Monika Martens
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Monika Martens has a total of 74 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Josefien van Olmen
Department of Family Medicine and Population Health (FAMPOP), Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium
11 shared publications - Edwin Wouters
University of Antwerp
8 shared publications - Katrien Danhieux
Department of Family Medicine and Population Health (FAMPOP), Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Antwerp, Belgium
8 shared publications - Antonija Poplas Susič
Community Health Centre Ljubljana, Primary Healthcare Research and Development Institute , Metelkova ulica 9 , Ljubljana , Slovenia
5 shared publications - Roy Remmen
Chair Care and the Natural Living Environment, Department of Family Medicine and Population Health, University of Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium
5 shared publications - Wim Van Damme
Department of Public Health, Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp, Belgium
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Youth co-production for sustainable engagement and empowerment in health (YiPEE): protocol for a cluster-randomised controlled trial of an intervention for mental health promotion among adolescents in schools in Chennai, India
Introduction Adolescence is a time of rapid physical, social and psychological development and many risk factors for mental disorders have their roots in this age period. Primary prevention through school platforms has been extensively used and evaluated, but many interventions have poor uptake, high dropout and limited long-term sustainability. Mental health is a complex phenomenon and may be best supported through multicomponent interventions that more holistically consider inner, social and environmental levels. Character education-focused interventions are effective for improving adolescent psychosocial functioning and mental well-being. Therefore, an intervention that focuses on developing these strengths and is delivered within a school environment, through an adolescent-informed approach using creativity-focused components, has the potential to improve adolescent mental health and well-being. Methods and analysis This protocol describes the YiPEE cluster-randomised controlled trial with concurrent mixed-methods process evaluation and economic evaluation, which aims to determine the impact of a multilevel multicomponent intervention in schools in Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India. Clusters—defined as schools which include Grades 6–8 (ages 11–16 years), will be randomised to intervention (n=15) or control (n=15). The intervention consists of: an 8-week classroom-based component, a 12-week teacher-focused component and a board comprising members from across the whole school. All children attending Grade 7 (aged 12–15) will be exposed to the classroom component, and teachers who actively teach Grade 7 will be invited to participate in the teacher component. Within schools, students for the individual-level evaluation will be included if they are: (1) aged 12–15 years; (2) currently attending Grade 7; (3) competent to give consent and (4) have a legal guardian competent of giving consent. We aim to sample a minimum of 100 students from each school (n=3000). All teachers of Grades 6–8 will be recruited for the evaluation. The primary outcome is symptoms of anxiety and depression measured using an abbreviated version of the UNICEF MMAPP tool. The primary analysis will be intention-to-treat, comparing the mean change in mental health score between baseline and endline, between intervention and control clusters. In addition, we will record school monitoring data (student attendance, student grades). Individual interviews with students and teachers, focus group discussions with school staff, and ethnographic observations will provide data for the process evaluation. For the economic evaluation, the combined direct and non-direct costs will be compared with changes in mental health in the intervention arm. Ethics and dissemination The trial is approved by the Ethics Council of the Schizophrenia Research Foundation, India, with approval number EC/NEW/INST/2023/TN/0329. We plan to publish the main impact, process and economic evaluation results as academic publications in international peer-reviewed journals in 2026. Trial registration number Clinical Trials Registry—India (CTRI/2024/07/070949).
