Marley Conceição dos Santos
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Marley Conceição dos Santos has a total of 47 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Simone Gisele de Oliveira
Universidade Federal do Paraná, Brazil
7 shared publications - Alex Maiorka
Federal University of Parana
6 shared publications Alex Maiorka
4 shared publications- Leopoldo Malcorra de Almeida
Department of Veterinary Science, Federal University of Paraná, Curitiba 80035-050, PR, Brazil
4 shared publications - Lucas Schmidt Bassi
Universidade Federal do Paraná, Brazil
4 shared publications - Uislei Antonio Dias Orlando
Genus plc
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- Published by FapUNIFESP (SciELO) in Ciência Rural
- Vol. 53 (4)
Phytase in diets with different phytate concentrations for broilers
This study evaluated the effect of including different doses of phytase in broiler diets with different levels of phytate and reduced levels of calcium (Ca) and available phosphorus (aP), on broilers performance, digestibility (CAID), and bone characteristics. One thousand four hundred and four Cobb®500 broilers were used, distributed in a complete randomized design, and a 2x3 factorial arrangement, with two phytate levels (4.25 kg/ton - MP and 6.0 kg/ton - HP) and three phytase levels (0, 750, and 1500 FTU/kg) totalizing six treatments with nine replicates each. The animals that received phytase in their diet showed higher average feed intake and weight gain, and higher bone weight, % mineral residue, % Ca, and % P, when compared to the treatment without phytase (P < 0.01). Animals that received a diet containing HP with the inclusion of 1500FTU/kg phytase had the best CAID of nutrients (P < 0.0001). Regarding phytate, animals that received the MP diet showed a higher CAID of dry matter, and higher %P in the tibia when compared to animals that received the HP diet. The addition of phytase to diets with reduced Ca and aP levels can improve the CAIDs and bone characteristics in the presence of high phytate levels. However, reducing Ca and aP levels in the diet without adding phytase impairs the performance of broilers and has no effect on their carcass and cuts yield.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by FapUNIFESP (SciELO) in Ciência Rural
- Vol. 53 (4)
Open AccessPhytase in diets with different phytate concentrations for broilers
This study evaluated the effect of including different doses of phytase in broiler diets with different levels of phytate and reduced levels of calcium (Ca) and available phosphorus (aP), on broilers performance, digestibility (CAID), and bone characteristics. One thousand four hundred and four Cobb®500 broilers were used, distributed in a complete randomized design, and a 2x3 factorial arrangement, with two phytate levels (4.25 kg/ton - MP and 6.0 kg/ton - HP) and three phytase levels (0, 750, and 1500 FTU/kg) totalizing six treatments with nine replicates each. The animals that received phytase in their diet showed higher average feed intake and weight gain, and higher bone weight, % mineral residue, % Ca, and % P, when compared to the treatment without phytase (P < 0.01). Animals that received a diet containing HP with the inclusion of 1500FTU/kg phytase had the best CAID of nutrients (P < 0.0001). Regarding phytate, animals that received the MP diet showed a higher CAID of dry matter, and higher %P in the tibia when compared to animals that received the HP diet. The addition of phytase to diets with reduced Ca and aP levels can improve the CAIDs and bone characteristics in the presence of high phytate levels. However, reducing Ca and aP levels in the diet without adding phytase impairs the performance of broilers and has no effect on their carcass and cuts yield.
