Rakesh Sarwal
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Interests
Rakesh Sarwal has a total of 157 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Sankaran Venkata Subramanian
Harvard University, Cambridge, USA
7 shared publications - Yamini Sarwal
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Vardhman Mahavir Medical College & Safdarjung Hospital New Delhi India
5 shared publications K. S. James
International Institute for Population Sciences Mumbai Maharashtra India
4 shared publications- Neena Bhatia
Food and Nutrition and Food Technology Lady Irwin College University of Delhi New Delhi IND
4 shared publications - Phuong Hong Nguyen
Nutrition, Diets, and Health Unit, International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI), Washington D.C., USA
4 shared publications Prasanth Vairavana Regy
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Real-World Outcomes of a Traffic-Light Approach to Lifestyle Modification in Chronic Disease: Evidence from an Integrative Health Clinic
Background: Non-communicable diseases driven by unhealthy lifestyles are a growing and largely avoidable burden among industrial workers. Patient-level evidence on the effectiveness of structured lifestyle programmes delivered alongside standard care — such as a traffic-light dietary guideline, a Yoga protocol and a daily four-spice culinary infusion — remains limited. The Integrative Health Clinic (IHC) at ESIC Medical College & Hospital, Faridabad, India, is a family-medicine-style outpatient clinic that follows the 21-item Health Building Lifestyle Guideline and delivers care through a 7-step COM-B-based protocol. We therefore estimated patient-reported relief and compliance with three lifestyle practices in patients attending the IHC. Methods: We conducted a retrospective single-arm cohort of patients first seen between February 2025 and 30 September 2026, with follow-up through 4 November 2026. All patients received the three-component lifestyle intervention (advice on spice infusion, diet and Yoga) and were offered follow-up; the 1,466 patients with a usable telephone contact were called for feedback and reinforcement of practices. A physical visit with a coded diagnosis was treated as a valid record. Each patient called was coded once for relief and for spice, diet and Yoga compliance using the most recent definitive answer (YES/NO); calls without a definitive answer (“no response”, “not interested”) were skipped, and patients with no definitive answer on any call were classified as such. Disease burden, including the screening-detected diagnoses, was counted as patient–condition pairs and classed into 14 systems. Results: There were 4,047 valid visit records from 1,737 unique patients (904 female [52.0%]; mean age 40.3 ± 14.6 years; 833 male [48.0%]; mean age 44.8 ± 15.1 years). Of these, there were 1,035 single-visit [59.6%] and 702 revisit patients [40.4%], i.e. 2.33 visits per patient. The 1,466 analysed patients (763 female [52.1%] and 703 male [47.9%]) comprised 666 revisit and 800 single-visit patients. Their most frequent patient–condition pairs were hypertension (511), obesity (397) and arthritis (268); objective-evidence screening contributed 246 pairs in 233 patients (obesity 161, hypertension 39, anaemia 44, diabetes 2). Of the 1,466 (84.4% of 1,737) patients with a usable telephone contact who were called, 1,016 had a definitive relief answer: 850 (83.7%; 95% CI 81.3–85.8) reported relief and 166 reported no relief. The remaining 450 had no definitive answer. Among the 1,016 patients with a definitive answer, relief was 87.2% (395/453) in revisit versus 80.8% (455/563) in single-visit patients. Treating all 450 patients without a definitive relief answer as no relief, the conservative lower bound of patients reporting relief was 58.0% overall (850/1,466), 59.3% in revisit (395/666) and 56.9% in single-visit patients (455/800). Among the 1,016 patients with practice data, compliance with the spice infusion, diet and Yoga was 77.1%, 83.3% and 81.2%, respectively; counting all 450 non-responders as non-compliant gave conservative estimates of 53.4%, 57.7% and 56.3% for the three practices (n = 1,466). In the responding cohort, relief rose with the five-level compliance dose, from 5.2% (6/115) at dose 0 to 98.2% (326/332) at dose 4 (all three practices plus a repeat visit). Conclusions: In this exploratory single-arm cohort, patient-reported relief was more frequent at higher levels of a composite measure that combined the three practices and repeat visits. Because there was no comparison group and all lifestyle components were delivered jointly alongside continuing pharmacotherapy, causality cannot be inferred. The findings support feasibility and justify prospective, controlled, disease-specific studies. The efficacy of the four-spice infusion remains under study and is not yet a proven treatment.
