CWCatherine L. Williams

Catherine L. Williams

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Catherine L. Williams has a total of 34 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Effects of positive or negative reinforcement history and extinction arrangement on resurgence

    by Abbie R. Cooper, Claire C. St. Peter, Catherine L. Williams

    The recurrence of previously reduced behavior following successful differential reinforcement has been termed resurgence . Across studies, resurgence has occurred following either positive or negative reinforcement, but no direct within‐experiment comparisons have been conducted. The primary purpose of the current experiments was to address this gap by comparing resurgence following a history of positive or negative reinforcement with human participants responding to earn or avoid losing money. Across experiments, we manipulated the arrangement of the resurgence test following negative reinforcement; money losses were discontinued in Experiment 1 and made inescapable during Experiment 2. Avoidance responding persisted after the discontinuation of monetary loss during Experiment 1, precluding comparisons of resurgence. Conversely, unavoidable monetary losses resulted in greater resurgence relative to discontinuation of monetary earnings during Experiment 2. The present experiments provide the first controlled within‐subject comparisons of resurgence following positive and negative reinforcement and show that the form of extinction affects avoidance responding.

  • Open Access

    Differential reinforcement using matched examples and nonexamples expedites the practice needed to learn concepts

    by Catherine L. Williams, Rebecca E. Woodard, Mackenzie R. Fowler, Brooke A. Franks‐Jacobucci

    Conceptual learning refers to correctly identifying novel examples and nonexamples of a concept. Concepts can be taught by presenting stimuli and differentially reinforcing responses to examples but not nonexamples. However, it is unclear which stimuli should be used and whether specifically designed stimuli can result in correct responding even in the absence of differential reinforcement. Stimulus selection can be informed by identifying features that a stimulus must have to be an example and can have without altering whether the stimulus is an example or a nonexample. Previous research suggests that using matched examples and nonexamples (the same can‐have features present) may expedite this learning. Experiment 1 compared acquisition and conceptual learning following practice with matched and unmatched examples and nonexamples lacking exactly one must‐have feature. Participants made fewer errors and completed practice faster with matched examples and nonexamples. Both practice conditions produced similar conceptual learning. Some participants also responded accurately during baseline. To evaluate whether the testing stimuli would produce conceptual learning in the absence of differential reinforcement, Experiment 2 compared conceptual learning without any practice. No conceptual learning was observed. The results support using matched examples and nonexamples for additional research on conceptual learning in classroom and laboratory settings.

  • Delay discounting of treatment outcomes by caregivers of children undergoing different behavior‐analytic interventions

    by Nathan A. Call, Mindy C. Scheithauer, Alec M. Bernstein, Scott E. Gillespie, Catherine L. Williams, Meara X. H. McMahon, Daniel R. Mitteer

    Outcomes of behavior‐analytic interventions implemented with children can be mediated by the behavior of their caregivers, such as when they are called upon to implement treatments in natural settings. However, those outcomes are also often delayed, and humans have shown a decreased sensitivity to delayed reinforcement. This study replicated prior research on discounting of delayed treatment outcomes by caregivers of children receiving behavior‐analytic interventions for dangerous or destructive behavior. It also compared sensitivity to delays by these caregivers with that of caregivers of children undergoing interventions focused on skill acquisition and to address food selectivity or refusal. Results demonstrated that caregivers of children receiving each type of behavior‐analytic intervention discounted the value of delayed treatment outcomes. Caregivers of children undergoing intervention for dangerous or destructive behavior discounted the value of delayed treatment outcomes significantly more than those whose children were undergoing intervention focused on skill acquisition, indicating that immediacy was particularly important for those caregivers.

  • Open Access

    Instruction consisting of a rule and set of examples and nonexamples reliably teaches concepts

    by Catherine L. Williams, Jennifer C. Roop

    Conceptual learning is discrimination between new examples and nonexamples and generalization to new examples. Conceptual learning can be demonstrated after practice with differential reinforcement of the correct response and is influenced by procedural variables during practice. However, less research has been done identifying an ideal structure for instruction (rules), which is likely a typical teaching format for learners with more advanced verbal repertoires. We developed a laboratory analog of conceptual instruction to evaluate conceptual learning following instruction made up of a rule describing the key features of the concept and examples and nonexamples that were carefully selected to demonstrate these rules. We also evaluated the efficacy of this instruction when it preceded or followed practice with feedback about accuracy but no rule presentation. All participants completed instruction and practice. The specific instructional sequence was completed before practice during Experiment 1 and after practice during Experiment 2. This instructional sequence reliably and rapidly resulted in concept learning regardless of whether it was completed before or after practice. Practice alone never produced conceptual learning within the duration of the session and was not necessary to produce conceptual learning. Instructors should evaluate the efficacy of this instructional sequence to teach concepts.


