Jana Ebler
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Jana Ebler has a total of 380 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Tobias Marschall
Institute for Medical Biometry and Bioinformatics, Medical Faculty and University Hospital Düsseldorf, Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf , Düsseldorf 40225
19 shared publications - Evan E. Eichler
Department of Genome Sciences, University of Washington School of Medicine
10 shared publications - Jan Oliver Korbel
Genome Biology Unit, European Molecular Biology Laboratory (EMBL), Heidelberg, Germany
8 shared publications - Peter Ebert
Core Unit Bioinformatics, Medical Faculty and University Hospital Dusseldorf, Heinrich Heine University, Dusseldorf, Germany
8 shared publications - David Porubsky
Department of Genome Sciences, University of Washington School of Medicine
7 shared publications - Peter A. Audano
The Jackson Laboratory
7 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
HPRC2: A human pangenome reference with near-complete coverage of common genetic variation
A pangenome reference overcomes the inherent limitation of any individual reference genome by integrating the variation present in a population. We present the Human Pangenome Reference Consortium's (HPRC) Release 2 (HPRC2), an openly available, second phase pangenome that is an approximately fivefold expansion in genome number over HPRC Release 1 (HPRC1) and measurable improvement in genome completeness, contiguity, and accuracy. Selecting samples with a principled algorithm prioritising common variant coverage, HPRC2 contributes 460 haplotypes that together capture over 99% of common variation observed in the All of Us Research Program v8 cohort. Combining high-coverage long and ultra-long reads with modern assemblers and polishers, we produce thousands of telomere-to-telomere (T2T) chromosomes, and relative to HPRC1 halve the number of structurally unreliable regions as well as individual base errors per haplotype. We complement the assemblies with whole genome multiple alignments and gene annotations, and derive formal pangenome coordinate systems for addressing off-reference variation, demonstrating that individual human genomes contain more than one hundred thousand variants not succinctly described with respect to existing reference genomes. We also present the first matched long-read backed pantranscriptome and panepigenome at this scale, provide continuous local-ancestry estimates spanning every genome, and outline a host of new tools and applications that leverage the pangenome resource for improved genomics analysis.
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessHPRC2: A human pangenome reference with near-complete coverage of common genetic variation
A pangenome reference overcomes the inherent limitation of any individual reference genome by integrating the variation present in a population. We present the Human Pangenome Reference Consortium's (HPRC) Release 2 (HPRC2), an openly available, second phase pangenome that is an approximately fivefold expansion in genome number over HPRC Release 1 (HPRC1) and measurable improvement in genome completeness, contiguity, and accuracy. Selecting samples with a principled algorithm prioritising common variant coverage, HPRC2 contributes 460 haplotypes that together capture over 99% of common variation observed in the All of Us Research Program v8 cohort. Combining high-coverage long and ultra-long reads with modern assemblers and polishers, we produce thousands of telomere-to-telomere (T2T) chromosomes, and relative to HPRC1 halve the number of structurally unreliable regions as well as individual base errors per haplotype. We complement the assemblies with whole genome multiple alignments and gene annotations, and derive formal pangenome coordinate systems for addressing off-reference variation, demonstrating that individual human genomes contain more than one hundred thousand variants not succinctly described with respect to existing reference genomes. We also present the first matched long-read backed pantranscriptome and panepigenome at this scale, provide continuous local-ancestry estimates spanning every genome, and outline a host of new tools and applications that leverage the pangenome resource for improved genomics analysis.
- Open Access
Pangenome-based human genome analysis improves trait association and genomic prediction
The Human Pangenome Reference Consortium has generated 462 open-access reference genomes and a variation graph that represents differences among them, providing a substrate for pangenome-based analysis methods that overcome the longstanding limitation of comparing all genomic data to a single linear reference. A key unresolved question is the extent to which these approaches can improve trait mapping. We investigate this using the genetics of gene expression variation as a model. We developed a graph-based method (EdgeDepth) for associating sequence variation with traits using short-read genome sequencing data, and show that it captures complex forms of genetic variation missed by other methods. We evaluated trait mapping performance using 430 samples with deep RNA-seq data, and found that pangenomic methods enable the detection of expression quantitative trait loci involving multiallelic indels and structural variants, leading to increased power at a subset of genes. These include 812 genes (7.9% of total) with ≥20% improvement in statistical significance relative to the 1000 Genomes Project callset, and 185 (1.8%) with a 50% improvement, 10 of which are candidates to explain prior GWAS results. Notably, these analyses implicate GBAP1 pseudogene copy number as a causal factor in Crohn's disease, likely via miRNA-mediated regulation of GBA1 , which explains prior GWAS results based on flanking SNPs. The inclusion of pangenome-specific variation also improved the performance of gene expression prediction models, with median variance explained increasing from 10.1% to 12.5%, and 14.6% of genes showing significant improvement (Δr 2 >0.05). Taken together, these results suggest that integration of pangenomic methods into human genetic studies will improve trait association and genomic prediction at a meaningful subset of genes.
