Nicholas Bernard Dadario
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Nicholas Bernard Dadario has a total of 135 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Michael Edward Sughrue
Cingulum Health, Sydney, Australia
19 shared publications - Isabella M. Young
Research, Omniscient Neurotechnology, Sydney, AUS
6 shared publications Andrew K. Conner
Department of Neurosurgery University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center Oklahoma City Oklahoma USA
4 shared publicationsCharles Teo
Centre for Minimally Invasive Neurosurgery, Prince of Wales Private Hospital, Suite 19, Level 7 Prince of Wales Private Hospital, Randwick , Sydney, NSW 2031
4 shared publicationsIsabella M. Young
Omniscient Neurotechnology Sydney New South Wales Australia
4 shared publicationsJorge Hormovas
Centre for Minimally Invasive Neurosurgery, Prince of Wales Private Hospital, Suite 19, Level 7 Prince of Wales Private Hospital, Randwick , Sydney, NSW 2031
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Brain Communications
- Vol. 7 (5)
Multi-network dynamical structure of the human brain in the setting of chronic pain: a coordinate-based meta-analysis
The treatment of chronic pain represents a widespread clinical challenge. Current approaches to network-based mapping of the cerebral cortex have the potential to localize chronic pain in the brain. In an effort to further characterize the dynamical brain networks, or the ‘dynome’ in the setting of chronic pain, we performed a Coordinate-Based Meta-Analysis of resting-state functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging studies on chronic pain to create a multinetwork dynome of chronic pain. A cluster-level analysis generated seven statistically significant activation likelihood estimates (ALEs): one for chronic pain as a whole dynome, three for chronic pain conditions, and three for chronic pain mechanisms. Chronic pain is a complex disease process involving tripartite network dysfunction encompassing the Default Mode Network, Central Executive Network and Salience Network. Chronic visceral pain was distinct from chronic headache and chronic musculoskeletal pain, and chronic pain mechanisms have the potential to share common cortical network rearrangements with their respective chronic pain conditions. Collectively, this work represents the first anatomically specific network-based cortical map of chronic pain, with representation of disease-specific and mechanism-specific disruptions in cortical function.
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Brain Communications
- Vol. 7 (5)
Open AccessMulti-network dynamical structure of the human brain in the setting of chronic pain: a coordinate-based meta-analysis
The treatment of chronic pain represents a widespread clinical challenge. Current approaches to network-based mapping of the cerebral cortex have the potential to localize chronic pain in the brain. In an effort to further characterize the dynamical brain networks, or the ‘dynome’ in the setting of chronic pain, we performed a Coordinate-Based Meta-Analysis of resting-state functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging studies on chronic pain to create a multinetwork dynome of chronic pain. A cluster-level analysis generated seven statistically significant activation likelihood estimates (ALEs): one for chronic pain as a whole dynome, three for chronic pain conditions, and three for chronic pain mechanisms. Chronic pain is a complex disease process involving tripartite network dysfunction encompassing the Default Mode Network, Central Executive Network and Salience Network. Chronic visceral pain was distinct from chronic headache and chronic musculoskeletal pain, and chronic pain mechanisms have the potential to share common cortical network rearrangements with their respective chronic pain conditions. Collectively, this work represents the first anatomically specific network-based cortical map of chronic pain, with representation of disease-specific and mechanism-specific disruptions in cortical function.
- Open Access
- 21 January 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Radiology Case Reports
- Vol. 19 (4) , 1319-1324
Brain abscesses following carotid blowout syndrome: a case report
- 21 January 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Radiology Case Reports
- Vol. 19 (4) , 1319-1324
Open AccessBrain abscesses following carotid blowout syndrome: a case report
- 19 December 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Neuroimaging
- Vol. 34 (2) , 267-279
A parcellation‐based connectomic model of hemispatial neglect
Background and Purpose: Hemispatial neglect is characterized by a reduced awareness to stimuli on the contralateral side. Current literature suggesting that damage to the right parietal lobe and attention networks may cause hemispatial neglect is conflicting and can be improved by investigating a connectomic model of the “neglect system” and the anatomical specificity of regions involved in it.Methods: A meta‐analysis of voxel‐based morphometry magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) studies of hemispatial neglect was used to identify regions associated with neglect. We applied parcellation schemes to these regions and performed diffusion spectrum imaging (DSI) tractography to determine their connectivity. By overlaying neglect areas and maps of the attention networks, we studied the relationship between them.Results: The meta‐analysis generated a list of 13 right hemisphere parcellations. These 13 neglect‐related parcellations were predominantly linked by the superior longitudinal fasciculus (SLF) throughout a fronto‐parietal‐temporal network. We found that the dorsal and ventral attention networks showed partial overlap with the neglect system and included various other higher‐order networks.Conclusions: We provide an anatomically specific connectomic model of the neurobehavioral substrates underlying hemispatial neglect. Our model suggests a fronto‐parietal‐temporal network linked via the SLF supports the functions impaired in neglect and implicates various higher‐order networks which are not limited to the attention networks.
