Juan Fischer
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Juan Fischer has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Margaret Bearman
Centre for Research in Assessment and Digital Learning (CRADLE), Deakin University, Melbourne, Australia
3 shared publications - Andrew Williams
Centre for Integrity and Impact in Teaching Excellence (CiiTE), The University of Western Australia
2 shared publications - David Boud
Centre for Research in Assessment and Digital Learning (CRADLE), Deakin University
2 shared publications - Joanna Tai
Centre for Research in Assessment and Digital Learning (CRADLE), Deakin University, Melbourne, Australia
2 shared publications - Kelly Benati
Monash Business School, Monash University, Melbourne, Australia
2 shared publications - Michelle Pedlow
Department of Nursing, School of Health and Clinical Sciences, The University of Western Australia
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 17 November 2026
- Published by Open Access Publishing Association in ASCILITE Publications
- p. 575-580
A tale of two trilemmas: Navigating trade-offs in assessment and feedback design
Assessment and feedback are expected to achieve an expanding range of educational purposes. They must support learning, assure standards, foster learner agency, provide credible evidence of achievement, promote inclusion, prepare students for professional practice, and remain feasible within increasingly complex institutional environments. These legitimate priorities cannot all be maximised simultaneously, requiring educators to navigate trade-offs in assessment and feedback design. Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has brought these longstanding tensions into sharper focus by challenging conventional assumptions about evidence, authorship and academic integrity. However, the underlying design problem extends well beyond AI. This paper proposes the Dual Trilemma Framework as a conceptual lens for designing assessment and feedback for learning. Rather than offering another set of design principles, the framework positions trade-offs as the central challenge of educational design. The assessment trilemma foregrounds tensions between authenticity, observability and feasibility, while the feedback trilemma highlights competing demands of usability, sources and sustainability. Together, these trilemmas function as a meta-framework that complements existing assessment and feedback frameworks by supporting explicit, context-sensitive design decisions. The paper argues that improving assessment and feedback depends less on pursuing idealised design principles and more on making informed, transparent and pedagogically defensible decisions about competing educational priorities.
- 17 November 2026
- Published by Open Access Publishing Association in ASCILITE Publications
- p. 575-580
Open AccessA tale of two trilemmas: Navigating trade-offs in assessment and feedback design
Assessment and feedback are expected to achieve an expanding range of educational purposes. They must support learning, assure standards, foster learner agency, provide credible evidence of achievement, promote inclusion, prepare students for professional practice, and remain feasible within increasingly complex institutional environments. These legitimate priorities cannot all be maximised simultaneously, requiring educators to navigate trade-offs in assessment and feedback design. Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has brought these longstanding tensions into sharper focus by challenging conventional assumptions about evidence, authorship and academic integrity. However, the underlying design problem extends well beyond AI. This paper proposes the Dual Trilemma Framework as a conceptual lens for designing assessment and feedback for learning. Rather than offering another set of design principles, the framework positions trade-offs as the central challenge of educational design. The assessment trilemma foregrounds tensions between authenticity, observability and feasibility, while the feedback trilemma highlights competing demands of usability, sources and sustainability. Together, these trilemmas function as a meta-framework that complements existing assessment and feedback frameworks by supporting explicit, context-sensitive design decisions. The paper argues that improving assessment and feedback depends less on pursuing idealised design principles and more on making informed, transparent and pedagogically defensible decisions about competing educational priorities.
- Open Access
- 22 September 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- p. 1-19
Trade-offs in assessment and feedback design: a trilemma-based model
Assessment in higher education is being asked to do more than at any previous point. Contemporary assessment designs are expected to support a myriad of objectives including authentic engagement wi...
- 22 September 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- p. 1-19
Open AccessTrade-offs in assessment and feedback design: a trilemma-based model
Assessment in higher education is being asked to do more than at any previous point. Contemporary assessment designs are expected to support a myriad of objectives including authentic engagement wi...
