Martin O'NEill
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Martin O'NEill has a total of 19 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Anke Schwittay
School of Global Studies, University of Sussex
1 shared publication Christian Schemmel
Lecturer in political theory at the Manchester Centre for Political Theory at the University of Manchester
1 shared publicationDavid Malone
1 shared publication- Emily McTernan
Department of Political Science/School of Public Policy, University College London
1 shared publication - Fabian Muniesa
Mines ParisTech at PSL University, France
1 shared publication Fabian Schuppert
Lecturer at the School of History, Anthropology, Philosophy and Politics at Queen's University Belfast
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Open Library of the Humanities in Political Philosophy
- Vol. 2 (1)
"We Cease to be Mere Fragments": Justice, Alienation, Liberalism and Socialism
What is the relationship between liberalism and socialism? Partisans of each political tradition often focus on the shortcomings of the other, with socialists charging liberals with defending merely formal ideas of freedom, which lead them to a naïve defence of the status quo, while liberals often view socialists as excessively utopian, and as blind to the ways in which collective forms of economic organisation can lead to oppression. This article examines the prospects for a more eirenic understanding of the relationship between liberalism and socialism, by means of examining the significance of the main points of contention between canonical representatives of each tradition, Rawls and Marx. By examining questions relating to the limits of liberal rights, the problems of alienation and self-realisation in work, the place of distributive principles in socialist views, and the possibility of a society beyond justice, the article defends a partial reconciliation between these two traditions.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Open Library of the Humanities in Political Philosophy
- Vol. 2 (1)
Top Cited PapersOpen Access"We Cease to be Mere Fragments": Justice, Alienation, Liberalism and Socialism
What is the relationship between liberalism and socialism? Partisans of each political tradition often focus on the shortcomings of the other, with socialists charging liberals with defending merely formal ideas of freedom, which lead them to a naïve defence of the status quo, while liberals often view socialists as excessively utopian, and as blind to the ways in which collective forms of economic organisation can lead to oppression. This article examines the prospects for a more eirenic understanding of the relationship between liberalism and socialism, by means of examining the significance of the main points of contention between canonical representatives of each tradition, Rawls and Marx. By examining questions relating to the limits of liberal rights, the problems of alienation and self-realisation in work, the place of distributive principles in socialist views, and the possibility of a society beyond justice, the article defends a partial reconciliation between these two traditions.
- Open Access
- 26 January 2024
- Published by Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics in Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics
- Vol. 16 (2) , 136–166
Public Provision in Democratic Societies
If we hope to see values of equality and democracy embodied in our societies’ institutions, then we have a range of good reasons to favor expansive public provision of goods and services, and to oppose many forms of privatization. While Joseph Heath is right to argue that there are at least some forms of ‘anodyne privatization’, and while he is also right to argue for a more nuanced philosophical debate about the different dimensions of choice between forms of public and private provision, Heath fails to register various regards in which private provision can undermine these central public values. We often have strong egalitarian and democratic reasons to protect zones of decommodification; to resist the imposition of user-charges; and to favor insourcing and direct public procurement over various forms of outsourcing of public services. Public libraries provide a totemic illustration of some of the deep virtues of collective public provision in democratic societies. Overall, our reasons to reject privatization are stronger and more diverse than theorists such as Heath might have supposed.
- 26 January 2024
- Published by Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics in Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics
- Vol. 16 (2) , 136–166
Open AccessPublic Provision in Democratic Societies
If we hope to see values of equality and democracy embodied in our societies’ institutions, then we have a range of good reasons to favor expansive public provision of goods and services, and to oppose many forms of privatization. While Joseph Heath is right to argue that there are at least some forms of ‘anodyne privatization’, and while he is also right to argue for a more nuanced philosophical debate about the different dimensions of choice between forms of public and private provision, Heath fails to register various regards in which private provision can undermine these central public values. We often have strong egalitarian and democratic reasons to protect zones of decommodification; to resist the imposition of user-charges; and to favor insourcing and direct public procurement over various forms of outsourcing of public services. Public libraries provide a totemic illustration of some of the deep virtues of collective public provision in democratic societies. Overall, our reasons to reject privatization are stronger and more diverse than theorists such as Heath might have supposed.
- 24 March 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 81-90
Domestic Abuse Protection Notices and Orders, Definitions, Breaches, and the Police Role (Sections 22–27)
This chapter elaborates on the correlation between domestic abuse protection notices and orders, definitions, breaches, and police roles. It explains the design of notices provides short-term breathing space for domestic violence victims to allow them to consider their next move following an incident. The Domestic Abuse Act (DAA) 2021 creates new notices and orders that replace the existing domestic violence protection notice (DVPN) and domestic violence protection order (DVPO). Meanwhile, unlike the DAPN, the Domestic Abuse Protection Order (DAPO) can include both prohibitions and requirements. The chapter elaborates on the guidance to police officers which suggests prohibitions that involve prohibiting access to premises or setting clear geographical restrictions such as how close to the premises the perpetrator is allowed.
