Carolyn M. Ritchey
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Carolyn M. Ritchey has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Christopher A. Podlesnik
Department of Psychology University of Florida Gainesville FL USA
13 shared publications - Toshikazu Kuroda
Advanced Telecommunications Research Institute International Kyoto Japan
8 shared publications - Carla N. Martinez‐Perez
Department of Psychology University of Florida Gainesville FL USA
4 shared publications Toshikazu Kuroda
Advanced Telecommunications Research Institute International Ringgold standard institution Soraku‐gun Kyoto Japan
3 shared publicationsChristopher A. Podlesnik
Affiliation Department of Psychology, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, United States of America
2 shared publications- Kyleigh L. Montague
University of Florida Gainesville FL USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 6 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 126 (3)
Brief stimulus changes signaling extinction enhance resurgence
Resurgence is the return of a previously reinforced and extinguished target response when conditions worsen for an alternative response. Several studies examined resurgence when brief stimulus changes/instructions accompanied phase transitions in standard three‐phase procedures, which confounded the effects of worsening with extinction and stimulus changes. Subsequent research found resurgence was greater when a 1‐s stimulus change preceded both phase changes compared with groups experiencing more frequent or no stimulus changes. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate whether presenting identical versus different stimuli prior to both phase changes influenced resurgence in Experiment 1 and a stimulus only prior to extinction testing was sufficient to observe enhanced resurgence effects in Experiment 2. We found no differences in resurgence whether the brief stimulus changes (1) between phases were identical or different or (2) occurred before Phases 2 and 3 or only before Phase 3; however, resurgence was greater when preceding only Phase 3 with a stimulus change versus no stimuli between phases or a stimulus only before Phase 2. These findings suggest stimuli signaling transitions to extinction testing enhance resurgence effects. We discuss whether brief stimulus changes are functionally similar to contextual changes accompanying phases previously shown to produce renewal and enhance resurgence.
- 6 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 126 (3)
Brief stimulus changes signaling extinction enhance resurgence
Resurgence is the return of a previously reinforced and extinguished target response when conditions worsen for an alternative response. Several studies examined resurgence when brief stimulus changes/instructions accompanied phase transitions in standard three‐phase procedures, which confounded the effects of worsening with extinction and stimulus changes. Subsequent research found resurgence was greater when a 1‐s stimulus change preceded both phase changes compared with groups experiencing more frequent or no stimulus changes. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate whether presenting identical versus different stimuli prior to both phase changes influenced resurgence in Experiment 1 and a stimulus only prior to extinction testing was sufficient to observe enhanced resurgence effects in Experiment 2. We found no differences in resurgence whether the brief stimulus changes (1) between phases were identical or different or (2) occurred before Phases 2 and 3 or only before Phase 3; however, resurgence was greater when preceding only Phase 3 with a stimulus change versus no stimuli between phases or a stimulus only before Phase 2. These findings suggest stimuli signaling transitions to extinction testing enhance resurgence effects. We discuss whether brief stimulus changes are functionally similar to contextual changes accompanying phases previously shown to produce renewal and enhance resurgence.
- 1 February 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 125 (2) , e70086
Multiple‐context training mitigates renewal during differential reinforcement
Renewal occurs when a behavior is reduced in one context but reemerges when transitioning to a different context, which poses challenges for behavioral interventions. This preclinical research evaluated whether multiple‐context training could mitigate renewal of operant behavior eliminated with extinction and differential reinforcement of an alternative behavior (DRA + EXT) in humans recruited through crowdsourcing. In each of two experiments, three groups received conditioning, with point deliveries as reinforcers for a target‐button press within Context A. During DRA + EXT, multiple‐context training arranged nine alternations among three contexts (BCD) for one group, while the other two groups experienced equal DRA + EXT exposure but within a single context (B). During testing, the control group remained in Context B while multiple‐ and single‐context groups transitioned to either the original Context A (Experiment 1) or a novel Context E (Experiment 2). Both experiments provided the first evidence suggesting multiple‐context training can mitigate renewal with DRA + EXT contingencies. However, the present findings joined others showing multiple‐context training slowed reductions in target responding during DRA + EXT compared with single‐context training, suggesting trade‐offs in the use of this mitigation strategy.