- Open Access
- 20 May 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Teaching in Higher Education
- Vol. 31 (7) , 1-18
Context matters! Unpacking its role in evaluative judgement through the Theory of Practice Architectures
- 20 May 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Teaching in Higher Education
- Vol. 31 (7) , 1-18
Open AccessContext matters! Unpacking its role in evaluative judgement through the Theory of Practice Architectures
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 3 March 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Studies in Higher Education
- Vol. 51 (1) , 197-209
Coming to belong in the university through small acts of connection
- 3 March 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Studies in Higher Education
- Vol. 51 (1) , 197-209
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessComing to belong in the university through small acts of connection
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 4 May 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 49 (2) , 233-245
How does assessment drive learning? A focus on students’ development of evaluative judgement
Summative assessment is often considered a motivator that drives students’ learning. Higher education has a responsibility in promoting lifelong learning and assessment plays an important role in supporting students’ capability to make evaluative judgements about their work and that of others. However, as research often focuses on formal pedagogical design, it is unclear what behaviours summative assessment prompts, thus the relationship between summative assessment, learning and evaluative judgement requires further investigation. Drawing on a small-scale ethnography-informed study, this paper adopts a practice theory approach to explore how undergraduate physics students from three year levels make evaluative judgements in the context of summative assessment tasks. The contexts explored through observations and interviews include a graded in-class tutorial, an out-of-class study group for an in-semester assignment, and individual preparation for examinations. The findings suggest that while summative assessment is a crucial aspect of students’ learning context, it does not fully shape students’ practices. Instead, students engage in incidental conversations about the quality of their work and how to do things in their studies. By focusing on what students actually do, this study integrates formal and informal aspects of students’ learning, highlighting the tensions between undergraduate practices and intended learning outcomes.
- 4 May 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 49 (2) , 233-245
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessHow does assessment drive learning? A focus on students’ development of evaluative judgement
Summative assessment is often considered a motivator that drives students’ learning. Higher education has a responsibility in promoting lifelong learning and assessment plays an important role in supporting students’ capability to make evaluative judgements about their work and that of others. However, as research often focuses on formal pedagogical design, it is unclear what behaviours summative assessment prompts, thus the relationship between summative assessment, learning and evaluative judgement requires further investigation. Drawing on a small-scale ethnography-informed study, this paper adopts a practice theory approach to explore how undergraduate physics students from three year levels make evaluative judgements in the context of summative assessment tasks. The contexts explored through observations and interviews include a graded in-class tutorial, an out-of-class study group for an in-semester assignment, and individual preparation for examinations. The findings suggest that while summative assessment is a crucial aspect of students’ learning context, it does not fully shape students’ practices. Instead, students engage in incidental conversations about the quality of their work and how to do things in their studies. By focusing on what students actually do, this study integrates formal and informal aspects of students’ learning, highlighting the tensions between undergraduate practices and intended learning outcomes.
- 28 February 2023
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Education + Training
- Vol. 65 (3) , 403-415
Career planning and workforce preparation during economic downturn: perceptions of graduating business students
Purpose: To gather insight into how graduating business students are preparing for the workplace and their future careers and how this has been impacted by COVID-19.Design/methodology/approach: In total, 144 business students at an Australian university who had recently completed an internship and were nearing graduation took part in the study. Group A was surveyed before COVID-19 had emerged and Group B undertook their internships during a COVID-19 lockdown when the related economic downturn had become apparent. The responses were analysed using career construction theory (CCT).Findings: This study concludes that graduating students do not generally place greater emphasis on career planning in times of economic downturn. However, they do devote more effort to job search and networking activities. They also display more career decisiveness and are less willing to seek out information about potential careers or their suitability for them. Their confidence in embarking on a career was not impacted.Research limitations/implications: This enables us to form a more complete picture of how graduating students perceive their work-readiness and the action they feel is important in order to improve their employability.Practical implications: This has implications for career practitioners and employers of graduates as it adds to the knowledge of employability and the decision-making process in times of economic crisis and is particularly important for the tertiary education sector as it seeks to better target initiatives to aid employability in graduates.Originality/value: The results increase the understanding of the impact of COVID-19 on early career development and argue that early-career decision-making is a specific area requiring investigation.
- 28 February 2023
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Education + Training
- Vol. 65 (3) , 403-415
Career planning and workforce preparation during economic downturn: perceptions of graduating business students
Purpose: To gather insight into how graduating business students are preparing for the workplace and their future careers and how this has been impacted by COVID-19.Design/methodology/approach: In total, 144 business students at an Australian university who had recently completed an internship and were nearing graduation took part in the study. Group A was surveyed before COVID-19 had emerged and Group B undertook their internships during a COVID-19 lockdown when the related economic downturn had become apparent. The responses were analysed using career construction theory (CCT).Findings: This study concludes that graduating students do not generally place greater emphasis on career planning in times of economic downturn. However, they do devote more effort to job search and networking activities. They also display more career decisiveness and are less willing to seek out information about potential careers or their suitability for them. Their confidence in embarking on a career was not impacted.Research limitations/implications: This enables us to form a more complete picture of how graduating students perceive their work-readiness and the action they feel is important in order to improve their employability.Practical implications: This has implications for career practitioners and employers of graduates as it adds to the knowledge of employability and the decision-making process in times of economic crisis and is particularly important for the tertiary education sector as it seeks to better target initiatives to aid employability in graduates.Originality/value: The results increase the understanding of the impact of COVID-19 on early career development and argue that early-career decision-making is a specific area requiring investigation.