- 19 December 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Neuroimaging
- Vol. 34 (2) , 267-279
A parcellation‐based connectomic model of hemispatial neglect
Background and Purpose: Hemispatial neglect is characterized by a reduced awareness to stimuli on the contralateral side. Current literature suggesting that damage to the right parietal lobe and attention networks may cause hemispatial neglect is conflicting and can be improved by investigating a connectomic model of the “neglect system” and the anatomical specificity of regions involved in it.Methods: A meta‐analysis of voxel‐based morphometry magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) studies of hemispatial neglect was used to identify regions associated with neglect. We applied parcellation schemes to these regions and performed diffusion spectrum imaging (DSI) tractography to determine their connectivity. By overlaying neglect areas and maps of the attention networks, we studied the relationship between them.Results: The meta‐analysis generated a list of 13 right hemisphere parcellations. These 13 neglect‐related parcellations were predominantly linked by the superior longitudinal fasciculus (SLF) throughout a fronto‐parietal‐temporal network. We found that the dorsal and ventral attention networks showed partial overlap with the neglect system and included various other higher‐order networks.Conclusions: We provide an anatomically specific connectomic model of the neurobehavioral substrates underlying hemispatial neglect. Our model suggests a fronto‐parietal‐temporal network linked via the SLF supports the functions impaired in neglect and implicates various higher‐order networks which are not limited to the attention networks.
- Open Access
- 16 September 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Personalized Medicine
- Vol. 13 (9) , 1384
Parcellation-Based Connectivity Model of the Judgement Core
Judgement is a higher-order brain function utilized in the evaluation process of problem solving. However, heterogeneity in the task methodology based on the many definitions of judgement and its expansive and nuanced applications have prevented the identification of a unified cortical model at a level of granularity necessary for clinical translation. Forty-six task-based fMRI studies were used to generate activation-likelihood estimations (ALE) across moral, social, risky, and interpersonal judgement paradigms. Cortical parcellations overlapping these ALEs were used to delineate patterns in neurocognitive network engagement for the four judgement tasks. Moral judgement involved the bilateral superior frontal gyri, right temporal gyri, and left parietal lobe. Social judgement demonstrated a left-dominant frontoparietal network with engagement of right-sided temporal limbic regions. Moral and social judgement tasks evoked mutual engagement of the bilateral DMN. Both interpersonal and risk judgement were shown to involve a right-sided frontoparietal network with accompanying engagement of the left insular cortex, converging at the right-sided CEN. Cortical activation in normophysiological judgement function followed two separable patterns involving the large-scale neurocognitive networks. Specifically, the DMN was found to subserve judgement centered around social inferences and moral cognition, while the CEN subserved tasks involving probabilistic reasoning, risk estimation, and strategic contemplation.
- 16 September 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Personalized Medicine
- Vol. 13 (9) , 1384
Open AccessParcellation-Based Connectivity Model of the Judgement Core
Judgement is a higher-order brain function utilized in the evaluation process of problem solving. However, heterogeneity in the task methodology based on the many definitions of judgement and its expansive and nuanced applications have prevented the identification of a unified cortical model at a level of granularity necessary for clinical translation. Forty-six task-based fMRI studies were used to generate activation-likelihood estimations (ALE) across moral, social, risky, and interpersonal judgement paradigms. Cortical parcellations overlapping these ALEs were used to delineate patterns in neurocognitive network engagement for the four judgement tasks. Moral judgement involved the bilateral superior frontal gyri, right temporal gyri, and left parietal lobe. Social judgement demonstrated a left-dominant frontoparietal network with engagement of right-sided temporal limbic regions. Moral and social judgement tasks evoked mutual engagement of the bilateral DMN. Both interpersonal and risk judgement were shown to involve a right-sided frontoparietal network with accompanying engagement of the left insular cortex, converging at the right-sided CEN. Cortical activation in normophysiological judgement function followed two separable patterns involving the large-scale neurocognitive networks. Specifically, the DMN was found to subserve judgement centered around social inferences and moral cognition, while the CEN subserved tasks involving probabilistic reasoning, risk estimation, and strategic contemplation.