Open AccessPangenome-based human genome analysis improves trait association and genomic prediction
The Human Pangenome Reference Consortium has generated 462 open-access reference genomes and a variation graph that represents differences among them, providing a substrate for pangenome-based analysis methods that overcome the longstanding limitation of comparing all genomic data to a single linear reference. A key unresolved question is the extent to which these approaches can improve trait mapping. We investigate this using the genetics of gene expression variation as a model. We developed a graph-based method (EdgeDepth) for associating sequence variation with traits using short-read genome sequencing data, and show that it captures complex forms of genetic variation missed by other methods. We evaluated trait mapping performance using 430 samples with deep RNA-seq data, and found that pangenomic methods enable the detection of expression quantitative trait loci involving multiallelic indels and structural variants, leading to increased power at a subset of genes. These include 812 genes (7.9% of total) with ≥20% improvement in statistical significance relative to the 1000 Genomes Project callset, and 185 (1.8%) with a 50% improvement, 10 of which are candidates to explain prior GWAS results. Notably, these analyses implicate GBAP1 pseudogene copy number as a causal factor in Crohn's disease, likely via miRNA-mediated regulation of GBA1 , which explains prior GWAS results based on flanking SNPs. The inclusion of pangenome-specific variation also improved the performance of gene expression prediction models, with median variance explained increasing from 10.1% to 12.5%, and 14.6% of genes showing significant improvement (Δr 2 >0.05). Taken together, these results suggest that integration of pangenomic methods into human genetic studies will improve trait association and genomic prediction at a meaningful subset of genes.
- Open Access
Scalable and rare-variant aware genome inference across the 1kGP cohort
Pangenome graphs built from haplotype-resolved de novo assemblies enable accurate analysis of genetic variation. The short-read-based tool PanGenie efficiently genotypes variants discovered in a pangenome across large cohorts and outperforms linear reference-based methods for structural variants (SVs). However, it cannot detect novel variants absent from the graph, missing many rare SVs (allele frequency <1%) and was limited to graphs with 254 haplotypes. First, we introduce a haplotype sampling step that reduces the number of haplotypes using sample-specific k-mers before genotyping, decreasing runtime twelvefold and memory usage 1.4-fold at 30x coverage. Second, we present a polishing workflow that corrects residual errors in haplotypes inferred from PanGenie genotypes and incorporates rare and private mutations. We genotype 3,202 samples from the 1000 Genomes Project and use low-coverage ONT data (967 samples) for polishing. We achieve a median QV of 46 and provide the 1,934 polished haplotype sequences as a community resource.
Open AccessScalable and rare-variant aware genome inference across the 1kGP cohort
Pangenome graphs built from haplotype-resolved de novo assemblies enable accurate analysis of genetic variation. The short-read-based tool PanGenie efficiently genotypes variants discovered in a pangenome across large cohorts and outperforms linear reference-based methods for structural variants (SVs). However, it cannot detect novel variants absent from the graph, missing many rare SVs (allele frequency <1%) and was limited to graphs with 254 haplotypes. First, we introduce a haplotype sampling step that reduces the number of haplotypes using sample-specific k-mers before genotyping, decreasing runtime twelvefold and memory usage 1.4-fold at 30x coverage. Second, we present a polishing workflow that corrects residual errors in haplotypes inferred from PanGenie genotypes and incorporates rare and private mutations. We genotype 3,202 samples from the 1000 Genomes Project and use low-coverage ONT data (967 samples) for polishing. We achieve a median QV of 46 and provide the 1,934 polished haplotype sequences as a community resource.
