Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Tuba Bircan has a total of 73 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Working to Do and Working to Be: Adolescent Girls’ Labor and Identity in a Rural Migrant Community in Bolivia

    by Camila Jimenez-Sanchez, Gerrit Loots, Tuba Bircan

    For rural adolescent girls in the Bolivian Andes, adolescence is not a “protected” transitional life stage but a gendered laboring condition. This article explores the lived experiences of adolescent girls in a rural Quechua community in Cochabamba, drawing on the initial phase of a longitudinal Community-Based Participatory Research (CBPR) project (2023–2024). By integrating Silvia Federici’s theory of social reproduction with Axel Honneth’s recognition theory, the study conceptualizes a “laboring subjectivity” defined by a ch’ixi reality where two dimensions of labor exist in constant, dynamic interaction. The findings reveal these dimensions of labor: “Working to Do,” which encompasses the invisible, naturalized reproductive and agricultural work and unremunerated affective work required to sustain family life as a form of cultural pedagogy; and “Working to Be,” which refers to the subjective labor girls perform to negotiate recognition. Through this structural arrangement, Honneth’s spheres of love, rights, and social esteem are systematically compromised, creating a distinct recognition deficit as girls carry adult responsibilities without structural protection. Ultimately, this article argues that seasonal migration to regions such as El Trópico functions as an existential terrain where girls seek the symbolic and economic recognition denied within the local rural order. By centering adolescent girls as active laboring subjects, the research challenges Western developmental biases in youth studies and offers a nuanced reframing of the nexus between labor, mobility, and identity formation in the Global South.

  • Open Access

    From compliance to refusal: White childhoods and abolitionist imaginaries in early childhood education and care

    by Duha Ceylan, Tuba Bircan, Michel Vandenbroeck

    This paper introduces the concept of white childhoods as a critical framework to examine how whiteness, coloniality, and racial capitalism shape early childhood education and care systems in Europe. Dominant norms of childhood, rooted in white, middle-class, heteronormative, and non-disabled ideals, structure how children are seen as emotionally legible, developmentally "normal," and worthy of institutional care. Racialized and migrant children are often positioned as deficient, with their languages, cultural practices, and family structures rendered unintelligible or threatening. Drawing on in-depth interviews with Syrian mothers and ethnographic observations across Belgium, Germany, and the Netherlands, the paper maps how white childhoods are enforced through language policy, affective expectations, and maternal surveillance. Beyond critique, the paper uses short speculative vignettes to explore abolitionist futures in which care is collective, multilingualism is embraced, and belonging is not conditional. These speculative fragments are grounded in the lived experiences and quiet refusals voiced by migrant mothers, treating imagination as both method and political strategy. Rather than seeking inclusion or reform, the paper calls for dismantling the racialized logics of early childhood education and care and for building educational spaces grounded in relationality, cultural sovereignty, and joy. Abolition here is framed not as utopian idealism but as a pedagogical and methodological commitment to living otherwise.


  • Open Access

    Editorial: New methodological approaches for migration and mobility studies: from traditional to big data

