Philip Anthony Martin
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Philip Anthony Martin has a total of 286 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Alec Philip Christie
Centre for Environmental Policy Imperial College London London UK
10 shared publications - William J. Sutherland
Department of Zoology University of Cambridge Cambridge UK
10 shared publications Andrew Balmford
8 shared publicationsAdrian C. Newton
Faculty of Science and Technology, Bournemouth University, Talbot Campus, Poole, United Kingdom
7 shared publicationsGorm Shackelford
7 shared publicationsAlec Christie
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (9)
Factors influencing the use of scientific evidence in conservation practice and policy: Insights from a systematic map
Evidence‐based conservation has the potential to improve biodiversity outcomes. Yet many conservation decisions do not explicitly incorporate scientific evidence, despite efforts to promote its use. To strengthen the role of scientific evidence in informing conservation decisions, it is vital to understand which factors influence its use by decision makers. However, to date, there has been no comprehensive attempt to characterise the scientific literature on this topic. To fill this knowledge gap, we conducted a systematic map to synthesise the literature on factors that impact evidence use in conservation decision‐making, including identifying where research has been conducted and which actors have been studied. Our searches and screening identified 169 relevant primary studies. We identified an apparent bias in the evidence use literature towards English‐speaking countries in the Global North. Few studies reported focal ecosystems, or threats, but those that did often focused on marine, forest or freshwater systems. The majority of studies investigated practitioners and researchers as actors, with relatively few studies focused on policymakers or other actors. The most commonly reported factors influencing evidence use were relationships between scientists and decision makers, the relevance of evidence and the capacity and resources of conservation organisations. Factors relating to the characteristics of evidence and practitioners/policymakers, including their organisations and decision contexts, were frequently referenced. However, few studies identified factors relating to researchers and research organisations. Synthesis and applications . Researchers should move from characterising factors impacting scientific evidence use to identifying and testing interventions to facilitate its use by conservation decision makers. Since these factors are interlinked, implementation and testing of actions that tackle multiple barriers should be prioritised. Decision makers and researchers should engage with each other early on when defining management, policy and research synthesis questions, define knowledge needs clearly and, where possible, invest in mechanisms to facilitate dialogue and interpretation of evidence. Together, these approaches offer the potential to promote evidence‐based conservation practice and policy, resulting in improved biodiversity outcomes.
- 27 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (9)
Open AccessFactors influencing the use of scientific evidence in conservation practice and policy: Insights from a systematic map
Evidence‐based conservation has the potential to improve biodiversity outcomes. Yet many conservation decisions do not explicitly incorporate scientific evidence, despite efforts to promote its use. To strengthen the role of scientific evidence in informing conservation decisions, it is vital to understand which factors influence its use by decision makers. However, to date, there has been no comprehensive attempt to characterise the scientific literature on this topic. To fill this knowledge gap, we conducted a systematic map to synthesise the literature on factors that impact evidence use in conservation decision‐making, including identifying where research has been conducted and which actors have been studied. Our searches and screening identified 169 relevant primary studies. We identified an apparent bias in the evidence use literature towards English‐speaking countries in the Global North. Few studies reported focal ecosystems, or threats, but those that did often focused on marine, forest or freshwater systems. The majority of studies investigated practitioners and researchers as actors, with relatively few studies focused on policymakers or other actors. The most commonly reported factors influencing evidence use were relationships between scientists and decision makers, the relevance of evidence and the capacity and resources of conservation organisations. Factors relating to the characteristics of evidence and practitioners/policymakers, including their organisations and decision contexts, were frequently referenced. However, few studies identified factors relating to researchers and research organisations. Synthesis and applications . Researchers should move from characterising factors impacting scientific evidence use to identifying and testing interventions to facilitate its use by conservation decision makers. Since these factors are interlinked, implementation and testing of actions that tackle multiple barriers should be prioritised. Decision makers and researchers should engage with each other early on when defining management, policy and research synthesis questions, define knowledge needs clearly and, where possible, invest in mechanisms to facilitate dialogue and interpretation of evidence. Together, these approaches offer the potential to promote evidence‐based conservation practice and policy, resulting in improved biodiversity outcomes.
