Vince Palace

Vince Palace

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Vince Palace has a total of 101 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Remediation of Simulated Heavy Crude Oil Spills in a Boreal Lake Using Enhanced Monitored Natural Recovery (eMNR): Impacts on Phytoplankton and Biofilm Communities

    by Hakeem Omilowo, Madeline Stanley, Lauren Timlick, Lisa Peters, Dave Findlay, Scott Higgins, Mark Hanson, Vince Palace

    A lake littoral enclosure study was conducted to evaluate the effects of a minimally invasive secondary remediation method (enhanced Monitored Natural Recovery eMNR) on phytoplankton and biofilm communities following a model heavy crude oil spill. Enclosures (n = 3; ~ 27,000 L) received 1.5 kg of weathered conventional heavy crude and underwent primary remediation by freshwater shoreline flushing and oil recovery using oleophilic sorbent pads, followed by nutrient addition to stimulate microbial degradation (eMNR). Reference enclosures (n = 3) received shoreline flushing only. Phytoplankton chlorophyll-a and biofilm ash-free dry mass were monitored over 400 days, while biofilm community composition was sampled at the end of the study. No statistically significant differences were detected between eMNR and reference enclosures for any measured endpoint. Under the single nutrient-addition regime tested and the specific oligotrophic conditions of this boreal lake, eMNR did not measurably affect primary producer biomass or community structure. However, alternative formulations, nutrient doses, or environmental conditions may yield different outcomes, and caution is warranted when generalizing these results to other systems.

  • Open Access

    Rapid Chemical Remediation of Freshwater Enclosures Treated with Conventional Heavy Crude Oil Spills Followed by Enhanced Monitored Natural Recovery

    by Madeline J. Stanley, Lauren Timlick, Lisa E. Peters, José Luis Rodríguez Gil, Gregg Tomy, Elliott Taylor, Sonya Havens, Vince P. Palace

    Canada is a top producer and exporter of crude oil but also has many in-land freshwater ecosystems that need protection using non-invasive remediation methods that are effective in sensitive environments. To assess the efficacy of enhanced monitored natural recovery (eMNR) as a secondary remediation strategy for freshwater oil spills, we conducted controlled spills of conventional heavy crude oil (CHV) in a freshwater lake at the IISD-Experimental Lakes Area in northwestern Ontario, Canada, in 2021. Three shoreline enclosures (5 × 10 m) were deployed on a wetland shoreline and treated with ~1.5 kg of weathered CHV. Four days later primary recovery of oil was conducted using shoreline washing followed by secondary remediation of residual oil using eMNR. Three unoiled, reference enclosures were also treated with shoreline washing but not secondary remediation. Polycyclic aromatic compounds (PAC) in water and sediment, and general water quality were monitored in the enclosures for 412 days after oiling. Total PACs in the water, mostly of 2- and 3-ring alkylated compounds, peaked three days after oiling (1188 ± 251 ng/L), declined to half of initial concentrations 8.26–11.75 days later and to near background levels by day 73. Total PACs were elevated in sediment of the oiled enclosures until day 70 likely due to sorption or settling oil but were heterogenous and influenced by pyrogenic compounds. Results from this study suggest that eMNR may be an effective remediation method following primary recovery efforts at sensitive aquatic sites where mechanical recovery is contraindicated.


  • Open Access

    Assessing the Capabilities of Oil Detection Canines to Detect Submerged Weathered Oils in a Boreal Lake

    by Vince Palace, Paul Bunker, Lauren Timlick, Christina Brewster, Ed Owens, James McCourt, David Dickins

    The efficacy of oil spill response depends on the speed of detecting the oil. Detecting submerged oil is more difficult than oil on the water surface, because most conventional sensors are not effective. Oil Detection Canines (ODCs) have been reliably used to detect oil during shoreline spill surveys, and preliminary laboratory studies also showed promising results for detecting oil submerged under water. To confirm their potential, a field study was conducted in a boreal freshwater lake in Northwestern Ontario, Canada to investigate the capability of an ODC to detect submerged weathered oils at depths of 1 to 5 m. Triplicate targets at each depth used weathered diluted bitumen (dilbit), Bunker C residual fuel oil, and Maya crude oil burn residue and both the ODC and handler blinded to the location of each target. Boat-based searches were conducted and the handler identified “alerts” based on ODC behaviour changes that were compared to georeferenced oil target locations. The ODC positively identified seven (7) of the eight (8) dilbit targets at 1 to 5 m, five (5) of the six (6) Bunker C targets at 1 and 3 m, and none of the burn residue targets at 1-m depth. The ability of ODCs to detect submerged or sunken oil in shallow water was clearly demonstrated, adding another technique for submerged and sunken oil surveys with the advantages of real-time data returns, the ability to detect small oil deposits, and an operational capability in shallow waters with potential for detection in deeper water.


