Hong-Zhi Liu
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Hong-Zhi Liu has a total of 35 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Zi-Han Wei
Tianjin Normal University
5 shared publications Qiu-Yue Li
Nankai University
3 shared publications- Xiaokang Lyu
Nankai Univ, Sch Sociol, Dept Social Psychol, Tianjin 300350, Peoples R China
2 shared publications - Xiaozhuang Wang
Tianjin Normal University
2 shared publications Yan Liang
Department of Social Psychology, School of Sociology Nankai University Tianjin China
2 shared publicationsYan-Bang Zhou
Institute of Teacher Education, Ningxia University, Yinchuan, China
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 15 June 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Pacific Rim Psychology
- Vol. 20
Choose for Others More Randomly: Psychological Distancing and Response Randomness in Intertemporal Choice
Intertemporal choices involve decisions that balance trade-offs occurring at different points in time. Previous research on self–other differences in intertemporal choice, often interpreted through a psychological-distance framework, has produced mixed findings. The authors propose that part of this heterogeneity reflects systematic changes in response randomness under greater psychological distance, which can alter observed choice proportions and recovered discounting indices even when underlying time preferences are not systematically shifted. To test this response-randomness hypothesis, they conducted a pre-registered within-subject eye-tracking experiment ( N = 100), in which the participants completed the same set of monetary intertemporal choices for themselves and for an anonymous stranger. Behaviorally, the participants chose a higher proportion of the larger-later options when deciding for the anonymous stranger than when deciding for themselves. However, multiple analyses converged on increased response randomness when deciding for the anonymous stranger. The authors examined the intertemporal preferences using a standard hyperbolic discounting model and quantified choice errors as deviations from the model-predicted responses. In addition, they applied a hierarchical Bayesian implementation of dynamic decision field theory to estimate a decision threshold parameter indexing response randomness, and examined whether this parameter statistically mediated the self–other difference in choice proportions. Across the measures, the choices for others were consistently noisier. The participants produced more choice errors, and the decision threshold was lower when choosing for the anonymous stranger, indicating reduced response consistency. The differences in response randomness were strongly associated with differences in time preference across roles and mediated the effect of role on the proportion of larger-later choices. The eye-tracking results further showed reduced engagement and less systematic information search for others, indexed by shorter total dwell time, reduced information inspection, and lower systematicity of the search. Trial-level mediation further suggested that reduced information acquisition and less systematic search partially contributed to choice differences across conditions. Together, these findings indicate that socially distanced intertemporal choices are accompanied by noisier responding and altered information processing, helping to clarify why self–other patterns in the literature can appear inconsistent across tasks and analytic approaches.
- 15 June 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Pacific Rim Psychology
- Vol. 20
Open AccessChoose for Others More Randomly: Psychological Distancing and Response Randomness in Intertemporal Choice
Intertemporal choices involve decisions that balance trade-offs occurring at different points in time. Previous research on self–other differences in intertemporal choice, often interpreted through a psychological-distance framework, has produced mixed findings. The authors propose that part of this heterogeneity reflects systematic changes in response randomness under greater psychological distance, which can alter observed choice proportions and recovered discounting indices even when underlying time preferences are not systematically shifted. To test this response-randomness hypothesis, they conducted a pre-registered within-subject eye-tracking experiment ( N = 100), in which the participants completed the same set of monetary intertemporal choices for themselves and for an anonymous stranger. Behaviorally, the participants chose a higher proportion of the larger-later options when deciding for the anonymous stranger than when deciding for themselves. However, multiple analyses converged on increased response randomness when deciding for the anonymous stranger. The authors examined the intertemporal preferences using a standard hyperbolic discounting model and quantified choice errors as deviations from the model-predicted responses. In addition, they applied a hierarchical Bayesian implementation of dynamic decision field theory to estimate a decision threshold parameter indexing response randomness, and examined whether this parameter statistically mediated the self–other difference in choice proportions. Across the measures, the choices for others were consistently noisier. The participants produced more choice errors, and the decision threshold was lower when choosing for the anonymous stranger, indicating reduced response consistency. The differences in response randomness were strongly associated with differences in time preference across roles and mediated the effect of role on the proportion of larger-later choices. The eye-tracking results further showed reduced engagement and less systematic information search for others, indexed by shorter total dwell time, reduced information inspection, and lower systematicity of the search. Trial-level mediation further suggested that reduced information acquisition and less systematic search partially contributed to choice differences across conditions. Together, these findings indicate that socially distanced intertemporal choices are accompanied by noisier responding and altered information processing, helping to clarify why self–other patterns in the literature can appear inconsistent across tasks and analytic approaches.