Open AccessYouth co-production for sustainable engagement and empowerment in health (YiPEE): protocol for a cluster-randomised controlled trial of an intervention for mental health promotion among adolescents in schools in Chennai, India
Introduction Adolescence is a time of rapid physical, social and psychological development and many risk factors for mental disorders have their roots in this age period. Primary prevention through school platforms has been extensively used and evaluated, but many interventions have poor uptake, high dropout and limited long-term sustainability. Mental health is a complex phenomenon and may be best supported through multicomponent interventions that more holistically consider inner, social and environmental levels. Character education-focused interventions are effective for improving adolescent psychosocial functioning and mental well-being. Therefore, an intervention that focuses on developing these strengths and is delivered within a school environment, through an adolescent-informed approach using creativity-focused components, has the potential to improve adolescent mental health and well-being. Methods and analysis This protocol describes the YiPEE cluster-randomised controlled trial with concurrent mixed-methods process evaluation and economic evaluation, which aims to determine the impact of a multilevel multicomponent intervention in schools in Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India. Clusters—defined as schools which include Grades 6–8 (ages 11–16 years), will be randomised to intervention (n=15) or control (n=15). The intervention consists of: an 8-week classroom-based component, a 12-week teacher-focused component and a board comprising members from across the whole school. All children attending Grade 7 (aged 12–15) will be exposed to the classroom component, and teachers who actively teach Grade 7 will be invited to participate in the teacher component. Within schools, students for the individual-level evaluation will be included if they are: (1) aged 12–15 years; (2) currently attending Grade 7; (3) competent to give consent and (4) have a legal guardian competent of giving consent. We aim to sample a minimum of 100 students from each school (n=3000). All teachers of Grades 6–8 will be recruited for the evaluation. The primary outcome is symptoms of anxiety and depression measured using an abbreviated version of the UNICEF MMAPP tool. The primary analysis will be intention-to-treat, comparing the mean change in mental health score between baseline and endline, between intervention and control clusters. In addition, we will record school monitoring data (student attendance, student grades). Individual interviews with students and teachers, focus group discussions with school staff, and ethnographic observations will provide data for the process evaluation. For the economic evaluation, the combined direct and non-direct costs will be compared with changes in mental health in the intervention arm. Ethics and dissemination The trial is approved by the Ethics Council of the Schizophrenia Research Foundation, India, with approval number EC/NEW/INST/2023/TN/0329. We plan to publish the main impact, process and economic evaluation results as academic publications in international peer-reviewed journals in 2026. Trial registration number Clinical Trials Registry—India (CTRI/2024/07/070949).
- 15 January 2025
- Published by University of Antwerp
Scaling up integrated care for chronic diseases : exploring perspectives on agency, processes, mechanisms and structures
This PhD started in 2019, embedded within the European-funded SCUBY project on facilitating scale-up of integrated care for chronic diseases in three contexts. It has now started to lead a life of its own, in this book, reflecting on agency, processes, mechanisms and structures required to scale-up. These four perspectives all support the aim of this thesis; to understand the scale-up of integrated care in diverse health systems. The role of policy dialogues, stakeholders, scale-up roadmap development and implementation and contextual processes pose central elements in this quest. Using case studies and qualitative research, we learn from scale-up efforts in a resource-constrained health system in a lower-middle-income country (Cambodia); a centrally steered health system in a high-income country (Slovenia); and a publicly-funded, highly privatised health care system in a high-income country (Belgium). We showcase and argue that both policy and (realist or theory-driven) implementation research are needed to study and close the gap between science and politics to scale-up. In summary, this thesis highlights the inherent complexity, ambiguity, uncertainty, and power dynamics involved in scaling up integrated care, emphasizing the need for collaborative, adaptive approaches that acknowledge diverse perspectives and meaningfully engage stakeholders in the problem-solving process.
- 15 January 2025
- Published by University of Antwerp
Scaling up integrated care for chronic diseases : exploring perspectives on agency, processes, mechanisms and structures
This PhD started in 2019, embedded within the European-funded SCUBY project on facilitating scale-up of integrated care for chronic diseases in three contexts. It has now started to lead a life of its own, in this book, reflecting on agency, processes, mechanisms and structures required to scale-up. These four perspectives all support the aim of this thesis; to understand the scale-up of integrated care in diverse health systems. The role of policy dialogues, stakeholders, scale-up roadmap development and implementation and contextual processes pose central elements in this quest. Using case studies and qualitative research, we learn from scale-up efforts in a resource-constrained health system in a lower-middle-income country (Cambodia); a centrally steered health system in a high-income country (Slovenia); and a publicly-funded, highly privatised health care system in a high-income country (Belgium). We showcase and argue that both policy and (realist or theory-driven) implementation research are needed to study and close the gap between science and politics to scale-up. In summary, this thesis highlights the inherent complexity, ambiguity, uncertainty, and power dynamics involved in scaling up integrated care, emphasizing the need for collaborative, adaptive approaches that acknowledge diverse perspectives and meaningfully engage stakeholders in the problem-solving process.
