Melissa H. Dancy
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Melissa H. Dancy has a total of 36 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Charles Henderson
North Carolina State University
11 shared publications Andy Rundquist
Department of Physics Hamline University MS-C1913 1536 Hewitt Ave. 55104 St. Paul MN
5 shared publications- Elizabeth Stearns
University of North Carolina at Charlotte
5 shared publications - Joel Christopher Corbo
Center for STEM Learning University of Colorado Boulder 80309 Boulder CO
5 shared publications - Stephanie Moller
University of North Carolina at Charlotte, Charlotte, NC, USA
5 shared publications - Alexandra Claire Lau
Department of Physics University of Colorado 390 UCB 80309 Boulder CO
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 26 June 2025
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
- Vol. 26 (4) , 909-925
Pre-collegiate factors contributing to the choice of a chemistry major: the role of science capital
Chemistry is a foundational discipline for many science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) professions. In the U.S. there are too few undergraduates completing majors in chemistry to meet current and projected labor force needs. Moreover, neither the chemistry workforce nor undergraduate majors are representative of the U.S. population's demographics. There is scant research on the pre-collegiate factors that contribute to choosing a chemistry major. This paper contributes to the research record with a qualitative study that applies a science capital lens to an investigation of the pre-collegiate factors associated with majoring in chemistry. Using a set of in-depth interviews with a self-selected sample of 12 undergraduates slated to earn a BS in chemistry from one of many campuses of the University of North Carolina, this study examined students’ experiences in families, communities, and schools in the years prior to their matriculation to their college campus. Our findings are consistent with the concept of science capital, which we extend by demonstrating that successful chemistry majors have greater stores of a more specific element of the science capital framework, namely knowledge about the transferability of chemistry. The article concludes with a set of recommendations to augment secondary students’ science capital and by doing so, is likely to increase the number of undergraduates majoring in chemistry.
- 26 June 2025
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
- Vol. 26 (4) , 909-925
Pre-collegiate factors contributing to the choice of a chemistry major: the role of science capital
Chemistry is a foundational discipline for many science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) professions. In the U.S. there are too few undergraduates completing majors in chemistry to meet current and projected labor force needs. Moreover, neither the chemistry workforce nor undergraduate majors are representative of the U.S. population's demographics. There is scant research on the pre-collegiate factors that contribute to choosing a chemistry major. This paper contributes to the research record with a qualitative study that applies a science capital lens to an investigation of the pre-collegiate factors associated with majoring in chemistry. Using a set of in-depth interviews with a self-selected sample of 12 undergraduates slated to earn a BS in chemistry from one of many campuses of the University of North Carolina, this study examined students’ experiences in families, communities, and schools in the years prior to their matriculation to their college campus. Our findings are consistent with the concept of science capital, which we extend by demonstrating that successful chemistry majors have greater stores of a more specific element of the science capital framework, namely knowledge about the transferability of chemistry. The article concludes with a set of recommendations to augment secondary students’ science capital and by doing so, is likely to increase the number of undergraduates majoring in chemistry.
- Open Access
- 25 April 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 21 (1)
Majority group physics instructors struggle to notice, name, and disrupt racist and sexist student interactions
Inequity is persistent in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics classrooms despite significant attention to upending it. In order to better understand how and why inequity persists, an analysis is presented of 27 self-identified white male physics faculty and graduate students responding to an interview prompt about the social exclusion of a Black woman by peers in a physics classroom. Three main research questions are addressed: (i) How familiar are these men with the alienation Black women frequently experience?, (ii) To what do they attribute this alienation?, and (iii) What do they think an instructor should do in a classroom where this alienation is occurring? Interviewees were found to have little understanding of the bias and discrimination Black women face, were hesitant to name the underlying cause as racism or sexism, and generally had limited insight into how to address racial and gender bias in their own classrooms. These findings indicate majority group instructors are ill equipped to recognize or disrupt oppressive structures in their own classrooms and may inadvertently exacerbate hostile interactions.
