Jinqing Liu
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Jinqing Liu has a total of 24 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Ayfer Eker
Department of Mathematics and Science Education, Giresun University, Giresun, Turkey
3 shared publications- Da Zhou
Faculty of Education, Northeast Normal University, Changchun 130024, China
2 shared publications - Dionne Cross Francis
University of North Carolina
2 shared publications Jane-Jane Lo
Western Michigan University
2 shared publications- Lili Zhou
Department of Curriculum and Instruction, College of Education, California State University, 5151 State University Dr, Los Angeles, CA 90032, USA
2 shared publications Pavneet Kaur Bharaj
California State University
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education
- Vol. 24 (7) , 109
Positioning Mathematical Routine Enactments Along the Ritual–Explorative Continuum: The Case of Prospective Teachers’ Fraction Ordering
Learners may solve the same mathematical task correctly using the same solution strategy while engaging in qualitatively different mathematical participation. Such variation is difficult to identify through correctness-based assessments alone, limiting insights into students’ mathematical learning. Drawing on Sfard’s commognitive framework, this study investigates how three prospective teachers enacted the shared common denominator routine while solving the same fraction-ordering task. Using the ritual–explorative continuum as a cross-sectional analytic framework, we analyzed four discursive characteristics—bondedness, substantiation, objectification, and agency—and reconstructed each participant’s construed task from observable discourse. The findings indicate that differences in routine enactment were associated not with procedural performance but with how participants construed the task, connected and justified mathematical actions, and positioned mathematical authority in their discourse. These findings demonstrate the value of the ritual–explorative continuum for cross-sectional analyses of mathematical participation, identify three analytic prototypes of routine enactment, and suggest that routine enactment is multidimensional, with mathematically successful performances differing substantially in their learning potential despite producing the same correct solution.
- 25 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education
- Vol. 24 (7) , 109
Open AccessPositioning Mathematical Routine Enactments Along the Ritual–Explorative Continuum: The Case of Prospective Teachers’ Fraction Ordering
Learners may solve the same mathematical task correctly using the same solution strategy while engaging in qualitatively different mathematical participation. Such variation is difficult to identify through correctness-based assessments alone, limiting insights into students’ mathematical learning. Drawing on Sfard’s commognitive framework, this study investigates how three prospective teachers enacted the shared common denominator routine while solving the same fraction-ordering task. Using the ritual–explorative continuum as a cross-sectional analytic framework, we analyzed four discursive characteristics—bondedness, substantiation, objectification, and agency—and reconstructed each participant’s construed task from observable discourse. The findings indicate that differences in routine enactment were associated not with procedural performance but with how participants construed the task, connected and justified mathematical actions, and positioned mathematical authority in their discourse. These findings demonstrate the value of the ritual–explorative continuum for cross-sectional analyses of mathematical participation, identify three analytic prototypes of routine enactment, and suggest that routine enactment is multidimensional, with mathematically successful performances differing substantially in their learning potential despite producing the same correct solution.
- Open Access
- 27 August 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Curriculum Studies
- Vol. 58 (2) , 338-356
Conducting research on teacher professional development in partnership with educators: promises, tensions and opportunities
Research on teacher professional development (PD) in mathematics highlights the challenges of designing learning experiences for teachers that are impactful for teaching improvement and student lea...
- 27 August 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Curriculum Studies
- Vol. 58 (2) , 338-356
Open AccessConducting research on teacher professional development in partnership with educators: promises, tensions and opportunities
Research on teacher professional development (PD) in mathematics highlights the challenges of designing learning experiences for teachers that are impactful for teaching improvement and student lea...
- Open Access
- 15 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Digital Experiences in Mathematics Education
- Vol. 10 (3) , 431-461
Instructional Technology Tetrahedron and Network Visualization: Conceptualizing Online Teaching Through a Lens of Reflective Noticing
Online learning and teaching, accelerated by the global pandemic and rapid advancement of digital technology, require novel conceptual and analytical tools to understand better the evolving nature of online teaching. Drawing on the classical model of the instructional triangle and previous attempts to extend it, we propose the Instructional Technology Tetrahedron (ITT)—a conceptual framework that integrates technology into the instructional triangle to represent the role of technology, as a learning tool and a mediator between teachers, students, and content. Combining the ITT framework with network visualization strategies allowed for representing the intensity of interactions within the tetrahedron. We illustrate the affordances of the ITT framework by analyzing reflective noticing patterns of three prospective secondary teachers (PSTs) who reflected on the video recordings of their own online teaching, with each PST teaching four online lessons to groups of high-school students. We demonstrate the utility of the ITT framework to characterize individual noticing patterns, in a particular lesson and across time, and to support a variety of cross-case comparisons. The discussion sheds light on the broader implications of the ITT framework.