- Open Access
- 22 December 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Health Policy
- Vol. 160, 105243
Scaling up integrated care for chronic diseases in belgium: A process evaluation
- 22 December 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Health Policy
- Vol. 160, 105243
Open AccessScaling up integrated care for chronic diseases in belgium: A process evaluation
- Open Access
- 20 December 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 24 (4) , 17
Country-Specific Roadmaps for Scaling Up Integrated Care in Belgium, Slovenia, and Cambodia – Lessons Learned from the SCUBY Project
Introduction: The SCUBY project aimed to provide knowledge on the scaling-up of an Integrated Care Package (ICP) for type 2 diabetes and hypertension across three distinct health systems (Cambodia, Slovenia, and Belgium). Here, we analyse the different elements of the country-specific scale-up roadmaps to identify similarities and differences, and share lessons learned. Methods: Thematic analysis was used to derive crucial roadmap elements from key SCUBY documents (n = 20), including policy briefs, interim reports, research outputs, and consortium meeting notes. Results: Roadmap elements differed according to priority needs, features of the (health) systems, and partly reflected the position of the SCUBY research team within each country. Common cross-country elements were: task-shifting to patients themselves, nurses and community health workers; strengthening monitoring and evaluation; and creating an enabling environment for ICP implementation. Discussion: Scale-up of complex interventions requires continuous engagement of multiple stakeholders and contextualization of action plans. The linkage of research teams with key implementation stakeholders and policy makers creates change-teams, allowing advancement from formative research to implementation of roadmap strategies and full scale-up in due time. Conclusion: The development processes and contents of the roadmaps provided essential and reciprocal learnings. These learnings help shape future policy dialogues and best practices to tackle chronic disease in each participating country.
- 20 December 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 24 (4) , 17
Open AccessCountry-Specific Roadmaps for Scaling Up Integrated Care in Belgium, Slovenia, and Cambodia – Lessons Learned from the SCUBY Project
Introduction: The SCUBY project aimed to provide knowledge on the scaling-up of an Integrated Care Package (ICP) for type 2 diabetes and hypertension across three distinct health systems (Cambodia, Slovenia, and Belgium). Here, we analyse the different elements of the country-specific scale-up roadmaps to identify similarities and differences, and share lessons learned. Methods: Thematic analysis was used to derive crucial roadmap elements from key SCUBY documents (n = 20), including policy briefs, interim reports, research outputs, and consortium meeting notes. Results: Roadmap elements differed according to priority needs, features of the (health) systems, and partly reflected the position of the SCUBY research team within each country. Common cross-country elements were: task-shifting to patients themselves, nurses and community health workers; strengthening monitoring and evaluation; and creating an enabling environment for ICP implementation. Discussion: Scale-up of complex interventions requires continuous engagement of multiple stakeholders and contextualization of action plans. The linkage of research teams with key implementation stakeholders and policy makers creates change-teams, allowing advancement from formative research to implementation of roadmap strategies and full scale-up in due time. Conclusion: The development processes and contents of the roadmaps provided essential and reciprocal learnings. These learnings help shape future policy dialogues and best practices to tackle chronic disease in each participating country.
