Dinara Rakhmatullayeva
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Dinara Rakhmatullayeva has a total of 32 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Rustamjon Urinboyev
Lund University
3 shared publications - Tatyana Kudasheva
I-Marketing LLP
3 shared publications - A. B. Khajiyeva
Казахский национальный университет имени аль-Фараби
2 shared publications - Bishala Maerdan
Al-Farabi Kazakh National University
2 shared publications T. Kakizhanova
«I-Marketing» LLP, Almaty, Kazakhstan
2 shared publicationsД.ж. Рахматуллаева
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 19 October 2026
- Published by Central Asian Academic Research Center LLP in THE BULLETIN
- Vol. 423 (5) , 472–494
ESG-INVESTMENT OF KAZAKHSTAN'S ENDOWMENT FUNDS: INSTITUTIONAL CONSTRAINTS AND MECHANISMS TO OVERCOME THEM
The study aims to identify and systematise the regulatory, financial, economic, organisational, and managerial constraints in Kazakhstan's endowment funds' transition to ESG investment, and to substantiate mechanisms for overcoming them. The methodological basis includes documentary and comparative legal analysis, an institutional approach, a comparative study of public examples, and scenario financial modelling. The regulatory framework has been analysed as of October 1, 2026. The analysis found that creating special legislation on endowment capital and developing national infrastructure for sustainable financing create institutional prerequisites for ESG investment but do not automatically ensure the implementation of relevant practices. The study identified limitations related to the permissibility of financial instruments, the certainty of the investment mandate, the quality of ESG information, professional competencies, and administrative costs. Scenario calculations for conditional funds with capital of 50, 100, and 500 million tenge showed that the financial availability of ESG procedures depends on asset scale. With a notional cost of 1.20 million tenge, the estimated coverage limits were 80 million tenge in the positive scenario and 240 million tenge in the negative scenario. Comparing institutional examples from Almaty, Astana, and the Karaganda region made it possible to identify differences in management tasks at certain stages of fund development. The scientific novelty lies in the development of an analytical model of the ESG transition, combining the legal admissibility of investments, financial capabilities, and organisational readiness. The practical significance of the results depends on their potential use in developing investment declarations, regulating interactions with management companies, and forming a control system. The limitations of the study are due to the lack of a comparable database of financial and portfolio indicators of endowment funds in Kazakhstan.
- 19 October 2026
- Published by Central Asian Academic Research Center LLP in THE BULLETIN
- Vol. 423 (5) , 472–494
Open AccessESG-INVESTMENT OF KAZAKHSTAN'S ENDOWMENT FUNDS: INSTITUTIONAL CONSTRAINTS AND MECHANISMS TO OVERCOME THEM
The study aims to identify and systematise the regulatory, financial, economic, organisational, and managerial constraints in Kazakhstan's endowment funds' transition to ESG investment, and to substantiate mechanisms for overcoming them. The methodological basis includes documentary and comparative legal analysis, an institutional approach, a comparative study of public examples, and scenario financial modelling. The regulatory framework has been analysed as of October 1, 2026. The analysis found that creating special legislation on endowment capital and developing national infrastructure for sustainable financing create institutional prerequisites for ESG investment but do not automatically ensure the implementation of relevant practices. The study identified limitations related to the permissibility of financial instruments, the certainty of the investment mandate, the quality of ESG information, professional competencies, and administrative costs. Scenario calculations for conditional funds with capital of 50, 100, and 500 million tenge showed that the financial availability of ESG procedures depends on asset scale. With a notional cost of 1.20 million tenge, the estimated coverage limits were 80 million tenge in the positive scenario and 240 million tenge in the negative scenario. Comparing institutional examples from Almaty, Astana, and the Karaganda region made it possible to identify differences in management tasks at certain stages of fund development. The scientific novelty lies in the development of an analytical model of the ESG transition, combining the legal admissibility of investments, financial capabilities, and organisational readiness. The practical significance of the results depends on their potential use in developing investment declarations, regulating interactions with management companies, and forming a control system. The limitations of the study are due to the lack of a comparable database of financial and portfolio indicators of endowment funds in Kazakhstan.
