Maria Pombo
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Maria Pombo has a total of 19 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Denis G. Pelli
Department of Psychology, New York University, New York, NY, USA
6 shared publications - Carlos Velasco
BI Norwegian Business School , Oslo
2 shared publications Denis G. Pelli
Department of Psychology, New York University, New York, NY, USA
2 shared publicationsAenne A. Brielmann
Department of Computational Neuroscience, Max-Planck Institute for Biological Cybernetics, Tübingen, Germany
1 shared publication- Aenne A. Brielmann
Max Planck Institute for Biological Cybernetics
1 shared publication Aleksandra Igdalova
Department of Psychology, Goldsmiths, University of London, London, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 18 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology
- Vol. 79 (3) , 589-611
When and how visual aesthetic features influence approach–avoidance motivated behavior
For decades, researchers have explored the relationship between aesthetic features such as symmetry and complexity and preference. Likewise, philosophers and psychologists alike have pondered the differences between preference and behavior. Nevertheless, little is known about the relationship between aesthetic preference and motivation. Using an online approach–avoidance motivation task, we compare the reaction times between congruent (aesthetic preference + approach) and incongruent (aesthetic preference + avoidance) conditions. In Experiment 1, we explore the relationship between symmetry and complexity and approach–avoidance motivated behavior. In Experiment 2, we distinguish the mechanisms in play in the relationship by manipulating presentation and decision-making time. In Experiment 3, we assess the generalizability of the results beyond abstract graphical patterns. Overall, our research advances knowledge of the relationship between aesthetic preferences for features like symmetry and complexity and approach–avoidance motivation, and it has implications for fields such as marketing.
- 18 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology
- Vol. 79 (3) , 589-611
When and how visual aesthetic features influence approach–avoidance motivated behavior
For decades, researchers have explored the relationship between aesthetic features such as symmetry and complexity and preference. Likewise, philosophers and psychologists alike have pondered the differences between preference and behavior. Nevertheless, little is known about the relationship between aesthetic preference and motivation. Using an online approach–avoidance motivation task, we compare the reaction times between congruent (aesthetic preference + approach) and incongruent (aesthetic preference + avoidance) conditions. In Experiment 1, we explore the relationship between symmetry and complexity and approach–avoidance motivated behavior. In Experiment 2, we distinguish the mechanisms in play in the relationship by manipulating presentation and decision-making time. In Experiment 3, we assess the generalizability of the results beyond abstract graphical patterns. Overall, our research advances knowledge of the relationship between aesthetic preferences for features like symmetry and complexity and approach–avoidance motivation, and it has implications for fields such as marketing.
- Open Access
- 9 July 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The relationship between beauty and comfort in fonts
Is beauty uncomfortable? Is comfort beautiful? We use fonts to explore the relationship between beauty and reading comfort. Participants viewed a paragraph of nonsensical Latin text and rated how much beauty they felt from the letters. They also rated comfort twice: after an ordinary reading task and after a Rapid Serial Visual Presentation (RSVP) task. In the ordinary reading task, participants rated comfort after reading a short story. In the RSVP task, participants read 40 words of a different short story, each word presented for 500 ms (120 words per minute), and again rated comfort. The first task maintains ecological validity, and the second eliminates reading speed as a confound. We found that the two comfort ratings are strongly correlated (R2 = 0.88), and comfort predicts beauty (R2 = 0.96). Beauty and comfort together revealed three distinct font clusters, which were not distinct using either measure alone. These clusters correspond to standard typographic categories: text, script, and display. Indeed, font category predicted ratings of beauty and comfort. However, within text fonts, beauty and comfort ratings did not distinguish between serif and sans serif. We also found striking individual differences. Beauty and comfort were positively correlated for most participants, but strongly negatively correlated for others. A participant’s beauty-comfort correlation is predicted by their preference for minimalist style and by the difference in their ratings across font categories (R2 = 0.60). We show how form and function, two aspects of product design often considered separate, are closely interconnected for fonts.
