know? Braiding knowledges within carnivore management in Europe
Growing recognition of Indigenous Peoples and traditional local communities as stewards of biodiversity has brought to the fore the issues of knowledge and value pluralism in conservation policy and practice. Given their basis in practical and multi‐generational experience, Indigenous and local knowledges are highly relevant to managing human–wildlife interactions, especially species that are challenging to live with. Yet, these situated forms of knowledge remain overlooked and marginalised, especially ‘local knowledge’, as it is unclear what or whom is encompassed within the term. We explore local knowledge in the context of pastoral areas in Europe, where populations of large carnivores such as wolves are currently expanding. We ask: who is ‘local’, what constitutes ‘local knowledge’ and what can this knowledge contribute to carnivore management? We show that continuous exchanges between long‐settled residents, newcomers and transient people in pastoral areas mean that ‘localness’ cannot be approached as a dualist position. Similarly, local knowledge is dynamic and continuously evolving in the face of ongoing and emerging change, which makes efforts of categorisation and preservation complex. We argue that current approaches to incorporating local knowledge often fail to account for this complexity, producing unjust and ineffective policies and strategies. To advance understanding, we offer an approach that situates local knowledge and those who hold it on a spectrum of knowledge characteristics. We then describe the challenges of braiding knowledge that are particularly relevant for carnivore management, illustrated by examples from our own research and the broader literature. To tackle the challenges, we propose ‘spacing’ conservation planning by investing in networks of emplaced practitioners, tasked with coordinating the mobilisation and braiding of relevant knowledges and producing locally adapted strategies for coexistence. Policy implications. Pluralism in carnivore management goes beyond incorporating the technical know‐how of local communities. It requires a better recognition and braiding of different kinds of knowledge and skills, at all scales, to produce better outcomes for people and nature. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- 22 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
Open AccessWho is local and what do they know? Braiding knowledges within carnivore management in Europe
Growing recognition of Indigenous Peoples and traditional local communities as stewards of biodiversity has brought to the fore the issues of knowledge and value pluralism in conservation policy and practice. Given their basis in practical and multi‐generational experience, Indigenous and local knowledges are highly relevant to managing human–wildlife interactions, especially species that are challenging to live with. Yet, these situated forms of knowledge remain overlooked and marginalised, especially ‘local knowledge’, as it is unclear what or whom is encompassed within the term. We explore local knowledge in the context of pastoral areas in Europe, where populations of large carnivores such as wolves are currently expanding. We ask: who is ‘local’, what constitutes ‘local knowledge’ and what can this knowledge contribute to carnivore management? We show that continuous exchanges between long‐settled residents, newcomers and transient people in pastoral areas mean that ‘localness’ cannot be approached as a dualist position. Similarly, local knowledge is dynamic and continuously evolving in the face of ongoing and emerging change, which makes efforts of categorisation and preservation complex. We argue that current approaches to incorporating local knowledge often fail to account for this complexity, producing unjust and ineffective policies and strategies. To advance understanding, we offer an approach that situates local knowledge and those who hold it on a spectrum of knowledge characteristics. We then describe the challenges of braiding knowledge that are particularly relevant for carnivore management, illustrated by examples from our own research and the broader literature. To tackle the challenges, we propose ‘spacing’ conservation planning by investing in networks of emplaced practitioners, tasked with coordinating the mobilisation and braiding of relevant knowledges and producing locally adapted strategies for coexistence. Policy implications. Pluralism in carnivore management goes beyond incorporating the technical know‐how of local communities. It requires a better recognition and braiding of different kinds of knowledge and skills, at all scales, to produce better outcomes for people and nature. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- Open Access
- 15 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
- Vol. 5 (6) , 1989-2005
Who must adapt to whom? Contested discourses on human–wolf coexistence and their impact on policy in Spain
Emerging nature restoration agendas are increasing the pressure on rural communities to coexist with expanding wildlife, including large carnivores. There are different interpretations of coexistence, stemming from divergent ways of conceptualising and relating to nature. Yet there is limited understanding of how and why certain interpretations become dominant, and how this influences conservation policy and practice. This question is highly relevant for the management of wolves in Spain. Until recently, the national strategy allowed certain regional autonomy in creating and enacting coexistence policy, including through culling and sport hunting. However, in 2021, the national government declared wolves strictly protected throughout the country, despite strong contestations about whether and why it was necessary. We studied the discursive processes that co‐produced this policy shift. First, we explored interpretations among communities that share, or will share, space with wolves, using qualitative field data. Second, we triangulated local interpretations with framings in public media to identify prominent