- 25 April 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 21 (1)
Open AccessMajority group physics instructors struggle to notice, name, and disrupt racist and sexist student interactions
Inequity is persistent in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics classrooms despite significant attention to upending it. In order to better understand how and why inequity persists, an analysis is presented of 27 self-identified white male physics faculty and graduate students responding to an interview prompt about the social exclusion of a Black woman by peers in a physics classroom. Three main research questions are addressed: (i) How familiar are these men with the alienation Black women frequently experience?, (ii) To what do they attribute this alienation?, and (iii) What do they think an instructor should do in a classroom where this alienation is occurring? Interviewees were found to have little understanding of the bias and discrimination Black women face, were hesitant to name the underlying cause as racism or sexism, and generally had limited insight into how to address racial and gender bias in their own classrooms. These findings indicate majority group instructors are ill equipped to recognize or disrupt oppressive structures in their own classrooms and may inadvertently exacerbate hostile interactions.
- 7 August 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Community College Journal of Research and Practice
- Vol. 49 (12) , 748-768
How Community College Educations Generate Both Science Capital and Science-Specific Transfer Capital Among Low-Income White Women Majoring in STEM
- 7 August 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Community College Journal of Research and Practice
- Vol. 49 (12) , 748-768
How Community College Educations Generate Both Science Capital and Science-Specific Transfer Capital Among Low-Income White Women Majoring in STEM
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 2 April 2024
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 20 (1) , 010119
Physics instructors’ knowledge and use of active learning has increased over the last decade but most still lecture too much
A survey of 722 physics faculty conducted in 2008 found that many physics instructors had knowledge of research-based instructional strategies (RBISs), were interested in using more, but often discontinued use after trying. Considerable effort has been made during the decade following 2008 to develop and disseminate RBISs in physics as well as change the culture within the physics community to value RBIS use and other forms of student-centered instruction. This paper uses data from a 2019 survey of 1176 physics instructors to understand the current state of RBIS use in college-level introductory physics, thus allowing us to better understand some of the impacts of these efforts on physics instruction. Results show that self-reported knowledge and use of RBISs has increased considerably and discontinuation is now relatively low. However, although the percentage of time lecturing is less than 10 years ago, many instructors still engage in substantial lecturing (i.e., more than one-third of class time). Relatedly, we find that the majority of RBIS use centers on pedagogies designed to supplement a primarily lecture-based classroom rather than pedagogies designed to support a primarily active learning classroom. This suggests that the physics education research community and beyond has done well promoting knowledge about RBISs and inspiring instructors to try RBISs in their courses. But, there is still room to improve. Based on available evidence about effective instructional practices, we recommend that change agents focus on supporting instructors to increase the percent of class time in active learning and to implement higher impact strategies. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
- 2 April 2024
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 20 (1) , 010119
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessPhysics instructors’ knowledge and use of active learning has increased over the last decade but most still lecture too much
A survey of 722 physics faculty conducted in 2008 found that many physics instructors had knowledge of research-based instructional strategies (RBISs), were interested in using more, but often discontinued use after trying. Considerable effort has been made during the decade following 2008 to develop and disseminate RBISs in physics as well as change the culture within the physics community to value RBIS use and other forms of student-centered instruction. This paper uses data from a 2019 survey of 1176 physics instructors to understand the current state of RBIS use in college-level introductory physics, thus allowing us to better understand some of the impacts of these efforts on physics instruction. Results show that self-reported knowledge and use of RBISs has increased considerably and discontinuation is now relatively low. However, although the percentage of time lecturing is less than 10 years ago, many instructors still engage in substantial lecturing (i.e., more than one-third of class time). Relatedly, we find that the majority of RBIS use centers on pedagogies designed to supplement a primarily lecture-based classroom rather than pedagogies designed to support a primarily active learning classroom. This suggests that the physics education research community and beyond has done well promoting knowledge about RBISs and inspiring instructors to try RBISs in their courses. But, there is still room to improve. Based on available evidence about effective instructional practices, we recommend that change agents focus on supporting instructors to increase the percent of class time in active learning and to implement higher impact strategies. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 23 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of STEM Education
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-29
How well-intentioned white male physicists maintain ignorance of inequity and justify inaction
Background: We present an analysis of interviews with 27 self-identified progressive white-male physics faculty and graduate students discussing race and gender in physics. White cis men dominate most STEM fields and are particularly overrepresented in positions of status and influence (i.e., full professors, chairs, deans, etc.), positioning them as a potentially powerful demographic for enacting systemic reform. Despite their proclaimed outrage at and interest in addressing inequity, they frequently engage in patterns of belief, speech and (in)action that ultimately support the status quo of white male privilege in opposition to their intentions. Results: The white male physicists we interviewed used numerous discourses which support racist and sexist norms and position them as powerless to disrupt their own privilege. We present and discuss three overarching themes, seen in our data, demonstrating how highly educated, well-intentioned people of privilege maintain their power and privilege despite their own intentions: (1) denying inequity is physically near them; (2) locating causes of inequity in large societal systems over which they have little influence; and (3) justifying inaction. Conclusions: Despite being progressively minded and highly educated, these men are frequently complicit in racism and sexism. We end with recommendations for helping cis men engage the power they hold to better work with marginalized people to disrupt inequity.
