STStefan Tübbicke

Stefan Tübbicke

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Stefan Tübbicke has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    How Effective are Generous Wage Subsidies for Long-Term Unemployed Welfare Recipients?

    by Zein Kasrin, Stefan Tübbicke

    Long-term unemployment remains a pressing issue. In Germany – the case we analyse in this study – the overwhelming majority of the long-term unemployed receive welfare benefits, and thus, are often economically and socially disadvantaged. This paper provides first evidence on the effects of a novel and generous wage subsidy programme for long-term unemployed welfare recipients up to 14 months after the expiry of the subsidy. Using rich administrative data on the total population of programme participants from May to October 2019 along with a sample of comparison individuals without the subsidy, we employ ridge kernel propensity score matching to compare participants with nearly identical comparison individuals in terms of observed characteristics. Our results show large positive effects on employment and negative effects on welfare dependency. Particularly large effects are found for older individuals and those with an especially sparse employment history. Using worst-case bounds and simulations, we show that unobserved confounding is highly unlikely to drive our conclusions.

  • Open Access

    Street‐Level Policymaking: From Local Political Preferences to Welfare Policy Delivery

    by Veronika J. Knize, Markus Wolf, Stefan Tübbicke

    Street‐level bureaucracy research argues that the local community shapes policy implementation. Yet, little is known about the impact of local political preferences on welfare policy application. This study extends this line of research examining how local political preferences in East Germany are linked to job centres' delivery of active labour market programmes—sanctions, workfare programmes, wage subsidies, and training programmes. Additionally, we assess whether local political preferences are related to welfare recipients' chances of labour market re‐integration. We apply a fixed‐effects approach to local elections data linked with job‐centre‐level registry data on welfare recipients. Our results suggest that left‐wing and right‐wing parties generally adhere to distinct welfare policy approaches, with higher far‐left party vote shares being associated with fewer restrictive policies and higher vote shares for the Right with more employment uptake. Overall, the results suggest an important role of local political preferences in shaping welfare policy implementation through political and organisational steering.

  • Open Access

    The German National Minimum Wage Raised Employment Prospects of Unemployed Welfare Recipients

    by Stefan Tübbicke

    This paper investigates the effects of the German national minimum wage introduction and its subsequent up-rating on job finding rates of unemployed welfare recipients. While the literature is inconclusive on the sign of overall employment effects of the minimum wage, the range of estimates suggests that if effects are negative, they are likely to be rather small. However, such overall effects may mask negative effects on employment prospects of unemployed welfare recipients, who tend to be only loosely attached to the labour market. For the analysis, this paper uses a sample of unemployed welfare recipients based on high-quality administrative data and employs a difference-in-differences strategy by exploiting regional variation in the bite of the minimum wage in order to estimate the effects of the minimum wage. While theoretically ambiguous, estimates show that minimum wages had a beneficial and rather homogeneous impact on job finding rates of unemployed welfare recipients. Sensitivity analyses highlight the robustness of these findings.

  • Open Access

    On the effects of active labour market policies among individuals reporting to have severe mental health problems

    by Stefan Tübbicke, Maximilian Schiele

    On the one hand, unemployment is known to have detrimental effects on individuals' mental health. On the other hand, poor mental health reduces re‐employment chances quite drastically, creating a vicious cycle. Active labour market policies (ALMPs) such as training programs or wage subsidies have been shown to ameliorate negative effects on mental health and improve labour market integration on average for the general unemployed population. In the context of individuals with severe mental health issues, however, it is unclear whether these interventions can be expected to deliver similar positive effects. In fact, one may argue that they have the potential to worsen employment prospects of individuals by adding additional stress to their pre‐existing mental health problems. Hence, this paper estimates the long‐term causal effects of ALMPs on the labour market integration of individuals with self‐reported severe mental health issues and compares estimates to individuals without such issues using unique combined survey and administrative data. Effects are estimated using the innovative double machine learning method and show that ALMPs do not only improve labour market integration of unemployed individuals with severe mental health issues, but they do so more effectively than for other unemployed individuals.