- 24 February 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 39 (2)
The Effects of “Time” and “Probability” Formats on Risk Perception and Decision‐Making About Long‐Term Hazards
For long‐term hazards, the likelihood of a hazardous event can be communicated in the format of the probability of occurrence per unit time (probability‐based, e.g., a flood with a 1% chance of occurring annually) or the average time of risk occurrence (time‐based, e.g., a 100‐year flood). This study investigates how the two presentation formats influence risk perception and related behavior in long‐term hazard scenarios, such as typhoons, healthcare, high‐risk occupations, and investments, and further examines the moderating role of probability magnitude. First, we demonstrated that at an extremely low probability level, time‐based formats reduced perceived risk and protective tendency compared to probability‐based formats (Studies 1 and 2). However, as probability increased to a moderately low level, this effect diminished and then reversed, such that time‐based formats increased risk perception and protective tendency compared to probability‐based formats (Study 2). The difference between the two formats diminished again when probabilities reached the moderate‐to‐high range and moved toward 50% (Studies 1 and 2). Second, we revealed that presentation formats also influenced perceived risk differences between options (Study 3) and altered individuals' risk preference between options (Studies 3, 4a, and 4b), with these effects also moderated by probability magnitude. For lower probability events, time‐based formats amplified perceived risk differences between options, promoting preferences for options with lower loss‐probabilities, whereas for higher probability events, this effect weakened and eventually reversed. The findings contribute to related theory by identifying probability magnitude as a key boundary condition under which time‐based and probability‐based formats have different influences on risk perception and behavior. Practically, the results offer implications for risk communication in long‐term hazard contexts, indicating how to choose between time‐based and probability‐based formats according to the size of the probability and the intended persuasive purpose.
- 24 February 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 39 (2)
The Effects of “Time” and “Probability” Formats on Risk Perception and Decision‐Making About Long‐Term Hazards
For long‐term hazards, the likelihood of a hazardous event can be communicated in the format of the probability of occurrence per unit time (probability‐based, e.g., a flood with a 1% chance of occurring annually) or the average time of risk occurrence (time‐based, e.g., a 100‐year flood). This study investigates how the two presentation formats influence risk perception and related behavior in long‐term hazard scenarios, such as typhoons, healthcare, high‐risk occupations, and investments, and further examines the moderating role of probability magnitude. First, we demonstrated that at an extremely low probability level, time‐based formats reduced perceived risk and protective tendency compared to probability‐based formats (Studies 1 and 2). However, as probability increased to a moderately low level, this effect diminished and then reversed, such that time‐based formats increased risk perception and protective tendency compared to probability‐based formats (Study 2). The difference between the two formats diminished again when probabilities reached the moderate‐to‐high range and moved toward 50% (Studies 1 and 2). Second, we revealed that presentation formats also influenced perceived risk differences between options (Study 3) and altered individuals' risk preference between options (Studies 3, 4a, and 4b), with these effects also moderated by probability magnitude. For lower probability events, time‐based formats amplified perceived risk differences between options, promoting preferences for options with lower loss‐probabilities, whereas for higher probability events, this effect weakened and eventually reversed. The findings contribute to related theory by identifying probability magnitude as a key boundary condition under which time‐based and probability‐based formats have different influences on risk perception and behavior. Practically, the results offer implications for risk communication in long‐term hazard contexts, indicating how to choose between time‐based and probability‐based formats according to the size of the probability and the intended persuasive purpose.
