Galina Shavard
Research Subjects
Galina Shavard has a total of 2 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Hilde Wågsås Afdal
Faculty of Education and languages, Østfold University College
1 shared publication - Sølvi Mausethagen
OsloMet – storbyuniversitetet. Postboks 4
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 11 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 19-33
Redefining teacher quality in the context of increased accountability in Norway
This chapter explores developments in how teachers’ professional ethics are practiced within a context of increased accountability. Professional ethics are seen at a broader level as it is practiced in the profession within a contested and dynamic educational policy in which teacher quality is being continuously redefined. Drawing on recent research conducted in the Norwegian context, the analysis shows that increased political expectations to use broader professional knowledge, student performance data to support learning, and more collaborative approaches to practice development have actualized new dimensions of professional ethics. These are related to evaluating the validity and relevance of professional knowledge, including the role of student performance data in promoting such values as educational equality, social mobility, and inclusion. Using empirical examples, we illustrate that the way professional ethics are being practiced makes value-laden, ethical dilemmas underlying professional practice more visible. We conclude that the new dimensions of professional ethics direct attention beyond the micro-level of situated ethics of care and classroom interactions to a macro-level of broader professional values and the social mandate. This suggests a more collective understanding of teacher quality, one related more closely to the quality of collectively developed professional knowledge and knowledge practices at schools than to teachers’ individual performances.
- 11 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 19-33
Redefining teacher quality in the context of increased accountability in Norway
This chapter explores developments in how teachers’ professional ethics are practiced within a context of increased accountability. Professional ethics are seen at a broader level as it is practiced in the profession within a contested and dynamic educational policy in which teacher quality is being continuously redefined. Drawing on recent research conducted in the Norwegian context, the analysis shows that increased political expectations to use broader professional knowledge, student performance data to support learning, and more collaborative approaches to practice development have actualized new dimensions of professional ethics. These are related to evaluating the validity and relevance of professional knowledge, including the role of student performance data in promoting such values as educational equality, social mobility, and inclusion. Using empirical examples, we illustrate that the way professional ethics are being practiced makes value-laden, ethical dilemmas underlying professional practice more visible. We conclude that the new dimensions of professional ethics direct attention beyond the micro-level of situated ethics of care and classroom interactions to a macro-level of broader professional values and the social mandate. This suggests a more collective understanding of teacher quality, one related more closely to the quality of collectively developed professional knowledge and knowledge practices at schools than to teachers’ individual performances.
- 12 April 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice
- Vol. 28 (5) , 555-567
Teacher agency in collaborative lesson planning: stabilising or transforming professional practice?
The article explores how space for professional agency is structured and used by teachers in collaborative professional development. Taking an ecological perspective on teacher agency and using a case study of with multiple data sets, the analysis identifies two patterns of agentic orientations. The conclusions discuss limitations associated with a primary focus on accumulating past experiences and little engagement with aspirations for the future in contexts for collaborative professional development.
- 12 April 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice
- Vol. 28 (5) , 555-567
Teacher agency in collaborative lesson planning: stabilising or transforming professional practice?
The article explores how space for professional agency is structured and used by teachers in collaborative professional development. Taking an ecological perspective on teacher agency and using a case study of with multiple data sets, the analysis identifies two patterns of agentic orientations. The conclusions discuss limitations associated with a primary focus on accumulating past experiences and little engagement with aspirations for the future in contexts for collaborative professional development.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research
- Vol. 67 (5) , 741-753
Teachers’ Collaborative Work at the Boundaries of Professional Responsibility for Student Wellbeing
Wellbeing is a current theme in educational policy. However, responsibility for ensuring student wellbeing is an underexplored aspect of teacher professionalism. Although the scope and boundaries of those responsibilities are becoming to a greater extent defined externally, this does not make teachers’ work more straightforward. This article examines how teachers handle ambiguity and tensions in order to find practical solutions in routine work with issues of student wellbeing. Extended observations of collaborative work in a Norwegian primary school and interviews with teachers form the dataset. The analysis centres on different patterns of handling ambiguity and tensions in everyday work. The conclusions highlight the significance of workplace collaborative contexts oriented toward making the complexity and underlying normative tensions of wellbeing work more visible and approachable.
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research
- Vol. 67 (5) , 741-753
Open AccessTeachers’ Collaborative Work at the Boundaries of Professional Responsibility for Student Wellbeing
Wellbeing is a current theme in educational policy. However, responsibility for ensuring student wellbeing is an underexplored aspect of teacher professionalism. Although the scope and boundaries of those responsibilities are becoming to a greater extent defined externally, this does not make teachers’ work more straightforward. This article examines how teachers handle ambiguity and tensions in order to find practical solutions in routine work with issues of student wellbeing. Extended observations of collaborative work in a Norwegian primary school and interviews with teachers form the dataset. The analysis centres on different patterns of handling ambiguity and tensions in everyday work. The conclusions highlight the significance of workplace collaborative contexts oriented toward making the complexity and underlying normative tensions of wellbeing work more visible and approachable.
- Open Access
- 25 January 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Professional Development in Education
- Vol. 48 (3) , 493-505
From school improvement to student cases: teacher collaborative work as a context for professional development
Research has extensively linked teacher collaborative work with opportunities for both explicit and implicit professional development. However, while teachers work together more often than before, little is known about how workplace collaborative contexts are structured in terms of who and how frames the problems of practice. Drawing on an ethnographically inspired case study, this article examines three common collaborative contexts and discusses how and why different ways of structuring them through problem framing mattered for professional development. The findings reveal that the context intended for school improvement offered only incidental opportunities for teachers to engage in problem framing. The ‘work works’ question was central in structuring the contexts intended for professional development and often acted as a limiting frame. In contrast, teachers’ work with student cases involved broader opportunities for explorative problem framing. The analysis emphasises the role of framing questions in structuring teacher collaborative work.
- 25 January 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Professional Development in Education
- Vol. 48 (3) , 493-505
Open AccessFrom school improvement to student cases: teacher collaborative work as a context for professional development
Research has extensively linked teacher collaborative work with opportunities for both explicit and implicit professional development. However, while teachers work together more often than before, little is known about how workplace collaborative contexts are structured in terms of who and how frames the problems of practice. Drawing on an ethnographically inspired case study, this article examines three common collaborative contexts and discusses how and why different ways of structuring them through problem framing mattered for professional development. The findings reveal that the context intended for school improvement offered only incidental opportunities for teachers to engage in problem framing. The ‘work works’ question was central in structuring the contexts intended for professional development and often acted as a limiting frame. In contrast, teachers’ work with student cases involved broader opportunities for explorative problem framing. The analysis emphasises the role of framing questions in structuring teacher collaborative work.