- Open Access
- 31 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (9) , e70520
Ten rules for using evidence to guide ecosystem restoration
While ecosystem restoration is critical for addressing the planetary crises, its effectiveness can be compromised when decisions are not informed by the best available knowledge. In an ideal world, scientific evidence would be used alongside multiple forms of knowledge to inform ecosystem restoration. However, the type of context‐specific information that practitioners find most useful is not always available or easily actionable. Knowledge brokering—practices that foster sustained interaction among researchers, practitioners, policymakers, local communities, and Indigenous Peoples to support evidence‐informed decisions—is key to improving the use of evidence for increasing restoration effectiveness. So far, we lack comprehensive and practical guidelines for brokering knowledge in ways that effectively inform ecosystem restoration. Based on our collective experience working in NGOs, government agencies, private companies, and research institutions, we outline 10 rules to consider when incorporating evidence into restoration practice. The rules are: (1) Ensure there are systems for knowledge brokering in the restoration context; (2) Identify priority restoration outcomes and associated challenges; (3) Find out what evidence exists, at what scale, and in what form; (4) Assess the robustness of evidence and potential for bias; (5) Assess expected effects and feasibility of application; (6) Integrate diverse worldviews and knowledge systems; (7) Examine the policy context; (8) Future‐proof restoration; (9) Address potential trade‐offs in restoration; (10) Foster research and practice collaborations to co‐produce actionable evidence and fill knowledge gaps. Synthesis and applications . These 10 rules provide a guidance framework to put into action the best available evidence, ensuring that restoration benefits people and nature. We highlight the importance of knowledge brokering systems in this process, effectively informed and empowered to fulfil their emerging role across existing institutions and new ones dedicated to Science‐Practice‐Policy co‐production, as a responsible strategy to tackle the urgent planetary crises.
- 31 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (9) , e70520
Open AccessTen rules for using evidence to guide ecosystem restoration
While ecosystem restoration is critical for addressing the planetary crises, its effectiveness can be compromised when decisions are not informed by the best available knowledge. In an ideal world, scientific evidence would be used alongside multiple forms of knowledge to inform ecosystem restoration. However, the type of context‐specific information that practitioners find most useful is not always available or easily actionable. Knowledge brokering—practices that foster sustained interaction among researchers, practitioners, policymakers, local communities, and Indigenous Peoples to support evidence‐informed decisions—is key to improving the use of evidence for increasing restoration effectiveness. So far, we lack comprehensive and practical guidelines for brokering knowledge in ways that effectively inform ecosystem restoration. Based on our collective experience working in NGOs, government agencies, private companies, and research institutions, we outline 10 rules to consider when incorporating evidence into restoration practice. The rules are: (1) Ensure there are systems for knowledge brokering in the restoration context; (2) Identify priority restoration outcomes and associated challenges; (3) Find out what evidence exists, at what scale, and in what form; (4) Assess the robustness of evidence and potential for bias; (5) Assess expected effects and feasibility of application; (6) Integrate diverse worldviews and knowledge systems; (7) Examine the policy context; (8) Future‐proof restoration; (9) Address potential trade‐offs in restoration; (10) Foster research and practice collaborations to co‐produce actionable evidence and fill knowledge gaps. Synthesis and applications . These 10 rules provide a guidance framework to put into action the best available evidence, ensuring that restoration benefits people and nature. We highlight the importance of knowledge brokering systems in this process, effectively informed and empowered to fulfil their emerging role across existing institutions and new ones dedicated to Science‐Practice‐Policy co‐production, as a responsible strategy to tackle the urgent planetary crises.
- Open Access
- 15 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (6)
Artificial intelligence and decision support in applied ecology
Artificial intelligence (AI) is bringing ecological inference closer to decision‐making, producing detections, alerts, trends, and prioritisation outputs. Yet, consensus on how to interpret or act on these remains limited. We synthesise AI adoption in applied ecology and identify governance pressures as models become multimodal, transferable, edge‐deployable, and increasingly shaped by large language models. We highlight cross‐cutting risks where uptake outpaces oversight, including limits in explainability, validation, data sovereignty, environmental costs, cognitive off‐loading, and evidence integrity. Using the British Bat Survey as a representative case study, we show how AI can be operationalised through governance principles spanning benchmarking, transparency, auditability, data governance, equity, and sustainability. Policy implications : We propose a roadmap for responsible AI in applied ecology linking evaluation to decision context, clarifying responsibility, and ensuring AI strengthens rather than displaces accountable decision‐making. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the journal's blog .
