Bushra Atfeh
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Bushra Atfeh has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Zoltán Barcza
Department of Meteorology, Institute of Geography and Earth Sciences, ELTE Eötvös Loránd University, Pázmány P. st. 1/A, H-1117 Budapest, Hungary
4 shared publications - Róbert Mészáros
Department of Meteorology, Institute of Geography and Earth Sciences, ELTE Eötvös Loránd University, Pázmány Péter Sétány 1/A, H-1117 Budapest, Hungary
3 shared publications - Erzsébet Kristóf
Department of Meteorology, Institute of Geography and Earth Sciences, ELTE Eötvös Loránd University, Pázmány Péter Sétány 1/A, H-1117 Budapest, Hungary
2 shared publications - Veronika Groma
HUN-REN Centre for Energy Research, 1121 Budapest, Hungary
2 shared publications - Ágoston Vilmos Tordai
Department of Meteorology, Institute of Geography and Earth Sciences, ELTE Eötvös Loránd University, Pázmány Péter Sétány 1/A, H-1117 Budapest, Hungary
2 shared publications Erzsébet Kristóf
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 5 August 2026
- Published by Eötvös Loránd University
Evaluation and Application of Low-Cost Air Quality Sensors in Hungary
- 5 August 2026
- Published by Eötvös Loránd University
Evaluation and Application of Low-Cost Air Quality Sensors in Hungary
- Open Access
- 23 August 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Atmosphere
- Vol. 16 (9) , 998
Quantification of the Spatial Heterogeneity of PM2.5 to Support the Evaluation of Low-Cost Sensors: A Long-Term Urban Case Study
During the last decades, development of novel low-cost sensors commercialized for indoor air quality measurements has gained interest. In this research, three AirVisual Pro air quality monitors were used to monitor PM2.5 and carbon dioxide concentrations in which two were installed indoors and one outdoors at two residential apartments in Central Europe (Budapest, Hungary). In our research, we present a methodology to support the evaluation of indoor sensors by utilizing official outdoor monitoring data, leveraging the fact that indoor spaces are frequently ventilated and thus influenced by outdoor conditions. We compared six-year measurement data (January 2017–December 2022) with outdoor concentrations provided by the Hungarian Air Quality Monitoring Network (HAQM). However, the well-known low spatial representativeness and high spatio-temporal variability of PM2.5 in city environments made this evaluation problematic, which needed to be addressed before comparison. Here we quantify the spatial heterogeneity of the HAQM PM2.5 data for a maximum of eight stations. Then, based on the carbon dioxide readings of the AirVisual Pro units, data filtering was performed for the AirVisual 1 and AirVisual 2 sensors located in indoor environments to identify ventilated periods (nearly 10,000 ventilated events) for the AirVisual 1 and AirVisual 2 sensors, respectively, for the comparison of indoor and outdoor PM2.5 concentrations. The AirVisual 3 sensor was placed in a garden storage, and the measurements taken there were considered outdoor values throughout. Finally, four heterogeneity criteria were set for the HAQM data to filter conditions that were assumed to be comparable with the indoor sensor data. The results indicate that the spatial heterogeneity was indeed detectable, and in approximately 50–60% of the cases, the readings could be considered as non-representative to single location comparison, but the results depend on the selected homogeneity criteria. The AirVisual and HAQM comparison indicated relatively low sensitivity to heterogeneity criteria, which is a promising result that can be exploited. AirVisual sensors generally overestimated PM2.5, but this bias could be corrected with a simple linear adjustment. Slopes changed across sensors (0.83–0.85 for AirVisual 1, 0.48–0.53 for AirVisual 2, and 0.70–0.73 for AirVisual 3), indicating general overestimation and correlations from moderate to high (R2 = 0.45–0.89) depending on the device. In contrast, when we compared the measurements only with data from the nearest reference station, we obtained a weaker match and slopes that did not match those calculated by taking into account homogeneity criteria. This research contributes to the proliferation of citizen science and supports the application of LCSs in indoor conditions.
