Ignacio Javier Navarro
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Ignacio Javier Navarro has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Víctor Yepes
Institute of Concrete Science and Technology (ICITECH), Universitat Politècnica de València, 46022 Valencia, Spain
22 shared publications - Jose Vicente Martí
Institute of Concrete Science and Technology (ICITECH), Universitat Politècnica de València, 46022 Valencia, Spain
4 shared publications José V. Martí
Institute of Concrete Science and Technology (ICITECH), Universitat Politècnica de València, Valencia, Spain
4 shared publicationsAntonio J. Sánchez-Garrido
3 shared publications- Antonio J. Sánchez-Garrido
Department of Construction Engineering, Universitat Politècnica de València, 46022 Valencia, Spain
3 shared publications - Mehrdad Hadizadeh-Bazaz
Department of Construction Engineering, Institute of Concrete Science and Technology (ICITECH), Universitat Politècnica de València, 46022 Valencia, Spain
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 2 June 2026
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Smart and Sustainable Built Environment
- p. 1-27
Smart integration of non-destructive damage detection and life-cycle assessment for sustainable maintenance of coastal bridges
Purpose: This paper proposes a sustainability-oriented method for detecting corrosion-induced damage in long-span reinforced concrete bridges using the power spectral density (PSD) approach. The paper aims to enhance the long-term performance and maintenance planning of bridge structures exposed to chloride environments by integrating structural health monitoring (SHM) with life-cycle sustainability assessment. Design/methodology/approach: A finite element model is developed for SHM of a coastal reinforced concrete bridge over a 100-year service life. The model captures the changing dynamic properties resulting from reinforcement corrosion. PSD analysis, adapted for damage caused by chloride corrosion, is used to extract frequency shifts and amplitude variations associated with the progression of internal damage. The results are assessed within a holistic sustainability framework that includes economic, environmental and social factors. Additionally, multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) techniques, including Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) and analytic hierarchy process (AHP), are utilized to rank and prioritize rehabilitation strategies. Findings: The results reveal that developed frequency-based analysis can effectively identify corrosion-induced deterioration at early stages, offering a non-destructive and reliable approach to SHM. Integrating this technique with sustainability assessment provides valuable insights into the cost-effectiveness, environmental performance and social implications of bridge maintenance interventions. Research limitations/implications: The study is based on a simulation-driven methodology and applied to a single base study of a coastal bridge. Sensitivity analysis is used to address major uncertainties; however, the lack of validation using field monitoring data may limit the applicability of the results. Future research should focus on experimental validation and on extending the framework to diverse bridge typologies and environmental conditions. Practical implications: The suggested framework serves as a decision-support tool for infrastructure asset managers, transportation authorities and policymakers by facilitating early damage identification and assessing life-cycle sustainability impacts. That, in turn, enables more informed, proactive and resource-efficient maintenance planning. Social implications: Implementing this approach promotes safer, longer-lasting bridge infrastructure, minimizing disruptions and risks for users and nearby communities. The sustainability assessment ensures that environmental and social dimensions – such as material efficiency, worker safety and societal well-being – are considered in maintenance decisions. By improving cost-effectiveness and reducing carbon emissions associated with premature repair, the method supports responsible resource use and aligns with global sustainable development goals. This integrative framework encourages social equity and community resilience through proactive and environmentally conscious infrastructure management. Originality/value: This study contributes to the advancement of sustainable infrastructure management by linking vibration-based damage detection methods with life-cycle sustainability and decision-making frameworks. It highlights the developed PSD as a practical tool for predicting and identifying chloride corrosion, thereby supporting proactive, sustainable maintenance planning and optimizing resource allocation for long-term durability.
