Iryna Tkachenko
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Iryna Tkachenko has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Andrii Borovyk
Scientific Institute of Public Law, Ukraine
3 shared publications - Olha Volodymyrivna Kryshevych
National Academy of Internal Affairs
3 shared publications - Bohdana-Yuliya Ivchenko
Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs, Ukraine
1 shared publication - Eduard Solovyov
Primakov National Research Institute of World Economy and International Relations, Russian Academy of Sciences (IMEMO), 23, Profsoyuznaya Str., Moscow, 117997, Russian Federation
1 shared publication - Karyna Fedosieieva1 shared publication
- Mykola Krutevych
National Academy of Internal Affairs, Ukraine
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 31 July 2026
- Published by Private Institution Scientific Institute of Public Law in International Bulletin on Public Administration and Legal Affairs
- Vol. 8 (2) , 243-249
CLASSIFICATION OF SPECIAL VICTIMS IN UKRAINIAN CRIMINAL LAW
У статті досліджується проблема класифікації спеціальних потерпілих у кримінальному праві України як одного з важливих засобів диференціації кримінальної відповідальності. Обґрунтовується, що в низці складів кримінальних правопорушень кримінально-правове значення має не будь-який потерпілий, а лише особа, яка наділена додатковими юридично значущими ознаками, зокрема віком, фізичним або психічним станом, професійним чи службовим статусом, процесуальною роллю, сімейними зв’язками, особливим становищем у збройному конфлікті або інституційною природою. Проаналізовано підходи науковців до систематизації спеціальних потерпілих за результатами чого встановлено, що особлива увага приділяється класифікації залежно від способу нормативного закріплення відповідних ознак досліджуваних учасників суспільних відносин у Загальній та Особливій частинах КК України. Визнано обґрунтованою позицію щодо поділу спеціальних потерпілих на тих, які виступають обставинами, що обтяжують покарання, та тих, які є конструктивними або кваліфікуючими (особливо кваліфікуючими) ознаками складу кримінального правопорушення. Встановлено, що традиційний підхід, заснований лише на переліку окремих категорій потерпілих, не забезпечує повного розкриття їх кримінально-правової природи. Доведено, що класифікаційний підхід дозволяє виявити внутрішню логіку законодавчого регулювання, сприяє правильній кваліфікації кримінальних правопорушень, розмежуванню суміжних складів та усуненню помилок у правозастосовній практиці. Запропоновано класифікацію спеціальних потерпілих саме за джерелом їх спеціального кримінально-правового статусу: потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений віком, фізіологічним або психофізичним станом; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений залежністю або контролем з боку іншої особи; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений сімейним, родинним або іншим особистим зв’язком з певною особою; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений участю у здійсненні правоохоронної діяльності, правосуддя, кримінальному провадженні або виконанні судових рішень; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений виконанням іншої публічно значущої функції; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений конкретною ситуацією посягання або спеціальною роллю в події; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений міжнародно-правовим захистом у контексті збройного конфлікту та міжнародних злочинів; потерпілі-організації та публічні утворення, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений їх інституційною природою. Це універсальна класифікація, яка пояснює логіку криміналізації, охоплює всі наявні різновиди потерпілих. Наголошено, що систематизація спеціальних потерпілих має важливе значення для вдосконалення положень Кримінального кодексу України з метою підвищення ефективності кримінально-правової охорони окремих соціально значущих категорій потерпілих
- 31 July 2026
- Published by Private Institution Scientific Institute of Public Law in International Bulletin on Public Administration and Legal Affairs
- Vol. 8 (2) , 243-249
Open AccessCLASSIFICATION OF SPECIAL VICTIMS IN UKRAINIAN CRIMINAL LAW
У статті досліджується проблема класифікації спеціальних потерпілих у кримінальному праві України як одного з важливих засобів диференціації кримінальної відповідальності. Обґрунтовується, що в низці складів кримінальних правопорушень кримінально-правове значення має не будь-який потерпілий, а лише особа, яка наділена додатковими юридично значущими ознаками, зокрема віком, фізичним або психічним станом, професійним чи службовим статусом, процесуальною роллю, сімейними зв’язками, особливим становищем у збройному конфлікті або інституційною природою. Проаналізовано підходи науковців до систематизації спеціальних потерпілих за результатами чого встановлено, що особлива увага приділяється класифікації залежно від способу нормативного закріплення відповідних ознак досліджуваних учасників суспільних відносин у Загальній та Особливій частинах КК України. Визнано обґрунтованою позицію щодо поділу спеціальних потерпілих на тих, які виступають обставинами, що обтяжують покарання, та тих, які є конструктивними або кваліфікуючими (особливо кваліфікуючими) ознаками складу