Panu Tanninen
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Panu Tanninen has a total of 46 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ville Leminen
Mechanical Engineering Lappeenranta‐Lahti University of Technology LUT Lappeenranta Finland
15 shared publications Juha Varis
Department of Mechanical Engineering Lappeenranta‐Lahti University of Technology LUT Lappeenranta Finland
8 shared publications- Johanna Lyytikäinen
Department of Mechanical Engineering Lappeenranta‐Lahti University of Technology LUT Lappeenranta Finland
7 shared publications Sami Matthews
LUT University, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Research Group of Packaging Technology
6 shared publicationsVille Leminen
LUT University, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Research Group of Packaging Technology
5 shared publicationsAntti Pesonen
Mechanical Engineering, Lappeenranta‐Lahti University of Technology LUT Lappeenranta Finland
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 39 (8) , 1003-1014
Investigating the Performance of Polytetrafluoroethylene and Polyoxymethylene Creasing Rules in the Package Conversion of Coated Paperboard
Novel dispersion‐coated paperboards offer a sustainable alternative to conventional plastic packaging but require modifications to traditional conversion methods. Although fibre‐based substrates with plastic coatings can be creased using conventional tools without substantial loss of barrier properties, more brittle dispersion coatings can crack under applied loads. To address this issue, two sets of creasing tools were designed and machined from polytetrafluoroethylene and polyoxymethylene in this study. Round and flat rule tip types were used to examine the convertibility and oil and grease resistance (OGR) of a commercially available dispersion‐coated paperboard MetsäBoard Prime FBB EB after creasing and folding. The performance of the round plastic rules was compared with that of an industrial‐grade steel creasing rule with the same geometry. The results showed that creasing with round rules and subsequent folding of the samples required similar forces. The flat plastic rules required higher creasing forces; however, the foldability of the samples was comparable to that of the samples creased with the round rules. Creasing with the steel rule drastically reduced the material OGR, especially for the samples creased parallel to the cross‐machine direction (CD). The materials creased with plastic rules did not encounter significant OGR reduction, except for the samples creased with flat rules parallel to the CD. After folding the samples, the maximum OGR time for all test points did not exceed 2 h, and the shortest minimum times were recorded for the steel‐creased samples. Scanning electron microscopy results confirmed severe coating cracking after creasing with the steel rule, and less surface damage to the plastic‐creased material was observed. Overall, the plastic rules demonstrated superior performance in the creasing process of the paperboard, facilitating their evaluation on a larger scale in future research.
- 18 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 39 (8) , 1003-1014
Open AccessInvestigating the Performance of Polytetrafluoroethylene and Polyoxymethylene Creasing Rules in the Package Conversion of Coated Paperboard
Novel dispersion‐coated paperboards offer a sustainable alternative to conventional plastic packaging but require modifications to traditional conversion methods. Although fibre‐based substrates with plastic coatings can be creased using conventional tools without substantial loss of barrier properties, more brittle dispersion coatings can crack under applied loads. To address this issue, two sets of creasing tools were designed and machined from polytetrafluoroethylene and polyoxymethylene in this study. Round and flat rule tip types were used to examine the convertibility and oil and grease resistance (OGR) of a commercially available dispersion‐coated paperboard MetsäBoard Prime FBB EB after creasing and folding. The performance of the round plastic rules was compared with that of an industrial‐grade steel creasing rule with the same geometry. The results showed that creasing with round rules and subsequent folding of the samples required similar forces. The flat plastic rules required higher creasing forces; however, the foldability of the samples was comparable to that of the samples creased with the round rules. Creasing with the steel rule drastically reduced the material OGR, especially for the samples creased parallel to the cross‐machine direction (CD). The materials creased with plastic rules did not encounter significant OGR reduction, except for the samples creased with flat rules parallel to the CD. After folding the samples, the maximum OGR time for all test points did not exceed 2 h, and the shortest minimum times were recorded for the steel‐creased samples. Scanning electron microscopy results confirmed severe coating cracking after creasing with the steel rule, and less surface damage to the plastic‐creased material was observed. Overall, the plastic rules demonstrated superior performance in the creasing process of the paperboard, facilitating their evaluation on a larger scale in future research.