- 29 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Genetics
- p. 1-17
Building and applying pangenome references to capture genetic diversity
Reference genomes serve as a coordinate system and are central to almost all analyses in genomics. However, linear reference genomes are based on a single individual or a small number of individuals and do not represent genetic diversity. Recent advances in de novo genome assembly, powered by long-read sequencing technologies, now enable the sequence reconstruction of many genomes to reference quality. These pangenomes integrate sequences from multiple individuals into graph-based or multi-haplotype representations, capturing genetic variation beyond a single linear reference. The widespread adoption of such pangenome references, which encode a diverse set of haplotypes, thus removes biases and enables the discovery of variants relative to all included haplotype backgrounds. The emergence of corresponding computational tools for analysing structural variants and complex genetic loci opens up opportunities in genome-wide association studies and rare-disease genetics. Here we review these opportunities, as well as challenges concerning pangenomes that need to be addressed by the research community.
- 29 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Genetics
- p. 1-17
Building and applying pangenome references to capture genetic diversity
Reference genomes serve as a coordinate system and are central to almost all analyses in genomics. However, linear reference genomes are based on a single individual or a small number of individuals and do not represent genetic diversity. Recent advances in de novo genome assembly, powered by long-read sequencing technologies, now enable the sequence reconstruction of many genomes to reference quality. These pangenomes integrate sequences from multiple individuals into graph-based or multi-haplotype representations, capturing genetic variation beyond a single linear reference. The widespread adoption of such pangenome references, which encode a diverse set of haplotypes, thus removes biases and enables the discovery of variants relative to all included haplotype backgrounds. The emergence of corresponding computational tools for analysing structural variants and complex genetic loci opens up opportunities in genome-wide association studies and rare-disease genetics. Here we review these opportunities, as well as challenges concerning pangenomes that need to be addressed by the research community.
- Open Access
Population-scale Y chromosome assemblies reveal recurrent remodeling within constrained architectures
The human Y chromosome is among the most structurally dynamic chromosomes in the human genome, yet much of its diversity remains unresolved because of extensive palindromes, ampliconic gene families, satellite-rich heterochromatin and large segmental duplications. What remained unclear was how these diverse forms of variation fit together across the full chromosome, how often similar structures recur in different lineages, and which aspects of organization remain constrained despite rapid sequence turnover. Here, we generated and analyzed 142 nearly complete human Y chromosome assemblies from 17 major haplogroups spanning approximately 180,000 years of evolution, creating a population-scale resource for studying Y chromosome biology and diversity. These assemblies show that structural change on the Y chromosome is recurrent but constrained, even in its most repetitive regions. In the fertility-associated azoospermia factor c (AZFc) region, recurrent inversions, deletions, and complex rearrangements generate a limited repertoire of structural haplotypes. Multicopy ampliconic gene families follow distinct evolutionary paths: DAZ paralogues differ in structural constraint, RBMY evolves within a modular array, and TSPY copy number varies mainly through local expansion and contraction. The centromere and Yq12 heterochromatin vary greatly in size but retain a stable higher-order organization, including a single hypomethylated centromeric core and conserved Yq12 repeat composition and orientation. Methylation across palindromic and ampliconic regions is likewise structured by repeat class, copy order and local architecture. Together, these results provide a population-scale resource for the human Y chromosome and show that its rapid structural evolution is repeatedly funneled into a limited set of architectural outcomes.
Open AccessPopulation-scale Y chromosome assemblies reveal recurrent remodeling within constrained architectures
The human Y chromosome is among the most structurally dynamic chromosomes in the human genome, yet much of its diversity remains unresolved because of extensive palindromes, ampliconic gene families, satellite-rich heterochromatin and large segmental duplications. What remained unclear was how these diverse forms of variation fit together across the full chromosome, how often similar structures recur in different lineages, and which aspects of organization remain constrained despite rapid sequence turnover. Here, we generated and analyzed 142 nearly complete human Y chromosome assemblies from 17 major haplogroups spanning approximately 180,000 years of evolution, creating a population-scale resource for studying Y chromosome biology and diversity. These assemblies show that structural change on the Y chromosome is recurrent but constrained, even in its most repetitive regions. In the fertility-associated azoospermia factor c (AZFc) region, recurrent inversions, deletions, and complex rearrangements generate a limited repertoire of structural haplotypes. Multicopy ampliconic gene families follow distinct evolutionary paths: DAZ paralogues differ in structural constraint, RBMY evolves within a modular array, and TSPY copy number varies mainly through local expansion and contraction. The centromere and Yq12 heterochromatin vary greatly in size but retain a stable higher-order organization, including a single hypomethylated centromeric core and conserved Yq12 repeat composition and orientation. Methylation across palindromic and ampliconic regions is likewise structured by repeat class, copy order and local architecture. Together, these results provide a population-scale resource for the human Y chromosome and show that its rapid structural evolution is repeatedly funneled into a limited set of architectural outcomes.
