Navpreet Kamboj
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Navpreet Kamboj has a total of 24 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Aaron Conway
Peter Munk Cardiac Centre, University Health Network, Toronto, Canada
8 shared publications - Kristina Chang
Univ Hlth Network, Peter Munk Cardiac Ctr, Toronto, ON, Canada
4 shared publications Kristina Chang
Peter Munk Cardiac Centre, University Health Network, Toronto, Canada
3 shared publications- Matteo Parotto
Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine, Interdepartmental Division of Critical Care Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
3 shared publications - Carla R. Jungquist
School of Nursing, University at Buffalo, Buffalo, NY
2 shared publications - Charlene H. Chu
Lawrence Bloomberg Faculty of Nursing University of Toronto Toronto Ontario Canada
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 29 May 2024
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Applied Clinical Informatics
- Vol. 15 (03) , 583-599
Designing the User Interface of a Nitroglycerin Dose Titration Decision Support System: User-Centered Design Study
Background Nurses adjust intravenous nitroglycerin infusions to provide acute relief for angina by manually increasing or decreasing the dosage. However, titration can pose challenges, as excessively high doses can lead to hypotension, and low doses may result in inadequate pain relief. Clinical decision support systems (CDSSs) that predict changes in blood pressure for nitroglycerin dose adjustments may assist nurses with titration. Objective This study aimed to design a user interface for a CDSS for nitroglycerin dose titration (Nitroglycerin Dose Titration Decision Support System [nitro DSS]). Methods A user-centered design (UCD) approach, consisting of an initial qualitative study with semistructured interviews to identify design specifications for prototype development, was used. This was followed by three iterative rounds of usability testing. Nurses with experience titrating nitroglycerin infusions in coronary care units participated. Results A total of 20 nurses participated, including 7 during the qualitative study and 15 during usability testing (2 nurses participated in both phases). Analysis of the qualitative data revealed four themes for the interface design to be (1) clear and consistent, (2) vigilant, (3) interoperable, and (4) reliable. The major elements of the final prototype included a feature for viewing the predicted and actual blood pressure over time to determine the reliability of the predictions, a drop-down option to report patient side effects, a feature to report reasons for not accepting the prediction, and a visual alert indicating any systolic blood pressure predictions below 90 mm Hg. Nurses' ratings on the questionnaires indicated excellent usability and acceptability of the final nitro DSS prototype. Conclusion This study successfully applied a UCD approach to collaborate with nurses in developing a user interface for the nitro DSS that supports the clinical decision-making of nurses titrating nitroglycerin.
- 29 May 2024
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Applied Clinical Informatics
- Vol. 15 (03) , 583-599
Designing the User Interface of a Nitroglycerin Dose Titration Decision Support System: User-Centered Design Study
Background Nurses adjust intravenous nitroglycerin infusions to provide acute relief for angina by manually increasing or decreasing the dosage. However, titration can pose challenges, as excessively high doses can lead to hypotension, and low doses may result in inadequate pain relief. Clinical decision support systems (CDSSs) that predict changes in blood pressure for nitroglycerin dose adjustments may assist nurses with titration. Objective This study aimed to design a user interface for a CDSS for nitroglycerin dose titration (Nitroglycerin Dose Titration Decision Support System [nitro DSS]). Methods A user-centered design (UCD) approach, consisting of an initial qualitative study with semistructured interviews to identify design specifications for prototype development, was used. This was followed by three iterative rounds of usability testing. Nurses with experience titrating nitroglycerin infusions in coronary care units participated. Results A total of 20 nurses participated, including 7 during the qualitative study and 15 during usability testing (2 nurses participated in both phases). Analysis of the qualitative data revealed four themes for the interface design to be (1) clear and consistent, (2) vigilant, (3) interoperable, and (4) reliable. The major elements of the final prototype included a feature for viewing the predicted and actual blood pressure over time to determine the reliability of the predictions, a drop-down option to report patient side effects, a feature to report reasons for not accepting the prediction, and a visual alert indicating any systolic blood pressure predictions below 90 mm Hg. Nurses' ratings on the questionnaires indicated excellent usability and acceptability of the final nitro DSS prototype. Conclusion This study successfully applied a UCD approach to collaborate with nurses in developing a user interface for the nitro DSS that supports the clinical decision-making of nurses titrating nitroglycerin.
