Huw Nolan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Huw Nolan has a total of 19 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jo Coghlan
University of New England
10 shared publications - Lisa J. Hackett
University of New England
7 shared publications - Jenny Wise
ISNI: University of New England
4 shared publications - Lesley McLean
ISNI: University of New England
2 shared publications - Alistair Harkness
University of New England
1 shared publication - Andrew J. Bengsen
ANSW Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development, Vertebrate Pest Research Unit, 4 Marsden Park Road, Calala, NSW 2340, Australia
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 64-81
Dead Threads
This chapter theorises the semiotic, ideological, and discursive roles played by costuming in Gothic and horror narratives across transmedia platforms. Drawing upon critical frameworks including theories of monstrosity, abjection, and cultural semiotics, it examines how costume operates not just as a visual signifier but as an ideological tool for constructing and problematising notions of identity, otherness, and cultural anxiety. The analysis is structured around four thematic discussions: the aesthetics and semiotics of Gothic and horror costuming, which outlines how costumes encode and externalise psychological and societal fears through visual symbolism; monstrosity and gender, analysing the ideological implications of costuming as a means of demarcating deviance, gender fluidity, and the instability of cultural norms; the undead and aesthetics of decay, exploring how costuming represents social critique through depictions of decay, disruption, and everyday horror; and finally, the transmedia circulation of monstrous costuming, investigating how costumes function beyond narrative contexts as dynamic, evolving cultural artefacts through practices such as cosplay, fan appropriations, “monstrous” dolls including Barbie, and high-fashion reinterpretations. This chapter positions Gothic and horror costuming as fluid signifiers that continually adapt to shifting socio-cultural discourses, reflecting broader processes of identity formation, and collective anxieties within popular and media culture.
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 64-81
Dead Threads
This chapter theorises the semiotic, ideological, and discursive roles played by costuming in Gothic and horror narratives across transmedia platforms. Drawing upon critical frameworks including theories of monstrosity, abjection, and cultural semiotics, it examines how costume operates not just as a visual signifier but as an ideological tool for constructing and problematising notions of identity, otherness, and cultural anxiety. The analysis is structured around four thematic discussions: the aesthetics and semiotics of Gothic and horror costuming, which outlines how costumes encode and externalise psychological and societal fears through visual symbolism; monstrosity and gender, analysing the ideological implications of costuming as a means of demarcating deviance, gender fluidity, and the instability of cultural norms; the undead and aesthetics of decay, exploring how costuming represents social critique through depictions of decay, disruption, and everyday horror; and finally, the transmedia circulation of monstrous costuming, investigating how costumes function beyond narrative contexts as dynamic, evolving cultural artefacts through practices such as cosplay, fan appropriations, “monstrous” dolls including Barbie, and high-fashion reinterpretations. This chapter positions Gothic and horror costuming as fluid signifiers that continually adapt to shifting socio-cultural discourses, reflecting broader processes of identity formation, and collective anxieties within popular and media culture.
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Intellect in The Australasian Journal of Popular Culture
- Vol. 15 (1) , 89-108
‘Man destroys god, man creates dinosaurs’: Escaping from freedom in the Jurassic Park franchise
This article analyses the Jurassic Park and Jurassic World franchises through Erich Fromm’s Escape from Freedom , arguing that the films dramatize a recurring dialectic in which technological freedom generates new forms of domination. Fromm contends that freedom, when experienced as anxiety and insecurity, produces a desire for submission to authority. Reading the two trilogies as distinct cultural formations, the article shows how this dynamic shifts from late-twentieth-century techno-scientific optimism to post-financial crisis anxieties about corporate power and technocratic governance. It argues that the franchise organizes this dialectic through three interrelated mechanisms: commodification, engineered autonomy and structured domination. Dinosaurs are transformed from ecological beings into market assets, then granted limited agency so that responsibility, violence and control can be displaced onto them. Drawing on political theory, critical theory and animal studies, the article situates Fromm’s framework as historically and culturally specific, demonstrating how popular cinema offers crucial insight into contemporary ideologies of freedom, authority and power.