- Open Access
- 24 July 2023
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Indian Journal of Neurosurgery
- Vol. 12 (02) , 116-131
Connectomic Networks and Their Impact on Clinical Outcomes in Glioma Treatment: A Review
The emerging field of connectomics has provided an improved understanding of the structural and functional organization of the human brain into large-scale brain networks. Recent studies have helped define the canonical neurological networks and outline how considering their presence may aid in surgical decision-making in brain tumor patients. Gliomas represent one of the most common types of brain tumor and often involve displacement and/or infiltration of neurological pathways, suggesting an opportunity to use connectomic maps to improve patient morbidity and mortality based on oncofunctional goals. This review aims to provide a working knowledge of important neurological networks, examine the use of networks in surgical planning, and describe the current literature discussing the impact of these networks on clinical outcomes in glioma resection.
- 24 July 2023
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Indian Journal of Neurosurgery
- Vol. 12 (02) , 116-131
Open AccessConnectomic Networks and Their Impact on Clinical Outcomes in Glioma Treatment: A Review
The emerging field of connectomics has provided an improved understanding of the structural and functional organization of the human brain into large-scale brain networks. Recent studies have helped define the canonical neurological networks and outline how considering their presence may aid in surgical decision-making in brain tumor patients. Gliomas represent one of the most common types of brain tumor and often involve displacement and/or infiltration of neurological pathways, suggesting an opportunity to use connectomic maps to improve patient morbidity and mortality based on oncofunctional goals. This review aims to provide a working knowledge of important neurological networks, examine the use of networks in surgical planning, and describe the current literature discussing the impact of these networks on clinical outcomes in glioma resection.
- 12 July 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness
- Vol. 17, e428
Use of Cognitive Aids to Augment Point of Care Hemorrhage Control Skills in Laypersons
Objective:The Stop the Bleed course aims to improve bystander hemorrhage control skills and may be improved with point-of-care aids. We sought to create and examine a variety of cognitive aids to identify an optimal method to augment bystander hemorrhage control skills in an emergency scenario.Methods:Randomized trial of 346 college students. Effects of a visual or visual-audio aid on hemorrhage control skills were assessed through randomization into groups with and without prior training or familiarization with aids compared with controls. Tourniquet placement, wound packing skills, and participant comfortability were assessed during a simulated active shooter scenario.Results:A total of 325 (94%) participants were included in the final analyses. Participants who had attended training (odds ratio [OR], 12.67; P = 9.3 × 10−11), were provided a visual-audio aid (OR, 1.96; P = 0.04), and were primed on their aid (OR, 2.23; P = 0.01) were superior in tourniquet placement with less errors (P < 0.05). Using an aid did not improve wound packing scores compared with bleeding control training alone (P > 0.05). Aid use improved comfortability and likelihood to intervene emergency hemorrhage scenarios (P < 0.05).Conclusions:Using cognitive aids can improve bystander hemorrhage control skills with the strongest effects if they were previously trained and used an aid which combined visual and audio feedback that they were previously introduced to during the course training.
- 12 July 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness
- Vol. 17, e428
Use of Cognitive Aids to Augment Point of Care Hemorrhage Control Skills in Laypersons
Objective:The Stop the Bleed course aims to improve bystander hemorrhage control skills and may be improved with point-of-care aids. We sought to create and examine a variety of cognitive aids to identify an optimal method to augment bystander hemorrhage control skills in an emergency scenario.Methods:Randomized trial of 346 college students. Effects of a visual or visual-audio aid on hemorrhage control skills were assessed through randomization into groups with and without prior training or familiarization with aids compared with controls. Tourniquet placement, wound packing skills, and participant comfortability were assessed during a simulated active shooter scenario.Results:A total of 325 (94%) participants were included in the final analyses. Participants who had attended training (odds ratio [OR], 12.67; P = 9.3 × 10−11), were provided a visual-audio aid (OR, 1.96; P = 0.04), and were primed on their aid (OR, 2.23; P = 0.01) were superior in tourniquet placement with less errors (P < 0.05). Using an aid did not improve wound packing scores compared with bleeding control training alone (P > 0.05). Aid use improved comfortability and likelihood to intervene emergency hemorrhage scenarios (P < 0.05).Conclusions:Using cognitive aids can improve bystander hemorrhage control skills with the strongest effects if they were previously trained and used an aid which combined visual and audio feedback that they were previously introduced to during the course training.
