ODOlivia Daub

Olivia Daub

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Olivia Daub has a total of 32 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Why Did You Use That Test? Exploring Speech-Language Pathologists' Clinical Decision Making in Bilingual Language and Literacy Assessment

    by Emily Wood, Mariya Kika, Olivia Daub, Monika Molnar

    Purpose: Our overarching goal is to advance our understanding of clinical decision-making processes in bilingual language and literacy assessment. When evaluating bilingual children, speech-language pathologists (SLPs) use static norm-referenced assessments (SAs) developed for English monolinguals more frequently than less-biased dynamic assessments (DAs). To date, no research has considered why SLPs use SAs over DAs or examined SLPs' conceptualization of validity beyond knowledge of psychometrics. In this study, we explore factors that affect SLPs' choice and use of assessments and how clinicians conceptualize and employ validity through the lens of modern validity frameworks. Method: Canadian SLPs ( N = 21) participated in semistructured interviews, using a guide informed by the Theoretical Domains Framework and Kane's Validity Framework. Reflexive thematic analysis was used to generate themes. Results: Clinicians rarely report using “dynamic assessment” but did “assess dynamically” by incorporating teaching in testing. When assessing oral language, SLPs acknowledged that using SAs with bilinguals may be inappropriate but that they continue to do primarily because scores from these measures are necessary for diagnosis and accessing services. To contend with this friction between clinical beliefs and workplace requirements, most SLPs report caveats alongside SA scores to contextualize findings. Though individual clinical knowledge of psychometrics and validity in assessment varies, systemic issues play a key role in perpetuating current assessment practices with bilinguals. Finally, bilingual literacy assessment practices differ. Clinicians use a wider variety of assessments and rely less on scores to achieve desired outcomes for students. Conclusions: Clinical decision making in bilingual language and literacy assessment is influenced by both individual and contextual factors. Accordingly, efforts to shift practice patterns cannot solely focus on individual clinical knowledge but must also examine and address these systemic issues. Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.29474237


  • Open Access

    Why did you use that test? Exploring speech-language pathologists clinical decision-making in bilingual language and literacy assessment

    by Emily Wood, Mariya Kika, Olivia Daub, Monika Molnar

    Purpose: Our overarching goal is to advance our understanding of clinical decision-making processes in bilingual language and literacy assessment. When evaluating bilingual children, speech-language pathologists (SLPs) use static norm-referenced assessments (SAs) developed for English monolinguals more frequently than less biased dynamic assessments (DAs). To date, no research has considered why SLPs use SAs over DAs or examined SLPs’ conceptualization of validity beyond knowledge of psychometrics. In this study we explore factors that affect SLPs’ choice and use of assessments and how clinicians conceptualize and employ validity through the lens of modern validity frameworks. Method: Canadian SLPs (n=21) participated in semi-structured interviews, using a guide informed by the Theoretical Domains frameworks and Kane’s Validity framework. Reflexive thematic analysis was used to generate themes. Results: Clinicians rarely report using “dynamic assessment” but did “assess dynamically” by incorporating teaching in testing. When assessing oral language, SLPs acknowledged that using SAs with bilinguals may be inappropriate, but that they continue to do primarily because scores from these measures are necessary for diagnosis and accessing services. To contend with this friction between clinical beliefs and workplace requirements, most SLPs report caveats alongside SA scores SAs to contextualize findings. Though individual clinical knowledge of psychometrics and validity in assessment varies, systemic issues play a key role in perpetuating current assessment practices with bilinguals. Finally, bilingual literacy assessment practices differ. Clinicians use a wider variety of assessments and rely less on scores to achieve desired outcomes for students. Conclusion: Clinical decision-making in bilingual language and literacy assessment is influenced by both individual and contextual factors. Accordingly, efforts to shift practice patterns cannot solely focus on individual clinical knowledge but must also examine and address these systemic issues.

  • Open Access

    Evaluating the quality of research co-production: Research Quality Plus for Co-Production (RQ + 4 Co-Pro)

    by Robert K. D. McLean, Fred Carden, Alice B. Aiken, Rebecca Armstrong, Judy Bray, Christine E. Cassidy, Olivia Daub, Erica Di Ruggiero, Leslie A. Fierro, Michelle Gagnon, et al.

    Background: Co-production is an umbrella term used to describe the process of generating knowledge through partnerships between researchers and those who will use or benefit from research. Multiple advantages of research co-production have been hypothesized, and in some cases documented, in both the academic and practice record. However, there are significant gaps in understanding how to evaluate the quality of co-production. This gap in rigorous evaluation undermines the potential of both co-production and co-producers. Methods: This research tests the relevance and utility of a novel evaluation framework: Research Quality Plus for Co-Production (RQ + 4 Co-Pro). Following a co-production approach ourselves, our team collaborated to develop study objectives, questions, analysis, and results sharing strategies. We used a dyadic field-test design to execute RQ + 4 Co-Pro evaluations amongst 18 independently recruited subject matter experts. We used standardized reporting templates and qualitative interviews to collect data from field-test participants, and thematic assessment and deliberative dialogue for analysis. Main limitations include that field-test participation included only health research projects and health researchers and this will limit perspective included in the study, and, that our own co-production team does not include all potential perspectives that may add value to this work. Results: The field test surfaced strong support for the relevance and utility of RQ + 4 Co-Pro as an evaluation approach and framework. Research participants shared opportunities for fine-tuning language and criteria within the prototype version, but also, for alternative uses and users of RQ + 4 Co-Pro. All research participants suggested RQ + 4 Co-Pro offered an opportunity for improving how co-production is evaluated and advanced. This facilitated our revision and publication herein of a field-tested RQ + 4 Co-Pro Framework and Assessment Instrument. Conclusion: Evaluation is necessary for understanding and improving co-production, and, for ensuring co-production delivers on its promise of better health.. RQ + 4 Co-Pro provides a practical evaluation approach and framework that we invite co-producers and stewards of co-production—including the funders, publishers, and universities who increasingly encourage socially relevant research—to study, adapt, and apply.


