Janine Ubink
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Janine Ubink has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Joanna Pickering
Former researcher at Land and Accountability Research Centre, Faculty of Law, University of Cape Town, Paris, South Africa
2 shared publicationsAninka Claassens
Land and Accountability Research Centre in the Faculty of Law, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa
1 shared publicationAnne Jonker
Master Law & Society: Governance and Global Development, Leiden Law School, Leiden, The Netherlands
1 shared publicationBernardo Almeida
Van Vollenhoven Institute for Law, Governance and Society, Leiden University, The Netherlands
1 shared publication- Bernardo Almeida
Leiden University College
1 shared publication - Thiyane Duda
Land and Accountability Research Centre, University of Cape Town
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 3 May 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Legal Pluralism and Critical Social Analysis
- Vol. 56 (2) , 236-264
The mine, the community, and the chief–mining governance and community representation in conditions of legal pluralism
- 3 May 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Legal Pluralism and Critical Social Analysis
- Vol. 56 (2) , 236-264
Open AccessThe mine, the community, and the chief–mining governance and community representation in conditions of legal pluralism
- Open Access
- 15 June 2023
- Published by Cogitatio in Politics and Governance
- Vol. 11 (2) , 357-367
Local Self‐Governance and the State in South Sudan: Studying Gendered Tenure Relations in Times of Uncertainty
With governance increasingly regarded as co-governance, states’ capacity to steer, correct, and discipline a wide range of self-governing actors becomes crucial for states’ effectiveness, efficiency, and democracy. This article investigates that capacity and the relationship between formal institutions and customary self-governance in areas of limited statehood. In South Sudan, the field of land governance can be regarded as an area of limited statehood. As land relations are closely connected to clan structures and intra-familial relationships, customary norms and institutions enjoy great legitimacy and are an important locus of local land governance and dispute resolution. The South Sudanese government has promulgated legal provisions for equal rights to property and inheritance that clash head-on with customary notions of gender roles in the family and the preservation of family land. By focusing on the case of women’s land rights in South Sudan, combining literature study with data from exploratory fieldwork in two South Sudanese towns, this article aims to reflect on the cohabitation of customary and formal norms and values and the role formal legal and administrative systems, in areas of limited statehood, can and do play in boundary setting for customary self-governance.
- 15 June 2023
- Published by Cogitatio in Politics and Governance
- Vol. 11 (2) , 357-367
Open AccessLocal Self‐Governance and the State in South Sudan: Studying Gendered Tenure Relations in Times of Uncertainty
With governance increasingly regarded as co-governance, states’ capacity to steer, correct, and discipline a wide range of self-governing actors becomes crucial for states’ effectiveness, efficiency, and democracy. This article investigates that capacity and the relationship between formal institutions and customary self-governance in areas of limited statehood. In South Sudan, the field of land governance can be regarded as an area of limited statehood. As land relations are closely connected to clan structures and intra-familial relationships, customary norms and institutions enjoy great legitimacy and are an important locus of local land governance and dispute resolution. The South Sudanese government has promulgated legal provisions for equal rights to property and inheritance that clash head-on with customary notions of gender roles in the family and the preservation of family land. By focusing on the case of women’s land rights in South Sudan, combining literature study with data from exploratory fieldwork in two South Sudanese towns, this article aims to reflect on the cohabitation of customary and formal norms and values and the role formal legal and administrative systems, in areas of limited statehood, can and do play in boundary setting for customary self-governance.