Open AccessReal-World Outcomes of a Traffic-Light Approach to Lifestyle Modification in Chronic Disease: Evidence from an Integrative Health Clinic
Background: Non-communicable diseases driven by unhealthy lifestyles are a growing and largely avoidable burden among industrial workers. Patient-level evidence on the effectiveness of structured lifestyle programmes delivered alongside standard care — such as a traffic-light dietary guideline, a Yoga protocol and a daily four-spice culinary infusion — remains limited. The Integrative Health Clinic (IHC) at ESIC Medical College & Hospital, Faridabad, India, is a family-medicine-style outpatient clinic that follows the 21-item Health Building Lifestyle Guideline and delivers care through a 7-step COM-B-based protocol. We therefore estimated patient-reported relief and compliance with three lifestyle practices in patients attending the IHC. Methods: We conducted a retrospective single-arm cohort of patients first seen between February 2025 and 30 September 2026, with follow-up through 4 November 2026. All patients received the three-component lifestyle intervention (advice on spice infusion, diet and Yoga) and were offered follow-up; the 1,466 patients with a usable telephone contact were called for feedback and reinforcement of practices. A physical visit with a coded diagnosis was treated as a valid record. Each patient called was coded once for relief and for spice, diet and Yoga compliance using the most recent definitive answer (YES/NO); calls without a definitive answer (“no response”, “not interested”) were skipped, and patients with no definitive answer on any call were classified as such. Disease burden, including the screening-detected diagnoses, was counted as patient–condition pairs and classed into 14 systems. Results: There were 4,047 valid visit records from 1,737 unique patients (904 female [52.0%]; mean age 40.3 ± 14.6 years; 833 male [48.0%]; mean age 44.8 ± 15.1 years). Of these, there were 1,035 single-visit [59.6%] and 702 revisit patients [40.4%], i.e. 2.33 visits per patient. The 1,466 analysed patients (763 female [52.1%] and 703 male [47.9%]) comprised 666 revisit and 800 single-visit patients. Their most frequent patient–condition pairs were hypertension (511), obesity (397) and arthritis (268); objective-evidence screening contributed 246 pairs in 233 patients (obesity 161, hypertension 39, anaemia 44, diabetes 2). Of the 1,466 (84.4% of 1,737) patients with a usable telephone contact who were called, 1,016 had a definitive relief answer: 850 (83.7%; 95% CI 81.3–85.8) reported relief and 166 reported no relief. The remaining 450 had no definitive answer. Among the 1,016 patients with a definitive answer, relief was 87.2% (395/453) in revisit versus 80.8% (455/563) in single-visit patients. Treating all 450 patients without a definitive relief answer as no relief, the conservative lower bound of patients reporting relief was 58.0% overall (850/1,466), 59.3% in revisit (395/666) and 56.9% in single-visit patients (455/800). Among the 1,016 patients with practice data, compliance with the spice infusion, diet and Yoga was 77.1%, 83.3% and 81.2%, respectively; counting all 450 non-responders as non-compliant gave conservative estimates of 53.4%, 57.7% and 56.3% for the three practices (n = 1,466). In the responding cohort, relief rose with the five-level compliance dose, from 5.2% (6/115) at dose 0 to 98.2% (326/332) at dose 4 (all three practices plus a repeat visit). Conclusions: In this exploratory single-arm cohort, patient-reported relief was more frequent at higher levels of a composite measure that combined the three practices and repeat visits. Because there was no comparison group and all lifestyle components were delivered jointly alongside continuing pharmacotherapy, causality cannot be inferred. The findings support feasibility and justify prospective, controlled, disease-specific studies. The efficacy of the four-spice infusion remains under study and is not yet a proven treatment.