- 2 June 2026
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Smart and Sustainable Built Environment
- p. 1-27
Smart integration of non-destructive damage detection and life-cycle assessment for sustainable maintenance of coastal bridges
Purpose: This paper proposes a sustainability-oriented method for detecting corrosion-induced damage in long-span reinforced concrete bridges using the power spectral density (PSD) approach. The paper aims to enhance the long-term performance and maintenance planning of bridge structures exposed to chloride environments by integrating structural health monitoring (SHM) with life-cycle sustainability assessment. Design/methodology/approach: A finite element model is developed for SHM of a coastal reinforced concrete bridge over a 100-year service life. The model captures the changing dynamic properties resulting from reinforcement corrosion. PSD analysis, adapted for damage caused by chloride corrosion, is used to extract frequency shifts and amplitude variations associated with the progression of internal damage. The results are assessed within a holistic sustainability framework that includes economic, environmental and social factors. Additionally, multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) techniques, including Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) and analytic hierarchy process (AHP), are utilized to rank and prioritize rehabilitation strategies. Findings: The results reveal that developed frequency-based analysis can effectively identify corrosion-induced deterioration at early stages, offering a non-destructive and reliable approach to SHM. Integrating this technique with sustainability assessment provides valuable insights into the cost-effectiveness, environmental performance and social implications of bridge maintenance interventions. Research limitations/implications: The study is based on a simulation-driven methodology and applied to a single base study of a coastal bridge. Sensitivity analysis is used to address major uncertainties; however, the lack of validation using field monitoring data may limit the applicability of the results. Future research should focus on experimental validation and on extending the framework to diverse bridge typologies and environmental conditions. Practical implications: The suggested framework serves as a decision-support tool for infrastructure asset managers, transportation authorities and policymakers by facilitating early damage identification and assessing life-cycle sustainability impacts. That, in turn, enables more informed, proactive and resource-efficient maintenance planning. Social implications: Implementing this approach promotes safer, longer-lasting bridge infrastructure, minimizing disruptions and risks for users and nearby communities. The sustainability assessment ensures that environmental and social dimensions – such as material efficiency, worker safety and societal well-being – are considered in maintenance decisions. By improving cost-effectiveness and reducing carbon emissions associated with premature repair, the method supports responsible resource use and aligns with global sustainable development goals. This integrative framework encourages social equity and community resilience through proactive and environmentally conscious infrastructure management. Originality/value: This study contributes to the advancement of sustainable infrastructure management by linking vibration-based damage detection methods with life-cycle sustainability and decision-making frameworks. It highlights the developed PSD as a practical tool for predicting and identifying chloride corrosion, thereby supporting proactive, sustainable maintenance planning and optimizing resource allocation for long-term durability.
- Open Access
- 6 July 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Building Engineering
- Vol. 95
Sustainable preventive maintenance of MMC-based concrete building structures in a harsh environment
- 6 July 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Building Engineering
- Vol. 95
Open AccessSustainable preventive maintenance of MMC-based concrete building structures in a harsh environment
- Open Access
- 28 March 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Cleaner Production
- Vol. 450
Social life cycle assessment of railway track substructure alternatives
- 28 March 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Cleaner Production
- Vol. 450
Open AccessSocial life cycle assessment of railway track substructure alternatives
- Open Access
- 29 November 2023
- Published by Universitat Politecnica de Valencia in ANUARI d’Arquitectura i Societat
- No. 3,p. 162-187
Hacia la rehabilitación de viviendas: demanda y necesidad social
El año 2008 se desencadenó una crisis económica mundial que hizo temblar los cimientos de la sociedad y produjo cambios en su visión. En España, esta crisis afectó con crudeza al sector inmobiliario, dejando miles de viviendas vacías. En la actualidad, aún quedan vestigios de esta herida en la sociedad: un parque de vivienda envejecido y la dificultad de acceso a la vivienda entre otros factores. Este contexto social sumado a la necesidad de trabajar para conseguir una manera de habitar más sostenible justifica una necesidad social que se está convirtiendo en una realidad. Rehabilitar vivienda en lugar de construir nueva. Un nuevo reto para la arquitectura en respuesta a la sociedad. Un nuevo reto para el que se están planteando diferentes soluciones.