- Top Cited Papers
- 31 May 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Brain
- Vol. 146 (9) , 3598-3607
The functional role of the precuneus
Recent advancements in computational approaches and neuroimaging techniques have refined our understanding of the precuneus. While previously believed to be largely a visual processing region, the importance of the precuneus in complex cognitive functions has been previously less familiar due to a lack of focal lesions in this deeply seated region, but also a poor understanding of its true underlying anatomy. Fortunately, recent studies have revealed significant information on the structural and functional connectivity of this region, and this data has provided a more detailed mechanistic understanding of the importance of the precuneus in healthy and pathologic states. Through improved resting-state functional MRI analyses, it has become clear that the function of the precuneus can be better understood based on its functional association with large scale brain networks. Dual default mode network systems have been well explained in recent years in supporting episodic memory and theory of mind; however, a novel ‘para-cingulate’ network, which is a subnetwork of the larger central executive network, with likely significant roles in self-referential processes and related psychiatric symptoms is introduced here and requires further clarification. Importantly, detailed anatomic studies on the precuneus structural connectivity inside and beyond the cingulate cortex has demonstrated the presence of large structural white matter connections, which provide an additional layer of meaning to the structural-functional significance of this region and its association with large scale brain networks. Together, the structural-functional connectivity of the precuneus has provided central elements which can model various neurodegenerative diseases and psychiatric disorders, such as Alzheimer’s disease and depression.
- 31 May 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Brain
- Vol. 146 (9) , 3598-3607
Top Cited PapersThe functional role of the precuneus
Recent advancements in computational approaches and neuroimaging techniques have refined our understanding of the precuneus. While previously believed to be largely a visual processing region, the importance of the precuneus in complex cognitive functions has been previously less familiar due to a lack of focal lesions in this deeply seated region, but also a poor understanding of its true underlying anatomy. Fortunately, recent studies have revealed significant information on the structural and functional connectivity of this region, and this data has provided a more detailed mechanistic understanding of the importance of the precuneus in healthy and pathologic states. Through improved resting-state functional MRI analyses, it has become clear that the function of the precuneus can be better understood based on its functional association with large scale brain networks. Dual default mode network systems have been well explained in recent years in supporting episodic memory and theory of mind; however, a novel ‘para-cingulate’ network, which is a subnetwork of the larger central executive network, with likely significant roles in self-referential processes and related psychiatric symptoms is introduced here and requires further clarification. Importantly, detailed anatomic studies on the precuneus structural connectivity inside and beyond the cingulate cortex has demonstrated the presence of large structural white matter connections, which provide an additional layer of meaning to the structural-functional significance of this region and its association with large scale brain networks. Together, the structural-functional connectivity of the precuneus has provided central elements which can model various neurodegenerative diseases and psychiatric disorders, such as Alzheimer’s disease and depression.
- 30 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Neurological Sciences
- Vol. 44 (9) , 3087-3097
Functional connectivity reveals different brain networks underlying the idiopathic foreign accent syndrome
Foreign accent syndrome (FAS) is characterized by new onset speech that is perceived as foreign. Available data from acquired cases suggests focal brain damage in language and sensorimotor brain networks, but little remains known about abnormal functional connectivity in idiopathic cases of FAS without structural damage. Here, connectomic analyses were completed on three patients with idiopathic FAS to investigate unique functional connectivity abnormalities underlying accent change for the first time. Machine learning (ML)-based algorithms generated personalized brain connectomes based on a validated parcellation scheme from the Human Connectome Project (HCP). Diffusion tractography was performed on each patient to rule out structural fiber damage to the language system. Resting-state-fMRI was assessed with ML-based software to examine functional connectivity between individual parcellations within language and sensorimotor networks and subcortical structures. Functional connectivity matrices were created and compared against a dataset of 200 healthy subjects to identify abnormally connected parcellations. Three female patients (28–42 years) who presented with accent changes from Australian English to Irish (n = 2) or American English to British English (n = 1) demonstrated fully intact language system structural connectivity. All patients demonstrated functional connectivity anomalies within language and sensorimotor networks in numerous left frontal regions and between subcortical structures in one patient. Few commonalities in functional connectivity anomalies were identified between all three patients, specifically 3 internal-network parcellation pairs. No common inter-network functional connectivity anomalies were identified between all patients. The current study demonstrates specific language, and sensorimotor functional connectivity abnormalities can exist and be quantitatively shown in the absence of structural damage for future study.