- 19 December 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Cognitive Psychology
- Vol. 37 (3) , 267-276
Dual system in the ultimatum game: evidence from the process dissociation procedure
- 19 December 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Cognitive Psychology
- Vol. 37 (3) , 267-276
Dual system in the ultimatum game: evidence from the process dissociation procedure
- Open Access
- 11 October 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 15, 1451674
Time pressure effects on decision-making in intertemporal loss scenarios: an eye-tracking study
This study utilized eye-tracking techniques to investigate decision-making behavior in intertemporal loss scenarios under both time pressure and no time pressure conditions. Results revealed shorter decision-making times and decreased large later (LL) option selection frequency under time pressure. Participants under time pressure exhibited reduced Mean Fixation Duration (MFD) and Search Measure (SM) values, indicating altered information processing. Mediation analyses confirmed that task choice outcomes were influenced by SM and MFD, suggesting a shift towards heuristic decision-making under time pressure.
- 11 October 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 15, 1451674
Open AccessTime pressure effects on decision-making in intertemporal loss scenarios: an eye-tracking study
This study utilized eye-tracking techniques to investigate decision-making behavior in intertemporal loss scenarios under both time pressure and no time pressure conditions. Results revealed shorter decision-making times and decreased large later (LL) option selection frequency under time pressure. Participants under time pressure exhibited reduced Mean Fixation Duration (MFD) and Search Measure (SM) values, indicating altered information processing. Mediation analyses confirmed that task choice outcomes were influenced by SM and MFD, suggesting a shift towards heuristic decision-making under time pressure.
- 23 August 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 36 (5)
Information search processing affects social decisions
Social decisions often require individuals to balance conflicts between their own selfish interests and the need for equality. The way information about available options is presented can have an impact on how people process information and make social decisions. In this study, we examined the effect of information presentation on social decisions in a mini‐dictator game, where participants must make binary choices about how to allocate money between themselves and another participant. We conducted two tasks with different presentation styles: the attribute‐based task, where attributes such as own payoffs or others' payoffs were displayed sequentially, and the alternative‐based task, where alternatives were displayed sequentially. We found that participants in the attribute‐based task made more selfish choices and were less sensitive to equality than those in the alternative‐based task. The direction of information search and the complexity level of information processing played a mediating role in the effect of task on social decisions. Our findings highlight the relationship between information search and social decisions, shedding light on the mechanisms and processes that underlie social decision‐making.
- 23 August 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 36 (5)
Information search processing affects social decisions
Social decisions often require individuals to balance conflicts between their own selfish interests and the need for equality. The way information about available options is presented can have an impact on how people process information and make social decisions. In this study, we examined the effect of information presentation on social decisions in a mini‐dictator game, where participants must make binary choices about how to allocate money between themselves and another participant. We conducted two tasks with different presentation styles: the attribute‐based task, where attributes such as own payoffs or others' payoffs were displayed sequentially, and the alternative‐based task, where alternatives were displayed sequentially. We found that participants in the attribute‐based task made more selfish choices and were less sensitive to equality than those in the alternative‐based task. The direction of information search and the complexity level of information processing played a mediating role in the effect of task on social decisions. Our findings highlight the relationship between information search and social decisions, shedding light on the mechanisms and processes that underlie social decision‐making.
- Open Access
- 4 August 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Judgment and Decision Making
- Vol. 18, e26
Probability or time: Effect of presentation format on continuous risky decisions
Continuous risky decisions refer to decisions that involve trade-offs among options with persistent risks. People can use the probability of occurrence per unit time (e.g., ‘the probability of occurrence is 1% per month’) or the average time of risk occurrence (e.g., ‘the average occurrence time is 100 months’) to represent continuous risky options. In this study, we examined the effect of the presentation format (i.e., the probability of occurrence per unit time vs. the average time of risk occurrence) on continuous risky decisions in the gain domain and further explored the underlying mechanism. In Study 1 (N = 122), we demonstrated the effect of presentation format on continuous risky decisions and the moderating effect of the magnitude of probabilities. Specifically, when the probabilities were relatively low, compared with the probability of occurrence per unit time, using the average time of risk occurrence to present the continuous risky options led to more risk-averse decisions. However, when the probabilities were relatively high, compared with the probability of occurrence per unit time, the presentation format of the average time occurrence led to more risk-seeking decisions. In Study 2 (N = 136), we found that the moderating effect of the option probabilities on continuous risky decisions was mediated by the subjective attribute-wise difference judgment. In Study 3 (N = 221), we replicated the effect of presentation format on continuous risky decisions in more natural scenarios. The study offered a deep understanding of the mechanism of continuous risky decision-making, and the results were conducive to further developing theories in relevant fields.