- 19 December 2023
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in CIN: Computers, Informatics, Nursing
- Vol. 42 (4) , 259-266
Predicting Blood Pressure After Nitroglycerin Infusion Dose Titration in Critical Care Units
Critical care nurses use physiological indicators, such as blood pressure, to guide their decision-making regarding the titration of nitroglycerin infusions. A retrospective study was conducted to determine the accuracy of systolic blood pressure predictions during nitroglycerin infusions. Data were extracted from the publicly accessible eICU program database. The accuracy of a linear model, least absolute shrinkage and selection operator, ridge regression, and a stacked ensemble model trained using the AutoGluon-Tabular framework were investigated. A persistence model, where the future value in a time series is predicted as equal to its preceding value, was used as the baseline comparison for model accuracy. Internal-external validation was used to examine if heterogeneity among hospitals could contribute to model performance. The sample consisted of 827 patients and 2541 nitroglycerin dose titrations with corresponding systolic blood pressure measurements. The root-mean-square error on the test set for the stacked ensemble model developed using the AutoGluon-Tabular framework was the lowest of all models at 15.3 mm Hg, equating to a 22% improvement against the baseline. Internal-external validation revealed consistent accuracy across hospitals. Further studies are needed to determine the impact of using systolic blood pressure predictions to inform nurses' clinical decision-making regarding nitroglycerin infusion titration in critical care.
- 19 December 2023
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in CIN: Computers, Informatics, Nursing
- Vol. 42 (4) , 259-266
Predicting Blood Pressure After Nitroglycerin Infusion Dose Titration in Critical Care Units
Critical care nurses use physiological indicators, such as blood pressure, to guide their decision-making regarding the titration of nitroglycerin infusions. A retrospective study was conducted to determine the accuracy of systolic blood pressure predictions during nitroglycerin infusions. Data were extracted from the publicly accessible eICU program database. The accuracy of a linear model, least absolute shrinkage and selection operator, ridge regression, and a stacked ensemble model trained using the AutoGluon-Tabular framework were investigated. A persistence model, where the future value in a time series is predicted as equal to its preceding value, was used as the baseline comparison for model accuracy. Internal-external validation was used to examine if heterogeneity among hospitals could contribute to model performance. The sample consisted of 827 patients and 2541 nitroglycerin dose titrations with corresponding systolic blood pressure measurements. The root-mean-square error on the test set for the stacked ensemble model developed using the AutoGluon-Tabular framework was the lowest of all models at 15.3 mm Hg, equating to a 22% improvement against the baseline. Internal-external validation revealed consistent accuracy across hospitals. Further studies are needed to determine the impact of using systolic blood pressure predictions to inform nurses' clinical decision-making regarding nitroglycerin infusion titration in critical care.
- 1 December 2021
- Published by Elsevier in Intensive and Critical Care Nursing
- Vol. 67, 103091
Accuracy and precision of continuous non-invasive arterial pressure monitoring in critical care: A systematic review and meta-analysis
- 1 December 2021
- Published by Elsevier in Intensive and Critical Care Nursing
- Vol. 67, 103091
Accuracy and precision of continuous non-invasive arterial pressure monitoring in critical care: A systematic review and meta-analysis
- Open Access
- 5 October 2021
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Perioperative Medicine
- Vol. 4 (2) , e29200
Predicting Prolonged Apnea During Nurse-Administered Procedural Sedation: Machine Learning Study
Background: Capnography is commonly used for nurse-administered procedural sedation. Distinguishing between capnography waveform abnormalities that signal the need for clinical intervention for an event and those that do not indicate the need for intervention is essential for the successful implementation of this technology into practice. It is possible that capnography alarm management may be improved by using machine learning to create a “smart alarm” that can alert clinicians to apneic events that are predicted to be prolonged. Objective: To determine the accuracy of machine learning models for predicting at the 15-second time point if apnea will be prolonged (ie, apnea that persists for >30 seconds). Methods: A secondary analysis of an observational study was conducted. We selected several candidate models to evaluate, including a random forest model, generalized linear model (logistic regression), least absolute shrinkage and selection operator regression, ridge regression, and the XGBoost model. Out-of-sample accuracy of the models was calculated using 10-fold cross-validation. The net benefit decision analytic measure was used to assist with deciding whether using the models in practice would lead to better outcomes on average than using the current default capnography alarm management strategies. The default strategies are the aggressive approach, in which an alarm is triggered after brief periods of apnea (typically 15 seconds) and the conservative approach, in which an alarm is triggered for only prolonged periods of apnea (typically >30 seconds). Results: A total of 384 apneic events longer than 15 seconds were observed in 61 of the 102 patients (59.8%) who participated in the observational study. Nearly half of the apneic events (180/384, 46.9%) were prolonged. The random forest model performed the best in terms of discrimination (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve 0.66) and calibration. The net benefit associated with the random forest model exceeded that associated with the aggressive strategy but was lower than that associated with the conservative strategy. Conclusions: Decision curve analysis indicated that using a random forest model would lead to a better outcome for capnography alarm management than using an aggressive strategy in which alarms are triggered after 15 seconds of apnea. The model would not be superior to the conservative strategy in which alarms are only triggered after 30 seconds.