- 2 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 631-639
The Interplay of Corruption and ESG Performance: A Systematic Literature Review
- 2 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 631-639
The Interplay of Corruption and ESG Performance: A Systematic Literature Review
- Open Access
- 17 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 391-415
Evaluating the Impact of Corruption on the Development of Entrepreneurship in Kazakhstan
- 17 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 391-415
Open AccessEvaluating the Impact of Corruption on the Development of Entrepreneurship in Kazakhstan
- 5 April 2026
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 21 (1)
Digital Finance and Agricultural Productivity Growth: Comparative Evidence from China and Kazakhstan
The digital transformation of the agricultural sector strengthens the role of digital infrastructure and financial inclusion as factors of productivity growth in agriculture in the context of structural modernization of the economy. The aim of the study is to assess the impact of digital infrastructure on agricultural productivity and to identify the cross—country heterogeneity of effects in economies with different levels of digitalization and institutional development. A balanced panel for 2011-2023 (26 observations) based on data from the World Bank and the International Labour Organisation was used. In the combined model, digital infrastructure demonstrates a positive and statistically significant relationship with performance (β = 0.7626; p < 0.01), with a high quality of fit (r2 = 0.946). The exclusion of pandemic years confirms the stability of the effect (β = 0.744; p < 0.01; r2 = 0.937). The cross-country analysis revealed heterogeneity: in China, the effect of digital infrastructure is positive and significant (β = 0.421; p < 0.01), while in Kazakhstan the coefficient is negative and weakly significant at the level of 10% (β = -0.483; p = 0.092), indicating differences in institutional readiness and the level of digital maturity. The results obtained confirm the importance of digital infrastructure in improving the efficiency of the agricultural sector, but demonstrate that the institutional and structural environment determines the scale and direction of this impact.
- 5 April 2026
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 21 (1)
Digital Finance and Agricultural Productivity Growth: Comparative Evidence from China and Kazakhstan
The digital transformation of the agricultural sector strengthens the role of digital infrastructure and financial inclusion as factors of productivity growth in agriculture in the context of structural modernization of the economy. The aim of the study is to assess the impact of digital infrastructure on agricultural productivity and to identify the cross—country heterogeneity of effects in economies with different levels of digitalization and institutional development. A balanced panel for 2011-2023 (26 observations) based on data from the World Bank and the International Labour Organisation was used. In the combined model, digital infrastructure demonstrates a positive and statistically significant relationship with performance (β = 0.7626; p < 0.01), with a high quality of fit (r2 = 0.946). The exclusion of pandemic years confirms the stability of the effect (β = 0.744; p < 0.01; r2 = 0.937). The cross-country analysis revealed heterogeneity: in China, the effect of digital infrastructure is positive and significant (β = 0.421; p < 0.01), while in Kazakhstan the coefficient is negative and weakly significant at the level of 10% (β = -0.483; p = 0.092), indicating differences in institutional readiness and the level of digital maturity. The results obtained confirm the importance of digital infrastructure in improving the efficiency of the agricultural sector, but demonstrate that the institutional and structural environment determines the scale and direction of this impact.
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Almaty Academy of Economy and Statistic in Statistika, učet i audit
- Vol. 100 (1) , 365-378
STRATEGIC SYNERGY: THE ROLE OF METHODOLOGIES AND TECHNOLOGIES IN ENHANCING ORGANIZATIONAL IMPLEMENTATION EFFICIENCY AND EFFECTIVENESS
In the article emphasizes the crucial phase of strategy implementation within organizations, transitioning plans from theory to practice. This phase determines if an organization can achieve its strategic objectives and tests the practical application of its vision, mission, and goals. The importance of methodologies like Agile, Lean, and Balanced Scorecard, and technologies such as project management software, data analytics, and artificial intelligence, is highlighted. These elements enhance agility, adaptability, and accountability while improving real-time monitoring, communication, and decision-making. In a complex business environment marked by globalization and technological advancements, the effective application of methodologies and technologies is vital for efficiency and effectiveness. Organizations must remain agile and responsive to maintain competitiveness and foster continuous improvement and innovation. The alignment of methodologies and technologies with strategic objectives is key to achieving success and long-term vitality.
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Almaty Academy of Economy and Statistic in Statistika, učet i audit
- Vol. 100 (1) , 365-378
STRATEGIC SYNERGY: THE ROLE OF METHODOLOGIES AND TECHNOLOGIES IN ENHANCING ORGANIZATIONAL IMPLEMENTATION EFFICIENCY AND EFFECTIVENESS
In the article emphasizes the crucial phase of strategy implementation within organizations, transitioning plans from theory to practice. This phase determines if an organization can achieve its strategic objectives and tests the practical application of its vision, mission, and goals. The importance of methodologies like Agile, Lean, and Balanced Scorecard, and technologies such as project management software, data analytics, and artificial intelligence, is highlighted. These elements enhance agility, adaptability, and accountability while improving real-time monitoring, communication, and decision-making. In a complex business environment marked by globalization and technological advancements, the effective application of methodologies and technologies is vital for efficiency and effectiveness. Organizations must remain agile and responsive to maintain competitiveness and foster continuous improvement and innovation. The alignment of methodologies and technologies with strategic objectives is key to achieving success and long-term vitality.