- 16 September 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Livestock Science
- Vol. 265
Effect of phytase supplementation and drinking water pH for turkey poults
- 16 September 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Livestock Science
- Vol. 265
Effect of phytase supplementation and drinking water pH for turkey poults
- Open Access
- 27 May 2022
- Published by Revista Brasileira de Zootecnia in Revista Brasileira de Zootecnia
- Vol. 51
Prepartum supplementation of soybean oil as an energy source for sows and their litters
The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of pre-farrowing lipid supplementation for three days on performance parameters of sows and piglets and the survival rate of litters. Four hundred hyperprolific sows were randomly distributed in blocks according to their body condition score, weight, and parity order. Three levels of soybean oil were added on top at the time of feed supply and compared to the control treatment. The levels were: 250 mL, 500 mL, and 1,000 [...] ABSTRACT The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of pre-farrowing lipid supplementation for three days on performance parameters of sows and piglets and the survival rate of litters. Four hundred hyperprolific sows were randomly distributed in blocks according to their body condition score, weight, and parity order. Three levels of soybean oil were added on top at the time of feed supply and compared to the control treatment. The levels were: 250 mL, 500 mL, and 1,000
- 27 May 2022
- Published by Revista Brasileira de Zootecnia in Revista Brasileira de Zootecnia
- Vol. 51
Open AccessPrepartum supplementation of soybean oil as an energy source for sows and their litters
The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of pre-farrowing lipid supplementation for three days on performance parameters of sows and piglets and the survival rate of litters. Four hundred hyperprolific sows were randomly distributed in blocks according to their body condition score, weight, and parity order. Three levels of soybean oil were added on top at the time of feed supply and compared to the control treatment. The levels were: 250 mL, 500 mL, and 1,000 [...] ABSTRACT The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of pre-farrowing lipid supplementation for three days on performance parameters of sows and piglets and the survival rate of litters. Four hundred hyperprolific sows were randomly distributed in blocks according to their body condition score, weight, and parity order. Three levels of soybean oil were added on top at the time of feed supply and compared to the control treatment. The levels were: 250 mL, 500 mL, and 1,000
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Wiley in Animal Science Journal
- Vol. 93 (1) , e13716
Effect of crude protein reduction in blood, performance, immunological, and intestinal histological parameters of broiler chickens
We aimed to evaluate the effects of the reduction in dietary crude protein (CP) on blood urea, uric acid, performance, immunity, and intestinal histology of broilers. Four diets were formulated with 22.50%, 21.50%, 20.50%, and 19.50% of CP (1 to 21 days) and 19.20%, 18.20%, 17.20%, and 16.20% of CP (22 to 42 days), meeting the requirements of essential amino acids in all diets. A total of 800 male Ross chicks were randomly allocated to 32 pens, with 25 birds each (n = 8). Blood and intestines had been collected for analysis. Uric acid decreased and urea increased with the reduction of CP (p < 0.05). Reduction in performance and intestinal parameters (villus, crypt, and goblet cells) was observed with the reduction of CP (p < 0.05). Lower levels of CP resulted in alteration (p < 0.05) in CD4 and CD8 lineages (21 and 42 days). Broken‐line models estimated (p < 0.05) the CP requirement for growth between 21% and 21.3% (1 to 21 days) and between 17.2% and 17.4% (22 to 42 days) and CP requirements between 17.2% and 18.2% for maximum response of immune cells (42 days). Reduction in dietary CP has a negative impact on performance, immune response, and intestinal histology of broilers, even with adequate levels of essential amino acids.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Wiley in Animal Science Journal
- Vol. 93 (1) , e13716
Effect of crude protein reduction in blood, performance, immunological, and intestinal histological parameters of broiler chickens
We aimed to evaluate the effects of the reduction in dietary crude protein (CP) on blood urea, uric acid, performance, immunity, and intestinal histology of broilers. Four diets were formulated with 22.50%, 21.50%, 20.50%, and 19.50% of CP (1 to 21 days) and 19.20%, 18.20%, 17.20%, and 16.20% of CP (22 to 42 days), meeting the requirements of essential amino acids in all diets. A total of 800 male Ross chicks were randomly allocated to 32 pens, with 25 birds each (n = 8). Blood and intestines had been collected for analysis. Uric acid decreased and urea increased with the reduction of CP (p < 0.05). Reduction in performance and intestinal parameters (villus, crypt, and goblet cells) was observed with the reduction of CP (p < 0.05). Lower levels of CP resulted in alteration (p < 0.05) in CD4 and CD8 lineages (21 and 42 days). Broken‐line models estimated (p < 0.05) the CP requirement for growth between 21% and 21.3% (1 to 21 days) and between 17.2% and 17.4% (22 to 42 days) and CP requirements between 17.2% and 18.2% for maximum response of immune cells (42 days). Reduction in dietary CP has a negative impact on performance, immune response, and intestinal histology of broilers, even with adequate levels of essential amino acids.
