Thijs van Dooremalen
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Thijs van Dooremalen has a total of 11 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Jan Willem Duyvendak
University of Amsterdam and the Netherlands Institute for Advanced Study in the Humanities and Social Sciences, the Netherlands
2 shared publicationsOlaf Knoester
Independent Researcher
2 shared publicationsAnne Lachance
École des hautes études publiques, Université de Moncton, Canada
1 shared publicationInga Gaižauskaitė
Institute of Sociology at the Lithuanian Centre for Social Sciences, Lithuania
1 shared publication- Jonathan Jan Benjamin Mijs
Department of Sociology, Boston University, MA, USA
1 shared publication Justus Uitermark
University of Amsterdam, the Netherlands
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 24 April 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
British Heatwave Discourse (1985 – 2023): From Ice Cream to Armageddon?
How has public discourse about climate change evolved? This paper answers this question through the paradigmatic case of British heatwaves. These are traditionally considered a fortunate break from dull weather, making them a least likely case for the emergency of a discourse of doom. With a topic-modeling analysis of British national newspaper articles on heatwaves from 1985 until 2023 (N = 35,127), we show that a longstanding Romantic heatwave discourse eventually buckled, and that Apocalypticism finally became the dominant genre in the last decade. A supplementary hermeneutic analysis then indicates and explains complexity within this broad trend. 1980s stories already noted routine heatwave problems, while many recent ones continue depicting positive lifestyle implications. Within the Apocalyptic genre itself climate change is today deemed a factual causal force, whereas in the 1980s and 1990s it was a possible carrier of future dangers. In connecting the genre perspective from literature theory to to the big data method topic modelling, our approach is parsimonious, novel and replicable in other national contexts.
- 24 April 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessBritish Heatwave Discourse (1985 – 2023): From Ice Cream to Armageddon?
How has public discourse about climate change evolved? This paper answers this question through the paradigmatic case of British heatwaves. These are traditionally considered a fortunate break from dull weather, making them a least likely case for the emergency of a discourse of doom. With a topic-modeling analysis of British national newspaper articles on heatwaves from 1985 until 2023 (N = 35,127), we show that a longstanding Romantic heatwave discourse eventually buckled, and that Apocalypticism finally became the dominant genre in the last decade. A supplementary hermeneutic analysis then indicates and explains complexity within this broad trend. 1980s stories already noted routine heatwave problems, while many recent ones continue depicting positive lifestyle implications. Within the Apocalyptic genre itself climate change is today deemed a factual causal force, whereas in the 1980s and 1990s it was a possible carrier of future dangers. In connecting the genre perspective from literature theory to to the big data method topic modelling, our approach is parsimonious, novel and replicable in other national contexts.
- Open Access
- 22 April 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Sociology
- Vol. 12 (1) , 92-106
British heatwave discourse (1985–2023): from ice cream to armageddon?
- 22 April 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Sociology
- Vol. 12 (1) , 92-106
Open AccessBritish heatwave discourse (1985–2023): from ice cream to armageddon?
- Open Access
- 22 August 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Sociology
- Vol. 40 (1) , 58-81
Linking crises: Connections between climate change and COVID-19 during American, Canadian, Dutch, and Lithuanian national elections (2020-2021)
Crisis responses are created in reference to the meanings of other crises. We develop the notion of ‘linking crises’ to capture this phenomenon and apply it to two contemporary global crises: climate change and COVID-19. Concretely, we study four crisis linkage dimensions in American, Canadian, Dutch, and Lithuanian party manifestos for national elections from the pandemic heydays (2020–2021): (1) how often links were drawn; (2) the issues they were related to; (3) the argumentative strategies for making connections; and (4) and the political level on which this occurred. We find many cross-national similarities. For instance, in every country links with economic and environmental issues were very present, an argumentative trope of ‘building back better’ was employed by various political parties, and the majority of the connections were made at supra-national levels. These findings bring up the question of when cross-national parity in crisis responses does (not) occur.