- Open Access
- 12 November 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 24 (4) , 8
Examining Macro-Level Barriers and Facilitators to Scaling Up Integrated Care from a Complexity Perspective: A Multi-Case Study of Cambodia, Slovenia, and Belgium
Introduction: The ‘Scale-Up diaBetes and hYpertension care’ (SCUBY) project provides evidence on scaling-up integrated care (IC) in Cambodia, Slovenia, and Belgium. This paper examines macro-level barriers and facilitators to scaling up IC in these settings. Methods: We used a multi-case study design, with each country being a case. Document review, focus groups, and stakeholder interviews were conducted. The WHO health system building blocks guided the thematic analysis. We then visualised and examined the interlinkages between barriers in each country. Results: Common challenges to scaling up IC across the three health systems relate to: governance and leadership; health workforce; inadequate health financing system; and fragmented health information systems. In Cambodia, access to non-communicable disease (NCD) services and medicine are important issues. IC scale-up is facilitated by its strong governance and public health service model in Slovenia but health workforce shortages risk progress. In Belgium, the fragmented governance system and predominant fee-for-service provider payment are important barriers. A common response to health workforce and workload challenges was task shifting: to primary care nurses in Belgium, peer supporters in Slovenia, and community health workers in Cambodia. Conclusions: Examining differences and similarities between barriers in each health system stimulated reciprocal learning. Interactions between health system barriers in specific contexts require further attention to move complex health systems forward.
- 12 November 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 24 (4) , 8
Open AccessExamining Macro-Level Barriers and Facilitators to Scaling Up Integrated Care from a Complexity Perspective: A Multi-Case Study of Cambodia, Slovenia, and Belgium
Introduction: The ‘Scale-Up diaBetes and hYpertension care’ (SCUBY) project provides evidence on scaling-up integrated care (IC) in Cambodia, Slovenia, and Belgium. This paper examines macro-level barriers and facilitators to scaling up IC in these settings. Methods: We used a multi-case study design, with each country being a case. Document review, focus groups, and stakeholder interviews were conducted. The WHO health system building blocks guided the thematic analysis. We then visualised and examined the interlinkages between barriers in each country. Results: Common challenges to scaling up IC across the three health systems relate to: governance and leadership; health workforce; inadequate health financing system; and fragmented health information systems. In Cambodia, access to non-communicable disease (NCD) services and medicine are important issues. IC scale-up is facilitated by its strong governance and public health service model in Slovenia but health workforce shortages risk progress. In Belgium, the fragmented governance system and predominant fee-for-service provider payment are important barriers. A common response to health workforce and workload challenges was task shifting: to primary care nurses in Belgium, peer supporters in Slovenia, and community health workers in Cambodia. Conclusions: Examining differences and similarities between barriers in each health system stimulated reciprocal learning. Interactions between health system barriers in specific contexts require further attention to move complex health systems forward.
- Open Access
- 8 November 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 24 (4) , 1-13
Process Evaluations for the Scale-Up of Complex Interventions – a Scoping Review
Introduction: Complex health interventions (CHIs) are common in (public) health and social care practice and policy. A process evaluation (PE) is an essential part of designing and testing CHIs and questions what is implemented, the mechanisms of change, and how context affects implementation. The scale-up of CHIs is challenging and heterogeneous, making the accompanying PE unique to the nature of the inquiry. Methods: We conducted a scoping review to describe the current practice of conducting PEs alongside or following the scale-up of CHI. Eight primary data sources were searched and data extracted on study characteristics, intervention characteristics, methods used in relation to the PE, and stakeholders included. Results: We reviewed 10,538 records and included 56 studies. Seven common thematic areas emerged in which CHIs were being scaled-up. The use of scale-up specific frameworks was rare, and common outcomes of the process evaluation focussed on barriers and facilitators in relation to the context; often obtained “once-off” using qualitative and quantitative data sources. Scale-up strategies reported were: supporting increased coverage, comprehensiveness, and institutionalisation; often simultaneously. Conclusion: Variations in the conduct of process evaluations during the scale-up phase of complex health interventions may reflect differences in context, conceptual challenges, the multi-dimensional nature of scale-up, and the point of engagement with the health care system (e.g., community-level). Ideally, a process evaluation is a recurrent continuous process, leveraging a systems-driven understanding and triangulation of qualitative and quantitative data, that takes place alongside the scale-up project to inform real-world adaptations of scale-up strategies and (untoward) mechanisms of impact when applicable.