- Open Access
- 8 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Remission of Irritable Bowel Syndrome Achieved Through Combined Diet, Lifestyle Modification, and Yoga: A Case Report
This report describes a 33-year-old male who was initially suspected of having Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) based on radiological findings, but was ultimately diagnosed with Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) using the Rome IV criteria, supported by normal colonoscopy findings and inflammatory biomarkers. When symptomatic pharmacotherapy for pain, constipation, and heartburn failed to provide lasting relief, he was referred for lifestyle therapy. Dietary modification, lifestyle counselling, and physical activity constitute the mainstay of current IBS management guidelines; however, beyond these broad recommendations, patients receive little practical guidance on day-to-day decision-making and the essential elements of healthy living. To address these limitations, we implemented the 21-point Health Building Guideline alongside Yoga, delivered through a seven-step protocol employing the traffic light approach to promote and sustain behavioural change in chronic disease management. After seven months of consistent adherence to this intervention, the patient achieved remission.
- 8 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessRemission of Irritable Bowel Syndrome Achieved Through Combined Diet, Lifestyle Modification, and Yoga: A Case Report
This report describes a 33-year-old male who was initially suspected of having Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) based on radiological findings, but was ultimately diagnosed with Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) using the Rome IV criteria, supported by normal colonoscopy findings and inflammatory biomarkers. When symptomatic pharmacotherapy for pain, constipation, and heartburn failed to provide lasting relief, he was referred for lifestyle therapy. Dietary modification, lifestyle counselling, and physical activity constitute the mainstay of current IBS management guidelines; however, beyond these broad recommendations, patients receive little practical guidance on day-to-day decision-making and the essential elements of healthy living. To address these limitations, we implemented the 21-point Health Building Guideline alongside Yoga, delivered through a seven-step protocol employing the traffic light approach to promote and sustain behavioural change in chronic disease management. After seven months of consistent adherence to this intervention, the patient achieved remission.
- Open Access
- 3 March 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Remission of Irritable Bowel Syndrome Achieved Through Combined Diet, Lifestyle Modification, and Yoga: A Case Report
This report describes a 33-year-old male initially suspected of Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) due to radiological findings, but finally diagnosed with Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) based on the Rome IV criteria, normal colonoscopy findings and inflammatory biomarkers. When symptomatic pharmacotherapy for pain, constipation and heartburn alone did not bring lasting relief, he was referred for lifestyle therapy. Dietary, lifestyle advice, and physical activity are mainstay in the current guidelines on the management of IBS. However, beyond these generalities, patients receive little guidance on day-to-day decision making and essential elements of healthy living. We addressed the limitations in current guidelines on IBS by following the 21-point Health Building Guideline, along with Yoga and delivered through a seven-point protocol that uses the traffic light approach to promote and sustain behavioural changes in chronic diseases. After seven months of consistent adherence to intervention; following the traffic light approach, the patient achieved remission.