  • Open Access

    Evaluating research co-production: protocol for the Research Quality Plus for Co-Production (RQ+ 4 Co-Pro) framework

    by Robert K. D. McLean, Fred Carden, Ian D. Graham, Alice B. Aiken, Rebecca Armstrong, Judy Bray, Christine E. Cassidy, Olivia Daub, Erica Di Ruggiero, Leslie A. Fierro, et al.

    Background: Research co-production is an umbrella term used to describe research users and researchers working together to generate knowledge. Research co-production is used to create knowledge that is relevant to current challenges and to increase uptake of that knowledge into practice, programs, products, and/or policy. Yet, rigorous theories and methods to assess the quality of co-production are limited. Here we describe a framework for assessing the quality of research co-production—Research Quality Plus for Co-Production (RQ+ 4 Co-Pro)—and outline our field test of this approach.Methods: Using a co-production approach, we aim to field test the relevance and utility of the RQ+ 4 Co-Pro framework. To do so, we will recruit participants who have led research co-production projects from the international Integrated Knowledge Translation Research Network. We aim to sample 16 to 20 co-production project leads, assign these participants to dyadic groups (8 to 10 dyads), train each participant in the RQ+ 4 Co-Pro framework using deliberative workshops and oversee a simulation assessment exercise using RQ+ 4 Co-Pro within dyadic groups. To study this experience, we use a qualitative design to collect participant demographic information and project demographic information and will use in-depth semi-structured interviews to collect data related to the experience each participant has using the RQ+ 4 Co-Pro framework.Discussion: This study will yield knowledge about a new way to assess research co-production. Specifically, it will address the relevance and utility of using RQ+ 4 Co-Pro, a framework that includes context as an inseparable component of research, identifies dimensions of quality matched to the aims of co-production, and applies a systematic and transferable evaluative method for reaching conclusions. This is a needed area of innovation for research co-production to reach its full potential. The findings may benefit co-producers interested in understanding the quality of their work, but also other stewards of research co-production. Accordingly, we undertake this study as a co-production team representing multiple perspectives from across the research enterprise, such as funders, journal editors, university administrators, and government and health organization leaders.


  • Adopting a Conceptual Validity Framework for Testing in Speech-Language Pathology

    by Olivia Daub, Barbara Jane Cunningham, Marlene P. Bagatto, Andrew M. Johnson, Elaine Y. Kwok, Rachael E. Smyth, Janis Oram Cardy

    Purpose: Limited evidence-based guidelines for test selection continue to result in inconsistency in test use and interpretation in speech-language pathology. A major barrier is the lack of explicit and consistent adoption of a validity framework by our field. In this viewpoint, we argue that adopting the conceptual validity framework in the Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing (American Educational Research Association et al., 2014) would support both the development of more meaningful and feasible clinical tests and more appropriate use and interpretation of tests in speech-language pathology. Method: We describe and evaluate the Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing (American Educational Research Association et al., 2014) validity framework and consider its relevance to speech-language pathology. We describe how the validity framework could be integrated into clinical practice and include examples of how it could be applied to support common clinical decisions. We evaluate the costs and benefits of adopting this framework, from the perspectives of speech-language pathologists, clients, and test developers. Results: The Standards' validity framework clarifies complex validity issues by shifting the focus of validity from tests to the decisions speech-language pathologists make based on test results. By focusing on decisions, the framework requires critical evaluation of test use, rather than evaluating tests against sets of criteria. Adopting this framework has the potential for appreciable improvement in the way tests are used and valued across our profession. Conclusions: Speech-language pathologists, test developers, and clients will benefit from improved evidence-based assessment practices. It is recommended that regulators, test developers, professional associations, universities, and researchers adopt the framework and endorse it as best practice moving forward. This viewpoint proposes a series of first steps toward supporting uptake of the framework into research and practice.


  • A Comment on Test Validation: The Importance of the Clinical Perspective

    by Olivia Daub, Elizabeth Skarakis-Doyle, Marlene P. Bagatto, Andrew M. Johnson, Janis Oram Cardy

    Purpose: The misuse of standardized assessments has been a long-standing concern in speech-language pathology and traditionally viewed as an issue of clinician competency and training. The purpose of this article is to consider the contribution of communication breakdowns between test developers and the end users to this issue. Method: We considered the misuse of standardized assessments through the lens of the 2-communities theory, in which standardized tests are viewed as a product developed in 1 community (researchers/test developers) to be used by another community (frontline clinicians). Under this view, optimal test development involves a conversation to which both parties bring unique expertise and perspectives. Results: Consideration of the interpretations that standardized tests are typically validated to support revealed a mismatch between these and the interpretations and decisions that speech-language pathologists typically need to make. Test development using classical test theory, which underpins many of the tests in our field, contributes to this mismatch. Application of item response theory could better equip clinicians with the psychometric evidence to support the interpretations they desire but is not commonly found in the standardized tests used by speech-language pathologists. Conclusions: Advocacy and insistence on the consideration of clinical perspectives and decision making in the test validation process is a necessary part of our role. In improving the nature of the statistical evidence reported in standardized assessments, we can ensure these tools are appropriate to fulfill our professional obligations in a clinically feasible way.