- Open Access
Complex genetic variation in nearly complete human genomes
Diverse sets of complete human genomes are required to construct a pangenome reference and to understand the extent of complex structural variation. Here, we sequence 65 diverse human genomes and build 130 haplotype-resolved assemblies (130 Mbp median continuity), closing 92% of all previous assembly gaps1,2 and reaching telomere-to-telomere (T2T) status for 39% of the chromosomes. We highlight complete sequence continuity of complex loci, including the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), SMN1/SMN2, NBPF8, and AMY1/AMY2, and fully resolve 1,852 complex structural variants (SVs). In addition, we completely assemble and validate 1,246 human centromeres. We find up to 30-fold variation in α-satellite high-order repeat (HOR) array length and characterize the pattern of mobile element insertions into α-satellite HOR arrays. While most centromeres predict a single site of kinetochore attachment, epigenetic analysis suggests the presence of two hypomethylated regions for 7% of centromeres. Combining our data with the draft pangenome reference1 significantly enhances genotyping accuracy from short-read data, enabling whole-genome inference3 to a median quality value (QV) of 45. Using this approach, 26,115 SVs per sample are detected, substantially increasing the number of SVs now amenable to downstream disease association studies.
Open AccessComplex genetic variation in nearly complete human genomes
Diverse sets of complete human genomes are required to construct a pangenome reference and to understand the extent of complex structural variation. Here, we sequence 65 diverse human genomes and build 130 haplotype-resolved assemblies (130 Mbp median continuity), closing 92% of all previous assembly gaps1,2 and reaching telomere-to-telomere (T2T) status for 39% of the chromosomes. We highlight complete sequence continuity of complex loci, including the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), SMN1/SMN2, NBPF8, and AMY1/AMY2, and fully resolve 1,852 complex structural variants (SVs). In addition, we completely assemble and validate 1,246 human centromeres. We find up to 30-fold variation in α-satellite high-order repeat (HOR) array length and characterize the pattern of mobile element insertions into α-satellite HOR arrays. While most centromeres predict a single site of kinetochore attachment, epigenetic analysis suggests the presence of two hypomethylated regions for 7% of centromeres. Combining our data with the draft pangenome reference1 significantly enhances genotyping accuracy from short-read data, enabling whole-genome inference3 to a median quality value (QV) of 45. Using this approach, 26,115 SVs per sample are detected, substantially increasing the number of SVs now amenable to downstream disease association studies.
- Open Access
Long-read sequencing and structural variant characterization in 1,019 samples from the 1000 Genomes Project
Structural variants (SVs) contribute significantly to human genetic diversity and disease 1–4 . Previously, SVs have remained incompletely resolved by population genomics, with short-read sequencing facing limitations in capturing the whole spectrum of SVs at nucleotide resolution 5–7 . Here we leveraged nanopore sequencing 8 to construct an intermediate coverage resource of 1,019 long-read genomes sampled within 26 human populations from the 1000 Genomes Project. By integrating linear and graph-based approaches for SV analysis via pangenome graph-augmentation, we uncover 167,291 sequence-resolved SVs in these samples, considerably advancing SV characterization compared to population-wide short-read sequencing studies 3,4 . Our analysis details diverse SV classes—deletions, duplications, insertions, and inversions—at population-scale. LINE-1 and SVA retrotransposition activities frequently mediate transductions 9,10 of unique sequences, with both mobile element classes transducing sequences at either the 3′- or 5′-end, depending on the source element locus. Furthermore, analyses of SV breakpoint junctions suggest a continuum of homology-mediated rearrangement processes are integral to SV formation, and highlight evidence for SV recurrence involving repeat sequences. Our open-access dataset underscores the transformative impact of long-read sequencing in advancing the characterisation of polymorphic genomic architectures, and provides a resource for guiding variant prioritisation in future long-read sequencing-based disease studies.