- 3 March 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessRemission of Irritable Bowel Syndrome Achieved Through Combined Diet, Lifestyle Modification, and Yoga: A Case Report
This report describes a 33-year-old male initially suspected of Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) due to radiological findings, but finally diagnosed with Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) based on the Rome IV criteria, normal colonoscopy findings and inflammatory biomarkers. When symptomatic pharmacotherapy for pain, constipation and heartburn alone did not bring lasting relief, he was referred for lifestyle therapy. Dietary, lifestyle advice, and physical activity are mainstay in the current guidelines on the management of IBS. However, beyond these generalities, patients receive little guidance on day-to-day decision making and essential elements of healthy living. We addressed the limitations in current guidelines on IBS by following the 21-point Health Building Guideline, along with Yoga and delivered through a seven-point protocol that uses the traffic light approach to promote and sustain behavioural changes in chronic diseases. After seven months of consistent adherence to intervention; following the traffic light approach, the patient achieved remission.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care
- Vol. 15 (1) , 60-66
A traffic light approach to lifestyle change: Health building guideline for NCD outpatients in India
A BSTRACT: Aim: To develop and describe a simple, culturally appropriate, evidence-based lifestyle intervention tool and administration protocol for stable NCD outpatients. Methods: A multidisciplinary team synthesized global (WHO) and national (ICMR-NIN) guidelines, behaviour-change principles (COM-B, Health Belief Model, self-efficacy), and patient/provider feedback to create a one-page bilingual handout containing 21 evidence-based recommendations classified using a traffic-light system (red: avoid; green: consume safely; yellow: lifestyle actions). A structured 7-step protocol was designed for administration by nurses/dietitians, physicians, and yoga instructors, incorporating motivational interviewing, lifestyle scoring (0–21), goal setting, practical demonstration, and follow-up. Results: The “Health Building Lifestyle Guideline” and protocol were successfully piloted in an integrative health clinic serving industrial workers. Patients and providers reported high acceptability, improved comprehension, and enthusiasm for the visual traffic-light format, numeric lifestyle score, and team-based reinforcement. Conclusion: This novel, low-cost, replicable traffic-light lifestyle guideline with a structured 7-step delivery protocol effectively bridges the knowledge–practice gap and empowers NCD outpatients to adopt and sustain healthier behaviours. Wider implementation and formal outcome evaluation are recommended.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care
- Vol. 15 (1) , 60-66
Open AccessA traffic light approach to lifestyle change: Health building guideline for NCD outpatients in India
A BSTRACT: Aim: To develop and describe a simple, culturally appropriate, evidence-based lifestyle intervention tool and administration protocol for stable NCD outpatients. Methods: A multidisciplinary team synthesized global (WHO) and national (ICMR-NIN) guidelines, behaviour-change principles (COM-B, Health Belief Model, self-efficacy), and patient/provider feedback to create a one-page bilingual handout containing 21 evidence-based recommendations classified using a traffic-light system (red: avoid; green: consume safely; yellow: lifestyle actions). A structured 7-step protocol was designed for administration by nurses/dietitians, physicians, and yoga instructors, incorporating motivational interviewing, lifestyle scoring (0–21), goal setting, practical demonstration, and follow-up. Results: The “Health Building Lifestyle Guideline” and protocol were successfully piloted in an integrative health clinic serving industrial workers. Patients and providers reported high acceptability, improved comprehension, and enthusiasm for the visual traffic-light format, numeric lifestyle score, and team-based reinforcement. Conclusion: This novel, low-cost, replicable traffic-light lifestyle guideline with a structured 7-step delivery protocol effectively bridges the knowledge–practice gap and empowers NCD outpatients to adopt and sustain healthier behaviours. Wider implementation and formal outcome evaluation are recommended.
- Open Access
- 22 May 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine
- Vol. 16 (3) , 101153
Export of evidence-based wellness services: An opportunity to actualize India's demographic dividend
- 22 May 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine
- Vol. 16 (3) , 101153
Open AccessExport of evidence-based wellness services: An opportunity to actualize India's demographic dividend
- Open Access
- 11 March 2025
- Published by Qeios Ltd in Qeios Preprints
Scaling up Food Processing in India by Tapping Houesholds’ Potential
Despite being one of the world’s largest producers of fresh food and a dedicated ministry, the processing level is low in India. While 70% of employment remains in informal, unregistered enterprises, government schemes encourage only formal enterprises. Informal enterprises remain because of the stringent registration procedures. We cite the example of the US Cottage License to suggest the need for a liberal household food processing regime in India. We call for the industry to come forward to modernize the household sector so that it receives the benefits of finance, technology, and the market. We outline the benefits of this move for the consumer (fresh and palatable content, wholesome character preserving micro nutrients, tolerable levels of fat, sugars, and salt, and the possibility of useful microorganisms that can act as probiotics), for women (self-employment at home where they can continue to attend to children), and for the environment (lower carbon footprint).