- 5 October 2021
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Perioperative Medicine
- Vol. 4 (2) , e29200
Open AccessPredicting Prolonged Apnea During Nurse-Administered Procedural Sedation: Machine Learning Study
Background: Capnography is commonly used for nurse-administered procedural sedation. Distinguishing between capnography waveform abnormalities that signal the need for clinical intervention for an event and those that do not indicate the need for intervention is essential for the successful implementation of this technology into practice. It is possible that capnography alarm management may be improved by using machine learning to create a “smart alarm” that can alert clinicians to apneic events that are predicted to be prolonged. Objective: To determine the accuracy of machine learning models for predicting at the 15-second time point if apnea will be prolonged (ie, apnea that persists for >30 seconds). Methods: A secondary analysis of an observational study was conducted. We selected several candidate models to evaluate, including a random forest model, generalized linear model (logistic regression), least absolute shrinkage and selection operator regression, ridge regression, and the XGBoost model. Out-of-sample accuracy of the models was calculated using 10-fold cross-validation. The net benefit decision analytic measure was used to assist with deciding whether using the models in practice would lead to better outcomes on average than using the current default capnography alarm management strategies. The default strategies are the aggressive approach, in which an alarm is triggered after brief periods of apnea (typically 15 seconds) and the conservative approach, in which an alarm is triggered for only prolonged periods of apnea (typically >30 seconds). Results: A total of 384 apneic events longer than 15 seconds were observed in 61 of the 102 patients (59.8%) who participated in the observational study. Nearly half of the apneic events (180/384, 46.9%) were prolonged. The random forest model performed the best in terms of discrimination (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve 0.66) and calibration. The net benefit associated with the random forest model exceeded that associated with the aggressive strategy but was lower than that associated with the conservative strategy. Conclusions: Decision curve analysis indicated that using a random forest model would lead to a better outcome for capnography alarm management than using an aggressive strategy in which alarms are triggered after 15 seconds of apnea. The model would not be superior to the conservative strategy in which alarms are only triggered after 30 seconds.
- Open Access
- 29 March 2021
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Predicting Prolonged Apnea During Nurse-Administered Procedural Sedation: Machine Learning Study (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Capnography is commonly used for nurse-administered procedural sedation. Distinguishing between capnography waveform abnormalities that signal the need for clinical intervention for an event and those that do not indicate the need for intervention is essential for the successful implementation of this technology into practice. It is possible that capnography alarm management may be improved by using machine learning to create a “smart alarm” that can alert clinicians to apneic events that are predicted to be prolonged. OBJECTIVE To determine the accuracy of machine learning models for predicting at the 15-second time point if apnea will be prolonged (ie, apnea that persists for >30 seconds). METHODS A secondary analysis of an observational study was conducted. We selected several candidate models to evaluate, including a random forest model, generalized linear model (logistic regression), least absolute shrinkage and selection operator regression, ridge regression, and the XGBoost model. Out-of-sample accuracy of the models was calculated using 10-fold cross-validation. The net benefit decision analytic measure was used to assist with deciding whether using the models in practice would lead to better outcomes on average than using the current default capnography alarm management strategies. The default strategies are the aggressive approach, in which an alarm is triggered after brief periods of apnea (typically 15 seconds) and the conservative approach, in which an alarm is triggered for only prolonged periods of apnea (typically >30 seconds). RESULTS A total of 384 apneic events longer than 15 seconds were observed in 61 of the 102 patients (59.8%) who participated in the observational study. Nearly half of the apneic events (180/384, 46.9%) were prolonged. The random forest model performed the best in terms of discrimination (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve 0.66) and calibration. The net benefit associated with the random forest model exceeded that associated with the aggressive strategy but was lower than that associated with the conservative strategy. CONCLUSIONS Decision curve analysis indicated that using a random forest model would lead to a better outcome for capnography alarm management than using an aggressive strategy in which alarms are triggered after 15 seconds of apnea. The model would not be superior to the conservative strategy in which alarms are only triggered after 30 seconds.