- 9 July 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe relationship between beauty and comfort in fonts
Is beauty uncomfortable? Is comfort beautiful? We use fonts to explore the relationship between beauty and reading comfort. Participants viewed a paragraph of nonsensical Latin text and rated how much beauty they felt from the letters. They also rated comfort twice: after an ordinary reading task and after a Rapid Serial Visual Presentation (RSVP) task. In the ordinary reading task, participants rated comfort after reading a short story. In the RSVP task, participants read 40 words of a different short story, each word presented for 500 ms (120 words per minute), and again rated comfort. The first task maintains ecological validity, and the second eliminates reading speed as a confound. We found that the two comfort ratings are strongly correlated (R2 = 0.88), and comfort predicts beauty (R2 = 0.96). Beauty and comfort together revealed three distinct font clusters, which were not distinct using either measure alone. These clusters correspond to standard typographic categories: text, script, and display. Indeed, font category predicted ratings of beauty and comfort. However, within text fonts, beauty and comfort ratings did not distinguish between serif and sans serif. We also found striking individual differences. Beauty and comfort were positively correlated for most participants, but strongly negatively correlated for others. A participant’s beauty-comfort correlation is predicted by their preference for minimalist style and by the difference in their ratings across font categories (R2 = 0.60). We show how form and function, two aspects of product design often considered separate, are closely interconnected for fonts.
- Open Access
Consensus and contention in beauty judgment
- Open Access
- 1 November 2023
- Published by Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology (ARVO) in Journal of Vision
- Vol. 23 (13) , 6
Emotions of subject and object affect beauty differently for images and music
What role do the emotions of subject and object play in judging the beauty of images and music? Eighty-one participants rated perceived beauty, liking, perceived happiness, and perceived sadness of 24 songs, 12 art images, and 12 nature photographs. Stimulus presentation was brief (2 seconds) or prolonged (20 seconds). The stimuli were presented in two blocks, and participants took the Positive and Negative Affect Score (PANAS) mood questionnaire before and after each block. They viewed a mood induction video between blocks either to increase their happiness or sadness or to maintain their mood. Using linear mixed-effects models, we found that perceived object happiness predicts an increase in image and song beauty regardless of duration. The effect of perceived object sadness on beauty, however, is stronger for songs than images and stronger for prolonged than brief durations. Subject emotion affects brief song beauty minimally and prolonged song beauty substantially. Whereas past studies of beauty and emotion emphasized sad music, here we analyze both happiness and sadness, both subject and object emotion, and both images and music. We conclude that the interactions between emotion and beauty are different for images and music and are strongly moderated by duration.
- 1 November 2023
- Published by Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology (ARVO) in Journal of Vision
- Vol. 23 (13) , 6
Open AccessEmotions of subject and object affect beauty differently for images and music
What role do the emotions of subject and object play in judging the beauty of images and music? Eighty-one participants rated perceived beauty, liking, perceived happiness, and perceived sadness of 24 songs, 12 art images, and 12 nature photographs. Stimulus presentation was brief (2 seconds) or prolonged (20 seconds). The stimuli were presented in two blocks, and participants took the Positive and Negative Affect Score (PANAS) mood questionnaire before and after each block. They viewed a mood induction video between blocks either to increase their happiness or sadness or to maintain their mood. Using linear mixed-effects models, we found that perceived object happiness predicts an increase in image and song beauty regardless of duration. The effect of perceived object sadness on beauty, however, is stronger for songs than images and stronger for prolonged than brief durations. Subject emotion affects brief song beauty minimally and prolonged song beauty substantially. Whereas past studies of beauty and emotion emphasized sad music, here we analyze both happiness and sadness, both subject and object emotion, and both images and music. We conclude that the interactions between emotion and beauty are different for images and music and are strongly moderated by duration.
- Open Access
Multiple Axes of Visual Symmetry: Detection and Aesthetic Preference
Little is known about the detection of and preference for multiple simultaneous parallel axes of symmetry. Neuroscientists have suggested that the detection of symmetry occurs in extrastriate brain areas with large receptive fields. Such large receptive fields may potentially hinder the simultaneous detection of more than one axis of symmetry. In contrast, psychophysicists have found that symmetry detection occurs within small spatial windows, allowing for the concurrent detection of multiple axes of symmetry. Using psychophysical and computational methods, we aim to test whether multiple axes of symmetry can be detected in parallel and to understand the role of multiple axes of symmetry on aesthetic valence. Experiment 1 provides evidence that multiple axes of symmetry cannot be detected simultaneously. However, with relatively long temporal integration, people can detect them. Experiment 2 suggests that multiple axes of symmetry tend to increase preference. However, the preference for symmetry is not universal because, although most people prefer symmetry, others prefer complex images without axes of symmetry. We present and test a computational model that explains the results of these experiments.
