Sharron FitzGerald
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Interests
Sharron FitzGerald has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jane Freedman
Université Paris 8, Saint-Denis, Île-de-France, France
8 shared publications May-Len Skilbrei
University of Oslo
5 shared publications- Anna Carline
University of Liverpool
2 shared publications - Gillian Wylie
Trinity College Dublin
1 shared publication - Jane Scoular
University of Strathclyde
1 shared publication Maggie O’nEill
University College Cork, Cork, Ireland
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 15 October 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social & Legal Studies
- Vol. 34 (5) , 714-734
Problematising the ‘Man Problem’ in the Domestic Abuse Act: Discursive Co-option and The (In)Visibility of Gender
This article offers a discourse analysis of domestic abuse's ‘Man Problem’ by combining and developing Naffine's, Foucault's and Bacchi's work in a new way. Taking the parliamentary debates around the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 in England and Wales as our focus, we critique how MPs problematise gender to justify a gender-neutral definition of domestic violence and abuse (DVA). We illustrate how MPs reframe DVA's ‘man problem’ not as the problem of men as perpetrators of violence against women. But rather, they represent the law and policy ‘problem’ as men's invisibility as victims of DVA. We develop a new theoretical innovation to advance our critique: discursive co-option, and we uncover two gender paradoxes. We argue that MPs co-opt gender equality discourses to advance masculinist politics and patriarchal logics in ways that have detrimental effects for the less powerful, and which elide the reality of women's experiences of DVA.
- 15 October 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social & Legal Studies
- Vol. 34 (5) , 714-734
Problematising the ‘Man Problem’ in the Domestic Abuse Act: Discursive Co-option and The (In)Visibility of Gender
This article offers a discourse analysis of domestic abuse's ‘Man Problem’ by combining and developing Naffine's, Foucault's and Bacchi's work in a new way. Taking the parliamentary debates around the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 in England and Wales as our focus, we critique how MPs problematise gender to justify a gender-neutral definition of domestic violence and abuse (DVA). We illustrate how MPs reframe DVA's ‘man problem’ not as the problem of men as perpetrators of violence against women. But rather, they represent the law and policy ‘problem’ as men's invisibility as victims of DVA. We develop a new theoretical innovation to advance our critique: discursive co-option, and we uncover two gender paradoxes. We argue that MPs co-opt gender equality discourses to advance masculinist politics and patriarchal logics in ways that have detrimental effects for the less powerful, and which elide the reality of women's experiences of DVA.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 68-92
Gender in EU migration policies
In this chapter, we examine EU policy-making procedures around immigration and asylum, focusing specifically on the politics of framing and why and how the EU has introduced (or did not introduce) gender equality into its immigration and asylum law and policy agenda. In order to exemplify the injustices that permeate this process, we will examine how legislators and policymakers and certain feminists working in the EU policy area have framed these issues.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 68-92
Gender in EU migration policies
In this chapter, we examine EU policy-making procedures around immigration and asylum, focusing specifically on the politics of framing and why and how the EU has introduced (or did not introduce) gender equality into its immigration and asylum law and policy agenda. In order to exemplify the injustices that permeate this process, we will examine how legislators and policymakers and certain feminists working in the EU policy area have framed these issues.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 139-146
Concluding remarks
In our concluding remarks, we return to Fraser’s ‘all subjected principle’ and reflect upon how this might be applied to advance a social justice agenda within the three policy areas discussed in the book. We highlight the importance of critical feminist thinking and practice when engaging with the EU and other institutional frameworks with regard to law and policy.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 139-146
Concluding remarks
In our concluding remarks, we return to Fraser’s ‘all subjected principle’ and reflect upon how this might be applied to advance a social justice agenda within the three policy areas discussed in the book. We highlight the importance of critical feminist thinking and practice when engaging with the EU and other institutional frameworks with regard to law and policy.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 93-113
The EU and sex work
This chapter examines how certain feminists working in or for EU institutions have integrated the concept of gender equality into EU sex work debates. Invoking Fraser’s theory to analyse the EU’s pivot towards neo-abolitionism, our objective is to use this analysis as a springboard to think about sex work as a contested issue, and to think ‘problematically’ about the kinds of exclusions and silencing practices that operate in this political space in the name of gender equality for all.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 93-113
The EU and sex work
This chapter examines how certain feminists working in or for EU institutions have integrated the concept of gender equality into EU sex work debates. Invoking Fraser’s theory to analyse the EU’s pivot towards neo-abolitionism, our objective is to use this analysis as a springboard to think about sex work as a contested issue, and to think ‘problematically’ about the kinds of exclusions and silencing practices that operate in this political space in the name of gender equality for all.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 43-67
Mapping a short history of EU gender equality law and policies
