Hendrik Nunner
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Hendrik Nunner has a total of 37 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Vincent Buskens
Department of Sociology / ICS, Utrecht University
8 shared publications - Mirjam Kretzschmar
Julius Center for Health Sciences and Primary care, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht University, Utrecht, the Netherlands
7 shared publications - André Calero Valdez
University of Lübeck
5 shared publications - Leonard Stellbrink
University of Luebeck
5 shared publications - Alexandra Teslya
Julius Center for Health Sciences and Primary care, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht University, Utrecht, the Netherlands
4 shared publications - Jens Friedel
Max Planck Institute for Dynamics and Self-Organization, Gottingen, Germany
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 April 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 28, e80311
Rapid Epidemiological Data Collection on Social Media for COVID-19: Comparative Study Between Online Surveys and Conventional Cohorts
Background: After COVID-19 was declared a pandemic by the World Health Organization (WHO) in March 2020, global responses relied on nonpharmaceutical interventions such as physical distancing and mask mandates. These measures were guided by mathematical models built on empirical data. Although traditional methods such as surveys and observational studies provide high-quality data, they are often slow and resource-intensive. Social media polls (SMPs) offer a faster, more cost-effective alternative. Objective: This study aims to evaluate the reliability and biases of SMPs as a rapid supplementary tool for epidemiological data collection and to compare their representativeness and data quality with conventional approaches. Methods: In this cross-sectional observational study in Germany, we used SMPs to collect data on infections and demographic attributes via Twitter and Mastodon. We collected data directly on the social media platforms as well as through forwarding to an external survey via post. The time frame covered was from 2019 to 2024. Data were analyzed for infection rates, sociodemographic representativeness, and overall data quality. Results: SMPs demonstrated viability as a rapid data collection tool. Based on a sample of 6127 answers on social media and 867 responses from the external survey, the self-reported frequency of infection aligned well with conventional sources. Across all 4 studies, approximately one-third of respondents reported having never been infected, half reported having had 1 infection, and one-sixth reported having had 2 or more infections. Statistical analyses of differences between data from Twitter, Mastodon, the external survey, and conventional data showed only small effect sizes (Cohen w =0.105‐0.188). Spearman rank correlation demonstrated strong positive associations between infection dates in the external survey and conventional data (ρ=0.883, P <.001), as well as between the external survey and the Robert Koch Institute (ρ=0.640, P <.001). However, demographic analyses revealed biases in the external survey. By design, SMPs do not provide detailed demographic data, limiting options for subgroup analyses. Conclusions: We found SMPs to be a practical and cost-effective method for quickly gathering epidemiological insights. In particular, self-reported infection frequency can aid during periods of high availability of self-testing during epidemics. We demonstrate that, even with a nonrepresentative and biased sample, we were able to closely match infection numbers with Multilocal and Serial Prevalence Study of Antibodies Against Respiratory Infectious Diseases in Germany data and produce incidence trends comparable to those in official Robert Koch Institute data. One can argue that SMPs alone are insufficient for public health modeling, as they do not allow real-time monitoring of, for example, population infection rates based on serological data. They are also limited with regard to inherent demographic bias related to recruitment and the inability to collect individual-level covariates. However, they can complement traditional approaches by offering rapid, low-cost insights.