- 1 February 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 125 (2) , e70086
Multiple‐context training mitigates renewal during differential reinforcement
Renewal occurs when a behavior is reduced in one context but reemerges when transitioning to a different context, which poses challenges for behavioral interventions. This preclinical research evaluated whether multiple‐context training could mitigate renewal of operant behavior eliminated with extinction and differential reinforcement of an alternative behavior (DRA + EXT) in humans recruited through crowdsourcing. In each of two experiments, three groups received conditioning, with point deliveries as reinforcers for a target‐button press within Context A. During DRA + EXT, multiple‐context training arranged nine alternations among three contexts (BCD) for one group, while the other two groups experienced equal DRA + EXT exposure but within a single context (B). During testing, the control group remained in Context B while multiple‐ and single‐context groups transitioned to either the original Context A (Experiment 1) or a novel Context E (Experiment 2). Both experiments provided the first evidence suggesting multiple‐context training can mitigate renewal with DRA + EXT contingencies. However, the present findings joined others showing multiple‐context training slowed reductions in target responding during DRA + EXT compared with single‐context training, suggesting trade‐offs in the use of this mitigation strategy.
- 30 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 124 (1) , e70024
Discriminative control of choice by reinforcers in children and adults
Research with nonhumans and human children has questioned the notion of the strengthening properties of reinforcers when choices are controlled by what reinforcers signal about upcoming events. We extended this work by developing and evaluating an automated task to evaluate the discriminative versus strengthening effects of reinforcers with two children of typical development (Experiment 1) and 18 university students (Experiments 2 and 3). Participants responded by touching one of two concurrently available images on a touchscreen. Across conditions, the probability that the next reinforcer would be delivered at the same location as the immediately preceding reinforced response varied with probabilities of .10 (switch), .50 (control), and .90 (stay). Both children and students responded according to the arranged reinforcer probabilities of the next reinforcer instead of where the most recent reinforcer had been delivered. The present findings add to the body of work suggesting that reinforcers serve a discriminative function, and we use a quantitative model of reinforcer misallocation to account for choices being imperfectly controlled by contingencies.
- 30 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 124 (1) , e70024
Discriminative control of choice by reinforcers in children and adults
Research with nonhumans and human children has questioned the notion of the strengthening properties of reinforcers when choices are controlled by what reinforcers signal about upcoming events. We extended this work by developing and evaluating an automated task to evaluate the discriminative versus strengthening effects of reinforcers with two children of typical development (Experiment 1) and 18 university students (Experiments 2 and 3). Participants responded by touching one of two concurrently available images on a touchscreen. Across conditions, the probability that the next reinforcer would be delivered at the same location as the immediately preceding reinforced response varied with probabilities of .10 (switch), .50 (control), and .90 (stay). Both children and students responded according to the arranged reinforcer probabilities of the next reinforcer instead of where the most recent reinforcer had been delivered. The present findings add to the body of work suggesting that reinforcers serve a discriminative function, and we use a quantitative model of reinforcer misallocation to account for choices being imperfectly controlled by contingencies.
- 14 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 123 (3) , 455-470
A quantitative analysis of the effects of target‐ and alternative‐reinforcement rate on resurgence
Resurgence is defined as an increase in a previously reinforced and reduced target response when conditions worsen for a more recently reinforced alternative response. The present experiment evaluated the effects of target‐ and alternative‐reinforcer rate on resurgence in humans. We arranged combinations of contingent high‐ and low‐rate target and high‐ and low‐rate alternative reinforcement across four groups. When extinguishing all reinforcement, resurgence occurred only in groups experiencing a high rate of alternative reinforcement, with resurgence being higher in the group that experienced high rates of both target and alternative reinforcement. Our findings join those of others that indicate that rates of alternative reinforcement contribute more to resurgence than target‐reinforcer rates. A quantitative model of resurgence, resurgence as choice in context (RaC2), tended to underpredict target responding and overpredict alternative responding in Phase 3. Including a misallocation parameter to account for a proportion of reinforcers misallocated between responses provided a better account of the findings.
