Yi Wang
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Yi Wang has a total of 29 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jing Zhao
College of Instrumentation and Electrical Engineering, Jilin University, Changchun, China
7 shared publications - Liangguang Yue
College of Instrumentation and Electrical Engineering, Jilin University, Changchun, China
4 shared publications - Wenliang Cao
College of Instrumentation and Electrical Engineering, Jilin University, Changchun, China
4 shared publications - Hongxing Zhu
College of Instrumentation and Electrical Engineering, Jilin University, Changchun, China
3 shared publications - Siming He
School of Electrical and Information Engineering, Changchun Institute of Technology, Changchun, China
3 shared publications - Yong Wang
Jilin University
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 17 March 2026
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing
- Vol. 64 (01962892) , 1-14
A Novel Real-Time Method for 3-D Localization and Magnetic Moment Estimation of Multiple Targets
This article proposes a real-time step-by-step method (SSM) based on an improved orthogonal basis function (IOBF) theory for 3D localization and magnetic moment (MM) estimation of multiple magnetic sources. SSM first determines targets’ X-coordinates by detecting peaks in rotationally invariant fusion energy, followed by a dual-fluxgate architecture to resolve Y- and Z-coordinates. After localization, MMs of all targets are jointly estimated via least-squares fitting. Unlike classical OBF methods, SSM eliminates reliance on the predefined CPA distance R0 by accurately estimating it, suppresses error propagation, is immune to misalignment errors, and avoids inherent localization error. Compared with the state-of-the-art optimization method (OPM), SSM delivers superior accuracy and exceptional efficiency. Both simulation and field experiments consistently demonstrate that SSM achieves lower errors and over 20-fold faster execution than OPM. Performance in real-world high-noise environment further validates the accuracy and robustness of the proposed method. Rigorous mathematical derivations, implementation simplicity, and extremely fast execution highlight considerable potential of SSM for real-time remote sensing applications.
- 17 March 2026
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing
- Vol. 64 (01962892) , 1-14
A Novel Real-Time Method for 3-D Localization and Magnetic Moment Estimation of Multiple Targets
This article proposes a real-time step-by-step method (SSM) based on an improved orthogonal basis function (IOBF) theory for 3D localization and magnetic moment (MM) estimation of multiple magnetic sources. SSM first determines targets’ X-coordinates by detecting peaks in rotationally invariant fusion energy, followed by a dual-fluxgate architecture to resolve Y- and Z-coordinates. After localization, MMs of all targets are jointly estimated via least-squares fitting. Unlike classical OBF methods, SSM eliminates reliance on the predefined CPA distance R0 by accurately estimating it, suppresses error propagation, is immune to misalignment errors, and avoids inherent localization error. Compared with the state-of-the-art optimization method (OPM), SSM delivers superior accuracy and exceptional efficiency. Both simulation and field experiments consistently demonstrate that SSM achieves lower errors and over 20-fold faster execution than OPM. Performance in real-world high-noise environment further validates the accuracy and robustness of the proposed method. Rigorous mathematical derivations, implementation simplicity, and extremely fast execution highlight considerable potential of SSM for real-time remote sensing applications.
- 11 August 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 74 (00189456) , 1-12
A Novel Magnetic Multitarget Localization Method Based on Energy Mutation Detection
Multitarget localization methods based on survey area data have significant efficiency advantages in applications such as unexploded ordnance detection. However, the existing methods still have many problems, including the target detection accuracy depends on the prior information, the parameter estimation accuracy is affected by the number of targets, the localization result is sensitive to the change of the magnetic moment direction, and the horizontal localization accuracy exhibits significant anisotropy. To solve these problems, this study proposes a novel magnetic multitarget localization method based on energy mutation detection. The method first transforms magnetic anomaly gradient vertical to the survey line (GVSL) into the energy domain using 2-D orthogonal basis functions (2D-OBFs), generating a new energy function. Then, the energy mutation detection method is used to identify target energy within local energy peaks. Finally, the target’s horizontal coordinates are determined based on the peak locations. Simulation results demonstrate the proposed method’s significant advantages over the total field 2-D OBF method. At a noise standard deviation (STD) of 20 nT/m, the method reduces the root-mean-square errors (RMSEs) of localization results in X- and Y-directions by 88.6% and 86.0%, respectively, while decreasing anisotropy in horizontal localization accuracy by 92.8%. Moreover, the method exhibits enhanced robustness to magnetic moment direction variations. In multitarget localization experiment, all targets were successfully identified, confirming the efficacy of the energy mutation detection method. Field experimental results closely match simulation data, underscoring the method’s practical utility.