- 29 March 2021
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessPredicting Prolonged Apnea During Nurse-Administered Procedural Sedation: Machine Learning Study (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Capnography is commonly used for nurse-administered procedural sedation. Distinguishing between capnography waveform abnormalities that signal the need for clinical intervention for an event and those that do not indicate the need for intervention is essential for the successful implementation of this technology into practice. It is possible that capnography alarm management may be improved by using machine learning to create a “smart alarm” that can alert clinicians to apneic events that are predicted to be prolonged. OBJECTIVE To determine the accuracy of machine learning models for predicting at the 15-second time point if apnea will be prolonged (ie, apnea that persists for >30 seconds). METHODS A secondary analysis of an observational study was conducted. We selected several candidate models to evaluate, including a random forest model, generalized linear model (logistic regression), least absolute shrinkage and selection operator regression, ridge regression, and the XGBoost model. Out-of-sample accuracy of the models was calculated using 10-fold cross-validation. The net benefit decision analytic measure was used to assist with deciding whether using the models in practice would lead to better outcomes on average than using the current default capnography alarm management strategies. The default strategies are the aggressive approach, in which an alarm is triggered after brief periods of apnea (typically 15 seconds) and the conservative approach, in which an alarm is triggered for only prolonged periods of apnea (typically >30 seconds). RESULTS A total of 384 apneic events longer than 15 seconds were observed in 61 of the 102 patients (59.8%) who participated in the observational study. Nearly half of the apneic events (180/384, 46.9%) were prolonged. The random forest model performed the best in terms of discrimination (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve 0.66) and calibration. The net benefit associated with the random forest model exceeded that associated with the aggressive strategy but was lower than that associated with the conservative strategy. CONCLUSIONS Decision curve analysis indicated that using a random forest model would lead to a better outcome for capnography alarm management than using an aggressive strategy in which alarms are triggered after 15 seconds of apnea. The model would not be superior to the conservative strategy in which alarms are only triggered after 30 seconds.
- Open Access
- 28 January 2021
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Open
- Vol. 8 (3) , 1135-1144
Development and validation of the nursing confidence in managing sedation complications scale
Aim: To develop the Nursing Confidence in Managing Sedation Complications Scale.Design: A multi‐phased approach was used.Methods: An initial bank of items was created based on the authors' experience and clinical practice guidelines. An expert panel assessed content validity. Exploratory factor analysis was used for item reduction and regression was used to explore construct validity. Responsiveness was evaluated using a pre‐test post‐test design.Results: Criteria for content validity was met for 34 items. An 18‐item, three‐factor solution was identified from exploratory factor analysis performed using Nursing Confidence in Managing Sedation Complications Scale scores from 228 nurses. Subscales accounted for 66% of the variance. Cronbach's alpha for the scale (0.95) and subscales was high (>0.85). There were differences (p < .001) in Nursing Confidence in Managing Sedation Complications Scale scores relative to years of experience and work environment. NC‐MSCS scores increased significantly from before to after sedation training (mean difference = 31.8; 95% CI = 24.4–39; N = 31).
- 28 January 2021
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Open
- Vol. 8 (3) , 1135-1144
Open AccessDevelopment and validation of the nursing confidence in managing sedation complications scale
Aim: To develop the Nursing Confidence in Managing Sedation Complications Scale.Design: A multi‐phased approach was used.Methods: An initial bank of items was created based on the authors' experience and clinical practice guidelines. An expert panel assessed content validity. Exploratory factor analysis was used for item reduction and regression was used to explore construct validity. Responsiveness was evaluated using a pre‐test post‐test design.Results: Criteria for content validity was met for 34 items. An 18‐item, three‐factor solution was identified from exploratory factor analysis performed using Nursing Confidence in Managing Sedation Complications Scale scores from 228 nurses. Subscales accounted for 66% of the variance. Cronbach's alpha for the scale (0.95) and subscales was high (>0.85). There were differences (p < .001) in Nursing Confidence in Managing Sedation Complications Scale scores relative to years of experience and work environment. NC‐MSCS scores increased significantly from before to after sedation training (mean difference = 31.8; 95% CI = 24.4–39; N = 31).