- 22 August 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Sociology
- Vol. 40 (1) , 58-81
Open AccessLinking crises: Connections between climate change and COVID-19 during American, Canadian, Dutch, and Lithuanian national elections (2020-2021)
Crisis responses are created in reference to the meanings of other crises. We develop the notion of ‘linking crises’ to capture this phenomenon and apply it to two contemporary global crises: climate change and COVID-19. Concretely, we study four crisis linkage dimensions in American, Canadian, Dutch, and Lithuanian party manifestos for national elections from the pandemic heydays (2020–2021): (1) how often links were drawn; (2) the issues they were related to; (3) the argumentative strategies for making connections; and (4) and the political level on which this occurred. We find many cross-national similarities. For instance, in every country links with economic and environmental issues were very present, an argumentative trope of ‘building back better’ was employed by various political parties, and the majority of the connections were made at supra-national levels. These findings bring up the question of when cross-national parity in crisis responses does (not) occur.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism
- Vol. 26 (1) , 108-127
To foreignize or to domesticate? How media vary cross-nationally in their degrees of incorporating foreign events
While the domestication literature indicates how national media link foreign events to a country’s domestic affairs, it has thus far only examined modes of domestication - the ways through which these links are created. In this article, we introduce a different dimension of the phenomenon: degrees of domestication. This includes the extents to which a foreign event gets connected with the domestic. By making a topic-modeling analysis of French and Dutch newspaper articles about 9/11, the 2004 tsunami in Southeast Asia, the Arab Spring and Donald Trump’s political rise, we provide an explorative case study of this dimension. We inductively arrive at a scale ranging from no to extreme domestication of the event, classified according to four degrees of domestication: (1) an entirely foreign affair; (2) a foreign political affair involving domestic actors; (3) a domestic political affair; (4) or a personal disruption. French newspapers score higher on the second degree, the Dutch ones on the third and fourth. A deepening of this pattern shows how these differences stem from two distinctive cultural repertoires that journalists and other media participants employ when relating to foreign events: a French one, which sees them as an opportunity to dominate the international political stage, and a Dutch one, which considers them a reason for reflecting on domestic or personal matters. These clear differences indicate the concept’s importance for the literature and for investigating it within other national media contexts.
- 1 February 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism
- Vol. 26 (1) , 108-127
Open AccessTo foreignize or to domesticate? How media vary cross-nationally in their degrees of incorporating foreign events
While the domestication literature indicates how national media link foreign events to a country’s domestic affairs, it has thus far only examined modes of domestication - the ways through which these links are created. In this article, we introduce a different dimension of the phenomenon: degrees of domestication. This includes the extents to which a foreign event gets connected with the domestic. By making a topic-modeling analysis of French and Dutch newspaper articles about 9/11, the 2004 tsunami in Southeast Asia, the Arab Spring and Donald Trump’s political rise, we provide an explorative case study of this dimension. We inductively arrive at a scale ranging from no to extreme domestication of the event, classified according to four degrees of domestication: (1) an entirely foreign affair; (2) a foreign political affair involving domestic actors; (3) a domestic political affair; (4) or a personal disruption. French newspapers score higher on the second degree, the Dutch ones on the third and fourth. A deepening of this pattern shows how these differences stem from two distinctive cultural repertoires that journalists and other media participants employ when relating to foreign events: a French one, which sees them as an opportunity to dominate the international political stage, and a Dutch one, which considers them a reason for reflecting on domestic or personal matters. These clear differences indicate the concept’s importance for the literature and for investigating it within other national media contexts.
- 3 July 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Behavioral Sciences of Terrorism and Political Aggression
- Vol. 17 (3) , 312-331
The importance of cultural and social proximity for the cross-border impacts of terrorist attacks
- 3 July 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Behavioral Sciences of Terrorism and Political Aggression
- Vol. 17 (3) , 312-331
The importance of cultural and social proximity for the cross-border impacts of terrorist attacks
- Open Access
- 6 September 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Cross-Border Impacts of Terrorist Attacks and the Importance of Proximity
Over the past two decades, social science research has repeatedly shown that societies tend to be affected more by a foreign event when it occurs in a geographically, culturally, and/or socially proximate location. The extant terrorism literature, however, has thus far only systematically examined the role played by geographical proximity in the creation of terrorist attacks’ cross-border impacts, thereby ignoring the possible importance of cultural and social proximity. In this paper, we therefore investigate both to what extent and why geographical, cultural, and/or social proximity between an audience and the locus of a foreign terrorist attack increases the latter’s impact on the former. We do this by conducting an exploratory case study of the impacts of seven foreign terrorist attacks on American public debates. Overall, while we find strong evidence that both cultural and social proximity increased a foreign terrorist incident’s impact on American public debates, there are no indications that geographical proximity had a similar effect. These findings suggest (1) that the concept of proximity should be more systematically integrated into the terrorism literature and (2) that a broader conception of proximity is needed to fully understand when and why the impacts of a terrorist attack cross national borders.
