AMAndrea Marston

Andrea Marston

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Andrea Marston has a total of 2 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Ch'ixi mobilities

    by Andrea Marston

    This chapter uses a mobilities framework to make two arguments about the relationship between small-scale mining and Indigenous autonomy in the tin belt of Norte Potosí, Bolivia. First, small-scale tin mining in this region is increasingly characterized by two relatively new forms of mobility: the movement of people between ayllus (Quechua and Aymara communities) and nearby tin mines, and the regional circulation of mining-derived profits within rural areas. While mining in Bolivia has long relied on the forced migration and labor of Indigenous people, Indigenous communities have been historically excluded from the wealth derived from their extractive labors; now, money from mining is mobile along with Indigenous miners themselves. Second, these mobilities are thoroughly ch’ixi (motley) in that they involve the strategic use of capitalist economic activities to support contemporary expressions of Indigenous autonomy. As developed by Silvia Rivera Cusicanqui, the Aymara word ch’ixi implies a non-synthetic coexistence of Indigenous and non-Indigenous worlds. As used in this chapter, the concept supports a critical analysis of the degree to which new mining mobilities have the capacity to support Indigenous autonomy efforts.

  • Architectures of Extraction: Labor and Industrial Ruination in Highland Bolivia

    by Andrea Marston

    What happens when the architectures of extraction, once intimately constituted by capitalist and racial forms of exclusion, begin to rot? Focusing on a Bolivian tin mine, this paper examines the social effects of deteriorating “architectures of extraction,” a category that includes both aboveground infrastructures and belowground networks of tunnels and scaffolding. First, I argue that when Llallagua’s extractive architecture was built, it helped shore up a connection between tin mining, working-class identity, and revolutionary nationalism – which in turn became bound up with mestizaje, an ideology of racial and cultural whitening. Second, I argue that the ruination of this extractive architecture has had ambivalent implications for the racial politics of contemporary small-scale mining operations that continue to operate inside the mountain. On the one hand, the rotting structures reinforce regional racial hierarchies in a variety of ways, but on the other hand, the slow degradation of the physical structures has made the corresponding social structures more porous, if not fully permeable, to members of regional Indigenous ayllus. While access to the financial benefits of mining is far from unambiguously liberatory, this paper nevertheless suggests that the political possibilities contained within the ruins of extractive architectures are not uniformly adverse.


  • Extractivist States: Contesting and Negotiating the “Commodities Consensus” in Bolivia, Ecuador, and Across Latin America

    by Andrea Marston

    Resource extraction has become something of an unavoidable topic for scholars of Latin America. Whether one begins one’s career by studying Indigenous language politics in Bolivia (Gustafson 2009) or populism in Argentina (Martuccelli and Svampa 1997), it seems that, these days, all roads lead to extractivism. There are good empirical and political reasons for this focus. In a context where the provenance of money used to fund progressive political agendas is increasingly under scrutiny (spoiler alert: it’s resource rent) and extractive frontiers are cropping up in relatively new places (where they provoke relatively new social conflicts), extractivism appears as the root problem, the key contradiction, or the articulating concern of multiple social groups. Accordingly, it is also the shared topic of interest for the three books examined in this review.As Maristella Svampa underscores in her recent summary of the topic, Neo-extractivism in Latin America, the commodity boom that started in 2003 prompted Latin American governments from across the political spectrum to lean into the “el dorado” promises of expansive and rapid resource extraction. However, it is the enthusiasm with which an emerging set of leftist governments approached resource extraction that has sparked the most debate. Elected across the region in the early 2000s and collectively described as the “pink tide,” the new left administrations of Latin America rose to power on platforms that combined elements drawn from socialist, developmentalist, environmentalist, and Indigenous political stances, albeit in different proportions. The pink tide governments’ multifaceted political campaigns often reflected the heterogeneous social movements that propelled them into power. These social movements were united, above all, in their rejection of neoliberalism, but stark divergences in their understandings of what ought to come after neoliberalism became increasingly apparent the longer the pink tide maintained regional control.Nowhere were these tensions clearer than around the topic of resource extraction. While leftist administrations differed from their neoliberal predecessors in that they were capturing and redistributing much larger profits from this resource windfall (hence the prefix neo- often attached to the term extractivism), the social and ecological impacts of their extractive programs were equal to, if not worse than, those that had come before. For political analysts and leftist organizers alike, this has presented a strategic as much as a conceptual dilemma. At what point are the damages caused by “progressive” economic policies great enough to justify blunt critique? What work will that critique do, and how can it avoid inadvertently strengthening right-wing political movements, which are already resurgent across the region?Svampa, Gustafson, and Riofrancos all approach this question carefully, drawing on different disciplinary backgrounds but shared commitments to a “postextractivist” Latin American future, however challenging that may be to wrangle from the extractivist present. Svampa, along with Eduardo Gudynas (2009), is one of the strongest intellectual forces behind an effort to understand, name, and resist neo-extractivism in Latin America, and her book offers a succinct review of much of the work that she has been sharing in article form over the last two decades. As always, Svampa’s insights are sharp and constitute a set of guide rails for everyone else working on the subject. In a dialectical analysis, she pairs an elaboration on her term “commodities consensus,” which describes the regional convergence on export-oriented commodity production in post–Washington Consensus Latin America (see also Svampa 2015), with a detailed analysis of the “eco-territorial turn,” which encapsulates “the innovative crossroads between the indigenous-community matrix and the autonomic narrative, in an environmentalist key” (2). In other words, she is thinking through the relationship between, on one hand, regional and national political economic tendencies and, on the other hand, particular forms of emergent contestation, which have questioned not just resource extraction but also the contours of a desirable society and the meaning of “development.” As Arturo Escobar (2006) has long emphasized, the struggle over nature and “natural resources” is always also the struggle over meanings and belonging; Svampa shows how the commodities consensus has elevated this struggle to national and regional levels.Svampa’s is a regional survey, and she therefore explores shared tendencies across countries that appear ideologically opposed, such as Colombia (where neoliberal economics have largely prevailed) and Bolivia (where neoliberal economics have been officially rejected). Regardless of whether resource rents accrue primarily to elites (Colombia) or are more evenly distributed across social groups (Bolivia), Svampa insists that reliance on resource extraction keeps all countries in a shared state of dependence. With an ascendant China, the United States need no longer be so omnipresent in Latin American politics for dependency to remain a recurrent problematic. Indeed, China looms large in Svampa’s account, owing to its role in spurring the commodity boom, its regional investment portfolios (in infrastructure and resource extraction), and its status as the most important holder of Latin American debts.According to Svampa, the neoextractivist turn can be periodized in three phases: an optimistic phase focused on social spending and poverty reduction (2003–2008), an intensified phase marked by the proliferation of both “megaprojects” (dams, highways, open-pit mining, etc.) and social resistance (2008–2013), and an “exacerbated phase” characterized...

