RSRaelyn Marguerite Sullivan

Raelyn Marguerite Sullivan

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Raelyn Marguerite Sullivan has a total of 165 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    LiteBIRD science goals and forecasts. E -mode anomalies

    by A.J. Banday, C. Gimeno-Amo, P. Diego-Palazuelos, E. de la Hoz, A. Gruppuso, N. Raffuzzi, E. Martínez-González, P. Vielva, R.B. Barreiro, M. Bortolami, et al.

    Various so-called anomalies have been found in both the WMAP and Planck cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature data that exert a mild tension against the highly successful best-fit 6 parameter cosmological model, potentially providing hints of new physics to be explored. That these are real features on the sky is uncontested. However, given their modest significance, whether they are indicative of true departures from the standard cosmology or simply statistical excursions due to a mildly unusual configuration of temperature anisotropies on the sky which we refer to as the “fluke hypothesis” cannot be addressed further without new information. No theoretical model of primordial perturbations has to date been constructed that can explain all of the temperature anomalies. Therefore, we focus in this paper on testing the fluke hypothesis, based on the partial correlation between the temperature and E -mode CMB polarisation signal. In particular, we compare the properties of specific statistics in polarisation, built from unconstrained realisations of the ΛCDM cosmological model as might be observed by the LiteBIRD satellite, with those determined from constrained simulations, where the part of the E -mode anisotropy correlated with temperature is constrained by observations of the latter. Specifically, we use inpainted Planck 2018 SMICA temperature data to constrain the E -mode realisations. Subsequent analysis makes use of masks defined to minimise the impact of the inpainting procedure on the E -mode map statistics. We find that statistical assessments of the E -mode data alone do not provide any evidence for or against the fluke hypothesis. However, tests based on cross-statistical measures determined from temperature and E modes can allow this hypothesis to be rejected with a moderate level of probability.


  • Open Access

    LiteBIRD science goals and forecasts: constraining isotropic cosmic birefringence

    by E. de la Hoz, P. Diego-Palazuelos, J. Errard, A. Gruppuso, B. Jost, R.M. Sullivan, M. Bortolami, Y. Chinone, L.T. Hergt, E. Komatsu, et al.

    Cosmic birefringence (CB) is the rotation of the photons' linear polarisation plane during propagation. Such an effect is a tracer of parity-violating extensions of standard electromagnetism and would probe the existence of a new cosmological field acting as dark matter or dark energy. It has become customary to employ cosmic microwave background (CMB) polarised data to probe such a phenomenon. Recent analyses on Planck and WMAP data provide a hint of detection of the isotropic CB angle with an amplitude of around 0.3° at the level of 2.4 to 3.6σ. In this work, we explore the LiteBIRD capabilities in constraining such an effect, accounting for the impact of the more relevant systematic effects, namely foreground emission and instrumental polarisation angles. We build five semi-independent pipelines and test these against four different simulation sets with increasing complexity in terms of non-idealities. All the pipelines are shown to be robust and capable of returning the expected values of the CB angle within statistical fluctuations for all the cases considered. We find that the uncertainties in the CB estimates increase with more complex simulations. However, the trend is less pronounced for pipelines that account for the instrumental polarisation angles. For the most complex case analysed, we find that LiteBIRD will be able to detect a CB angle of 0.3° with a statistical significance ranging from 5 to 13σ, depending on the pipeline employed, where the latter uncertainty corresponds to a total error budget of the order of 0.02°.


  • Open Access

    Planck PR4 (NPIPE) map-space cosmic birefringence

    by Raelyn M. Sullivan, Arefe Abghari, Patricia Diego-Palazuelos, Lukas T. Hergt, Douglas Scott

    Cosmic birefringence is an effect where the plane of polarisation of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) is rotated by an angle β through coupling to a hypothetical parity-violating field. We analyse the Planck Public Release 4 (PR4 or NPIPE) data using a map-space analysis method and find β= 0.46° ± 0.04°(stat.) ± 0.28°(syst.) for SEVEM CMB maps and β = 0.48° ± 0.04°(stat.) ± 0.28°(syst.) for Commander CMB maps. These values are slightly higher than previously published results, which may be explained by the fact that we have not attempted to remove any potential bias from miscalibration of the Planck polarimeters. The uncertainty in this miscalibration dominates the systematic uncertainty, which also means that our results are consistent with no parity violation. An advantage of the map-space analysis is that it is easy to investigate any variations on the sky, for example caused by foreground contamination. Our results for isotropic birefringence are fairly robust against different spatial data cuts, but there may be hints of a foreground systematic (north versus south hemispheres) or uncontrolled miscalibration effect (T peaks versus E peaks) that should be followed up in future studies. We additionally find no evidence of a cosmic birefringence dipole (anisotropic birefringence).


