Jean-Michel Brankart
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Jean-Michel Brankart has a total of 172 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Pierre Brasseur
Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CNRS, IRD, Grenoble INP, IGE, Grenoble, France
30 shared publicationsP. Brasseur
University Grenoble Alpes CNRS IRD Grenoble INP IGE Grenoble France
25 shared publicationsJacques Verron
Université Grenoble Alpes, CNRS, IRD, IGE
20 shared publicationsJ. Verron
Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique
12 shared publications- Emmanuel Cosme
Institut des Géosciences de l'Environnement
11 shared publications - Thierry Penduff
Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CNRS, IRD, Grenoble INP, IGE, Grenoble, France
9 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 19 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Ocean Science
- Vol. 22 (5) , 3207-3224
Efficient ensemble estimation using an MCMC sampler: a reconstruction of the Mediterranean low-frequency variability combining observed and simulated sea level
The skill of climate projections depends on the ability of models to reproduce the long-term and low-frequency variability of the system. It is thus important that low-frequency model statistics can be checked against observations. In this paper, a method is proposed to estimate directly the low-frequency component of the ocean variability from native observations using statistics from a prior long-term simulation. It is designed to account for possible model biases and to provide an estimate of the correction required to fit observations. The result is obtained by an MCMC sampler (modified to include localization of the model covariance), which provides an ensemble description of the solution, so that uncertainties can be properly assessed using independent data. This algorithm is shown well suited to work with MPI and GPUs, and efficient enough to solve large-size problems (about 10 8 variables and 10 7 observations). The approach is illustrated by the reconstruction of the low-frequency variability of the Mediterranean sea level, using statistics from a 1/12° resolution ensemble model simulation. The resulting ensemble is assessed against independent observations (by cross-validation), showing good reliability (flat rank histogram). The method also produces a consistent estimate of the model bias and of the observation error variance (mainly representativity error), while the missing prior ensemble variance is shown to be less controlable by the observations, and thus rather computed as a diagnostic. Overall, this application shows the importance of reliable model statistics, and thus the importance of enhancing model simulations to represent all main sources of uncertainty.
- 19 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Ocean Science
- Vol. 22 (5) , 3207-3224
Open AccessEfficient ensemble estimation using an MCMC sampler: a reconstruction of the Mediterranean low-frequency variability combining observed and simulated sea level
The skill of climate projections depends on the ability of models to reproduce the long-term and low-frequency variability of the system. It is thus important that low-frequency model statistics can be checked against observations. In this paper, a method is proposed to estimate directly the low-frequency component of the ocean variability from native observations using statistics from a prior long-term simulation. It is designed to account for possible model biases and to provide an estimate of the correction required to fit observations. The result is obtained by an MCMC sampler (modified to include localization of the model covariance), which provides an ensemble description of the solution, so that uncertainties can be properly assessed using independent data. This algorithm is shown well suited to work with MPI and GPUs, and efficient enough to solve large-size problems (about 10 8 variables and 10 7 observations). The approach is illustrated by the reconstruction of the low-frequency variability of the Mediterranean sea level, using statistics from a 1/12° resolution ensemble model simulation. The resulting ensemble is assessed against independent observations (by cross-validation), showing good reliability (flat rank histogram). The method also produces a consistent estimate of the model bias and of the observation error variance (mainly representativity error), while the missing prior ensemble variance is shown to be less controlable by the observations, and thus rather computed as a diagnostic. Overall, this application shows the importance of reliable model statistics, and thus the importance of enhancing model simulations to represent all main sources of uncertainty.