Open AccessMultiple Axes of Visual Symmetry: Detection and Aesthetic Preference
Little is known about the detection of and preference for multiple simultaneous parallel axes of symmetry. Neuroscientists have suggested that the detection of symmetry occurs in extrastriate brain areas with large receptive fields. Such large receptive fields may potentially hinder the simultaneous detection of more than one axis of symmetry. In contrast, psychophysicists have found that symmetry detection occurs within small spatial windows, allowing for the concurrent detection of multiple axes of symmetry. Using psychophysical and computational methods, we aim to test whether multiple axes of symmetry can be detected in parallel and to understand the role of multiple axes of symmetry on aesthetic valence. Experiment 1 provides evidence that multiple axes of symmetry cannot be detected simultaneously. However, with relatively long temporal integration, people can detect them. Experiment 2 suggests that multiple axes of symmetry tend to increase preference. However, the preference for symmetry is not universal because, although most people prefer symmetry, others prefer complex images without axes of symmetry. We present and test a computational model that explains the results of these experiments.
- Open Access
EasyEyes — Accurate fixation for online vision testing of crowding and beyond
Online methods allow testing of larger, more diverse populations, with much less effort than in-lab testing. However, many psychophysical measurements, including visual crowding, require accurate eye fixation, which is classically achieved by testing only experienced observers who have learned to fixate reliably, or by using a gaze tracker to restrict testing to moments when fixation is accurate. Alas, both approaches are impractical online since online observers tend to be inexperienced, and online gaze tracking, using the built-in webcam, has a low precision (±4 deg, Papoutsaki et al., 2016). The EasyEyes open-source software reliably measures peripheral thresholds online with accurate fixation achieved in a novel way, without gaze tracking. EasyEyes tells observers to use the cursor to track a moving crosshair. At a random time during successful tracking, a brief target is presented in the periphery. The observer responds by identifying the target. To evaluate EasyEyes fixation accuracy and thresholds, we tested 12 naive observers in three ways in a counterbalanced order: first, in the lab, using gaze-contingent stimulus presentation (Kurzawski et al., 2023; Pelli et al., 2016); second, in the lab, using EasyEyes while independently monitoring gaze; third, online at home, using EasyEyes. We find that crowding thresholds are consistent (no significant differences in mean and variance of thresholds across ways) and individual differences are conserved. The small root mean square (RMS) fixation error (0.6 deg) during target presentation eliminates the need for gaze tracking. Thus, EasyEyes enables fixation-dependent measurements online, for easy testing of larger and more diverse populations.
Open AccessEasyEyes — Accurate fixation for online vision testing of crowding and beyond
Online methods allow testing of larger, more diverse populations, with much less effort than in-lab testing. However, many psychophysical measurements, including visual crowding, require accurate eye fixation, which is classically achieved by testing only experienced observers who have learned to fixate reliably, or by using a gaze tracker to restrict testing to moments when fixation is accurate. Alas, both approaches are impractical online since online observers tend to be inexperienced, and online gaze tracking, using the built-in webcam, has a low precision (±4 deg, Papoutsaki et al., 2016). The EasyEyes open-source software reliably measures peripheral thresholds online with accurate fixation achieved in a novel way, without gaze tracking. EasyEyes tells observers to use the cursor to track a moving crosshair. At a random time during successful tracking, a brief target is presented in the periphery. The observer responds by identifying the target. To evaluate EasyEyes fixation accuracy and thresholds, we tested 12 naive observers in three ways in a counterbalanced order: first, in the lab, using gaze-contingent stimulus presentation (Kurzawski et al., 2023; Pelli et al., 2016); second, in the lab, using EasyEyes while independently monitoring gaze; third, online at home, using EasyEyes. We find that crowding thresholds are consistent (no significant differences in mean and variance of thresholds across ways) and individual differences are conserved. The small root mean square (RMS) fixation error (0.6 deg) during target presentation eliminates the need for gaze tracking. Thus, EasyEyes enables fixation-dependent measurements online, for easy testing of larger and more diverse populations.