    by Tuba Bircan, Haodong Qi

    In their article, Nalbandian and Dreher (2023) provide a comprehensive review of advanced digital technologies in migration management. They chart the growing use of biometrics, artificial intelligence, mobile analytics, and drones across different regions and governance domains. Their analysis exposes a striking gap: while technological experimentation is widespread, systematic technical evaluation is rare. Descriptive accounts dominate, particularly in high-stakes domains such as border surveillance and asylum processing. Without calibration against independent benchmarks, the risk is techno-solutionism, policies justified by tools whose performance is neither transparent nor reproducible. The review calls for deeper scrutiny, interdisciplinary collaboration, and attention to the power asymmetries that shape how technologies are deployed.Where Nalbandian and Dreher highlight the risks of under-evaluation, Umel (2024) shows how calibration can also be interpretative. Combining topic modelling with ethnographically informed qualitative analysis, and grounding both in social representations theory, the study examines Filipino migrants' Facebook exchanges in Germany. Rather than treating automated topics as answers, the approach positions them as pointers requiring contextual interpretation. This reflexive design demonstrates that calibration is not limited to statistical benchmarking but also involves anchoring computational outputs in theory and meaning. In multilingual and culturally dense settings, validity arises not from scale but from aligning methods with lived realities. Kondyli, Nisiotis, and Klironomos (2024) remind us that calibration is not only a methodological practice but also an infrastructural achievement. Using the SoDaNet repository in Greece as a case study, they show how rigorous documentation, anonymisation, versioning, and persistent identifiers enable secondary analysis and replication. Their demonstration of "secondary added value" highlights how indices, replications, and derivative datasets themselves become future benchmarks. Calibration therefore depends on more than individual diligence: it requires repositories and infrastructures that embed transparency and reusability in the architecture of migration research. This echoes broader calls for FAIR data principles to become operational realities rather than aspirational slogans.Ahmad Yar and Bircan (2025) provide a state-of-the-art synthesis on the role of big data in migration statistics. They show that digital traces, social media activity, mobile phone records, and satellite imagery, have genuine strengths in timeliness and granularity, and have advanced nowcasting, short-term mobility mapping, and integration research. However, the value of these innovations lies not in isolated applications but in systematic approaches that combine computational methods with established demographic infrastructures (Salah, Korkmaz, & Bircan, 2022). Yet persistent weaknesses remain: digital divides, unstable denominators, proprietary data access, and a several lack of detailed demographic information of migrants. Their conclusion is clear. Big data has scientific value not in isolation but when triangulated with registers, surveys, and administrative data, and when models are validated against credible counterfactuals. Calibration is thus the route from experimental innovation to policy relevance.When considered as a whole in this research topic, the papers point to a shared agenda for methodological progress. First, validation against trusted benchmarks is a must, not an optional add-on. These benchmarks continue to rely on long-standing instruments such as censuses, registers, and household surveys, which remain the backbone of official migration statistics worldwide (UN DESA, 2020). Without systematic comparison to such sources, computational estimates remain largely uncertain and questionable. Second, reflexivity must be treated as integral to calibration. Automated analyses of online discourse or mobility traces cannot stand alone; they must be anchored in theoretical and contextual interpretation to avoid decontextualisation or cultural misreading. Third, infrastructures for documentation and reuse are essential to make calibration sustainable, turning individual good practice into collective scientific standards. Infrastructures such as repositories, metadata systems, and replication protocols extend calibration from a scholarly habit to a field-wide norm.While big data holds potential for migration research, it cannot substitute for traditional sources. A full transition 'from traditional to big data' is neither feasible nor desirable. What emerges instead is complementary methodological innovations; traditional sources continue to offer comparability, demographic depth, and legal anchoring, meanwhile, big data sources provide timely and granular information, enabling deeper insights into the spatial-temporal patterns of human mobility. Qualitative and participatory approaches, on the other hand, add context, ensuring that numerical findings are interpretable. Calibration is the practice that holds these strands together, through adaptive statistical frameworks that can integrate prior knowledge into statistical analysis, mandates for sharing code and metadata ensuring reproducible numerical findings, and ethics-by-design protocols that protect individuals while allowing verification.The calibration process proposed here by no means intends to address all aspects of limitations and challenges in migration research. Some populations will remain difficult to observe and some data will remain inaccessible, leading to incomplete adjustments for sample selection and other biases. But the lesson from this Research Topic is clear. When new and traditional sources are aligned, findings become more credible, contestable, and reusable. This is the path by which methodological innovation strengthens not only predictive...


  • Combining Twitter and mobile phone data to observe border-rush: the Turkish-European border opening

    by Carlos Arcila-Calderón, Bilgeçağ Aydoğdu, Tuba Bircan, Bünyamin Gündüz, Onur Önes, Albert Ali Salah, Alina Sîrbu, Aydoğdu, Bilgeçağ, Gündüz, et al.


  • Open Access

    Augmentation or replication? Assessing big data’s role in migration studies

    by Tuba Bircan

    As the field of migration studies evolves in the digital age, big data analytics emerge as a potential game-changer, promising unprecedented granularity, timeliness, and dynamism in understanding migration patterns. However, the epistemic value added by this data explosion remains an open question. This paper critically appraises the claim, investigating the extent to which big data augments, rather than merely replicates, traditional data insights in migration studies. Through a rigorous literature review of empirical research, complemented by a conceptual analysis, we aim to map out the methodological shifts and intellectual advancements brought forth by big data. The potential scientific impact of this study extends into the heart of the discipline, providing critical illumination on the actual knowledge contribution of big data to migration studies. This, in turn, delivers a clarified roadmap for navigating the intersections of data science, migration research, and policymaking.


  • Open Access

    AI, big data, and quest for truth: the role of theoretical insight

    by Tuba Bircan

    This paper aims at exploring the dynamic interplay between advanced technological developments in AI and Big Data and the sustained relevance of theoretical frameworks in scientific inquiry. It questions whether the abundance of data in the AI era reduces the necessity for theory or, conversely, enhances its importance. Arguing for a synergistic approach, the paper emphasizes the need for integrating computational capabilities with theoretical insight to uncover deeper truths within extensive datasets. The discussion extends into computational social science, where elements from sociology, psychology, and economics converge. The application of these interdisciplinary theories in the context of AI is critically examined, highlighting the need for methodological diversity and addressing the ethical implications of AI-driven research. The paper concludes by identifying future trends and challenges in AI and computational social science, offering a call to action for the scientific community, policymakers, and society. Being positioned at the intersection of AI, data science, and social theory, this paper illuminates the complexities of our digital era and inspires a re-evaluation of the methodologies and ethics guiding our pursuit of knowledge.


  • A Bourdieusian theory on communicating an opinion about AI governance

    by Brett Binst, Tuba Bircan, Annelien Smets