Oliver Scheel
Oliver Scheel has a total of 36 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Anke Weidlich
Department of Sustainable Systems Engineering (INATECH), University of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany
2 shared publications- Anke Weidlich
University of Freiburg image/svg+xml
2 shared publications Claudia Sutardhio
Department of Sustainable Systems Engineering (INATECH), University of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany
2 shared publicationsFabienne Minn
Center for Interdisciplinary Risk and Innovation Studies (ZIRIUS), University of Stuttgart, Stuttgart, Germany
2 shared publicationsHeidi Hottenroth
Institute for Industrial Ecology (INEC), Pforzheim University, Pforzheim, Germany
2 shared publicationsIngela Tietze
Institute for Industrial Ecology (INEC), Pforzheim University, Pforzheim, Germany
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 7 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 239-258
Praxisbeitrag: Anwendungsbeispiel zur Integration inhaltsanalytischer Betrachtungen in Multi-Methoden-Forschungsstrategien im Bereich der Wissenschaftskommunikation
Zusammenfassung: Der Beitrag skizziert die Potenziale inhaltsanalytischer Betrachtungen als Bestandteil der Begleitforschung von Initiativen im Bereich Wissenschaftskommunikation und speziell in Bezug auf den Einsatz interaktiver Online-Designs. Inhaltsanalytische Betrachtungen erwiesen sich als zielführende Ergänzung des Multi-Method Designs der Forschungsstudie, wobei die Verzahnung aller Methoden eine Rolle spielt. Die vorgestellte explorative Teilstudie erarbeitet auch inhaltliche Erkenntnisse. Online-Verfahren wie Foren oder Diskussionstische zeigten viel Potenzial für die Wissenschaftskommunikation insbesondere dann, wenn die Auswahl des Designs unter Berücksichtigung auf die Zielsetzung des Dialogverfahrens erfolgt. Mit den Ergebnissen deutet sich an, dass die Frage welche Kommunikationsmodi (deliberativ-konstruktiv, aggregierend oder additiv) in einem Dialogdesign entwickelt werden sollen bzw. können wichtiger ist als die Frage der Umsetzung als Online versus Präsenzveranstaltung.
- 7 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 239-258
Open AccessPraxisbeitrag: Anwendungsbeispiel zur Integration inhaltsanalytischer Betrachtungen in Multi-Methoden-Forschungsstrategien im Bereich der Wissenschaftskommunikation
Zusammenfassung: Der Beitrag skizziert die Potenziale inhaltsanalytischer Betrachtungen als Bestandteil der Begleitforschung von Initiativen im Bereich Wissenschaftskommunikation und speziell in Bezug auf den Einsatz interaktiver Online-Designs. Inhaltsanalytische Betrachtungen erwiesen sich als zielführende Ergänzung des Multi-Method Designs der Forschungsstudie, wobei die Verzahnung aller Methoden eine Rolle spielt. Die vorgestellte explorative Teilstudie erarbeitet auch inhaltliche Erkenntnisse. Online-Verfahren wie Foren oder Diskussionstische zeigten viel Potenzial für die Wissenschaftskommunikation insbesondere dann, wenn die Auswahl des Designs unter Berücksichtigung auf die Zielsetzung des Dialogverfahrens erfolgt. Mit den Ergebnissen deutet sich an, dass die Frage welche Kommunikationsmodi (deliberativ-konstruktiv, aggregierend oder additiv) in einem Dialogdesign entwickelt werden sollen bzw. können wichtiger ist als die Frage der Umsetzung als Online versus Präsenzveranstaltung.
- Open Access
- 24 September 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Energy, Sustainability and Society
- Vol. 12 (1) , 1-23
Sustainability assessments of energy scenarios: citizens’ preferences for and assessments of sustainability indicators
Background: Given the multitude of scenarios on the future of our energy systems, multi-criteria assessments are increasingly called for to analyze and assess desired and undesired effects of possible pathways with regard to their environmental, economic and social sustainability. Existing studies apply elaborate lists of sustainability indicators, yet these indicators are defined and selected by experts and the relative importance of each indicator for the overall sustainability assessments is either determined by experts or is computed using mathematical functions. Target group-specific empirical data regarding citizens’ preferences for sustainability indicators as well as their reasoning behind their choices are not included in existing assessments. Approach and results: We argue that citizens’ preferences and values need to be more systematically analyzed. Next to valid and reliable data regarding diverse sets of indicators, reflections and deliberations are needed regarding what different societal actors, including citizens, consider as justified and legitimate interventions in nature and society, and what considerations they include in their own assessments. For this purpose, we present results from a discrete choice experiment. The method originated in marketing and is currently becoming a popular means to systematically analyze individuals’ preference structures for energy technology assessments. As we show in our paper, it can be fruitfully applied to study citizens’ values and weightings with regard to sustainability issues. Additionally, we present findings from six focus groups that unveil the reasons behind citizens’ preferences and choices. Conclusions: Our combined empirical methods provide main insights with strong implications for the future development and assessment of energy pathways: while environmental and climate-related effects significantly influenced citizens’ preferences for or against certain energy pathways, total systems and production costs were of far less importance to citizens than the public discourse suggests. Many scenario studies seek to optimize pathways according to total systems costs. In contrast, our findings show that the role of fairness and distributional justice in transition processes featured as a dominant theme for citizens. This adds central dimensions for future multi-criteria assessments that, so far, have been neglected by current energy systems models.