- 15 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Digital Experiences in Mathematics Education
- Vol. 10 (3) , 431-461
Open AccessInstructional Technology Tetrahedron and Network Visualization: Conceptualizing Online Teaching Through a Lens of Reflective Noticing
Online learning and teaching, accelerated by the global pandemic and rapid advancement of digital technology, require novel conceptual and analytical tools to understand better the evolving nature of online teaching. Drawing on the classical model of the instructional triangle and previous attempts to extend it, we propose the Instructional Technology Tetrahedron (ITT)—a conceptual framework that integrates technology into the instructional triangle to represent the role of technology, as a learning tool and a mediator between teachers, students, and content. Combining the ITT framework with network visualization strategies allowed for representing the intensity of interactions within the tetrahedron. We illustrate the affordances of the ITT framework by analyzing reflective noticing patterns of three prospective secondary teachers (PSTs) who reflected on the video recordings of their own online teaching, with each PST teaching four online lessons to groups of high-school students. We demonstrate the utility of the ITT framework to characterize individual noticing patterns, in a particular lesson and across time, and to support a variety of cross-case comparisons. The discussion sheds light on the broader implications of the ITT framework.
- Open Access
- 30 July 2024
- Published by Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta in JRAMathEdu (Journal of Research and Advances in Mathematics Education)
Using international large-scale assessment for learning: Analyzing U.S. students’ geometry performance in TIMSS
The data from international large-scale assessments, such as The Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS), is often designed and used as an assessment of learning rather than an assessment for learning. This research employed TIMSS 2011 data, focusing on the geometric performance of fourth-grade students in the United States, to demonstrate how large-scale assessments can be utilized qualitatively to identify students' learning challenges, providing valuable insights to inform geometry teaching practices. Using van Hiele’s levels of geometric thinking as a guiding framework, the 24 released geometry items were analyzed to identify students’ struggle points in geometry nationwide. Our analysis revealed that students performed well on tasks that were visual, contextually grounded, and had clearly defined manipulative expectations.. However, students needed further support to solve items requiring a deep understanding of geometrical concepts, such as finding the perimeter of a square. Additionally, students excelled at solving tasks involving the identification of relative positions of objects on a map and recognizing lines of symmetry in regular shapes. However, they struggled with measurement-related tasks. Our analysis also identified a range of item features that might cause difficulties that impacted the way students responded to these items. Instructional implications for elementary mathematics education are discussed.
- 30 July 2024
- Published by Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta in JRAMathEdu (Journal of Research and Advances in Mathematics Education)
Open AccessUsing international large-scale assessment for learning: Analyzing U.S. students’ geometry performance in TIMSS
The data from international large-scale assessments, such as The Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS), is often designed and used as an assessment of learning rather than an assessment for learning. This research employed TIMSS 2011 data, focusing on the geometric performance of fourth-grade students in the United States, to demonstrate how large-scale assessments can be utilized qualitatively to identify students' learning challenges, providing valuable insights to inform geometry teaching practices. Using van Hiele’s levels of geometric thinking as a guiding framework, the 24 released geometry items were analyzed to identify students’ struggle points in geometry nationwide. Our analysis revealed that students performed well on tasks that were visual, contextually grounded, and had clearly defined manipulative expectations.. However, students needed further support to solve items requiring a deep understanding of geometrical concepts, such as finding the perimeter of a square. Additionally, students excelled at solving tasks involving the identification of relative positions of objects on a map and recognizing lines of symmetry in regular shapes. However, they struggled with measurement-related tasks. Our analysis also identified a range of item features that might cause difficulties that impacted the way students responded to these items. Instructional implications for elementary mathematics education are discussed.
