Marcela Vieira
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Marcela Vieira has a total of 20 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Suerie Moon
Global Health CentreGeneva Graduate Institute, Maison de La Paix Chemin Eugène-Rigot 2 1202 Geneva Switzerland
5 shared publications- Adrián Alonso Ruiz
Global Health Centre, Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies, Geneve, Switzerland
4 shared publications Kaitlin Large
Global Health CentreGeneva Graduate Institute, Maison de La Paix Chemin Eugène-Rigot 2 1202 Geneva Switzerland
3 shared publications- Kaitlin Large
Affiliation Global Health Centre, Geneva Graduate Institute, Genève, Switzerland
3 shared publications - Suerie Moon
Global Health Centre, Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies, Geneva, GE, Switzerland
3 shared publications - Iulia Slovenski
Global Health Centre, Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies, Geneva, Switzerland
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 24 April 2026
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Global Health
- Vol. 11 (4) , e021596
Orchestrating faster access to products of non-profit R&D: a case study of a novel regimen for drug-resistant tuberculosis
Introduction: Non-profit product development partnerships (PDPs) have succeeded in bringing nearly 80 new drugs, vaccines and diagnostics for neglected diseases through regulatory approval, but arrangements to ensure they reach patients are unclear since the usual commercial incentives do not apply. We conducted a case study of how unusually fast access was achieved to a new treatment regimen for drug-resistant tuberculosis (DR-TB) developed by the TB Alliance (TBA). Over 100 countries procured the regimen in quantities to reach 67% of global demand by 2024, 5 years after first regulatory approval and 2 years after the WHO recommended it for routine use. What interventions contributed to this rapid rollout, and what role did the PDP play? Methods: We analysed the academic and grey literature, internal documents from TBA, and conducted interviews with 21 key informants from 16 organisations. We identified relevant interventions and actors, constructed a timeline and analysed the role TBA played. Results: We found TBA orchestrated a complex set of interventions implemented by dozens of actors over an 8-year time period across three categories: regulatory and normative guidance; market shaping for affordability and availability; and supporting country-level implementation through knowledge generation, knowledge sharing, stakeholder engagement and advocacy. Five attributes enabled TBA to do so: ability to generate and share knowledge about the product and regimen; non-profit status; ability to mobilise material resources for access interventions; pre-existing relationships and/or ability to develop new collaborative relationships; and intrinsic motivation to see the product reaching people with DR-TB. Conclusion: An orchestrator able to steer many actors towards the shared goal of reaching patients is critical in a complex ecosystem where no single organisation can realise access alone. Non-profit product developers can play this role well, including managing actual or perceived conflicts of interest, but require clearer mandates and financial support to do so.
- 24 April 2026
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Global Health
- Vol. 11 (4) , e021596
Open AccessOrchestrating faster access to products of non-profit R&D: a case study of a novel regimen for drug-resistant tuberculosis
Introduction: Non-profit product development partnerships (PDPs) have succeeded in bringing nearly 80 new drugs, vaccines and diagnostics for neglected diseases through regulatory approval, but arrangements to ensure they reach patients are unclear since the usual commercial incentives do not apply. We conducted a case study of how unusually fast access was achieved to a new treatment regimen for drug-resistant tuberculosis (DR-TB) developed by the TB Alliance (TBA). Over 100 countries procured the regimen in quantities to reach 67% of global demand by 2024, 5 years after first regulatory approval and 2 years after the WHO recommended it for routine use. What interventions contributed to this rapid rollout, and what role did the PDP play? Methods: We analysed the academic and grey literature, internal documents from TBA, and conducted interviews with 21 key informants from 16 organisations. We identified relevant interventions and actors, constructed a timeline and analysed the role TBA played. Results: We found TBA orchestrated a complex set of interventions implemented by dozens of actors over an 8-year time period across three categories: regulatory and normative guidance; market shaping for affordability and availability; and supporting country-level implementation through knowledge generation, knowledge sharing, stakeholder engagement and advocacy. Five attributes enabled TBA to do so: ability to generate and share knowledge about the product and regimen; non-profit status; ability to mobilise material resources for access interventions; pre-existing relationships and/or ability to develop new collaborative relationships; and intrinsic motivation to see the product reaching people with DR-TB. Conclusion: An orchestrator able to steer many actors towards the shared goal of reaching patients is critical in a complex ecosystem where no single organisation can realise access alone. Non-profit product developers can play this role well, including managing actual or perceived conflicts of interest, but require clearer mandates and financial support to do so.
