NMNatalja Menold

Natalja Menold

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Natalja Menold has a total of 49 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Gütekriterien quantitativer Sozialforschung

    by Natalja Menold, Dagmar Krebs

  • Offene Fragen

    by Natalja Menold, Cornelia Züll, Peter Winker

  • Open Access

    Differential Item Functioning Can Explain Mean Differences in Mental Health Between Ethnic Groups

    by Natalja Menold

    This paper examines whether measurement non-invariance introduces bias into comparisons of means across language groups, leading to spurious findings. A probabilistic sample was taken from three large cities in a German federal state (N = 542), and mail invitations to a web survey were sent out in two languages (German and Arabic). Mental and physical health were evaluated with the Short-Form Health Survey (SF-12). Participants were randomly assigned to either a baseline SF-12 version or an adapted version developed through cognitive pretesting. Reliability and validity were evaluated using Structural Equation Models (SEM) to ensure nomological and criterion validity and to confirm that the SF-12 versions were parallel. Multiple Indicators Multiple Causes (MIMIC) models were implemented. Substantial non-invariance was identified in the mental health subscale of the baseline version, leading to an overestimation of ethnic group latent mean differences. Measurement non-invariance can lead to overestimation of ethnic health disparities. In addition to ensuring construct validity and reliability, uniform measurement invariance should be established or controlled for before interpreting mean differences among groups.

  • Open Access

    Towards the assessment of financial distress among cancer patients: a conceptual model of the financial effects of a tumour disease

    by Sophie Pauge, Andrea Züger, Luise Richter, Viktoria Mathies, Bastian Surmann, Thomas Ernst, Natalja Menold, Wolfgang Greiner, Eva C. Winkler, Katja Mehlis

    Purpose: A conceptualisation of subjective financial distress as a consequence of a cancer diagnosis and treatment is still missing due to a lack of a comprehensive model accounting for all relevant dimensions of financial effects of cancer experienced by patients. Our goal was to derive a model for the German healthcare system to shed light on the complex process of financial effects of cancer. Methods: The model was developed through systematic literature review and qualitative studies, including interviews with 18 cancer patients and a focus group with 4 social services representatives. The iterative process of model development was accompanied by an ongoing exchange in the interdisciplinary research team. Results: The developed model of financial effects of cancer experienced by patients consists of three dimensions: (1) actual and anticipated financial disadvantages , (2) behavioural and cognitive coping strategies , and (3) subjective financial distress conceptualised as negative effects in different aspects of daily living: employment , living situation , family , social participation , health promoting lifestyle , additional personally preferred treatments , navigating the health system , and a further area so-called unspecific. Conclusion: Subjective financial distress is driven by different financial effects of cancer experienced by patients and is perceived as negative in various aspects of daily living. While the identified categories of daily living can be observed in countries with universal healthcare coverage, the content and degree of each subcategory depend on country-specific characteristics. The introduced model can be used to inform the development of a new patient-reported outcome measure (PROM). Trial registration number: NCT05319925 (registration date, 2022-06-01)

  • Open Access

    Effect of Cognitive Pretests on Measurement Invariance and Reliability in Quality of Life Measures: An Evaluation in Refugee Studies

    by Natalja Menold

    The issue evaluated was how cross-cultural cognitive pretests affect the reliability and comparability of data when studying refugees and using cross-language comparisons. Three instruments employed to assess general and health-related quality of life were revised based on the findings of cognitive pretests. The versions before and after cognitive pretests were randomly assigned to respondents in two web survey studies. The first study recruited Arabic and Dari speaking refugees (N = 3448) via Facebook. The second study used a random sample (N = 610) of Arabic-speaking refugees and the German-speaking population. The comparability of data was evaluated by means of two popular measurement invariance analysis methods (exact and Bayesian measurement invariance analysis). These methods rely on factor analysis and thus enable the evaluation of the comparability of factor structure (configural invariance), the loadings or weights an item has on the factor (metric invariance), and the intercepts of an item on latent factor (scalar invariance). The revision of instruments on the basis of cognitive pretests primarily yielded positive outcomes with regard to reliability and cross-language comparability with respect to the factorial structure and loadings. However, the outcomes pertaining to scalar invariance were more equivocal. Cognitive pretests can therefore help to improve measurement quality, but further research is needed on the cross-cultural questionnaire design to make revisions with respect to cross-cultural comparability more conclusive.