кримінального правопорушення. Встановлено, що традиційний підхід, заснований лише на переліку окремих категорій потерпілих, не забезпечує повного розкриття їх кримінально-правової природи. Доведено, що класифікаційний підхід дозволяє виявити внутрішню логіку законодавчого регулювання, сприяє правильній кваліфікації кримінальних правопорушень, розмежуванню суміжних складів та усуненню помилок у правозастосовній практиці. Запропоновано класифікацію спеціальних потерпілих саме за джерелом їх спеціального кримінально-правового статусу: потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений віком, фізіологічним або психофізичним станом; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений залежністю або контролем з боку іншої особи; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений сімейним, родинним або іншим особистим зв’язком з певною особою; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений участю у здійсненні правоохоронної діяльності, правосуддя, кримінальному провадженні або виконанні судових рішень; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений виконанням іншої публічно значущої функції; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений конкретною ситуацією посягання або спеціальною роллю в події; потерпілі, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений міжнародно-правовим захистом у контексті збройного конфлікту та міжнародних злочинів; потерпілі-організації та публічні утворення, спеціальний статус яких зумовлений їх інституційною природою. Це універсальна класифікація, яка пояснює логіку криміналізації, охоплює всі наявні різновиди потерпілих. Наголошено, що систематизація спеціальних потерпілих має важливе значення для вдосконалення положень Кримінального кодексу України з метою підвищення ефективності кримінально-правової охорони окремих соціально значущих категорій потерпілих
- 14 May 2026
- Published by Dniprovskii University of the Humanities in Law and Society
- Vol. 2 (2) , 229-236
OBJECT OF THE CRIMINAL OFFENSE AS A CRITERION FOR THE CLASSIFICATION OF VICTIMS IN CRIMINAL LAW
- 14 May 2026
- Published by Dniprovskii University of the Humanities in Law and Society
- Vol. 2 (2) , 229-236
OBJECT OF THE CRIMINAL OFFENSE AS A CRITERION FOR THE CLASSIFICATION OF VICTIMS IN CRIMINAL LAW
- Open Access
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (2) , 434-439
Issues in the Classification of the Legalization (Laundering) of Proceeds of Crime and Distinctions from Related Criminal Offenses
The article outlines that the legalization (laundering) of property obtained by criminal means is one of the key tools for preserving and utilizing proceeds from organized crime. It has been established that offenses involving the legalization (laundering) of property obtained by criminal means are international in nature, having recently taken on migratory characteristics, facilitated by the unimpeded movement (transfer) of assets of criminal origin to any jurisdiction. One area of criminal activity involves the laundering of property and criminal proceeds, their investment in the legal economy, and the transfer of capital abroad followed by its re-importation through offshore zones (e.g., Cyprus). At the national level, the primary legislative act governing financial monitoring is the Law of Ukraine “On Preventing and Combating the Legalization (Laundering) of Proceeds from Crime, the Financing of Terrorism, and the Financing of the Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction,” which establishes the legal framework for preventing and combating these phenomena, including the obligations of primary financial monitoring entities (banks, insurance companies, real estate agents) to report suspicious financial transactions. Money laundering (Article 209 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine) is a complex crime aimed at giving the appearance of legitimacy to assets obtained through criminal means. It encompasses a wide range of actions: acquisition, possession, use, disposal, transfer, alteration (conversion) of property, or actions to conceal its origin, rights, or location. When proving the predicate offense, it must be established that the property was obtained through criminal means (even if the predicate offense has not been investigated separately). Issues of classification include proving the predicate offense, the intent to conceal, and distinguishing between complicity (Art. 396 of the Criminal Code) and economic criminal offenses under Articles 212 and 222 of the Criminal Code, in accordance with national practice and FATF/ EU standards. Money laundering (Article 209 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine) is a complex offense, where key classification issues include proving the criminal origin of assets (“predicate offense”), distinguishing it from acts of corruption and fictitious business operations, as well as the difficulty of distinguishing between self-laundering and complicity. UN/EU Conventions The Council of Europe Convention on Laundering, Search, Seizure and Confiscation of the Proceeds from Crime (2005), FATF (Financial Action Task Force) international standards require an expansion of the concept of predicate offenses to include tax offenses, which creates difficulties in the application of national legislation.