- Open Access
- 16 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Pharmaceutical Policy and Practice
- Vol. 18 (1) , 2436899
Reforming the innovation system to deliver affordable medicines: a conceptual framework of pharmaceutical innovation as a complex adaptive system (forest) and theory of change
The current mainstream pharmaceutical innovation system (PIS) is driven by the market-based logic of charging the highest prices societies will bear. Outcomes include unaffordable medicines, restricted access and pressure on health budgets. How can the innovation system change to deliver fairly-priced medicines? We inductively developed a novel conceptual framework of the PIS as a complex adaptive system (CAS) analogous to a forest. We constructed a database of 140 pharmaceutical innovation initiatives that sought to address global public interest objectives such as fair pricing or missing innovation. We found a critical mass of initiatives clustered around four areas: pandemic preparedness, neglected diseases, rare diseases and antibiotics, which we conceptualised as niches within the ecosystem. We reviewed the literature on how each niche had emerged and evolved, conducted interviews, and organised workshops with experts on each niche. Finally, we identified from the literature an initial list of ‘levers’ of change in the PIS, supplemented them with additional levers found in each niche, then compared across niches. We found that actors created niches in the broader system by purposefully problematising an issue, then pulling on one or more of three levers: mobilising new resources, changing the roles of or creating new actors, and/or changing societal norms or legal rules. A wide range of actors – including governments, funders, R&D practitioners, or civil society groups – could pull these levers, and the order in which they were pulled was not fixed, consistent with a CAS. Parts of the vast pharmaceutical innovation system have changed to deliver more affordable medicines by design. Such change has occurred largely within specialised niches, responding to evolving societal norms about the purpose of pharmaceutical innovation. Actors can achieve larger-scale change by further expanding and/or solidifying these niches through changes to resources, actor roles, norms and rules.
- 16 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Pharmaceutical Policy and Practice
- Vol. 18 (1) , 2436899
Open AccessReforming the innovation system to deliver affordable medicines: a conceptual framework of pharmaceutical innovation as a complex adaptive system (forest) and theory of change
The current mainstream pharmaceutical innovation system (PIS) is driven by the market-based logic of charging the highest prices societies will bear. Outcomes include unaffordable medicines, restricted access and pressure on health budgets. How can the innovation system change to deliver fairly-priced medicines? We inductively developed a novel conceptual framework of the PIS as a complex adaptive system (CAS) analogous to a forest. We constructed a database of 140 pharmaceutical innovation initiatives that sought to address global public interest objectives such as fair pricing or missing innovation. We found a critical mass of initiatives clustered around four areas: pandemic preparedness, neglected diseases, rare diseases and antibiotics, which we conceptualised as niches within the ecosystem. We reviewed the literature on how each niche had emerged and evolved, conducted interviews, and organised workshops with experts on each niche. Finally, we identified from the literature an initial list of ‘levers’ of change in the PIS, supplemented them with additional levers found in each niche, then compared across niches. We found that actors created niches in the broader system by purposefully problematising an issue, then pulling on one or more of three levers: mobilising new resources, changing the roles of or creating new actors, and/or changing societal norms or legal rules. A wide range of actors – including governments, funders, R&D practitioners, or civil society groups – could pull these levers, and the order in which they were pulled was not fixed, consistent with a CAS. Parts of the vast pharmaceutical innovation system have changed to deliver more affordable medicines by design. Such change has occurred largely within specialised niches, responding to evolving societal norms about the purpose of pharmaceutical innovation. Actors can achieve larger-scale change by further expanding and/or solidifying these niches through changes to resources, actor roles, norms and rules.
- Open Access
- 8 October 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Tropical Medicine and Infectious Disease
- Vol. 9 (10) , 233
Alternative Pharmaceutical Innovation Models in Competitive Markets: A Collaborative Approach to Develop a Novel Drug for Hepatitis C
Alternative innovation models have emerged to address failures of the traditional pharmaceutical system, particularly for diseases where market incentives do not attract sufficient research and development efforts. However, the feasibility of such models for diseases with significant markets is not well-established. This article analyses the development of a novel drug (ravidasvir) for the treatment of hepatitis C, a highly profitable market. Data from qualitative research methods, including literature reviews and semi-structured interviews, was analyzed using a novel conceptual framework focusing on actors, resources, organizational practices, and outcomes. Dissimilar to other projects, ravidasvir did not involve any major pharmaceutical companies. Rather, it leveraged the capacities of actors less traditionally involved in the development of novel medicines by constructing a collaborative network of private and public partners from low- and middle-income countries with a shared goal. The collaboration was successful in developing a highly effective, easy-to-use, and affordable medicine and contributed significantly to capacity-strengthening. However, the case also highlighted that strategic behavior by competing for-profit firms could pose significant challenges and that changing external conditions reduced the potential public health impact of the drug. Lessons from ravidasvir can inform future efforts to develop alternative innovation models for therapeutic areas with significant commercial interest.