- 16 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 269-276
Measurement of the Barrier Properties of Multilayer Plastic Sealing Joints Used in Packaging Applications
- 16 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 269-276
Measurement of the Barrier Properties of Multilayer Plastic Sealing Joints Used in Packaging Applications
- Open Access
- 29 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 39 (1) , 33-48
Heat Sealability and Convertibility of Cellulose Film in Vertical Form, Fill and Seal Machine for Food Packaging Applications
The environmental challenges posed by petroleum‐based flexible packaging have accelerated interest in sustainable alternatives such as regenerated cellulose films. Despite their biodegradability, transparency and mechanical properties, their applicability in vertical form, fill and seal (VFFS) machines remains uninvestigated, particularly regarding sealability, frictional behaviour and material convertibility. This study investigates the commercial cellulose film under standard and tropical climate conditions. A comprehensive analysis was conducted through laboratory and VFFS machine experiments, including seal strength and integrity, friction measurements, convertibility tests using different forming shoulders, and assessments of oil and grease resistance (OGR) and oxygen transmission rate (OTR). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and 3D profilometry were employed to analyse sealing morphology and surface characteristics, respectively. The results revealed that cellulose films provided satisfactory seal strength at lower temperatures with serrated tools, but performance decreased sharply beyond 110 °C due to thermal degradation of the heat‐seal coating layer and cellulose film. SEM analysis confirmed better sealing interfaces with serrated tools, whereas flat tools led to unsealed microchannels. Convertibility and runnability were successful under standard conditions with minimal wrinkling, although tropical conditions caused surface adhesion and film softening. Surface topography measurements showed that the commercial sheet metal shoulder reduced wrinkle visibility as compared to the machined shoulder, although the machined shoulder offered better control. OTR results showed that commercial sheet metal shoulder and machined shoulder preserved the OTR properties up to 98% and 93%, respectively. OGR results confirmed that the material retained its surface integrity regardless of the forming shoulder type. These findings support the cellulose film's potential as a sustainable packaging solution. However, expanding their sealing window, enhancing mechanical resistance against deformation and refining shoulder designs are essential future improvements to ensure consistent barrier performance and visual integrity in VFFS applications.
- 29 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 39 (1) , 33-48
Open AccessHeat Sealability and Convertibility of Cellulose Film in Vertical Form, Fill and Seal Machine for Food Packaging Applications
The environmental challenges posed by petroleum‐based flexible packaging have accelerated interest in sustainable alternatives such as regenerated cellulose films. Despite their biodegradability, transparency and mechanical properties, their applicability in vertical form, fill and seal (VFFS) machines remains uninvestigated, particularly regarding sealability, frictional behaviour and material convertibility. This study investigates the commercial cellulose film under standard and tropical climate conditions. A comprehensive analysis was conducted through laboratory and VFFS machine experiments, including seal strength and integrity, friction measurements, convertibility tests using different forming shoulders, and assessments of oil and grease resistance (OGR) and oxygen transmission rate (OTR). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and 3D profilometry were employed to analyse sealing morphology and surface characteristics, respectively. The results revealed that cellulose films provided satisfactory seal strength at lower temperatures with serrated tools, but performance decreased sharply beyond 110 °C due to thermal degradation of the heat‐seal coating layer and cellulose film. SEM analysis confirmed better sealing interfaces with serrated tools, whereas flat tools led to unsealed microchannels. Convertibility and runnability were successful under standard conditions with minimal wrinkling, although tropical conditions caused surface adhesion and film softening. Surface topography measurements showed that the commercial sheet metal shoulder reduced wrinkle visibility as compared to the machined shoulder, although the machined shoulder offered better control. OTR results showed that commercial sheet metal shoulder and machined shoulder preserved the OTR properties up to 98% and 93%, respectively. OGR results confirmed that the material retained its surface integrity regardless of the forming shoulder type. These findings support the cellulose film's potential as a sustainable packaging solution. However, expanding their sealing window, enhancing mechanical resistance against deformation and refining shoulder designs are essential future improvements to ensure consistent barrier performance and visual integrity in VFFS applications.