- 15 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (6)
Open AccessArtificial intelligence and decision support in applied ecology
Artificial intelligence (AI) is bringing ecological inference closer to decision‐making, producing detections, alerts, trends, and prioritisation outputs. Yet, consensus on how to interpret or act on these remains limited. We synthesise AI adoption in applied ecology and identify governance pressures as models become multimodal, transferable, edge‐deployable, and increasingly shaped by large language models. We highlight cross‐cutting risks where uptake outpaces oversight, including limits in explainability, validation, data sovereignty, environmental costs, cognitive off‐loading, and evidence integrity. Using the British Bat Survey as a representative case study, we show how AI can be operationalised through governance principles spanning benchmarking, transparency, auditability, data governance, equity, and sustainability. Policy implications : We propose a roadmap for responsible AI in applied ecology linking evaluation to decision context, clarifying responsibility, and ensuring AI strengthens rather than displaces accountable decision‐making. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the journal's blog .
- 11 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Ecology & Evolution
- Vol. 9 (2) , 296-313
Loss of pollinator diversity consistently reduces reproductive success for wild and cultivated plants
Pollination is a crucial ecosystem service, yet pollinator species diversity is declining as a result of factors such as climate change, habitat loss and agricultural intensification. While previous studies have often examined the extreme scenario of complete pollinator removal, showing negative impacts on plant reproductive success, we take a more realistic approach by focusing on the effects of decreasing pollinator diversity. Our global meta-analysis reveals a notable negative impact of reduced pollinator species diversity on plant reproductive success measures, such as seed set, fruit set and fruit weight. Notably, this effect varies across plant families, impacting both self-incompatible and self-compatible species. We also find that wild plant species suffer more than cultivated ones. Furthermore, the loss of invertebrate, nocturnal and wild pollinators has a more substantial impact than the loss of vertebrate, diurnal or managed pollinators. Overall, our findings consistently underscore the positive role of biodiversity in maintaining ecosystem functioning, highlighting the urgency of mitigating factors that lead to the decline in pollinator species diversity.
- 11 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Ecology & Evolution
- Vol. 9 (2) , 296-313
Loss of pollinator diversity consistently reduces reproductive success for wild and cultivated plants
Pollination is a crucial ecosystem service, yet pollinator species diversity is declining as a result of factors such as climate change, habitat loss and agricultural intensification. While previous studies have often examined the extreme scenario of complete pollinator removal, showing negative impacts on plant reproductive success, we take a more realistic approach by focusing on the effects of decreasing pollinator diversity. Our global meta-analysis reveals a notable negative impact of reduced pollinator species diversity on plant reproductive success measures, such as seed set, fruit set and fruit weight. Notably, this effect varies across plant families, impacting both self-incompatible and self-compatible species. We also find that wild plant species suffer more than cultivated ones. Furthermore, the loss of invertebrate, nocturnal and wild pollinators has a more substantial impact than the loss of vertebrate, diurnal or managed pollinators. Overall, our findings consistently underscore the positive role of biodiversity in maintaining ecosystem functioning, highlighting the urgency of mitigating factors that lead to the decline in pollinator species diversity.
- 7 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 30 (5) , e17305
Meta‐analysis reveals that the effects of precipitation change on soil and litter fauna in forests depend on body size
Anthropogenic climate change is altering precipitation regimes at a global scale. While precipitation changes have been linked to changes in the abundance and diversity of soil and litter invertebrate fauna in forests, general trends have remained elusive due to mixed results from primary studies. We used a meta‐analysis based on 430 comparisons from 38 primary studies to address associated knowledge gaps, (i) quantifying impacts of precipitation change on forest soil and litter fauna abundance and diversity, (ii) exploring reasons for variation in impacts and (iii) examining biases affecting the realism and accuracy of experimental studies. Precipitation reductions led to a decrease of 39% in soil and litter fauna abundance, with a 35% increase in abundance under precipitation increases, while diversity impacts were smaller. A statistical model containing an interaction between body size and the magnitude of precipitation change showed that mesofauna (e.g. mites, collembola) responded most to changes in precipitation. Changes in taxonomic richness were related solely to the magnitude of precipitation change. Our results suggest that body size is related to the ability of a taxon to survive under drought conditions, or to benefit from high precipitation. We also found that most experiments manipulated precipitation in a way that aligns better with predicted extreme climatic events than with predicted average annual changes in precipitation and that the experimental plots used in experiments were likely too small to accurately capture changes for mobile taxa. The relationship between body size and response to precipitation found here has far‐reaching implications for our ability to predict future responses of soil biodiversity to climate change and will help to produce more realistic mechanistic soil models which aim to simulate the responses of soils to global change.
