M.A. Kotugina
M.A. Kotugina has a total of 14 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mariya I. Pakharukova
Clinical and Diagnostic Center of Yekaterinburg
3 shared publications - L.N. Rebrikova
Clinical and Diagnostic Center of Yekaterinburg
2 shared publications - B. G. Yushkov
Institute of Immunology and Physiology of the Ural Branch of the RAS
1 shared publication - E.E. Lysak1 shared publication
- E.S. Gorchakovskaia
Sverdlovsk Regional Oncological Dispensary
1 shared publication - Elena Vainberg
The Hebrew University School of Medicine
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 January 2024
- Published by FSBSI Research Institute of Human Morphology in CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL MORPHOLOGY
- Vol. 13 (1)
Application of cyto-histological correlation as a quality control in diagnosing cervical pathology
Introduction. In Russia, cervical cancer screening with cytological techniques faces a problem of quality control. Currently, it is necessary to standardize the methodology for comparing the results of morphological methods. The aim of the paper was to compare the findings of cytological and histological studies when diagnosing cervical pathology, classify discrepancies, and evaluate the effectiveness of the cytological method. Materials and methods. A comparative retrospective analysis of cytological examination followed by histological examination was carried out in 2,739 patients. Results. Both methods showed coincidence in 57.9% of cases. Minor and major discrepancies were determined in 29% and 13.1% of cases, respectively. The cytologic technique showed the following figures: sensitivity of 79.3%, specificity of 77.6%, positive prognostic value of 80%, and negative predictive value of 76.9%. When using the liquid-based cytology method, the number of true positive results was significantly higher, while that of false negative results was lower. The interval of up to 2 months between cytological and histological examinations yielded the highest rate of true positive and the lowest rate of false negative results. Conclusion. Comparing the results of morphological methods is most likely to be the best option for ensuring quality control of laboratory tests. This should be a guideline with a subsequent revision of samples in the presence of discrepancies, analysis of their causes, and evaluation of method effectiveness.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by FSBSI Research Institute of Human Morphology in CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL MORPHOLOGY
- Vol. 13 (1)
Application of cyto-histological correlation as a quality control in diagnosing cervical pathology
Introduction. In Russia, cervical cancer screening with cytological techniques faces a problem of quality control. Currently, it is necessary to standardize the methodology for comparing the results of morphological methods. The aim of the paper was to compare the findings of cytological and histological studies when diagnosing cervical pathology, classify discrepancies, and evaluate the effectiveness of the cytological method. Materials and methods. A comparative retrospective analysis of cytological examination followed by histological examination was carried out in 2,739 patients. Results. Both methods showed coincidence in 57.9% of cases. Minor and major discrepancies were determined in 29% and 13.1% of cases, respectively. The cytologic technique showed the following figures: sensitivity of 79.3%, specificity of 77.6%, positive prognostic value of 80%, and negative predictive value of 76.9%. When using the liquid-based cytology method, the number of true positive results was significantly higher, while that of false negative results was lower. The interval of up to 2 months between cytological and histological examinations yielded the highest rate of true positive and the lowest rate of false negative results. Conclusion. Comparing the results of morphological methods is most likely to be the best option for ensuring quality control of laboratory tests. This should be a guideline with a subsequent revision of samples in the presence of discrepancies, analysis of their causes, and evaluation of method effectiveness.
- 28 December 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Laboratory Service
- Vol. 12 (4)
Diagnostic assessment of the cytological method in the diagnosis of glandular lesions during cervical screening: the results of a retrospective single-center analysis
Атипичные железистые клетки (AGC) — редкое цитологическое заключение при цервикальном скрининге. Диагностика железистых поражений представляет ряд трудностей. Появившиеся в последние годы исследования обсуждают необходимость подкатегорий AGC ввиду их разной прогностической значимости. ЦЕЛЬ РАБОТЫ Оценить частоту встречаемости атипичных железистых клеток у пациенток с впервые выявленным раком тела матки, показатели эффективности цитологического метода в диагностике железистых поражений, а также клиническую значимость подкатегорий AGC. МАТЕРИАЛ И МЕТОДЫ Для оценки частоты обнаружения клеток эндометрия при цервикальном скрининге у пациенток с раком тела матки включены результаты 197 обследованных за 2021—2022 гг. Проведен сравнительный ретроспективный анализ результатов цитологического исследования 320 мазков с последующим гистологическим исследованием материала в период с 2018 по 2022 г. Произведен расчет показателей эффективности цитологического метода. РЕЗУЛЬТАТЫ Клетки эндометрия у пациенток с подтвержденным раком тела матки при цервикальном скрининге обнаруживались в 41,1% случаев. Чувствительность цитологического метода исследования в диагностике железистых поражений составила 83,8% (95% ДИ 77,7—88,8%), специфичность — 88,8% (95% ДИ 82,2—93,60%), PPV — 91,2% (95% ДИ 85,7—94,98%), NPV — 79,9% (95% ДИ 72,5—85,9%). Получены статистически значимые различия вероятности обнаружения злокачественного новообразования или неопластического процесса в зависимости от цитологического заключения в следующих категориях: NILM, EM и ADC, EM (pp=0,019); AGC NOS, EM и ADC, EM (pp=0,009). ЗАКЛЮЧЕНИЕ Цитологический метод обладает высокими показателями эффективности для диагностики железистых поражений. При подразделении категории AGC NOS на EC/EM и AGC FN на EC/EM возрастает прогностическая значимость цитологического заключения для дальнейшего обследования пациенток.