- Open Access
- 28 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 38 (5) , 359-367
Convertibility and Barrier Performance of Novel Bio‐Based Extrusion‐Coated Paperboards
Conventional fossil fuel–based plastics for food packaging currently cause environmental concerns owing to poor recyclability and degradability, and new strategies are being developed to address these issues. One strategy involves the use of bioresources to produce bio‐based plastics that exhibit similar performance with enhanced sustainability. However, the understanding of the properties of these materials remains limited. Consequently, the convertibility and barrier properties of three extrusion‐coated paperboards before and after creasing were examined in this study. Each coating was composed of a partially bio‐based polymer:low‐density polyethylene (Bio‐PE) and two polybutylene succinate (PBS) grades. All materials demonstrated high oil resistance and low water absorbency (Cobb1800). Certain creased samples of Bio‐PE unexpectedly exhibited a higher barrier to oxygen than the unconverted material, whereas the results for the PBS grades were more consistent. In contrast, Bio‐PE provided a superior barrier to water vapour compared with PBS. The tests indicated that conversion did not reduce the material barrier properties, as confirmed by the negligible surface damage observed using scanning electron microscopy. The issues encountered were attributed to deviations in the production quality of Bio‐PE and insufficient adhesion of both PBS films to the substrate. Although further research is required for improving the coating uniformity and adhesion to substrate, the materials exhibit potential to advance the sustainable packaging.
- 28 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 38 (5) , 359-367
Open AccessConvertibility and Barrier Performance of Novel Bio‐Based Extrusion‐Coated Paperboards
Conventional fossil fuel–based plastics for food packaging currently cause environmental concerns owing to poor recyclability and degradability, and new strategies are being developed to address these issues. One strategy involves the use of bioresources to produce bio‐based plastics that exhibit similar performance with enhanced sustainability. However, the understanding of the properties of these materials remains limited. Consequently, the convertibility and barrier properties of three extrusion‐coated paperboards before and after creasing were examined in this study. Each coating was composed of a partially bio‐based polymer:low‐density polyethylene (Bio‐PE) and two polybutylene succinate (PBS) grades. All materials demonstrated high oil resistance and low water absorbency (Cobb1800). Certain creased samples of Bio‐PE unexpectedly exhibited a higher barrier to oxygen than the unconverted material, whereas the results for the PBS grades were more consistent. In contrast, Bio‐PE provided a superior barrier to water vapour compared with PBS. The tests indicated that conversion did not reduce the material barrier properties, as confirmed by the negligible surface damage observed using scanning electron microscopy. The issues encountered were attributed to deviations in the production quality of Bio‐PE and insufficient adhesion of both PBS films to the substrate. Although further research is required for improving the coating uniformity and adhesion to substrate, the materials exhibit potential to advance the sustainable packaging.
- 13 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 111-119
Evaluation of the Plastic Film Thermoforming Process and the Operation of the Forming Tool with a Thermal Camera
- 13 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 111-119
Evaluation of the Plastic Film Thermoforming Process and the Operation of the Forming Tool with a Thermal Camera
- Open Access
- 23 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 38 (2) , 131-143
Novel Forming Shoulder for Coated Paper‐Based Materials With Improved Convertibility and Minimum Wrinkles for Use in Vertical Form, Fill and Seal Machines
Most vertical form, fill and seal machines use thermoplastic films. However, the gradual shift towards sustainability has created challenges for the packaging industry to employ flexible coated paper‐based materials for packing products. Forming shoulders are a crucial component in packaging machinery for creating coated paper‐based packaging as the size and shape of the packaging depend on their geometrical features. However, the shoulder geometry and design can negatively affect paper packaging by causing unwanted wrinkles and tears, which can affect the shelf lives of products. Therefore, this study focused on developing a new shoulder and optimizing its geometrical parameters for coated paper‐based packaging. Conventional forming shoulders were experimentally investigated by evaluating the influence of their geometrical parameters on flexible coated papers before focusing on optimizing the new shoulder. Additionally, this study aimed to improve the overall runnability and convertibility of the coated paper on the forming shoulder. The newly designed optimized shoulder features an enhanced geometry that can minimize the stress–strain effect. Additionally, the computerized numerical control machined new shoulder features improved web tracking and material handling process. The study achieved to produce lower surface roughness with minimum number of wrinkles on the pillow bag's surface. Furthermore, it ensures that the oil‐ and grease‐resistance properties of the converted coated paper are maintained and feature an enhanced geometry that minimizes the stress–strain effect on paper, thereby offering a more sustainable and efficient packaging solution.