- 8 November 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 24 (4) , 1-13
Open AccessProcess Evaluations for the Scale-Up of Complex Interventions – a Scoping Review
Introduction: Complex health interventions (CHIs) are common in (public) health and social care practice and policy. A process evaluation (PE) is an essential part of designing and testing CHIs and questions what is implemented, the mechanisms of change, and how context affects implementation. The scale-up of CHIs is challenging and heterogeneous, making the accompanying PE unique to the nature of the inquiry. Methods: We conducted a scoping review to describe the current practice of conducting PEs alongside or following the scale-up of CHI. Eight primary data sources were searched and data extracted on study characteristics, intervention characteristics, methods used in relation to the PE, and stakeholders included. Results: We reviewed 10,538 records and included 56 studies. Seven common thematic areas emerged in which CHIs were being scaled-up. The use of scale-up specific frameworks was rare, and common outcomes of the process evaluation focussed on barriers and facilitators in relation to the context; often obtained “once-off” using qualitative and quantitative data sources. Scale-up strategies reported were: supporting increased coverage, comprehensiveness, and institutionalisation; often simultaneously. Conclusion: Variations in the conduct of process evaluations during the scale-up phase of complex health interventions may reflect differences in context, conceptual challenges, the multi-dimensional nature of scale-up, and the point of engagement with the health care system (e.g., community-level). Ideally, a process evaluation is a recurrent continuous process, leveraging a systems-driven understanding and triangulation of qualitative and quantitative data, that takes place alongside the scale-up project to inform real-world adaptations of scale-up strategies and (untoward) mechanisms of impact when applicable.
- Open Access
- 28 June 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 24 (2) , 27
Evaluation of the Implementation of Integrated Primary Care for Patients with Type 2 Diabetes and Hypertension in Belgium, Cambodia, and Slovenia
Integrated care of chronic patients improves quality of their management, but there is scarce evidence of its implementation in different healthcare settings. With this article, we wanted to determine the level of integrated care implementation in the management of T2D (diabetes) and HT (hypertension) in three different settings: Belgium, Slovenia, and Cambodia. This was an observational study with integrated approach. It was conducted in primary health care organisations in three countries. In each primary health care organisation, we aimed to include primary care workers that worked with Type 2 Diabetes (T2D) and hypertension (HT) patients. Data was collected with the Integrated Care Package (ICP) grid (consisting of six elements: identification, treatment, health education, self-management, caregiver collaboration, and care organisation). ICP is almost completely implemented without major differences within Slovenia. There is a considerable variability across practice types in Belgium. Implementation is constrained by health system resources in Cambodia. Some elements, especially identification, are better implemented then others, across health systems. Countries can enhance integrated care for chronic diseases by implementing central policies, standardized protocols, and local adaptation, addressing resource constraints, promoting systematic screening and health education, and providing training for healthcare workers, tailored to community needs, to improve patient outcomes and healthcare delivery.
- 28 June 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 24 (2) , 27
Open AccessEvaluation of the Implementation of Integrated Primary Care for Patients with Type 2 Diabetes and Hypertension in Belgium, Cambodia, and Slovenia
Integrated care of chronic patients improves quality of their management, but there is scarce evidence of its implementation in different healthcare settings. With this article, we wanted to determine the level of integrated care implementation in the management of T2D (diabetes) and HT (hypertension) in three different settings: Belgium, Slovenia, and Cambodia. This was an observational study with integrated approach. It was conducted in primary health care organisations in three countries. In each primary health care organisation, we aimed to include primary care workers that worked with Type 2 Diabetes (T2D) and hypertension (HT) patients. Data was collected with the Integrated Care Package (ICP) grid (consisting of six elements: identification, treatment, health education, self-management, caregiver collaboration, and care organisation). ICP is almost completely implemented without major differences within Slovenia. There is a considerable variability across practice types in Belgium. Implementation is constrained by health system resources in Cambodia. Some elements, especially identification, are better implemented then others, across health systems. Countries can enhance integrated care for chronic diseases by implementing central policies, standardized protocols, and local adaptation, addressing resource constraints, promoting systematic screening and health education, and providing training for healthcare workers, tailored to community needs, to improve patient outcomes and healthcare delivery.
