Tuomo Poutanen
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Tuomo Poutanen has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Sampsa Pursiainen
Tampere University
4 shared publications - Tim Länsivaara
Civil Engineering, Faculty of Built Environment, Tampere University, P.O. Box 600, FI-33014 Tampere, Finland
3 shared publications - Jari Mäkinen
Faculty of Built Environment, Tampere University, P.O. Box 600, FI-33014 Tampere, Finland
2 shared publications - Olli Asp
Faculty of Built Environment—Concrete and Bridge Structures Tampere University Tampere Finland
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 March 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 16 (6) , 3002
Deterministic Structural Design
Current structural design codes use a stochastic approach (SC) in load combination and reliability calculation. This article presents a design model with a deterministic (DC) approach. Currently, design codes have variable load factors (γG ≠ γQ) and constant safety factors (γM) for all loads. This approach makes two significant approximations: It assumes a single material factor for all ratios of permanent to variable loads and across all types of variable loads. This research proposes the opposite strategy: instead of a single material factor, each load is assigned to its own material factor. Such a shift removes those approximations, simplifies codes, and reduces calculation effort. A central challenge in reliability assessment is combining loads. Existing SC methods differ in their reference time and target reliability. The fundamental fact of load–material interaction is that each load acts independently, without influencing others. This deduction results in the DC combination. Safety factors within the Eurocode framework are derived using today’s semi-probabilistic SC methods and a fully probabilistic DC approach. The proposed design model is straightforward, requires minimal computation, meets the target reliability, and yields significant savings in material use.
- 20 March 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 16 (6) , 3002
Open AccessDeterministic Structural Design
Current structural design codes use a stochastic approach (SC) in load combination and reliability calculation. This article presents a design model with a deterministic (DC) approach. Currently, design codes have variable load factors (γG ≠ γQ) and constant safety factors (γM) for all loads. This approach makes two significant approximations: It assumes a single material factor for all ratios of permanent to variable loads and across all types of variable loads. This research proposes the opposite strategy: instead of a single material factor, each load is assigned to its own material factor. Such a shift removes those approximations, simplifies codes, and reduces calculation effort. A central challenge in reliability assessment is combining loads. Existing SC methods differ in their reference time and target reliability. The fundamental fact of load–material interaction is that each load acts independently, without influencing others. This deduction results in the DC combination. Safety factors within the Eurocode framework are derived using today’s semi-probabilistic SC methods and a fully probabilistic DC approach. The proposed design model is straightforward, requires minimal computation, meets the target reliability, and yields significant savings in material use.
- Open Access
- 19 March 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 16 (6) , 2965
Structural Loads Should Be Combined Deterministically
Current structural reliability calculations are typically based on combinations of load pairs. However, there is no consensus on key aspects such as the reference time, the target reliability, or the choice between a stochastic and independent (SC) versus a deterministic and dependent (DC) approach. This article shifts the focus from load–pair combinations to individual load–material pairs and evaluates structural reliability using both the existing Eurocode methodology and a new approach based on 50-year loads and 50-year target reliability as well as the DC framework. The aim is to provide a more consistent and transparent basis for reliability assessment in structural design.
- 19 March 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 16 (6) , 2965
Open AccessStructural Loads Should Be Combined Deterministically
Current structural reliability calculations are typically based on combinations of load pairs. However, there is no consensus on key aspects such as the reference time, the target reliability, or the choice between a stochastic and independent (SC) versus a deterministic and dependent (DC) approach. This article shifts the focus from load–pair combinations to individual load–material pairs and evaluates structural reliability using both the existing Eurocode methodology and a new approach based on 50-year loads and 50-year target reliability as well as the DC framework. The aim is to provide a more consistent and transparent basis for reliability assessment in structural design.
- Open Access
- 24 July 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 14 (15) , 6466
Combination of Variable Loads in Structural Design
This study delves into the intricacies of variable load combination factors (ψ) within structural codes under fundamental design scenarios, with Eurocodes serving as the primary reference. Currently, variable loads are combined by adding one load, the leading load with its full value, and the other load, the accompanying load, with a reduced value multiplied by a combination factor ψ. This approach employs an independent load combination methodology, utilizing hypothetical reference materials. In contrast, this paper advocates for a shift towards dependent load combination, anchored in the use of actual reference materials. Specifically, it is proposed that imposed loads be combined without the combination factor, i.e., ψ = 1. Given that combination factors are in approximate unity or pertain to infrequent load cases, this research recommends the elimination of ψ from codes altogether. This recommendation stems from the recognition that the current combination factor calculation excels in cases with approximately equal loads with a significant reliability gain, while more frequent unequal loads introduce a minor reliability gain and harmful unsafe errors. Despite the overall minor safety advantage of about 2–3% being negligible considering unavoidable safe errors of about 7% in codes, this simplification significantly reduces code complexity, enhances user-friendliness, and substantially decreases the workload associated with design processes.
