Sarah K. Anderson
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Sarah K. Anderson has a total of 19 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Pinky Jain
Leeds Beckett University
2 shared publications - Andrew James Davies
Swansea University
1 shared publication Brittany D. Hagen
Mayville State University
1 shared publicationCalum M. Cooper
1 shared publication- Christopher Michael Whitsel
North Dakota State University
1 shared publication - Cristina Mio
University of Glasgow
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Assessment, Evaluation and Accountability
- p. 1-30
Evaluating instruments for assessing teaching practices in teacher preparation programmes: insights from a systematic review
The evaluation of complex professional practice raises persistent challenges concerning construct representation and the defensibility of judgements. Teacher preparation programmes (TPPs) provide a particularly consequential context in which to examine these challenges as evaluating teaching practices remains a contested and uneven process. This systematic review examined 11 evaluation instruments used in TPPs, analysing development, implementation, and trustworthiness. The review explored how teaching practices are judged and ways systemic complexity shaped the use and effectiveness of these tools. The analysis identified recurring concerns around reliability, rater preparation, construct representation, and the alignment of instruments with professional standards. Viewed through Social Judgement Theory and Complexity Theory, the findings demonstrate how instrument design structures the evidence available for judgement, while contextual and human factors continue to shape how that evidence is interpreted. The review contributes to educational evaluation scholarship by showing why reliability alone is insufficient for defensible high-stakes evaluation and highlighting the importance of construct representation, rater cognition, contextual validity, and consequences of use. Adaptive and modular approaches are proposed to balance comparability and accountability with the contextual and developmental nature of professional competence.
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Assessment, Evaluation and Accountability
- p. 1-30
Open AccessEvaluating instruments for assessing teaching practices in teacher preparation programmes: insights from a systematic review
The evaluation of complex professional practice raises persistent challenges concerning construct representation and the defensibility of judgements. Teacher preparation programmes (TPPs) provide a particularly consequential context in which to examine these challenges as evaluating teaching practices remains a contested and uneven process. This systematic review examined 11 evaluation instruments used in TPPs, analysing development, implementation, and trustworthiness. The review explored how teaching practices are judged and ways systemic complexity shaped the use and effectiveness of these tools. The analysis identified recurring concerns around reliability, rater preparation, construct representation, and the alignment of instruments with professional standards. Viewed through Social Judgement Theory and Complexity Theory, the findings demonstrate how instrument design structures the evidence available for judgement, while contextual and human factors continue to shape how that evidence is interpreted. The review contributes to educational evaluation scholarship by showing why reliability alone is insufficient for defensible high-stakes evaluation and highlighting the importance of construct representation, rater cognition, contextual validity, and consequences of use. Adaptive and modular approaches are proposed to balance comparability and accountability with the contextual and developmental nature of professional competence.
- 13 February 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 110-130
Cultivating Enduring Social Responsibility in Financial Literacy
- 13 February 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 110-130
Cultivating Enduring Social Responsibility in Financial Literacy
- Open Access
- 24 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Teacher Educator
- p. 1-41
A Comparative Analysis of Professional Teacher Standards Across the UK Home Nations of England, Scotland, and Wales
- 24 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Teacher Educator
- p. 1-41
Open AccessA Comparative Analysis of Professional Teacher Standards Across the UK Home Nations of England, Scotland, and Wales
- Open Access
- 13 February 2025
- Published by Open Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in Open Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 4 (1)
Mapping curriculum in higher education: Unveiling alignment, complexity, and ideology
In this case study the authors explore how an investigation of curricular sources, curriculum mapping and foundational curriculum ideologies provided insights into teaching and learning and continuous improvement efforts in a university-based teacher education programme. The study is based on three reflective activities: identification of context-specific priorities, comparison with international practices as an external benchmark, and utilization of Schiro’s (2013) curriculum ideology inventory as an analytic tool. By investigating the planned, taught, and learned curricula, the study identifies gaps, redundancies, and areas for enhancement. Results from curriculum mapping and the adapted curriculum ideologies inventory underscore the complexity of aligning professional standards, accreditation requirements, and institutional visions. The reflective process fostered transparency, collaboration, and deeper understanding of ideological influences on curriculum design. Insights gained extend to higher education contexts, suggesting that curriculum mapping, coupled with ideological exploration, is a valuable tool for quality assurance and continuous improvement. The findings advocate for integrating student voices and fostering cross-disciplinary collaboration in curriculum development. The processes, results, and adapted ideologies inventory are shared for consideration and use for educators in higher education.