- Open Access
- 15 December 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Higher Education
- Vol. 86 (6) , 1363-1376
“Attending lectures in your pyjamas”: student agency in constrained circumstances
COVID-19 forced the digitalisation of teaching and learning in a response often described as emergency remote teaching (ERT). This rapid response changed the social, spatial, and temporal arrangements of higher education and required important adaptations from educators and students alike. However, while the literature has examined the constraints students faced (e.g. availability of the internet) and the consequences of the pandemic (e.g. student mental health), students’ active management of these constraints for learning remains underexplored. This paper aims to “think with” COVID-19 to explore student agency in home learning under constrained circumstances. This qualitative study used semi-structured interviews to understand the day-to-day actions of nineteen undergraduate students managing their learning during the COVID-19 lockdowns in Victoria, Australia. Emirbayer and Mische’s multiple dimensions of agency — iterative, projective, and practical-evaluative — are used to explore student experience. The findings illustrate students’ adaptability and agency in navigating life-integrated learning, with most of their actions oriented to their present circumstances. This practical evaluative form of agency was expressed through (1) organising self, space, time, and relationships; (2) self-care; and (3) seeking help. Although this study took place in the context of ERT, it has implications beyond the pandemic because higher education always operates under constraints, and in other circumstances, many students still experience emotionally and materially difficult times.
- 15 December 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Higher Education
- Vol. 86 (6) , 1363-1376
Open Access“Attending lectures in your pyjamas”: student agency in constrained circumstances
COVID-19 forced the digitalisation of teaching and learning in a response often described as emergency remote teaching (ERT). This rapid response changed the social, spatial, and temporal arrangements of higher education and required important adaptations from educators and students alike. However, while the literature has examined the constraints students faced (e.g. availability of the internet) and the consequences of the pandemic (e.g. student mental health), students’ active management of these constraints for learning remains underexplored. This paper aims to “think with” COVID-19 to explore student agency in home learning under constrained circumstances. This qualitative study used semi-structured interviews to understand the day-to-day actions of nineteen undergraduate students managing their learning during the COVID-19 lockdowns in Victoria, Australia. Emirbayer and Mische’s multiple dimensions of agency — iterative, projective, and practical-evaluative — are used to explore student experience. The findings illustrate students’ adaptability and agency in navigating life-integrated learning, with most of their actions oriented to their present circumstances. This practical evaluative form of agency was expressed through (1) organising self, space, time, and relationships; (2) self-care; and (3) seeking help. Although this study took place in the context of ERT, it has implications beyond the pandemic because higher education always operates under constraints, and in other circumstances, many students still experience emotionally and materially difficult times.
- 6 July 2021
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Education + Training
- Vol. 63 (9) , 1213-1224
Applying theory in practice: views of graduating business students
Purpose: Universities have traditionally focused on imparting theoretical knowledge, which graduates then transfer to the workplace. However, the unpredictable modern workplace makes this transfer less certain. Whilst the gap between theory and practice has often been considered from an employer and academic standpoint, less is known about the graduate perspective. The purpose of this study is to determine the ways in which theoretical knowledge and practical experience interact for graduating students.Design/methodology/approach: The views of 86 undergraduate business approaching graduation were gathered on how they applied theory to practice during their recent internship.Findings: Graduating students apply theory that they have learnt at university through the direct application of fundamental knowledge and through workplace experience, which built on and deepened the knowledge accumulated at university. The findings indicate that there is, indeed, a gap between theory and practice but that employability skills may assist in the transfer process.Research limitations/implications: The research broadens the understanding of how theoretical knowledge is applied in practice and helps to determine if graduating students are prepared to meet the demands of an ever-changing workplace.Practical implications: The results give us insight into how theory and practice interact for graduating students and give support to universities further exploring experiential learning opportunities for students and continuing to the development of employability skills.Originality/value: The findings encourage a more nuanced debate regarding the role of universities and that both the provision of core theoretical concept and employability skills are necessary for graduates to effectively use their academic education in the modern workplace.