- Open Access
- 27 December 2021
- Published by Universidade Federal do Parana in Archives of Veterinary Science
- Vol. 26 (4)
Fungus Damage Effect on Physical-Chemical Characteristics of Corn Grains
The objective of this study was to analyze the physical-chemical characteristics of corn lots with different ratios of damaged to intact grains, considering the interaction between them. Recently harvested corn grains were selected, and grains attacked by fungi (fermented and moldy) and intact grains were separated to establish the following grain mixtures (treatments): 1 – 0% fermented/moldy and 100% intact grains; 2 - 10% fermented/moldy and 90% intact grains; 3 - 20% fermented/moldy and 80% intact grains; 4 - 30% fermented/moldy and 70% intact grains; and 5 - 40% fermented/moldy and 60% intact grains. Samples from each treatment were analyzed for dry matter (DM), ash (A), crude protein (CP), crude fiber (CF), ether extract (EE), and gross energy (GE) contents, water activity (aw), density, and hardness. Chemical composition and density data were submitted to analysis of regression, hardness values were compared by Tukey test (P<0.05), and Pearson’s correlations (P<0.05) between chemical and physical parameters were calculated. Increasing ratios of moldy corn relative to intact corn reduced DM, CF, EE, and GE contents, increased A, CP, Wa values, and reduced the density of the lot. Moldy grains presented lower hardness values compared with intact corn. This study shows that fungus damage affects corn grain physical-chemical properties.
- 27 December 2021
- Published by Universidade Federal do Parana in Archives of Veterinary Science
- Vol. 26 (4)
Open AccessFungus Damage Effect on Physical-Chemical Characteristics of Corn Grains
The objective of this study was to analyze the physical-chemical characteristics of corn lots with different ratios of damaged to intact grains, considering the interaction between them. Recently harvested corn grains were selected, and grains attacked by fungi (fermented and moldy) and intact grains were separated to establish the following grain mixtures (treatments): 1 – 0% fermented/moldy and 100% intact grains; 2 - 10% fermented/moldy and 90% intact grains; 3 - 20% fermented/moldy and 80% intact grains; 4 - 30% fermented/moldy and 70% intact grains; and 5 - 40% fermented/moldy and 60% intact grains. Samples from each treatment were analyzed for dry matter (DM), ash (A), crude protein (CP), crude fiber (CF), ether extract (EE), and gross energy (GE) contents, water activity (aw), density, and hardness. Chemical composition and density data were submitted to analysis of regression, hardness values were compared by Tukey test (P<0.05), and Pearson’s correlations (P<0.05) between chemical and physical parameters were calculated. Increasing ratios of moldy corn relative to intact corn reduced DM, CF, EE, and GE contents, increased A, CP, Wa values, and reduced the density of the lot. Moldy grains presented lower hardness values compared with intact corn. This study shows that fungus damage affects corn grain physical-chemical properties.
- Open Access
- 4 December 2021
- Published by Research, Society and Development in Research, Society and Development
- Vol. 10 (16)
Microalgae use in animal nutrition
Looking for alternative sources in animal nutrition, microalgae began to be explored, gaining space in commercial production. The aim of this review is to present available information about the use of microalgae in animal nutrition, as well as its effect and applications. Many microalgae are important sources of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA), mainly eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). These PUFA is poorly synthesized by animals, so they should be included in their diet. In addition, they are a rich source of almost all of the important minerals as well as vitamins. Additionally, some microalgae generally have a high protein content and high digestibility. In this context, microalgae already available on the market, become an alternative replacing conventional ingredients. To our knowledge, the use of small amounts of microalgae biomass in the feed can benefit the physiology of the animals, improving the immune response, resistance to diseases, antiviral and antibacterial action, intestinal function, and stimulation of probiotic colonization. In general, the addition of these compounds to the diets of animals enhances their overall health and immune status, productivity, and the quality and stability of the resulting animal products. Although the use of microalgae is increasingly directed towards many types of animals: cats, dogs, ornamental fish, horses, poultry, swine, sheep, and cow, studies still need to be explored.