- 23 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 38 (2) , 131-143
Open AccessNovel Forming Shoulder for Coated Paper‐Based Materials With Improved Convertibility and Minimum Wrinkles for Use in Vertical Form, Fill and Seal Machines
Most vertical form, fill and seal machines use thermoplastic films. However, the gradual shift towards sustainability has created challenges for the packaging industry to employ flexible coated paper‐based materials for packing products. Forming shoulders are a crucial component in packaging machinery for creating coated paper‐based packaging as the size and shape of the packaging depend on their geometrical features. However, the shoulder geometry and design can negatively affect paper packaging by causing unwanted wrinkles and tears, which can affect the shelf lives of products. Therefore, this study focused on developing a new shoulder and optimizing its geometrical parameters for coated paper‐based packaging. Conventional forming shoulders were experimentally investigated by evaluating the influence of their geometrical parameters on flexible coated papers before focusing on optimizing the new shoulder. Additionally, this study aimed to improve the overall runnability and convertibility of the coated paper on the forming shoulder. The newly designed optimized shoulder features an enhanced geometry that can minimize the stress–strain effect. Additionally, the computerized numerical control machined new shoulder features improved web tracking and material handling process. The study achieved to produce lower surface roughness with minimum number of wrinkles on the pillow bag's surface. Furthermore, it ensures that the oil‐ and grease‐resistance properties of the converted coated paper are maintained and feature an enhanced geometry that minimizes the stress–strain effect on paper, thereby offering a more sustainable and efficient packaging solution.
- Open Access
- 1 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 37 (11) , 1037-1048
Investigating the Convertibility and Barrier Performance of a Novel Suberin Dispersion Coating During the Paperboard Creasing Process
Packaging plastics are being substituted by more sustainable materials to satisfy modern‐life requirements. For example, utilisation of biocoated paperboards for packaging is one of the options; however, certain challenges exist in maintaining the integrity of the coated surface. In this study, the barrier formation and convertibility properties of a novel suberin dispersion coating were examined and compared with those of six commercial coatings by measuring their oil and grease resistance and using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) before and after creasing. Even before creasing, SEM revealed deep cavities on the coated surfaces, with the potential to impair the material barrier properties. Furthermore, finite element modelling provided evidence that creasing stresses emerged under the rules and in nearby areas. These outer stresses with internal fibre structure realignment caused the formation of surface defects such as grazes, microcracks and coating ruptures. The deepest defects, which critically reduce the barrier properties, were oriented parallel to the machine direction of the materials. In contrast, the cross‐machine direction‐oriented defects were bridged by the substrate fibres and did not penetrate that deeply into the coating thickness. The amount and severity of the surface damage revealed by SEM were correlated with the actual oil resistance measured for each material. The results indicate that the suberin dispersion exhibits promising barrier performance as a paperboard coating but requires further development to enhance its resistance to the conversion stresses.