- 30 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Neurological Sciences
- Vol. 44 (9) , 3087-3097
Functional connectivity reveals different brain networks underlying the idiopathic foreign accent syndrome
Foreign accent syndrome (FAS) is characterized by new onset speech that is perceived as foreign. Available data from acquired cases suggests focal brain damage in language and sensorimotor brain networks, but little remains known about abnormal functional connectivity in idiopathic cases of FAS without structural damage. Here, connectomic analyses were completed on three patients with idiopathic FAS to investigate unique functional connectivity abnormalities underlying accent change for the first time. Machine learning (ML)-based algorithms generated personalized brain connectomes based on a validated parcellation scheme from the Human Connectome Project (HCP). Diffusion tractography was performed on each patient to rule out structural fiber damage to the language system. Resting-state-fMRI was assessed with ML-based software to examine functional connectivity between individual parcellations within language and sensorimotor networks and subcortical structures. Functional connectivity matrices were created and compared against a dataset of 200 healthy subjects to identify abnormally connected parcellations. Three female patients (28–42 years) who presented with accent changes from Australian English to Irish (n = 2) or American English to British English (n = 1) demonstrated fully intact language system structural connectivity. All patients demonstrated functional connectivity anomalies within language and sensorimotor networks in numerous left frontal regions and between subcortical structures in one patient. Few commonalities in functional connectivity anomalies were identified between all three patients, specifically 3 internal-network parcellation pairs. No common inter-network functional connectivity anomalies were identified between all patients. The current study demonstrates specific language, and sensorimotor functional connectivity abnormalities can exist and be quantitatively shown in the absence of structural damage for future study.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2023
- Published by Wiley in Brain and Behavior
- Vol. 13 (4)
Topology of the lateral visual system: The fundus of the superior temporal sulcus and parietal area H connect nonvisual cerebrum to the lateral occipital lobe
Background and Purpose: Mapping the topology of the visual system is critical for understanding how complex cognitive processes like reading can occur. We aim to describe the connectivity of the visual system to understand how the cerebrum accesses visual information in the lateral occipital lobe.Methods: Using meta‐analytic software focused on task‐based functional MRI studies, an activation likelihood estimation (ALE) of the visual network was created. Regions of interest corresponding to the cortical parcellation scheme previously published under the Human Connectome Project were co‐registered onto the ALE to identify the hub‐like regions of the visual network. Diffusion Spectrum Imaging‐based fiber tractography was performed to determine the structural connectivity of these regions with extraoccipital cortices.Results: The fundus of the superior temporal sulcus (FST) and parietal area H (PH) were identified as hub‐like regions for the visual network. FST and PH demonstrated several areas of coactivation beyond the occipital lobe and visual network. Furthermore, these parcellations were highly interconnected with other cortical regions throughout extraoccipital cortices related to their nonvisual functional roles. A cortical model demonstrating connections to these hub‐like areas was created.Conclusions: FST and PH are two hub‐like areas that demonstrate extensive functional coactivation and structural connections to nonvisual cerebrum. Their structural interconnectedness with language cortices along with the abnormal activation of areas commonly located in the temporo‐occipital region in dyslexic individuals suggests possible important roles of FST and PH in the integration of information related to language and reading. Future studies should refine our model by examining the functional roles of these hub areas and their clinical significance.