- 11 August 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 74 (00189456) , 1-12
A Novel Magnetic Multitarget Localization Method Based on Energy Mutation Detection
Multitarget localization methods based on survey area data have significant efficiency advantages in applications such as unexploded ordnance detection. However, the existing methods still have many problems, including the target detection accuracy depends on the prior information, the parameter estimation accuracy is affected by the number of targets, the localization result is sensitive to the change of the magnetic moment direction, and the horizontal localization accuracy exhibits significant anisotropy. To solve these problems, this study proposes a novel magnetic multitarget localization method based on energy mutation detection. The method first transforms magnetic anomaly gradient vertical to the survey line (GVSL) into the energy domain using 2-D orthogonal basis functions (2D-OBFs), generating a new energy function. Then, the energy mutation detection method is used to identify target energy within local energy peaks. Finally, the target’s horizontal coordinates are determined based on the peak locations. Simulation results demonstrate the proposed method’s significant advantages over the total field 2-D OBF method. At a noise standard deviation (STD) of 20 nT/m, the method reduces the root-mean-square errors (RMSEs) of localization results in X- and Y-directions by 88.6% and 86.0%, respectively, while decreasing anisotropy in horizontal localization accuracy by 92.8%. Moreover, the method exhibits enhanced robustness to magnetic moment direction variations. In multitarget localization experiment, all targets were successfully identified, confirming the efficacy of the energy mutation detection method. Field experimental results closely match simulation data, underscoring the method’s practical utility.
- 23 May 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Sensors Journal
- Vol. 25 (13) , 25047-25062
A Novel Method for Magnetic Anomaly Localization and Magnetic Moment Orientation Estimation Using a Three-Axis Fluxgate Sensor
Using the simplest sensor setup to achieve magnetic anomaly localization and magnetic moment orientation estimation is significant in magnetic anomaly detection. This paper presents a novel approach using a single fluxgate sensor to accomplish this goal. In the proposed method, the number and horizontal positions of magnetic targets are determined by 2D constant false alarm rate (2D CFAR) detection applied to pseudo l2 norm energy. The remaining parameters are then estimated by minimizing a pseudo l1 norm energy loss function. Compared with fixed-threshold detection, this method achieves 2D dynamic threshold detection, effectively mitigating the risk of missing low-energy targets. Unlike traditional magnetic anomaly-based optimization, this method innovatively performs inversion in energy domain, significantly enhancing noise resilience. Moreover, it keeps the number of optimization parameters constant as target count increases, avoiding the accuracy deterioration commonly associated with parameter growth. In Monte Carlo comparison experiment at 20 nT noise level, the proposed method outperformed the total magnetic field 2D orthogonal basis function method, achieving approximately 59 and 81% improvements in the root mean square error of horizontal localization and false alarm rate, respectively. Single-target simulations demonstrated the effectiveness of the proposed method, while multi-target simulation confirmed its robustness. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of total energy exhibits a 25.51 dB improvement over the average SNR of magnetic anomaly components, underscoring strong noise suppression capability. Field experiments involving both single and multiple targets yielded results consistent with simulations, further validating the method’s practicality.
