GMGillian MacNaughton

Gillian MacNaughton

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Gillian MacNaughton has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Is economic inequality a violation of human rights?

    by Gillian MacNaughton

    Over the past decade, scholars, activists, and policymakers have been alarmed by extreme and growing economic inequalities. Research shows that these inequalities adversely impact myriad human rights, including the rights to health, personal security, nondiscrimination, and political participation. While recognizing that greater economic equality is instrumentally important to reducing poverty and realizing human rights, this chapter asks whether there is a human right to economic equality per se? In response, the chapter examines the International Bill of Human Rights. Drawing on rules for interpretation of international law, as well as US constitutional law – the source of the right to equal protection – the chapter concludes that the right to equal protection in international human rights law must encompass not just rights to civil and political equality, but also rights to economic and social equality. It then presents an initial research agenda to discover a human rights approach to economic inequalities.

  • Economic inequality and human rights impact assessments of economic reforms

    by Gillian MacNaughton

    For over a decade, activists and scholars have sounded alarms over the extreme and growing economic inequalities in the world. In 2020, Forbes reported that there were 2095 billionaires in the world, while the World Bank recorded that 3.5 billion people lived on less than the poverty line of $5.50 per day. Such inequalities prevent the full realisation of human rights, undermine democracy and threaten peace. Economic inequalities are not inevitable however. They are the result of policy choices. As governments are obligated to respect, protect and fulfil human rights, they must take steps to ensure that their actions are consistent with their human rights obligations. Human rights impact assessment is an evidence-based method to aid governments in considering the potential human rights effects of policy options. The UN Independent Expert on Debt and Human Rights recently issued Guiding Principles on Human Rights Impact Assessment of Economic Reforms. This article reviews the Guiding Principles and argues for including a Guiding Principle on economic inequality in order to ensure that governments consider the impact of economic reforms on income and wealth inequality as critical causes of human rights violations.


  • The Promises and Challenges of Human Rights Cities

    by Gillian MacNaughton, Sindiso Mnisi Weeks, Esther Kamau, Shahrzad Sajadi, Prisca Tarimo


    • 1 June 2020
      • Vol. 22  (1) , 343-345

    The Maturing Right to Health: Deeper, Broader and More Complex but Still Unequal

    by Gillian MacNaughton

    • 1 December 2019
      • Vol. 21  (2) , 251-262
    Open Access

    The Challenge of Interdisciplinarity in Operationalizing the Right to Health

    by Gillian Macnaughton, Mariah Mcgill

    Interdisciplinary collaboration between the health and human rights communities is essential to operationalize the right to health. In practice, however, such collaboration has been infrequent. As noted by Jonathan Mann et al., the fields of health and human rights have "differing philosophical perspectives, vocabularies, professional recruitment and training, societal roles, and methods of work." These differences have posed barriers to interdisciplinary collaboration. This article focuses on interdisciplinarity-especially between health and human rights communities-as key to realizing the right to health. Drawing on interviews with experts on health and human rights, the article explores the challenges of interdisciplinarity at the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), the United Nations (UN) agency charged with mainstreaming human rights, including the right to health, across the UN system. To operationalize the right to health, experts perceive the need (1) to move beyond legalistic concepts of the right to health; (2) to enhance appreciation of the right to health across UN agencies; (3) to employ health professionals at the OHCHR; (4) to develop deep expertise on the right to health to advise on operationalization; and (5) to understand the right to health as an expanded right that includes the social determinants of health.


    • 1 December 2018
      • Vol. 20  (2) , 43-55
    Open Access

    Challenging Neoliberalism: ILO, Human Rights, and Public Health Frameworks on Decent Work

    by Gillian Macnaughton, Diane Frey

    In the 2008 report Closing the gap in a generation, the Commission on the Social Determinants of Health (CSDH) described "fair employment and decent work" as components of daily living conditions that have "powerful effects on health." The CSDH therefore proposed far-reaching structural changes to bring about decent work and health for all. Crucially, however, it failed to acknowledge two relevant international legal frameworks, the Decent Work Agenda of the International Labour Organization (ILO) and the right to decent work in international human rights law. This article compares the three frameworks for decent work-CSDH, ILO, and human rights-and makes two arguments. First, it contends that the CSDH, as a creation of the World Health Organization (WHO) and therefore part of the UN system, should have grounded its report-including the section on decent work-in the applicable international law, including the UN Charter and human rights treaties. Second, had the CSDH linked its report to established international law, it would have strengthened all three frameworks, bringing coherence to international law and policy and bolstering the power of the ILO, WHO, and the human rights mechanisms to counter neoliberalism toward achieving their common goal of decent work and health for all.


  • Vertical inequalities: are the SDGs and human rights up to the challenges?

    by Gillian MacNaughton

    Extreme inequalities in income, wealth and social outcomes are one of the greatest human rights challenges that we face today as they threaten individual and community health, national political and economic stability and global peace. This article considers the extent to which the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), adopted on September 25, 2016, and international human rights norms are adequate to address the challenges of these extreme inequalities. It focuses specifically on SDG 10, which aims to reduce inequalities within and among countries, and finds the targets inadequate to address many of the most pressing inequalities. It then examines international human rights law to discern whether human rights standards might inform the SDGs to alleviate some of the shortcomings of SDG 10. The article concludes that interpretations of international human rights to date also fall short in terms of addressing income, wealth and social inequalities. It therefore calls for research on the legal interpretation of the multiple equality provisions in the International Bill of Human Rights in a manner that would address the greatest human rights challenges of our time.


    • 10 December 2015
      • Vol. 17  (2) , 83-95

    The Impact of Human Rights on Universalizing Health Care in Vermont, USA.

    by Gillian Macnaughton, Fiona Haigh, Mariah McGill, Konstantinos Koutsioumpas, Courtney Sprague

    In 2010, Vermont adopted a new law embracing human rights principles as guidelines for health care reform, and in 2011, Vermont was the first state in the US to enact framework legislation to establish a universal health care system for all its residents. This article reports on the Vermont Workers' Center's human rights-based approach to universal health care and the extent to which this approach influenced decision makers. We found the following: (1) by learning about the human right to health care and sharing experiences, Vermonters were motivated to demand universal health care; (2) mobilizing Vermonters around a unified message on the right to health care made universal health care politically important; (3) using the human rights framework to assess new proposals enabled the Vermont Workers' Center to respond quickly to new policy proposals; (4) framing health care as a human right provided an alternative to the dominant economics-based discourse; and (5) while economics continues to dominate discussions among Vermont leaders, both legislative committees on health care use the human rights principles as guiding norms for health care reform. Importantly, the principles have empowered Vermonters by giving them more voice in policymaking and have been internalized by legislators as democratic principles of governance.


  • Human Rights and Health Impact Assessments of Trade-Related Intellectual Property Rights: A Comparative Study of Experiences in Thailand and Peru

    by Gillian MacNaughton, Lisa Forman

    In recent years, there has been growing concern about the negative impact on access to affordable medicines of international trade rules, including the World Trade Organization Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) and bilateral and regional free trade agreements containing “TRIPS-Plus” rights. These rules run counter to the human rights imperative to increase access to affordable medicines with deleterious impacts on individual and population health. In response, human rights and public health communities have employed impact assessments to provide decision makers with evidence of the potential effects of proposed laws and policies on individual and population well-being. In this article, we explore and contrast human rights and health impact assessments conducted in Thailand and Peru, respectively, during trade negotiations with the United States, to elucidate broader lessons for conducting human rights and health impact assessments in this arena.