- 13 February 2025
- Published by Open Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in Open Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 4 (1)
Open AccessMapping curriculum in higher education: Unveiling alignment, complexity, and ideology
In this case study the authors explore how an investigation of curricular sources, curriculum mapping and foundational curriculum ideologies provided insights into teaching and learning and continuous improvement efforts in a university-based teacher education programme. The study is based on three reflective activities: identification of context-specific priorities, comparison with international practices as an external benchmark, and utilization of Schiro’s (2013) curriculum ideology inventory as an analytic tool. By investigating the planned, taught, and learned curricula, the study identifies gaps, redundancies, and areas for enhancement. Results from curriculum mapping and the adapted curriculum ideologies inventory underscore the complexity of aligning professional standards, accreditation requirements, and institutional visions. The reflective process fostered transparency, collaboration, and deeper understanding of ideological influences on curriculum design. Insights gained extend to higher education contexts, suggesting that curriculum mapping, coupled with ideological exploration, is a valuable tool for quality assurance and continuous improvement. The findings advocate for integrating student voices and fostering cross-disciplinary collaboration in curriculum development. The processes, results, and adapted ideologies inventory are shared for consideration and use for educators in higher education.
- Open Access
- 7 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in PROSPECTS
- Vol. 54 (3-4) , 607-626
Visions of peace: Exploring how Scottish youth understand and define peace
In this article, we report on a study that explored how young people in Scotland understand and define peace. A total of 59 young people aged 12–18, from three schools (independent, state Roman Catholic, and state non-denominational) participated in this study. The young people were asked to participate in a peace data walk and, after that, to draw or paint pictures of what peace means for them in their local community and beyond. We utilize a combination of Personal Meaning Mapping, visual content analytic procedures, and visual art coding scheme to analyse the pictures. We drew on Critical Peace Education as an overarching framework to approach data collection and on the Peace Education Curricular Analysis framework to examine the presence of positive peace elements in youth drawings/paintings. Previous research in different contexts suggests that youth find it difficult to conceptualize peace, whereas it appears to be easy to explain war and negative peace (i.e., absence of war). Previous research conducted in Scotland showed that the curriculum focused on the element of wellbeing, with many other positive peace elements being either absent or not well represented. By contrast, youth in our study showed a strong understanding of positive peace, with a particular emphasis on the following facets: peace zone, eco mind, wellbeing, peace bond, and social justice. In our conclusion, we discuss these findings in relation to Scottish education policies and ways of capitalizing on this method of engagement and overall findings to support youth learning about peace.
- 7 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in PROSPECTS
- Vol. 54 (3-4) , 607-626
Open AccessVisions of peace: Exploring how Scottish youth understand and define peace
In this article, we report on a study that explored how young people in Scotland understand and define peace. A total of 59 young people aged 12–18, from three schools (independent, state Roman Catholic, and state non-denominational) participated in this study. The young people were asked to participate in a peace data walk and, after that, to draw or paint pictures of what peace means for them in their local community and beyond. We utilize a combination of Personal Meaning Mapping, visual content analytic procedures, and visual art coding scheme to analyse the pictures. We drew on Critical Peace Education as an overarching framework to approach data collection and on the Peace Education Curricular Analysis framework to examine the presence of positive peace elements in youth drawings/paintings. Previous research in different contexts suggests that youth find it difficult to conceptualize peace, whereas it appears to be easy to explain war and negative peace (i.e., absence of war). Previous research conducted in Scotland showed that the curriculum focused on the element of wellbeing, with many other positive peace elements being either absent or not well represented. By contrast, youth in our study showed a strong understanding of positive peace, with a particular emphasis on the following facets: peace zone, eco mind, wellbeing, peace bond, and social justice. In our conclusion, we discuss these findings in relation to Scottish education policies and ways of capitalizing on this method of engagement and overall findings to support youth learning about peace.
