PKPaulina Konca

Paulina Konca

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    "The Interpretation Act 2005: Twenty Years Later"

    by Paulina Konca

    Twenty years after the enactment of the Interpretation Act 2005, the Act's impact on statutory interpretation in Ireland warrants close scrutiny. This paper focuses on ss.5 and 6 of the Act, which were considered the most significant innovations and remain particularly interesting approaches in comparison with other interpretation acts in force in various jurisdictions. Section 5 establishes fundamental rules of interpretation, serving as the basis for all interpretative exercises, whereas s.6 is applied sparingly. Both enhance legal certainty and transparency. Drawing on over 130 judgments, this paper examines how these provisions have been applied and their contribution to consistency and predictability in Irish law. By situating the Irish experience within broader debates on interpretation acts and statutory interpretation, the study offers insights of both domestic and comparative relevance, highlighting the continuing evolution and significance of Ireland's regulatory framework.

  • Open Access

    Helpful or hollow? Rethinking the interpretive role of Interpretation Acts

    by Paulina Konca

    In the era of increasingly complex legislation, the issue of statutory interpretation is gaining prominence, raising important questions about the role and effectiveness of normative acts that seek to regulate interpretive practices. This article analyses the content of Interpretation Acts currently in force in selected common law jurisdictions—including Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Ireland, and the UK—with a focus on provisions that explicitly address interpretive issues. This article is divided into three parts. The first offers a general overview of interpretive provisions in Interpretation Acts, highlighting both their common regulatory areas and notable absences. The second examines substantive choices made within these Acts in response to key interpretive debates, with emphasis on the selected approach and use of extrinsic aids. The third section focuses on ambulatory provisions, a topic of growing significance in recent interpretive discourse. In this context, the article highlights Irish provisions, largely overlooked in discussions about interpretation in changing circumstances. The aim of the study is to assess the extent to which Interpretation Acts may influence interpretive practice. This article encourages further debate on the potential of these Acts to promote interpretive coherence and enhance the transparency of the interpretive process.

  • Open Access

    Does Static Interpretation Exist? Ways of Understanding and Applying Dynamic and Static Approaches to Statutory Interpretation in Polish and Spanish Case Law

    by Paulina Konca

    This article’s primary objectives are twofold. The first is to analyse and compare how terms associated with dynamic interpretation operate in the jurisprudence of Spain and Poland. In the process, it will be demonstrated how courts may avoid such terminology while still applying methods typically described as ‘dynamic.’ The second objective is to assess whether dynamicity is an inherent feature of legal interpretation or merely one possible approach. The study draws on over 3,200 judicial decisions handed down by Polish and Spanish courts where interpretation was adapted to changing circumstances, or where terms such as dynamic, evolutionary, or sociological interpretation appeared. The findings show that these expressions are often linked to varied legal principles and lack precision in judicial usage. Moreover, contrary to common assumptions, labels such as dynamic interpretation are frequently used in contexts that do not involve or otherwise denote significant external change. The paper argues that legal interpretation is inherently dynamic and that so-called static interpretation , understood as a fixed and unchanging meaning, does not constitute a distinct and equally accepted method. However, it does not follow that extreme static theories are not genuinely advocated or that static reasoning lacks relevance. On the contrary, static approaches may serve as important exceptions that protect key democratic values. The analysis focuses on statutory interpretation, which has received far less scholarly attention in debates on dynamic and static approaches, having long been centred on constitutional law.


  • Open Access

    Sądowa aktualizacja znaczenia tekstu prawnego w trzech pytaniach

    by Paulina Konca

    The aim of the article is to illustrate the complexity of the process of judicial updating of the meaning of a legal text in changing circumstances (e.g., developments in technology and science, social changes) and to answer the question about the role of courts and the legislator in such updating. On the basis of an analysis of literature, legislation, and judicial practice, the basic problems of updating a legal text and their selected solutions are presented. The topic has been widely discussed in the context of the Constitution, while the literature on updating statutes is still relatively rare. Meanwhile, the dynamics of external changes is intense. It has become urgent to develop a theoretical framework for this issue. Judges, when updating, must ask themselves three questions. First, has there been a change? Second, what is the impact of the change on the meaning? Third, is the judiciary allowed to update? Within each of them, a question arises as to who is entitled to make a binding conclusion: the courts or the legislature. As for the first question, determining a change is often easy, but in doubtful cases where there is no general agreement that circumstances have changed, judges would be well advised not to update on their own, but to rely on the legislature’s assessment of the disputed change. With regard to the second question, judges determine the updated meaning, being primarily guided by the purpose of the regulation. However, even when updating the same provisions, two different judges may come to different conclusions. Finally, as for question three, judges update, inter alia, when they conclude that the failure to update is an omission on the part of the legislature and consider themselves entitled to correct this error. Significantly, in some countries, the ability of the judiciary to update arises from legislation: the Irish and Spanish provisions governing the issue are discussed in the article.