  • Open Access

    Methods for CMB Map Analysis

    by Raelyn M. Sullivan, Lukas Tobias Hergt, Douglas Scott

    There are standard tools for analyzing cosmic microwave background maps. However, several important details are not usually highlighted. Here we describe best practices for several common map-modifying procedures, including masking, downgrading resolution, convolving with beam and pixel window functions, and adding white noise. We will explore how these modifications affect the final power spectrum measured from a map. We recommend the best ways to perform each of these procedures, describe when the different steps and measures should be carried out, and show the effects of incorrectly performing or applying any of them.


  • Open Access

    Planck PR4 (NPIPE) map-space cosmic birefringence

    by Raelyn Marguerite Sullivan, Arefe Abghari, Patricia Diego-Palazuelos, Lukas Tobias Hergt, Douglas Scott

    Cosmic birefringence is an effect where the plane of polarisation of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) is rotated by an angle $β$ through coupling to a hypothetical parity-violating field. We analyse the Planck Public Release 4 (PR4 or NPIPE) data using a map-space analysis method and find $β=0.46^\circ\pm 0.04^\circ(\mathrm{stat.})\pm0.28^\circ(\mathrm{syst.})$ for SEVEM CMB maps and $β=0.48^\circ\pm 0.04^\circ(\mathrm{stat.})\pm 0.28^\circ(\mathrm{syst.})$ for Commander CMB maps. These values are slightly higher than previously published results, which may be explained by the fact that we have not attempted to remove any potential bias from miscalibration of the Planck polarimeters. The uncertainty in this miscalibration dominates the systematic uncertainty, which also means that our results are consistent with no parity violation. An advantage of the map-space analysis is that it is easy to investigate any variations on the sky, for example caused by foreground contamination. Our results for isotropic birefringence are fairly robust against different spatial data cuts, but there may be hints of a foreground systematic (north versus south hemispheres) or uncontrolled miscalibration effect (T peaks versus E peaks) that should be followed up in future studies. We additionally find no evidence of a cosmic birefringence dipole (anisotropic birefringence).

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Cosmic Birefringence from thePlanckData Release 4

    by P. Diego-Palazuelos, J. R. Eskilt, Y. Minami, M. Tristram, R. M. Sullivan, A. J. Banday, R. B. Barreiro, H. K. Eriksen, K. M. Górski, R. Keskitalo, et al.

    We search for the signature of parity-violating physics in the cosmic microwave background, called cosmic birefringence, using the Planck data release 4. We initially find a birefringence angle of β=0.30°±0.11° (68% C.L.) for nearly full-sky data. The values of β decrease as we enlarge the Galactic mask, which can be interpreted as the effect of polarized foreground emission. Two independent ways to model this effect are used to mitigate the systematic impact on β for different sky fractions. We choose not to assign cosmological significance to the measured value of β until we improve our knowledge of the foreground polarization.


  • Open Access

    Cosmic backgrounds from the radio to the far-infrared: recent results and perspectives from cosmological and astrophysical surveys

    by Carlo Burigana, Elia Sefano Battistelli, Laura Bonavera, Tirthankar Roy Choudhury, Marcos Lopez-Caniego, Constantinos Skordis, Raelyn Marguerite Sullivan, Hideki Tanimura, Seddigheh Tizchang, Matthieu Tristram, et al.