- 23 May 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Sensors Journal
- Vol. 25 (13) , 25047-25062
A Novel Method for Magnetic Anomaly Localization and Magnetic Moment Orientation Estimation Using a Three-Axis Fluxgate Sensor
Using the simplest sensor setup to achieve magnetic anomaly localization and magnetic moment orientation estimation is significant in magnetic anomaly detection. This paper presents a novel approach using a single fluxgate sensor to accomplish this goal. In the proposed method, the number and horizontal positions of magnetic targets are determined by 2D constant false alarm rate (2D CFAR) detection applied to pseudo l2 norm energy. The remaining parameters are then estimated by minimizing a pseudo l1 norm energy loss function. Compared with fixed-threshold detection, this method achieves 2D dynamic threshold detection, effectively mitigating the risk of missing low-energy targets. Unlike traditional magnetic anomaly-based optimization, this method innovatively performs inversion in energy domain, significantly enhancing noise resilience. Moreover, it keeps the number of optimization parameters constant as target count increases, avoiding the accuracy deterioration commonly associated with parameter growth. In Monte Carlo comparison experiment at 20 nT noise level, the proposed method outperformed the total magnetic field 2D orthogonal basis function method, achieving approximately 59 and 81% improvements in the root mean square error of horizontal localization and false alarm rate, respectively. Single-target simulations demonstrated the effectiveness of the proposed method, while multi-target simulation confirmed its robustness. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of total energy exhibits a 25.51 dB improvement over the average SNR of magnetic anomaly components, underscoring strong noise suppression capability. Field experiments involving both single and multiple targets yielded results consistent with simulations, further validating the method’s practicality.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Geoscience and Remote Sensing Letters
- Vol. 21 (1545598X) , 1-5
A Dual Scalar Magnetic Target Localization Method Using Anderson Basis Functions and Cuckoo-Search-Based Spiral Update
Efficient and accurate magnetic target localization methods have important value in navigation, archaeology and other fields. The current scalar positioning technology of magnetic target mainly adopts more than two scalar magnetometers to form a spatial gradient observation array. However, this method has some shortcomings, such as requiring multiple magnetometers, perpendicular gradient axes and appropriate baseline distance. Therefore, this letter proposes a method with a horizontal structured dual scalar magnetometers. Firstly, we construct a set of Anderson basis functions using the magnetic anomaly signals measured by two magnetometers respectively, and further solve them using an Improved Cuckoo Search (ICS) algorithm based on the idea of spiral update. Finally, the exact estimation of the target characteristic parameters is achieved by combining the spatial structure relationship of the two magnetometers. The proposed method greatly reduces the number of magnetometers required and does not need to consider the baseline distance and gradient axis non-vertical problems. Numerical simulation results show that the target depth is in the range of [10 m, 25 m], with a root mean square error (RMSE) of target position and magnetic moment below 0.4 m and 30 A·m 2 , respectively. The results of field experimental data further demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Geoscience and Remote Sensing Letters
- Vol. 21 (1545598X) , 1-5
A Dual Scalar Magnetic Target Localization Method Using Anderson Basis Functions and Cuckoo-Search-Based Spiral Update
Efficient and accurate magnetic target localization methods have important value in navigation, archaeology and other fields. The current scalar positioning technology of magnetic target mainly adopts more than two scalar magnetometers to form a spatial gradient observation array. However, this method has some shortcomings, such as requiring multiple magnetometers, perpendicular gradient axes and appropriate baseline distance. Therefore, this letter proposes a method with a horizontal structured dual scalar magnetometers. Firstly, we construct a set of Anderson basis functions using the magnetic anomaly signals measured by two magnetometers respectively, and further solve them using an Improved Cuckoo Search (ICS) algorithm based on the idea of spiral update. Finally, the exact estimation of the target characteristic parameters is achieved by combining the spatial structure relationship of the two magnetometers. The proposed method greatly reduces the number of magnetometers required and does not need to consider the baseline distance and gradient axis non-vertical problems. Numerical simulation results show that the target depth is in the range of [10 m, 25 m], with a root mean square error (RMSE) of target position and magnetic moment below 0.4 m and 30 A·m 2 , respectively. The results of field experimental data further demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2024
- Published by AIP Publishing in Review of Scientific Instruments
- Vol. 95 (2)
A method for measuring soil water content based on principal component analysis
Principal component analysis (PCA) has been applied in many aspects. To address the problem of measuring water content in soil, this paper proposes a method to measure soil water content based on the PCA. We used PCA to reduce the dimension of the data and processed the soil amplitude ratio frequency response spectra. First, we designed the measuring device and measured the soil amplitude ratio frequency response data of different water content, then we used the PCA to extract features from the frequency response spectra of different water contents, established a relationship model of soil water content, and finally, we solved the model, the maximum error between the calculation results and the actual water content was no more than 0.85%. Subsequently, we carried out experimental verification, and we measured six kinds of soil with known water content by this method. The experimental results showed that the maximum error did not exceed 1.16%, and the average error was 0.71%. Thus, the proposed method can provide a useful way of measuring soil water content.