discourses about coexistence. Third, we traced how these discourses interacted with Spanish conservation policy: who was heard and why. We highlight three prominent discourses: wolf protectionism, traditionalism and pragmatism, each proposing a distinct pathway to coexistence with wolves. Through our policy analysis, we illuminate a dominance of protectionism within national politics, which justified a centralised technocratic pathway while downplaying place‐based approaches. The resulting coexistence policy was highly contested and appears to have increased social conflict over wolves. Our findings reveal knowledge hierarchies within Spanish policy frameworks that promotes ‘mainstream’ conservationists' narrow interpretation of what nature and coexistence should be. This has perpetuated an apolitical approach that is focussed on mediating direct impacts from wolves, rather than conflicting worldviews, and that undermines efforts to promote dialogue and local stewardship. While our research is centred on Spain, the findings are of broad relevance since they reveal structural barriers that constrain the incorporation of diverse knowledge systems into conservation policy, and subsequent transformations towards socially just and locally adapted coexistence programmes. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- 15 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
- Vol. 5 (6) , 1989-2005
Open AccessWho must adapt to whom? Contested discourses on human–wolf coexistence and their impact on policy in Spain
Emerging nature restoration agendas are increasing the pressure on rural communities to coexist with expanding wildlife, including large carnivores. There are different interpretations of coexistence, stemming from divergent ways of conceptualising and relating to nature. Yet there is limited understanding of how and why certain interpretations become dominant, and how this influences conservation policy and practice. This question is highly relevant for the management of wolves in Spain. Until recently, the national strategy allowed certain regional autonomy in creating and enacting coexistence policy, including through culling and sport hunting. However, in 2021, the national government declared wolves strictly protected throughout the country, despite strong contestations about whether and why it was necessary. We studied the discursive processes that co‐produced this policy shift. First, we explored interpretations among communities that share, or will share, space with wolves, using qualitative field data. Second, we triangulated local interpretations with framings in public media to identify prominent discourses about coexistence. Third, we traced how these discourses interacted with Spanish conservation policy: who was heard and why. We highlight three prominent discourses: wolf protectionism, traditionalism and pragmatism, each proposing a distinct pathway to coexistence with wolves. Through our policy analysis, we illuminate a dominance of protectionism within national politics, which justified a centralised technocratic pathway while downplaying place‐based approaches. The resulting coexistence policy was highly contested and appears to have increased social conflict over wolves. Our findings reveal knowledge hierarchies within Spanish policy frameworks that promotes ‘mainstream’ conservationists' narrow interpretation of what nature and coexistence should be. This has perpetuated an apolitical approach that is focussed on mediating direct impacts from wolves, rather than conflicting worldviews, and that undermines efforts to promote dialogue and local stewardship. While our research is centred on Spain, the findings are of broad relevance since they reveal structural barriers that constrain the incorporation of diverse knowledge systems into conservation policy, and subsequent transformations towards socially just and locally adapted coexistence programmes. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- Open Access
- 10 September 2021
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Conservation Science
- Vol. 2
Welcoming Wolves? Governing the Return of Large Carnivores in Traditional Pastoral Landscapes
Wolf populations are recovering across Europe and readily recolonize most areas where humans allow their presence. Reintegrating wolves in human-dominated landscapes is a major challenge, particularly in places where memories and experience of coexistence have been lost. Despite the observed expansion trends, little has been done to prepare communities for the return of these apex predators, or to understand what fosters and perpetuates coexistence. In this study, we present a theoretical framework for resilient coexistence based on four conditions: Effective institutions, large carnivore persistence, social legitimacy, and low levels of risk and vulnerability, nested within the social-ecological systems (SES) concept. To empirically show how the conditions can be manifested and interconnected, and how this knowledge could be used to improve local coexistence capacities, the framework is applied in a case study of human–wolf relations in Spain. We examined three traditionally pastoral landscapes at different states of cohabitation with wolves: uninterrupted presence, recent recolonization, and imminent return. We found that both the perceptions of wolves and the capacity to coexist with them diverged across these states, and that this was largely determined by a diversity of vulnerabilities that have not been recognized or addressed within current management regimes, such as economic precarity and weak legitimacy for governing institutions. Our results illustrate the importance of working in close contact with communities to understand local needs and enhance adaptive capacities in the face of rural transitions, beyond those directly related to wolves. The framework complements emerging tools for coexistence developed by researchers and practitioners, which offer guidance on the process of situational analysis, planning, and resource allocation needed to balance large carnivore conservation with local livelihoods.