- 30 September 2024
- Published by Toraighyrov University in Bulletin of Toraighyrov University. Economics series
- No. 3.2024,p. 251-263
IMPLEENTATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL, SOCIAL, AND GOVERNANCE (ESG) PRINCIPLES IN HEALTHCARE COMPANY MANAGEMENT: A COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW
The global healthcare system accounts for 4 % of the world’s carbon dioxide emissions, surpassing both aviation and shipping. Characterized by significant waste production and energy consumption, the industry faces direct challenges from climate change and requires tailored measures due to its unique attributes. Historically, the sector has prioritized social considerations, often at the expense of environmental issues. Enhancing the healthcare industry’s ESG performance is essential for achieving sustainability and Sustainable Development Goals, and it offers potential economic benefits. The primary aim of this research is to comprehensively analyze and understand the implementation of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) principles within the management frameworks of the healthcare industry. The results show, most current research focuses on the value or connection that ESG brings to corporate financial performance or market performance, or pays more attention to the connection between CSR and ESG. In other words, many researchers pay more attention to the S part of ESG and pay less attention to the E and G parts. The research’s conclusions reflect the strategic importance of ESG in the global healthcare industry and underscore the importance of companies considering sustainability and social responsibility when making business strategies and operational decisions. Keywords: ESG, management, healthcare, medicine, pharmaceutical industry, sustainable development.
- 30 September 2024
- Published by Toraighyrov University in Bulletin of Toraighyrov University. Economics series
- No. 3.2024,p. 251-263
IMPLEENTATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL, SOCIAL, AND GOVERNANCE (ESG) PRINCIPLES IN HEALTHCARE COMPANY MANAGEMENT: A COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW
The global healthcare system accounts for 4 % of the world’s carbon dioxide emissions, surpassing both aviation and shipping. Characterized by significant waste production and energy consumption, the industry faces direct challenges from climate change and requires tailored measures due to its unique attributes. Historically, the sector has prioritized social considerations, often at the expense of environmental issues. Enhancing the healthcare industry’s ESG performance is essential for achieving sustainability and Sustainable Development Goals, and it offers potential economic benefits. The primary aim of this research is to comprehensively analyze and understand the implementation of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) principles within the management frameworks of the healthcare industry. The results show, most current research focuses on the value or connection that ESG brings to corporate financial performance or market performance, or pays more attention to the connection between CSR and ESG. In other words, many researchers pay more attention to the S part of ESG and pay less attention to the E and G parts. The research’s conclusions reflect the strategic importance of ESG in the global healthcare industry and underscore the importance of companies considering sustainability and social responsibility when making business strategies and operational decisions. Keywords: ESG, management, healthcare, medicine, pharmaceutical industry, sustainable development.
- 30 September 2024
- Published by Toraighyrov University in Bulletin of Toraighyrov University. Economics series
- No. 3.2024,p. 307-320
ANALYSIS OF ISSUES AND BARRIERS TO DOING BUSINESS IN THE REGIONS OF KAZAKHSTAN
The article aims to assess the regulatory burden small and medium-sized businesses face in the republic’s regions from the company’s opening to its closure. The primary method is an analysis of the results of the sociological survey conducted within the framework of a research project sponsored by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The authors conducted the sociological survey through questionnaires combined with in-depth interviews, ensuring a comprehensive understanding of the issues. As a result, the authors found that an overwhelming number (85 %) of business leaders consider Kazakhstan attractive for business and investment. The authors assessed four key indicators to understand the high barriers to doing business. Companies’ surveys showed that business registration is quite accessible. However, expert interviews confirmed that they experienced the most significant difficulties with staff recruitment. The authors analyzed the access to infrastructure (electricity, water, land, and logistics) separately, which entrepreneurs assessed at an average level. Also, the authors identified the problem of accessing bank capital for business and the need to reduce the tax burden for new companies and startups. In addition, the authors tried to evaluate the financial aspects of doing business in Kazakhstan and the impact of digitalization on business development. Thus, research attempted to identify the main problems and barriers to evaluating the ease of doing business in Kazakhstan’s regions. We concluded that the business environment in the country is «far from perfect», and the authorities have a lot of work to do to improve it. Keywords: Kazakhstan’s regions, EDB, Investment, Business environment, Business leaders, Survey, Barriers to business.