- 27 April 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 28, e80311
Open AccessRapid Epidemiological Data Collection on Social Media for COVID-19: Comparative Study Between Online Surveys and Conventional Cohorts
Background: After COVID-19 was declared a pandemic by the World Health Organization (WHO) in March 2020, global responses relied on nonpharmaceutical interventions such as physical distancing and mask mandates. These measures were guided by mathematical models built on empirical data. Although traditional methods such as surveys and observational studies provide high-quality data, they are often slow and resource-intensive. Social media polls (SMPs) offer a faster, more cost-effective alternative. Objective: This study aims to evaluate the reliability and biases of SMPs as a rapid supplementary tool for epidemiological data collection and to compare their representativeness and data quality with conventional approaches. Methods: In this cross-sectional observational study in Germany, we used SMPs to collect data on infections and demographic attributes via Twitter and Mastodon. We collected data directly on the social media platforms as well as through forwarding to an external survey via post. The time frame covered was from 2019 to 2024. Data were analyzed for infection rates, sociodemographic representativeness, and overall data quality. Results: SMPs demonstrated viability as a rapid data collection tool. Based on a sample of 6127 answers on social media and 867 responses from the external survey, the self-reported frequency of infection aligned well with conventional sources. Across all 4 studies, approximately one-third of respondents reported having never been infected, half reported having had 1 infection, and one-sixth reported having had 2 or more infections. Statistical analyses of differences between data from Twitter, Mastodon, the external survey, and conventional data showed only small effect sizes (Cohen w =0.105‐0.188). Spearman rank correlation demonstrated strong positive associations between infection dates in the external survey and conventional data (ρ=0.883, P <.001), as well as between the external survey and the Robert Koch Institute (ρ=0.640, P <.001). However, demographic analyses revealed biases in the external survey. By design, SMPs do not provide detailed demographic data, limiting options for subgroup analyses. Conclusions: We found SMPs to be a practical and cost-effective method for quickly gathering epidemiological insights. In particular, self-reported infection frequency can aid during periods of high availability of self-testing during epidemics. We demonstrate that, even with a nonrepresentative and biased sample, we were able to closely match infection numbers with Multilocal and Serial Prevalence Study of Antibodies Against Respiratory Infectious Diseases in Germany data and produce incidence trends comparable to those in official Robert Koch Institute data. One can argue that SMPs alone are insufficient for public health modeling, as they do not allow real-time monitoring of, for example, population infection rates based on serological data. They are also limited with regard to inherent demographic bias related to recruitment and the inability to collect individual-level covariates. However, they can complement traditional approaches by offering rapid, low-cost insights.
- Open Access
- 19 December 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (12) , e0338818
Impact of adherence and stringency on the effectiveness of lockdown measures: A modelling study
During the COVID-19 pandemic, lockdowns were a widely used strategy to reduce disease transmission. However, there was much debate about the optimal level of strictness and duration of lockdowns. This study considers how lockdowns impact public health opinions, which in turn influence adherence to and effectiveness of these measures. We developed an agent-based simulation model to theoretically explore the impact of health-related opinions on the effectiveness of lockdowns in controlling disease spread. We simulated these dynamics within a hypothetical population connected via a simplified contact network (Watts-Strogatz), incorporating feedback loops between disease prevalence, opinions, and behaviour, including ‘lockdown fatigue’. We explored different scenarios of lockdown implementation in our hypothetical population network by varying a threshold value of prevalence when a lockdown is initiated and the stringency of the lockdown. Our qualitative findings imply that quickly imposing a lockdown with high stringency is the most effective at reducing infection spread, provided that there is a certain degree of adherence to the lockdown among the population. Furthermore, stricter lockdowns minimize fatigue with respect to the imposed measures, since the duration of a lockdown is shorter on average in this scenario. These theoretical results imply that such lockdown policies might therefore be a beneficial, high-impact tool in containing epidemic spread, especially when supplemented by information interventions maintaining the adherence to lockdown measures.
- 19 December 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (12) , e0338818
Open AccessImpact of adherence and stringency on the effectiveness of lockdown measures: A modelling study
During the COVID-19 pandemic, lockdowns were a widely used strategy to reduce disease transmission. However, there was much debate about the optimal level of strictness and duration of lockdowns. This study considers how lockdowns impact public health opinions, which in turn influence adherence to and effectiveness of these measures. We developed an agent-based simulation model to theoretically explore the impact of health-related opinions on the effectiveness of lockdowns in controlling disease spread. We simulated these dynamics within a hypothetical population connected via a simplified contact network (Watts-Strogatz), incorporating feedback loops between disease prevalence, opinions, and behaviour, including ‘lockdown fatigue’. We explored different scenarios of lockdown implementation in our hypothetical population network by varying a threshold value of prevalence when a lockdown is initiated and the stringency of the lockdown. Our qualitative findings imply that quickly imposing a lockdown with high stringency is the most effective at reducing infection spread, provided that there is a certain degree of adherence to the lockdown among the population. Furthermore, stricter lockdowns minimize fatigue with respect to the imposed measures, since the duration of a lockdown is shorter on average in this scenario. These theoretical results imply that such lockdown policies might therefore be a beneficial, high-impact tool in containing epidemic spread, especially when supplemented by information interventions maintaining the adherence to lockdown measures.