- 7 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 30 (5) , e17305
Meta‐analysis reveals that the effects of precipitation change on soil and litter fauna in forests depend on body size
Anthropogenic climate change is altering precipitation regimes at a global scale. While precipitation changes have been linked to changes in the abundance and diversity of soil and litter invertebrate fauna in forests, general trends have remained elusive due to mixed results from primary studies. We used a meta‐analysis based on 430 comparisons from 38 primary studies to address associated knowledge gaps, (i) quantifying impacts of precipitation change on forest soil and litter fauna abundance and diversity, (ii) exploring reasons for variation in impacts and (iii) examining biases affecting the realism and accuracy of experimental studies. Precipitation reductions led to a decrease of 39% in soil and litter fauna abundance, with a 35% increase in abundance under precipitation increases, while diversity impacts were smaller. A statistical model containing an interaction between body size and the magnitude of precipitation change showed that mesofauna (e.g. mites, collembola) responded most to changes in precipitation. Changes in taxonomic richness were related solely to the magnitude of precipitation change. Our results suggest that body size is related to the ability of a taxon to survive under drought conditions, or to benefit from high precipitation. We also found that most experiments manipulated precipitation in a way that aligns better with predicted extreme climatic events than with predicted average annual changes in precipitation and that the experimental plots used in experiments were likely too small to accurately capture changes for mobile taxa. The relationship between body size and response to precipitation found here has far‐reaching implications for our ability to predict future responses of soil biodiversity to climate change and will help to produce more realistic mechanistic soil models which aim to simulate the responses of soils to global change.
- Open Access
- 14 June 2023
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 120 (25)
Flexible synthesis can deliver more tailored and timely evidence for research and policy
- 14 June 2023
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 120 (25)
Open AccessFlexible synthesis can deliver more tailored and timely evidence for research and policy
- Open Access
- 1 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Solutions and Evidence
- Vol. 4 (2)
A systematic map of cassava farming practices and their agricultural and environmental impacts using new ontologies: Agri‐ontologies 1.0
Cassava is consumed by 800 million people and is a staple crop in Africa. Its production may increase under climate change due to its high drought tolerance. We produced a systematic map of scientific studies about cassava farming practices, with the aim of identifying knowledge gaps and clusters. Our secondary aim was to develop a classification system for [1] farming interventions and [2] agricultural, economic and environmental outcomes. Standardised classification systems facilitate data reuse, including for evidence synthesis, and promote research efficiency. Following our published protocol, we searched eight publication databases using the search string ‘cassava OR mandioca OR manihot OR manioc OR yuca’ in December 2017. We screened 36,580 records and included publications that measured the impact of cassava farming practices on agricultural, economic or environmental outcomes, including yield, soil, water, wildlife and labour. We classified the resultant 1599 publications by interventions, outcomes, location, study year and study design. We assessed coding consistency using Kappa scores. We found regional knowledge clusters (Nigeria, Columbia and Brazil accounted for 45.5% of country occurrences) and gaps (e.g. the Democratic Republic of Congo). There were knowledge clusters for interventions testing cultivar type, fertiliser use and diversifying crop rotations and outcomes related to crop production (e.g. yield/biomass). We found knowledge gaps for environmental interventions and outcomes (e.g. 5% of studies measured pollutants or wildlife). In terms of study design, reporting standards were poor (e.g. 24% of studies did not report start dates), average study duration was 2 years, and average publication delays were 4 years. The Kappa scores indicated that we successfully developed consistent ontologies (named Agri‐ontologies 1.0). The map and ontologies are available online: https://www.metadataset.com/. This systematic map of cassava farming practices can direct researchers and funders to knowledge gaps that need addressing, and reviewers to knowledge clusters for synthesis. Better research practices should be promoted within cassava research, as poor reporting standards, short study durations and long publication delays result in an ineffective research environment. This systematic map provides an evidence base for cassava production and the ontologies (Agri‐ontologies 1.0) can be applied to other systems to facilitate more efficient and effective synthesis.