- 8 October 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Tropical Medicine and Infectious Disease
- Vol. 9 (10) , 233
Open AccessAlternative Pharmaceutical Innovation Models in Competitive Markets: A Collaborative Approach to Develop a Novel Drug for Hepatitis C
Alternative innovation models have emerged to address failures of the traditional pharmaceutical system, particularly for diseases where market incentives do not attract sufficient research and development efforts. However, the feasibility of such models for diseases with significant markets is not well-established. This article analyses the development of a novel drug (ravidasvir) for the treatment of hepatitis C, a highly profitable market. Data from qualitative research methods, including literature reviews and semi-structured interviews, was analyzed using a novel conceptual framework focusing on actors, resources, organizational practices, and outcomes. Dissimilar to other projects, ravidasvir did not involve any major pharmaceutical companies. Rather, it leveraged the capacities of actors less traditionally involved in the development of novel medicines by constructing a collaborative network of private and public partners from low- and middle-income countries with a shared goal. The collaboration was successful in developing a highly effective, easy-to-use, and affordable medicine and contributed significantly to capacity-strengthening. However, the case also highlighted that strategic behavior by competing for-profit firms could pose significant challenges and that changing external conditions reduced the potential public health impact of the drug. Lessons from ravidasvir can inform future efforts to develop alternative innovation models for therapeutic areas with significant commercial interest.
- Open Access
- 31 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Pharmaceutical Policy and Practice
- Vol. 16 (1) , 1-19
Rising pharmaceutical innovation in the Global South: a landscape study
There is growing interest in pharmaceutical innovation in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), but information on existing activities, capacities, and outcomes is scarce. We mapped available data at the global level, and studied the national pharmaceutical innovation systems of Bangladesh and Colombia to shed light on pharmaceutical research and development (R&D) in the Global South, including challenges and prospects, to help fill existing knowledge gaps. We gathered and analyzed data from three types of sources: literature, semi-structured interviews with key informants, and publicly available data on R&D funding, R&D scientific capacity measured by human resources, and clinical trial activities. Pharmaceutical R&D activities are occurring in many LMICs, but 16 countries have emerged as frontrunners. Investment in R&D in LMICs has increased in the past decade, particularly from middle-income countries (MICs). Capacity is also growing, with an increase in the number of research organizations and the amount of funding available from external sources. The total number of clinical trials and the proportion of trials in LMICs increased markedly, and there is also growing activity in the earlier, more innovative and riskier Phase 1 and 2 trials. Non-commercial entities comprise the majority of clinical trial funders and sponsors in LMICs. Finally, investments have borne fruit, as indicated by a number of innovative medicines developed in LMICs. The Bangladesh and Colombia country studies showed that there is still a need for both targeted R&D policies to strengthen capacities in the pharmaceutical sector, and more government support to overcome the challenges of a lack of funding and coordination among different actors. By triangulating between the data sources, it was possible to paint a broad picture of who was involved in pharmaceutical R&D in LMICs, in which particular countries, for which diseases, in which R&D phases, and with what results—as well as how these trends have changed over time. Prioritizing pharmaceutical R&D is an important strategy for better meeting health needs. The trendlines are promising, but focused attention is still needed to realize the potential for greater innovation in the Global South.