- Open Access
- 22 March 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 24 (1) , 20
Development of a Qualitative Data Analysis Codebook for Arterial Hypertension and Type-2-Diabetes Integrated Care Evaluation
Introduction: Non-communicable diseases, such as arterial hypertension (HTN) and type-2 diabetes (T2D), pose a global public health problem. Integrated care with focus on person-centred principles aims to enhance healthcare quality and access. Previous qualitative research has identified facilitators and barriers for scaling-up integrated care, however the lack of standardized terms and measures hinder cross-country comparisons. This paper addresses these gaps by presenting a generic codebook for qualitative research on integrated care implementation for HTN and T2D. Description: The codebook serves as a tool for deductive or deductive-inductive qualitative analysis, organizing concepts and themes from qualitative data. It consists of nine first level and 39 second level themes. First level codes cover core issues; and second level codes provide detailed insights into facilitators and barriers. Discussion: his codebook is more widely applicable than previously developed tools because it includes a broader scope of stakeholders across micro, meso, and macro levels, and the themes being derived from highly diverse health systems across high- and low-income countries. Conclusion: The codebook is a useful tool for implementation research on integrated care for HTN and T2D at global scale. It facilitates cross-country learning, contributing to improved implementation, scale-up and outcomes.
- 22 March 2024
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 24 (1) , 20
Open AccessDevelopment of a Qualitative Data Analysis Codebook for Arterial Hypertension and Type-2-Diabetes Integrated Care Evaluation
Introduction: Non-communicable diseases, such as arterial hypertension (HTN) and type-2 diabetes (T2D), pose a global public health problem. Integrated care with focus on person-centred principles aims to enhance healthcare quality and access. Previous qualitative research has identified facilitators and barriers for scaling-up integrated care, however the lack of standardized terms and measures hinder cross-country comparisons. This paper addresses these gaps by presenting a generic codebook for qualitative research on integrated care implementation for HTN and T2D. Description: The codebook serves as a tool for deductive or deductive-inductive qualitative analysis, organizing concepts and themes from qualitative data. It consists of nine first level and 39 second level themes. First level codes cover core issues; and second level codes provide detailed insights into facilitators and barriers. Discussion: his codebook is more widely applicable than previously developed tools because it includes a broader scope of stakeholders across micro, meso, and macro levels, and the themes being derived from highly diverse health systems across high- and low-income countries. Conclusion: The codebook is a useful tool for implementation research on integrated care for HTN and T2D at global scale. It facilitates cross-country learning, contributing to improved implementation, scale-up and outcomes.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 1-35
Learning from Integrated Care in Belgium: Implementation Challenges and Opportunities
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 1-35
Learning from Integrated Care in Belgium: Implementation Challenges and Opportunities
- Open Access
- 28 December 2023
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 23 (S1) , 66
Scaling up integrated care: a realist evaluation on the role of country-specific policy dialogues and scale-up roadmaps in Belgium, Slovenia, and Cambodia
Background: The ‘SCale-Up of diaBetes and hYpertension care’ (SCUBY) project aims to support the scale-up of integrated care for diabetes and hypertension in Cambodia, Slovenia, and Belgium through the co-creation, implementation, and evaluation of contextualized roadmaps. These roadmaps offer avenues for action and are built on evidence as well as stakeholder engagement in policy dialogues. These two implementation strategies – roadmaps and policy dialogues – are very much intertwined and considered to be key elements for successful stakeholder supported scale-up. Yet, little is known about how, why, and under which conditions a roadmap leads to successful implementation and scale-up of integrated care. Therefore, the resulting research question is: ‘How, why, and under which context conditions does a co-created scale-up roadmap lead to adoption, implementation, and scale-up of integrated care?’