- 1 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Solutions and Evidence
- Vol. 4 (2)
Open AccessA systematic map of cassava farming practices and their agricultural and environmental impacts using new ontologies: Agri‐ontologies 1.0
Cassava is consumed by 800 million people and is a staple crop in Africa. Its production may increase under climate change due to its high drought tolerance. We produced a systematic map of scientific studies about cassava farming practices, with the aim of identifying knowledge gaps and clusters. Our secondary aim was to develop a classification system for [1] farming interventions and [2] agricultural, economic and environmental outcomes. Standardised classification systems facilitate data reuse, including for evidence synthesis, and promote research efficiency. Following our published protocol, we searched eight publication databases using the search string ‘cassava OR mandioca OR manihot OR manioc OR yuca’ in December 2017. We screened 36,580 records and included publications that measured the impact of cassava farming practices on agricultural, economic or environmental outcomes, including yield, soil, water, wildlife and labour. We classified the resultant 1599 publications by interventions, outcomes, location, study year and study design. We assessed coding consistency using Kappa scores. We found regional knowledge clusters (Nigeria, Columbia and Brazil accounted for 45.5% of country occurrences) and gaps (e.g. the Democratic Republic of Congo). There were knowledge clusters for interventions testing cultivar type, fertiliser use and diversifying crop rotations and outcomes related to crop production (e.g. yield/biomass). We found knowledge gaps for environmental interventions and outcomes (e.g. 5% of studies measured pollutants or wildlife). In terms of study design, reporting standards were poor (e.g. 24% of studies did not report start dates), average study duration was 2 years, and average publication delays were 4 years. The Kappa scores indicated that we successfully developed consistent ontologies (named Agri‐ontologies 1.0). The map and ontologies are available online: https://www.metadataset.com/. This systematic map of cassava farming practices can direct researchers and funders to knowledge gaps that need addressing, and reviewers to knowledge clusters for synthesis. Better research practices should be promoted within cassava research, as poor reporting standards, short study durations and long publication delays result in an ineffective research environment. This systematic map provides an evidence base for cassava production and the ontologies (Agri‐ontologies 1.0) can be applied to other systems to facilitate more efficient and effective synthesis.
- Open Access
- 1 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 4 (12)
Determining the economic costs and benefits of conservation actions: A decision support framework
The need for conservation action to be cost‐effective is widely accepted, resulting in increased interest and effort to assess effectiveness. Assessing the financial and economic costs of conservation is equally important for assessing cost‐effectiveness, yet their measurement and assessment are repeatedly identified as lacking. The healthcare sector, in contrast, has made substantial progress in identifying and including costs in decision‐making. Here, we consider what conservation can learn from this experience. We present a three‐step framework for identifying and recording the relevant economic costs and benefits of conservation interventions where the user (1) describes the costing context, (2) determines which types of cost and benefit to include, and (3) obtains values for these costs and benefits alongside metadata necessary for others to interpret the data. This framework is designed to help estimate economic costs but can also be used flexibly to record the direct costs of interventions (i.e., financial costs) and calculate financial and economic benefits. Although recording data on economic costs and benefits is deceptively complex, this framework facilitates improved recording, and indicates how collating this data could enhance the assessment of cost‐effectiveness across conservation contexts using a range of decision‐making tools.
- 1 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 4 (12)
Open AccessDetermining the economic costs and benefits of conservation actions: A decision support framework
The need for conservation action to be cost‐effective is widely accepted, resulting in increased interest and effort to assess effectiveness. Assessing the financial and economic costs of conservation is equally important for assessing cost‐effectiveness, yet their measurement and assessment are repeatedly identified as lacking. The healthcare sector, in contrast, has made substantial progress in identifying and including costs in decision‐making. Here, we consider what conservation can learn from this experience. We present a three‐step framework for identifying and recording the relevant economic costs and benefits of conservation interventions where the user (1) describes the costing context, (2) determines which types of cost and benefit to include, and (3) obtains values for these costs and benefits alongside metadata necessary for others to interpret the data. This framework is designed to help estimate economic costs but can also be used flexibly to record the direct costs of interventions (i.e., financial costs) and calculate financial and economic benefits. Although recording data on economic costs and benefits is deceptively complex, this framework facilitates improved recording, and indicates how collating this data could enhance the assessment of cost‐effectiveness across conservation contexts using a range of decision‐making tools.
- Open Access
- 15 September 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Flexible synthesis to deliver relevant evidence for decision-making
The use of systematic reviews to collate and summarise evidence is considered one of the great intellectual achievements of recent times. Evidence synthesis has had far-reaching impacts and has helped to inform decision-making in multiple fields. However, it also faces three problems: (i) reviews cannot be relevant to everyone, hampering decision-making, (ii) multiple conflicting review are often produced, and (iii) reviews can become out-of-date rapidly. Here we present a solution to these problems that we term 'dynamic meta-analysis.' With a tool we have developed, users can filter and weight evidence depending on their interests to produce analyses that are highly relevant to their needs.