- 24 March 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 81-90
Domestic Abuse Protection Notices and Orders, Definitions, Breaches, and the Police Role (Sections 22–27)
This chapter elaborates on the correlation between domestic abuse protection notices and orders, definitions, breaches, and police roles. It explains the design of notices provides short-term breathing space for domestic violence victims to allow them to consider their next move following an incident. The Domestic Abuse Act (DAA) 2021 creates new notices and orders that replace the existing domestic violence protection notice (DVPN) and domestic violence protection order (DVPO). Meanwhile, unlike the DAPN, the Domestic Abuse Protection Order (DAPO) can include both prohibitions and requirements. The chapter elaborates on the guidance to police officers which suggests prohibitions that involve prohibiting access to premises or setting clear geographical restrictions such as how close to the premises the perpetrator is allowed.
- 24 March 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 217-226
Schedules
This chapter looks into the provisions concerning the provisions of remands, consequential amendments, and offences committed outside the UK. Further provisions in Section 40 allow for remand in custody or on bail ad provide time scales in defined circumstances. England and Wales' criminal law jurisdiction was extended to have extra-territorial effect concerning the offence enacted in accordance with the Istanbul Convention's Article 34, which requires the UK to ensure that the intentional conduct by a UK national. The chapter discusses the extension of territorial jurisdiction through the amendments of the Protection from Harassment Order (Northern Ireland) 1997, the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 and the Sexual Offences (Scotland) Act 2009. It also considers the consequential amendments of provisions concerned with strangulation and suffocation offences.
- 24 March 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 217-226
Schedules
This chapter looks into the provisions concerning the provisions of remands, consequential amendments, and offences committed outside the UK. Further provisions in Section 40 allow for remand in custody or on bail ad provide time scales in defined circumstances. England and Wales' criminal law jurisdiction was extended to have extra-territorial effect concerning the offence enacted in accordance with the Istanbul Convention's Article 34, which requires the UK to ensure that the intentional conduct by a UK national. The chapter discusses the extension of territorial jurisdiction through the amendments of the Protection from Harassment Order (Northern Ireland) 1997, the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 and the Sexual Offences (Scotland) Act 2009. It also considers the consequential amendments of provisions concerned with strangulation and suffocation offences.
- 24 March 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 99-106
Breaches of Orders, Notification, and Police Powers (Sections 39–43)
This chapter explores the provision of breaches of orders, notification, and police powers. It clarifies that the domestic violence protection order (DVPO) did not carry any criminal sanction upon breach. However, unlike the DVPO, a breach of the domestic abuse protection order (DAPO) can result in a conviction for a criminal offence with a maximum penalty of six months imprisonment or a fine. According to government minister Victoria Atkins, the severity of the consequences aims to put pressure on the perpetrator to comply and discourage non-compliance. The chapter highlights the consequences of failure to notify and the subsequent notification requirements. It considers the court's discretion with breaches due to concerns that some victims may be deterred from reporting a breach because of the ultimate criminal sanction.
- 24 March 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 99-106
Breaches of Orders, Notification, and Police Powers (Sections 39–43)
This chapter explores the provision of breaches of orders, notification, and police powers. It clarifies that the domestic violence protection order (DVPO) did not carry any criminal sanction upon breach. However, unlike the DVPO, a breach of the domestic abuse protection order (DAPO) can result in a conviction for a criminal offence with a maximum penalty of six months imprisonment or a fine. According to government minister Victoria Atkins, the severity of the consequences aims to put pressure on the perpetrator to comply and discourage non-compliance. The chapter highlights the consequences of failure to notify and the subsequent notification requirements. It considers the court's discretion with breaches due to concerns that some victims may be deterred from reporting a breach because of the ultimate criminal sanction.
- 23 March 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 181-194
Offenders: Police and Prosecution (Sections 75–77)
This chapter explores Sections 75 to 77 of the Domestic Abuse Act (DAA) 2021 that revolve around police and prosecution. The strategy for prosecution and management of offenders arose following criticism that perpetrators were absent from the domestic abuse narrative. The chapter considers the function and features of the Domestic Abuse, Stalking and Harassment (DASH) tool, MAPPA (Multi-agency public protection arrangements) guidance, and SPECSS+ (Separation, pregnancy, escalation, community issues, stalking and sexual assault) model. It also discusses the polygraph conditions for offenders released on licence. Meanwhile, Section 77 focuses on the guidance about the disclosure of information by UK police forces.