- Open Access
- 21 January 2021
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in European Journal of Anaesthesiology
- Vol. 38 (8) , 839-849
High flow nasal oxygen during procedural sedation for cardiac implantable electronic device procedures
BACKGROUND: High flow nasal oxygen may better support the vulnerable respiratory state of patients during procedural sedation. OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to investigate the effects of high flow nasal oxygen in comparison to facemask oxygen on ventilation during cardiac implantable electronic device procedures performed with procedural sedation. DESIGN: A randomised controlled trial. SETTING: The study was conducted at one academic hospital in Canada. PARTICIPANTS: Adults undergoing elective cardiac implantable electronic device procedures with sedation administered by an anaesthesia assistant, supervised by an anaesthesiologist from August 2019 to March 2020. INTERVENTIONS: Participants were randomised 1 : 1 to facemask (≥ 8 l · min−1) or high flow nasal oxygen (50 l · min−1 and a 50 : 50 oxygen to air ratio). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary outcome was peak transcutaneous carbon dioxide. Outcomes were analysed using Bayesian statistics. RESULTS: The 129 participants who were randomised and received sedation were included. The difference in peak transcutaneous carbon dioxide was 0.0 kPa (95% CI -0.17 to 0.18). Minor adverse sedation events were 6.4 times more likely to occur in the high flow nasal oxygen group. This estimate is imprecise (95% CI 1.34 to 42.99). The odds ratio for oxygen desaturation for the high flow nasal oxygen group compared with the facemask group was 1.2 (95% CI 0.37 to 3.75). The difference in satisfaction with sedation scores between groups was 0.0 (95% CI -0.33 to 0.23). CONCLUSIONS: Ventilation, as measured by TcCO2, is highly unlikely to differ by a clinically important amount between high flow nasal oxygen at 50 l min−1 or facemask oxygen at 8 l min−1. Further research with a larger sample size would be required to determine the optimal oxygen:air ratio when using high flow nasal oxygen during cardiac implantable electronic device procedures performed with sedation. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT03858257
- 21 January 2021
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in European Journal of Anaesthesiology
- Vol. 38 (8) , 839-849
Open AccessHigh flow nasal oxygen during procedural sedation for cardiac implantable electronic device procedures
BACKGROUND: High flow nasal oxygen may better support the vulnerable respiratory state of patients during procedural sedation. OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to investigate the effects of high flow nasal oxygen in comparison to facemask oxygen on ventilation during cardiac implantable electronic device procedures performed with procedural sedation. DESIGN: A randomised controlled trial. SETTING: The study was conducted at one academic hospital in Canada. PARTICIPANTS: Adults undergoing elective cardiac implantable electronic device procedures with sedation administered by an anaesthesia assistant, supervised by an anaesthesiologist from August 2019 to March 2020. INTERVENTIONS: Participants were randomised 1 : 1 to facemask (≥ 8 l · min−1) or high flow nasal oxygen (50 l · min−1 and a 50 : 50 oxygen to air ratio). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary outcome was peak transcutaneous carbon dioxide. Outcomes were analysed using Bayesian statistics. RESULTS: The 129 participants who were randomised and received sedation were included. The difference in peak transcutaneous carbon dioxide was 0.0 kPa (95% CI -0.17 to 0.18). Minor adverse sedation events were 6.4 times more likely to occur in the high flow nasal oxygen group. This estimate is imprecise (95% CI 1.34 to 42.99). The odds ratio for oxygen desaturation for the high flow nasal oxygen group compared with the facemask group was 1.2 (95% CI 0.37 to 3.75). The difference in satisfaction with sedation scores between groups was 0.0 (95% CI -0.33 to 0.23). CONCLUSIONS: Ventilation, as measured by TcCO2, is highly unlikely to differ by a clinically important amount between high flow nasal oxygen at 50 l min−1 or facemask oxygen at 8 l min−1. Further research with a larger sample size would be required to determine the optimal oxygen:air ratio when using high flow nasal oxygen during cardiac implantable electronic device procedures performed with sedation. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT03858257
- 15 December 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Radiology Nursing
- Vol. 40 (1) , 75-79
Validating the Peri-operative Thirst Discomfort Scale for Measuring Thirst Discomfort Prior to Procedures
- 15 December 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Radiology Nursing
- Vol. 40 (1) , 75-79
Validating the Peri-operative Thirst Discomfort Scale for Measuring Thirst Discomfort Prior to Procedures