- 4 August 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Judgment and Decision Making
- Vol. 18, e26
Open AccessProbability or time: Effect of presentation format on continuous risky decisions
Continuous risky decisions refer to decisions that involve trade-offs among options with persistent risks. People can use the probability of occurrence per unit time (e.g., ‘the probability of occurrence is 1% per month’) or the average time of risk occurrence (e.g., ‘the average occurrence time is 100 months’) to represent continuous risky options. In this study, we examined the effect of the presentation format (i.e., the probability of occurrence per unit time vs. the average time of risk occurrence) on continuous risky decisions in the gain domain and further explored the underlying mechanism. In Study 1 (N = 122), we demonstrated the effect of presentation format on continuous risky decisions and the moderating effect of the magnitude of probabilities. Specifically, when the probabilities were relatively low, compared with the probability of occurrence per unit time, using the average time of risk occurrence to present the continuous risky options led to more risk-averse decisions. However, when the probabilities were relatively high, compared with the probability of occurrence per unit time, the presentation format of the average time occurrence led to more risk-seeking decisions. In Study 2 (N = 136), we found that the moderating effect of the option probabilities on continuous risky decisions was mediated by the subjective attribute-wise difference judgment. In Study 3 (N = 221), we replicated the effect of presentation format on continuous risky decisions in more natural scenarios. The study offered a deep understanding of the mechanism of continuous risky decision-making, and the results were conducive to further developing theories in relevant fields.
- Open Access
- 3 November 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 13, 989511
The effect of incentives on intertemporal choice: Choice, confidence, and eye movements
Despite various studies examining intertemporal choice with hypothetical rewards due to problematic real reward delivery, there remains no substantial evidence on the effect of the incentives on the decision confidence and cognitive process in intertemporal choice and no comprehensive exploration on the loss domain. Hence, this study conducts an eye-tracking experiment to examine the effect of incentive approach and measure participants' decision confidence using a between-subject design in both gain and loss domains. Results replicated previous findings which show incentives do not affect intertemporal choice in the gain domain. In contrast, in the loss domain, participants in the incentivized group were more likely to choose the larger-later options than those in the non-incentivized group. Furthermore, the decision confidence and the mean fixation duration differed between the incentivized and non-incentivized groups in both gain and loss domains. These findings allow for a better understanding of the effect of incentives on intertemporal choice and provide valuable information for the design of incentives in future intertemporal experiments.
- 3 November 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 13, 989511
Open AccessThe effect of incentives on intertemporal choice: Choice, confidence, and eye movements
Despite various studies examining intertemporal choice with hypothetical rewards due to problematic real reward delivery, there remains no substantial evidence on the effect of the incentives on the decision confidence and cognitive process in intertemporal choice and no comprehensive exploration on the loss domain. Hence, this study conducts an eye-tracking experiment to examine the effect of incentive approach and measure participants' decision confidence using a between-subject design in both gain and loss domains. Results replicated previous findings which show incentives do not affect intertemporal choice in the gain domain. In contrast, in the loss domain, participants in the incentivized group were more likely to choose the larger-later options than those in the non-incentivized group. Furthermore, the decision confidence and the mean fixation duration differed between the incentivized and non-incentivized groups in both gain and loss domains. These findings allow for a better understanding of the effect of incentives on intertemporal choice and provide valuable information for the design of incentives in future intertemporal experiments.