- Open Access
- 3 September 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Rapid Data Collection for Infectious Diseases: Comparing Observational Survey Studies on Social Media with Conventional Cohort Studies (Preprint)
BACKGROUND After COVID-19 was declared a pandemic by the WHO in March 2020, global responses relied heavily on non-pharmaceutical interventions such as physical distancing and mask mandates. These measures were guided by mathematical models built on empirical data. Although traditional methods such as surveys and observational studies provide high-quality data, they are often slow and resource-intensive. Social media polls (SMPs) offer a faster, more cost-effective alternative. OBJECTIVE This study evaluates the feasibility of SMPs as a rapid supplementary tool for collecting epidemiological data and compares their representativeness and quality with conventional approaches. METHODS In this cross-sectional observational study in Germany, we utilized SMPs to collect data on infections and demographic attributes via Twitter and Mastodon. To assess data quality, SMP results were compared with conventional data sources, including the Multilocal and Serial Prevalence Study of Antibodies Against Respiratory Infectious Diseases (MuSPAD), COVID-19 Snapshot Monitoring (COSMO) survey, official Robert-Koch-Institute reports, and German Federal Statistical Office demographics. The timeframe covered was from 2019 to 2024. Data were analyzed for infection rates, sociodemographic representativeness, and overall data quality, employing descriptive RESULTS SMPs demonstrated feasibility as a rapid data collection tool. Self-reported infection frequency aligned closely with conventional sources such as MuSPAD, with similar proportions of respondents reporting zero, one, or multiple infections. However, demographic analyses revealed biases: individuals aged 40--59 and those with higher education were overrepresented, while one-person households were underrepresented. We used bootstrapping to address these issues, indicating that the effect of sampling bias on overall infection numbers was low. By design, SMPs do not provide detailed demographic data, limiting options for subgroup analyses. CONCLUSIONS We found SMPs to be a practical and cost-effective method for quickly gathering epidemiological insights. In particular, self-reported infection frequency can aid during a period of high availability of self-testing during epidemics. One can argue that SMPs alone are insufficient for comprehensive public health modeling, as they do not allow real-time monitoring of, e.g., serological indicator-based population-based infection frequency estimates. However, they complement traditional methods by providing near-real-time, cost-effective data to guide interventions, inform policymaking, and refine epidemiological models. Further refinement and integration with established approaches could enhance their utility for public health decision-making.