- 23 March 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 181-194
Offenders: Police and Prosecution (Sections 75–77)
This chapter explores Sections 75 to 77 of the Domestic Abuse Act (DAA) 2021 that revolve around police and prosecution. The strategy for prosecution and management of offenders arose following criticism that perpetrators were absent from the domestic abuse narrative. The chapter considers the function and features of the Domestic Abuse, Stalking and Harassment (DASH) tool, MAPPA (Multi-agency public protection arrangements) guidance, and SPECSS+ (Separation, pregnancy, escalation, community issues, stalking and sexual assault) model. It also discusses the polygraph conditions for offenders released on licence. Meanwhile, Section 77 focuses on the guidance about the disclosure of information by UK police forces.
- Open Access
- 24 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Philosophy
- Vol. 41 (2) , 306-329
Work, Justice, and Collective Capital Institutions: Revisiting Rudolf Meidner and the Case for Wage‐Earner Funds
This article makes the case for a specific variety of what we call Collective Capital Institutions (CCIs), by returning to the idea of Wage‐Earner Funds (WEFs) – a 1970s Swedish policy proposal designed gradually to shift ownership and control over parts of the economy to democratically controlled institutions. We identify two attractive rationales in favour of such a scheme and argue that both can fruitfully be transposed to the current worldwide economic situation. The egalitarian rationale is that WEFs could help in the pursuit of equality by giving a wider set of people a stake in collectively owned companies and a right to their profits. The democratic rationale is that WEFs redistribute not only these profits, but also the power over economic decisions made within companies. We then contrast such schemes for collective capital ownership with the similar but much more privatised proposals set out in, for instance, John Rawls's idea of a ‘property‐owning democracy’. We argue that CCIs ultimately are more likely to contribute to the development of the ‘sense of justice’ within society that is needed for a stable just society. We conclude that CCIs deserve a great deal more exploration in academic and political discussions of egalitarian economic systems.
- 24 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Philosophy
- Vol. 41 (2) , 306-329
Open AccessWork, Justice, and Collective Capital Institutions: Revisiting Rudolf Meidner and the Case for Wage‐Earner Funds
This article makes the case for a specific variety of what we call Collective Capital Institutions (CCIs), by returning to the idea of Wage‐Earner Funds (WEFs) – a 1970s Swedish policy proposal designed gradually to shift ownership and control over parts of the economy to democratically controlled institutions. We identify two attractive rationales in favour of such a scheme and argue that both can fruitfully be transposed to the current worldwide economic situation. The egalitarian rationale is that WEFs could help in the pursuit of equality by giving a wider set of people a stake in collectively owned companies and a right to their profits. The democratic rationale is that WEFs redistribute not only these profits, but also the power over economic decisions made within companies. We then contrast such schemes for collective capital ownership with the similar but much more privatised proposals set out in, for instance, John Rawls's idea of a ‘property‐owning democracy’. We argue that CCIs ultimately are more likely to contribute to the development of the ‘sense of justice’ within society that is needed for a stable just society. We conclude that CCIs deserve a great deal more exploration in academic and political discussions of egalitarian economic systems.
- 4 April 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement
- Vol. 91, 185-212
Radical Democratic Inclusion: Why We Should Lower the Voting Age to 12
Democratic societies such as the United Kingdom have come to fail their young citizens, often sacrificing their interests in a political process that gives much greater weight to the preferences and interests of older citizens. Against this background of intergenerational injustice, this article presents the case for a shift in the political system in the direction of radical democratic inclusion of younger citizens, through reducing the voting age to 12. This change in the voting age can be justified directly, with reference to the status, interests, and capacities of younger citizens, and it can also be justified as a remedy to existing forms of intergenerational injustice. This change in the voting age would require a parallel transformation in the role of secondary schools as part of the ‘critical infrastructure' of a democratic society, which would be part of a broader shift towards a more genuinely democratic political culture. The proposal is defended against less radical alternatives (such as votes at 16) and more radical alternatives (such as votes for younger children). The article concludes with some reflections on democracy and intergenerational justice in light of the Covid pandemic and the climate emergency.
- 4 April 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement
- Vol. 91, 185-212
Radical Democratic Inclusion: Why We Should Lower the Voting Age to 12
Democratic societies such as the United Kingdom have come to fail their young citizens, often sacrificing their interests in a political process that gives much greater weight to the preferences and interests of older citizens. Against this background of intergenerational injustice, this article presents the case for a shift in the political system in the direction of radical democratic inclusion of younger citizens, through reducing the voting age to 12. This change in the voting age can be justified directly, with reference to the status, interests, and capacities of younger citizens, and it can also be justified as a remedy to existing forms of intergenerational injustice. This change in the voting age would require a parallel transformation in the role of secondary schools as part of the ‘critical infrastructure' of a democratic society, which would be part of a broader shift towards a more genuinely democratic political culture. The proposal is defended against less radical alternatives (such as votes at 16) and more radical alternatives (such as votes for younger children). The article concludes with some reflections on democracy and intergenerational justice in light of the Covid pandemic and the climate emergency.