- 2 June 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Clinical Monitoring and Computing
- Vol. 35 (1) , 39-49
Accuracy and precision of zero-heat-flux temperature measurements with the 3M™ Bair Hugger™ Temperature Monitoring System: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Zero-heat-flux thermometers provide clinicians with the ability to continuously and non-invasively monitor body temperature. These devices are increasingly being used to substitute for more invasive core temperature measurements during surgery and in critical care. The aim of this review was to determine the accuracy and precision of zero-heat-flux temperature measurements from the 3M™ Bair Hugger™ Temperature Monitoring System. Medline and EMBASE were searched for studies that reported on a measurement of core or peripheral temperature that coincided with a measurement from the zero-heat-flux device. Study selection and quality assessment was performed independently using the Revised Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies tool (QUADAS-2). The Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations (GRADE) approach was used to summarize the strength of the evidence. Pooled estimates of the mean bias and limits of agreement with outer 95% confidence intervals (population limits of agreement) were calculated. Sixteen studies were included. The primary meta-analysis of zero-heat-flux versus core temperature consisted of 22 comparisons from 16 individual studies. Data from 952 participants with 314,137 paired measurements were included. The pooled estimate for the mean bias was 0.03 °C. Population limits of agreement, which take into consideration the between-study heterogeneity and sampling error, were wide, spanning from − 0.93 to 0.98 °C. The GRADE evidence quality rating was downgraded to moderate due to concerns about study limitations. Population limits of agreement for the sensitivity analysis restricted to studies rated as having low risk of bias across all the domains of the QUADAS-2 were similar to the primary analysis. The range of uncertainty in the accuracy of a thermometer should be taken into account when using this device to inform clinical decision-making. Clinicians should therefore consider the potential that a temperature measurement from a 3M™ Bair Hugger™ Temperature Monitoring System could be as much as 1 °C higher or lower than core temperature. Use of this device may not be appropriate in situations where a difference in temperature of less than 1 °C is important to detect.
- 2 June 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Clinical Monitoring and Computing
- Vol. 35 (1) , 39-49
Accuracy and precision of zero-heat-flux temperature measurements with the 3M™ Bair Hugger™ Temperature Monitoring System: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Zero-heat-flux thermometers provide clinicians with the ability to continuously and non-invasively monitor body temperature. These devices are increasingly being used to substitute for more invasive core temperature measurements during surgery and in critical care. The aim of this review was to determine the accuracy and precision of zero-heat-flux temperature measurements from the 3M™ Bair Hugger™ Temperature Monitoring System. Medline and EMBASE were searched for studies that reported on a measurement of core or peripheral temperature that coincided with a measurement from the zero-heat-flux device. Study selection and quality assessment was performed independently using the Revised Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies tool (QUADAS-2). The Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations (GRADE) approach was used to summarize the strength of the evidence. Pooled estimates of the mean bias and limits of agreement with outer 95% confidence intervals (population limits of agreement) were calculated. Sixteen studies were included. The primary meta-analysis of zero-heat-flux versus core temperature consisted of 22 comparisons from 16 individual studies. Data from 952 participants with 314,137 paired measurements were included. The pooled estimate for the mean bias was 0.03 °C. Population limits of agreement, which take into consideration the between-study heterogeneity and sampling error, were wide, spanning from − 0.93 to 0.98 °C. The GRADE evidence quality rating was downgraded to moderate due to concerns about study limitations. Population limits of agreement for the sensitivity analysis restricted to studies rated as having low risk of bias across all the domains of the QUADAS-2 were similar to the primary analysis. The range of uncertainty in the accuracy of a thermometer should be taken into account when using this device to inform clinical decision-making. Clinicians should therefore consider the potential that a temperature measurement from a 3M™ Bair Hugger™ Temperature Monitoring System could be as much as 1 °C higher or lower than core temperature. Use of this device may not be appropriate in situations where a difference in temperature of less than 1 °C is important to detect.