- 3 September 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessRapid Data Collection for Infectious Diseases: Comparing Observational Survey Studies on Social Media with Conventional Cohort Studies (Preprint)
BACKGROUND After COVID-19 was declared a pandemic by the WHO in March 2020, global responses relied heavily on non-pharmaceutical interventions such as physical distancing and mask mandates. These measures were guided by mathematical models built on empirical data. Although traditional methods such as surveys and observational studies provide high-quality data, they are often slow and resource-intensive. Social media polls (SMPs) offer a faster, more cost-effective alternative. OBJECTIVE This study evaluates the feasibility of SMPs as a rapid supplementary tool for collecting epidemiological data and compares their representativeness and quality with conventional approaches. METHODS In this cross-sectional observational study in Germany, we utilized SMPs to collect data on infections and demographic attributes via Twitter and Mastodon. To assess data quality, SMP results were compared with conventional data sources, including the Multilocal and Serial Prevalence Study of Antibodies Against Respiratory Infectious Diseases (MuSPAD), COVID-19 Snapshot Monitoring (COSMO) survey, official Robert-Koch-Institute reports, and German Federal Statistical Office demographics. The timeframe covered was from 2019 to 2024. Data were analyzed for infection rates, sociodemographic representativeness, and overall data quality, employing descriptive RESULTS SMPs demonstrated feasibility as a rapid data collection tool. Self-reported infection frequency aligned closely with conventional sources such as MuSPAD, with similar proportions of respondents reporting zero, one, or multiple infections. However, demographic analyses revealed biases: individuals aged 40--59 and those with higher education were overrepresented, while one-person households were underrepresented. We used bootstrapping to address these issues, indicating that the effect of sampling bias on overall infection numbers was low. By design, SMPs do not provide detailed demographic data, limiting options for subgroup analyses. CONCLUSIONS We found SMPs to be a practical and cost-effective method for quickly gathering epidemiological insights. In particular, self-reported infection frequency can aid during a period of high availability of self-testing during epidemics. One can argue that SMPs alone are insufficient for comprehensive public health modeling, as they do not allow real-time monitoring of, e.g., serological indicator-based population-based infection frequency estimates. However, they complement traditional methods by providing near-real-time, cost-effective data to guide interventions, inform policymaking, and refine epidemiological models. Further refinement and integration with established approaches could enhance their utility for public health decision-making.
- Open Access
Bimodal Contact Reductions and Social Homophily during COVID-19
Background: The COVID-19 pandemic disrupted social life and forced people to reconsider how, where, and with whom to spend time. These decisions are deeply personal and their intricacies are still poorly understood. Methods: To understand how people make such decisions, we conducted an online survey in summer 2023, collecting self-reported absolute contact numbers for four time points: 2019, 03/2020, summer 2021, and 01/2023. We analyzed the resulting contact data, focusing on the quantification of heterogeneities in reductions. Results: Analysis of the survey data revealed that the COVID-19 pandemic triggered substantial reductions in both the work and the leisure context. Mean reductions gradually decreased as time progressed, but by 01/2023 contact numbers remained below pre-pandemic levels. We found contact behavior to demonstrate heterogeneity in three different aspects. First, the distribution of contact reductions followed a bimodal pattern, with a distinct peak at either extreme: A large fraction of the survey participants initially strongly reduced their contacts, a smaller group maintained nearly normal contact levels, and the remainder of participants reduced their contacts intermediately. Consistent with the decrease of mean contact reductions, the relative sizes of these behavioral groups shifted over time, with participants relaxing their reductions incrementally. Second, we found risk perception to be an indicator for the strength of contact reductions: Risk-averse participants reduced their leisure contacts significantly more than risk-tolerant participants, resulting in a trend of both fewer and later COVID-19 infections. Neither age, gender, nor having a COVID-19-relevant comorbidity significantly influenced self-reported contact reductions. Third, the survey results provide evidence that social homophily persisted during the COVID-19 pandemic, revealing a correlation between participants’ and their closest contacts’ number of contacts during the COVID-19 pandemic. Risk-averse participants hereby especially preferred to maintain contact with equally careful individuals. Conclusions: Our study emphasizes the time-dependency and heterogeneity of contact reductions. On the one hand, our findings can easily be integrated into epidemiological models, improving their accuracy and predictive power. On the other hand, the results may guide the design of effective public health interventions, and help to predict and understand their effectiveness.