- Open Access
- 28 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Reply on RC2
The skill of climate projections depends on the ability of models to reproduce the long-term and low-frequency variability of the system. It is thus important that low-frequency model statistics can be checked against observations. In this paper, a method is proposed to estimate directly the low-frequency component of the ocean variability from native observations using statistics from a prior long-term simulation. It is designed to account for possible model biases and to provide an estimate of the correction required to fit observations. The result is obtained by an MCMC sampler (modified to include localization of the model covariance), which provides an ensemble description of the solution, so that uncertainties can be properly assessed using independent data. This algorithm is shown well suited to work with MPI and GPUs, and efficient enough to solve large-size problems (about 108 variables and 107 observations). The approach is illustrated by the reconstruction of the low-frequency variability of the Mediterranean sea level, using statistics from a 1/12° resolution ensemble model simulation. The resulting ensemble is assessed against independent observations (by cross-validation), showing good reliability (flat rank histogram). The method also produces a consistent estimate of the model bias and of the observation error variance (mainly representativity error), while the missing prior ensemble variance is shown to be less controlable by the observations, and thus rather computed as a diagnostic. Overall, this application shows the importance of reliable model statistics, and thus the importance of enhancing model simulations to represent all main sources of uncertainty.
- 28 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Open AccessReply on RC2
The skill of climate projections depends on the ability of models to reproduce the long-term and low-frequency variability of the system. It is thus important that low-frequency model statistics can be checked against observations. In this paper, a method is proposed to estimate directly the low-frequency component of the ocean variability from native observations using statistics from a prior long-term simulation. It is designed to account for possible model biases and to provide an estimate of the correction required to fit observations. The result is obtained by an MCMC sampler (modified to include localization of the model covariance), which provides an ensemble description of the solution, so that uncertainties can be properly assessed using independent data. This algorithm is shown well suited to work with MPI and GPUs, and efficient enough to solve large-size problems (about 108 variables and 107 observations). The approach is illustrated by the reconstruction of the low-frequency variability of the Mediterranean sea level, using statistics from a 1/12° resolution ensemble model simulation. The resulting ensemble is assessed against independent observations (by cross-validation), showing good reliability (flat rank histogram). The method also produces a consistent estimate of the model bias and of the observation error variance (mainly representativity error), while the missing prior ensemble variance is shown to be less controlable by the observations, and thus rather computed as a diagnostic. Overall, this application shows the importance of reliable model statistics, and thus the importance of enhancing model simulations to represent all main sources of uncertainty.
- Open Access
- 28 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Reply on RC1
The skill of climate projections depends on the ability of models to reproduce the long-term and low-frequency variability of the system. It is thus important that low-frequency model statistics can be checked against observations. In this paper, a method is proposed to estimate directly the low-frequency component of the ocean variability from native observations using statistics from a prior long-term simulation. It is designed to account for possible model biases and to provide an estimate of the correction required to fit observations. The result is obtained by an MCMC sampler (modified to include localization of the model covariance), which provides an ensemble description of the solution, so that uncertainties can be properly assessed using independent data. This algorithm is shown well suited to work with MPI and GPUs, and efficient enough to solve large-size problems (about 108 variables and 107 observations). The approach is illustrated by the reconstruction of the low-frequency variability of the Mediterranean sea level, using statistics from a 1/12° resolution ensemble model simulation. The resulting ensemble is assessed against independent observations (by cross-validation), showing good reliability (flat rank histogram). The method also produces a consistent estimate of the model bias and of the observation error variance (mainly representativity error), while the missing prior ensemble variance is shown to be less controlable by the observations, and thus rather computed as a diagnostic. Overall, this application shows the importance of reliable model statistics, and thus the importance of enhancing model simulations to represent all main sources of uncertainty.
- 28 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Open AccessReply on RC1
The skill of climate projections depends on the ability of models to reproduce the long-term and low-frequency variability of the system. It is thus important that low-frequency model statistics can be checked against observations. In this paper, a method is proposed to estimate directly the low-frequency component of the ocean variability from native observations using statistics from a prior long-term simulation. It is designed to account for possible model biases and to provide an estimate of the correction required to fit observations. The result is obtained by an MCMC sampler (modified to include localization of the model covariance), which provides an ensemble description of the solution, so that uncertainties can be properly assessed using independent data. This algorithm is shown well suited to work with MPI and GPUs, and efficient enough to solve large-size problems (about 108 variables and 107 observations). The approach is illustrated by the reconstruction of the low-frequency variability of the Mediterranean sea level, using statistics from a 1/12° resolution ensemble model simulation. The resulting ensemble is assessed against independent observations (by cross-validation), showing good reliability (flat rank histogram). The method also produces a consistent estimate of the model bias and of the observation error variance (mainly representativity error), while the missing prior ensemble variance is shown to be less controlable by the observations, and thus rather computed as a diagnostic. Overall, this application shows the importance of reliable model statistics, and thus the importance of enhancing model simulations to represent all main sources of uncertainty.