- 31 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Pharmaceutical Policy and Practice
- Vol. 16 (1) , 1-19
Open AccessRising pharmaceutical innovation in the Global South: a landscape study
There is growing interest in pharmaceutical innovation in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), but information on existing activities, capacities, and outcomes is scarce. We mapped available data at the global level, and studied the national pharmaceutical innovation systems of Bangladesh and Colombia to shed light on pharmaceutical research and development (R&D) in the Global South, including challenges and prospects, to help fill existing knowledge gaps. We gathered and analyzed data from three types of sources: literature, semi-structured interviews with key informants, and publicly available data on R&D funding, R&D scientific capacity measured by human resources, and clinical trial activities. Pharmaceutical R&D activities are occurring in many LMICs, but 16 countries have emerged as frontrunners. Investment in R&D in LMICs has increased in the past decade, particularly from middle-income countries (MICs). Capacity is also growing, with an increase in the number of research organizations and the amount of funding available from external sources. The total number of clinical trials and the proportion of trials in LMICs increased markedly, and there is also growing activity in the earlier, more innovative and riskier Phase 1 and 2 trials. Non-commercial entities comprise the majority of clinical trial funders and sponsors in LMICs. Finally, investments have borne fruit, as indicated by a number of innovative medicines developed in LMICs. The Bangladesh and Colombia country studies showed that there is still a need for both targeted R&D policies to strengthen capacities in the pharmaceutical sector, and more government support to overcome the challenges of a lack of funding and coordination among different actors. By triangulating between the data sources, it was possible to paint a broad picture of who was involved in pharmaceutical R&D in LMICs, in which particular countries, for which diseases, in which R&D phases, and with what results—as well as how these trends have changed over time. Prioritizing pharmaceutical R&D is an important strategy for better meeting health needs. The trendlines are promising, but focused attention is still needed to realize the potential for greater innovation in the Global South.
- Open Access
- 13 November 2023
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 12, 211
Pharmaceutical policy and innovation for rare diseases: A narrative review
This article aims to synthesize the existing literature on the implementation of public policies to incentivize the development of treatments for rare diseases, (diseases with very low prevalence and therefore with low commercial interest) otherwise known as orphan drugs. The implementation of these incentives in the United States (US), Japan, and in the European Union (EU) seems to be related to a substantial increase in treatments for these diseases, and has influenced the way the pharmaceutical research & development (R&D) system operates beyond this policy area. Despite the success of the Orphan Drug model, the academic literature also highlights the negative implications that these public policies have on affordability and access to orphan drugs, as well as on the prioritization of certain disease rare areas over others. The synthesis focuses mostly on the United States’ Orphan Drug Act (ODA) as a model for subsequent policies in other regions and countries. It starts with a historical overview of the creation of the term “rare diseases”, continues with a summary of the evidence available on the US ODA’s positive and negative impacts, and provides a summary of the different proposals to reform these incentives in light of the negative outcomes described. Finally, it describes some key aspects of the Japanese and European policies, as well as some of the challenges captured in the literature related to their impact in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs).
- 13 November 2023
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 12, 211
Open AccessPharmaceutical policy and innovation for rare diseases: A narrative review
This article aims to synthesize the existing literature on the implementation of public policies to incentivize the development of treatments for rare diseases, (diseases with very low prevalence and therefore with low commercial interest) otherwise known as orphan drugs. The implementation of these incentives in the United States (US), Japan, and in the European Union (EU) seems to be related to a substantial increase in treatments for these diseases, and has influenced the way the pharmaceutical research & development (R&D) system operates beyond this policy area. Despite the success of the Orphan Drug model, the academic literature also highlights the negative implications that these public policies have on affordability and access to orphan drugs, as well as on the prioritization of certain disease rare areas over others. The synthesis focuses mostly on the United States’ Orphan Drug Act (ODA) as a model for subsequent policies in other regions and countries. It starts with a historical overview of the creation of the term “rare diseases”, continues with a summary of the evidence available on the US ODA’s positive and negative impacts, and provides a summary of the different proposals to reform these incentives in light of the negative outcomes described. Finally, it describes some key aspects of the Japanese and European policies, as well as some of the challenges captured in the literature related to their impact in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs).
- Open Access
- 24 February 2023
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 12, 211
Pharmaceutical policy and innovation for rare diseases: A narrative review
This article aims to synthesize the existing literature on the implementation of public policies to incentivize the development of treatments for rare diseases (which are diseases with very low prevalence and therefore with low commercial interest) otherwise known as orphan drugs. The implementation of these incentives in the 1980s in the United States (US), later in Japan, and in the European Union (EU) seems to be related to a substantial increase in treatments for these diseases, and has influenced the way the pharmaceutical research & development (R&D) system operates beyond this area. In spite of this success, the academic literature also highlights the negative implications that these public policies have on affordability and access to orphan drugs, as well as on the prioritization of certain rare disease areas over others. The synthesis focuses mostly on the United States’ Orphan Drug Act (ODA) as a model for subsequent policies in other regions and countries. It starts with a historical overview of the creation of the term “rare diseases”, continues with a summary of the evidence available on the US ODA’s positive and negative impacts, and provides a summary of the different proposals to reform these incentives in light of the negative outcomes described. Finally, it describes some key aspects of the Japanese and European policies, as well as some of the challenges captured in the literature related to their impact in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs).