- 23 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of STEM Education
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-29
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessHow well-intentioned white male physicists maintain ignorance of inequity and justify inaction
Background: We present an analysis of interviews with 27 self-identified progressive white-male physics faculty and graduate students discussing race and gender in physics. White cis men dominate most STEM fields and are particularly overrepresented in positions of status and influence (i.e., full professors, chairs, deans, etc.), positioning them as a potentially powerful demographic for enacting systemic reform. Despite their proclaimed outrage at and interest in addressing inequity, they frequently engage in patterns of belief, speech and (in)action that ultimately support the status quo of white male privilege in opposition to their intentions. Results: The white male physicists we interviewed used numerous discourses which support racist and sexist norms and position them as powerless to disrupt their own privilege. We present and discuss three overarching themes, seen in our data, demonstrating how highly educated, well-intentioned people of privilege maintain their power and privilege despite their own intentions: (1) denying inequity is physically near them; (2) locating causes of inequity in large societal systems over which they have little influence; and (3) justifying inaction. Conclusions: Despite being progressively minded and highly educated, these men are frequently complicit in racism and sexism. We end with recommendations for helping cis men engage the power they hold to better work with marginalized people to disrupt inequity.
- 9 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education
- Vol. 10 (1) , 87-106
“I use IBL in this course” may say more about an instructor’s beliefs than about their teaching
- 9 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education
- Vol. 10 (1) , 87-106
“I use IBL in this course” may say more about an instructor’s beliefs than about their teaching
- Open Access
- 10 February 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of STEM Education
- Vol. 9 (1) , 1-23
Evaluating the impact of malleable factors on percent time lecturing in gateway chemistry, mathematics, and physics courses
Background: Active learning used in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) courses has been shown to improve student outcomes. Nevertheless, traditional lecture-orientated approaches endure in these courses. The implementation of teaching practices is a result of many interrelated factors including disciplinary norms, classroom context, and beliefs about learning. Although factors influencing uptake of active learning are known, no study to date has had the statistical power to empirically test the relative association of these factors with active learning when considered collectively. Prior studies have been limited to a single or small number of evaluated factors; in addition, such studies did not capture the nested nature of institutional contexts. We present the results of a multi-institution, large-scale (N = 2382 instructors;N = 1405 departments;N = 749 institutions) survey-based study in the United States to evaluate 17 malleable factors (i.e., influenceable and changeable) that are associated with the amount of time an instructor spends lecturing, a proxy for implementation of active learning strategies, in introductory postsecondary chemistry, mathematics, and physics courses.Results: Regression analyses, using multilevel modeling to account for the nested nature of the data, indicate several evaluated contextual factors, personal factors, and teacher thinking factors were significantly associated with percent of class time lecturing when controlling for other factors used in this study. Quantitative results corroborate prior research in indicating that large class sizes are associated with increased percent time lecturing. Other contextual factors (e.g., classroom setup for small group work) and personal contexts (e.g., participation in scholarship of teaching and learning activities) are associated with a decrease in percent time lecturing.Conclusions: Given the malleable nature of the factors, we offer tangible implications for instructors and administrators to influence the adoption of more active learning strategies in introductory STEM courses.