- 24 September 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Energy, Sustainability and Society
- Vol. 12 (1) , 1-23
Open AccessSustainability assessments of energy scenarios: citizens’ preferences for and assessments of sustainability indicators
Background: Given the multitude of scenarios on the future of our energy systems, multi-criteria assessments are increasingly called for to analyze and assess desired and undesired effects of possible pathways with regard to their environmental, economic and social sustainability. Existing studies apply elaborate lists of sustainability indicators, yet these indicators are defined and selected by experts and the relative importance of each indicator for the overall sustainability assessments is either determined by experts or is computed using mathematical functions. Target group-specific empirical data regarding citizens’ preferences for sustainability indicators as well as their reasoning behind their choices are not included in existing assessments. Approach and results: We argue that citizens’ preferences and values need to be more systematically analyzed. Next to valid and reliable data regarding diverse sets of indicators, reflections and deliberations are needed regarding what different societal actors, including citizens, consider as justified and legitimate interventions in nature and society, and what considerations they include in their own assessments. For this purpose, we present results from a discrete choice experiment. The method originated in marketing and is currently becoming a popular means to systematically analyze individuals’ preference structures for energy technology assessments. As we show in our paper, it can be fruitfully applied to study citizens’ values and weightings with regard to sustainability issues. Additionally, we present findings from six focus groups that unveil the reasons behind citizens’ preferences and choices. Conclusions: Our combined empirical methods provide main insights with strong implications for the future development and assessment of energy pathways: while environmental and climate-related effects significantly influenced citizens’ preferences for or against certain energy pathways, total systems and production costs were of far less importance to citizens than the public discourse suggests. Many scenario studies seek to optimize pathways according to total systems costs. In contrast, our findings show that the role of fairness and distributional justice in transition processes featured as a dominant theme for citizens. This adds central dimensions for future multi-criteria assessments that, so far, have been neglected by current energy systems models.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
- Vol. 156
Beyond climate change. Multi-attribute decision making for a sustainability assessment of energy system transformation pathways
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
- Vol. 156
Open AccessBeyond climate change. Multi-attribute decision making for a sustainability assessment of energy system transformation pathways
- Open Access
- 18 October 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Bridging the Gap: An Empirical Approach to Studying the Social Sustainability of Future Energy Systems
Background: Given the multitude of scenarios on the future of our energy systems, multi-criteria assessments are increasingly called for to analyze and anticipate long-term effects of possible pathways with regards to their environmental, economic and social sustainability. While economic and ecologic indicators are covered through energy systems modelling and life cycle sustainability assessments, approaches to the social sustainability of future energy systems remain methodologically under-developed. Previous studies have either focused only on the social acceptance of single energy technologies or used expert-based environmental and economic indicators with social implications. Approach and results: We argue that in order to gather empirical insights on the social sustainability of future energy systems and to integrate it in multi-criteria assessments, citizens’ preferences and values need to be more systematically analyzed while informing their decisions more transparently with full life cycle data. Given the lack of theoretical underpinnings of sustainability and of empirical insights into citizens’ perceptions of sustainability with respect to future energy systems, we further argue that an explorative research design is needed. Therefore, next to six focus groups, we conducted a discrete choice experiment. The method is currently becoming more popular to analyze individuals’ preference structures for energy technologies or investments. As we show in our paper, it can be fruitfully applied to study the values and trade-offs of citizens with regards to sustainability issues. Our combined empirical methods provide two main insights with strong implications for the future development and assessment of energy pathways: While environmental and climate-related effects significantly influenced citizens’ preferences for or against certain energy pathways, total systems and production costs were of far less importance to citizens than the public discourse suggests. Conclusions: Our findings are contrary to the focus of many scenario studies that seek to optimize pathways according to total systems costs. The role of fairness and distributional justice in transition processes featured as a dominant theme in all focus groups. This adds central dimensions for future multi-criteria assessments that, so far, have been neglected by current energy systems models.