- 11 March 2025
- Published by Qeios Ltd in Qeios Preprints
Open AccessScaling up Food Processing in India by Tapping Houesholds’ Potential
Despite being one of the world’s largest producers of fresh food and a dedicated ministry, the processing level is low in India. While 70% of employment remains in informal, unregistered enterprises, government schemes encourage only formal enterprises. Informal enterprises remain because of the stringent registration procedures. We cite the example of the US Cottage License to suggest the need for a liberal household food processing regime in India. We call for the industry to come forward to modernize the household sector so that it receives the benefits of finance, technology, and the market. We outline the benefits of this move for the consumer (fresh and palatable content, wholesome character preserving micro nutrients, tolerable levels of fat, sugars, and salt, and the possibility of useful microorganisms that can act as probiotics), for women (self-employment at home where they can continue to attend to children), and for the environment (lower carbon footprint).
- Open Access
- 1 February 2024
- Published by Medknow in Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care
- Vol. 13 (2) , 401-408
Catastrophic impact of 1947 partition of India on people’s health
Introduction: The partition of India on the dissolution of British Raj into two dominions is known to have been violent, polarizing and caused large-scale loss of life (about two million) and an unprecedented migration of 14 million people between the two dominions, India and Pakistan. It is not known how well the then scientific community covered this man-made disaster, and the response of the international community with aid. Methodology: A systematic review was conducted using different electronic databases of PubMed, Econlit, United Nations resolutions, Government of India websites, and Google Scholar for the period January 1947 to December 1951 on the impact of the partition of the Indian sub-continent, and to identify the international response toward this humanitarian crisis. Result: We could locate only twenty-four publications. Partition not only caused monumental humanitarian suffering, but also contributed to food deficits, adverse impact on trade and industries, national income and harmed public health. In contrast, no significant attention was expressed by the international scientific community or the United Nations, or aid provided during this catastrophic event. Conclusion: The review demonstrates the apathy by the contemporary international scientific research community on the social as well as economic damage caused by the partition of India. We suggest that the international scientific and research community should play the role of vigilante and fact finder to unearth the facets of mass human tragedy and its long-term consequences so that global consciousness is awakened, and help and aid flows when it is most needed.
- 1 February 2024
- Published by Medknow in Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care
- Vol. 13 (2) , 401-408
Open AccessCatastrophic impact of 1947 partition of India on people’s health
Introduction: The partition of India on the dissolution of British Raj into two dominions is known to have been violent, polarizing and caused large-scale loss of life (about two million) and an unprecedented migration of 14 million people between the two dominions, India and Pakistan. It is not known how well the then scientific community covered this man-made disaster, and the response of the international community with aid. Methodology: A systematic review was conducted using different electronic databases of PubMed, Econlit, United Nations resolutions, Government of India websites, and Google Scholar for the period January 1947 to December 1951 on the impact of the partition of the Indian sub-continent, and to identify the international response toward this humanitarian crisis. Result: We could locate only twenty-four publications. Partition not only caused monumental humanitarian suffering, but also contributed to food deficits, adverse impact on trade and industries, national income and harmed public health. In contrast, no significant attention was expressed by the international scientific community or the United Nations, or aid provided during this catastrophic event. Conclusion: The review demonstrates the apathy by the contemporary international scientific research community on the social as well as economic damage caused by the partition of India. We suggest that the international scientific and research community should play the role of vigilante and fact finder to unearth the facets of mass human tragedy and its long-term consequences so that global consciousness is awakened, and help and aid flows when it is most needed.
- Open Access
- 31 October 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Health Outcomes in India, Israel & Palestine
The recent armed conflict between Israel and Palestine has drawn focus on the human impact of war, especially on the children and women. It would be of interest to recap the level of health attainments of the countries in conflict with those of India. These graphs compare the health outcomes in terms of life expectancy, child and maternal mortality, health spending and cause of death in these countries. While Israel is a High Income country, Palestine has features of a Least Developed Countries, while India is a Lower Middle Income economy. The performance of Palestine is impressive, despite low income and chronic conflict.