Open AccessBimodal Contact Reductions and Social Homophily during COVID-19
Background: The COVID-19 pandemic disrupted social life and forced people to reconsider how, where, and with whom to spend time. These decisions are deeply personal and their intricacies are still poorly understood. Methods: To understand how people make such decisions, we conducted an online survey in summer 2023, collecting self-reported absolute contact numbers for four time points: 2019, 03/2020, summer 2021, and 01/2023. We analyzed the resulting contact data, focusing on the quantification of heterogeneities in reductions. Results: Analysis of the survey data revealed that the COVID-19 pandemic triggered substantial reductions in both the work and the leisure context. Mean reductions gradually decreased as time progressed, but by 01/2023 contact numbers remained below pre-pandemic levels. We found contact behavior to demonstrate heterogeneity in three different aspects. First, the distribution of contact reductions followed a bimodal pattern, with a distinct peak at either extreme: A large fraction of the survey participants initially strongly reduced their contacts, a smaller group maintained nearly normal contact levels, and the remainder of participants reduced their contacts intermediately. Consistent with the decrease of mean contact reductions, the relative sizes of these behavioral groups shifted over time, with participants relaxing their reductions incrementally. Second, we found risk perception to be an indicator for the strength of contact reductions: Risk-averse participants reduced their leisure contacts significantly more than risk-tolerant participants, resulting in a trend of both fewer and later COVID-19 infections. Neither age, gender, nor having a COVID-19-relevant comorbidity significantly influenced self-reported contact reductions. Third, the survey results provide evidence that social homophily persisted during the COVID-19 pandemic, revealing a correlation between participants’ and their closest contacts’ number of contacts during the COVID-19 pandemic. Risk-averse participants hereby especially preferred to maintain contact with equally careful individuals. Conclusions: Our study emphasizes the time-dependency and heterogeneity of contact reductions. On the one hand, our findings can easily be integrated into epidemiological models, improving their accuracy and predictive power. On the other hand, the results may guide the design of effective public health interventions, and help to predict and understand their effectiveness.
- Open Access
Social Media Polls on Twitter and Mastodon: Rapid Data Collection for Public Health
Background: After COVID-19 was declared a pandemic by the WHO in March 2020, global responses relied heavily on non-pharmaceutical interventions such as physical distancing and mask mandates. These measures were guided by mathematical models built on empirical data. Although traditional methods such as surveys and observational studies provide high-quality data, they are often slow and resource-intensive. Social media polls (SMPs) offer a faster, more cost-effective alternative. This study evaluates the feasibility of SMPs as a rapid supplementary tool for collecting epidemiological data and compares their representativeness and quality with conventional approaches. Methods: In this cross-sectional observational study in Germany, we utilized SMPs to collect data on infections and demographic attributes via Twitter and Mastodon. To assess data quality, SMP results were compared with conventional data sources, including the Multilocal and Serial Prevalence Study of Antibodies Against Respiratory Infectious Diseases (MuS-PAD), COVID-19 Snapshot Monitoring (COSMO) survey, official Robert-Koch-Institute reports, and German Federal Statistical Office demographics. The timeframe covered was from 2019 to 2024. Data were analyzed for infection rates, sociodemographic representativeness, and overall data quality, employing descriptive statistics. Findings: SMPs demonstrated feasibility as a rapid data collection tool. Self-reported infection frequency aligned closely with conventional sources such as MuSPAD, with similar proportions of respondents reporting zero, one, or multiple infections. However, demographic analyses revealed biases: individuals aged 40–59 and those with higher education were over-represented, while one-person households were underrepresented. We used bootstrapping to address these issues, indicating that the effect of sampling bias on overall infection numbers was low. By design, SMPs do not provide detailed demographic data, limiting options for subgroup analyses. Interpretation: We found SMPs to be a practical and cost-effective method for quickly gathering epidemiological insights. In particular, self-reported infection frequency can aid during a period of high availability of self-testing during epidemics. One can argue that SMPs alone are insufficient for comprehensive public health modeling, as they do not allow real-time monitoring of, e.g., serological indicator-based population-based infection frequency estimates. However, they complement traditional methods by providing near-real-time, cost-effective data to guide interventions, inform policymaking, and refine epidemiological models. Further refinement and integration with established approaches could enhance their utility for public health decision-making. Funding: This study was conducted within the infoXpand project, which is funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (Funding Code: 031L0300A, 031L0300C, 031L0300D). This work was additionally supported by The Helmholtz Association, the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program (Grant Number 101003480), and intramural funds of the Helmholtz Center for Infection Research.