- Open Access
- 9 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-28
Comment on egusphere-2026-3237
The skill of climate projections depends on the ability of models to reproduce the long-term and low-frequency variability of the system. It is thus important that low-frequency model statistics can be checked against observations. In this paper, a method is proposed to estimate directly the low-frequency component of the ocean variability from native observations using statistics from a prior long-term simulation. It is designed to account for possible model biases and to provide an estimate of the correction required to fit observations. The result is obtained by an MCMC sampler (modified to include localization of the model covariance), which provides an ensemble description of the solution, so that uncertainties can be properly assessed using independent data. This algorithm is shown well suited to work with MPI and GPUs, and efficient enough to solve large-size problems (about 108 variables and 107 observations). The approach is illustrated by the reconstruction of the low-frequency variability of the Mediterranean sea level, using statistics from a 1/12° resolution ensemble model simulation. The resulting ensemble is assessed against independent observations (by cross-validation), showing good reliability (flat rank histogram). The method also produces a consistent estimate of the model bias and of the observation error variance (mainly representativity error), while the missing prior ensemble variance is shown to be less controlable by the observations, and thus rather computed as a diagnostic. Overall, this application shows the importance of reliable model statistics, and thus the importance of enhancing model simulations to represent all main sources of uncertainty.
- 9 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-28
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-3237
The skill of climate projections depends on the ability of models to reproduce the long-term and low-frequency variability of the system. It is thus important that low-frequency model statistics can be checked against observations. In this paper, a method is proposed to estimate directly the low-frequency component of the ocean variability from native observations using statistics from a prior long-term simulation. It is designed to account for possible model biases and to provide an estimate of the correction required to fit observations. The result is obtained by an MCMC sampler (modified to include localization of the model covariance), which provides an ensemble description of the solution, so that uncertainties can be properly assessed using independent data. This algorithm is shown well suited to work with MPI and GPUs, and efficient enough to solve large-size problems (about 108 variables and 107 observations). The approach is illustrated by the reconstruction of the low-frequency variability of the Mediterranean sea level, using statistics from a 1/12° resolution ensemble model simulation. The resulting ensemble is assessed against independent observations (by cross-validation), showing good reliability (flat rank histogram). The method also produces a consistent estimate of the model bias and of the observation error variance (mainly representativity error), while the missing prior ensemble variance is shown to be less controlable by the observations, and thus rather computed as a diagnostic. Overall, this application shows the importance of reliable model statistics, and thus the importance of enhancing model simulations to represent all main sources of uncertainty.
- Open Access
- 31 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-28
Comment on egusphere-2026-3237
The skill of climate projections depends on the ability of models to reproduce the long-term and low-frequency variability of the system. It is thus important that low-frequency model statistics can be checked against observations. In this paper, a method is proposed to estimate directly the low-frequency component of the ocean variability from native observations using statistics from a prior long-term simulation. It is designed to account for possible model biases and to provide an estimate of the correction required to fit observations. The result is obtained by an MCMC sampler (modified to include localization of the model covariance), which provides an ensemble description of the solution, so that uncertainties can be properly assessed using independent data. This algorithm is shown well suited to work with MPI and GPUs, and efficient enough to solve large-size problems (about 108 variables and 107 observations). The approach is illustrated by the reconstruction of the low-frequency variability of the Mediterranean sea level, using statistics from a 1/12° resolution ensemble model simulation. The resulting ensemble is assessed against independent observations (by cross-validation), showing good reliability (flat rank histogram). The method also produces a consistent estimate of the model bias and of the observation error variance (mainly representativity error), while the missing prior ensemble variance is shown to be less controlable by the observations, and thus rather computed as a diagnostic. Overall, this application shows the importance of reliable model statistics, and thus the importance of enhancing model simulations to represent all main sources of uncertainty.