- 14 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 123 (3) , 455-470
A quantitative analysis of the effects of target‐ and alternative‐reinforcement rate on resurgence
Resurgence is defined as an increase in a previously reinforced and reduced target response when conditions worsen for a more recently reinforced alternative response. The present experiment evaluated the effects of target‐ and alternative‐reinforcer rate on resurgence in humans. We arranged combinations of contingent high‐ and low‐rate target and high‐ and low‐rate alternative reinforcement across four groups. When extinguishing all reinforcement, resurgence occurred only in groups experiencing a high rate of alternative reinforcement, with resurgence being higher in the group that experienced high rates of both target and alternative reinforcement. Our findings join those of others that indicate that rates of alternative reinforcement contribute more to resurgence than target‐reinforcer rates. A quantitative model of resurgence, resurgence as choice in context (RaC2), tended to underpredict target responding and overpredict alternative responding in Phase 3. Including a misallocation parameter to account for a proportion of reinforcers misallocated between responses provided a better account of the findings.
- 12 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis
- Vol. 58 (1) , 225-231
Different criteria affect prevalence of relapse of behavior targeted for treatment
Several studies have examined the prevalence of behavioral relapse among individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities following common treatment challenges (context changes, schedule thinning). Most applied studies compare behavior during the treatment challenges with the maximum level of behavior from five preceding treatment sessions. This max‐of‐5 criterion could inadvertently capture behavior in transition during the preceding treatment phase, thereby underestimating the prevalence of relapse. In the current study, we reanalyzed existing clinical data with the max‐of‐5 criterion and an alternative criterion less likely to capture target behavior in transition—the mean of the last two sessions (mean‐of‐2 criterion) of the treatment phase. As hypothesized, the max‐of‐5 criterion produced lower prevalence estimates relative to the mean‐of‐2 criterion. We encourage researchers conducting these analyses to weigh different approaches to reporting prevalence data and discuss considerations for future areas of research and practice related to measurement of relapse.
- 12 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis
- Vol. 58 (1) , 225-231
Different criteria affect prevalence of relapse of behavior targeted for treatment
Several studies have examined the prevalence of behavioral relapse among individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities following common treatment challenges (context changes, schedule thinning). Most applied studies compare behavior during the treatment challenges with the maximum level of behavior from five preceding treatment sessions. This max‐of‐5 criterion could inadvertently capture behavior in transition during the preceding treatment phase, thereby underestimating the prevalence of relapse. In the current study, we reanalyzed existing clinical data with the max‐of‐5 criterion and an alternative criterion less likely to capture target behavior in transition—the mean of the last two sessions (mean‐of‐2 criterion) of the treatment phase. As hypothesized, the max‐of‐5 criterion produced lower prevalence estimates relative to the mean‐of‐2 criterion. We encourage researchers conducting these analyses to weigh different approaches to reporting prevalence data and discuss considerations for future areas of research and practice related to measurement of relapse.
- 22 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 122 (2) , 139-157
A parametric manipulation and meta‐analysis of target‐response punishment on resurgence
Resurgence can be defined as increases in previously reinforced and subsequently extinguished target responding when conditions for an alternative response worsen. Worsening of alternative conditions, such as extinction, has been linked to relapse of clinically relevant behavior. Preclinical researchers have evaluated whether punishing target responses while differentially reinforcing an alternative response could reduce resurgence when conditions are worsened with extinction, with mixed results. In the present investigation, we systematically replicated this line of research with human participants recruited via crowdsourcing, using response cost as punishment. During Phase 1, we reinforced target responses with 100 points per delivery, exchangeable for money. During Phase 2, we reinforced alternative responses, discontinued point reinforcement for target responses, and parametrically manipulated across groups the magnitude of point loss (1, 100, 320, or 1,000 points) contingent on target responses. During Phase 3, we tested for resurgence by extinguishing target and alternative responses. Added punishment systematically decreased target responding during Phase 2 but did not influence resurgence during Phase 3. With a meta‐analysis, we compared our findings with existing research examining a range of punishers and species. The results of the meta‐analysis comport with the present findings, suggesting that the inclusion of punishment reduces target responding during DRA but, overall, has no systematic effects on resurgence.