- 24 February 2023
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 12, 211
Open AccessPharmaceutical policy and innovation for rare diseases: A narrative review
This article aims to synthesize the existing literature on the implementation of public policies to incentivize the development of treatments for rare diseases (which are diseases with very low prevalence and therefore with low commercial interest) otherwise known as orphan drugs. The implementation of these incentives in the 1980s in the United States (US), later in Japan, and in the European Union (EU) seems to be related to a substantial increase in treatments for these diseases, and has influenced the way the pharmaceutical research & development (R&D) system operates beyond this area. In spite of this success, the academic literature also highlights the negative implications that these public policies have on affordability and access to orphan drugs, as well as on the prioritization of certain rare disease areas over others. The synthesis focuses mostly on the United States’ Orphan Drug Act (ODA) as a model for subsequent policies in other regions and countries. It starts with a historical overview of the creation of the term “rare diseases”, continues with a summary of the evidence available on the US ODA’s positive and negative impacts, and provides a summary of the different proposals to reform these incentives in light of the negative outcomes described. Finally, it describes some key aspects of the Japanese and European policies, as well as some of the challenges captured in the literature related to their impact in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs).
- Open Access
- 16 August 2021
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 10, 190
Non-commercial pharmaceutical R&D: what do neglected diseases suggest about costs and efficiency?
Background: The past two decades have witnessed significant growth in non-commercial research and development (R&D) initiatives, particularly for neglected diseases, but there is limited understanding of the ways in which they compare with commercial R&D. This study analyses costs, timelines, and attrition rates of non-commercial R&D across multiple initiatives and how they compare to commercial R&D. Methods: This is a mixed-method, observational, descriptive, and analytic study. We contacted 48 non-commercial R&D initiatives and received either quantitative and/or qualitative data from 13 organizations. We used the Portfolio to Impact (P2I) model’s estimates of average costs, timelines, and attrition rates for commercial R&D, while noting that P2I cost estimates are far lower than some previous findings in the literature. Results: The quantitative data suggested that the costs and timelines per candidate per phase (from preclinical through Phase 3) of non-commercial R&D for new chemical entities are largely in line with commercial averages. The quantitative data was insufficient to compare attrition rates. The qualitative data identified more reasons why non-commercial R&D costs would be lower than commercial R&D, timelines would be longer, and attrition rates would be equivalent or higher, though the data does not allow for estimating the magnitude of these effects. Conclusions: The quantitative data suggest that costs and timelines per candidate per phase were largely in line with (lower-end estimates of) commercial averages. We were unable to draw conclusions on overall efficiency, however, due to insufficient data on attrition rates. Given that non-commercial R&D is a nascent area of research with limited data available, this study contributes to the literature by generating hypotheses for further testing against a larger sample of quantitative data. It also offers a range of explanatory factors for further exploration regarding how non-commercial and commercial R&D may differ in costs and efficiency.
- 16 August 2021
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 10, 190
Open AccessNon-commercial pharmaceutical R&D: what do neglected diseases suggest about costs and efficiency?
Background: The past two decades have witnessed significant growth in non-commercial research and development (R&D) initiatives, particularly for neglected diseases, but there is limited understanding of the ways in which they compare with commercial R&D. This study analyses costs, timelines, and attrition rates of non-commercial R&D across multiple initiatives and how they compare to commercial R&D. Methods: This is a mixed-method, observational, descriptive, and analytic study. We contacted 48 non-commercial R&D initiatives and received either quantitative and/or qualitative data from 13 organizations. We used the Portfolio to Impact (P2I) model’s estimates of average costs, timelines, and attrition rates for commercial R&D, while noting that P2I cost estimates are far lower than some previous findings in the literature. Results: The quantitative data suggested that the costs and timelines per candidate per phase (from preclinical through Phase 3) of non-commercial R&D for new chemical entities are largely in line with commercial averages. The quantitative data was insufficient to compare attrition rates. The qualitative data identified more reasons why non-commercial R&D costs would be lower than commercial R&D, timelines would be longer, and attrition rates would be equivalent or higher, though the data does not allow for estimating the magnitude of these effects. Conclusions: The quantitative data suggest that costs and timelines per candidate per phase were largely in line with (lower-end estimates of) commercial averages. We were unable to draw conclusions on overall efficiency, however, due to insufficient data on attrition rates. Given that non-commercial R&D is a nascent area of research with limited data available, this study contributes to the literature by generating hypotheses for further testing against a larger sample of quantitative data. It also offers a range of explanatory factors for further exploration regarding how non-commercial and commercial R&D may differ in costs and efficiency.