- 31 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-28
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-3237
The skill of climate projections depends on the ability of models to reproduce the long-term and low-frequency variability of the system. It is thus important that low-frequency model statistics can be checked against observations. In this paper, a method is proposed to estimate directly the low-frequency component of the ocean variability from native observations using statistics from a prior long-term simulation. It is designed to account for possible model biases and to provide an estimate of the correction required to fit observations. The result is obtained by an MCMC sampler (modified to include localization of the model covariance), which provides an ensemble description of the solution, so that uncertainties can be properly assessed using independent data. This algorithm is shown well suited to work with MPI and GPUs, and efficient enough to solve large-size problems (about 108 variables and 107 observations). The approach is illustrated by the reconstruction of the low-frequency variability of the Mediterranean sea level, using statistics from a 1/12° resolution ensemble model simulation. The resulting ensemble is assessed against independent observations (by cross-validation), showing good reliability (flat rank histogram). The method also produces a consistent estimate of the model bias and of the observation error variance (mainly representativity error), while the missing prior ensemble variance is shown to be less controlable by the observations, and thus rather computed as a diagnostic. Overall, this application shows the importance of reliable model statistics, and thus the importance of enhancing model simulations to represent all main sources of uncertainty.
- Open Access
- 8 May 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 17 (5)
Link Between Stochastic Grid Perturbation and Location Uncertainty Framework
This paper investigates the relationship between a Stochastic Grid Perturbation (SGP) and Location Uncertainty (LU) in the context of ocean modeling. The LU formulation, which introduces random velocity fluctuations, has shown efficacy in organizing large‐scale flow and replicating long‐term statistical characteristics. SGP was created as a simpler approach which perturbs the computational grid for ensemble members, aiming to simulate small uncertainties in high‐resolution predictability studies. We aim to clarify the link between SGP and LU. After introducing the LU formalism, we derive the SGP method and discuss its connection to LU. Correlated noise in time is introduced in the SGP method to preserve the structure of the original grid. A compensating advection term is shown to preserve LU properties despite the latter correlated noise. Numerical experiments on a 3‐layer Quasi‐Geostrophic model compare various SGP implementations with an explicit LU implementation, highlighting the importance of the compensating advection term to achieve strict equivalence.
- 8 May 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 17 (5)
Open AccessLink Between Stochastic Grid Perturbation and Location Uncertainty Framework
This paper investigates the relationship between a Stochastic Grid Perturbation (SGP) and Location Uncertainty (LU) in the context of ocean modeling. The LU formulation, which introduces random velocity fluctuations, has shown efficacy in organizing large‐scale flow and replicating long‐term statistical characteristics. SGP was created as a simpler approach which perturbs the computational grid for ensemble members, aiming to simulate small uncertainties in high‐resolution predictability studies. We aim to clarify the link between SGP and LU. After introducing the LU formalism, we derive the SGP method and discuss its connection to LU. Correlated noise in time is introduced in the SGP method to preserve the structure of the original grid. A compensating advection term is shown to preserve LU properties despite the latter correlated noise. Numerical experiments on a 3‐layer Quasi‐Geostrophic model compare various SGP implementations with an explicit LU implementation, highlighting the importance of the compensating advection term to achieve strict equivalence.
- Open Access
- 17 July 2024
- Published by Wiley
Link between stochastic grid perturbation and location uncertainty framework
This paper investigates the relationship between a Stochastic Grid Perturbation (SGP) and Location Uncertainty (LU). The LU formulation, which introduces random velocity fluctuations, has shown efficacy in organizing large-scale flow and replicating long-term statistical characteristics. SGP was created as a simpler approach which perturbs the computational grid for ensemble members, aiming to simulate small uncertainties in high-resolution predictability studies. We aim to clarify the link between SGP and LU. After introducing the LU formalism, we derive the SGP method and discuss its connection to LU. Correlated noise in time is introduced in the SGP method to preserve the structure of the original grid. A compensating advection term is shown to preserve LU properties despite the latter correlated noise. Numerical experiments on a 3-layer Quasi-Geostrophic model compare various SGP implementations with an explicit LU implementation, highlighting the importance of the compensating advection term to achieve strict equivalence.