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (2) , 434-439
Open AccessIssues in the Classification of the Legalization (Laundering) of Proceeds of Crime and Distinctions from Related Criminal Offenses
The article outlines that the legalization (laundering) of property obtained by criminal means is one of the key tools for preserving and utilizing proceeds from organized crime. It has been established that offenses involving the legalization (laundering) of property obtained by criminal means are international in nature, having recently taken on migratory characteristics, facilitated by the unimpeded movement (transfer) of assets of criminal origin to any jurisdiction. One area of criminal activity involves the laundering of property and criminal proceeds, their investment in the legal economy, and the transfer of capital abroad followed by its re-importation through offshore zones (e.g., Cyprus). At the national level, the primary legislative act governing financial monitoring is the Law of Ukraine “On Preventing and Combating the Legalization (Laundering) of Proceeds from Crime, the Financing of Terrorism, and the Financing of the Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction,” which establishes the legal framework for preventing and combating these phenomena, including the obligations of primary financial monitoring entities (banks, insurance companies, real estate agents) to report suspicious financial transactions. Money laundering (Article 209 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine) is a complex crime aimed at giving the appearance of legitimacy to assets obtained through criminal means. It encompasses a wide range of actions: acquisition, possession, use, disposal, transfer, alteration (conversion) of property, or actions to conceal its origin, rights, or location. When proving the predicate offense, it must be established that the property was obtained through criminal means (even if the predicate offense has not been investigated separately). Issues of classification include proving the predicate offense, the intent to conceal, and distinguishing between complicity (Art. 396 of the Criminal Code) and economic criminal offenses under Articles 212 and 222 of the Criminal Code, in accordance with national practice and FATF/ EU standards. Money laundering (Article 209 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine) is a complex offense, where key classification issues include proving the criminal origin of assets (“predicate offense”), distinguishing it from acts of corruption and fictitious business operations, as well as the difficulty of distinguishing between self-laundering and complicity. UN/EU Conventions The Council of Europe Convention on Laundering, Search, Seizure and Confiscation of the Proceeds from Crime (2005), FATF (Financial Action Task Force) international standards require an expansion of the concept of predicate offenses to include tax offenses, which creates difficulties in the application of national legislation.
- Open Access
- 26 February 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 2 (1) , 460-475
Classification of criminal-law characteristics of the victim: theoretical foundations and law-enforcement guidelines
The article is devoted to systematizing the criminal-law characteristics of the victim and formulating practical guidelines for their application in the qualification of criminal offenses, sentencing, and the use of incentive-based legal mechanisms. The author substantiates a conceptual understanding of the content and functions of the criminal-law features of the victim. Based on the analysis of doctrinal approaches, legislative constructions, and the practical needs of criminal justice, a multi-level classification of victim-related characteristics is proposed. It is structured according to: their criminal-law significance; their role within the structure of the corpus delicti; the distinction between general and special categories of victims; the type of offense composition; the form of guilt; the degree of legislative specification; the level of normative definition; the quantitative characteristics of victims; and the source of regulatory determination. It is demonstrated that mandatory characteristics perform a constructive function within the structure of a criminal offense, while optional characteristics ensure the individualization of punishment and influence the application of incentive norms. The study shows that in qualified and especially qualified offense compositions, special characteristics of the victim increase the degree of social harm of the act, while in privileged compositions certain attributes or behavior of the victim, conversely, tend to mitigate the criminal-law assessment of the act. Differences in the functioning of these characteristics depending on the form of guilt are highlighted: in intentional offenses they personalize the direction and focus of the unlawful act (including the offender’s awareness of specific features of the victim), whereas in negligent offenses they indirectly influence the assessment of consequences and the degree of liability. The scientific novelty of the study lies in the development of a comprehensive classification of victim-related characteristics that integrates substantive (functional) criteria with criteria of legislative technique and the source of legal regulation, as well as in establishing practical guidelines on the limits of literal, restrictive, and expansive interpretation. The practical significance of the work lies in enhancing the predictability of law enforcement, unifying approaches to legal qualification, providing proper differentiation of liability, and reducing the risk of errors arising from the competition of norms.