- 31 October 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessHealth Outcomes in India, Israel & Palestine
The recent armed conflict between Israel and Palestine has drawn focus on the human impact of war, especially on the children and women. It would be of interest to recap the level of health attainments of the countries in conflict with those of India. These graphs compare the health outcomes in terms of life expectancy, child and maternal mortality, health spending and cause of death in these countries. While Israel is a High Income country, Palestine has features of a Least Developed Countries, while India is a Lower Middle Income economy. The performance of Palestine is impressive, despite low income and chronic conflict.
- Open Access
- 29 March 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
The Impact of Household’s Better Access to Water on Children’s Health and Survival in Rural Rajasthan, India
Malnutrition and lack of access to water and sanitation are responsible for one third of disability Adjusted Life Years lost in developing countries, and 62% of under-five mortality worldwide. Both factors are preventable, but persist as risks largely among the poor, 75% of whom live in rural area and depend on agriculture for livelihood. In the context of water and sanitation, Shuval suggests that a segmental approach for addressing the numerous handicaps that the poor face are unlikely to be successful, while a multi-dimensional intervention is likely to work synergistically. Income, and food security of the rural people are linked to their agricultural practices, which in turn is largely dependent on availability of irrigation. Water collection time is a good marker of thee dimensions of access to drinking water - quantity, quality and ease of availability - all of which impact health. Water, thus, is a common, distal determinant of health and income of people in rural areas of low-income countries. We studied the independent and combined effects of better access to water in rural, under-developed areas of Rajasthan, India. We also evaluated a community driven rural development project, piloted by TBS, a Non Governmental Organization, that constructed ponds to harvest rainwater and recharge groundwater, and thereby improved access to water for drinking and irrigation. Our outcomes were under-five mortality and anthropometry, which are the best indicators of population health, and are appropriate for evaluation of both agricultural and water projects.We used a combined retrospective cohort and cross-sectional design, benefiting from the high reliabilities of maternal birth histories, to evaluate the TBS project. Through a survey in 2004, we collected data on 1838 households and 1925 ever married women aged 15-49 years, weighed and measured 1715 children aged 0-59 months and their mothers.Our findings reveal the protective effects of: (i) Closer access to drinking water (i.e. 10 minutes or less of collection time) on risk of stunting among children (OR: 0.70, p<.1), (ii) Multiple cropping (a correlate of irrigation) on risk of stunting (OR: 0.53, p<.05), wasting (OR: 0.67,p<.1), and (iii) Irrigable land with the household on under-five mortality (Incidence Rate Ratio 0.78, p<.05 for one standard deviation increase). Closer access to water and multiple cropping were associated with multiplicative benefits in lowering the risk of stunting, though neither of them was protective in households with only a minimal access to the other. We identified better dietary intake by children and mothers, lower risk of diarrhea among children and low Body Mass Index among women, and higher incomes as pathways. We found weak evidence that the TBS project helped reverse the deteriorating trend in child survival, and reduced the prevalence of stunting relative to the control area. Our findings vindicate the role of water as an underlying determinant of health and income. We suggest that governments and developmental agencies should: • In rural areas, plan for improving access to water for both drinking and irrigation in a sustainable manner with community involvement; • Promote integrated delivery of inputs, drinking water and irrigation being mere examples, not only because of the likely synergisms, but also because a segmental approach is unlikely to benefit those who might need them the most. Even though water interventions are largely engineering based, public health professionals should play a proactive role in promoting access, in conjunction with other public health inputs.