- Open Access
- 8 March 2021
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 10, 190
Non-commercial pharmaceutical R&D: what do neglected diseases suggest about costs and efficiency?
Background: The past two decades have witnessed significant growth in non-commercial research and development (R&D) initiatives, particularly for neglected diseases, but there is limited understanding of the ways in which they compare with traditional commercial R&D. This study analyses costs, timeframes, and attrition rates of non-commercial R&D across multiple initiatives and how they compare to commercial R&D using the Portfolio-to-Impact (P2I) model as parameter of comparison. Methods: This is a mixed-method, observational, descriptive and analytic study. We contacted 48 non-commercial R&D initiatives and received quantitative data from 8 organizations on 83 candidate products, and qualitative data through 14 interviews from 12 organizations. Results: The quantitative data suggested that non-commercial R&D for new chemical entities is largely in line with P2I averages regarding total costs and timeframes, with variation by phase. The qualitative data identified more reasons why non-commercial R&D costs would be lower than commercial R&D, timeframes would be longer and attrition rates would be equivalent or higher, though the magnitude of effect is not known. The overall emerging hypothesis is that direct costs of non-commercial R&D are expected to be equivalent or somewhat lower than commercial, timeframes are expected to be equivalent or somewhat longer and attrition rates would be equivalent. Conclusions: The study found that non-commercial R&D differs in many significant ways from commercial R&D. However, it is possible that the sum of these differences cancelled each other out such that total costs, timeframes and attrition rates were largely in line with P2I averages. Given the nascent area, with almost no prior literature focusing on costs, timeframes or attrition rates of non-commercial R&D initiatives, we see the merits of this study as generating hypotheses for further testing against a larger sample of quantitative data, and for understanding reasons underlying any significant differences between non-commercial and commercial initiatives.
- 8 March 2021
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 10, 190
Open AccessNon-commercial pharmaceutical R&D: what do neglected diseases suggest about costs and efficiency?
Background: The past two decades have witnessed significant growth in non-commercial research and development (R&D) initiatives, particularly for neglected diseases, but there is limited understanding of the ways in which they compare with traditional commercial R&D. This study analyses costs, timeframes, and attrition rates of non-commercial R&D across multiple initiatives and how they compare to commercial R&D using the Portfolio-to-Impact (P2I) model as parameter of comparison. Methods: This is a mixed-method, observational, descriptive and analytic study. We contacted 48 non-commercial R&D initiatives and received quantitative data from 8 organizations on 83 candidate products, and qualitative data through 14 interviews from 12 organizations. Results: The quantitative data suggested that non-commercial R&D for new chemical entities is largely in line with P2I averages regarding total costs and timeframes, with variation by phase. The qualitative data identified more reasons why non-commercial R&D costs would be lower than commercial R&D, timeframes would be longer and attrition rates would be equivalent or higher, though the magnitude of effect is not known. The overall emerging hypothesis is that direct costs of non-commercial R&D are expected to be equivalent or somewhat lower than commercial, timeframes are expected to be equivalent or somewhat longer and attrition rates would be equivalent. Conclusions: The study found that non-commercial R&D differs in many significant ways from commercial R&D. However, it is possible that the sum of these differences cancelled each other out such that total costs, timeframes and attrition rates were largely in line with P2I averages. Given the nascent area, with almost no prior literature focusing on costs, timeframes or attrition rates of non-commercial R&D initiatives, we see the merits of this study as generating hypotheses for further testing against a larger sample of quantitative data, and for understanding reasons underlying any significant differences between non-commercial and commercial initiatives.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2010
- Published by Universidade de São Paulo. Agência de Bibliotecas e Coleções Digitais in Revista de Direito Sanitário
- Vol. 11 (2) , 164-188
O instituto de patentes Pipeline e o acesso a medicamentos: aspectos econômicos e jurídicos deletérios à economia da saúde
O instituto de patentes Pipeline e o acesso a medicamentos: aspectos econômicos e jurídicos deletérios à economia da saúde
- 1 October 2010
- Published by Universidade de São Paulo. Agência de Bibliotecas e Coleções Digitais in Revista de Direito Sanitário
- Vol. 11 (2) , 164-188
Open AccessO instituto de patentes Pipeline e o acesso a medicamentos: aspectos econômicos e jurídicos deletérios à economia da saúde
O instituto de patentes Pipeline e o acesso a medicamentos: aspectos econômicos e jurídicos deletérios à economia da saúde