- 1 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 37 (11) , 1037-1048
Open AccessInvestigating the Convertibility and Barrier Performance of a Novel Suberin Dispersion Coating During the Paperboard Creasing Process
Packaging plastics are being substituted by more sustainable materials to satisfy modern‐life requirements. For example, utilisation of biocoated paperboards for packaging is one of the options; however, certain challenges exist in maintaining the integrity of the coated surface. In this study, the barrier formation and convertibility properties of a novel suberin dispersion coating were examined and compared with those of six commercial coatings by measuring their oil and grease resistance and using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) before and after creasing. Even before creasing, SEM revealed deep cavities on the coated surfaces, with the potential to impair the material barrier properties. Furthermore, finite element modelling provided evidence that creasing stresses emerged under the rules and in nearby areas. These outer stresses with internal fibre structure realignment caused the formation of surface defects such as grazes, microcracks and coating ruptures. The deepest defects, which critically reduce the barrier properties, were oriented parallel to the machine direction of the materials. In contrast, the cross‐machine direction‐oriented defects were bridged by the substrate fibres and did not penetrate that deeply into the coating thickness. The amount and severity of the surface damage revealed by SEM were correlated with the actual oil resistance measured for each material. The results indicate that the suberin dispersion exhibits promising barrier performance as a paperboard coating but requires further development to enhance its resistance to the conversion stresses.
- Open Access
- 25 June 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Cellulose
- Vol. 31 (11) , 6955-6973
Foam-laid extensible paper for improved extensibility and press-forming performance
This study was motivated by the recent raising interest for the sustainable plastic-free dry 3D formable materials. 3D forming processes are capable to produce large unit quantities, but the process conditions for packaging applications have been typically very demanding for cellulose-based materials. This study covers some of the key factors affecting the extensibility of cellulose fibre-based materials and presents a laboratory-scale development study of a press-formable material concept. The investigation focused on comparisons of two refining concepts for bleached softwood kraft (BSK) pulp and two sheet forming concepts, namely water-laid and foam-laid forming. Additionally, influence of thermoplastic additives on the extensibility and 3D forming performance were investigated. In-plane compaction was applied with Expanda® laboratory device. Performance of the materials was evaluated by tensile tests and depth of the 3D formed shapes. In this study, in-plane compaction at first in cross-machine direction (CD) and then in machine direction (MD) led to over 30% elongation with BSK-based laboratory sheets containing latex as a binder and foaming agent. In addition to high elongation, optimal strength was needed for the best press-forming performances. In-plane compaction was the most significant factor regarding the elongation, but it also decreased the strength of the materials. Similar press-forming performance was found with two materials with either highly anisotropic or more isotropic elongation. The elongation anisotropy was created by one-way and two-way in-plane compactions. The results indicate that a reasonable performance for BSK-based materials for 3D forming applications can be reached using the presented concept.
- 25 June 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Cellulose
- Vol. 31 (11) , 6955-6973
Open AccessFoam-laid extensible paper for improved extensibility and press-forming performance
This study was motivated by the recent raising interest for the sustainable plastic-free dry 3D formable materials. 3D forming processes are capable to produce large unit quantities, but the process conditions for packaging applications have been typically very demanding for cellulose-based materials. This study covers some of the key factors affecting the extensibility of cellulose fibre-based materials and presents a laboratory-scale development study of a press-formable material concept. The investigation focused on comparisons of two refining concepts for bleached softwood kraft (BSK) pulp and two sheet forming concepts, namely water-laid and foam-laid forming. Additionally, influence of thermoplastic additives on the extensibility and 3D forming performance were investigated. In-plane compaction was applied with Expanda® laboratory device. Performance of the materials was evaluated by tensile tests and depth of the 3D formed shapes. In this study, in-plane compaction at first in cross-machine direction (CD) and then in machine direction (MD) led to over 30% elongation with BSK-based laboratory sheets containing latex as a binder and foaming agent. In addition to high elongation, optimal strength was needed for the best press-forming performances. In-plane compaction was the most significant factor regarding the elongation, but it also decreased the strength of the materials. Similar press-forming performance was found with two materials with either highly anisotropic or more isotropic elongation. The elongation anisotropy was created by one-way and two-way in-plane compactions. The results indicate that a reasonable performance for BSK-based materials for 3D forming applications can be reached using the presented concept.