Open AccessLong-read sequencing and structural variant characterization in 1,019 samples from the 1000 Genomes Project
Structural variants (SVs) contribute significantly to human genetic diversity and disease 1–4 . Previously, SVs have remained incompletely resolved by population genomics, with short-read sequencing facing limitations in capturing the whole spectrum of SVs at nucleotide resolution 5–7 . Here we leveraged nanopore sequencing 8 to construct an intermediate coverage resource of 1,019 long-read genomes sampled within 26 human populations from the 1000 Genomes Project. By integrating linear and graph-based approaches for SV analysis via pangenome graph-augmentation, we uncover 167,291 sequence-resolved SVs in these samples, considerably advancing SV characterization compared to population-wide short-read sequencing studies 3,4 . Our analysis details diverse SV classes—deletions, duplications, insertions, and inversions—at population-scale. LINE-1 and SVA retrotransposition activities frequently mediate transductions 9,10 of unique sequences, with both mobile element classes transducing sequences at either the 3′- or 5′-end, depending on the source element locus. Furthermore, analyses of SV breakpoint junctions suggest a continuum of homology-mediated rearrangement processes are integral to SV formation, and highlight evidence for SV recurrence involving repeat sequences. Our open-access dataset underscores the transformative impact of long-read sequencing in advancing the characterisation of polymorphic genomic architectures, and provides a resource for guiding variant prioritisation in future long-read sequencing-based disease studies.
- Open Access
SVarp: pangenome-based structural variant discovery
The linear human reference genome that we use today does not represent the haplotypic diversity of the global human population. This raises bias in genomic read alignment and limits our ability to call large structural variations (SV), especially at highly polymorphic loci. Thus, many SV alleles remain unresolved. Recent efforts to transition to a graph-based reference genome resulted in the generation of the first draft human pangenome reference, but tools to call SVs relative to the pangenome reference are presently lacking. In this study, we present the SVarp algorithm, aiming to discover haplotype resolved SVs on top of a pangenome reference using long sequencing reads. SVarp outputs local assemblies of SV alleles, termed svtigs, instead of a VCF file of SV breakpoints, which we propose as a general exchange format allowing for flexible downstream analyses. In order to assess the accuracy of svtigs, we used simulated and real human genomes. Simulations allowed us to make exact breakpoint comparisons against the true callsets. We observed ~96% recall with deletions, insertions and duplications larger than 1,000bp, showing that SVarp can reliably detect genomic structural variants not yet represented in the graph. On the other hand, we compared SVarp output for ONT sequencing data at 20X coverage against independent genome assemblies of the same samples and found that ~82% of our svtig predictions are validated by the assemblies by a match with more than 85% sequence identity. SVarp was implemented using C++ and its source code is available at https://github.com/asylvz/SVarp under MIT license.
Open AccessSVarp: pangenome-based structural variant discovery
The linear human reference genome that we use today does not represent the haplotypic diversity of the global human population. This raises bias in genomic read alignment and limits our ability to call large structural variations (SV), especially at highly polymorphic loci. Thus, many SV alleles remain unresolved. Recent efforts to transition to a graph-based reference genome resulted in the generation of the first draft human pangenome reference, but tools to call SVs relative to the pangenome reference are presently lacking. In this study, we present the SVarp algorithm, aiming to discover haplotype resolved SVs on top of a pangenome reference using long sequencing reads. SVarp outputs local assemblies of SV alleles, termed svtigs, instead of a VCF file of SV breakpoints, which we propose as a general exchange format allowing for flexible downstream analyses. In order to assess the accuracy of svtigs, we used simulated and real human genomes. Simulations allowed us to make exact breakpoint comparisons against the true callsets. We observed ~96% recall with deletions, insertions and duplications larger than 1,000bp, showing that SVarp can reliably detect genomic structural variants not yet represented in the graph. On the other hand, we compared SVarp output for ONT sequencing data at 20X coverage against independent genome assemblies of the same samples and found that ~82% of our svtig predictions are validated by the assemblies by a match with more than 85% sequence identity. SVarp was implemented using C++ and its source code is available at https://github.com/asylvz/SVarp under MIT license.