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Intellect in The Australasian Journal of Popular Culture
- Vol. 15 (1) , 89-108
‘Man destroys god, man creates dinosaurs’: Escaping from freedom in the Jurassic Park franchise
This article analyses the Jurassic Park and Jurassic World franchises through Erich Fromm’s Escape from Freedom , arguing that the films dramatize a recurring dialectic in which technological freedom generates new forms of domination. Fromm contends that freedom, when experienced as anxiety and insecurity, produces a desire for submission to authority. Reading the two trilogies as distinct cultural formations, the article shows how this dynamic shifts from late-twentieth-century techno-scientific optimism to post-financial crisis anxieties about corporate power and technocratic governance. It argues that the franchise organizes this dialectic through three interrelated mechanisms: commodification, engineered autonomy and structured domination. Dinosaurs are transformed from ecological beings into market assets, then granted limited agency so that responsibility, violence and control can be displaced onto them. Drawing on political theory, critical theory and animal studies, the article situates Fromm’s framework as historically and culturally specific, demonstrating how popular cinema offers crucial insight into contemporary ideologies of freedom, authority and power.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Intellect in International Journal of Disney Studies
- Vol. 2 (2) , 103-110
The Magic Kingdom: Exploring Disney’s Impact on Popular Culture
Disney occupies a special place in popular culture, both as a site of the imaginary and as one of the largest entertainment companies globally. Drawing on papers presented at the Popular Culture Research Network (PopCRN) international conference, The Magic Kingdom: Exploring Disney’s Impact on Popular Culture, held in July 2025, this Special Issue examines how Disney’s canon is shaped not only by its narratives, but also by their limits, silences and ambiguities. Disney presents itself as a site of family-friendly entertainment, avoiding areas of cultural contestation. This approach, however, has drawn criticism of ‘Disneyfication’: a process that seeks to maintain a conservative hegemony. This Special Issue brings together historians, sociologists, criminologists and media studies scholars to interrogate concepts of corporate power, fan engagement and representation across the Disney canon. The articles include discussions on racial erasures within the Haunted Mansion attraction, cautious depictions of queerness within the Marvel Multiverse, and fan negotiations of ambiguity in The Owl House . Conversely, analyses of moral certainty in the depictions of criminals and the narrative of rewarding specific dreams through the motif of flight reveal deliberate choices in character construction. Together, papers in this Special Issue demonstrate how Disney negotiates the pressures of popular engagement while striving to preserve its brand coherence.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Intellect in International Journal of Disney Studies
- Vol. 2 (2) , 103-110
The Magic Kingdom: Exploring Disney’s Impact on Popular Culture
Disney occupies a special place in popular culture, both as a site of the imaginary and as one of the largest entertainment companies globally. Drawing on papers presented at the Popular Culture Research Network (PopCRN) international conference, The Magic Kingdom: Exploring Disney’s Impact on Popular Culture, held in July 2025, this Special Issue examines how Disney’s canon is shaped not only by its narratives, but also by their limits, silences and ambiguities. Disney presents itself as a site of family-friendly entertainment, avoiding areas of cultural contestation. This approach, however, has drawn criticism of ‘Disneyfication’: a process that seeks to maintain a conservative hegemony. This Special Issue brings together historians, sociologists, criminologists and media studies scholars to interrogate concepts of corporate power, fan engagement and representation across the Disney canon. The articles include discussions on racial erasures within the Haunted Mansion attraction, cautious depictions of queerness within the Marvel Multiverse, and fan negotiations of ambiguity in The Owl House . Conversely, analyses of moral certainty in the depictions of criminals and the narrative of rewarding specific dreams through the motif of flight reveal deliberate choices in character construction. Together, papers in this Special Issue demonstrate how Disney negotiates the pressures of popular engagement while striving to preserve its brand coherence.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Intellect in International Journal of Disney Studies
- Vol. 2 (2) , 163-180
‘I’m going to do what I do best: lie, deceive, manipulate, and cheat’: Disney representations of crime shaping ‘real-world’ views of ‘typical’ criminals
One consequence of becoming immersed in the Disney universe from an early age is the shaping of viewers’/consumers’ perceptions about what is ‘normal’ and ‘acceptable’ behaviour. This article focuses on Disney’s portrayal of illegal behaviour, comparing and contrasting actions committed by villains and heroes to illustrate the importance of context (the act itself, who commits the act and the motivations driving the behaviour) in shaping viewers’ understandings of criminality. Following on from this discussion, the article explores the types of punishments inflicted on villains, as well as the rehabilitative methods applied to wayward heroes and antagonists. Ultimately, crime is used throughout Disney narratives as a plot device to showcase evil and the need to thwart it in order to achieve ‘happily ever after’. As such, Disney films reinforce and reflect existing political messages about what (and who) is right and wrong.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Intellect in International Journal of Disney Studies
- Vol. 2 (2) , 163-180
‘I’m going to do what I do best: lie, deceive, manipulate, and cheat’: Disney representations of crime shaping ‘real-world’ views of ‘typical’ criminals
One consequence of becoming immersed in the Disney universe from an early age is the shaping of viewers’/consumers’ perceptions about what is ‘normal’ and ‘acceptable’ behaviour. This article focuses on Disney’s portrayal of illegal behaviour, comparing and contrasting actions committed by villains and heroes to illustrate the importance of context (the act itself, who commits the act and the motivations driving the behaviour) in shaping viewers’ understandings of criminality. Following on from this discussion, the article explores the types of punishments inflicted on villains, as well as the rehabilitative methods applied to wayward heroes and antagonists. Ultimately, crime is used throughout Disney narratives as a plot device to showcase evil and the need to thwart it in order to achieve ‘happily ever after’. As such, Disney films reinforce and reflect existing political messages about what (and who) is right and wrong.