  • Open Access

    Improving Cross-Cultural Comparability of Measures on Gender and Age Stereotypes by Means of Piloting Methods

    by Natalja Menold, Patricia Hadler, Cornelia Neuert

    The study addresses the effects of piloting methods on the cross-cultural comparability and reliability of the measurement of gender and age stereotypes. We conducted a summative evaluation of expert reviews, cognitive pretests and web probing. We first piloted a gender role, an ageism, and a children stereotypes instrument in German and American English. We then randomly assigned the original and piloted versions to respondents in Germany and the United States using an online survey experiment and quota samples. No configural invariance was shown by the original instruments and the reliability of the gender role instrument was insufficiently low. The results show that piloting methods increased reliability and improved measurement invariance, although the effects varied by topic. Cross-cultural expert reviews and web probing provided more consistent results than other methods. A combination of web probing and cross-cultural expert reviews can maximize both reliability and measurement invariance.


  • Open Access

    Measuring financial distress in German cancer patients: development and validation of the Financial Distress of Cancer Assessment Tool (FIAT)

    by L. Richter, S. Pauge, K. Mehlis, A. Zueger, B. Surmann, V. Mathies, W. Greiner, T. Ernst, E.C. Winkler, N. Menold


  • Open Access

    Linking survey and Facebook data: mechanisms of consent and linkage

    by Jette Schröder, Sanja Kapidzic, Henning Silber, Florian Keusch, Natalja Menold, Christoph Beuthner


  • Open Access

    Linking Survey and Facebook Data: Mechanisms of Consent and Linkage

    by Jette Schröder, Sanja Kapidzic, Henning Silber, Florian Keusch, Natalja Menold, Christoph Beuthner

    Using a German online panel, we investigate respondents’ propensity to consent to the linkage of publicly available Facebook data to their survey data and to enable linkage post-consent. We analyze the effects of three experimental variations on consent and actual linkage: (1) the consent question wording, (2) the position of the Facebook consent question in a series of consent questions, and (3) the incentive offered. To describe potential selection bias, we consider respondents’ attitudes and sociodemographic characteristics. We found effects of consent question placement on consent and linkage, and effects of higher incentives on linkage, but we did find no effects of question wording. Our analysis showed that consent and linkage is dependent on several respondent characteristics.

  • Open Access

    Ensuring cross-cultural data comparability by means of anchoring vignettes in heterogeneous refugee samples

    by Natalja Menold, Louise Biddle, Hagen von Hermanni, Jasmin Kadel, Kayvan Bozorgmehr

    Background: Configural, metric, and scalar measurement invariance have been indicators of bias-free statistical cross-group comparisons, although they are difficult to verify in the data. Low comparability of translated questionnaires or the different understanding of response formats by respondents might lead to rejection of measurement invariance and point to comparability bias in multi-language surveys. Anchoring vignettes have been proposed as a method to control for the different understanding of response categories by respondents (the latter is referred to as differential item functioning related to response categories or rating scales: RC-DIF). We evaluate the question whether the cross-cultural comparability of data can be assured by means of anchoring vignettes or by considering socio-demographic heterogeneity as an alternative approach. Methods: We used the Health System Responsiveness (HSR) questionnaire and collected survey data in English (n = 183) and Arabic (n = 121) in a random sample of refugees in the third largest German federal state. We conducted multiple-group Confirmatory Factor Analyses (MGCFA) to analyse measurement invariance and compared the results when 1) using rescaled data on the basis of anchoring vignettes (non-parametric approach), 2) including information on RC-DIF from the analyses with anchoring vignettes as covariates (parametric approach) and 3) including socio-demographic covariates. Results: For the HSR, every level of measurement invariance between the Arabic and English languages was rejected. Implementing rescaling or modelling on the basis of anchoring vignettes provided superior results over the initial MGCFA analysis, since configural, metric and – for ordered categorical analyses—scalar invariance could not be rejected. A consideration of socio-demographic variables did not show such an improvement. Conclusions: Surveys may consider anchoring vignettes as a method to assess cross-cultural comparability of data, whereas socio-demographic variables cannot be used to improve data comparability as a standalone method. More research on the efficient implementation of anchoring vignettes and further development of methods to incorporate them when modelling measurement invariance is needed.