  • Open Access

    Freshwater Phenanthrene Removal by Three Emergent Wetland Plants

    by Madeline J. Stanley, Aidan Guttormson, Lisa E. Peters, Thor Halldorson, Gregg Tomy, José Luis Rodríguez Gil, Blake Cooney, Richard Grosshans, David B. Levin, Vince P. Palace

    The use of floating wetlands has been receiving increased attention as a minimally invasive method for oil spill remediation, but the species of vegetation incorporated in floating wetlands may influence the success of oil degradation. Therefore, a freshwater microcosm experiment was conducted at the IISD Experimental Lakes Area, Canada to assess the potential of common wetland plants Typha sp., Carex utriculata, and C. lasiocarpa, to remove phenanthrene, a polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon ubiquitously found at oil spill sites. Triplicate microcosms containing 3L of lake water were established with either Typha sp., Carex utriculata, or C. lasiocarpa and then treated with nominal concentration of 1 mg/L phenanthrene and monitored over 21 days. Two types of reference microcosms were also included: one set with the same plant allocations but not treated with phenanthrene and another with water only and no plants or phenanthrene. Phenanthrene declined by over 89.30% in all microcosms that received the compound, but the decline was more rapid in microcosms that included Typha sp. and C. lasiocarpa, than those with C. utriculate or no plants. Declining phenanthrene concentrations in microcosms without plants may have resulted from biofilm stimulation. Specific conductivity and pH were influenced by plant type but not phenanthrene, while dissolved oxygen was influenced by both. There was no influence of phenanthrene on plant growth rates or root biofilm bioactivity, measured by adenosine triphosphate or oxygen consumption. Results indicate there may be plant-specific factors influencing remediation success which should be explored in future research.


  • Open Access

    Assessing changes to the root biofilm microbial community on an engineered floating wetland upon exposure to a controlled diluted bitumen spill

    by Madeline J. Stanley, Lisa Peters, Aidan Guttormson, Julien Tremblay, Jessica Wasserscheid, Lauren Timlick, Charles W. Greer, José Luis Rodríguez Gil, Thor Halldorson, Sonya Havens, et al.

    Conventional oil spill recovery practices can damage sensitive habitats, like freshwater shorelines, and leave residual oil in the environment, causing chronic exposure to interacting biota. Non-invasive remediation efforts are required to enhance recovery of residual oil after primary recovery without further environmental damage. Engineered Floating Wetlands (EFWs), also known as Floating Treatment Wetlands, have been used around the world for phytoremediation and biodegradation of aquatic contaminants. EFWs have the potential to increase crude oil biodegradation by enhancing surface area for microbial colonization and interaction with contaminants in the water column. To assess changes in the prokaryotic and eukaryotic microbial communities associated with EFWs in conjunction with primary recovery of shoreline washing, a contained oil spill of diluted bitumen was conducted in a shoreline enclosure in an experimental lake at the International Institute for Sustainable Development Experimental Lakes Area, northwestern Ontario, Canada, in 2019. Total polycyclic aromatic compound (PAC) concentrations in the water column of the experimental enclosure peaked 20 days post spill, declining to near background conditions by day 66, and were dominated by 2-, 3-, and 4-ring alkylated PACs. Although total sediment PACs were highly variable and were influenced by pyrogenic sources (e.g., retene from wood combustion/forest fires) in all sites, concentrations in the experimental enclosure indicated influence from diluted bitumen. The EFW prokaryotic community was diverse and evenly distributed, while the eukaryotic community had lower richness and evenness, with a few dominant organisms. To our knowledge, this was the first in-lake experiment studying EFWs for oil spill remediation under natural environmental conditions, responding to scientific and industrial research needs. While we were unable to confirm whether community shifts were a result of diluted bitumen or seasonal changes, EFWs supported natural microbial diversity, with presence of amplicon sequence variants capable of degrading PACs without the need for bacterial inoculation. Further research should assess EFW microbial changes with other oil products commonly transported in Canada. As well, assessing target PAC degradation rates, EFW surface area requirements, and microbial activity will continue to advance collective knowledge in this field on the potential of EFWs as a secondary remediation strategy.