- 4 December 2021
- Published by Research, Society and Development in Research, Society and Development
- Vol. 10 (16)
Open AccessMicroalgae use in animal nutrition
Looking for alternative sources in animal nutrition, microalgae began to be explored, gaining space in commercial production. The aim of this review is to present available information about the use of microalgae in animal nutrition, as well as its effect and applications. Many microalgae are important sources of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA), mainly eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). These PUFA is poorly synthesized by animals, so they should be included in their diet. In addition, they are a rich source of almost all of the important minerals as well as vitamins. Additionally, some microalgae generally have a high protein content and high digestibility. In this context, microalgae already available on the market, become an alternative replacing conventional ingredients. To our knowledge, the use of small amounts of microalgae biomass in the feed can benefit the physiology of the animals, improving the immune response, resistance to diseases, antiviral and antibacterial action, intestinal function, and stimulation of probiotic colonization. In general, the addition of these compounds to the diets of animals enhances their overall health and immune status, productivity, and the quality and stability of the resulting animal products. Although the use of microalgae is increasingly directed towards many types of animals: cats, dogs, ornamental fish, horses, poultry, swine, sheep, and cow, studies still need to be explored.
- 3 September 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Archives of Animal Nutrition
- Vol. 75 (5) , 345-354
Soybean oil supplementation for sows in the first three days after farrowing
One of the main causes of death in newborn piglets is the low level of energy reserves to maintain their body temperature, which can lead to hypothermia and, subsequently, death. Thus, the objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of soybean oil supplementation to sows in the first three days after farrowing to save piglet fat reserves through the higher nutritional intake of sow milk. In total, 604.5, 750, 1000, 1250 and 1500 g of soybean oil were provided for each sow during the three days of supplementation. A total of 60 sows were evaluated per treatment, distributed in a random block design, supplemented in the first three days after farrowing with soybean oil added on top of the feed at the time of feeding. Performance and reproductive data and milk samples were collected from the sows to determine fat levels. Piglets were evaluated for fall-back rate and survival. There was no significant effect of soybean oil supplementation on any of the parameters evaluated for both sows and their milk. Therefore, soybean oil supplementation for sows in the first three days after farrowing does not influence performance parameters, reproduction and milk fat of the sows and mortality and fall-back rate of the piglets.
- 3 September 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Archives of Animal Nutrition
- Vol. 75 (5) , 345-354
Soybean oil supplementation for sows in the first three days after farrowing
One of the main causes of death in newborn piglets is the low level of energy reserves to maintain their body temperature, which can lead to hypothermia and, subsequently, death. Thus, the objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of soybean oil supplementation to sows in the first three days after farrowing to save piglet fat reserves through the higher nutritional intake of sow milk. In total, 604.5, 750, 1000, 1250 and 1500 g of soybean oil were provided for each sow during the three days of supplementation. A total of 60 sows were evaluated per treatment, distributed in a random block design, supplemented in the first three days after farrowing with soybean oil added on top of the feed at the time of feeding. Performance and reproductive data and milk samples were collected from the sows to determine fat levels. Piglets were evaluated for fall-back rate and survival. There was no significant effect of soybean oil supplementation on any of the parameters evaluated for both sows and their milk. Therefore, soybean oil supplementation for sows in the first three days after farrowing does not influence performance parameters, reproduction and milk fat of the sows and mortality and fall-back rate of the piglets.