- Open Access
- 27 September 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 13, 937366
Cognitive process underlying ultimatum game: An eye-tracking study from a dual-system perspective
According to the dual-system theories, the decisions in an ultimatum game (UG) are governed by the automatic System 1 and the controlled System 2. The former drives the preference for fairness, whereas the latter drives the self-interest motive. However, the association between the contributions of the two systems in UG and the cognitive process needs more direct evidence. In the present study, we used the process dissociation procedure to estimate the contributions of the two systems and recorded participants eye movements to examine the cognitive processes underlying UG decisions. Results showed that the estimated contributions of the two systems are uncorrelated and that they demonstrate a dissociated pattern of associations with third variables, such as reaction time (RT) and mean fixation duration (MFD). Furthermore, the relative time advantage (RTA) and the transitions between the two payoffs can predict the final UG decisions. Our findings provide evidence for the independent contributions of preference for fairness (System 1) and self-interest maximizing (System 2) inclinations to UG and shed light on the underlying processes.
- 27 September 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 13, 937366
Open AccessCognitive process underlying ultimatum game: An eye-tracking study from a dual-system perspective
According to the dual-system theories, the decisions in an ultimatum game (UG) are governed by the automatic System 1 and the controlled System 2. The former drives the preference for fairness, whereas the latter drives the self-interest motive. However, the association between the contributions of the two systems in UG and the cognitive process needs more direct evidence. In the present study, we used the process dissociation procedure to estimate the contributions of the two systems and recorded participants eye movements to examine the cognitive processes underlying UG decisions. Results showed that the estimated contributions of the two systems are uncorrelated and that they demonstrate a dissociated pattern of associations with third variables, such as reaction time (RT) and mean fixation duration (MFD). Furthermore, the relative time advantage (RTA) and the transitions between the two payoffs can predict the final UG decisions. Our findings provide evidence for the independent contributions of preference for fairness (System 1) and self-interest maximizing (System 2) inclinations to UG and shed light on the underlying processes.
- Open Access
- 14 April 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 13, 865598
Evaluation Scale or Output Format: The Attentional Mechanism Underpinning Time Preference Reversal
Time preference reversals refers to systematic inconsistencies between preferences and valuations in intertemporal choice. When faced with a pair of intertemporal options, people preferred the smaller-sooner option but assign a higher price to the larger-later one. Different hypotheses postulate that the differences in evaluation scale or output format between the choice and the bid tasks cause the preference reversal. However, these hypotheses have not been distinguished. In the present study, we conducted a hybrid task, which shares the same evaluation scale with the bid task and shares the same output format with the choice task. By comparing these three tasks, we can figure out the key reason for time preference reversal. The eye-tracking measures reflecting attention allocation, cognitive effort and information search pattern were examined. Results showed that participants' time preference and eye-tracking measures in the hybrid task were similar to those in the choice task, but different from those in the bid task. Our findings suggest that the output format is the core reason for time preference reversal and may deepen our understanding of the mechanisms that underlie time preference reversal.
- 14 April 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 13, 865598
Open AccessEvaluation Scale or Output Format: The Attentional Mechanism Underpinning Time Preference Reversal
Time preference reversals refers to systematic inconsistencies between preferences and valuations in intertemporal choice. When faced with a pair of intertemporal options, people preferred the smaller-sooner option but assign a higher price to the larger-later one. Different hypotheses postulate that the differences in evaluation scale or output format between the choice and the bid tasks cause the preference reversal. However, these hypotheses have not been distinguished. In the present study, we conducted a hybrid task, which shares the same evaluation scale with the bid task and shares the same output format with the choice task. By comparing these three tasks, we can figure out the key reason for time preference reversal. The eye-tracking measures reflecting attention allocation, cognitive effort and information search pattern were examined. Results showed that participants' time preference and eye-tracking measures in the hybrid task were similar to those in the choice task, but different from those in the bid task. Our findings suggest that the output format is the core reason for time preference reversal and may deepen our understanding of the mechanisms that underlie time preference reversal.
- 10 October 2021
- Published by Wiley in Asian Journal of Social Psychology
- Vol. 25 (3) , 464-475
Group punishment does not always discount: Cultural difference in punishment of individuals and groups
- 10 October 2021
- Published by Wiley in Asian Journal of Social Psychology
- Vol. 25 (3) , 464-475
Group punishment does not always discount: Cultural difference in punishment of individuals and groups