- 26 February 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 2 (1) , 460-475
Open AccessClassification of criminal-law characteristics of the victim: theoretical foundations and law-enforcement guidelines
The article is devoted to systematizing the criminal-law characteristics of the victim and formulating practical guidelines for their application in the qualification of criminal offenses, sentencing, and the use of incentive-based legal mechanisms. The author substantiates a conceptual understanding of the content and functions of the criminal-law features of the victim. Based on the analysis of doctrinal approaches, legislative constructions, and the practical needs of criminal justice, a multi-level classification of victim-related characteristics is proposed. It is structured according to: their criminal-law significance; their role within the structure of the corpus delicti; the distinction between general and special categories of victims; the type of offense composition; the form of guilt; the degree of legislative specification; the level of normative definition; the quantitative characteristics of victims; and the source of regulatory determination. It is demonstrated that mandatory characteristics perform a constructive function within the structure of a criminal offense, while optional characteristics ensure the individualization of punishment and influence the application of incentive norms. The study shows that in qualified and especially qualified offense compositions, special characteristics of the victim increase the degree of social harm of the act, while in privileged compositions certain attributes or behavior of the victim, conversely, tend to mitigate the criminal-law assessment of the act. Differences in the functioning of these characteristics depending on the form of guilt are highlighted: in intentional offenses they personalize the direction and focus of the unlawful act (including the offender’s awareness of specific features of the victim), whereas in negligent offenses they indirectly influence the assessment of consequences and the degree of liability. The scientific novelty of the study lies in the development of a comprehensive classification of victim-related characteristics that integrates substantive (functional) criteria with criteria of legislative technique and the source of legal regulation, as well as in establishing practical guidelines on the limits of literal, restrictive, and expansive interpretation. The practical significance of the work lies in enhancing the predictability of law enforcement, unifying approaches to legal qualification, providing proper differentiation of liability, and reducing the risk of errors arising from the competition of norms.
- 31 December 2025
- Published by Institute of Legislative Forecasts and Legal Expertise in SOCIOLOGY OF LAW
- No. 2,p. 237-243
THE CRIMINAL LAW CHARACTERISTICS OF THE VICTIM: CERTAIN ISSUES OF LAW ENFORCEMENT
- 31 December 2025
- Published by Institute of Legislative Forecasts and Legal Expertise in SOCIOLOGY OF LAW
- No. 2,p. 237-243
THE CRIMINAL LAW CHARACTERISTICS OF THE VICTIM: CERTAIN ISSUES OF LAW ENFORCEMENT
- Open Access
- 31 December 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 4 (92) , 124-129
War crimes: problematic issues of classification and differentiation from related criminal offenses
International justice focuses on investigating the most serious international crimes – genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and the crime of aggression – and ensuring that those responsible are brought to justice is a universal goal for the entire international community. To emphasize this, the International Criminal Court was established to ensure the administration of justice based on the Rome Statute, which defines the jurisdiction of the court and establishes the concept of the most serious international crimes. With regard to national legislation, in connection with Russia’s full-scale aggression against Ukraine, the prosecution of criminal proceedings for criminal offenses under Section XX “Criminal Offenses against Peace, Security of Humanity and International Legal Order” and issues of criminal law protection of peace and security from war crimes and Article 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, which is the basis for the classification of war crimes, given that the Criminal Code of Ukraine does not contain such a term, but it is recognized in international law. Since war crimes regulate the behavior of parties during armed conflicts, they limit violence by prohibiting certain methods and weapons so that the goal is not the destruction of all life, but only the military weakening of the enemy. These war crimes must be covered by international treaties that are legally binding on Ukraine, i.e., international treaties in force that have been ratified by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. The provisions of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court embody the latest developments in international law regarding the criminal prosecution of international crimes. According to the Office of the Prosecutor General of Ukraine, as of December 2025, 200,136 criminal offenses under Article 438 of the Criminal Code, i.e., war crimes under the Criminal Code of Ukraine committed during the full-scale invasion by the Russian Federation, had been entered into the Unified Register of Pre-trial Investigations. However, it should be noted that among this number of recorded criminal proceedings, 172 war criminals have been convicted since 2022, of whom only 59 were on trial. Persons who have committed a crime under Article 438 of the Criminal Code are not subject to the statute of limitations for criminal liability and the execution of a conviction (in accordance with Part 5 of Article 49 and Part 6 of Article 80 of the Criminal Code).