- 17 July 2024
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessLink between stochastic grid perturbation and location uncertainty framework
This paper investigates the relationship between a Stochastic Grid Perturbation (SGP) and Location Uncertainty (LU). The LU formulation, which introduces random velocity fluctuations, has shown efficacy in organizing large-scale flow and replicating long-term statistical characteristics. SGP was created as a simpler approach which perturbs the computational grid for ensemble members, aiming to simulate small uncertainties in high-resolution predictability studies. We aim to clarify the link between SGP and LU. After introducing the LU formalism, we derive the SGP method and discuss its connection to LU. Correlated noise in time is introduced in the SGP method to preserve the structure of the original grid. A compensating advection term is shown to preserve LU properties despite the latter correlated noise. Numerical experiments on a 3-layer Quasi-Geostrophic model compare various SGP implementations with an explicit LU implementation, highlighting the importance of the compensating advection term to achieve strict equivalence.
- Open Access
- 16 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Ocean Science
- Vol. 20 (1) , 155-180
Ensemble analysis and forecast of ecosystem indicators in the North Atlantic using ocean colour observations and prior statistics from a stochastic NEMO–PISCES simulator
This study is anchored in the H2020 SEAMLESS project (https://www.seamlessproject.org, last access: 29 January 2024), which aims to develop ensemble assimilation methods to be implemented in Copernicus Marine Service monitoring and forecasting systems, in order to operationally estimate a set of targeted ecosystem indicators in various regions, including uncertainty estimates. In this paper, a simplified approach is introduced to perform a 4D (space–time) ensemble analysis describing the evolution of the ocean ecosystem. An example application is provided, which covers a limited time period in a limited subregion of the North Atlantic (between 31 and 21∘ W, between 44 and 50.5∘ N, between 15 March and 15 June 2019, at a ∘ and a 1 d resolution). The ensemble analysis is based on prior ensemble statistics from a stochastic NEMO (Nucleus for European Modelling of the Ocean)–PISCES simulator. Ocean colour observations are used as constraints to condition the 4D prior probability distribution. As compared to classic data assimilation, the simplification comes from the decoupling between the forward simulation using the complex modelling system and the update of the 4D ensemble to account for the observation constraint. The shortcomings and possible advantages of this approach for biogeochemical applications are discussed in the paper. The results show that it is possible to produce a multivariate ensemble analysis continuous in time and consistent with the observations. Furthermore, we study how the method can be used to extrapolate analyses calculated from past observations into the future. The resulting 4D ensemble statistical forecast is shown to contain valuable information about the evolution of the ecosystem for a few days after the last observation. However, as a result of the short decorrelation timescale in the prior ensemble, the spread of the ensemble forecast increases quickly with time. Throughout the paper, a special emphasis is given to discussing the statistical reliability of the solution. Two different methods have been applied to perform this 4D statistical analysis and forecast: the analysis step of the ensemble transform Kalman filter (with domain localization) and a Monte Carlo Markov chain (MCMC) sampler (with covariance localization), both enhanced by the application of anamorphosis to the original variables. Despite being very different, the two algorithms produce very similar results, thus providing support to each other's estimates. As shown in the paper, the decoupling of the statistical analysis from the dynamical model allows us to restrict the analysis to a few selected variables and, at the same time, to produce estimates of additional ecological indicators (in our example: phenology, trophic efficiency, downward flux of particulate organic matter). This approach can easily be appended to existing operational systems to focus on dedicated users' requirements, at a small additional cost, as long as a reliable prior ensemble simulation is available. It can also serve as a baseline to compare with the dynamical ensemble forecast and as a possible substitute whenever useful.- 16 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Ocean Science
- Vol. 20 (1) , 155-180
Open AccessEnsemble analysis and forecast of ecosystem indicators in the North Atlantic using ocean colour observations and prior statistics from a stochastic NEMO–PISCES simulator