- 28 December 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Laboratory Service
- Vol. 12 (4)
Diagnostic assessment of the cytological method in the diagnosis of glandular lesions during cervical screening: the results of a retrospective single-center analysis
Атипичные железистые клетки (AGC) — редкое цитологическое заключение при цервикальном скрининге. Диагностика железистых поражений представляет ряд трудностей. Появившиеся в последние годы исследования обсуждают необходимость подкатегорий AGC ввиду их разной прогностической значимости. ЦЕЛЬ РАБОТЫ Оценить частоту встречаемости атипичных железистых клеток у пациенток с впервые выявленным раком тела матки, показатели эффективности цитологического метода в диагностике железистых поражений, а также клиническую значимость подкатегорий AGC. МАТЕРИАЛ И МЕТОДЫ Для оценки частоты обнаружения клеток эндометрия при цервикальном скрининге у пациенток с раком тела матки включены результаты 197 обследованных за 2021—2022 гг. Проведен сравнительный ретроспективный анализ результатов цитологического исследования 320 мазков с последующим гистологическим исследованием материала в период с 2018 по 2022 г. Произведен расчет показателей эффективности цитологического метода. РЕЗУЛЬТАТЫ Клетки эндометрия у пациенток с подтвержденным раком тела матки при цервикальном скрининге обнаруживались в 41,1% случаев. Чувствительность цитологического метода исследования в диагностике железистых поражений составила 83,8% (95% ДИ 77,7—88,8%), специфичность — 88,8% (95% ДИ 82,2—93,60%), PPV — 91,2% (95% ДИ 85,7—94,98%), NPV — 79,9% (95% ДИ 72,5—85,9%). Получены статистически значимые различия вероятности обнаружения злокачественного новообразования или неопластического процесса в зависимости от цитологического заключения в следующих категориях: NILM, EM и ADC, EM (pp=0,019); AGC NOS, EM и ADC, EM (pp=0,009). ЗАКЛЮЧЕНИЕ Цитологический метод обладает высокими показателями эффективности для диагностики железистых поражений. При подразделении категории AGC NOS на EC/EM и AGC FN на EC/EM возрастает прогностическая значимость цитологического заключения для дальнейшего обследования пациенток.
- 1 January 2021
- Published by FSBSI Research Institute of Human Morphology in CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL MORPHOLOGY
- Vol. 10 (1)
Analyzing the differences between the cytological and histological methods in the vulva malignant neoplasm diagnosis
Introduction. Vulvar cancer is a rare female genital tract tumor. Unfortunately, the final diagnosis is often made in the late stage despite the available visualization methods. It indicates the need to improve the early diagnosis methods. The aim of the study was to improve the efficiency of the cytological diagnosis of vulvar cancer and pre-cancerous lesions by comparing the cytological and histological findings and diagnoses and analyzing the differences. Materials and methods. A retrospective analysis of the biopsies, smears, and scrapings of 82 patients from 2014 to 2019 was carried out. Results. We found that true positive conclusions were given in 75% of cases, false negative – in 25% (17 cases). False positive results (overdiagnosis) occurred in 3.6% of all cases compared. The sensitivity of the cytological method was 76.4%, its specificity – 70%. We discussed the possible causes of incorrect cytology conclusions. Conclusion. A retrospective analysis of the discrepancy between the cytological and the histological diag-noses allowed us to identify the microscopic features that resulted into incorrect conclusions and, thus, to increase the reliability of the cytological diagnosis Keywords: vulvar cancer, neoplasia, melanoma, Paget’s disease, vulvar cytology
- 1 January 2021
- Published by FSBSI Research Institute of Human Morphology in CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL MORPHOLOGY
- Vol. 10 (1)
Analyzing the differences between the cytological and histological methods in the vulva malignant neoplasm diagnosis
Introduction. Vulvar cancer is a rare female genital tract tumor. Unfortunately, the final diagnosis is often made in the late stage despite the available visualization methods. It indicates the need to improve the early diagnosis methods. The aim of the study was to improve the efficiency of the cytological diagnosis of vulvar cancer and pre-cancerous lesions by comparing the cytological and histological findings and diagnoses and analyzing the differences. Materials and methods. A retrospective analysis of the biopsies, smears, and scrapings of 82 patients from 2014 to 2019 was carried out. Results. We found that true positive conclusions were given in 75% of cases, false negative – in 25% (17 cases). False positive results (overdiagnosis) occurred in 3.6% of all cases compared. The sensitivity of the cytological method was 76.4%, its specificity – 70%. We discussed the possible causes of incorrect cytology conclusions. Conclusion. A retrospective analysis of the discrepancy between the cytological and the histological diag-noses allowed us to identify the microscopic features that resulted into incorrect conclusions and, thus, to increase the reliability of the cytological diagnosis Keywords: vulvar cancer, neoplasia, melanoma, Paget’s disease, vulvar cytology