- 15 September 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessFlexible synthesis to deliver relevant evidence for decision-making
The use of systematic reviews to collate and summarise evidence is considered one of the great intellectual achievements of recent times. Evidence synthesis has had far-reaching impacts and has helped to inform decision-making in multiple fields. However, it also faces three problems: (i) reviews cannot be relevant to everyone, hampering decision-making, (ii) multiple conflicting review are often produced, and (iii) reviews can become out-of-date rapidly. Here we present a solution to these problems that we term 'dynamic meta-analysis.' With a tool we have developed, users can filter and weight evidence depending on their interests to produce analyses that are highly relevant to their needs.
- Open Access
- 15 August 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Effects of forestry practices on the conservation of soil and forest ecosystem health and functioning: an umbrella review protocol
Background: Forests host a majority of the world’s terrestrial biodiversity and provide habitats and numerous resources, making them a vitally important ecosystem for plants, animals and humans alike. However, forest ecosystems are continuously lost under pressures such as land use change and fragmentation, logging activities and climate change. Timber and other forest resources are in high demand, so different economic and environmental interests lead to conflicts between resource extraction and biodiversity conservation. Nonetheless, forest management practices differ in their intensity and conclusively in their impacts on forest ecosystem health. Although various evidence syntheses have been conducted for specific forestry practices or geographic regions, a global overview of these impacts is still lacking. We use an umbrella review of existing evidence syntheses to fill this knowledge gap and to provide a basis for designing better informed forest management strategies and policies. We address the research questions: 1. How do different forestry practices affect the conservation of soil and forest ecosystem health and functioning? 2. Which evidence synthesis gaps exist with regards to the effects of forestry practices on forest and soil health? and 3. What is the quality and reliability of evidence from existing meta-analyses and syntheses on impacts of forestry practices on forest and soil health?Methods: The review will be conducted using a standardised methodology for systematic reviews. We use relevant keywords on forest management and forest health to construct search strings for multiple published and grey literature databases. Inclusion criteria require that studies are meta-analyses reporting a quantitative effect size, focus on forest ecosystems, assess the effect of pre-defined forest management practices on pre-defined forest health indicators at different levels of intensity, and that the full manuscript is written in English. Relevant evidence syntheses are identified, collected and their quality critically appraised. A pre-defined list of data is extracted from the manuscripts into a global dataset, with a particular focus on the effect size and measures of heterogeneity. Finally, data synthesis will focus on narrative, tabular, and graphic summaries of the dataset to answer the research questions, highlight evidence gaps and make recommendations for future reviews, policies and decision-making.
- 15 August 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessEffects of forestry practices on the conservation of soil and forest ecosystem health and functioning: an umbrella review protocol
Background: Forests host a majority of the world’s terrestrial biodiversity and provide habitats and numerous resources, making them a vitally important ecosystem for plants, animals and humans alike. However, forest ecosystems are continuously lost under pressures such as land use change and fragmentation, logging activities and climate change. Timber and other forest resources are in high demand, so different economic and environmental interests lead to conflicts between resource extraction and biodiversity conservation. Nonetheless, forest management practices differ in their intensity and conclusively in their impacts on forest ecosystem health. Although various evidence syntheses have been conducted for specific forestry practices or geographic regions, a global overview of these impacts is still lacking. We use an umbrella review of existing evidence syntheses to fill this knowledge gap and to provide a basis for designing better informed forest management strategies and policies. We address the research questions: 1. How do different forestry practices affect the conservation of soil and forest ecosystem health and functioning? 2. Which evidence synthesis gaps exist with regards to the effects of forestry practices on forest and soil health? and 3. What is the quality and reliability of evidence from existing meta-analyses and syntheses on impacts of forestry practices on forest and soil health?Methods: The review will be conducted using a standardised methodology for systematic reviews. We use relevant keywords on forest management and forest health to construct search strings for multiple published and grey literature databases. Inclusion criteria require that studies are meta-analyses reporting a quantitative effect size, focus on forest ecosystems, assess the effect of pre-defined forest management practices on pre-defined forest health indicators at different levels of intensity, and that the full manuscript is written in English. Relevant evidence syntheses are identified, collected and their quality critically appraised. A pre-defined list of data is extracted from the manuscripts into a global dataset, with a particular focus on the effect size and measures of heterogeneity. Finally, data synthesis will focus on narrative, tabular, and graphic summaries of the dataset to answer the research questions, highlight evidence gaps and make recommendations for future reviews, policies and decision-making.