- 10 February 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of STEM Education
- Vol. 9 (1) , 1-23
Open AccessEvaluating the impact of malleable factors on percent time lecturing in gateway chemistry, mathematics, and physics courses
Background: Active learning used in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) courses has been shown to improve student outcomes. Nevertheless, traditional lecture-orientated approaches endure in these courses. The implementation of teaching practices is a result of many interrelated factors including disciplinary norms, classroom context, and beliefs about learning. Although factors influencing uptake of active learning are known, no study to date has had the statistical power to empirically test the relative association of these factors with active learning when considered collectively. Prior studies have been limited to a single or small number of evaluated factors; in addition, such studies did not capture the nested nature of institutional contexts. We present the results of a multi-institution, large-scale (N = 2382 instructors;N = 1405 departments;N = 749 institutions) survey-based study in the United States to evaluate 17 malleable factors (i.e., influenceable and changeable) that are associated with the amount of time an instructor spends lecturing, a proxy for implementation of active learning strategies, in introductory postsecondary chemistry, mathematics, and physics courses.Results: Regression analyses, using multilevel modeling to account for the nested nature of the data, indicate several evaluated contextual factors, personal factors, and teacher thinking factors were significantly associated with percent of class time lecturing when controlling for other factors used in this study. Quantitative results corroborate prior research in indicating that large class sizes are associated with increased percent time lecturing. Other contextual factors (e.g., classroom setup for small group work) and personal contexts (e.g., participation in scholarship of teaching and learning activities) are associated with a decrease in percent time lecturing.Conclusions: Given the malleable nature of the factors, we offer tangible implications for instructors and administrators to influence the adoption of more active learning strategies in introductory STEM courses.
- Open Access
- 12 October 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of STEM Education
- Vol. 7 (1) , 1-17
Undergraduates’ awareness of White and male privilege in STEM
Background: It is well-documented that experiences in STEM courses for women and students of color are different from the experiences of White men. As part of a larger interview study, 183 college seniors from diverse gender and race backgrounds were asked their thoughts on whether the experience of being a STEM major was different for people of different races and genders. We use a framework of “science as White property”, derived from critical race theory, to frame this study and results.Results: White men were largely unaware of any impact of race or gender. In contrast, women of color overwhelmingly report, consistent with results from a large body of prior research, that both race and gender impact their experiences as STEM majors. Students who acknowledged race and gender impacts did not always attribute these impacts to cultural or systemic factors (i.e., some reported women are underrepresented because they are less interested in STEM rather than a structural reason). Impacts identified that were attributable to systemic factors included impacts related to being a demographic minority (i.e., intimidation, feeling out of place, feeling pressure to work harder) and/or discrimination (i.e., job discrimination, bias against women or people of color and cultural assumptions implying the superiority of White people and men). A small number of students (mostly White women) stated that women or people of color benefit from their underrepresented status, often attributing this benefit to a perception of extra encouragement and opportunities. A common theme across categorizations was that women and students of color work harder than men and White people either because they are perceived to be harder workers or as a response to the sexism and racism they encounter.Conclusions: We found that White men are largely unaware of the impacts of race or gender on the pursuit of a STEM degree. Additionally, with the exception of women of color, students are less likely to perceive race as having an impact on the experiences of students than gender. We conclude with a discussion of implications for future work related to gender and race representation in STEM.
- 12 October 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of STEM Education
- Vol. 7 (1) , 1-17
Open AccessUndergraduates’ awareness of White and male privilege in STEM
Background: It is well-documented that experiences in STEM courses for women and students of color are different from the experiences of White men. As part of a larger interview study, 183 college seniors from diverse gender and race backgrounds were asked their thoughts on whether the experience of being a STEM major was different for people of different races and genders. We use a framework of “science as White property”, derived from critical race theory, to frame this study and results.Results: White men were largely unaware of any impact of race or gender. In contrast, women of color overwhelmingly report, consistent with results from a large body of prior research, that both race and gender impact their experiences as STEM majors. Students who acknowledged race and gender impacts did not always attribute these impacts to cultural or systemic factors (i.e., some reported women are underrepresented because they are less interested in STEM rather than a structural reason). Impacts identified that were attributable to systemic factors included impacts related to being a demographic minority (i.e., intimidation, feeling out of place, feeling pressure to work harder) and/or discrimination (i.e., job discrimination, bias against women or people of color and cultural assumptions implying the superiority of White people and men). A small number of students (mostly White women) stated that women or people of color benefit from their underrepresented status, often attributing this benefit to a perception of extra encouragement and opportunities. A common theme across categorizations was that women and students of color work harder than men and White people either because they are perceived to be harder workers or as a response to the sexism and racism they encounter.Conclusions: We found that White men are largely unaware of the impacts of race or gender on the pursuit of a STEM degree. Additionally, with the exception of women of color, students are less likely to perceive race as having an impact on the experiences of students than gender. We conclude with a discussion of implications for future work related to gender and race representation in STEM.