- 18 October 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessBridging the Gap: An Empirical Approach to Studying the Social Sustainability of Future Energy Systems
Background: Given the multitude of scenarios on the future of our energy systems, multi-criteria assessments are increasingly called for to analyze and anticipate long-term effects of possible pathways with regards to their environmental, economic and social sustainability. While economic and ecologic indicators are covered through energy systems modelling and life cycle sustainability assessments, approaches to the social sustainability of future energy systems remain methodologically under-developed. Previous studies have either focused only on the social acceptance of single energy technologies or used expert-based environmental and economic indicators with social implications. Approach and results: We argue that in order to gather empirical insights on the social sustainability of future energy systems and to integrate it in multi-criteria assessments, citizens’ preferences and values need to be more systematically analyzed while informing their decisions more transparently with full life cycle data. Given the lack of theoretical underpinnings of sustainability and of empirical insights into citizens’ perceptions of sustainability with respect to future energy systems, we further argue that an explorative research design is needed. Therefore, next to six focus groups, we conducted a discrete choice experiment. The method is currently becoming more popular to analyze individuals’ preference structures for energy technologies or investments. As we show in our paper, it can be fruitfully applied to study the values and trade-offs of citizens with regards to sustainability issues. Our combined empirical methods provide two main insights with strong implications for the future development and assessment of energy pathways: While environmental and climate-related effects significantly influenced citizens’ preferences for or against certain energy pathways, total systems and production costs were of far less importance to citizens than the public discourse suggests. Conclusions: Our findings are contrary to the focus of many scenario studies that seek to optimize pathways according to total systems costs. The role of fairness and distributional justice in transition processes featured as a dominant theme in all focus groups. This adds central dimensions for future multi-criteria assessments that, so far, have been neglected by current energy systems models.
- Open Access
- 7 May 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (9) , 5217
Integrated Multidimensional Sustainability Assessment of Energy System Transformation Pathways
Sustainable development embraces a broad spectrum of social, economic and ecological aspects. Thus, a sustainable transformation process of energy systems is inevitably multidimensional and needs to go beyond climate impact and cost considerations. An approach for an integrated and interdisciplinary sustainability assessment of energy system transformation pathways is presented here. It first integrates energy system modeling with a multidimensional impact assessment that focuses on life cycle-based environmental and macroeconomic impacts. Then, stakeholders’ preferences with respect to defined sustainability indicators are inquired, which are finally integrated into a comparative scenario evaluation through a multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA), all in one consistent assessment framework. As an illustrative example, this holistic approach is applied to the sustainability assessment of ten different transformation strategies for Germany. Applying multi-criteria decision analysis reveals that both ambitious (80%) and highly ambitious (95%) carbon reduction scenarios can achieve top sustainability ranks, depending on the underlying energy transformation pathways and respective scores in other sustainability dimensions. Furthermore, this research highlights an increasingly dominant contribution of energy systems’ upstream chains on total environmental impacts, reveals rather small differences in macroeconomic effects between different scenarios and identifies the transition among societal segments and climate impact minimization as the most important stakeholder preferences.
- 7 May 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (9) , 5217
Open AccessIntegrated Multidimensional Sustainability Assessment of Energy System Transformation Pathways
Sustainable development embraces a broad spectrum of social, economic and ecological aspects. Thus, a sustainable transformation process of energy systems is inevitably multidimensional and needs to go beyond climate impact and cost considerations. An approach for an integrated and interdisciplinary sustainability assessment of energy system transformation pathways is presented here. It first integrates energy system modeling with a multidimensional impact assessment that focuses on life cycle-based environmental and macroeconomic impacts. Then, stakeholders’ preferences with respect to defined sustainability indicators are inquired, which are finally integrated into a comparative scenario evaluation through a multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA), all in one consistent assessment framework. As an illustrative example, this holistic approach is applied to the sustainability assessment of ten different transformation strategies for Germany. Applying multi-criteria decision analysis reveals that both ambitious (80%) and highly ambitious (95%) carbon reduction scenarios can achieve top sustainability ranks, depending on the underlying energy transformation pathways and respective scores in other sustainability dimensions. Furthermore, this research highlights an increasingly dominant contribution of energy systems’ upstream chains on total environmental impacts, reveals rather small differences in macroeconomic effects between different scenarios and identifies the transition among societal segments and climate impact minimization as the most important stakeholder preferences.