- 24 July 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 14 (15) , 6466
Open AccessCombination of Variable Loads in Structural Design
This study delves into the intricacies of variable load combination factors (ψ) within structural codes under fundamental design scenarios, with Eurocodes serving as the primary reference. Currently, variable loads are combined by adding one load, the leading load with its full value, and the other load, the accompanying load, with a reduced value multiplied by a combination factor ψ. This approach employs an independent load combination methodology, utilizing hypothetical reference materials. In contrast, this paper advocates for a shift towards dependent load combination, anchored in the use of actual reference materials. Specifically, it is proposed that imposed loads be combined without the combination factor, i.e., ψ = 1. Given that combination factors are in approximate unity or pertain to infrequent load cases, this research recommends the elimination of ψ from codes altogether. This recommendation stems from the recognition that the current combination factor calculation excels in cases with approximately equal loads with a significant reliability gain, while more frequent unequal loads introduce a minor reliability gain and harmful unsafe errors. Despite the overall minor safety advantage of about 2–3% being negligible considering unavoidable safe errors of about 7% in codes, this simplification significantly reduces code complexity, enhances user-friendliness, and substantially decreases the workload associated with design processes.
- Open Access
- 12 June 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 11 (12) , 5474
Code Calibration of the Eurocodes
This article addresses the process to optimally select safety factors and characteristic values for the Eurocodes. Five amendments to the present codes are proposed: (1) The load factors are fixed, γG = γQ, by making the characteristic load of the variable load changeable, it simplifies the codes and lessens the calculation work. (2) Currently, the characteristic load of the variable load is the same for all variable loads. It creates excess safety and material waste for the variable loads with low variation. This deficiency can be avoided by applying the same amendment as above. (3) Various materials fit with different accuracy in the reliability model. This article explains two options to reduce this difficulty. (4) A method to avoid rounding errors in the safety factors is explained. (5) The current safety factors are usually set by minimizing the reliability indexes regarding the target when the obtained codes include considerable safe and unsafe design cases with the variability ratio (high reliability/low) of about 1.4. The proposed three code models match the target β50 = 3.2 with high accuracy, no unsafe design cases and insignificant safe design cases with the variability ratio 1.07, 1.03 and 1.04.
- 12 June 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 11 (12) , 5474
Open AccessCode Calibration of the Eurocodes
This article addresses the process to optimally select safety factors and characteristic values for the Eurocodes. Five amendments to the present codes are proposed: (1) The load factors are fixed, γG = γQ, by making the characteristic load of the variable load changeable, it simplifies the codes and lessens the calculation work. (2) Currently, the characteristic load of the variable load is the same for all variable loads. It creates excess safety and material waste for the variable loads with low variation. This deficiency can be avoided by applying the same amendment as above. (3) Various materials fit with different accuracy in the reliability model. This article explains two options to reduce this difficulty. (4) A method to avoid rounding errors in the safety factors is explained. (5) The current safety factors are usually set by minimizing the reliability indexes regarding the target when the obtained codes include considerable safe and unsafe design cases with the variability ratio (high reliability/low) of about 1.4. The proposed three code models match the target β50 = 3.2 with high accuracy, no unsafe design cases and insignificant safe design cases with the variability ratio 1.07, 1.03 and 1.04.
- Open Access
- 13 May 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 11 (10) , 4434
Combination of Permanent and Variable Load Is Dependent
This study concerns the combination of the permanent and the variable loads in the structural design. The Eurocodes are used as a reference. Three new findings are presented: (1) In each physical structure, and in every load pair of the permanent load and the variable load, the maximum variable load is the service time load, the 50-year load, i.e., the high value of the variable load. Therefore, no load reduction should be applied in the combination. (2) The governing hypothesis is the independent load combination (ILC) with random load pairs and random single loads. However, the load pairs are not independent as normally one variable load occurs simultaneously in multiple structures and in multiple load pairs inducing correlation between the loads, ultimately full correlation, and the dependent load combination (DLC). (3) In the current Eurocodes, the design load combination applies to one load pair only. However, one design load combination virtually always applies to multiple load pairs which demands using the DLC. The authors have explained earlier that the permanent and variable loads should be combined dependently as the ILC contradicts the physics. The new findings support this conclusion. Changing the current codes towards the DLC approach would simplify them and eases their use in the structural design work.