- Open Access
- 12 May 2023
- Published by Utrecht University School of Law in Utrecht Law Review
- Vol. 19 (2) , 44-57
Community Mediators in South Sudan: Empirical Legitimacy and Post-conflict Rule of Law Building
The scholarship on legitimacy of dispute settlement institutions has largely ignored community mediation institutions operating in the global south. This article aims to remedy that gap, through a case study of community mediation groups in South Sudan, a state emerging from large-scale conflict where formal courts are only marginally able to fulfill their assigned roles and the rule of law needs to be built almost from the ground-up. The article studies both the empirical legitimacy of the community mediation groups and how they relate to the rule of law building project in the country. Is the empirical legitimacy of formal and informal dispute settlement institutions as a zero-sum relationship, where increasing popularity and use of informal dispute settlement institutions detract from the popularity and empirical legitimacy of formal institutions, inhibiting the maturation of the legal system and a rule of law? Or could informal dispute settlement institutions – with proper linkages to the formal system – strengthen formal institutions, both judicial and administrative? These are highly relevant questions for post-conflict states where building a well-functioning legal system is seen as a precondition for sustainable peace and development.
- 12 May 2023
- Published by Utrecht University School of Law in Utrecht Law Review
- Vol. 19 (2) , 44-57
Open AccessCommunity Mediators in South Sudan: Empirical Legitimacy and Post-conflict Rule of Law Building
The scholarship on legitimacy of dispute settlement institutions has largely ignored community mediation institutions operating in the global south. This article aims to remedy that gap, through a case study of community mediation groups in South Sudan, a state emerging from large-scale conflict where formal courts are only marginally able to fulfill their assigned roles and the rule of law needs to be built almost from the ground-up. The article studies both the empirical legitimacy of the community mediation groups and how they relate to the rule of law building project in the country. Is the empirical legitimacy of formal and informal dispute settlement institutions as a zero-sum relationship, where increasing popularity and use of informal dispute settlement institutions detract from the popularity and empirical legitimacy of formal institutions, inhibiting the maturation of the legal system and a rule of law? Or could informal dispute settlement institutions – with proper linkages to the formal system – strengthen formal institutions, both judicial and administrative? These are highly relevant questions for post-conflict states where building a well-functioning legal system is seen as a precondition for sustainable peace and development.
- Open Access
- 2 September 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law
- Vol. 53 (3) , 498-521
An exploration of legal pluralism, power and custom in South Africa. A conversation with Aninka Claassens
Aninka Claassens is an academic and practitioner who has worked since 1982 as a land activist and academic in the field of legal pluralism in South Africa. During the apartheid era she worked for t...
- 2 September 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law
- Vol. 53 (3) , 498-521
Open AccessAn exploration of legal pluralism, power and custom in South Africa. A conversation with Aninka Claassens
Aninka Claassens is an academic and practitioner who has worked since 1982 as a land activist and academic in the field of legal pluralism in South Africa. During the apartheid era she worked for t...
- Open Access
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Southern African Studies
- Vol. 47 (2) , 191-208
Traditional Authority in South Africa: Reconstruction and Resistance in the Eastern Cape
This article examines two contradictory conceptions of customary law, as either fundamentally democratic or autocratic, and their impact on the constant reconstruction of and resistance to chiefly authority in modern-day South Africa. In the last 15 years or so South Africa has witnessed a strong legislative agenda to centralise the power of senior traditional leaders. The new traditional authority laws’ ahistorical, authoritarian understanding of customary law – as something to be defined and imposed on rural communities by senior traditional leaders – is directly opposed to the Constitutional Court’s interpretation of customary law as something to be determined with reference to practice from and acceptance by the people whose customary law is under consideration. This article studies the net result of these contradictory processes on local contestations over chiefly power in the Eastern Cape. It displays the state’s concerted efforts to impose a model of traditional authority that empowers senior traditional leaders, even in contexts where local communities strongly contest this model, arguing that it contravenes their custom and history, as well as their democratic rights. The article highlights the enduring legacy of apartheid constructions, and the powerful role of contemporary governments in their recreation. New laws are an important tool in this process. They entrench an apartheid model of traditional leaders and minimise rural democracy. It is only with serious efforts of community mobilisation and legal education and support that local communities can successfully access the courts to challenge the actions taken by an alliance of chiefs and state. Ultimately, our analysis highlights an understudied link between the functioning and legitimacy of chiefs in democratic states and the autocratic or democratic conception of the customary law underlying the powers of such chiefs.