Open AccessSocial Media Polls on Twitter and Mastodon: Rapid Data Collection for Public Health
Background: After COVID-19 was declared a pandemic by the WHO in March 2020, global responses relied heavily on non-pharmaceutical interventions such as physical distancing and mask mandates. These measures were guided by mathematical models built on empirical data. Although traditional methods such as surveys and observational studies provide high-quality data, they are often slow and resource-intensive. Social media polls (SMPs) offer a faster, more cost-effective alternative. This study evaluates the feasibility of SMPs as a rapid supplementary tool for collecting epidemiological data and compares their representativeness and quality with conventional approaches. Methods: In this cross-sectional observational study in Germany, we utilized SMPs to collect data on infections and demographic attributes via Twitter and Mastodon. To assess data quality, SMP results were compared with conventional data sources, including the Multilocal and Serial Prevalence Study of Antibodies Against Respiratory Infectious Diseases (MuS-PAD), COVID-19 Snapshot Monitoring (COSMO) survey, official Robert-Koch-Institute reports, and German Federal Statistical Office demographics. The timeframe covered was from 2019 to 2024. Data were analyzed for infection rates, sociodemographic representativeness, and overall data quality, employing descriptive statistics. Findings: SMPs demonstrated feasibility as a rapid data collection tool. Self-reported infection frequency aligned closely with conventional sources such as MuSPAD, with similar proportions of respondents reporting zero, one, or multiple infections. However, demographic analyses revealed biases: individuals aged 40–59 and those with higher education were over-represented, while one-person households were underrepresented. We used bootstrapping to address these issues, indicating that the effect of sampling bias on overall infection numbers was low. By design, SMPs do not provide detailed demographic data, limiting options for subgroup analyses. Interpretation: We found SMPs to be a practical and cost-effective method for quickly gathering epidemiological insights. In particular, self-reported infection frequency can aid during a period of high availability of self-testing during epidemics. One can argue that SMPs alone are insufficient for comprehensive public health modeling, as they do not allow real-time monitoring of, e.g., serological indicator-based population-based infection frequency estimates. However, they complement traditional methods by providing near-real-time, cost-effective data to guide interventions, inform policymaking, and refine epidemiological models. Further refinement and integration with established approaches could enhance their utility for public health decision-making. Funding: This study was conducted within the infoXpand project, which is funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (Funding Code: 031L0300A, 031L0300C, 031L0300D). This work was additionally supported by The Helmholtz Association, the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program (Grant Number 101003480), and intramural funds of the Helmholtz Center for Infection Research.
- Open Access
Impact of adherence and stringency on the effectiveness of lockdown measures: a modelling study
During the COVID-19 pandemic, lockdowns were a widely used strategy to reduce disease transmission. However, there was much debate about the optimal level of strictness and duration of lockdowns. This study considers how lockdowns impact public health opinions, which in turn influence adherence to and effectiveness of these measures. We developed an agent-based simulation model to study the impact of health-related opinions on the effectiveness of lockdowns in controlling disease spread. The model simulates infection spread and health opinion dynamics among individuals connected through a network of contacts and incorporates feedback loops between epidemic variables and opinion dynamics. We simulated different scenarios of lockdown implementation by varying a threshold value of prevalence when a lockdown is initiated and the stringency of the lockdown. We found that quickly imposing a lockdown with high stringency is the most effective at reducing infection spread, provided that there is a certain degree of adherence to the lockdown among the population. Furthermore, stricter lockdowns minimize fatigue with respect to the imposed measures, since the duration of a lockdown is shorter on average in this scenario. Such lockdown policies can therefore be a beneficial, high-impact tool in containing epidemic spread, especially when supplemented by information interventions maintaining the adherence to lockdown measures. Author summary Lockdowns were a widely used strategy to curb disease transmission during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the effectiveness of such measures depends on the population’s adherence to the regulations. Long and strict lockdowns may lower this adherence as the population experiences ‘fatigue’ with the regulations. In our study, we model the interplay between lockdowns, disease transmission, and health-related opinions in a population network. We tested various lockdown scenarios by altering strictness of measures on the one hand, and lockdown initiation times based on disease prevalence rates on the other hand. Our findings show that swift, stringent lockdowns are the most effective in reducing infections, particularly with strong public compliance. Additionally, stricter lockdowns tend to reduce fatigue as they are generally shorter. These results highlight that prompt, rigorous lockdown policies, supported by strategies to maintain public adherence, are most efficient in controlling epidemics. Furthermore, effective communication to ensure community cooperation may enhance the success of these measures.