- 10 September 2021
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Conservation Science
- Vol. 2
Open AccessWelcoming Wolves? Governing the Return of Large Carnivores in Traditional Pastoral Landscapes
Wolf populations are recovering across Europe and readily recolonize most areas where humans allow their presence. Reintegrating wolves in human-dominated landscapes is a major challenge, particularly in places where memories and experience of coexistence have been lost. Despite the observed expansion trends, little has been done to prepare communities for the return of these apex predators, or to understand what fosters and perpetuates coexistence. In this study, we present a theoretical framework for resilient coexistence based on four conditions: Effective institutions, large carnivore persistence, social legitimacy, and low levels of risk and vulnerability, nested within the social-ecological systems (SES) concept. To empirically show how the conditions can be manifested and interconnected, and how this knowledge could be used to improve local coexistence capacities, the framework is applied in a case study of human–wolf relations in Spain. We examined three traditionally pastoral landscapes at different states of cohabitation with wolves: uninterrupted presence, recent recolonization, and imminent return. We found that both the perceptions of wolves and the capacity to coexist with them diverged across these states, and that this was largely determined by a diversity of vulnerabilities that have not been recognized or addressed within current management regimes, such as economic precarity and weak legitimacy for governing institutions. Our results illustrate the importance of working in close contact with communities to understand local needs and enhance adaptive capacities in the face of rural transitions, beyond those directly related to wolves. The framework complements emerging tools for coexistence developed by researchers and practitioners, which offer guidance on the process of situational analysis, planning, and resource allocation needed to balance large carnivore conservation with local livelihoods.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2020
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 3 (5)
Rewilding and gazetting the Iberá National Park: Using an asset approach to evaluate project success
The rising demand for natural resources increases the pressure on conservationists to justify the protection and restoration of biodiversity. However, the benefits of protected wild spaces to people are not always evident. In this study, we analyzed a rewilding and national park project in the Iberá Wetlands. We deployed the Protected Area Asset Framework to analyze how investments made by an international NGO in local products, resources and relationships developed new value‐generating practices in the area. We also studied the resulting impact on local stakeholders' perceptions of the project. The results indicate that the NGO's investments have enhanced Iberá's perceived value, also of its less tangible assets such as its aesthetic beauty and cultural significance. This has generated a gradual shift in attitudes from widespread apprehension to increased local support for the new national park. The study contends that gaining local acceptance for protected areas may be facilitated by illuminating their diverse social, cultural and economic potential. The Asset Framework can be used to reveal values that emerge out of society's interaction with nature and help managers develop new and engaging narratives for conservation projects. The lessons provided by the Iberá project can inform management of protected areas in Argentina and elsewhere.
- 18 September 2020
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 3 (5)
Open AccessRewilding and gazetting the Iberá National Park: Using an asset approach to evaluate project success
The rising demand for natural resources increases the pressure on conservationists to justify the protection and restoration of biodiversity. However, the benefits of protected wild spaces to people are not always evident. In this study, we analyzed a rewilding and national park project in the Iberá Wetlands. We deployed the Protected Area Asset Framework to analyze how investments made by an international NGO in local products, resources and relationships developed new value‐generating practices in the area. We also studied the resulting impact on local stakeholders' perceptions of the project. The results indicate that the NGO's investments have enhanced Iberá's perceived value, also of its less tangible assets such as its aesthetic beauty and cultural significance. This has generated a gradual shift in attitudes from widespread apprehension to increased local support for the new national park. The study contends that gaining local acceptance for protected areas may be facilitated by illuminating their diverse social, cultural and economic potential. The Asset Framework can be used to reveal values that emerge out of society's interaction with nature and help managers develop new and engaging narratives for conservation projects. The lessons provided by the Iberá project can inform management of protected areas in Argentina and elsewhere.