- 6 September 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessCross-Border Impacts of Terrorist Attacks and the Importance of Proximity
Over the past two decades, social science research has repeatedly shown that societies tend to be affected more by a foreign event when it occurs in a geographically, culturally, and/or socially proximate location. The extant terrorism literature, however, has thus far only systematically examined the role played by geographical proximity in the creation of terrorist attacks’ cross-border impacts, thereby ignoring the possible importance of cultural and social proximity. In this paper, we therefore investigate both to what extent and why geographical, cultural, and/or social proximity between an audience and the locus of a foreign terrorist attack increases the latter’s impact on the former. We do this by conducting an exploratory case study of the impacts of seven foreign terrorist attacks on American public debates. Overall, while we find strong evidence that both cultural and social proximity increased a foreign terrorist incident’s impact on American public debates, there are no indications that geographical proximity had a similar effect. These findings suggest (1) that the concept of proximity should be more systematically integrated into the terrorism literature and (2) that a broader conception of proximity is needed to fully understand when and why the impacts of a terrorist attack cross national borders.
- Open Access
- 4 September 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
To Foreignize or to Domesticate? How Media Vary Cross-Nationally in Their Degrees of Incorporating Foreign Events
While the domestication literature indicates how national media link foreign events to a country’s domestic affairs, it has thus far only examined modes of domestication - the ways through which these links are created. In this article, we introduce a different dimension of the phenomenon: degrees of domestication. This includes the extents to which a foreign event gets connected with the domestic. By making a topic-modeling analysis of French and Dutch newspaper articles about 9/11, the 2004 tsunami in Southeast Asia, the Arab Spring and Donald Trump’s political rise, we provide an explorative case study of this dimension. We inductively arrive at a scale ranging from no to extreme domestication of the event, classified according to four degrees of domestication: 1) an entirely foreign affair; 2) a foreign political affair involving domestic actors; 3) a domestic political affair; 4) or a personal disruption. French newspapers score higher on the second degree, the Dutch ones on the third and fourth. A deepening of this pattern shows how these differences stem from two distinctive cultural repertoires that journalists and other media participants employ when relating to foreign events: a French one, which sees them as an opportunity to dominate the international political stage, and a Dutch one, which considers them a reason for reflecting on domestic or personal matters. These clear differences indicate the concept’s importance for the literature and for investigating it within other national media contexts.
- 4 September 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessTo Foreignize or to Domesticate? How Media Vary Cross-Nationally in Their Degrees of Incorporating Foreign Events
While the domestication literature indicates how national media link foreign events to a country’s domestic affairs, it has thus far only examined modes of domestication - the ways through which these links are created. In this article, we introduce a different dimension of the phenomenon: degrees of domestication. This includes the extents to which a foreign event gets connected with the domestic. By making a topic-modeling analysis of French and Dutch newspaper articles about 9/11, the 2004 tsunami in Southeast Asia, the Arab Spring and Donald Trump’s political rise, we provide an explorative case study of this dimension. We inductively arrive at a scale ranging from no to extreme domestication of the event, classified according to four degrees of domestication: 1) an entirely foreign affair; 2) a foreign political affair involving domestic actors; 3) a domestic political affair; 4) or a personal disruption. French newspapers score higher on the second degree, the Dutch ones on the third and fourth. A deepening of this pattern shows how these differences stem from two distinctive cultural repertoires that journalists and other media participants employ when relating to foreign events: a French one, which sees them as an opportunity to dominate the international political stage, and a Dutch one, which considers them a reason for reflecting on domestic or personal matters. These clear differences indicate the concept’s importance for the literature and for investigating it within other national media contexts.