- 14 March 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 113-130
Longitudinal Studies on Video-based Interventions for Mathematics Teacher Noticing
Over the past two decades, the field of teacher noticing, which refers to how teachers observe and interpret classroom events, has received considerable attention in educational research. This chapter presents a review of the literature on mathematics teacher noticing, with a particular focus on longitudinal studies that use video-based interventions to enhance teachers’ noticing skills. Video resources have been instrumental in supporting the development of noticing skills by serving as reflective tools, facilitating replay, and the analysis of instructional moments. This chapter addresses the importance of longitudinal studies in capturing the long-term effects of video-based interventions on teacher noticing and highlights the benefits of monitoring changes over time. A structured review identified seven studies that met specific criteria related to video-based noticing interventions for mathematics teachers. These studies provide insight into how different interventions, ranging from video clubs to lesson studies, affect teachers’ noticing abilities over time. The discussion is complemented by an additional study, by the first author of the chapter, which examines noticing skills longitudinally into the first two years of teaching. The chapter concludes with a synthesis of the findings, highlighting the potential and challenges of these interventions and offering directions for future research in teacher noticing.
- 14 March 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 113-130
Longitudinal Studies on Video-based Interventions for Mathematics Teacher Noticing
Over the past two decades, the field of teacher noticing, which refers to how teachers observe and interpret classroom events, has received considerable attention in educational research. This chapter presents a review of the literature on mathematics teacher noticing, with a particular focus on longitudinal studies that use video-based interventions to enhance teachers’ noticing skills. Video resources have been instrumental in supporting the development of noticing skills by serving as reflective tools, facilitating replay, and the analysis of instructional moments. This chapter addresses the importance of longitudinal studies in capturing the long-term effects of video-based interventions on teacher noticing and highlights the benefits of monitoring changes over time. A structured review identified seven studies that met specific criteria related to video-based noticing interventions for mathematics teachers. These studies provide insight into how different interventions, ranging from video clubs to lesson studies, affect teachers’ noticing abilities over time. The discussion is complemented by an additional study, by the first author of the chapter, which examines noticing skills longitudinally into the first two years of teaching. The chapter concludes with a synthesis of the findings, highlighting the potential and challenges of these interventions and offering directions for future research in teacher noticing.
- Open Access
- 5 November 2023
- Published by OpenEd Network in Journal of Curriculum Studies Research
- Vol. 5 (3) , 80-95
The Journey Continues: Mathematics Curriculum Analysis from the Official Curriculum to the Intended Curriculum
In this paper, we share major lessons we have learned in our curriculum analysis explorations and provide suggestions for future mathematics curriculum research. Specifically, we will discuss the successes and challenges of using comparative methods and developing analytical frameworks. Using an old Chinese saying, follow the vine to get the melon (顺藤摸瓜), our journey starts with getting a holistic picture of standards and moves to identifying a specific topic in the textbooks. We first conducted a study to compare the geometry standards of the Common Core State Standards for Mathematics (CCSSM) and the Chinese Compulsory Education Mathematics Curriculum Standards (CMCS); then we analyzed the presentation of a specific topic, triangle congruence, in multiple geometry textbooks. For each comparative study we conducted, developing the analytical framework that can be used to guide future investigations constituted a critical step in the research methodology. We have learned lessons from adapting the well-known van Hiele model, which was created for the development of geometric reasoning, into a lens for a detailed curriculum analysis. We have also learned lessons from elaborating on the key constructs from the “Mathematics Curriculum as Story” framework for coding and analysis. These lessons as well as our future directions serve as the primary focus of this paper.
- 5 November 2023
- Published by OpenEd Network in Journal of Curriculum Studies Research
- Vol. 5 (3) , 80-95
Open AccessThe Journey Continues: Mathematics Curriculum Analysis from the Official Curriculum to the Intended Curriculum
In this paper, we share major lessons we have learned in our curriculum analysis explorations and provide suggestions for future mathematics curriculum research. Specifically, we will discuss the successes and challenges of using comparative methods and developing analytical frameworks. Using an old Chinese saying, follow the vine to get the melon (顺藤摸瓜), our journey starts with getting a holistic picture of standards and moves to identifying a specific topic in the textbooks. We first conducted a study to compare the geometry standards of the Common Core State Standards for Mathematics (CCSSM) and the Chinese Compulsory Education Mathematics Curriculum Standards (CMCS); then we analyzed the presentation of a specific topic, triangle congruence, in multiple geometry textbooks. For each comparative study we conducted, developing the analytical framework that can be used to guide future investigations constituted a critical step in the research methodology. We have learned lessons from adapting the well-known van Hiele model, which was created for the development of geometric reasoning, into a lens for a detailed curriculum analysis. We have also learned lessons from elaborating on the key constructs from the “Mathematics Curriculum as Story” framework for coding and analysis. These lessons as well as our future directions serve as the primary focus of this paper.