- 13 March 2023
- Published by Wiley in Brain and Behavior
- Vol. 13 (4)
Open AccessTopology of the lateral visual system: The fundus of the superior temporal sulcus and parietal area H connect nonvisual cerebrum to the lateral occipital lobe
Background and Purpose: Mapping the topology of the visual system is critical for understanding how complex cognitive processes like reading can occur. We aim to describe the connectivity of the visual system to understand how the cerebrum accesses visual information in the lateral occipital lobe.Methods: Using meta‐analytic software focused on task‐based functional MRI studies, an activation likelihood estimation (ALE) of the visual network was created. Regions of interest corresponding to the cortical parcellation scheme previously published under the Human Connectome Project were co‐registered onto the ALE to identify the hub‐like regions of the visual network. Diffusion Spectrum Imaging‐based fiber tractography was performed to determine the structural connectivity of these regions with extraoccipital cortices.Results: The fundus of the superior temporal sulcus (FST) and parietal area H (PH) were identified as hub‐like regions for the visual network. FST and PH demonstrated several areas of coactivation beyond the occipital lobe and visual network. Furthermore, these parcellations were highly interconnected with other cortical regions throughout extraoccipital cortices related to their nonvisual functional roles. A cortical model demonstrating connections to these hub‐like areas was created.Conclusions: FST and PH are two hub‐like areas that demonstrate extensive functional coactivation and structural connections to nonvisual cerebrum. Their structural interconnectedness with language cortices along with the abnormal activation of areas commonly located in the temporo‐occipital region in dyslexic individuals suggests possible important roles of FST and PH in the integration of information related to language and reading. Future studies should refine our model by examining the functional roles of these hub areas and their clinical significance.
- 29 January 2023
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Journal of Neurological Surgery Part B: Skull Base
- Vol. 85 (02) , 145-155
Simpson's Grading Scale for WHO Grade I Meningioma Resection in the Modern Neurosurgical Era: Are We Really Asking the Right Question?
The Simpson grading scale for the classification of the extent of meningioma resection provided a tremendous movement forward in 1957 suggesting increasing the extent of resection improves recurrence rates. However, equal, if not greater, movements forward have been made in the neurosurgical community over the last half a century owing to improvements in neuroimaging capabilities, microsurgical techniques, and radiotherapeutic strategies. Sughrue et al proposed the idea that these advancements have altered what a “recurrence” and “subtotal resection” truly means in modern neurosurgery compared with Simpson's era, and that a mandated use of the Simpson Scale is likely less clinically relevant today. A subsequent period of debate ensued in the literature which sought to re-examine the clinical value of using the Simpson Scale in modern neurosurgery. While a large body of evidence has recently been provided, these data generally continue to support the clinical importance of gross tumor resection as well as the value of adjuvant radiation therapy and the importance of recently updated World Health Organization classifications. However, there remains a negligible interval benefit in performing overly aggressive surgery and heroic maneuvers to remove the last bit of tumor, dura, and/or bone just for the simple act of achieving a lower Simpson score. Ultimately, meningioma surgery may be better contextualized as a continuous set of weighted risk–benefit decisions throughout the entire operation.
- 29 January 2023
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Journal of Neurological Surgery Part B: Skull Base
- Vol. 85 (02) , 145-155
Simpson's Grading Scale for WHO Grade I Meningioma Resection in the Modern Neurosurgical Era: Are We Really Asking the Right Question?
The Simpson grading scale for the classification of the extent of meningioma resection provided a tremendous movement forward in 1957 suggesting increasing the extent of resection improves recurrence rates. However, equal, if not greater, movements forward have been made in the neurosurgical community over the last half a century owing to improvements in neuroimaging capabilities, microsurgical techniques, and radiotherapeutic strategies. Sughrue et al proposed the idea that these advancements have altered what a “recurrence” and “subtotal resection” truly means in modern neurosurgery compared with Simpson's era, and that a mandated use of the Simpson Scale is likely less clinically relevant today. A subsequent period of debate ensued in the literature which sought to re-examine the clinical value of using the Simpson Scale in modern neurosurgery. While a large body of evidence has recently been provided, these data generally continue to support the clinical importance of gross tumor resection as well as the value of adjuvant radiation therapy and the importance of recently updated World Health Organization classifications. However, there remains a negligible interval benefit in performing overly aggressive surgery and heroic maneuvers to remove the last bit of tumor, dura, and/or bone just for the simple act of achieving a lower Simpson score. Ultimately, meningioma surgery may be better contextualized as a continuous set of weighted risk–benefit decisions throughout the entire operation.