- 1 February 2024
- Published by AIP Publishing in Review of Scientific Instruments
- Vol. 95 (2)
Open AccessA method for measuring soil water content based on principal component analysis
Principal component analysis (PCA) has been applied in many aspects. To address the problem of measuring water content in soil, this paper proposes a method to measure soil water content based on the PCA. We used PCA to reduce the dimension of the data and processed the soil amplitude ratio frequency response spectra. First, we designed the measuring device and measured the soil amplitude ratio frequency response data of different water content, then we used the PCA to extract features from the frequency response spectra of different water contents, established a relationship model of soil water content, and finally, we solved the model, the maximum error between the calculation results and the actual water content was no more than 0.85%. Subsequently, we carried out experimental verification, and we measured six kinds of soil with known water content by this method. The experimental results showed that the maximum error did not exceed 1.16%, and the average error was 0.71%. Thus, the proposed method can provide a useful way of measuring soil water content.
- 14 September 2023
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Geoscience and Remote Sensing Letters
- Vol. 20 (1545598X) , 1-5
Joint Use of Scalar and Vector Magnetometers for Underwater Magnetic Target Localization
Autonomous Underwater Vehicle (AUV) with towed Magnetic Anomaly Detection (MAD) system is a reliable technique for detecting underwater magnetic targets. However, arranging too many magnetometers in the towed MAD system is not suitable, and the key lies in their reasonable arrangement. As a result, this paper proposes a new MAD system equipped with two scalar and one vector magnetometers, along with the corresponding multi-parameter magnetic target localization method. By using two scalar magnetometers and the geometric relationship with vector magnetometer, the time when the vector magnetometer reaches the closest point approach (CPA) on the trajectory and the value range of the shortest distance are obtained. The value range of the shortest distance is cleverly set as the search boundary for the improved particle swarm optimization algorithm in this dimension, which greatly mitigates the randomness of the optimization algorithm and enhances the accuracy of the solution. Subsequently, the unique solution for the magnetic target parameters can be easily obtained by using the vector magnetometer. The combination of scalar and vector magnetometers proves to be both economical and effective. Numerical simulation and field experiments show that this method provides a new idea for static magnetic target detection.
- 14 September 2023
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Geoscience and Remote Sensing Letters
- Vol. 20 (1545598X) , 1-5
Joint Use of Scalar and Vector Magnetometers for Underwater Magnetic Target Localization
Autonomous Underwater Vehicle (AUV) with towed Magnetic Anomaly Detection (MAD) system is a reliable technique for detecting underwater magnetic targets. However, arranging too many magnetometers in the towed MAD system is not suitable, and the key lies in their reasonable arrangement. As a result, this paper proposes a new MAD system equipped with two scalar and one vector magnetometers, along with the corresponding multi-parameter magnetic target localization method. By using two scalar magnetometers and the geometric relationship with vector magnetometer, the time when the vector magnetometer reaches the closest point approach (CPA) on the trajectory and the value range of the shortest distance are obtained. The value range of the shortest distance is cleverly set as the search boundary for the improved particle swarm optimization algorithm in this dimension, which greatly mitigates the randomness of the optimization algorithm and enhances the accuracy of the solution. Subsequently, the unique solution for the magnetic target parameters can be easily obtained by using the vector magnetometer. The combination of scalar and vector magnetometers proves to be both economical and effective. Numerical simulation and field experiments show that this method provides a new idea for static magnetic target detection.