- 29 November 2023
- Published by Universitat Politecnica de Valencia in ANUARI d’Arquitectura i Societat
- No. 3,p. 162-187
Open AccessHacia la rehabilitación de viviendas: demanda y necesidad social
El año 2008 se desencadenó una crisis económica mundial que hizo temblar los cimientos de la sociedad y produjo cambios en su visión. En España, esta crisis afectó con crudeza al sector inmobiliario, dejando miles de viviendas vacías. En la actualidad, aún quedan vestigios de esta herida en la sociedad: un parque de vivienda envejecido y la dificultad de acceso a la vivienda entre otros factores. Este contexto social sumado a la necesidad de trabajar para conseguir una manera de habitar más sostenible justifica una necesidad social que se está convirtiendo en una realidad. Rehabilitar vivienda en lugar de construir nueva. Un nuevo reto para la arquitectura en respuesta a la sociedad. Un nuevo reto para el que se están planteando diferentes soluciones.
- 1 September 2023
- Published by UK Zhende Publishing Limited Company in DYNA Ingenieria e Industria
- Vol. 98 (5) , 473-479
ENHANCING SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT OF BRIDGES IN AGGRESSIVE ENVIRONMENTS THROUGH MULTI-CRITERIA GROUP DECISION-MAKING
The construction industry is increasingly recognized as critical in achieving Sustainable Development Goals. Construction activities and infrastructure have both beneficial and non-beneficial impacts, making infrastructure design a focal point of current research investigating how best to contribute to sustainability as society demands. Although methods exist to assess infrastructures' economic, environmental, and social life cycle, the challenge remains in combining these dimensions into a single holistic indicator to facilitate decision-making. This study applies four decision-making techniques (ANP, TOPSIS, COPRAS, and VIKOR) to evaluate five different design alternatives for a concrete bridge exposed to a coastal environment. The results indicate that concretes containing even small amounts of silica fume perform better over their life cycle than other solutions usually considered to increase durability, such as water/cement ratio reduction or concrete cover increase. Keywords: sustainable design, bridges, life cycle assessment, Analytic Network Process, TOPSIS, VIKOR, COPRAS, Multi-criteria decision-making
- 1 September 2023
- Published by UK Zhende Publishing Limited Company in DYNA Ingenieria e Industria
- Vol. 98 (5) , 473-479
ENHANCING SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT OF BRIDGES IN AGGRESSIVE ENVIRONMENTS THROUGH MULTI-CRITERIA GROUP DECISION-MAKING
The construction industry is increasingly recognized as critical in achieving Sustainable Development Goals. Construction activities and infrastructure have both beneficial and non-beneficial impacts, making infrastructure design a focal point of current research investigating how best to contribute to sustainability as society demands. Although methods exist to assess infrastructures' economic, environmental, and social life cycle, the challenge remains in combining these dimensions into a single holistic indicator to facilitate decision-making. This study applies four decision-making techniques (ANP, TOPSIS, COPRAS, and VIKOR) to evaluate five different design alternatives for a concrete bridge exposed to a coastal environment. The results indicate that concretes containing even small amounts of silica fume perform better over their life cycle than other solutions usually considered to increase durability, such as water/cement ratio reduction or concrete cover increase. Keywords: sustainable design, bridges, life cycle assessment, Analytic Network Process, TOPSIS, VIKOR, COPRAS, Multi-criteria decision-making
- Open Access
- 24 August 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Marine Science and Engineering
- Vol. 11 (9) , 1656
Life Cycle Assessment of a Coastal Concrete Bridge Aided by Non-Destructive Damage Detection Methods
Recently, using economic damage identification techniques to ensure the safety of bridges has become essential. But investigating the performance of those techniques for various conditions and environments and, in addition, a life cycle assessment (LCA) through these methods depending on the situation and during the life of a structure could help specialists and engineers in this field. In these regards, analyzing the implementation of a technique for the restoration and maintenance stages of costly structures such as bridges can illustrate the effect of each damage detection method on the LCA. This research assessed non-destructive abilities and a dynamic approach to predict the amount and location of damages in the LCA. For this purpose, the power spectral density (PSD) technique’s performance by different approaches in identifying corrosion damages for a coastal bridge and the effectiveness of using this technique on reducing the environmental impact compared with a conventional method were evaluated. The results demonstrate a reduction of the environmental impacts by approximately 23% when using the PSD during the bridge’s service life. In conclusion, the PSD approach does well in anticipating the damage quantity and location on a coastal bridge, which reduces the environmental impacts during the repair and maintenance.