Open AccessImpact of adherence and stringency on the effectiveness of lockdown measures: a modelling study
During the COVID-19 pandemic, lockdowns were a widely used strategy to reduce disease transmission. However, there was much debate about the optimal level of strictness and duration of lockdowns. This study considers how lockdowns impact public health opinions, which in turn influence adherence to and effectiveness of these measures. We developed an agent-based simulation model to study the impact of health-related opinions on the effectiveness of lockdowns in controlling disease spread. The model simulates infection spread and health opinion dynamics among individuals connected through a network of contacts and incorporates feedback loops between epidemic variables and opinion dynamics. We simulated different scenarios of lockdown implementation by varying a threshold value of prevalence when a lockdown is initiated and the stringency of the lockdown. We found that quickly imposing a lockdown with high stringency is the most effective at reducing infection spread, provided that there is a certain degree of adherence to the lockdown among the population. Furthermore, stricter lockdowns minimize fatigue with respect to the imposed measures, since the duration of a lockdown is shorter on average in this scenario. Such lockdown policies can therefore be a beneficial, high-impact tool in containing epidemic spread, especially when supplemented by information interventions maintaining the adherence to lockdown measures. Author summary Lockdowns were a widely used strategy to curb disease transmission during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the effectiveness of such measures depends on the population’s adherence to the regulations. Long and strict lockdowns may lower this adherence as the population experiences ‘fatigue’ with the regulations. In our study, we model the interplay between lockdowns, disease transmission, and health-related opinions in a population network. We tested various lockdown scenarios by altering strictness of measures on the one hand, and lockdown initiation times based on disease prevalence rates on the other hand. Our findings show that swift, stringent lockdowns are the most effective in reducing infections, particularly with strong public compliance. Additionally, stricter lockdowns tend to reduce fatigue as they are generally shorter. These results highlight that prompt, rigorous lockdown policies, supported by strategies to maintain public adherence, are most efficient in controlling epidemics. Furthermore, effective communication to ensure community cooperation may enhance the success of these measures.
- Open Access
- 18 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Reports
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-15
Disease avoidance threatens social cohesion in a large-scale social networking experiment
People tend to limit social contacts during times of increased health risks, leading to disruption of social networks thus changing the course of epidemics. To what extent, however, do people show such avoidance reactions? To test the predictions and assumptions of an agent-based model on the feedback loop between avoidance behavior, social networks, and disease spread, we conducted a large-scale (2,879 participants) incentivized experiment. The experiment rewards maintaining social relations and structures, and penalizes acquiring infections. We find that disease avoidance dominates networking decisions, despite relatively low penalties for infections; and that participants use more sophisticated strategies than expected (e.g., avoiding susceptible others with infectious neighbors), while they forget to maintain a beneficial network structure. Consequently, we observe low infection numbers, but also deterioration of network positions. These results imply that the focus on a more obvious signal (i.e., infection) may lead to unwanted side effects (i.e., loss of social cohesion).