- 31 December 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 4 (92) , 124-129
Open AccessWar crimes: problematic issues of classification and differentiation from related criminal offenses
International justice focuses on investigating the most serious international crimes – genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and the crime of aggression – and ensuring that those responsible are brought to justice is a universal goal for the entire international community. To emphasize this, the International Criminal Court was established to ensure the administration of justice based on the Rome Statute, which defines the jurisdiction of the court and establishes the concept of the most serious international crimes. With regard to national legislation, in connection with Russia’s full-scale aggression against Ukraine, the prosecution of criminal proceedings for criminal offenses under Section XX “Criminal Offenses against Peace, Security of Humanity and International Legal Order” and issues of criminal law protection of peace and security from war crimes and Article 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, which is the basis for the classification of war crimes, given that the Criminal Code of Ukraine does not contain such a term, but it is recognized in international law. Since war crimes regulate the behavior of parties during armed conflicts, they limit violence by prohibiting certain methods and weapons so that the goal is not the destruction of all life, but only the military weakening of the enemy. These war crimes must be covered by international treaties that are legally binding on Ukraine, i.e., international treaties in force that have been ratified by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. The provisions of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court embody the latest developments in international law regarding the criminal prosecution of international crimes. According to the Office of the Prosecutor General of Ukraine, as of December 2025, 200,136 criminal offenses under Article 438 of the Criminal Code, i.e., war crimes under the Criminal Code of Ukraine committed during the full-scale invasion by the Russian Federation, had been entered into the Unified Register of Pre-trial Investigations. However, it should be noted that among this number of recorded criminal proceedings, 172 war criminals have been convicted since 2022, of whom only 59 were on trial. Persons who have committed a crime under Article 438 of the Criminal Code are not subject to the statute of limitations for criminal liability and the execution of a conviction (in accordance with Part 5 of Article 49 and Part 6 of Article 80 of the Criminal Code).
- Open Access
- 5 November 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (5) , 109-114
The victim as a social subject in the criminal law dimension
The article explores current issues related to the victim as a social subject in the criminal law dimension. Based on the conducted research, it has been established that the following cannot be considered a victim in the criminal law sense: 1)an animal or an object; 2) a corpse (in cases where a crime is committed against a deceased person); 3) a person from among the close relatives or family members of the victim (essentially a representative of the victim who has acquired the procedural status of a victim in criminal proceedings). It is proposed to differentiate between situations where a person’s death results from a crime and those where a criminal offense is committed against someone who is already deceased. In some cases, a natural person should be recognized as a victim, as they were alive at the time the offense was committed. In other cases, a deceased person is considered an object rather than a victim. Thus, it can be concluded that only a living person may be regarded as a victim. Unlike subjects of a criminal offense, any natural person who has suffered harm, regardless of age, gender, nationality, religion, physical condition, etc., is recognized as a victim. It is recommended that even individuals who provoked the commission of a crime or misdemeanor against them – whether by lawful or unlawful actions, including those who themselves committed a criminal offense – should still be recognized as victims. The article criticizes the mistaken practice of law enforcement and judicial authorities, which, in cases of mutual harm inflicted by individuals upon each other, tend to recognize only one party as the victim. To denote other social entities as victims, aside from natural and legal persons, the use of the term “public association” is proposed. A victim should not be understood as any natural or legal person who has suffered harm or faced a threat of harm and is mentioned in the disposition of an article in the Special Part of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, but only as a person who constitutes an element of the particular offense. This applies only if the victim is directly referenced in the article’s disposition or if their existence can be inferred through interpretation of the criminal law provision. Thus, the legal recognition of a person as a victim is associated not only with the fact of harm inflicted upon them, but also with whether that person constitutes a structural element of the criminal offense.