- Open Access
- 16 March 2026
- Published by Queensland University of Technology in M/C Journal
- Vol. 29 (1)
From Breaking Bad to Pluribus
Introduction The multiverse has become one of the defining narrative logics of contemporary media culture. Across blockbuster franchises and transmedia franchises alike, multiplicity is imagined as spectacle: branching timelines, parallel realities, alternate versions of the same character colliding across fractured worlds. In this dominant model, difference is achieved through ontological rupture. Worlds are split so that variation can exist without destabilising the primary narrative. The multiverse promises expansion without consequence. This article argues that this understanding is conceptually limited. The multiverse doesn’t require cosmological divergence, parallel universes, or duplicated bodies. It requires structured multiplicity within a shared world. By separating structural splits in narrative form from reality-level splits in fictional ontology, this article redefines the multiverse as recursive multiplicity within a stable diegesis. Multiplicity, in this sense, doesn’t have to emerge from fracture, but can emerge from repetition. It can arise through temporal adjacency, spatial reoccupation, and the iterative reconfiguration of subjectivity. Vince Gilligan’s Breaking Bad (2008-2013), Better Call Saul (2015-2022), El Camino: A Breaking Bad Movie (2019), and Pluribus (2025-) provide an interesting case study to reconceptualise what a multiverse is and can be. Gilligan’s universe doesn’t split into alternate realities. Albuquerque remains materially continuous across the series. Geography, causality, and chronology hold, and the viewer repeatedly encounters the same infrastructures (the car wash, laundromat, diner, supermarket, the suburban home) but as radically different moral worlds across time. This article firstly challenges the assumption that the multiverse is necessarily centrifugal and cosmological. Second, it demonstrates that multiplicity can be centripetal and infrastructural. Gilligan’s texts reveal how identical spaces generate divergent ethical universes without ontological rupture. Serial return thickens these sites with layered temporalities. Characters inhabit iterative configurations of selfhood without becoming alternate versions of themselves. The Gilligan world doesn’t diverge and rupture; instead, it intensifies internally. In this model, the multiverse is not a spectacular expansion but a recursive density. It is embedded in the mundane architectures of late capitalism. The car wash launders money and identity. The laundromat sanitises surfaces while concealing production. The diner performs hospitality while facilitating violence. The supermarket restocks to manage autonomy. Each space remains materially stable while hosting incompatible moral climates across time. Multiplicity emerges through repetition rather than fracture. By reframing the multiverse as ethical and infrastructural rather than cosmological, this article argues that Gilligan exposes a form of multiplicity already present in the everyday. Rethinking the Multiverse: From Branching Worlds to Recursive Worlds The term ‘multiverse’ has become so familiar in contemporary media culture that it often passes without definition. Most commonly, it refers to branching realities, alternate timelines, and parallel versions of characters that coexist across narrative arcs (Doležel; Wolf). In contemporary franchise storytelling, these parallel domains frequently collide, overlap, or intersect, allowing narrative expansion without ontological collapse (Jenkins; Wittenberg). Ontological collapse can also be recontextualised as ontological instability. A structural split concerns the formal organisation of narrative, such as parallel timelines or layered narrative levels (Genette; Bordwell; Bal). A reality-level split, by contrast, refers to an ontological division within the fictional world itself, where distinct domains of existence coexist (Ryan; Doležel; McHale). Understandings of the multiverse draw loosely on cosmological theories of parallel universes (Tegmark) and, within narrative theory, on Marie-Laure Ryan’s account of possible worlds in fiction (Ryan). In both cases, multiplicity depends upon separation. Distinct worlds coexist because they are ontologically divided. Media franchises have adopted this logic enthusiastically. As Henry Jenkins argues, transmedia storytelling builds expansive storyworlds that can sustain extension across platforms (Jenkins), while Mark Wolf describes world-building as the construction of environments capacious enough to host narrative growth (Wolf). Within this industrial framework, the multiverse guarantees longevity by allowing contradiction without collapse because it can house variation in alternate continuities. Yet this outward model is not the only way to understand multiplicity. Serial television complicates the assumption that new worlds are required to produce difference. Jason Mittell’s account of complex television shows how long-form seriality generates meaning through accumulation, revisitation, and retrospective reconfiguration (Mittell). The same events acquire new significance as the narrative context deepens. Multiplicity emerges not because the world fractures, but because time thickens within it. Umberto Eco’s distinction between repetition and innovation helps clarify this point. Repetition does not merely reproduce the same; it produces variation through altered conditions (Eco). Difference, in other words, can arise through return. This shift from divergence to recursion becomes even clearer when space is foregrounded. Henri Lefebvre insists that space is not a neutral backdrop but a social product that organises relations of power, labour, and meaning (Lefebvre). If space structures social experience, then re-entering the same space under altered circumstances can generate a different experiential world without altering the physical environment. A...