- 7 April 2023
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Sensors Journal
- Vol. 23 (10) , 10694-10705
Compensation Method for the Carrier Magnetic Interference of Underwater Magnetic Vector Measurement System
This paper proposed a new compensation method of underwater magnetic vector measurement system which innovatively using the geomagnetic total field as benchmark. Moreover, this method does not require the use of heading angle data in the calculation of the compensation parameters, which avoids errors caused by insufficient accuracy of underwater heading angle. The implementation of these features relies on the new objective function constructed according to the characteristics of the spatial projection of the magnetic vector field on the horizontal plane of the geographical coordinate. The core matrix of the geomagnetic vector ellipsoid model is used as a constraint to determine the range of function solutions. The Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm is used to find the optimal solution to the new objective function. Three experiments were carried out to verify the proposed method. In simulation experiment, the deviation between the calculated value and the preset value is less than 0.01%. In field experiment, the standard deviation value of x, y, z magnetic components and the root mean square error of magnetic total field after compensation are reduced from 1527.38nT, 1397.35nT, 1529.16nT, 574.94nT to 9.86nT (0.65%), 9.99nT (0.72%), 5.63nT (0.38%), 2.14nT (0.37%). The proposed method is finally verified by marine experiment. The standard deviation value of x, y, z magnetic components and the root mean square error of magnetic total field after compensation are reduced from 575.02 nT, 830.60 nT, 620.95 nT, 1702.35 nT to 17.43 nT (1.11%), 14.14 nT (1.70%), 25.17nT (4.10%), 7.18 nT (0.42%).
- 7 April 2023
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Sensors Journal
- Vol. 23 (10) , 10694-10705
Compensation Method for the Carrier Magnetic Interference of Underwater Magnetic Vector Measurement System
This paper proposed a new compensation method of underwater magnetic vector measurement system which innovatively using the geomagnetic total field as benchmark. Moreover, this method does not require the use of heading angle data in the calculation of the compensation parameters, which avoids errors caused by insufficient accuracy of underwater heading angle. The implementation of these features relies on the new objective function constructed according to the characteristics of the spatial projection of the magnetic vector field on the horizontal plane of the geographical coordinate. The core matrix of the geomagnetic vector ellipsoid model is used as a constraint to determine the range of function solutions. The Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm is used to find the optimal solution to the new objective function. Three experiments were carried out to verify the proposed method. In simulation experiment, the deviation between the calculated value and the preset value is less than 0.01%. In field experiment, the standard deviation value of x, y, z magnetic components and the root mean square error of magnetic total field after compensation are reduced from 1527.38nT, 1397.35nT, 1529.16nT, 574.94nT to 9.86nT (0.65%), 9.99nT (0.72%), 5.63nT (0.38%), 2.14nT (0.37%). The proposed method is finally verified by marine experiment. The standard deviation value of x, y, z magnetic components and the root mean square error of magnetic total field after compensation are reduced from 575.02 nT, 830.60 nT, 620.95 nT, 1702.35 nT to 17.43 nT (1.11%), 14.14 nT (1.70%), 25.17nT (4.10%), 7.18 nT (0.42%).