This study is anchored in the H2020 SEAMLESS project (https://www.seamlessproject.org, last access: 29 January 2024), which aims to develop ensemble assimilation methods to be implemented in Copernicus Marine Service monitoring and forecasting systems, in order to operationally estimate a set of targeted ecosystem indicators in various regions, including uncertainty estimates. In this paper, a simplified approach is introduced to perform a 4D (space–time) ensemble analysis describing the evolution of the ocean ecosystem. An example application is provided, which covers a limited time period in a limited subregion of the North Atlantic (between 31 and 21∘ W, between 44 and 50.5∘ N, between 15 March and 15 June 2019, at a ∘ and a 1 d resolution). The ensemble analysis is based on prior ensemble statistics from a stochastic NEMO (Nucleus for European Modelling of the Ocean)–PISCES simulator. Ocean colour observations are used as constraints to condition the 4D prior probability distribution. As compared to classic data assimilation, the simplification comes from the decoupling between the forward simulation using the complex modelling system and the update of the 4D ensemble to account for the observation constraint. The shortcomings and possible advantages of this approach for biogeochemical applications are discussed in the paper. The results show that it is possible to produce a multivariate ensemble analysis continuous in time and consistent with the observations. Furthermore, we study how the method can be used to extrapolate analyses calculated from past observations into the future. The resulting 4D ensemble statistical forecast is shown to contain valuable information about the evolution of the ecosystem for a few days after the last observation. However, as a result of the short decorrelation timescale in the prior ensemble, the spread of the ensemble forecast increases quickly with time. Throughout the paper, a special emphasis is given to discussing the statistical reliability of the solution. Two different methods have been applied to perform this 4D statistical analysis and forecast: the analysis step of the ensemble transform Kalman filter (with domain localization) and a Monte Carlo Markov chain (MCMC) sampler (with covariance localization), both enhanced by the application of anamorphosis to the original variables. Despite being very different, the two algorithms produce very similar results, thus providing support to each other's estimates. As shown in the paper, the decoupling of the statistical analysis from the dynamical model allows us to restrict the analysis to a few selected variables and, at the same time, to produce estimates of additional ecological indicators (in our example: phenology, trophic efficiency, downward flux of particulate organic matter). This approach can easily be appended to existing operational systems to focus on dedicated users' requirements, at a small additional cost, as long as a reliable prior ensemble simulation is available. It can also serve as a baseline to compare with the dynamical ensemble forecast and as a possible substitute whenever useful. - Open Access
- 7 December 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-38
Reply on RC2
This study is anchored in the H2020 SEAMLESS project (www.seamlessproject.org), which aims to develop ensemble assimilation methods to be implemented in Copernicus Marine Service monitoring and forecasting systems, in order to operationally estimate a set of targeted ecosystem indicators in various regions, including uncertainty estimates. In this paper, a simplified approach is introduced to perform a 4D (space-time) ensemble analysis describing the evolution of the ocean ecosystem. An example application is provided, which covers a limited time period in a limited subregion of the North Atlantic (between 31° W and 21° W, between 44° N and 50.5° N, between March 15 and June 15, 2019, at a 1/4° and a 1 day resolution). The ensemble analysis is based on prior ensemble statistics from a stochastic NEMO/PISCES simulator. Ocean colour observations are used as constraints to condition the 4D prior probability distribution. As compared to classic data assimilation, the simplification comes from the decoupling between the forward simulation using the complex modelling system and the update of the 4D ensemble to account for the observation constraint. The shortcomings and possible advantages of this approach for biogeochemical applications are discussed in the paper. The results show that it is possible to produce a multivariate ensemble analysis continuous in time and consistent with the observations. Furthermore, we study how the method can be used to extrapolate analyses calculated from past observations into the future. The resulting 4D ensemble statistical forecast is shown to contain valuable information about the evolution of the ecosystem for a few days after the last observation. However, as a result of the short decorrelation time scale in the prior ensemble, the spread of the ensemble forecast is increasing quickly with time. Throughout the paper, a special emphasis is given to discussing the statistical reliability of the solution. Two different methods have been applied to perform this 4D statistical analysis and forecast: the analysis step of the Ensemble Transform Kalman Filter (with domain localization) and a Monte Carlo Markov Chain (MCMC) sampler (with covariance localization), both enhanced by the application of anamorphosis to the original variables. Despite being very different, the two algorithms produce very similar results, thus somehow validating each other. As shown in the paper, the decoupling of the statistical analysis from the dynamical model allows us to restrict the analysis to a few selected variables and, at the same time, to produce estimates of additional ecological indicators (in our example: phenology, trophic efficiency, downward flux of particulate organic matter). This approach can easily be appended to existing operational systems to focus on dedicated users' requirements, at small additional cost, as long as a reliable prior ensemble simulation is available. It can also serve as a baseline to compare with the dynamical ensemble forecast, and as a possible substitute whenever useful.