- 24 August 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Marine Science and Engineering
- Vol. 11 (9) , 1656
Open AccessLife Cycle Assessment of a Coastal Concrete Bridge Aided by Non-Destructive Damage Detection Methods
Recently, using economic damage identification techniques to ensure the safety of bridges has become essential. But investigating the performance of those techniques for various conditions and environments and, in addition, a life cycle assessment (LCA) through these methods depending on the situation and during the life of a structure could help specialists and engineers in this field. In these regards, analyzing the implementation of a technique for the restoration and maintenance stages of costly structures such as bridges can illustrate the effect of each damage detection method on the LCA. This research assessed non-destructive abilities and a dynamic approach to predict the amount and location of damages in the LCA. For this purpose, the power spectral density (PSD) technique’s performance by different approaches in identifying corrosion damages for a coastal bridge and the effectiveness of using this technique on reducing the environmental impact compared with a conventional method were evaluated. The results demonstrate a reduction of the environmental impacts by approximately 23% when using the PSD during the bridge’s service life. In conclusion, the PSD approach does well in anticipating the damage quantity and location on a coastal bridge, which reduces the environmental impacts during the repair and maintenance.
- Open Access
- 16 February 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Marine Science and Engineering
- Vol. 11 (2) , 433
Life-Cycle Cost Assessment Using the Power Spectral Density Function in a Coastal Concrete Bridge
Recently, the repair and maintenance of structures has been necessary to prevent these structures’ sudden collapse and to prevent human and financial damage. A natural factor in marine environments that destroys structures and reduces their life is the presence of chloride ions. So regular health monitoring of concrete coastal buildings for on-time repair is essential. This study investigates the performance of the power spectral density (PSD) method as a non-destructive damage-detection method to monitor the location and amount of damage caused by chloride ions during a structure’s life using different approaches according to life-cycle assessment (LCA) and life-cycle cost assessment (LCCA). In this regard, chloride corrosion damage dependent on zone distance from seawater was first calculated to obtain the service life of each part of a coastal concrete bridge according to the conventional method. Based on rebar corrosion each year, the next stage forecasted the bridge’s concrete deterioration. The PSD method monitored the annual loss of reinforcement cross-sectional area, changes in dynamic characteristics such as stiffness and mass, and the bridge structure’s life using sensitivity equations and the linear-least-squares algorithm. Finally, according to the location and quality of damage in each year of bridge life until the end of life, LCC and maintenance and repair costs of the PSD method were compared with the conventional method. The results showed that this strategy was very effective at lowering and optimizing the costs of maintenance and repair caused by chloride corrosion.
- 16 February 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Marine Science and Engineering
- Vol. 11 (2) , 433
Open AccessLife-Cycle Cost Assessment Using the Power Spectral Density Function in a Coastal Concrete Bridge
Recently, the repair and maintenance of structures has been necessary to prevent these structures’ sudden collapse and to prevent human and financial damage. A natural factor in marine environments that destroys structures and reduces their life is the presence of chloride ions. So regular health monitoring of concrete coastal buildings for on-time repair is essential. This study investigates the performance of the power spectral density (PSD) method as a non-destructive damage-detection method to monitor the location and amount of damage caused by chloride ions during a structure’s life using different approaches according to life-cycle assessment (LCA) and life-cycle cost assessment (LCCA). In this regard, chloride corrosion damage dependent on zone distance from seawater was first calculated to obtain the service life of each part of a coastal concrete bridge according to the conventional method. Based on rebar corrosion each year, the next stage forecasted the bridge’s concrete deterioration. The PSD method monitored the annual loss of reinforcement cross-sectional area, changes in dynamic characteristics such as stiffness and mass, and the bridge structure’s life using sensitivity equations and the linear-least-squares algorithm. Finally, according to the location and quality of damage in each year of bridge life until the end of life, LCC and maintenance and repair costs of the PSD method were compared with the conventional method. The results showed that this strategy was very effective at lowering and optimizing the costs of maintenance and repair caused by chloride corrosion.