- 23 August 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Atmosphere
- Vol. 16 (9) , 998
Open AccessQuantification of the Spatial Heterogeneity of PM2.5 to Support the Evaluation of Low-Cost Sensors: A Long-Term Urban Case Study
During the last decades, development of novel low-cost sensors commercialized for indoor air quality measurements has gained interest. In this research, three AirVisual Pro air quality monitors were used to monitor PM2.5 and carbon dioxide concentrations in which two were installed indoors and one outdoors at two residential apartments in Central Europe (Budapest, Hungary). In our research, we present a methodology to support the evaluation of indoor sensors by utilizing official outdoor monitoring data, leveraging the fact that indoor spaces are frequently ventilated and thus influenced by outdoor conditions. We compared six-year measurement data (January 2017–December 2022) with outdoor concentrations provided by the Hungarian Air Quality Monitoring Network (HAQM). However, the well-known low spatial representativeness and high spatio-temporal variability of PM2.5 in city environments made this evaluation problematic, which needed to be addressed before comparison. Here we quantify the spatial heterogeneity of the HAQM PM2.5 data for a maximum of eight stations. Then, based on the carbon dioxide readings of the AirVisual Pro units, data filtering was performed for the AirVisual 1 and AirVisual 2 sensors located in indoor environments to identify ventilated periods (nearly 10,000 ventilated events) for the AirVisual 1 and AirVisual 2 sensors, respectively, for the comparison of indoor and outdoor PM2.5 concentrations. The AirVisual 3 sensor was placed in a garden storage, and the measurements taken there were considered outdoor values throughout. Finally, four heterogeneity criteria were set for the HAQM data to filter conditions that were assumed to be comparable with the indoor sensor data. The results indicate that the spatial heterogeneity was indeed detectable, and in approximately 50–60% of the cases, the readings could be considered as non-representative to single location comparison, but the results depend on the selected homogeneity criteria. The AirVisual and HAQM comparison indicated relatively low sensitivity to heterogeneity criteria, which is a promising result that can be exploited. AirVisual sensors generally overestimated PM2.5, but this bias could be corrected with a simple linear adjustment. Slopes changed across sensors (0.83–0.85 for AirVisual 1, 0.48–0.53 for AirVisual 2, and 0.70–0.73 for AirVisual 3), indicating general overestimation and correlations from moderate to high (R2 = 0.45–0.89) depending on the device. In contrast, when we compared the measurements only with data from the nearest reference station, we obtained a weaker match and slopes that did not match those calculated by taking into account homogeneity criteria. This research contributes to the proliferation of citizen science and supports the application of LCSs in indoor conditions.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Atmosphere
- Vol. 16 (7) , 796
Performance Assessment of Low- and Medium-Cost PM2.5 Sensors in Real-World Conditions in Central Europe
In addition to the use of reference instruments, low-cost sensors (LCSs) are becoming increasingly popular for air quality monitoring both indoors and outdoors. These sensors provide real-time measurements of pollutants and facilitate better spatial and temporal coverage. However, these simpler devices are typically characterised by lower accuracy and precision and can be more sensitive to the environmental conditions than the reference instruments. It is therefore crucial to characterise the applicability and limitations of these instruments, for which a possible solution is their comparison with reference measurements in real-world conditions. To this end, a measurement campaign has been carried out to evaluate the PM2.5 readings of several low- and medium-cost air quality instruments of different types and categories (IQAir AirVisual Pro, TSI DustTrak™ II Aerosol Monitor 8532, Xiaomi Mijia Air Detector, and Xiaomi Smartmi PM2.5 Air Detector). A GRIMM EDM180 instrument was used as the reference. This campaign took place in Budapest, Hungary, from 12 November to 15 December 2020, during typically humid and foggy weather conditions, when the air pollution level was high due to the increased anthropogenic emissions, including wood burning for heating purposes. The results indicate that the individual sensors tracked the dynamics of PM2.5 concentration changes well (in a linear fashion), but the readings deviated from the reference measurements to varying degrees. Even though the AirVisual sensors performed generally well (0.85 < R2 < 0.93), the accuracy of the units showed inconsistency (13–93%) with typical overestimation, and their readings were significantly affected by elevated relative humidity levels and by temperature. Despite the overall overestimation of PM2.5 by the Xiaomi sensors, they also exhibited strong correlation coefficients with the reference, with R2 values of 0.88 and 0.94. TSI sensors exhibited slight underestimations with high explained variance (R2 = 0.93–0.94) and good accuracy. The results indicated that despite the inherent bias, the low-cost sensors are capable of capturing the temporal variability of PM2.5, thus providing relevant information. After simple and multiple linear regression-based correction, the low-cost sensors provided acceptable results. The results indicate that sensor data correction is a necessary prerequisite for the usability of the instruments. The ensemble method is a reasonable alternative for more accurate estimations of PM2.5.
- 30 June 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Atmosphere
- Vol. 16 (7) , 796
Open AccessPerformance Assessment of Low- and Medium-Cost PM2.5 Sensors in Real-World Conditions in Central Europe
In addition to the use of reference instruments, low-cost sensors (LCSs) are becoming increasingly popular for air quality monitoring both indoors and outdoors. These sensors provide real-time measurements of pollutants and facilitate better spatial and temporal coverage. However, these simpler devices are typically characterised by lower accuracy and precision and can be more sensitive to the environmental conditions than the reference instruments. It is therefore crucial to characterise the applicability and limitations of these instruments, for which a possible solution is their comparison with reference measurements in real-world conditions. To this end, a measurement campaign has been carried out to evaluate the PM2.5 readings of several low- and medium-cost air quality instruments of different types and categories (IQAir AirVisual Pro, TSI DustTrak™ II Aerosol Monitor 8532, Xiaomi Mijia Air Detector, and Xiaomi Smartmi PM2.5 Air Detector). A GRIMM EDM180 instrument was used as the reference. This campaign took place in Budapest, Hungary, from 12 November to 15 December 2020, during typically humid and foggy weather conditions, when the air pollution level was high due to the increased anthropogenic emissions, including wood burning for heating purposes. The results indicate that the individual sensors tracked the dynamics of PM2.5 concentration changes well (in a linear fashion), but the readings deviated from the reference measurements to varying degrees. Even though the AirVisual sensors performed generally well (0.85 < R2 < 0.93), the accuracy of the units showed inconsistency (13–93%) with typical overestimation, and their readings were significantly affected by elevated relative humidity levels and by temperature. Despite the overall overestimation of PM2.5 by the Xiaomi sensors, they also exhibited strong correlation coefficients with the reference, with R2 values of 0.88 and 0.94. TSI sensors exhibited slight underestimations with high explained variance (R2 = 0.93–0.94) and good accuracy. The results indicated that despite the inherent bias, the low-cost sensors are capable of capturing the temporal variability of PM2.5, thus providing relevant information. After simple and multiple linear regression-based correction, the low-cost sensors provided acceptable results. The results indicate that sensor data correction is a necessary prerequisite for the usability of the instruments. The ensemble method is a reasonable alternative for more accurate estimations of PM2.5.