- Open Access
- 1 May 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Animal Science
- Vol. 99 (Supplement) , 196-197
PSV-21 Effects of Increasing Soybean Oil Supplementation Prior to Farrowing on Sow and Litter Performance Under Commercial Conditions
A total of 400 mixed parity sows (PIC Camborough, Hendersonville, TN) were used to evaluate the effects of increasing soybean oil supplementation prior to farrowing on sow and litter performance under commercial conditions. On d 111 of gestation, females were transferred to the farrowing room, blocked by parity and body weight, and allotted to one of four treatments within block in a randomized complete block design. Treatments included different amounts of soybean oil supplementation from d 111 to 113 of gestation, which included: 1) 0 g; 2) 250 g; 3) 500 g; 4) 1000 g. A corn-soybean meal-based diet containing 3.06% crude fat was fed and treatments were top-dressed at an equal amount for at least 3 d to achieve the designated supplementation level. The experimental data were analyzed using generalized linear mixed models with the GLIMMIX procedure of SAS. Polynomial contrasts were implemented to evaluate the linear and quadratic effects of increasing soybean oil supplementation. Response variables analyzed as normally distributed included sow body weight (BW) and caliper score at weaning, BW and caliper changes during lactation, piglet weight at birth, 24h after birth, and at weaning, colostrum yield, and litter average daily gain from cross-foster to weaning. Total born was analyzed following a poisson distribution and percentage born alive, stillbirth, and pre-weaning survivability were analyzed following a binomial distribution. Covariates were used if they significantly improved the model fit. Stillbirth rate increased (quadratic, P< 0.05) and percentage born alive marginally reduced (quadratic, P< 0.10) with increasing soybean oil supplementation up to 500 g, and then reduced and increased at 1000 g. There was no evidence (P >0.10) for linear or quadratic treatment effects for any of the other response variables evaluated. In conclusion, results from this study did not support supplementing increasing levels of soybean oil for sows prior to farrowing.
- 1 May 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Animal Science
- Vol. 99 (Supplement) , 196-197
Open AccessPSV-21 Effects of Increasing Soybean Oil Supplementation Prior to Farrowing on Sow and Litter Performance Under Commercial Conditions
A total of 400 mixed parity sows (PIC Camborough, Hendersonville, TN) were used to evaluate the effects of increasing soybean oil supplementation prior to farrowing on sow and litter performance under commercial conditions. On d 111 of gestation, females were transferred to the farrowing room, blocked by parity and body weight, and allotted to one of four treatments within block in a randomized complete block design. Treatments included different amounts of soybean oil supplementation from d 111 to 113 of gestation, which included: 1) 0 g; 2) 250 g; 3) 500 g; 4) 1000 g. A corn-soybean meal-based diet containing 3.06% crude fat was fed and treatments were top-dressed at an equal amount for at least 3 d to achieve the designated supplementation level. The experimental data were analyzed using generalized linear mixed models with the GLIMMIX procedure of SAS. Polynomial contrasts were implemented to evaluate the linear and quadratic effects of increasing soybean oil supplementation. Response variables analyzed as normally distributed included sow body weight (BW) and caliper score at weaning, BW and caliper changes during lactation, piglet weight at birth, 24h after birth, and at weaning, colostrum yield, and litter average daily gain from cross-foster to weaning. Total born was analyzed following a poisson distribution and percentage born alive, stillbirth, and pre-weaning survivability were analyzed following a binomial distribution. Covariates were used if they significantly improved the model fit. Stillbirth rate increased (quadratic, P< 0.05) and percentage born alive marginally reduced (quadratic, P< 0.10) with increasing soybean oil supplementation up to 500 g, and then reduced and increased at 1000 g. There was no evidence (P >0.10) for linear or quadratic treatment effects for any of the other response variables evaluated. In conclusion, results from this study did not support supplementing increasing levels of soybean oil for sows prior to farrowing.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2021
- Published by KEAI Publishing in Animal Nutrition
- Vol. 7 (1) , 163-167
Effect of age and different doses of dietary vitamin E on breast meat qualitative characteristics of finishing broilers
The supplementation of vitamin E on broiler chicken diets is essential to the prevention of lipid oxidation reactions in the meat and improvement of meat quality. The objective of this study was to assess the effect of different doses of dietary vitamin E on breast meat quality of broiler chickens in the finishing period. Five doses of vitamin E were used (30, 90, 150, 210, and 270 mg/kg feed) in broilers' diets from 42 to 54 d of age. A completely randomized design was conducted, followed by a split-plot, where the vitamin E dose was considered as the whole plot, and broilers’ age at slaughter was the subplot. Breast meat quality was assessed at 4 different ages (45, 48, 51, and 54 d old), using 50 birds per age, totaling 200 birds. Meat quality characteristics evaluated were: pH at 24 h post mortem, color (brightness, redness, and yellowness), water holding capacity, cooking loss, shear force, and lipid peroxidation. There was no interaction between age and dose of vitamin E for meat quality characteristics (P > 0.05). The age at slaughter had a quadratic effect (P < 0.05) on pH, brightness, redness, and water holding capacity. Although pH values were higher in the breast meat of older birds (51 and 52 d old), breast meat of younger birds (48 d) had a more reddish aspect. Shear force value was higher in breast meat of birds slaughtered at later ages (P < 0.01), as a linear age-effect was observed. Brightness increased linearly (P < 0.05) with higher vitamin doses, whereas treatments did not alter yellowness, cooking loss, and lipid peroxidation. In this study, increasing vitamin E doses in the finishing period increased the brightness of broiler breast meat, whereas slaughtering at later ages resulted in greater meat pH and shear force value.