- Open Access
- 16 July 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in British Journal of Educational Studies
- Vol. 72 (5) , 553-585
Judging Student Teacher Effectiveness: A Systematic Review of Literature
- 16 July 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in British Journal of Educational Studies
- Vol. 72 (5) , 553-585
Open AccessJudging Student Teacher Effectiveness: A Systematic Review of Literature
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
- Vol. 23
Engaging Young People in Peace Education Research: Using an Arts Based Approach to Gain Congruence through Democratic Methods
Qualitative research has increasingly been utilising visual methods such as drawing to collect richer insights from participants of all ages and backgrounds. This article demonstrates the methodological potential of a structured arts based workshop that included a data walk, a drawing session, and a reflective peace wall. We reflect on the suitability and value of this approach to support young people’s learning about peace, to collect insights on what peace means to them, and how they envision their contribution to a peaceful world. This project was done with 12–18-year-old students in three schools in Glasgow, Scotland. We found that a structured approach allowed students to understand and express what positive peace means and to see themselves as agents of change. Three key methodological insights are offered: ways the approach addresses a crisis of praxis in peace education research, how research methods can gain congruence with democratic concepts in of peace education, and normative validity established through the voice of young people. This article contributes to the literature on arts based and creative methodologies and offers a novel model of peace education research inclusive of multiple ways of knowing and more democratic methods.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
- Vol. 23
Open AccessEngaging Young People in Peace Education Research: Using an Arts Based Approach to Gain Congruence through Democratic Methods
Qualitative research has increasingly been utilising visual methods such as drawing to collect richer insights from participants of all ages and backgrounds. This article demonstrates the methodological potential of a structured arts based workshop that included a data walk, a drawing session, and a reflective peace wall. We reflect on the suitability and value of this approach to support young people’s learning about peace, to collect insights on what peace means to them, and how they envision their contribution to a peaceful world. This project was done with 12–18-year-old students in three schools in Glasgow, Scotland. We found that a structured approach allowed students to understand and express what positive peace means and to see themselves as agents of change. Three key methodological insights are offered: ways the approach addresses a crisis of praxis in peace education research, how research methods can gain congruence with democratic concepts in of peace education, and normative validity established through the voice of young people. This article contributes to the literature on arts based and creative methodologies and offers a novel model of peace education research inclusive of multiple ways of knowing and more democratic methods.
- Open Access
- 10 July 2023
- Published by Open Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in Open Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 2 (3)
A post-critical pedagogy for sustainability: Engaging the head, heart, and hands
To realise the entitlement to Learning for Sustainability (LfS), the authors advocate for a post-critical orientation in university-based teacher education of the ‘head, heart, and hands’ model of transformative learning as an organising principle. Integration of intellect, emotion, and body as the activation triad can encourage students and teachers towards transformative engagement. Educational policies of the Scottish government, the influence on teaching practices, and benefits to student learning experiences are explored through the context of COP26 and teacher education in Scotland. Implications are proposed to inspire change in higher education for educating for a sustainable future.
- 10 July 2023
- Published by Open Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in Open Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 2 (3)
Open AccessA post-critical pedagogy for sustainability: Engaging the head, heart, and hands
To realise the entitlement to Learning for Sustainability (LfS), the authors advocate for a post-critical orientation in university-based teacher education of the ‘head, heart, and hands’ model of transformative learning as an organising principle. Integration of intellect, emotion, and body as the activation triad can encourage students and teachers towards transformative engagement. Educational policies of the Scottish government, the influence on teaching practices, and benefits to student learning experiences are explored through the context of COP26 and teacher education in Scotland. Implications are proposed to inspire change in higher education for educating for a sustainable future.