- 5 November 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (5) , 109-114
Open AccessThe victim as a social subject in the criminal law dimension
The article explores current issues related to the victim as a social subject in the criminal law dimension. Based on the conducted research, it has been established that the following cannot be considered a victim in the criminal law sense: 1)an animal or an object; 2) a corpse (in cases where a crime is committed against a deceased person); 3) a person from among the close relatives or family members of the victim (essentially a representative of the victim who has acquired the procedural status of a victim in criminal proceedings). It is proposed to differentiate between situations where a person’s death results from a crime and those where a criminal offense is committed against someone who is already deceased. In some cases, a natural person should be recognized as a victim, as they were alive at the time the offense was committed. In other cases, a deceased person is considered an object rather than a victim. Thus, it can be concluded that only a living person may be regarded as a victim. Unlike subjects of a criminal offense, any natural person who has suffered harm, regardless of age, gender, nationality, religion, physical condition, etc., is recognized as a victim. It is recommended that even individuals who provoked the commission of a crime or misdemeanor against them – whether by lawful or unlawful actions, including those who themselves committed a criminal offense – should still be recognized as victims. The article criticizes the mistaken practice of law enforcement and judicial authorities, which, in cases of mutual harm inflicted by individuals upon each other, tend to recognize only one party as the victim. To denote other social entities as victims, aside from natural and legal persons, the use of the term “public association” is proposed. A victim should not be understood as any natural or legal person who has suffered harm or faced a threat of harm and is mentioned in the disposition of an article in the Special Part of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, but only as a person who constitutes an element of the particular offense. This applies only if the victim is directly referenced in the article’s disposition or if their existence can be inferred through interpretation of the criminal law provision. Thus, the legal recognition of a person as a victim is associated not only with the fact of harm inflicted upon them, but also with whether that person constitutes a structural element of the criminal offense.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 3 (83) , 151-155
Threat in the context of identifying the victim
It is indicated that an important feature of the injured person, which allows to distinguish him from other persons, is related to the infliction of damage. The etymological and semantic analysis of the term «victim» shows that damage is an integral feature of a victim. The article examines the possibility and expediency of recognizing a person as a victim in the criminal law field in the event of a threat to cause harm to him. Provisions of the current Criminal Code of Ukraine, the project of the new Criminal Code of Ukraine, national judicial practice are taken into account. It is argued that in context of the injured person, term damage is understood in two meanings: 1) narrowly (includes only real damage); 2) in a broad sense (includes both damage and the danger/threat of causing it, as well as the threat). At the same time, attributing the threat as an independent action to a type of harm, as suggested by authors of the draft Criminal Code of Ukraine, seems debatable, because in such a case the term «threat» will denote both an action and a consequence. It is also worth paying attention to whether there is a need to use both the term «threat» and the term «danger» in the draft Criminal Code of Ukraine. It has been established that the term «threat» in the context of the definition of the victim means both actual moral or other types of harm to him, as well as the threat/danger of his task. It has been proven that victim in a certain composition of a criminal offense can be characterized not only by harm in its narrow sense, but also by threat or danger of its occurrence, that is, harm in the broad sense, as well as the threat of harm. The threat in the context of the criminal-legal understanding of victim is important, first of all, if there is no implementation. In case of the implementation of a threat, which is provided as an independent crime and is a stage of a single criminal activity, united by a single intention and aimed at causing damage to the same object, qualification under the article providing for responsibility for the threat is not required, and therefore and there is no need to establish the victim of the threat. If a threat is a way of committing an act, then the victim is determined in the context of act in general, taking into account the threat as a way of committing it.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 3 (83) , 151-155
Open AccessThreat in the context of identifying the victim
It is indicated that an important feature of the injured person, which allows to distinguish him from other persons, is related to the infliction of damage. The etymological and semantic analysis of the term «victim» shows that damage is an integral feature of a victim. The article examines the possibility and expediency of recognizing a person as a victim in the criminal law field in the event of a threat to cause harm to him. Provisions of the current Criminal Code of Ukraine, the project of the new Criminal Code of Ukraine, national judicial practice are taken into account. It is argued that in context of the injured person, term damage is understood in two meanings: 1) narrowly (includes only real damage); 2) in a broad sense (includes both damage and the danger/threat of causing it, as well as the threat). At the same time, attributing the threat as an independent action to a type of harm, as suggested by authors of the draft Criminal Code of Ukraine, seems debatable, because in such a case the term «threat» will denote both an action and a consequence. It is also worth paying attention to whether there is a need to use both the term «threat» and the term «danger» in the draft Criminal Code of Ukraine. It has been established that the term «threat» in the context of the definition of the victim means both actual moral or other types of harm to him, as well as the threat/danger of his task. It has been proven that victim in a certain composition of a criminal offense can be characterized not only by harm in its narrow sense, but also by threat or danger of its occurrence, that is, harm in the broad sense, as well as the threat of harm. The threat in the context of the criminal-legal understanding of victim is important, first of all, if there is no implementation. In case of the implementation of a threat, which is provided as an independent crime and is a stage of a single criminal activity, united by a single intention and aimed at causing damage to the same object, qualification under the article providing for responsibility for the threat is not required, and therefore and there is no need to establish the victim of the threat. If a threat is a way of committing an act, then the victim is determined in the context of act in general, taking into account the threat as a way of committing it.