- 30 September 2024
- Published by Toraighyrov University in Bulletin of Toraighyrov University. Economics series
- No. 3.2024,p. 307-320
ANALYSIS OF ISSUES AND BARRIERS TO DOING BUSINESS IN THE REGIONS OF KAZAKHSTAN
The article aims to assess the regulatory burden small and medium-sized businesses face in the republic’s regions from the company’s opening to its closure. The primary method is an analysis of the results of the sociological survey conducted within the framework of a research project sponsored by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The authors conducted the sociological survey through questionnaires combined with in-depth interviews, ensuring a comprehensive understanding of the issues. As a result, the authors found that an overwhelming number (85 %) of business leaders consider Kazakhstan attractive for business and investment. The authors assessed four key indicators to understand the high barriers to doing business. Companies’ surveys showed that business registration is quite accessible. However, expert interviews confirmed that they experienced the most significant difficulties with staff recruitment. The authors analyzed the access to infrastructure (electricity, water, land, and logistics) separately, which entrepreneurs assessed at an average level. Also, the authors identified the problem of accessing bank capital for business and the need to reduce the tax burden for new companies and startups. In addition, the authors tried to evaluate the financial aspects of doing business in Kazakhstan and the impact of digitalization on business development. Thus, research attempted to identify the main problems and barriers to evaluating the ease of doing business in Kazakhstan’s regions. We concluded that the business environment in the country is «far from perfect», and the authorities have a lot of work to do to improve it. Keywords: Kazakhstan’s regions, EDB, Investment, Business environment, Business leaders, Survey, Barriers to business.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2024
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 19 (2) , 84-99
Business Environment in Kazakhstan: Assessing Infrastructure Availability
The study aims to quantitatively assess the availability of various infrastructures for doing business and identify the main barriers in the infrastructure industry that hinder the ease of doing business and investment development in regions of Kazakhstan. The authors assessed infrastructure accessibility in Kazakhstan's regions based on an SME managers' survey. They developed an index of infrastructure availability, a practical tool for gauging infrastructure development in a specific region or country. This index is crucial for investment planning and developing relevant sectors of the national economy. The findings revealed that no region in Kazakhstan has a good infrastructure. Access to its most essential types is only at an average level, with the lowest index values observed in Almaty and East Kazakhstan regions. The analysis of SMEs' problems with access to infrastructure highlighted bureaucracy and difficulties in obtaining permits, high wear and tear of networks, and high connection costs as the main issues. The authors underscore the increasing global economic and geopolitical risks that lead to fundamental changes in Central Asia, particularly Kazakhstan, which has excellent potential for developing transit routes between East and West. They advocate for active investment in infrastructure projects as a solution. According to expert forecasts, if Kazakhstan invests at least 4% of its GDP annually, it can completely replace and modernize the republic's worn-out transport infrastructure by 2040, leading to significant economic benefits. The authors will use the study's results to create regional indices of doing business in Kazakhstan.
- 30 June 2024
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 19 (2) , 84-99
Open AccessBusiness Environment in Kazakhstan: Assessing Infrastructure Availability
The study aims to quantitatively assess the availability of various infrastructures for doing business and identify the main barriers in the infrastructure industry that hinder the ease of doing business and investment development in regions of Kazakhstan. The authors assessed infrastructure accessibility in Kazakhstan's regions based on an SME managers' survey. They developed an index of infrastructure availability, a practical tool for gauging infrastructure development in a specific region or country. This index is crucial for investment planning and developing relevant sectors of the national economy. The findings revealed that no region in Kazakhstan has a good infrastructure. Access to its most essential types is only at an average level, with the lowest index values observed in Almaty and East Kazakhstan regions. The analysis of SMEs' problems with access to infrastructure highlighted bureaucracy and difficulties in obtaining permits, high wear and tear of networks, and high connection costs as the main issues. The authors underscore the increasing global economic and geopolitical risks that lead to fundamental changes in Central Asia, particularly Kazakhstan, which has excellent potential for developing transit routes between East and West. They advocate for active investment in infrastructure projects as a solution. According to expert forecasts, if Kazakhstan invests at least 4% of its GDP annually, it can completely replace and modernize the republic's worn-out transport infrastructure by 2040, leading to significant economic benefits. The authors will use the study's results to create regional indices of doing business in Kazakhstan.
- Open Access
- 29 December 2023
- Published by Kazakh University of Economics, Finance and International Trade in Вестник Казахского университета экономики, финансов и международной торговли
- No. 4(53)
РЫНОК ЧАСТНОГО КАПИТАЛА: МЕЖДУНАРОДНЫЙ ОПЫТ И КАЗАХСТАНСКАЯ ПРАКТИКА
- 29 December 2023
- Published by Kazakh University of Economics, Finance and International Trade in Вестник Казахского университета экономики, финансов и международной торговли
- No. 4(53)
Open AccessРЫНОК ЧАСТНОГО КАПИТАЛА: МЕЖДУНАРОДНЫЙ ОПЫТ И КАЗАХСТАНСКАЯ ПРАКТИКА