  • Scholarship as an operant class: Strategies and tactics for increasing dissemination of applied behavior analysis

    by Nathan A. Call, Catherine L. Williams, Joanna Lomas Mevers, Tracy Argueta

    Dissemination of applied behavior analytic scholarship to those outside the field can produce potent reinforcers. This discussion proposes that increasing dissemination requires the application of behavior analytic principles to scholarly behavior by applied behavior analysts. Its major premise is that increasing consumption of products of applied behavior analytic scholarship by those from outside the field requires distinct strategies to (a) attract individuals from outside the field to traditional outlets for applied behavior analytic scholarship and (b) increase the frequency of applied behavior analytic scholarship appearing in outlets that do not regularly feature it. A critical element of both strategies is the judicious adoption of methods or terminology from other disciplines. However, different approaches are required to implement each strategy. Practical tactics for individual applied behavior analysts to contribute to both strategies are also discussed.


  • Initial Suppression of Escape Behavior Across Three Behavioral Treatments

    by Sarah K. Slocum, Alec M. Bernstein, Catherine L. Williams, Timothy R. Vollmer

    Prevalence reports continue to indicate that social‐negative reinforcement is the most likely reinforcer for challenging behavior. Although there are several well‐established, durable treatments for escape‐maintained challenging behavior, some situations require the immediate suppression of challenging behavior while working toward a return to instruction completion. Little is known about the initial suppressive effects of treatments. We randomly assigned 22 children with escape‐maintained challenging behavior to one of three treatments—differential negative reinforcement with escape extinction, differential positive reinforcement without escape extinction, or instructional fading without escape extinction—and evaluated the initial suppression of challenging behavior during the first 10 treatment sessions. Both interventions without escape extinction led to more rapid immediate suppression compared to differential negative reinforcement with escape extinction. Differential positive reinforcement or instructional fading may be preferential interventions when the goal is an immediate reduction of severe or dangerous challenging behavior.


  • Open Access

    Using must‐have and can‐have features to improve conceptual learning

    by Catherine L. Williams, Claire C. St. Peter, Michael Perone, Marisela Aguilar, Benjamin A. Cederberg, Daniella J. Gregersen, Elijah J. Richardson

    Concepts can be taught by presenting examples and nonexamples and giving the learner feedback on whether they accurately identify the examples, but it is not clear how to select examples and nonexamples. Specifically, the degree to which examples and nonexamples should differ is unknown. Six experiments were conducted to compare conceptual learning for four stimulus sets (three sets of arbitrary stimuli and one set of biological stimuli) across up to three practice conditions: (a) nonexamples that were relatively similar to the examples, (b) nonexamples that were relatively dissimilar to the examples, and (c) examples only. Conceptual learning was measured before and after practice using tests with examples and nonexamples that were not used during practice. Including nonexamples in practice increased the likelihood of conceptual learning relative to including only examples. Using nonexamples that were more similar to the examples resulted in the most robust conceptual learning. Adding new but conceptually irrelevant features to the testing stimuli disrupted conceptual learning but less so when the practice included nonexamples that were more similar to the examples. The efficacy and efficiency of instruction for conceptual learning were affected by features of the stimuli used to practice and test conceptual learning.


  • Correction to: Time-Out During Alternative Reinforcement Does Not Reduce Resurgence: An Exploratory Study

    by Alexander L. Houchins, Catherine L. Williams, Claire C. St. Peter

  • Descriptive characteristics of extinction bursts: A record review

    by Colin Muething, Tom Cariveau, Summer Bottini, Sarah Slocum, Catherine Williams, Scott Gillespie, Mindy Scheithauer

    Procedural extinction is sometimes associated with a temporary increase in responding known as an extinction burst. Extinction bursts present unique challenges in the context of treating behavior targeted for reduction. The present study updates the prevalence of extinction bursts using a clinical sample (N = 108) receiving treatment for targeted behavior. The prevalence of extinction bursts in our sample (24%) was consistent with that in prior literature. The extinction‐burst magnitude decreased across sessions after extinction was contacted during treatment, but this sample did not demonstrate decreased persistence or magnitude of extinction bursts across successive transitions from baseline to treatment. We also examined the prevalence and magnitude of extinction bursts based on the function and topography of targeted behavior and treatment components and found no consistent relation among these variables. These findings should lead clinicians to prepare for transient extinction bursts when implementing extinction‐based treatment for challenging behavior.