- 7 December 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-38
Open AccessReply on RC2
This study is anchored in the H2020 SEAMLESS project (www.seamlessproject.org), which aims to develop ensemble assimilation methods to be implemented in Copernicus Marine Service monitoring and forecasting systems, in order to operationally estimate a set of targeted ecosystem indicators in various regions, including uncertainty estimates. In this paper, a simplified approach is introduced to perform a 4D (space-time) ensemble analysis describing the evolution of the ocean ecosystem. An example application is provided, which covers a limited time period in a limited subregion of the North Atlantic (between 31° W and 21° W, between 44° N and 50.5° N, between March 15 and June 15, 2019, at a 1/4° and a 1 day resolution). The ensemble analysis is based on prior ensemble statistics from a stochastic NEMO/PISCES simulator. Ocean colour observations are used as constraints to condition the 4D prior probability distribution. As compared to classic data assimilation, the simplification comes from the decoupling between the forward simulation using the complex modelling system and the update of the 4D ensemble to account for the observation constraint. The shortcomings and possible advantages of this approach for biogeochemical applications are discussed in the paper. The results show that it is possible to produce a multivariate ensemble analysis continuous in time and consistent with the observations. Furthermore, we study how the method can be used to extrapolate analyses calculated from past observations into the future. The resulting 4D ensemble statistical forecast is shown to contain valuable information about the evolution of the ecosystem for a few days after the last observation. However, as a result of the short decorrelation time scale in the prior ensemble, the spread of the ensemble forecast is increasing quickly with time. Throughout the paper, a special emphasis is given to discussing the statistical reliability of the solution. Two different methods have been applied to perform this 4D statistical analysis and forecast: the analysis step of the Ensemble Transform Kalman Filter (with domain localization) and a Monte Carlo Markov Chain (MCMC) sampler (with covariance localization), both enhanced by the application of anamorphosis to the original variables. Despite being very different, the two algorithms produce very similar results, thus somehow validating each other. As shown in the paper, the decoupling of the statistical analysis from the dynamical model allows us to restrict the analysis to a few selected variables and, at the same time, to produce estimates of additional ecological indicators (in our example: phenology, trophic efficiency, downward flux of particulate organic matter). This approach can easily be appended to existing operational systems to focus on dedicated users' requirements, at small additional cost, as long as a reliable prior ensemble simulation is available. It can also serve as a baseline to compare with the dynamical ensemble forecast, and as a possible substitute whenever useful.