- 1 September 2022
- Published by UK Zhende Publishing Limited Company in DYNA Ingenieria e Industria
- Vol. 97 (5) , 493-500
PERFORMANCE COMPARISON OF STRUCTURAL DAMAGE DETECTION METHODS BASED ON FREQUENCY RESPONSE FUNCTION AND POWER SPECTRAL DENSITY
Recent catastrophic events have aroused great interest in the scientific community regarding the evaluation and prediction of the structural response along the life cycle of infrastructures. Efforts are put into developing adequate health monitoring systems to help prevent future human life and economic losses. Here, two non-destructive damage detection methods are presented: the Frequency Response Function-based and the Spectral Density Function-based methods. The damage detection performance of both methods is compared through a particular case study, where different damage scenarios are analyzed in a 2D truss bridge. The reliability of each method is studied in terms of different prediction errors. Numerical results show that the PSD method for damage detection on a steel truss bridge structure provides more accurate and robust results when compared to that based on FRF. Keywords: Structural Health Monitoring, Power Spectral Density Function, Frequency Response Function, Construction, Structures, Damage detection, Non-destructive Los recientes sucesos catastróficos han despertado un gran interés en la comunidad científica por la evaluación y predicción de la respuesta estructural a lo largo del ciclo de vida de las infraestructuras. Se están realizando esfuerzos para desarrollar sistemas adecuados de monitorización de la salud que ayuden a prevenir futuras pérdidas de vidas humanas y económicas. Aquí se presentan dos métodos no destructivos de detección de daños: el basado en la función de respuesta en frecuencia y el basado en la función de densidad espectral. El rendimiento de la detección de daños de ambos métodos se compara a través de un caso de estudio particular, en el que se analizan diferentes escenarios de daños en un puente de celosía 2D. La fiabilidad de cada método se estudia en términos de diferentes errores de predicción. Los resultados numéricos muestran que el método PSD para la detección de daños en una estructura de puente de celosía de acero proporciona resultados más precisos y robustos en comparación con el basado en FRF. Palabras clave: Control de la salud estructural, Función de densidad espectral de potencia, Función de respuesta en frecuencia, Construcción, Estructuras, Detección de daños, No destructiva
- 1 September 2022
- Published by UK Zhende Publishing Limited Company in DYNA Ingenieria e Industria
- Vol. 97 (5) , 493-500
PERFORMANCE COMPARISON OF STRUCTURAL DAMAGE DETECTION METHODS BASED ON FREQUENCY RESPONSE FUNCTION AND POWER SPECTRAL DENSITY
Recent catastrophic events have aroused great interest in the scientific community regarding the evaluation and prediction of the structural response along the life cycle of infrastructures. Efforts are put into developing adequate health monitoring systems to help prevent future human life and economic losses. Here, two non-destructive damage detection methods are presented: the Frequency Response Function-based and the Spectral Density Function-based methods. The damage detection performance of both methods is compared through a particular case study, where different damage scenarios are analyzed in a 2D truss bridge. The reliability of each method is studied in terms of different prediction errors. Numerical results show that the PSD method for damage detection on a steel truss bridge structure provides more accurate and robust results when compared to that based on FRF. Keywords: Structural Health Monitoring, Power Spectral Density Function, Frequency Response Function, Construction, Structures, Damage detection, Non-destructive Los recientes sucesos catastróficos han despertado un gran interés en la comunidad científica por la evaluación y predicción de la respuesta estructural a lo largo del ciclo de vida de las infraestructuras. Se están realizando esfuerzos para desarrollar sistemas adecuados de monitorización de la salud que ayuden a prevenir futuras pérdidas de vidas humanas y económicas. Aquí se presentan dos métodos no destructivos de detección de daños: el basado en la función de respuesta en frecuencia y el basado en la función de densidad espectral. El rendimiento de la detección de daños de ambos métodos se compara a través de un caso de estudio particular, en el que se analizan diferentes escenarios de daños en un puente de celosía 2D. La fiabilidad de cada método se estudia en términos de diferentes errores de predicción. Los resultados numéricos muestran que el método PSD para la detección de daños en una estructura de puente de celosía de acero proporciona resultados más precisos y robustos en comparación con el basado en FRF. Palabras clave: Control de la salud estructural, Función de densidad espectral de potencia, Función de respuesta en frecuencia, Construcción, Estructuras, Detección de daños, No destructiva
- Open Access
- 27 August 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 14 (17) , 10688
Analytic Network Process-Based Sustainability Life Cycle Assessment of Concrete Bridges in Coastal Regions
Since establishing the Sustainable Development Goals in 2015, the assessment of the sustainability performance of existing and future infrastructures has been in the spotlight of the scientific community. This is because the construction sector is essential for promoting the social welfare and economic development of countries, but is also one of the main environmental stressors existing to date. However, assessing infrastructure sustainability throughout its life cycle remains a significant challenge, as the criteria involved in sustainable design are often complex and conflicting. The Analytic Network Process (ANP) is recognized as a powerful decision-making tool to model such problems. Here, the life cycle sustainability performance of different design alternatives for a concrete bridge near the shore is evaluated using ANP. The obtained results are compared with those obtained using the conventional Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP). The results obtained using ANP are more reliable than those derived from the conventional AHP in terms of the expert’s consistency and the number of comparisons made.