- Open Access
- 6 July 2023
- Published by Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology (ARVO) in Journal of Vision
- Vol. 23 (7) , 6
Beauty isn't special: Comparing the information capacity of beauty and other sensory judgments
Information theory (bits) allows comparing beauty judgment to perceptual judgment on the same absolute scale. In one of the most influential articles in psychology, Miller (1956) found that classifying a stimulus into one of eight or more categories of the attribute transmits roughly 2.6 bits of information. That corresponds to 7 ± 2 categories. This number is both remarkably small and highly conserved across attributes and sensory modalities. This appears to be a signature of one-dimensional perceptual judgment. We wondered whether beauty can break this limit. Beauty judgments matter and play a key role in many of our real-life decisions, large and small. Mutual information is how much information about one variable can be obtained from observing another. We measured the mutual information of 50 participants’ beauty ratings of everyday images. The mutual information saturated at 2.3 bits. We also replicated the results using different images. The 2.3 bits conveyed by beauty judgment are close to Miller's 2.6 bits of unidimensional perceptual judgment and far less than the 5 to 14 bits of a multidimensional perceptual judgment. By this measure, beauty judgment acts like a perceptual judgment, such as rating pitch, hue, or loudness.
- 6 July 2023
- Published by Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology (ARVO) in Journal of Vision
- Vol. 23 (7) , 6
Open AccessBeauty isn't special: Comparing the information capacity of beauty and other sensory judgments
Information theory (bits) allows comparing beauty judgment to perceptual judgment on the same absolute scale. In one of the most influential articles in psychology, Miller (1956) found that classifying a stimulus into one of eight or more categories of the attribute transmits roughly 2.6 bits of information. That corresponds to 7 ± 2 categories. This number is both remarkably small and highly conserved across attributes and sensory modalities. This appears to be a signature of one-dimensional perceptual judgment. We wondered whether beauty can break this limit. Beauty judgments matter and play a key role in many of our real-life decisions, large and small. Mutual information is how much information about one variable can be obtained from observing another. We measured the mutual information of 50 participants’ beauty ratings of everyday images. The mutual information saturated at 2.3 bits. We also replicated the results using different images. The 2.3 bits conveyed by beauty judgment are close to Miller's 2.6 bits of unidimensional perceptual judgment and far less than the 5 to 14 bits of a multidimensional perceptual judgment. By this measure, beauty judgment acts like a perceptual judgment, such as rating pitch, hue, or loudness.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Attention, Perception, & Psychophysics
- Vol. 85 (4) , 1355-1373
The intrinsic variance of beauty judgment
Recall memory and sequential dependence threaten the independence of successive beauty ratings. Such independence is usually assumed when using repeated measures to estimate the intrinsic variance of a rating. We call “intrinsic” the variance of all possible responses that the participant could give on a trial. Variance arises within and across participants. In attributing the measured variance to sources, the first step is to assess how much is intrinsic. In seven experiments, we measure how much of the variability across beauty ratings can be attributed to recall memory and sequential dependence. With a set size of one, memory is a problem and contributes half the measured variance. However, we showed that for both beauty and ellipticity, with set size of nine or more, recall memory causes a mere 10% increase in the variance of repeated ratings. Moreover, we showed that as long as the stimuli are diverse (i.e., represent different object categories), sequential dependence does not affect the variance of beauty ratings. Lastly, the variance of beauty ratings increases in proportion to the 0.15 power of stimulus set size. We show that the beauty rating of a stimulus in a diverse set is affected by the stimulus set size and not the value of other stimuli. Overall, we conclude that the variance of repeated ratings is a good way to estimate the intrinsic variance of a beauty rating of a stimulus in a diverse set.
- 14 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Attention, Perception, & Psychophysics
- Vol. 85 (4) , 1355-1373
Open AccessThe intrinsic variance of beauty judgment
Recall memory and sequential dependence threaten the independence of successive beauty ratings. Such independence is usually assumed when using repeated measures to estimate the intrinsic variance of a rating. We call “intrinsic” the variance of all possible responses that the participant could give on a trial. Variance arises within and across participants. In attributing the measured variance to sources, the first step is to assess how much is intrinsic. In seven experiments, we measure how much of the variability across beauty ratings can be attributed to recall memory and sequential dependence. With a set size of one, memory is a problem and contributes half the measured variance. However, we showed that for both beauty and ellipticity, with set size of nine or more, recall memory causes a mere 10% increase in the variance of repeated ratings. Moreover, we showed that as long as the stimuli are diverse (i.e., represent different object categories), sequential dependence does not affect the variance of beauty ratings. Lastly, the variance of beauty ratings increases in proportion to the 0.15 power of stimulus set size. We show that the beauty rating of a stimulus in a diverse set is affected by the stimulus set size and not the value of other stimuli. Overall, we conclude that the variance of repeated ratings is a good way to estimate the intrinsic variance of a beauty rating of a stimulus in a diverse set.