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Southern African Studies
- Vol. 47 (2) , 191-208
Open AccessTraditional Authority in South Africa: Reconstruction and Resistance in the Eastern Cape
This article examines two contradictory conceptions of customary law, as either fundamentally democratic or autocratic, and their impact on the constant reconstruction of and resistance to chiefly authority in modern-day South Africa. In the last 15 years or so South Africa has witnessed a strong legislative agenda to centralise the power of senior traditional leaders. The new traditional authority laws’ ahistorical, authoritarian understanding of customary law – as something to be defined and imposed on rural communities by senior traditional leaders – is directly opposed to the Constitutional Court’s interpretation of customary law as something to be determined with reference to practice from and acceptance by the people whose customary law is under consideration. This article studies the net result of these contradictory processes on local contestations over chiefly power in the Eastern Cape. It displays the state’s concerted efforts to impose a model of traditional authority that empowers senior traditional leaders, even in contexts where local communities strongly contest this model, arguing that it contravenes their custom and history, as well as their democratic rights. The article highlights the enduring legacy of apartheid constructions, and the powerful role of contemporary governments in their recreation. New laws are an important tool in this process. They entrench an apartheid model of traditional leaders and minimise rural democracy. It is only with serious efforts of community mobilisation and legal education and support that local communities can successfully access the courts to challenge the actions taken by an alliance of chiefs and state. Ultimately, our analysis highlights an understudied link between the functioning and legitimacy of chiefs in democratic states and the autocratic or democratic conception of the customary law underlying the powers of such chiefs.
- Open Access
- 2 July 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in South African Journal on Human Rights
- Vol. 36 (2-3) , 178-199
Shaping legal and institutional pluralism: land rights, access to justice and citizenship in South Africa
In November 2019, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa signed the Traditional and Khoi-San Leadership Bill into law. The Act forms part of a broader package of recent laws and proposed legislation regulating traditional leadership, which have been strongly critiqued for undermining the property and citizenship rights of South Africans residing in the former homelands. The Act is most strongly contested for providing traditional councils with the power to conclude agreements with companies on behalf of their communities. Mining deals are at the forefront of this debate, and the site of this study. Combining literature study and legal analysis with unique data obtained through interviews and participant observation, this article analyses how the new shape of legal and institutional pluralism affects the rights, strategies and access to justice of rural people in mining areas. It shows how laws regulating traditional authority and mining together paint a veneer of legality over mining deals that in fact infringe on the land rights of rural citizens who, both according to customary law and the Interim Protection of Informal Land Rights Act, have a say regarding their own land. Their residence in so-called traditional communities impedes their enjoyment of the same effective political and property rights as the rest of South Africa’s population.
- 2 July 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in South African Journal on Human Rights
- Vol. 36 (2-3) , 178-199
Open AccessShaping legal and institutional pluralism: land rights, access to justice and citizenship in South Africa
In November 2019, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa signed the Traditional and Khoi-San Leadership Bill into law. The Act forms part of a broader package of recent laws and proposed legislation regulating traditional leadership, which have been strongly critiqued for undermining the property and citizenship rights of South Africans residing in the former homelands. The Act is most strongly contested for providing traditional councils with the power to conclude agreements with companies on behalf of their communities. Mining deals are at the forefront of this debate, and the site of this study. Combining literature study and legal analysis with unique data obtained through interviews and participant observation, this article analyses how the new shape of legal and institutional pluralism affects the rights, strategies and access to justice of rural people in mining areas. It shows how laws regulating traditional authority and mining together paint a veneer of legality over mining deals that in fact infringe on the land rights of rural citizens who, both according to customary law and the Interim Protection of Informal Land Rights Act, have a say regarding their own land. Their residence in so-called traditional communities impedes their enjoyment of the same effective political and property rights as the rest of South Africa’s population.