- Open Access
- 6 November 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in American Journal of Distance Education
- Vol. 38 (1) , 3-23
The Student Voice: Recommendations for Supporting the Success of Graduate Students with Disabilities in Online Courses
This article offers recommendations for online graduate students, instructors, and universities to better meet the needs of students with disabilities who increasingly participate in online courses. Using semi-structured interviews, researchers asked what recommendations participants from respective disability categories have for supporting them in their pursuit of a graduate education in an online environment. Thirteen graduate participants represented five disability classifications including learning disabilities, attention deficit disorder/attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, psychological disorders, chronic health impairments, or visual impairments. Interview transcripts were analyzed to identify disability-specific recommendations through constant comparison of individual data sets. Recommendations for students, instructors, and universities focused on instructor-student communication and relationships, online course design, and a changing and active role of institutional support services. The collaborative efforts of all are emphasized.
- 6 November 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in American Journal of Distance Education
- Vol. 38 (1) , 3-23
Open AccessThe Student Voice: Recommendations for Supporting the Success of Graduate Students with Disabilities in Online Courses
This article offers recommendations for online graduate students, instructors, and universities to better meet the needs of students with disabilities who increasingly participate in online courses. Using semi-structured interviews, researchers asked what recommendations participants from respective disability categories have for supporting them in their pursuit of a graduate education in an online environment. Thirteen graduate participants represented five disability classifications including learning disabilities, attention deficit disorder/attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, psychological disorders, chronic health impairments, or visual impairments. Interview transcripts were analyzed to identify disability-specific recommendations through constant comparison of individual data sets. Recommendations for students, instructors, and universities focused on instructor-student communication and relationships, online course design, and a changing and active role of institutional support services. The collaborative efforts of all are emphasized.
- Open Access
- 6 November 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Action in Teacher Education
- Vol. 43 (2) , 195-213
Multiple Measures of Student Learning: A Case Study Examination of Completer Impact
Evaluating the impact of new teachers on student learning is a requirement for accredited teacher preparation programs. This article shares findings from a mixed methods, multiple case study investigating P-12 student learning in the classrooms of six graduates two-three years after completing a teacher preparation program. Data collection included student engagement surveys, de-identified student growth percentile scores, teacher selected pre-post assessment data, and structured phone interviews with each graduate. Results indicated a majority of students from participants’ classrooms demonstrated learning growth, and participants viewed their teaching as effective. Implications for programs include pre-service opportunities to identify and respond to authentic student engagement and opportunities to build collective teacher efficacy. Additional insights describe pre-service teacher training to measure student progress and measure impact based on classroom assessments. The investigation provides a replicable case study design for teacher educators to examine relationships between teacher preparation, program graduates, and P-12 student outcomes.
- 6 November 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Action in Teacher Education
- Vol. 43 (2) , 195-213
Open AccessMultiple Measures of Student Learning: A Case Study Examination of Completer Impact
Evaluating the impact of new teachers on student learning is a requirement for accredited teacher preparation programs. This article shares findings from a mixed methods, multiple case study investigating P-12 student learning in the classrooms of six graduates two-three years after completing a teacher preparation program. Data collection included student engagement surveys, de-identified student growth percentile scores, teacher selected pre-post assessment data, and structured phone interviews with each graduate. Results indicated a majority of students from participants’ classrooms demonstrated learning growth, and participants viewed their teaching as effective. Implications for programs include pre-service opportunities to identify and respond to authentic student engagement and opportunities to build collective teacher efficacy. Additional insights describe pre-service teacher training to measure student progress and measure impact based on classroom assessments. The investigation provides a replicable case study design for teacher educators to examine relationships between teacher preparation, program graduates, and P-12 student outcomes.