- 29 March 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessThe Impact of Household’s Better Access to Water on Children’s Health and Survival in Rural Rajasthan, India
Malnutrition and lack of access to water and sanitation are responsible for one third of disability Adjusted Life Years lost in developing countries, and 62% of under-five mortality worldwide. Both factors are preventable, but persist as risks largely among the poor, 75% of whom live in rural area and depend on agriculture for livelihood. In the context of water and sanitation, Shuval suggests that a segmental approach for addressing the numerous handicaps that the poor face are unlikely to be successful, while a multi-dimensional intervention is likely to work synergistically. Income, and food security of the rural people are linked to their agricultural practices, which in turn is largely dependent on availability of irrigation. Water collection time is a good marker of thee dimensions of access to drinking water - quantity, quality and ease of availability - all of which impact health. Water, thus, is a common, distal determinant of health and income of people in rural areas of low-income countries. We studied the independent and combined effects of better access to water in rural, under-developed areas of Rajasthan, India. We also evaluated a community driven rural development project, piloted by TBS, a Non Governmental Organization, that constructed ponds to harvest rainwater and recharge groundwater, and thereby improved access to water for drinking and irrigation. Our outcomes were under-five mortality and anthropometry, which are the best indicators of population health, and are appropriate for evaluation of both agricultural and water projects.We used a combined retrospective cohort and cross-sectional design, benefiting from the high reliabilities of maternal birth histories, to evaluate the TBS project. Through a survey in 2004, we collected data on 1838 households and 1925 ever married women aged 15-49 years, weighed and measured 1715 children aged 0-59 months and their mothers.Our findings reveal the protective effects of: (i) Closer access to drinking water (i.e. 10 minutes or less of collection time) on risk of stunting among children (OR: 0.70, p<.1), (ii) Multiple cropping (a correlate of irrigation) on risk of stunting (OR: 0.53, p<.05), wasting (OR: 0.67,p<.1), and (iii) Irrigable land with the household on under-five mortality (Incidence Rate Ratio 0.78, p<.05 for one standard deviation increase). Closer access to water and multiple cropping were associated with multiplicative benefits in lowering the risk of stunting, though neither of them was protective in households with only a minimal access to the other. We identified better dietary intake by children and mothers, lower risk of diarrhea among children and low Body Mass Index among women, and higher incomes as pathways. We found weak evidence that the TBS project helped reverse the deteriorating trend in child survival, and reduced the prevalence of stunting relative to the control area. Our findings vindicate the role of water as an underlying determinant of health and income. We suggest that governments and developmental agencies should: • In rural areas, plan for improving access to water for both drinking and irrigation in a sustainable manner with community involvement; • Promote integrated delivery of inputs, drinking water and irrigation being mere examples, not only because of the likely synergisms, but also because a segmental approach is unlikely to benefit those who might need them the most. Even though water interventions are largely engineering based, public health professionals should play a proactive role in promoting access, in conjunction with other public health inputs.
- Open Access
- 9 February 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
PARLIAMENTARY DISCOURSE ON NUTRITION: What motivates law makers to ask questions
The review of two decades of parliamentary questions on nutrition and associated topics revealed information on the topics of interest, themes covered, nature of discourse and what influenced the composition of questions. We found that a majority of the questions raised focused upon the national level implementation of key programmes such as the Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS), Mid-day Meal Scheme (MDMS), Public Distribution System (PDS), Supplementary Nutrition Programme (SNP), Rajiv Gandhi Scheme for Empowerment of Adolescent Girls (SABLA) and Poshan Abhiyaan. In terms of house-wise distribution of questions, Lok Sabha had a higher number of questions as compared to the Rajya Sabha. The peak years for number of questions raised in the Parliament were 2009, 2011 and 2020. Poshan Abhiyaan, launched in 2018, was identified as the likely stimulus for many questions. Other important events in the nutrition domain were not found to be linked to the number or type of questions raised. In terms of probable triggers, only 10.7% of the total questions had references to specific articles or publications. Other key findings include:` ` Out of a total of 52,698 questions, 2,005 questions (4%) were raised on nutrition and associated themes. The highest number of questions (233) were raised in 2021 and the lowest number in 2004 (38). The years 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2021 saw higher number of questions being raised` ` Considering the underlying themes of major nutrition programmes, nearly 891 (44%) questions