- Open Access
- 7 December 2023
- Published by Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory in Genome Research
- Vol. 33 (12) , 2029-2040
Whole-genome long-read sequencing downsampling and its effect on variant-calling precision and recall
Advances in long-read sequencing (LRS) technologies continue to make whole-genome sequencing more complete, affordable, and accurate. LRS provides significant advantages over short-read sequencing approaches, including phased de novo genome assembly, access to previously excluded genomic regions, and discovery of more complex structural variants (SVs) associated with disease. Limitations remain with respect to cost, scalability, and platform-dependent read accuracy and the tradeoffs between sequence coverage and sensitivity of variant discovery are important experimental considerations for the application of LRS. We compare the genetic variant-calling precision and recall of Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) and Pacific Biosciences (PacBio) HiFi platforms over a range of sequence coverages. For read-based applications, LRS sensitivity begins to plateau around 12-fold coverage with a majority of variants called with reasonable accuracy (F1score above 0.5), and both platforms perform well for SV detection. Genome assembly increases variant-calling precision and recall of SVs and indels in HiFi data sets with HiFi outperforming ONT in quality as measured by the F1score of assembly-based variant call sets. While both technologies continue to evolve, our work offers guidance to design cost-effective experimental strategies that do not compromise on discovering novel biology.
- 7 December 2023
- Published by Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory in Genome Research
- Vol. 33 (12) , 2029-2040
Open AccessWhole-genome long-read sequencing downsampling and its effect on variant-calling precision and recall
Advances in long-read sequencing (LRS) technologies continue to make whole-genome sequencing more complete, affordable, and accurate. LRS provides significant advantages over short-read sequencing approaches, including phased de novo genome assembly, access to previously excluded genomic regions, and discovery of more complex structural variants (SVs) associated with disease. Limitations remain with respect to cost, scalability, and platform-dependent read accuracy and the tradeoffs between sequence coverage and sensitivity of variant discovery are important experimental considerations for the application of LRS. We compare the genetic variant-calling precision and recall of Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) and Pacific Biosciences (PacBio) HiFi platforms over a range of sequence coverages. For read-based applications, LRS sensitivity begins to plateau around 12-fold coverage with a majority of variants called with reasonable accuracy (F1score above 0.5), and both platforms perform well for SV detection. Genome assembly increases variant-calling precision and recall of SVs and indels in HiFi data sets with HiFi outperforming ONT in quality as measured by the F1score of assembly-based variant call sets. While both technologies continue to evolve, our work offers guidance to design cost-effective experimental strategies that do not compromise on discovering novel biology.
- Open Access
Whole-genome long-read sequencing downsampling and its effect on variant calling precision and recall
Advances in long-read sequencing (LRS) technology continue to make whole-genome sequencing more complete, affordable, and accurate. LRS provides significant advantages over short-read sequencing approaches, including phased de novo genome assembly, access to previously excluded genomic regions, and discovery of more complex structural variants (SVs) associated with disease. Limitations remain with respect to cost, scalability, and platform-dependent read accuracy and the tradeoffs between sequence coverage and sensitivity of variant discovery are important experimental considerations for the application of LRS. We compare the genetic variant calling precision and recall of Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) and PacBio HiFi platforms over a range of sequence coverages. For read-based applications, LRS sensitivity begins to plateau around 12-fold coverage with a majority of variants called with reasonable accuracy (F1 score above 0.5), and both platforms perform well for SV detection. Genome assembly increases variant calling precision and recall of SVs and indels in HiFi datasets with HiFi outperforming ONT in quality as measured by the F1 score of assembly-based variant callsets. While both technologies continue to evolve, our work offers guidance to design cost-effective experimental strategies that do not compromise on discovering novel biology.
Open AccessWhole-genome long-read sequencing downsampling and its effect on variant calling precision and recall
Advances in long-read sequencing (LRS) technology continue to make whole-genome sequencing more complete, affordable, and accurate. LRS provides significant advantages over short-read sequencing approaches, including phased de novo genome assembly, access to previously excluded genomic regions, and discovery of more complex structural variants (SVs) associated with disease. Limitations remain with respect to cost, scalability, and platform-dependent read accuracy and the tradeoffs between sequence coverage and sensitivity of variant discovery are important experimental considerations for the application of LRS. We compare the genetic variant calling precision and recall of Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) and PacBio HiFi platforms over a range of sequence coverages. For read-based applications, LRS sensitivity begins to plateau around 12-fold coverage with a majority of variants called with reasonable accuracy (F1 score above 0.5), and both platforms perform well for SV detection. Genome assembly increases variant calling precision and recall of SVs and indels in HiFi datasets with HiFi outperforming ONT in quality as measured by the F1 score of assembly-based variant callsets. While both technologies continue to evolve, our work offers guidance to design cost-effective experimental strategies that do not compromise on discovering novel biology.