SPSaleem Pathuthara

Saleem Pathuthara

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Saleem Pathuthara has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Xylene-Free Papanicolaou Staining

    by Suhas Dhende, Saleem Pathuthara, Maya Uke, Kedar Deodhar

    Introduction: Xylene (XL) is the most commonly used clearing agent in Papanicolaou staining. XL is hazardous and toxic chemical and prolonged exposure to XL can cause many ill-health effects. The health risk due to XL can be minimized by substituting XL with less hazardous clearing reagents such as Pine Oil (PO), Eucalyptus oil (EO), or Limonene (LM). The objective of this study was to compare the clearing ability, staining quality, preservation of morphology, physical properties, and cost of XL, PO, EO, and LM. Methods: Four smears were prepared from each of 50 serous effusions and were subjected to Papanicolaou stain. Out of four smears, one each was exposed to clearing specifically with XL (control), PO (test), EO (test), and LM (test). Test smears were compared with control for clearing, staining and morphology; graded as excellent, good or fair and further scored as 3, 2, 1, and the quality index (QI) was calculated. Statistical analysis was performed and the p value was calculated. In addition, the physical properties and cost of all the reagents were compared. Results: QI was 0.96 for both XL and PO, whereas 0.92 and 0.54 for EO and LM, respectively. Compared to XL, the quality of staining, clearing and morphology of PO and EO were statistically not significant, whereas the difference was statistically significant with LM (p = 0.005). Physical properties such as volatility, flammability, miscibility with alcohol and DPX and the refractive indices of all the reagents were almost similar and all were recyclable. Odor was pungent for XL and EO but was pleasant for PO and LM. The cost was less for PO as compared to others. Conclusion: PO was a natural, less hazardous, less toxic, and economical clearing agent and can be considered as a substitute for XL.


  • Open Access

    Conventional versus Liquid-based Cytology: “Man versus Machine”

    by Saleem Pathuthara, Swati Dighe, Maya Uke, Neelam Prabhudesai, Kedar Deodhar, Sangeeta B. Desai

    Background: Liquid-based cytology (LBC) can improve adequacy, monolayer quality with a clean background compared to conventional smears (CS). Aims and Objectives: The objective was to compare the quality and diagnostic yield of CS and LBC in routine cytological investigations. Materials and Methods: This retrospective study consisted of 306 samples (255 gynecological, 39 nongynecological, and 12 fine needle aspiration cytology [FNAC]) during a 2-year period (2019–2020). From each patient, two samples were collected in the same manner in the same sitting and processed by CS and LBC (ThinPrep® 2000, Hologic Inc.). Both CS and LBC were compared for adequacy, quality, representativeness, inflammation, hemorrhage, necrosis, preservation, reactive changes, organisms, atypia/dysplasia/malignancy, and preparation/screening time. Statistical analysis was performed. Results: No statistically significant difference was noted for adequacy, representativeness, reactive changes, preservation, and atypia/dysplasia/malignancy. CS was better in cellularity and diagnosis of inflammation and organisms, whereas LBC had a clean background and the difference was statistically significant (P = 0.0005). Conclusions: CS was equivalent to LBC in adequacy, representativeness, reactive changes, and atypia/dysplasia/malignancy. Adequacy comparable to LBC can be achieved in CS by careful sample collection, processing, and screening by trained cytotechnologists. CS was better in detecting organisms and inflammation than LBC. The advantages of LBC were monolayer smear, clean background, and lesser screening time, but the demerit was higher cost and longer processing time. Therefore, LBC is best suited to those laboratories having high sample inadequacy rates, lack of competent cytotechnologists, and no financial constraints. Either man or machine, appropriate and adequate sample collection by trained personnel forms the cornerstone for ensuring adequacy in both CS and LBC.


  • Open Access

    Heat Induced Processing of Cellblocks with Significant Reduction in Overall Turn Around Time

    by Suhas Dhende, Saleem Pathuthara, Neelam Prabhudesai, Dipak Shinde, Nupur Karnik, Kedar Deodhar

    Introduction: Cellblock (CB) with immunohistochemistry (IHC) is practically indispensable in the diagnostic workup of serous effusions; however, CB requires a minimum of 15–20 h for routine histopathological processing. A reduction in processing time can expedite a faster diagnosis. Aim: This study was undertaken to evaluate the utility of the heat-induced CB (HICB) technique. Material and Methods: Two sets of agar-embedded CBs were processed from 50 effusion samples. CBs were further processed by conventional and rapid methods. Conventional CBs (CCB) were processed in a histoprocessor, whereas rapid CB was processed in a heated water bath with an agitation facility. For HICB processing, dehydration and clearing were performed at 50°C followed by paraffin wax impregnation at 65°C temperature. From both CBs, sections of 5 um thickness were cut and stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H and E). Cell morphology, cost, and time were compared between the two methods. The feasibility of IHC was attempted in a few cases. Results: HICB was completed within 4.30 h compared with CCB. Diagnoses on both CBs were concordant in all the cases. Incomplete dehydration was noted in six (12%) cases, but the diagnosis was not compromised. No additional cost was involved in HICB. On IHC, both HICB and CCB exhibited equivalent expression. Conclusions: HICB is a rapid, innovative, simple, and cost-effective technique and expedites faster diagnosis. It does not require any advanced equipment.