- Open Access
- 14 November 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Beauty isn't special: Comparing the information capacity of beauty and other sensory judgments
In one of the most influential papers in psychology, Miller (1956) found that classifying a stimulus into one of 8 or more categories of the attribute transmits roughly 2.6 bits of information. That corresponds to 7 ± 2 categories. This number is both remarkably small and highly conserved across attributes and sensory modalities. This appears to be a signature of one-dimensional perceptual judgment. We wondered whether beauty can break this limit. Beauty judgments matter and play a key role in many of our real-life decisions, large and small. Mutual information is how much information about one variable can be obtained from observing another. We measured the mutual information of 50 participants’ beauty ratings of everyday images. The mutual information saturated at 2.3 bits. The 2.3 bits conveyed by beauty judgment are close to Miller’s 2.6 bits of unidimensional perceptual judgment and far less than the 5 to 14 bits of a multidimensional perceptual judgment. By this measure, beauty judgment acts like a sensory judgment, such as rating pitch, hue, or loudness.
- 14 November 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessBeauty isn't special: Comparing the information capacity of beauty and other sensory judgments
In one of the most influential papers in psychology, Miller (1956) found that classifying a stimulus into one of 8 or more categories of the attribute transmits roughly 2.6 bits of information. That corresponds to 7 ± 2 categories. This number is both remarkably small and highly conserved across attributes and sensory modalities. This appears to be a signature of one-dimensional perceptual judgment. We wondered whether beauty can break this limit. Beauty judgments matter and play a key role in many of our real-life decisions, large and small. Mutual information is how much information about one variable can be obtained from observing another. We measured the mutual information of 50 participants’ beauty ratings of everyday images. The mutual information saturated at 2.3 bits. The 2.3 bits conveyed by beauty judgment are close to Miller’s 2.6 bits of unidimensional perceptual judgment and far less than the 5 to 14 bits of a multidimensional perceptual judgment. By this measure, beauty judgment acts like a sensory judgment, such as rating pitch, hue, or loudness.
- Open Access
- 4 March 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The intrinsic variance of beauty judgment
Recall memory and sequential dependence threaten the independence of successive beauty ratings. Such independence is usually assumed when using repeated measures to estimate the intrinsic variance of a rating. We call “intrinsic” the variance of all possible responses that the participant could give on a trial. Variance arises within and across participants. In attributing the measured variance to sources, the first step is to assess how much is intrinsic. In seven experiments, we measure how much of the variability across beauty ratings can be attributed to recall memory and sequential dependence. With a set size of one, memory is a problem and contributes half the measured variance. However, we showed that for both beauty and ellipticity, with set size of nine or more, recall memory causes a mere 10% increase in the variance of repeated ratings. Moreover, we showed that as long as the stimuli are diverse (i.e., represent different object categories), sequential dependence does not affect the variance of beauty ratings. Lastly, the variance of beauty ratings increases in proportion to the 0.15 power of stimulus set size. We show that the beauty rating of a stimulus in a diverse set is affected by the stimulus set size and not the value of other stimuli. Overall, we conclude that the variance of repeated ratings is a good way to estimate the intrinsic variance of a beauty rating of a stimulus in a diverse set.
- 4 March 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe intrinsic variance of beauty judgment
Recall memory and sequential dependence threaten the independence of successive beauty ratings. Such independence is usually assumed when using repeated measures to estimate the intrinsic variance of a rating. We call “intrinsic” the variance of all possible responses that the participant could give on a trial. Variance arises within and across participants. In attributing the measured variance to sources, the first step is to assess how much is intrinsic. In seven experiments, we measure how much of the variability across beauty ratings can be attributed to recall memory and sequential dependence. With a set size of one, memory is a problem and contributes half the measured variance. However, we showed that for both beauty and ellipticity, with set size of nine or more, recall memory causes a mere 10% increase in the variance of repeated ratings. Moreover, we showed that as long as the stimuli are diverse (i.e., represent different object categories), sequential dependence does not affect the variance of beauty ratings. Lastly, the variance of beauty ratings increases in proportion to the 0.15 power of stimulus set size. We show that the beauty rating of a stimulus in a diverse set is affected by the stimulus set size and not the value of other stimuli. Overall, we conclude that the variance of repeated ratings is a good way to estimate the intrinsic variance of a beauty rating of a stimulus in a diverse set.