  • Of Flesh and Ore: Material Histories and Embodied Geologies

    by Andrea Marston

    This article explores the constitution of subterranean space in a Bolivian tin mine through an analysis of the discursive practices that materialize differentially valued people and differentially valued rocks. Drawing on archival and ethnographic research, I examine the processes through which tin miners are formed as socially stratified subjects and tin is mattered in its multiple forms—as mineral, as commodity, and as symbolic metal of modernity. Through this analysis, I develop a conceptual–methodological approach that integrates insights from feminist materialisms with commitments recuperated from “old” materialist geographies; I call this approach material history. Using this analytic, I argue that nonliving matters (1) are always historied before becoming materially entangled with human bodies, (2) are unevenly distributed and unevenly valued across volumetric space, and (3) contribute to the social stratification of the humans who labor with them. In the tin mine, racialized and gendered differences manifest in spatial association with differences in ore quality, ore exhaustion, and technologies of extraction. These arguments show how apparently inanimate matters can be counterintuitively influential in shaping human bodies and human social worlds, where subjects and objects are relationally formed, sorted, and ranked. : .


  • Post-Conflict Territorialization in Three Dimensions: Volumetric Territorial Struggles in Post-Peace Agreement Colombia

    by Daniela Mosquera-Camacho, Andrea Marston

    Four years after the signing of the 2016 Peace Agreement that ended the longest armed conflict in the history of the Americas, violent struggles over territory continue apace in many parts of rural Colombia. Official and academic explanations for this ongoing violence tend to link the problem to unequal land access, meaning that political solutions have tended to focus on rural land redistribution. However, we argue that shifting from a planar to a volumetric analysis of the problem reveals how the state and private capital have dramatically reconfigured territorial access in the post-Peace Agreement era. Drawing evidence from the department of Cesar, in the northeast of the Colombian Caribbean, we show how biophysical and social interconnections as well as legal disconnections between the land, subterranean, and atmosphere shape the daily lives of rural people and their expectations in the context of political transition. resumen: A cuatro años de la firma del acuerdo de paz que terminó con el conflicto armado más largo de la historia de América, las disputas sobre la configuración del espacio y los territorios continúan y se han exacerbado en las zonas rurales. La narrativa oficial y no-oficial que pone el problema de la inequidad sobre el acceso de la tierra como la explicación central de la violencia y la desigualdad del país sigue siendo la de mayor relevancia para académicos. Sin embargo, nosotras argumentamos que es necesario ampliar la mirada y pensar en los procesos de territorialización, sobre todo en el posconflicto, desde una perspectiva volumétrica para entender las formas en las que el estado y los capitales privados han configurado el acceso a la naturaleza, a la justicia y a la vida en Colombia. Partiendo del caso del departamento del Cesar en el nororiente del caribe Colombiano, nosotras mostramos las formas como las interconexiones biofísicas y sociales y las desconexiones legales sobre lo subterráneo, lo terrestre y la atmósfera tienen efectos sobre la vida cotidiana de la gente y sus expectativas en un contexto de transición política.


  • Vertical farming: tin mining and agro-mineros in Bolivia

    by Andrea Marston

    Throughout Bolivia, collectives of small-scale miners known as ‘mining cooperatives’ have developed a reputation for cutthroat extractive practices that were shaped by neoliberal restructuring starting in the 1980s. Charting a history that starts at the turn of the twentieth century, this paper argues that cooperative mining in the tin belt of Northern Potosí has emerged as a vertical instantiation of small-holder farming practices that migrated, along with miners themselves, from surrounding indigenous ayllus. In the subterranean, however, these practices interacted with the legacies of tin mining, which was characterized by labor hierarchies that corresponded with vertical variation in ore quality. New social striations crystallized as small-holder farming customs settled into the subterranean structure, creating sharp social differentiation across these subsoil ‘family farms.’ The class composition of mining cooperatives at the national level has been shaped by these entangled underground histories, with implications for the country’s economic and environmental futures.