  • Prawo interpretacyjne

    by Paulina Konca

    Although the interpretation of legal rules has a direct impact on the content of judicial decisions, law of interpretation has not yet been the subject of a monographic study in Polish legal theory. The author describes the status of interpretative directives in various legal cultures (e.g. Poland, Spain, Australia, USA, Great Britain, Ireland and Latin America) and analyses the problems caused by enacting interpretative directives. She puts forward proposals for the creation of the law of interpretation and analyses the nature of interpretative directives. An important advantage of the work is the reference to a wide range of literature and jurisprudence from many jurisdictions.


  • Open Access

    Servants or Masters? Linguistic Aids in Legal Interpretation

    by Paulina Konca

    This paper presents the role of some intrinsic sources in legal interpretation. Some of linguistic aids follow from provisions of the law and other from the commonly accepted ruling practice or views expressed in literature. The position of those aids was verified through the analysis of case-law, literature, and provisions of law. The first section and second section focus on the priority of plain meaning rule and intrinsic sources in legal interpretation which is strongly emphasized in legal literature, case-law and the interpretative provisions of many countries. Next, it presents how certain linguistic tools work in case law practice, what problems they can cause and what problems they can solve. The third point addresses the use of dictionaries as tools of linguistic interpretation. The fourth section explores the role of selected interpretative canons often found in legal regulations and case law practice: ordinary meaning canon, gender/number canon, ejusdem generis canon, presumption of consistent usage and prefatory-materials canon. It is concluded that the priority of a linguistic interpretation is not absolute and can never be understood as its exclusivity. Linguistic tools are not in themselves determinants of correct meaning. In order to make a correct interpretation, it is necessary not to be guided, by indications labelled as objective, sometimes artificially imposed, but by the intention of the legislator, which such tools may discover and should only be used for that purpose.


  • Open Access

    Materiały legislacyjne w świetle prawa, praktyki orzeczniczej i poglądów doktryny z perspektywy polskiej i hiszpańskiej

    by Paulina Konca

    The purpose of the paper is to present a comparative analysis of the use of legislative materials in the process of statutory interpretation in Poland and Spain, by referring to statutes, theoretical literature and case law. The paper is divided into three parts. The first part shows that in difficult cases, when the text is not clear enough as an evidence of the legislator’s intention, other evidence should be sought, including the legislative materials. The second part delivers an analysis of the term ‘legislative materials’, followed by a study of particular examples of legislative materials, including bills and their justifications. It focuses especially on the issue of the Spanish exposiciones de motivos. Moreover, there is a reference to interpretative guidance contained in the legal regulations and to the ways in which legislative materials are used in case law. The third part of the paper responds, on the basis of Polish and Spanish theoretical literature, to some of the objections against the use of legislative materials, underlining its importance for the interpreting the law.


  • Open Access

    Jawność postępowania karnego a prywatność jego uczestników w sprawach o przestępstwa na tle seksualnym. Aspekt prawnoporównawczy

    by Paulina Konca

    Artykuł dotyczy problemu kolizji prawa do prywatności z zasadą jawności zewnętrznej oraz z niektórymi innymi zasadami procesu karnego w sprawach, w których przedmiotem postępowania jest przestępstwo na tle seksualnym. Autorka, przedstawiając uregulowania polskie na tle regulacji hiszpańskich oraz odwołując się do kampanii społecznych i rozwiązań funkcjonujących w innych krajach europejskich, stara się wykazać, jak ważna jest ochrona godności i prawa do intymności ofiary w kontekście zapobiegania wtórnej wiktymizacji oraz przedstawić mechanizmy zapewniające taką ochronę. Autorka analizuje również kwestię ochrony prawa do prywatności oskarżonego. Jako że zasada jawności zewnętrznej jest ściśle związana z dostępem mediów do procesu, opracowanie poświęcone jest także problemowi sprawozdawczości radiowo-telewizyjnej w kontekście rozwoju nowych mediów, ze szczególnym uwzględnieniem spraw, których uczestnikami są osoby publiczne.