- Open Access
- 6 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 72 (3) , 725-741
How happenings do (not) turn into events: A typology and an application to the case of 9/11 in the American and Dutch public spheres
Why do some happenings become incentives for cultural or political transformation (that is: turn into events), whereas others remain ordinary occurrences? The theoretical perspectives of cultural repertoires, cleavage structures, and discursive opportunities are prominent and fruitful approaches for explaining cultural or political behavior and attitudes, yet they do not have a satisfactory answer to this question. To fill in this gap, I introduce a typology that indicates how certain happenings merely reproduce existing trends, whereas other ones turn into motives to change them. This can be either because they are “focus events,” which confirm dominant cultural or political patterns, or because they are “shock events,” which form a break from them. I illustrate this typology by investigating the distinct meanings that 9/11 were accorded in the American and Dutch public spheres. This analysis shows that this happening became a “shock event” on the issue of safety in the American case, as it broke with the cultural repertoire of viewing the United States as a safe, militarily impenetrable nation. In contrast, 9/11 turned into a “focus event” concerning the issue of Islam in the Dutch case because it confirmed the discursive opportunities to problematize Muslims, which public actors in the Netherlands had already developed in the years leading up to 2001.
- 6 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in The British Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 72 (3) , 725-741
Open AccessHow happenings do (not) turn into events: A typology and an application to the case of 9/11 in the American and Dutch public spheres
Why do some happenings become incentives for cultural or political transformation (that is: turn into events), whereas others remain ordinary occurrences? The theoretical perspectives of cultural repertoires, cleavage structures, and discursive opportunities are prominent and fruitful approaches for explaining cultural or political behavior and attitudes, yet they do not have a satisfactory answer to this question. To fill in this gap, I introduce a typology that indicates how certain happenings merely reproduce existing trends, whereas other ones turn into motives to change them. This can be either because they are “focus events,” which confirm dominant cultural or political patterns, or because they are “shock events,” which form a break from them. I illustrate this typology by investigating the distinct meanings that 9/11 were accorded in the American and Dutch public spheres. This analysis shows that this happening became a “shock event” on the issue of safety in the American case, as it broke with the cultural repertoire of viewing the United States as a safe, militarily impenetrable nation. In contrast, 9/11 turned into a “focus event” concerning the issue of Islam in the Dutch case because it confirmed the discursive opportunities to problematize Muslims, which public actors in the Netherlands had already developed in the years leading up to 2001.
- Open Access
- 23 November 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Sociology
- Vol. 36 (3) , 464-488
The framing of 9/11 in American, French, and Dutch national newspapers (2001–2015): An inductive approach to studying events
In this article, the authors employ work on events, framing, and social problems to develop an inductive approach to studying events. The article’s central premise is that tracing direct references made to events offers a fruitful strategy to investigate their framing cross-nationally and over time. The authors apply their approach to the case of 9/11 in American, French, and Dutch national newspapers (2001–2015). By combining word counting, topic modeling, and content analysis they examine the amount of attention given to 9/11, the issues to which it has been linked, and the implications attributed to it. The results indicate that the framing of 9/11 in the above three countries has been stable and uniform regarding foreign issues. There are however enduring, marked cross-national differences with respect to domestic issues. In France, 9/11 has barely been related to such issues; in the United States, the event has been connected principally to national security; and in the Netherlands, it has mainly prompted the problematization of Muslim immigrants. Because 9/11 has been a significant event many years after its occurrence, albeit differently so in each country of study, the findings point to the relevance of studying the framing of events cross-nationally and over extended periods of time.
- 23 November 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Sociology
- Vol. 36 (3) , 464-488
Open AccessThe framing of 9/11 in American, French, and Dutch national newspapers (2001–2015): An inductive approach to studying events
In this article, the authors employ work on events, framing, and social problems to develop an inductive approach to studying events. The article’s central premise is that tracing direct references made to events offers a fruitful strategy to investigate their framing cross-nationally and over time. The authors apply their approach to the case of 9/11 in American, French, and Dutch national newspapers (2001–2015). By combining word counting, topic modeling, and content analysis they examine the amount of attention given to 9/11, the issues to which it has been linked, and the implications attributed to it. The results indicate that the framing of 9/11 in the above three countries has been stable and uniform regarding foreign issues. There are however enduring, marked cross-national differences with respect to domestic issues. In France, 9/11 has barely been related to such issues; in the United States, the event has been connected principally to national security; and in the Netherlands, it has mainly prompted the problematization of Muslim immigrants. Because 9/11 has been a significant event many years after its occurrence, albeit differently so in each country of study, the findings point to the relevance of studying the framing of events cross-nationally and over extended periods of time.