- 6 July 2021
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Education + Training
- Vol. 63 (9) , 1213-1224
Applying theory in practice: views of graduating business students
Purpose: Universities have traditionally focused on imparting theoretical knowledge, which graduates then transfer to the workplace. However, the unpredictable modern workplace makes this transfer less certain. Whilst the gap between theory and practice has often been considered from an employer and academic standpoint, less is known about the graduate perspective. The purpose of this study is to determine the ways in which theoretical knowledge and practical experience interact for graduating students.Design/methodology/approach: The views of 86 undergraduate business approaching graduation were gathered on how they applied theory to practice during their recent internship.Findings: Graduating students apply theory that they have learnt at university through the direct application of fundamental knowledge and through workplace experience, which built on and deepened the knowledge accumulated at university. The findings indicate that there is, indeed, a gap between theory and practice but that employability skills may assist in the transfer process.Research limitations/implications: The research broadens the understanding of how theoretical knowledge is applied in practice and helps to determine if graduating students are prepared to meet the demands of an ever-changing workplace.Practical implications: The results give us insight into how theory and practice interact for graduating students and give support to universities further exploring experiential learning opportunities for students and continuing to the development of employability skills.Originality/value: The findings encourage a more nuanced debate regarding the role of universities and that both the provision of core theoretical concept and employability skills are necessary for graduates to effectively use their academic education in the modern workplace.
- 10 November 2020
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Education + Training
- Vol. 63 (1) , 151-163
Beyond human capital: student preparation for graduate life
Purpose: This research moves beyond a focus on employability skills and explores student perceptions of preparedness for graduate life in a more holistic manner.Design/methodology/approach: Final-year business students were asked to outline their concerns regarding graduate life and the personal and professional challenges anticipated in their careers. The results are presented in the context of graduate capitals, which is a broader view than the more traditional skills-based approach.Findings: The results indicate students do not feel underprepared for the workplace in terms of human capital, social capital, cultural capital and identity capital. However, many students feel inadequately prepared in terms of psychological capital and their ability to deal with the expected challenges of the workplace such as stress, long hours and the demands of a professional environment.Research limitations/implications: This study extends our knowledge of student preparation for the workplace and suggests research opportunities to better understand psychological capital development in graduates.Practical implications: Greater confidence and a perception of preparedness may be increased for graduates if opportunities for psychological capital development and increased promotion of its importance are enhanced.Social implications: The results encourage a more holistic approach to employability in graduates and have relevance for all stakeholders concerned with graduate outcomes and workplace transition.Originality/value: The paper presents work-readiness in the context of graduate capitals, which is broader than the traditional skills-based approach. It also focuses on student perceptions of their level of preparation for the workplace. This has enabled results which highlight psychological capital development as a key area in which students feel underprepared.
- 10 November 2020
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Education + Training
- Vol. 63 (1) , 151-163
Beyond human capital: student preparation for graduate life
Purpose: This research moves beyond a focus on employability skills and explores student perceptions of preparedness for graduate life in a more holistic manner.Design/methodology/approach: Final-year business students were asked to outline their concerns regarding graduate life and the personal and professional challenges anticipated in their careers. The results are presented in the context of graduate capitals, which is a broader view than the more traditional skills-based approach.Findings: The results indicate students do not feel underprepared for the workplace in terms of human capital, social capital, cultural capital and identity capital. However, many students feel inadequately prepared in terms of psychological capital and their ability to deal with the expected challenges of the workplace such as stress, long hours and the demands of a professional environment.Research limitations/implications: This study extends our knowledge of student preparation for the workplace and suggests research opportunities to better understand psychological capital development in graduates.Practical implications: Greater confidence and a perception of preparedness may be increased for graduates if opportunities for psychological capital development and increased promotion of its importance are enhanced.Social implications: The results encourage a more holistic approach to employability in graduates and have relevance for all stakeholders concerned with graduate outcomes and workplace transition.Originality/value: The paper presents work-readiness in the context of graduate capitals, which is broader than the traditional skills-based approach. It also focuses on student perceptions of their level of preparation for the workplace. This has enabled results which highlight psychological capital development as a key area in which students feel underprepared.