- Open Access
- 25 April 2024
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 37 (7) , 655-665
Evaluation of Frictional Influence and Thermal Analysis of Flexible Paper‐Based Materials Used in the Vertical Form–Fill–Seal Process: An Experimental Study
This study evaluated the frictional behaviour of flexible polymer‐coated and dispersion‐coated materials used in vertical form–fill–seal (VFFS) machines. A laboratory‐scale friction measurement device was developed to investigate the relationship between different surface topographies, roughness and frictional properties. Furthermore, surface roughness, contact angle and surface energy of the material were analysed and a microscopic analysis was performed to further understand the effect of material properties on friction. Thermal camera analysis was performed to measure the temperature changes within the material during the film‐transport stage of the VFFS machine. The friction measurement results indicated that the sliding direction did not affect the static and kinetic coefficients of friction. The significant influence of friction on the surface topography of the plate (forming shoulder and tube) was particularly evident. Some materials experienced the stick–slip phenomenon during sliding, depending on the surface type. Teflon tape, which is commonly used in the forming tubes of VFFS machines, exhibited the lowest coefficient of friction. Thermal camera analysis revealed that polymer‐coated paper materials generated more heat than dispersion‐coated papers during VFFS trials and thermoplastic films generated the least heat. No clear relationship between the surface roughness of the paper, fibre orientation, surface energy and friction coefficient was noted. Furthermore, paper‐based materials exhibited a higher coefficient of friction, which is possibly related to the dispersion components of surface energy. The findings of this study provide additional knowledge for designing the forming tube, shoulder geometry and surface plate to minimize the occurrence of defects, such as wrinkles, in paper‐based packages.
- 25 April 2024
- Published by Wiley in Packaging Technology and Science
- Vol. 37 (7) , 655-665
Open AccessEvaluation of Frictional Influence and Thermal Analysis of Flexible Paper‐Based Materials Used in the Vertical Form–Fill–Seal Process: An Experimental Study
This study evaluated the frictional behaviour of flexible polymer‐coated and dispersion‐coated materials used in vertical form–fill–seal (VFFS) machines. A laboratory‐scale friction measurement device was developed to investigate the relationship between different surface topographies, roughness and frictional properties. Furthermore, surface roughness, contact angle and surface energy of the material were analysed and a microscopic analysis was performed to further understand the effect of material properties on friction. Thermal camera analysis was performed to measure the temperature changes within the material during the film‐transport stage of the VFFS machine. The friction measurement results indicated that the sliding direction did not affect the static and kinetic coefficients of friction. The significant influence of friction on the surface topography of the plate (forming shoulder and tube) was particularly evident. Some materials experienced the stick–slip phenomenon during sliding, depending on the surface type. Teflon tape, which is commonly used in the forming tubes of VFFS machines, exhibited the lowest coefficient of friction. Thermal camera analysis revealed that polymer‐coated paper materials generated more heat than dispersion‐coated papers during VFFS trials and thermoplastic films generated the least heat. No clear relationship between the surface roughness of the paper, fibre orientation, surface energy and friction coefficient was noted. Furthermore, paper‐based materials exhibited a higher coefficient of friction, which is possibly related to the dispersion components of surface energy. The findings of this study provide additional knowledge for designing the forming tube, shoulder geometry and surface plate to minimize the occurrence of defects, such as wrinkles, in paper‐based packages.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by AIP Publishing in AIP Conference Proceedings
- Vol. 3059 (1) , 040001
Investigation of the thermoformability of bioplastics
In an effort to move towards a more sustainable future, bioplastics are being promoted as sustainable alternatives to plastics. Nevertheless, the market transit
- 1 January 2024
- Published by AIP Publishing in AIP Conference Proceedings
- Vol. 3059 (1) , 040001
Open AccessInvestigation of the thermoformability of bioplastics
In an effort to move towards a more sustainable future, bioplastics are being promoted as sustainable alternatives to plastics. Nevertheless, the market transit