- 13 May 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 11 (10) , 4434
Open AccessCombination of Permanent and Variable Load Is Dependent
This study concerns the combination of the permanent and the variable loads in the structural design. The Eurocodes are used as a reference. Three new findings are presented: (1) In each physical structure, and in every load pair of the permanent load and the variable load, the maximum variable load is the service time load, the 50-year load, i.e., the high value of the variable load. Therefore, no load reduction should be applied in the combination. (2) The governing hypothesis is the independent load combination (ILC) with random load pairs and random single loads. However, the load pairs are not independent as normally one variable load occurs simultaneously in multiple structures and in multiple load pairs inducing correlation between the loads, ultimately full correlation, and the dependent load combination (DLC). (3) In the current Eurocodes, the design load combination applies to one load pair only. However, one design load combination virtually always applies to multiple load pairs which demands using the DLC. The authors have explained earlier that the permanent and variable loads should be combined dependently as the ILC contradicts the physics. The new findings support this conclusion. Changing the current codes towards the DLC approach would simplify them and eases their use in the structural design work.
- Open Access
- 11 April 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 11 (8) , 3424
Test Loading of Structures with a Suspect Resistance
The reliability of load-bearing structures is normally secured through codes, a competent structural design and proper execution inspection. Alternatively, the reliability can be obtained via skilled test loading, which is a feasible technique both in the construction of new structures and in the load-bearing verification of existing ones. Although the current codes lack instructions for test loading, they are, however, used in special cases; for example, when the reliability of the structures is doubtful due to a defect, or when the structure is suspected to have especially high resistance variability. Test loading involves significant research questions that need to be addressed, including: What is the test load in comparison with the expected maximum service time load or the characteristic load? How can the instantaneous test load be compared with the actual long-term service-time load? Does the test loading harm the structure, and what is the target reliability in the test loading calculation? In this paper, we approach these questions from a theoretical point of view and propose how a suitable test load can be chosen in practice using an approximate and a precise approach.
- 11 April 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 11 (8) , 3424
Open AccessTest Loading of Structures with a Suspect Resistance
The reliability of load-bearing structures is normally secured through codes, a competent structural design and proper execution inspection. Alternatively, the reliability can be obtained via skilled test loading, which is a feasible technique both in the construction of new structures and in the load-bearing verification of existing ones. Although the current codes lack instructions for test loading, they are, however, used in special cases; for example, when the reliability of the structures is doubtful due to a defect, or when the structure is suspected to have especially high resistance variability. Test loading involves significant research questions that need to be addressed, including: What is the test load in comparison with the expected maximum service time load or the characteristic load? How can the instantaneous test load be compared with the actual long-term service-time load? Does the test loading harm the structure, and what is the target reliability in the test loading calculation? In this paper, we approach these questions from a theoretical point of view and propose how a suitable test load can be chosen in practice using an approximate and a precise approach.
- Open Access
- 28 December 2020
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 11 (1) , 208
Calculation of Safety Factors of the Eurocodes
This study concerns the safety factor and the reliability calculation for structural codes. The Eurocodes are used as a reference. Safety factor calculation is a demanding task which necessitates using an appropriate root-solving algorithm with a sufficient numerical accuracy. This article introduces a simple algorithm to calculate the safety factors directly, as previously there has been no means to control the accuracy. Presently, the safety factors are defined indirectly through the reliability index. The basic safety factor calculation is presented here in six different equations with the same outcome but differences regarding the numerical calculation, which provides a method to check the accuracy and select a proper equation for the root solver. The safety factor calculation for the permanent and the variable load in the Eurocodes is based on the independent, i.e., random, load combination and single load pairs. The current approach of safety factor calculation applied in the Eurocodes is disclosed here. Simple analytical equations based on the convolution equation are presented. Those can be used instead of the computer programs applied currently.
- 28 December 2020
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 11 (1) , 208
Open AccessCalculation of Safety Factors of the Eurocodes
This study concerns the safety factor and the reliability calculation for structural codes. The Eurocodes are used as a reference. Safety factor calculation is a demanding task which necessitates using an appropriate root-solving algorithm with a sufficient numerical accuracy. This article introduces a simple algorithm to calculate the safety factors directly, as previously there has been no means to control the accuracy. Presently, the safety factors are defined indirectly through the reliability index. The basic safety factor calculation is presented here in six different equations with the same outcome but differences regarding the numerical calculation, which provides a method to check the accuracy and select a proper equation for the root solver. The safety factor calculation for the permanent and the variable load in the Eurocodes is based on the independent, i.e., random, load combination and single load pairs. The current approach of safety factor calculation applied in the Eurocodes is disclosed here. Simple analytical equations based on the convolution equation are presented. Those can be used instead of the computer programs applied currently.