. Methods: A realist approach is used towards testing the initial programme theory (IPT) in the three countries. The IPT draws on political science theory of the multiple streams model (MSM) adapted by Howlett and includes five streams (problem, solution, politics, process and programme) that can emerge, converge and diverge across all policy stages. To test the IPT, information from different sources was collected. Firstly, qualitative interviews were conducted with the researchers in the SCUBY country teams as well as with key stakeholders (health facility managers, policy makers, civil servants, professional medical and patient associations, NGOs, and implementers). Secondly, a document review of grey literature, meeting reports, and official documents was performed. Finally, a workshop was organised with SCUBY researchers from all country teams to refine the IPT. We used the Intervention-Context-Actors-Mechanism-Outcome (ICAMO) configuration to synthesise information into a configurational map. Results: In each country case, the project partner’s mandate was key in the approach to scale-up, the design, and content, leading to different mechanisms, scale-up pathways, and outcomes. In Belgium, the (scientific) solutions stream was dominant with creating common understanding as a key mechanism; in Slovenia, the programme stream became the dominant focus whilst exemplifying good practices of patient empowerment; and in Cambodia, the political stream was dominant yet closely knit together with the solutions stream – with knowledge sharing and credibility as key mechanisms. A finding across all three countries was that a lack of political support can derail or slow down scale-up. Discussion: This study extends the knowledge base about the use of co-creation in policy dialogues to build a roadmap for scale-up. The roadmaps illustrate how the MSM theory can be used to theorize the policy process of roadmap and policy dialogues in different contexts, aligning the context-dominant stream with the context-specific scale-up strategy. By testing theories in real cases, the theories can be adapted, refuted and/or reconstructed to elicit a refined theory of how and why a roadmap co-created in policy dialogues for scale-up works.
- 28 December 2023
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 23 (S1) , 66
Open AccessScaling up integrated care: a realist evaluation on the role of country-specific policy dialogues and scale-up roadmaps in Belgium, Slovenia, and Cambodia
Background: The ‘SCale-Up of diaBetes and hYpertension care’ (SCUBY) project aims to support the scale-up of integrated care for diabetes and hypertension in Cambodia, Slovenia, and Belgium through the co-creation, implementation, and evaluation of contextualized roadmaps. These roadmaps offer avenues for action and are built on evidence as well as stakeholder engagement in policy dialogues. These two implementation strategies – roadmaps and policy dialogues – are very much intertwined and considered to be key elements for successful stakeholder supported scale-up. Yet, little is known about how, why, and under which conditions a roadmap leads to successful implementation and scale-up of integrated care. Therefore, the resulting research question is: ‘How, why, and under which context conditions does a co-created scale-up roadmap lead to adoption, implementation, and scale-up of integrated care?’. Methods: A realist approach is used towards testing the initial programme theory (IPT) in the three countries. The IPT draws on political science theory of the multiple streams model (MSM) adapted by Howlett and includes five streams (problem, solution, politics, process and programme) that can emerge, converge and diverge across all policy stages. To test the IPT, information from different sources was collected. Firstly, qualitative interviews were conducted with the researchers in the SCUBY country teams as well as with key stakeholders (health facility managers, policy makers, civil servants, professional medical and patient associations, NGOs, and implementers). Secondly, a document review of grey literature, meeting reports, and official documents was performed. Finally, a workshop was organised with SCUBY researchers from all country teams to refine the IPT. We used the Intervention-Context-Actors-Mechanism-Outcome (ICAMO) configuration to synthesise information into a configurational map. Results: In each country case, the project partner’s mandate was key in the approach to scale-up, the design, and content, leading to different mechanisms, scale-up pathways, and outcomes. In Belgium, the (scientific) solutions stream was dominant with creating common understanding as a key mechanism; in Slovenia, the programme stream became the dominant focus whilst exemplifying good practices of patient empowerment; and in Cambodia, the political stream was dominant yet closely knit together with the solutions stream – with knowledge sharing and credibility as key mechanisms. A finding across all three countries was that a lack of political support can derail or slow down scale-up. Discussion: This study extends the knowledge base about the use of co-creation in policy dialogues to build a roadmap for scale-up. The roadmaps illustrate how the MSM theory can be used to theorize the policy process of roadmap and policy dialogues in different contexts, aligning the context-dominant stream with the context-specific scale-up strategy. By testing theories in real cases, the theories can be adapted, refuted and/or reconstructed to elicit a refined theory of how and why a roadmap co-created in policy dialogues for scale-up works.