- 1 March 2021
- Published by KEAI Publishing in Animal Nutrition
- Vol. 7 (1) , 163-167
Open AccessEffect of age and different doses of dietary vitamin E on breast meat qualitative characteristics of finishing broilers
The supplementation of vitamin E on broiler chicken diets is essential to the prevention of lipid oxidation reactions in the meat and improvement of meat quality. The objective of this study was to assess the effect of different doses of dietary vitamin E on breast meat quality of broiler chickens in the finishing period. Five doses of vitamin E were used (30, 90, 150, 210, and 270 mg/kg feed) in broilers' diets from 42 to 54 d of age. A completely randomized design was conducted, followed by a split-plot, where the vitamin E dose was considered as the whole plot, and broilers’ age at slaughter was the subplot. Breast meat quality was assessed at 4 different ages (45, 48, 51, and 54 d old), using 50 birds per age, totaling 200 birds. Meat quality characteristics evaluated were: pH at 24 h post mortem, color (brightness, redness, and yellowness), water holding capacity, cooking loss, shear force, and lipid peroxidation. There was no interaction between age and dose of vitamin E for meat quality characteristics (P > 0.05). The age at slaughter had a quadratic effect (P < 0.05) on pH, brightness, redness, and water holding capacity. Although pH values were higher in the breast meat of older birds (51 and 52 d old), breast meat of younger birds (48 d) had a more reddish aspect. Shear force value was higher in breast meat of birds slaughtered at later ages (P < 0.01), as a linear age-effect was observed. Brightness increased linearly (P < 0.05) with higher vitamin doses, whereas treatments did not alter yellowness, cooking loss, and lipid peroxidation. In this study, increasing vitamin E doses in the finishing period increased the brightness of broiler breast meat, whereas slaughtering at later ages resulted in greater meat pH and shear force value.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2021
- Published by Research, Society and Development in Research, Society and Development
- Vol. 10 (2)
Influence of the reproductive cycle on the zootechnical indexes in hyperproliferous swine matrices
In swine breeding stock, the calving order has a direct correlation with the performance of the litter, both at birth and at weaning. Thus, the present study aimed to evaluate the effect of the number of reproductive cycles of swine females on their zootechnical indexes. Forty healthy swine females from an industrial cross (Landrace X Large White) were used, distributed in five treatments, eight females per treatment, submitted to the same type of diet and water ad libitum. Being carried out the management of confirmation of pregnancies or return to heat and transfer to maternity After calving, productive indexes of females and piglets were evaluated. The data obtained were analyzed through analysis of variance, and comparison of means by the Tukey test (p
- 1 February 2021
- Published by Research, Society and Development in Research, Society and Development
- Vol. 10 (2)
Open AccessInfluence of the reproductive cycle on the zootechnical indexes in hyperproliferous swine matrices
In swine breeding stock, the calving order has a direct correlation with the performance of the litter, both at birth and at weaning. Thus, the present study aimed to evaluate the effect of the number of reproductive cycles of swine females on their zootechnical indexes. Forty healthy swine females from an industrial cross (Landrace X Large White) were used, distributed in five treatments, eight females per treatment, submitted to the same type of diet and water ad libitum. Being carried out the management of confirmation of pregnancies or return to heat and transfer to maternity After calving, productive indexes of females and piglets were evaluated. The data obtained were analyzed through analysis of variance, and comparison of means by the Tukey test (p