- 22 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 122 (2) , 139-157
A parametric manipulation and meta‐analysis of target‐response punishment on resurgence
Resurgence can be defined as increases in previously reinforced and subsequently extinguished target responding when conditions for an alternative response worsen. Worsening of alternative conditions, such as extinction, has been linked to relapse of clinically relevant behavior. Preclinical researchers have evaluated whether punishing target responses while differentially reinforcing an alternative response could reduce resurgence when conditions are worsened with extinction, with mixed results. In the present investigation, we systematically replicated this line of research with human participants recruited via crowdsourcing, using response cost as punishment. During Phase 1, we reinforced target responses with 100 points per delivery, exchangeable for money. During Phase 2, we reinforced alternative responses, discontinued point reinforcement for target responses, and parametrically manipulated across groups the magnitude of point loss (1, 100, 320, or 1,000 points) contingent on target responses. During Phase 3, we tested for resurgence by extinguishing target and alternative responses. Added punishment systematically decreased target responding during Phase 2 but did not influence resurgence during Phase 3. With a meta‐analysis, we compared our findings with existing research examining a range of punishers and species. The results of the meta‐analysis comport with the present findings, suggesting that the inclusion of punishment reduces target responding during DRA but, overall, has no systematic effects on resurgence.
- Open Access
- 4 October 2023
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 18 (10) , e0292372
Effects of pay rate and instructions on attrition in crowdsourcing research
Researchers in social sciences increasingly rely on crowdsourcing marketplaces such as Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk) and Prolific to facilitate rapid, low-cost data collection from large samples. However, crowdsourcing suffers from high attrition, threatening the validity of crowdsourced studies. Separate studies have demonstrated that (1) higher pay rates and (2) additional instructions–i.e., informing participants about task requirements, asking for personal information, and describing the negative impact of attrition on research quality–can reduce attrition rates with MTurk participants. The present study extended research on these possible remedies for attrition to Prolific, another crowdsourcing marketplace with strict requirements for participant pay. We randomly assigned 225 participants to one of four groups. Across groups, we evaluated effects of pay rates commensurate with or double the US minimum wage, expanding the upper range of this independent variable; two groups also received additional instructions. Higher pay reduced attrition and correlated with more accurate performance on experimental tasks but we observed no effect of additional instructions. Overall, our findings suggest that effects of increased pay on attrition generalize to higher minimum pay rates and across crowdsourcing platforms. In contrast, effects of additional instructions might not generalize across task durations, task types, or crowdsourcing platforms.
- 4 October 2023
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 18 (10) , e0292372
Open AccessEffects of pay rate and instructions on attrition in crowdsourcing research
Researchers in social sciences increasingly rely on crowdsourcing marketplaces such as Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk) and Prolific to facilitate rapid, low-cost data collection from large samples. However, crowdsourcing suffers from high attrition, threatening the validity of crowdsourced studies. Separate studies have demonstrated that (1) higher pay rates and (2) additional instructions–i.e., informing participants about task requirements, asking for personal information, and describing the negative impact of attrition on research quality–can reduce attrition rates with MTurk participants. The present study extended research on these possible remedies for attrition to Prolific, another crowdsourcing marketplace with strict requirements for participant pay. We randomly assigned 225 participants to one of four groups. Across groups, we evaluated effects of pay rates commensurate with or double the US minimum wage, expanding the upper range of this independent variable; two groups also received additional instructions. Higher pay reduced attrition and correlated with more accurate performance on experimental tasks but we observed no effect of additional instructions. Overall, our findings suggest that effects of increased pay on attrition generalize to higher minimum pay rates and across crowdsourcing platforms. In contrast, effects of additional instructions might not generalize across task durations, task types, or crowdsourcing platforms.