- 27 August 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 14 (17) , 10688
Open AccessAnalytic Network Process-Based Sustainability Life Cycle Assessment of Concrete Bridges in Coastal Regions
Since establishing the Sustainable Development Goals in 2015, the assessment of the sustainability performance of existing and future infrastructures has been in the spotlight of the scientific community. This is because the construction sector is essential for promoting the social welfare and economic development of countries, but is also one of the main environmental stressors existing to date. However, assessing infrastructure sustainability throughout its life cycle remains a significant challenge, as the criteria involved in sustainable design are often complex and conflicting. The Analytic Network Process (ANP) is recognized as a powerful decision-making tool to model such problems. Here, the life cycle sustainability performance of different design alternatives for a concrete bridge near the shore is evaluated using ANP. The obtained results are compared with those obtained using the conventional Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP). The results obtained using ANP are more reliable than those derived from the conventional AHP in terms of the expert’s consistency and the number of comparisons made.
- Open Access
- 10 June 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Mathematics
- Vol. 10 (12) , 2009
An Adaptive ANP & ELECTRE IS-Based MCDM Model Using Quantitative Variables
The analytic network process (ANP) is a discrete multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) method conceived as a generalization of the traditional analytic hierarchical process (AHP) to address its limitations. ANP allows the incorporation of interdependence and feedback relationships between the criteria and alternatives that make up the system. This implies much more complexity and intervention time, which reduces the expert’s ability to make accurate and consistent judgments. The present paper takes advantage of the usefulness of this methodology by formulating the model for exclusively quantitative variables, simplifying the decision problem by resulting in fewer paired comparisons. Seven sustainability-related criteria are used to determine, among four design alternatives for a building structure, which is the most sustainable over its life cycle. The results reveal that the number of questions required by the conventional AHP is reduced by 92%. The weights obtained between the AHP and ANP groups show significant variations of up to 71% in the relative standard deviation of some criteria. This sensitivity to subjectivity has been implemented by combining the ANP-ELECTRE IS methods, allowing the expert to reflect the view of the decision problem with greater flexibility and accuracy. The sensitivity of the results on different methods has been analyzed.
- 10 June 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Mathematics
- Vol. 10 (12) , 2009
Open AccessAn Adaptive ANP & ELECTRE IS-Based MCDM Model Using Quantitative Variables
The analytic network process (ANP) is a discrete multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) method conceived as a generalization of the traditional analytic hierarchical process (AHP) to address its limitations. ANP allows the incorporation of interdependence and feedback relationships between the criteria and alternatives that make up the system. This implies much more complexity and intervention time, which reduces the expert’s ability to make accurate and consistent judgments. The present paper takes advantage of the usefulness of this methodology by formulating the model for exclusively quantitative variables, simplifying the decision problem by resulting in fewer paired comparisons. Seven sustainability-related criteria are used to determine, among four design alternatives for a building structure, which is the most sustainable over its life cycle. The results reveal that the number of questions required by the conventional AHP is reduced by 92%. The weights obtained between the AHP and ANP groups show significant variations of up to 71% in the relative standard deviation of some criteria. This sensitivity to subjectivity has been implemented by combining the ANP-ELECTRE IS methods, allowing the expert to reflect the view of the decision problem with greater flexibility and accuracy. The sensitivity of the results on different methods has been analyzed.