In this chapter, we will map the cartography of different EU institutions’ and groups’ roles in making gender equality policy. Specifically, we will examine why and how the concept has evolved with this institutional framework. We indicate those areas of conflict that arise when certain powerful feminists attempt to use what Audre Lorde defines as the ‘master’s tools’ to integrate their version of gender equality into the EU’s institutional arrangements. To the extent that these tensions highlight political and ideological conflicts between ‘governance’ and ‘critical’ feminist framings of gender equality, we submit that this situation offers a concrete manifestation of, and testing ground for, the longstanding debate that feminist networks working in the EU gender equality sphere play a constitutive role in forms of neoliberal governance.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 43-67
Mapping a short history of EU gender equality law and policies
In this chapter, we will map the cartography of different EU institutions’ and groups’ roles in making gender equality policy. Specifically, we will examine why and how the concept has evolved with this institutional framework. We indicate those areas of conflict that arise when certain powerful feminists attempt to use what Audre Lorde defines as the ‘master’s tools’ to integrate their version of gender equality into the EU’s institutional arrangements. To the extent that these tensions highlight political and ideological conflicts between ‘governance’ and ‘critical’ feminist framings of gender equality, we submit that this situation offers a concrete manifestation of, and testing ground for, the longstanding debate that feminist networks working in the EU gender equality sphere play a constitutive role in forms of neoliberal governance.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-17
Introduction
The introduction sets out the context and objectives of this volume. It explains why and how we focus on the gendered effects of EU institutions and policies on specific populations as objectives of governmentality, and on the role that EU institutions and certain feminist groups and experts play in creating and maintaining this assemblage of governmentality. We set out how we believe our contribution to feminist critiques in this area offers a needed analysis of the current situation because it sees these actors as playing a role in excluding and silencing marginal voices from law and policy deliberations on gender equality in the EU policy sphere.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-17
Introduction
The introduction sets out the context and objectives of this volume. It explains why and how we focus on the gendered effects of EU institutions and policies on specific populations as objectives of governmentality, and on the role that EU institutions and certain feminist groups and experts play in creating and maintaining this assemblage of governmentality. We set out how we believe our contribution to feminist critiques in this area offers a needed analysis of the current situation because it sees these actors as playing a role in excluding and silencing marginal voices from law and policy deliberations on gender equality in the EU policy sphere.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 114-138
The emergence of sex trafficking as a gender equality issue in the EU
This chapter focuses on the emergence of sex trafficking as a gender equality issue in the EU, tracing the ways in which the coincidence between neo-abolitionist positions on sex work and securitised migration policies have led to the adoption of racialised and gendered framings of sex trafficking, which results in closure of the space for debate around issues of sex trafficking. This in turn leads to an obliteration, both in an understanding of the meaning of sex trafficking for Europe’s ‘others’, and of the gendered and racialised structures that create violence for migrant women involved in sex work.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 114-138
The emergence of sex trafficking as a gender equality issue in the EU
This chapter focuses on the emergence of sex trafficking as a gender equality issue in the EU, tracing the ways in which the coincidence between neo-abolitionist positions on sex work and securitised migration policies have led to the adoption of racialised and gendered framings of sex trafficking, which results in closure of the space for debate around issues of sex trafficking. This in turn leads to an obliteration, both in an understanding of the meaning of sex trafficking for Europe’s ‘others’, and of the gendered and racialised structures that create violence for migrant women involved in sex work.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 18-42
Where is the justice in gender equality policy?
In this chapter, we turn our attention towards trying to understand various aspects of EU gender equality law and policy and gender mainstreaming. We start the process of thinking ‘problematically’ about these policies and instruments by reflecting upon their implications for the scope and reach of EU law and policy in the three linked policy areas of migration, sex work and sex trafficking. Our principal objective in this chapter is to develop a feminist critique of the discourses, practices and politics shaping certain actors, including certain feminists’ involvement in the law and policy domains of migration, sex trafficking and transborder and domestic sex work from the standpoint of social justice.
- 26 July 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 18-42
Where is the justice in gender equality policy?
In this chapter, we turn our attention towards trying to understand various aspects of EU gender equality law and policy and gender mainstreaming. We start the process of thinking ‘problematically’ about these policies and instruments by reflecting upon their implications for the scope and reach of EU law and policy in the three linked policy areas of migration, sex work and sex trafficking. Our principal objective in this chapter is to develop a feminist critique of the discourses, practices and politics shaping certain actors, including certain feminists’ involvement in the law and policy domains of migration, sex trafficking and transborder and domestic sex work from the standpoint of social justice.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 101-124
Forging National Sexual Politics: A Dance of Moving Targets and Sitting Ducks
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 101-124
Forging National Sexual Politics: A Dance of Moving Targets and Sitting Ducks
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 125-132
Sexual Politics in Contemporary Europe: Resonance and Dissonance
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 125-132
Sexual Politics in Contemporary Europe: Resonance and Dissonance