- Open Access
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Reports
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-14
Selective effects of conspecific movement on social preference in zebrafish (Danio rerio) using real-time 3D tracking and 3D animation
Zebrafish show social behavior such as shoaling and schooling, which is a result of complex and interdependent interactions among conspecifics. Zebrafish social behavior is interdependent in the sense that one fish’s behavior affects both conspecific behavior and, as a result, their own behavior. Previous research examined effects of the interdependent interactions on the preference for social stimulus but lacked clear evidence that specific conspecific movements were reinforcing. The present research examined whether dependency between individual experimental fish’s motion and a social-stimulus fish’s motions contributes to preference for the social stimulus. In Experiment 1, a 3D animated stimulus fish either chased individual experimental fish or was motionless, serving as dependent and independent motions, respectively. In Experiment 2, the stimulus fish either chased experimental fish, moved away, or moved independently of the experimental fish. In both experiments, experimental fish spent more time near the stimulus fish showing dependent and interactive movements, indicating preference for dependent motion over independent motion, and chasing over other motions. Implications of these results are discussed including a potential role of operant conditioning in the preference for social stimuli.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Reports
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-14
Open AccessSelective effects of conspecific movement on social preference in zebrafish (Danio rerio) using real-time 3D tracking and 3D animation
Zebrafish show social behavior such as shoaling and schooling, which is a result of complex and interdependent interactions among conspecifics. Zebrafish social behavior is interdependent in the sense that one fish’s behavior affects both conspecific behavior and, as a result, their own behavior. Previous research examined effects of the interdependent interactions on the preference for social stimulus but lacked clear evidence that specific conspecific movements were reinforcing. The present research examined whether dependency between individual experimental fish’s motion and a social-stimulus fish’s motions contributes to preference for the social stimulus. In Experiment 1, a 3D animated stimulus fish either chased individual experimental fish or was motionless, serving as dependent and independent motions, respectively. In Experiment 2, the stimulus fish either chased experimental fish, moved away, or moved independently of the experimental fish. In both experiments, experimental fish spent more time near the stimulus fish showing dependent and interactive movements, indicating preference for dependent motion over independent motion, and chasing over other motions. Implications of these results are discussed including a potential role of operant conditioning in the preference for social stimuli.
- 15 March 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 119 (3) , 501-512
A quantitative analysis of resurgence following downshifts in alternative‐reinforcer magnitude
Resurgence is the increase in a previously reinforced and then extinguished target response due to changes in reinforcement conditions for an alternative response, including reductions in the rate or magnitude of reinforcement for the alternative response. Research with nonhumans suggests that reductions in both alternative‐reinforcer rate and magnitude produce resurgence, but the present study was the first to examine effects of downshifts in alternative‐reinforcer magnitude on humans' resurgence. Moreover, it was the first to evaluate whether the quantitative framework, resurgence as choice in context (RaC2), could account for those effects. Consistent with predictions of RaC2, resurgence of a target button press occurred with reductions in point gain for an alternative response, with greater reductions producing higher levels of resurgence. However, the model consistently underpredicted and then overpredicted resurgence during tests with low‐magnitude reinforcement and extinction. Systematic deviations in model predictions of alternative responding were also evident and consistent with previous fits of RaC2 to nonhuman data. Overall, our findings suggest that RaC2 could be a useful quantitative theoretical framework for understanding processes contributing to resurgence in humans, but further theoretical development is needed to account for the apparent divergent effects of extinction versus downshifts in reinforcer magnitude.
- 15 March 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 119 (3) , 501-512
A quantitative analysis of resurgence following downshifts in alternative‐reinforcer magnitude
Resurgence is the increase in a previously reinforced and then extinguished target response due to changes in reinforcement conditions for an alternative response, including reductions in the rate or magnitude of reinforcement for the alternative response. Research with nonhumans suggests that reductions in both alternative‐reinforcer rate and magnitude produce resurgence, but the present study was the first to examine effects of downshifts in alternative‐reinforcer magnitude on humans' resurgence. Moreover, it was the first to evaluate whether the quantitative framework, resurgence as choice in context (RaC2), could account for those effects. Consistent with predictions of RaC2, resurgence of a target button press occurred with reductions in point gain for an alternative response, with greater reductions producing higher levels of resurgence. However, the model consistently underpredicted and then overpredicted resurgence during tests with low‐magnitude reinforcement and extinction. Systematic deviations in model predictions of alternative responding were also evident and consistent with previous fits of RaC2 to nonhuman data. Overall, our findings suggest that RaC2 could be a useful quantitative theoretical framework for understanding processes contributing to resurgence in humans, but further theoretical development is needed to account for the apparent divergent effects of extinction versus downshifts in reinforcer magnitude.
- 21 November 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Perspectives on Behavior Science
- Vol. 46 (1) , 137-184
A Comprehensive Systematic Review of Procedures and Analyses Used in Basic and Preclinical Studies of Resurgence, 1970–2020
- 21 November 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Perspectives on Behavior Science
- Vol. 46 (1) , 137-184
A Comprehensive Systematic Review of Procedures and Analyses Used in Basic and Preclinical Studies of Resurgence, 1970–2020