    Cosmological and astrophysical surveys in various wavebands, in particular from the radio to the far-infrared, offer a unique view of the universe's properties and the formation and evolution of its structures. After a preamble on the so-called tension problem, which occurs when different types of data are used to determine cosmological parameters, we discuss the role of fast radio bursts in cosmology, in particular for the missing baryon problem, and the perspectives from the analysis of the 21 cm redshifted line from neutral hydrogen. We then describe the Planck Legacy Archive, its wealth of scientific information and next developments, and the promising perspectives expected from higher resolution observations, in particular for the analysis of the thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect. Three cosmological results of the Planck mission are presented next: the implications of the map of Comptonization fluctuations, the dipole analysis from cross-correlating cosmic microwave background anisotropy and Comptonization fluctuation maps, and the constraints on the primordial tensor-to-scalar perturbation ratio. Finally, we discuss some future perspectives and alternative scenarios in cosmology, such as the study of the Lorentz invariance violation with the cosmic microwave background polarization, the introduction of new gravitational degrees of freedom to solve the dark matter problem, and the exploitation of the magnification bias with high-redshift sub-millimeter galaxies to constrain cosmological parameters.

  • Role of T0 in CMB anisotropy measurements

    by Yunfei Wen, Douglas Scott, Raelyn Sullivan, J. P. Zibin

    The quantity T0, the cosmic microwave background (CMB) monopole, is an often neglected seventh parameter of the standard cosmological model. As well as its variation affecting the physics of the CMB, the measurement of T0 is also used to calibrate the anisotropies via the orbital dipole. We point out that it is easy to misestimate the effect of T0 because the CMB anisotropies are conventionally provided in temperature units. In fact the anisotropies are most naturally described as dimensionless and we argue for restoring the convention of working with ΔT/T rather than ΔT. As a free cosmological parameter, T0 most naturally only impacts the CMB power spectra through late-time effects. Thus if we ignore the COBE-FIRAS measurement, current CMB data only weakly constrain T0. Even ideal future CMB data can at best provide a percent-level constraint on T0, although adding large-scale structure data will lead to further improvement. The FIRAS measurement is so precise that its uncertainty negligibly affects most, but not all, cosmological parameter inferences for current CMB experiments. However, if we eventually want to extract all available information from CMB power spectra measured to multipoles ℓ≃5000, then we will need a better determination of T0 than is currently available.


  • Open Access

    The role of $T_0$ in CMB anisotropy measurements

    by Yunfei Wen, Douglas Scott, Raelyn Sullivan, J. P. Zibin

    The quantity $T_0$, the cosmic microwave background (CMB) monopole, is an often neglected seventh parameter of the standard cosmological model. As well as its variation affecting the physics of the CMB, the measurement of $T_0$ is also used to calibrate the anisotropies, via the orbital dipole. We point out that it is easy to misestimate the effect of $T_0$ because the CMB anisotropies are conventionally provided in temperature units. In fact the anisotropies are most naturally described as dimensionless and we argue for restoring the convention of working with $\Delta T/T$ rather than $\Delta T$. As a free cosmological parameter, $T_0$ most naturally only impacts the CMB power spectra through late-time effects. Thus if we ignore the COBE-FIRAS measurement, current CMB data only weakly constrain $T_0$. Even ideal future CMB data can at best provide a percent-level constraint on $T_0$, although adding large-scale structure data will lead to further improvement. The FIRAS measurement is so precise that its uncertainty negligibly effects most, but not all, cosmological parameter inferences for current CMB experiments. However, if we eventually want to extract all available information from CMB power spectra measured to multipoles $\ell\simeq5000$, then we will need a better determination of $T_0$ than is currently available.

  • Searching for extremal spots in Planck lensing maps

    by Clemens Jakubec, Raelyn M. Sullivan, Douglas Scott

    A great deal of attention has been given to the so-called Cold Spot in maps of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature. We present a similar analysis, searching for extremal spots in the CMB lensing convergence and lensing potential maps from the Planck 2018 data release. We perform a multi-scale and multi-filter analysis using the first three members of the Mexican-hat wavelet family to search for extremal features of different shapes and sizes. Although an initial analysis appears to show the existence of some extremal spots at scales below about 5, we conclude, after marginalising over all scales and filters, that no significant features are detected in the lensing maps. We conclude that in terms of maxima and minima of various sizes, the lensing data have similar statistical properties to Gaussian simulations.