- Open Access
- 21 January 2019
- Published by American Association of Physics Teachers (AAPT)
Describing and Facilitating Productive Teaching Talk in a Faculty Online Learning Community
This paper presents our preliminary work towards being able to describe productive conversations in the context of faculty talking about teaching in a Faculty Online Learning Community (FOLC) as well as facilitator moves that lead to productive conversations. We present an analysis of a short video clip from a particularly productive FOLC meeting in which a rich discussion of pedagogical issues occurs. In order to understand why this conversation was productive, we describe the types of talk present and the function each type of talk served. Drawing from the literature on teacher workgroup conversations and using an emergent coding scheme, we identify four types of teaching talk: Reflection, Replay, Philosophy, and Rehearsal as well as three facilitation moves: Agency, Withholding, and Elaboration present in the conversation. We consider how teaching talk and facilitation moves are connected and offer guidance for those engaging in facilitation of either online or in-person faculty learning communities.
- 21 January 2019
- Published by American Association of Physics Teachers (AAPT)
Open AccessDescribing and Facilitating Productive Teaching Talk in a Faculty Online Learning Community
This paper presents our preliminary work towards being able to describe productive conversations in the context of faculty talking about teaching in a Faculty Online Learning Community (FOLC) as well as facilitator moves that lead to productive conversations. We present an analysis of a short video clip from a particularly productive FOLC meeting in which a rich discussion of pedagogical issues occurs. In order to understand why this conversation was productive, we describe the types of talk present and the function each type of talk served. Drawing from the literature on teacher workgroup conversations and using an emergent coding scheme, we identify four types of teaching talk: Reflection, Replay, Philosophy, and Rehearsal as well as three facilitation moves: Agency, Withholding, and Elaboration present in the conversation. We consider how teaching talk and facilitation moves are connected and offer guidance for those engaging in facilitation of either online or in-person faculty learning communities.
- 1 December 2018
- Published by American Association of Physics Teachers (AAPT) in American Journal of Physics
- Vol. 86 (12) , 934-942
Will my student evaluations decrease if I adopt an active learning instructional strategy?
College instructors are often afraid to use active learning instructional strategies because they fear that students may complain and/or give them lower evaluations of teaching. In this paper, we present data from a survey of 431 physics instructors who had attended the Physics and Astronomy New Faculty Workshop and who attempted to incorporate active learning into their introductory course. Nearly half of respondents (48%) felt that their student evaluations increased, one-third (32%) felt that their student evaluations had not been impacted, and one-fifth (20%) felt that their student evaluations decreased. Thus, contrary to common fears, for these instructors the most likely result from the incorporation of active learning was an increase in student evaluations.
- 1 December 2018
- Published by American Association of Physics Teachers (AAPT) in American Journal of Physics
- Vol. 86 (12) , 934-942
Will my student evaluations decrease if I adopt an active learning instructional strategy?
College instructors are often afraid to use active learning instructional strategies because they fear that students may complain and/or give them lower evaluations of teaching. In this paper, we present data from a survey of 431 physics instructors who had attended the Physics and Astronomy New Faculty Workshop and who attempted to incorporate active learning into their introductory course. Nearly half of respondents (48%) felt that their student evaluations increased, one-third (32%) felt that their student evaluations had not been impacted, and one-fifth (20%) felt that their student evaluations decreased. Thus, contrary to common fears, for these instructors the most likely result from the incorporation of active learning was an increase in student evaluations.