- 6 September 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Pure and Applied Geophysics
- Vol. 178 (9) , 3619-3628
A Fusion Approach for Suppression of Environmental Noise in Spread Spectrum Induced Polarization Data
- 6 September 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Pure and Applied Geophysics
- Vol. 178 (9) , 3619-3628
A Fusion Approach for Suppression of Environmental Noise in Spread Spectrum Induced Polarization Data
- Open Access
- 19 May 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics
- Vol. 28 (2) , 247-256
An enhanced correlation identification algorithm and its application on spread spectrum induced polarization data
In spread spectrum induced polarization (SSIP) data processing, attenuation of background noise from the observed data is the essential step that improves the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of SSIP data. The time-domain spectral induced polarization based on pseudorandom sequence (TSIP) algorithm has been proposed to improve the SNR of these data. However, signal processing in background noise is still a challenging problem. We propose an enhanced correlation identification (ECI) algorithm to attenuate the background noise. In this algorithm, the cross-correlation matching method is helpful for the extraction of useful components of the raw SSIP data and suppression of background noise. Then the frequency-domain IP (FDIP) method is used for extracting the frequency response of the observation system. Experiments on both synthetic and real SSIP data show that the ECI algorithm will not only suppress the background noise but also better preserve the valid information of the raw SSIP data to display the actual location and shape of adjacent high-resistivity anomalies, which can improve subsequent steps in SSIP data processing and imaging.
- 19 May 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics
- Vol. 28 (2) , 247-256
Open AccessAn enhanced correlation identification algorithm and its application on spread spectrum induced polarization data
In spread spectrum induced polarization (SSIP) data processing, attenuation of background noise from the observed data is the essential step that improves the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of SSIP data. The time-domain spectral induced polarization based on pseudorandom sequence (TSIP) algorithm has been proposed to improve the SNR of these data. However, signal processing in background noise is still a challenging problem. We propose an enhanced correlation identification (ECI) algorithm to attenuate the background noise. In this algorithm, the cross-correlation matching method is helpful for the extraction of useful components of the raw SSIP data and suppression of background noise. Then the frequency-domain IP (FDIP) method is used for extracting the frequency response of the observation system. Experiments on both synthetic and real SSIP data show that the ECI algorithm will not only suppress the background noise but also better preserve the valid information of the raw SSIP data to display the actual location and shape of adjacent high-resistivity anomalies, which can improve subsequent steps in SSIP data processing and imaging.
- 9 April 2021
- Published by Society of Exploration Geophysicists in Geophysics
- Vol. 86 (4) , E297-E303
A hybrid correlation denoising method based on complex resistivity and application on spread-spectrum induced-polarization data
In electrical exploration techniques, an effective suppression method for Gaussian and impulsive random noise in spread-spectrum induced-polarization (SSIP) data continues to be challenging for conventional denoising methods. Remnant noise influences the complex resistivity spectrum and damages the subsequent interpretation of geophysical surveys. We have developed a hybrid method based on a correlation function and complex resistivity, which introduces the correlation analyses among the transmitting source, the measured potential, and the injected current signal. According to the analyses, reliable results for complex resistivity spectra can be calculated, which can be further used for noise suppression. We apply the hybrid method to numerical and field experiments to process the measured SSIP data. Simulation tests find that the hybrid method not only suppresses the two types of noise but also improves the relative error of the complex resistivity spectrum. Field data processing indicates that the hybrid method can minimize the standard deviation of the data and can have a greater ability to distinguish adjacent objects, which can improve the reliability of the data in subsequent processing and interpretation.
- 9 April 2021
- Published by Society of Exploration Geophysicists in Geophysics
- Vol. 86 (4) , E297-E303
A hybrid correlation denoising method based on complex resistivity and application on spread-spectrum induced-polarization data
In electrical exploration techniques, an effective suppression method for Gaussian and impulsive random noise in spread-spectrum induced-polarization (SSIP) data continues to be challenging for conventional denoising methods. Remnant noise influences the complex resistivity spectrum and damages the subsequent interpretation of geophysical surveys. We have developed a hybrid method based on a correlation function and complex resistivity, which introduces the correlation analyses among the transmitting source, the measured potential, and the injected current signal. According to the analyses, reliable results for complex resistivity spectra can be calculated, which can be further used for noise suppression. We apply the hybrid method to numerical and field experiments to process the measured SSIP data. Simulation tests find that the hybrid method not only suppresses the two types of noise but also improves the relative error of the complex resistivity spectrum. Field data processing indicates that the hybrid method can minimize the standard deviation of the data and can have a greater ability to distinguish adjacent objects, which can improve the reliability of the data in subsequent processing and interpretation.