  • Open Access

    Overcoming water quality effects in biological monitoring: a case study of amphipod in situ exposures in Ontario agricultural streams

    by Matthew Hammond, Lisa Brown, John Struger, Lee Grapentine, Vince Palace, Adrienne J. Bartlett

    Bioindicators add valuable understanding of biological impacts to contaminant monitoring programs. However, attributing effects (e.g., mortality and growth impairment) to contaminant exposures is challenging because of potential confounding by environmental variables. We assessed the influence of four water quality variables (temperature, dissolved oxygen, pH, and conductivity) on contaminant effects assessments during in situ exposures of the amphipod Hyalella azteca in six agricultural and urban watersheds in southern Ontario, Canada (2005–06, 2008–10). We further tested whether sampling in specific months of the growing season would minimize confounding effects. While high toxicity from organophosphate and carbamate pesticides increased mortality and reduced growth in caged amphipods, warmer stream temperatures also affected endpoints, increasing mortality and improving growth. Seasonal patterns indicated early summer (June) as optimal for detecting impacts when: (1) stream pesticide concentrations were highest, (2) acetylcholinesterase (AChE) inhibition (a biomarker of organophosphate/carbamate exposure) was highest, and (3) stream temperature was below its seasonal peak. Specifically, higher correlations among organophosphate pesticide concentrations, AChE inhibition, and mortality indicated better attribution of cause in this month (r = 0.53—0.76, p < 0.05). Ability to discriminate between pesticide-impacted sites and reference sites was also greater than other months (June = 100% correct assignment as high-impact or reference site). Considering sampling times of stream bioindicators that maximize pesticide responses and limit confounding effects of water quality may improve the accuracy and resource-efficiency of biological monitoring programs.


  • Open Access

    Pangenomic analysis of three putative hydrocarbon degrading genera Limnohabitans, Aquabacterium, and Novosphingobium collected from freshwater sources

    by Gurpreet S. Kharey, Vince Palace, Lyle Whyte, Charles W. Greer

    A pangenome analysis offers a unique exploration of the metabolic and genetic diversity, range of ecological niches, and evolution of a particular genus or species. However, such pangenomic analyses are uncommon among environmentally relevant genera. Here, we present freshwater pangenomes of three environmentally relevant genera, Limnohabitans, Aquabacterium, and Novosphingobium. These genera had been detected in hydrocarbon degrading cultures in previous research by our group. Using pangenomic tools we attempted to characterize the extent of hydrocarbon degradation potential within each pangenome and determine what ecological niche each genus occupies within hydrocarbon degradation. In total 46 Limnohabitans, 10 Aquabacterium, and 32 Novosphingobium freshwater genomes were collected from various databases and compiled into pangenomes. We found that each pangenome harbours downstream hydrocarbon degrading potential and unexpected genetic diversity within its core and accessory pangenomes possibly stemming from geographic and metagenomic data processing influences. This work was the first to explore pangenomes of these environmentally relevant genera.


  • Guidance on assessing the potential impacts of selenium in freshwater ecosystems

    by Vince Palace, Stephanie Graves, Jessica Brandt

    Despite decades of fate and effects studies, environmental selenium (Se) contamination and management remain an issue for many freshwater systems in North America. Several regulatory bodies have promulgated updated targets or management levels for Se; however, additional guidance on best practices for monitoring Se to protect freshwater aquatic life is warranted. In this article, we describe current approaches to assessing the ecological risks of Se in impaired freshwater systems and outline recommended methods for collecting and analyzing biological and abiotic samples and interpreting data. Because reproductive impairment of fish populations is most commonly used to determine the potential impacts of Se, several biological factors that could affect Se toxicity are explored, including diet, trophic positions, reproductive biology, body size and maturity, migratory movements, and use of seasonal habitats. Measuring Se concentrations in mature eggs is the most reliable metric for estimating potential reproductive impairment in fish populations because the range of toxicity thresholds is relatively narrow for all but a few tolerant fish species. In situations where collecting mature eggs is not feasible, we review the use of alternative fish tissue for estimating potential effects. Factors affecting Se uptake from freshwater are also considered with guidance on collecting abiotic (e.g., water and sediment) and biotic components of aquatic food webs (e.g., macroinvertebrates, biofilm).