  • Open Access

    How sensitive are matching estimates of active labor market policy effects to typically unobserved confounders?

    by Stefan Tübbicke

    Using a rich and unique combined administrative-survey dataset, this paper explores how sensitive propensity score (PS) matching estimates of Active Labor Market Policies (ALMPs) based on the selection-on-observables assumption are to typically unobserved covariates. Using a sample of German unemployed welfare recipients, the analysis shows that typically unobserved factors such job search behavior, concessions willing to make for a job as well as (mental) health are in fact relevant confounders. However, results also show that matching on the PS using only typically observed covariates reduces imbalance in terms of typically unobserved covariates by about 46 percent in this setting. In line with this finding, the inclusion of typically unobserved covariates yields very similar estimates to estimates based on a standard specification. Hence, a standard matching approach based on rich and high quality administrative data appears to be sufficient to obtain estimates that are rather robust to unobserved confounding.


  • Open Access

    When to use matching and weighting or regression in instrumental variable estimation? Evidence from college proximity and returns to college

    by Stefan Tübbicke

    Standard two-stage least squares (2SLS) regression remains dominant in instrumental variables estimation of causal effects even though the literature has shown that 2SLS may be inconsistent when effects are heterogenous and the instrument is only valid when conditioning on covariates. To show that this is not merely a hypothetical threat, this paper re-estimates the returns to college using college proximity as an instrument based on the data from Card (Aspects of labour market behavior: essays in honour of John Vanderkamp, University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1995). The results show that 2SLS yields systematically larger estimates of the returns to college than more flexible estimators based on the instrument propensity score. In the full sample, differences amount to about 50 to 100%. This is due to the implicit conditional-variance weighting performed by 2SLS. Moreover, in line with the theoretical prediction by Sloczynski (When should we (not) interpret linear IV estimands as LATE? IZA discussion papers 14349, Institute of Labor Economics (IZA), 2021), findings suggest that the impact of the conditional-variance weighting is larger when instrument groups are not roughly the same size. Thus, it is advised to use 2SLS with caution and use estimators based on the instrument propensity score instead when groups are of different size and covariates are predictive of the instrument.


  • Open Access

    Which Active Labor Market Policies Work for Male Refugees? Evidence from Germany

    by Zein Kasrin, Stefan Tübbicke

    In this paper, we estimate the causal effects of a set of active labor market programs for male unemployed refugees on welfare who entered Germany between, 2013 and September, 2016. Using rich administrative data, we employ covariate balancing propensity scores combined with inverse probability weighting to estimate effects up to 33 months after the start of treatment. Our results show that relatively short-term training in the form of Schemes by Providers and In-Firm Training, as well as longer-term Further Vocational Training programs have a positive impact on both the employment chances as well as labor market earnings of refugees in the medium run. So-called “One Euro Jobs”, a public employment program, does not yield positive effects on employment or earnings. Sensitivity analyses confirm that our results are unlikely to be driven by unobserved confounding.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Entropy Balancing for Continuous Treatments

    by Stefan Tübbicke

    Interest in evaluating the effects of continuous treatments has been on the rise recently. To facilitate the estimation of causal effects in this setting, the present paper introduces entropy balancing for continuous treatments (EBCT) – an intuitive and user-friendly automated covariate balancing scheme – by extending the original entropy balancing methodology of Hainmueller, J. 2012. “Entropy Balancing for Causal Effects: A Multivariate Reweighting Method to Produce Balanced Samples in Observational Studies.” Political Analysis 20 (1): 25–46. In order to estimate balancing weights, the proposed approach solves a globally convex constrained optimization problem, allowing for computationally efficient software implementation. EBCT weights reliably eradicate Pearson correlations between covariates (and their transformations) and the continuous treatment variable. As uncorrelatedness may not be sufficient to guarantee consistent estimates of dose–response functions, EBCT also allows to render higher moments of the treatment variable uncorrelated with covariates to mitigate this issue. Empirical Monte-Carlo simulations suggest that treatment effect estimates using EBCT display favorable properties in terms of bias and root mean squared error, especially when balance on higher moments of the treatment variable is sought. These properties make EBCT an attractive method for the evaluation of continuous treatments. Software implementation is available for Stata and R.