- Open Access
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Indoor air quality assessment in a residential apartment in Budapest
This work focuses on indoor air quality measurements carried out in an apartment in the suburban region of Budapest. The measurements were made by an IQAir AirVisual node air quality monitor which is a so-called low-cost sensor capable to monitor PM2.5 and carbon dioxide concentration. In this study we analyze data measured during January 2017 that was characterized by an extreme air pollution episode in Budapest. The aim of the study was to calculate daily indoor PM2.5 concentrations that are comparable with the outdoor concentrations provided by the official Hungarian Air Quality Monitoring Network. Given the fact that AirVisual Pro provides data with irregular sampling frequency, data processing is expected to influence the calculated daily mean concentrations. The results indicated that the uneven sampling frequency characteristic of AirVisual node indeed causes problems during data processing and has an effect on the calculated means. We propose a ‘best method’ for data processing for sensors with irregular sampling frequency.
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessIndoor air quality assessment in a residential apartment in Budapest
This work focuses on indoor air quality measurements carried out in an apartment in the suburban region of Budapest. The measurements were made by an IQAir AirVisual node air quality monitor which is a so-called low-cost sensor capable to monitor PM2.5 and carbon dioxide concentration. In this study we analyze data measured during January 2017 that was characterized by an extreme air pollution episode in Budapest. The aim of the study was to calculate daily indoor PM2.5 concentrations that are comparable with the outdoor concentrations provided by the official Hungarian Air Quality Monitoring Network. Given the fact that AirVisual Pro provides data with irregular sampling frequency, data processing is expected to influence the calculated daily mean concentrations. The results indicated that the uneven sampling frequency characteristic of AirVisual node indeed causes problems during data processing and has an effect on the calculated means. We propose a ‘best method’ for data processing for sensors with irregular sampling frequency.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Eötvös Loránd University
- p. 5-14
Evaluating the effect of data processing techniques on indoor air quality assessment in Budapest
This study focuses on indoor air quality measurements carried out in an apartment in the suburban region of Budapest. The measurements were made by an IQAir AirVisual Pro air quality monitor which is a so-called low-cost sensor capable to monitor PM2.5 and carbon dioxide concentration. In this study we analyze data measured during January 2017 that was characterized by an extreme air pollution episode in Budapest. The aim of the study was to calculate daily indoor PM2.5 concentrations that are comparable with the outdoor concentrations provided by the Hungarian Air Quality Monitoring Network. Given the fact that AirVisual Pro provides data with irregular sampling frequency, data processing is expected to affect the calculated daily mean concentrations. The main purpose of the study was to evaluate the effect of data processing technique selection on the calculated daily data. The results indicated that the uneven sampling frequency characteristic to AirVisual Pro indeed causes problems during data processing and has effect on the calculated means. We propose a ‘best method’ for data processing for sensors with irregular sampling frequency.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Eötvös Loránd University
- p. 5-14
Evaluating the effect of data processing techniques on indoor air quality assessment in Budapest
This study focuses on indoor air quality measurements carried out in an apartment in the suburban region of Budapest. The measurements were made by an IQAir AirVisual Pro air quality monitor which is a so-called low-cost sensor capable to monitor PM2.5 and carbon dioxide concentration. In this study we analyze data measured during January 2017 that was characterized by an extreme air pollution episode in Budapest. The aim of the study was to calculate daily indoor PM2.5 concentrations that are comparable with the outdoor concentrations provided by the Hungarian Air Quality Monitoring Network. Given the fact that AirVisual Pro provides data with irregular sampling frequency, data processing is expected to affect the calculated daily mean concentrations. The main purpose of the study was to evaluate the effect of data processing technique selection on the calculated daily data. The results indicated that the uneven sampling frequency characteristic to AirVisual Pro indeed causes problems during data processing and has effect on the calculated means. We propose a ‘best method’ for data processing for sensors with irregular sampling frequency.