were addressed to the Ministry of Women and Child Development (MoWCD), 532 (27%) questions were directed at the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW), followed by 230 (11%) questions at the Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution` ` Four broad categories of questions have emerged: Questions on the prevalence of malnutrition in the country; questions on nutrition programmes and interventions; questions on implementation of policies and plans of action; questions on institutional bodies including composition, roles and responsibilities and reports submitted by these institutions` ` The number and composition of questions were driven by critical events and probable triggers related to nutrition that had occurred in that particular year but not limited to a particular session (there are 3 sessions per year)` ` Majority of questions raised (74%) focused on the implementation of policies and programmes at the national level, whereas only 10% of the questions were concerned with the implementation of policies and programmes in specific States ` ` Five types of sources were cited in the Parliamentary Questions - newspaper articles, Global Hunger Index, Reports, reports published by the UNICEF, Supreme Court Orders and reports published by International and domestic organizations` ` Amongst all the sources, reports published by UNICEF have been referred to the highest number of times and constituted 37.5% of the total number of questions that had mentioned a reference (81/221)` ` The discourse on nutrition as evident from analysis appears to be repetitive and limited in scope. This is especially relevant in cases where sources or references were not stated clearly. Many questions leaned towards being outside the realm of discussion, thereby not suggesting any clear change in the policy, legal and institutional frameworks associated with nutrition.
- 9 February 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessPARLIAMENTARY DISCOURSE ON NUTRITION: What motivates law makers to ask questions
The review of two decades of parliamentary questions on nutrition and associated topics revealed information on the topics of interest, themes covered, nature of discourse and what influenced the composition of questions. We found that a majority of the questions raised focused upon the national level implementation of key programmes such as the Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS), Mid-day Meal Scheme (MDMS), Public Distribution System (PDS), Supplementary Nutrition Programme (SNP), Rajiv Gandhi Scheme for Empowerment of Adolescent Girls (SABLA) and Poshan Abhiyaan. In terms of house-wise distribution of questions, Lok Sabha had a higher number of questions as compared to the Rajya Sabha. The peak years for number of questions raised in the Parliament were 2009, 2011 and 2020. Poshan Abhiyaan, launched in 2018, was identified as the likely stimulus for many questions. Other important events in the nutrition domain were not found to be linked to the number or type of questions raised. In terms of probable triggers, only 10.7% of the total questions had references to specific articles or publications. Other key findings include:` ` Out of a total of 52,698 questions, 2,005 questions (4%) were raised on nutrition and associated themes. The highest number of questions (233) were raised in 2021 and the lowest number in 2004 (38). The years 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2021 saw higher number of questions being raised` ` Considering the underlying themes of major nutrition programmes, nearly 891 (44%) questions were addressed to the Ministry of Women and Child Development (MoWCD), 532 (27%) questions were directed at the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW), followed by 230 (11%) questions at the Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution` ` Four broad categories of questions have emerged: Questions on the prevalence of malnutrition in the country; questions on nutrition programmes and interventions; questions on implementation of policies and plans of action; questions on institutional bodies including composition, roles and responsibilities and reports submitted by these institutions` ` The number and composition of questions were driven by critical events and probable triggers related to nutrition that had occurred in that particular year but not limited to a particular session (there are 3 sessions per year)` ` Majority of questions raised (74%) focused on the implementation of policies and programmes at the national level, whereas only 10% of the questions were concerned with the implementation of policies and programmes in specific States ` ` Five types of sources were cited in the Parliamentary Questions - newspaper articles, Global Hunger Index, Reports, reports published by the UNICEF, Supreme Court Orders and reports published by International and domestic organizations` ` Amongst all the sources, reports published by UNICEF have been referred to the highest number of times and constituted 37.5% of the total number of questions that had mentioned a reference (81/221)` ` The discourse on nutrition as evident from analysis appears to be repetitive and limited in scope. This is especially relevant in cases where sources or references were not stated clearly. Many questions leaned towards being outside the realm of discussion, thereby not suggesting any clear change in the policy, legal and institutional frameworks associated with nutrition.