- Open Access
- 30 December 2021
- Published by Corporacion Filosofia y Sociedad in Mutatis Mutandis: Revista Internacional de Filosofía
- Vol. 1 (17) , 67-99
Justicia social y sistemas económicos: sobre Rawls, socialismo democrático y alternativas al capitalismo
La preocupación central del presente ensayo es la pregunta por cuál es el sistema económico que se necesitaría para realizar los principios de justicia social elaborados por John Rawls. Hasta este punto, los debates sobre la democracia de propietarios (property-owning democracy) y socialismo liberal (liberal socialism) han sido tratados de manera esquemática en diversos aspectos y, por ello, han errado en identificar algunos de los problemas más importantes respecto a las relaciones entre justicia social y sistemas e instituciones económicas. En general, lo que está en juego entre sistemas económicos capitalistas y socialistas no se identifica con una simple decisión unidimensional, sino que más bien con un rango de opciones dentro de un espectro de distintas dimensiones. De esta manera, este ensayo tiene un objetivo dual: en primer lugar, busca proveer de consideraciones más sofisticadas en este territorio normativo, de la misma forma que pretende mostrar cómo todas las cuestiones relativas a la economía democrática, desmercantilización y límites de los mercados, así como el rol de la planificación democrática de la economía, levantan preguntas sobre la justicia que no se encuentran bien capturadas por la óptica que centra dichos problemas meramente en la pregunta por la propiedad. En segundo lugar, su propósito es mostrar cómo la defensa del socialismo democrático puede ser desarrollada a partir de fundamentos rawlsianos de forma tal que pueda ser sensible a las relaciones normativas entre el liberalismo igualitario rawlsiano y las preocupaciones del pensamiento político socialista, de manera que atienda cuidadosamente a los distintos tipos de elementos institucionales que una sociedad democrática estable y justa requeriría. Considerando estos objetivos conjuntamente, la esperanza es que podamos avanzar hacia un debate más enriquecido respecto de las vías en que la realización de las instituciones socialistas democráticas pueda verse como un requerimiento de la justicia social.
- 30 December 2021
- Published by Corporacion Filosofia y Sociedad in Mutatis Mutandis: Revista Internacional de Filosofía
- Vol. 1 (17) , 67-99
Open AccessJusticia social y sistemas económicos: sobre Rawls, socialismo democrático y alternativas al capitalismo
La preocupación central del presente ensayo es la pregunta por cuál es el sistema económico que se necesitaría para realizar los principios de justicia social elaborados por John Rawls. Hasta este punto, los debates sobre la democracia de propietarios (property-owning democracy) y socialismo liberal (liberal socialism) han sido tratados de manera esquemática en diversos aspectos y, por ello, han errado en identificar algunos de los problemas más importantes respecto a las relaciones entre justicia social y sistemas e instituciones económicas. En general, lo que está en juego entre sistemas económicos capitalistas y socialistas no se identifica con una simple decisión unidimensional, sino que más bien con un rango de opciones dentro de un espectro de distintas dimensiones. De esta manera, este ensayo tiene un objetivo dual: en primer lugar, busca proveer de consideraciones más sofisticadas en este territorio normativo, de la misma forma que pretende mostrar cómo todas las cuestiones relativas a la economía democrática, desmercantilización y límites de los mercados, así como el rol de la planificación democrática de la economía, levantan preguntas sobre la justicia que no se encuentran bien capturadas por la óptica que centra dichos problemas meramente en la pregunta por la propiedad. En segundo lugar, su propósito es mostrar cómo la defensa del socialismo democrático puede ser desarrollada a partir de fundamentos rawlsianos de forma tal que pueda ser sensible a las relaciones normativas entre el liberalismo igualitario rawlsiano y las preocupaciones del pensamiento político socialista, de manera que atienda cuidadosamente a los distintos tipos de elementos institucionales que una sociedad democrática estable y justa requeriría. Considerando estos objetivos conjuntamente, la esperanza es que podamos avanzar hacia un debate más enriquecido respecto de las vías en que la realización de las instituciones socialistas democráticas pueda verse como un requerimiento de la justicia social.
- 21 June 2021
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 47 (7) , 482-483
Genetic information, social justice, and risk-sharing institutions
- 21 June 2021
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 47 (7) , 482-483
Genetic information, social justice, and risk-sharing institutions