- Open Access
- 28 December 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Learning Environments Research
- Vol. 26 (2) , 573-593
Mathematically productive relationships (MPRs): a potentially effective classroom management approach
Positive teacher–student relationships are considered essential for effective classroom management. Thus, focusing efforts to understand better and strengthen teacher–student relationships in order to improve student outcome metrics is prudent. This study examined seven elementary teachers’ descriptions and enactment of mathematically productive relationships (MPRs), a type of teacher-student relationship, and their influence on classroom management practices. Teachers’ descriptions of MPRs incorporated four themes: (a) creating safe, mistake-friendly environments, (b) developing trust and respect between the teacher and the students, (c) establishing and maintaining clear and high expectations, and (d) ensuring that classrooms remain safe spaces. However, these features did not always appear in the teachers’ classrooms. The enactment of MPRs varied across cases, with the participants’ classroom management priorities lying along a continuum from behavioural management to cognitive engagement. Implications of MPRs and the influence of different classroom management practices on students’ learning opportunities are discussed.
- 28 December 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Learning Environments Research
- Vol. 26 (2) , 573-593
Open AccessMathematically productive relationships (MPRs): a potentially effective classroom management approach
Positive teacher–student relationships are considered essential for effective classroom management. Thus, focusing efforts to understand better and strengthen teacher–student relationships in order to improve student outcome metrics is prudent. This study examined seven elementary teachers’ descriptions and enactment of mathematically productive relationships (MPRs), a type of teacher-student relationship, and their influence on classroom management practices. Teachers’ descriptions of MPRs incorporated four themes: (a) creating safe, mistake-friendly environments, (b) developing trust and respect between the teacher and the students, (c) establishing and maintaining clear and high expectations, and (d) ensuring that classrooms remain safe spaces. However, these features did not always appear in the teachers’ classrooms. The enactment of MPRs varied across cases, with the participants’ classroom management priorities lying along a continuum from behavioural management to cognitive engagement. Implications of MPRs and the influence of different classroom management practices on students’ learning opportunities are discussed.
- Open Access
- 15 December 2021
- Published by ISTES Organization in International Journal of Education in Mathematics, Science and Technology
- Vol. 10 (1) , 38-56
A Comparison of U.S. and Chinese Geometry Standards through the Lens of van Hiele Levels
The present study aims to compare the geometry standards in U.S. Common Core State Standards of Mathematics (CCSSM) and Chinese Compulsory Education Mathematics Curriculum Standards (CMCS) through the lens of van Hiele levels. The study considered a standard unit as one or multiple learning expectation(s) and placed each learning expectation into van Hiele levels. By examining the van Hiele level distributions of the learning expectations and major topics, this study investigated how CCSSM and CMCS propose the students' development of geometric thoughts. The findings reveal different emphases in geometry learning expectations of CCSSM and CMCS. Specifically, (a) Geometry standards in CCSSM are more general, whereas geometry standards in CMCS are more specific; (b) CMCS shows a more consistent progression through grade bands than CCSSM; (c) CCSSM makes more connections between various aspects within a topic and across multiple topics than CMCS; (d) CCSSM highlights Dynamic Geometry Environments (DGEs), whereas CMCS underscores abstract and rigor at the upper level. Implications of this study and suggestions for future revisions for both standards are discussed.
- 15 December 2021
- Published by ISTES Organization in International Journal of Education in Mathematics, Science and Technology
- Vol. 10 (1) , 38-56
Open AccessA Comparison of U.S. and Chinese Geometry Standards through the Lens of van Hiele Levels
The present study aims to compare the geometry standards in U.S. Common Core State Standards of Mathematics (CCSSM) and Chinese Compulsory Education Mathematics Curriculum Standards (CMCS) through the lens of van Hiele levels. The study considered a standard unit as one or multiple learning expectation(s) and placed each learning expectation into van Hiele levels. By examining the van Hiele level distributions of the learning expectations and major topics, this study investigated how CCSSM and CMCS propose the students' development of geometric thoughts. The findings reveal different emphases in geometry learning expectations of CCSSM and CMCS. Specifically, (a) Geometry standards in CCSSM are more general, whereas geometry standards in CMCS are more specific; (b) CMCS shows a more consistent progression through grade bands than CCSSM; (c) CCSSM makes more connections between various aspects within a topic and across multiple topics than CMCS; (d) CCSSM highlights Dynamic Geometry Environments (DGEs), whereas CMCS underscores abstract and rigor at the upper level. Implications of this study and suggestions for future revisions for both standards are discussed.