- Open Access
- 7 December 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-38
Reply on RC1
This study is anchored in the H2020 SEAMLESS project (www.seamlessproject.org), which aims to develop ensemble assimilation methods to be implemented in Copernicus Marine Service monitoring and forecasting systems, in order to operationally estimate a set of targeted ecosystem indicators in various regions, including uncertainty estimates. In this paper, a simplified approach is introduced to perform a 4D (space-time) ensemble analysis describing the evolution of the ocean ecosystem. An example application is provided, which covers a limited time period in a limited subregion of the North Atlantic (between 31° W and 21° W, between 44° N and 50.5° N, between March 15 and June 15, 2019, at a 1/4° and a 1 day resolution). The ensemble analysis is based on prior ensemble statistics from a stochastic NEMO/PISCES simulator. Ocean colour observations are used as constraints to condition the 4D prior probability distribution. As compared to classic data assimilation, the simplification comes from the decoupling between the forward simulation using the complex modelling system and the update of the 4D ensemble to account for the observation constraint. The shortcomings and possible advantages of this approach for biogeochemical applications are discussed in the paper. The results show that it is possible to produce a multivariate ensemble analysis continuous in time and consistent with the observations. Furthermore, we study how the method can be used to extrapolate analyses calculated from past observations into the future. The resulting 4D ensemble statistical forecast is shown to contain valuable information about the evolution of the ecosystem for a few days after the last observation. However, as a result of the short decorrelation time scale in the prior ensemble, the spread of the ensemble forecast is increasing quickly with time. Throughout the paper, a special emphasis is given to discussing the statistical reliability of the solution. Two different methods have been applied to perform this 4D statistical analysis and forecast: the analysis step of the Ensemble Transform Kalman Filter (with domain localization) and a Monte Carlo Markov Chain (MCMC) sampler (with covariance localization), both enhanced by the application of anamorphosis to the original variables. Despite being very different, the two algorithms produce very similar results, thus somehow validating each other. As shown in the paper, the decoupling of the statistical analysis from the dynamical model allows us to restrict the analysis to a few selected variables and, at the same time, to produce estimates of additional ecological indicators (in our example: phenology, trophic efficiency, downward flux of particulate organic matter). This approach can easily be appended to existing operational systems to focus on dedicated users' requirements, at small additional cost, as long as a reliable prior ensemble simulation is available. It can also serve as a baseline to compare with the dynamical ensemble forecast, and as a possible substitute whenever useful.
- 7 December 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-38
Open AccessReply on RC1
This study is anchored in the H2020 SEAMLESS project (www.seamlessproject.org), which aims to develop ensemble assimilation methods to be implemented in Copernicus Marine Service monitoring and forecasting systems, in order to operationally estimate a set of targeted ecosystem indicators in various regions, including uncertainty estimates. In this paper, a simplified approach is introduced to perform a 4D (space-time) ensemble analysis describing the evolution of the ocean ecosystem. An example application is provided, which covers a limited time period in a limited subregion of the North Atlantic (between 31° W and 21° W, between 44° N and 50.5° N, between March 15 and June 15, 2019, at a 1/4° and a 1 day resolution). The ensemble analysis is based on prior ensemble statistics from a stochastic NEMO/PISCES simulator. Ocean colour observations are used as constraints to condition the 4D prior probability distribution. As compared to classic data assimilation, the simplification comes from the decoupling between the forward simulation using the complex modelling system and the update of the 4D ensemble to account for the observation constraint. The shortcomings and possible advantages of this approach for biogeochemical applications are discussed in the paper. The results show that it is possible to produce a multivariate ensemble analysis continuous in time and consistent with the observations. Furthermore, we study how the method can be used to extrapolate analyses calculated from past observations into the future. The resulting 4D ensemble statistical forecast is shown to contain valuable information about the evolution of the ecosystem for a few days after the last observation. However, as a result of the short decorrelation time scale in the prior ensemble, the spread of the ensemble forecast is increasing quickly with time. Throughout the paper, a special emphasis is given to discussing the statistical reliability of the solution. Two different methods have been applied to perform this 4D statistical analysis and forecast: the analysis step of the Ensemble Transform Kalman Filter (with domain localization) and a Monte Carlo Markov Chain (MCMC) sampler (with covariance localization), both enhanced by the application of anamorphosis to the original variables. Despite being very different, the two algorithms produce very similar results, thus somehow validating each other. As shown in the paper, the decoupling of the statistical analysis from the dynamical model allows us to restrict the analysis to a few selected variables and, at the same time, to produce estimates of additional ecological indicators (in our example: phenology, trophic efficiency, downward flux of particulate organic matter). This approach can easily be appended to existing operational systems to focus on dedicated users' requirements, at small additional cost, as long as a reliable prior ensemble simulation is available. It can also serve as a baseline to compare with the dynamical ensemble forecast, and as a possible substitute whenever useful.