- 18 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Reports
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-15
Open AccessDisease avoidance threatens social cohesion in a large-scale social networking experiment
People tend to limit social contacts during times of increased health risks, leading to disruption of social networks thus changing the course of epidemics. To what extent, however, do people show such avoidance reactions? To test the predictions and assumptions of an agent-based model on the feedback loop between avoidance behavior, social networks, and disease spread, we conducted a large-scale (2,879 participants) incentivized experiment. The experiment rewards maintaining social relations and structures, and penalizes acquiring infections. We find that disease avoidance dominates networking decisions, despite relatively low penalties for infections; and that participants use more sophisticated strategies than expected (e.g., avoiding susceptible others with infectious neighbors), while they forget to maintain a beneficial network structure. Consequently, we observe low infection numbers, but also deterioration of network positions. These results imply that the focus on a more obvious signal (i.e., infection) may lead to unwanted side effects (i.e., loss of social cohesion).
- 9 July 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 368-377
Using Agent-Based Modeling to Understand Complex Social Phenomena - A Curriculum Approach
- 9 July 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 368-377
Using Agent-Based Modeling to Understand Complex Social Phenomena - A Curriculum Approach
- 9 July 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 355-370
Adapting the “Networking During Infectious Diseases Model” (NIDM) for Science Communication Using Julia and Genie
- 9 July 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 355-370
Adapting the “Networking During Infectious Diseases Model” (NIDM) for Science Communication Using Julia and Genie
- Open Access
- 1 November 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in PNAS Nexus
- Vol. 1 (5) , pgac260
The effect of competition between health opinions on epidemic dynamics
Past major epidemic events showed that when an infectious disease is perceived to cause severe health outcomes, individuals modify health behavior affecting epidemic dynamics. To investigate the effect of this feedback relationship on epidemic dynamics, we developed a compartmental model that couples a disease spread framework with competition of two mutually exclusive health opinions (health-positive and health-neutral) associated with different health behaviors. The model is based on the assumption that individuals switch health opinions as a result of exposure to opinions of others through interpersonal communications. To model opinion switch rates, we considered a family of functions and identified the ones that allow health opinions to coexist. Finally, the model includes assortative mixing by opinions. In the disease-free population, either the opinions cannot coexist and one of them is always dominating (mono-opinion equilibrium) or there is at least one stable coexistence of opinions equilibrium. In the latter case, there is multistability between the coexistence equilibrium and the two mono-opinion equilibria. When two opinions coexist, it depends on their distribution whether the infection can invade. If presence of the infection leads to increased switching to a health-positive opinion, the epidemic burden becomes smaller than indicated by the basic reproduction number. Additionally, a feedback between epidemic dynamics and health opinion dynamics may result in (sustained) oscillatory dynamics and a switch to a different stable opinion distribution. Our model captures feedback between spread of awareness through social interactions and infection dynamics and can serve as a basis for more elaborate individual-based models.
- 1 November 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in PNAS Nexus
- Vol. 1 (5) , pgac260
Open AccessThe effect of competition between health opinions on epidemic dynamics
Past major epidemic events showed that when an infectious disease is perceived to cause severe health outcomes, individuals modify health behavior affecting epidemic dynamics. To investigate the effect of this feedback relationship on epidemic dynamics, we developed a compartmental model that couples a disease spread framework with competition of two mutually exclusive health opinions (health-positive and health-neutral) associated with different health behaviors. The model is based on the assumption that individuals switch health opinions as a result of exposure to opinions of others through interpersonal communications. To model opinion switch rates, we considered a family of functions and identified the ones that allow health opinions to coexist. Finally, the model includes assortative mixing by opinions. In the disease-free population, either the opinions cannot coexist and one of them is always dominating (mono-opinion equilibrium) or there is at least one stable coexistence of opinions equilibrium. In the latter case, there is multistability between the coexistence equilibrium and the two mono-opinion equilibria. When two opinions coexist, it depends on their distribution whether the infection can invade. If presence of the infection leads to increased switching to a health-positive opinion, the epidemic burden becomes smaller than indicated by the basic reproduction number. Additionally, a feedback between epidemic dynamics and health opinion dynamics may result in (sustained) oscillatory dynamics and a switch to a different stable opinion distribution. Our model captures feedback between spread of awareness through social interactions and infection dynamics and can serve as a basis for more elaborate individual-based models.