  • Open Access

    Is Diagnosis of Low-Grade Urothelial Carcinoma Possible in Urine Cytology?

    by Saloni Bansal, Saleem Pathuthara, Santhosh Joseph, Swati Dighe, Santosh Menon, Sangeeta B. Desai

    Background: Urine cytology is a useful modality, primarily for the diagnosis and follow-up surveillance of high-grade urothelial carcinoma (HGUC). Its utility in diagnosing low-grade urothelial carcinoma (LGUC) remains controversial because of low reported sensitivity compared to cystoscopy. Aim: To study the cytomorphology of LGUC in voided urine samples and analyze its utility in diagnosis. Materials and Methods: This is a retrospective study of one year, including 48 voided urine samples in cases which were confirmed as LGUC on subsequent histology. Urine cytology smears of these cases, originally stained with Papanicolaou stain were reviewed, critically analyzed and the specific cytomorphologic and cystoscopic findings were documented. Results: On review 18 samples were re-categorized as LGUC which included 10 samples initially diagnosed as Negative for HGUC, 2 as Atypical Urothelial Cells – Not Otherwise Specified (AUC-NOS) and 6 as Suspicious for Carcinoma. In addition, another 3 samples with initial diagnosis of LGUC remained as LGUC on review. Thus, a total of 21 LGUC samples were identified after the review. 26 (54%) samples with a diagnosis of negative for HGUC remained negative even after review, as the tumor cells were not identified either due to sampling error or unrecognizable morphology. One (2%) samples of AUC-NOS remained the same on review due to very scant atypical cells. In 21 LGUC samples, cytology showed a dual population of benign differentiated urothelial cells and small urothelial cells with subtle nuclear atypia such as irregular and thickened nuclear membrane with increased nuclear cytoplasmic ratio. In 12 false negative LGUC samples, the diagnostic cells were camouflaged by their subtle nuclear atypia coupled with an overwhelming background of differentiated benign urothelial cells as both appeared almost similar in morphology. Papillary fragments were identified only in 2 samples. Conclusions: Diagnosis of LGUC on cytology is challenging and depends on the presence of diagnostic cells, pick up of diagnostic cells on screening and accurate interpretation. Special attention to papillary fragments and aforementioned nuclear atypia should be paid as tumor cells may resemble normal urothelial cells and can be easily missed.


  • Incremental value of endoscopic brush cytology in response assessment after chemo-irradiation for Esophageal cancer

    by Shreyasee Karmakar, Naveen Mummudi, Sarbani Ghosh-Laskar, Anil Tibdewal, Rajiv Kumar, Prachi Patil, Shaesta Mehta, Vanita Noronha, Kumar Prabhash, Nilendu Purandare, et al.

    Background Response assessment after chemo-radiotherapy (CTRT) in locally advanced esophageal cancer is usually performed using a PET-CT scan, an upper GI endoscopy (UGIE) and histological correlation with biopsy or cytology. We aim to study the incremental value of brush cytology in addition to PET-CT for response assessment. Materials and methods In this retrospective analysis, 40 patients with Stage II- IV carcinoma esophagus treated with radical intent between June 2015 and August 2019 were included. Patients were treated with either upfront concurrent CTRT or neo-adjuvant chemotherapy followed by CTRT. All patients underwent PET-CT and UGIE for initial staging and response assessment on follow-up. Patients with esophageal stricture (disease related or treatment induced) had brush cytology done during UGIE. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) of brush cytology were calculated considering serial clinical follow-up as gold standard. Results Twenty-three male (57.5%) and 17 (42.5%) female patients with median age of 57 years (range: 27 – 79 years) were analyzed. Concurrent CTRT was delivered in 52.5%; 75% patients were treated with intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT); median RT dose was 63 Gy (range- 41.4 to 64 Gy). At a median follow-up of 16 months (range 6- 54 months), 20 patients (55.5%) were clinically controlled, 9 (25%) had local recurrence, 5 (13.8%) had loco-regional recurrence and 2 had distant metastasis. Considering clinical follow-up as the gold standard, sensitivity, PPV and NPV of PET-CT combined with brush cytology improved compared to PET-CT alone and was found to be 75%, 90%, 85.7% and 81.8% respectively. Conclusion We found that brush cytology on endoscopy is a simple tool with high specificity which adds value to the findings of response assessment PET-CT scan and thereby can increase the confidence of the treating oncologist in making clinical decisions.