- 16 March 2026
- Published by Queensland University of Technology in M/C Journal
- Vol. 29 (1)
Open AccessFrom Breaking Bad to Pluribus
Introduction The multiverse has become one of the defining narrative logics of contemporary media culture. Across blockbuster franchises and transmedia franchises alike, multiplicity is imagined as spectacle: branching timelines, parallel realities, alternate versions of the same character colliding across fractured worlds. In this dominant model, difference is achieved through ontological rupture. Worlds are split so that variation can exist without destabilising the primary narrative. The multiverse promises expansion without consequence. This article argues that this understanding is conceptually limited. The multiverse doesn’t require cosmological divergence, parallel universes, or duplicated bodies. It requires structured multiplicity within a shared world. By separating structural splits in narrative form from reality-level splits in fictional ontology, this article redefines the multiverse as recursive multiplicity within a stable diegesis. Multiplicity, in this sense, doesn’t have to emerge from fracture, but can emerge from repetition. It can arise through temporal adjacency, spatial reoccupation, and the iterative reconfiguration of subjectivity. Vince Gilligan’s Breaking Bad (2008-2013), Better Call Saul (2015-2022), El Camino: A Breaking Bad Movie (2019), and Pluribus (2025-) provide an interesting case study to reconceptualise what a multiverse is and can be. Gilligan’s universe doesn’t split into alternate realities. Albuquerque remains materially continuous across the series. Geography, causality, and chronology hold, and the viewer repeatedly encounters the same infrastructures (the car wash, laundromat, diner, supermarket, the suburban home) but as radically different moral worlds across time. This article firstly challenges the assumption that the multiverse is necessarily centrifugal and cosmological. Second, it demonstrates that multiplicity can be centripetal and infrastructural. Gilligan’s texts reveal how identical spaces generate divergent ethical universes without ontological rupture. Serial return thickens these sites with layered temporalities. Characters inhabit iterative configurations of selfhood without becoming alternate versions of themselves. The Gilligan world doesn’t diverge and rupture; instead, it intensifies internally. In this model, the multiverse is not a spectacular expansion but a recursive density. It is embedded in the mundane architectures of late capitalism. The car wash launders money and identity. The laundromat sanitises surfaces while concealing production. The diner performs hospitality while facilitating violence. The supermarket restocks to manage autonomy. Each space remains materially stable while hosting incompatible moral climates across time. Multiplicity emerges through repetition rather than fracture. By reframing the multiverse as ethical and infrastructural rather than cosmological, this article argues that Gilligan exposes a form of multiplicity already present in the everyday. Rethinking the Multiverse: From Branching Worlds to Recursive Worlds The term ‘multiverse’ has become so familiar in contemporary media culture that it often passes without definition. Most commonly, it refers to branching realities, alternate timelines, and parallel versions of characters that coexist across narrative arcs (Doležel; Wolf). In contemporary franchise storytelling, these parallel domains frequently collide, overlap, or intersect, allowing narrative expansion without ontological collapse (Jenkins; Wittenberg). Ontological collapse can also be recontextualised as ontological instability. A structural split concerns the formal organisation of narrative, such as parallel timelines or layered narrative levels (Genette; Bordwell; Bal). A reality-level split, by contrast, refers to an ontological division within the fictional world itself, where distinct domains of existence coexist (Ryan; Doležel; McHale). Understandings of the multiverse draw loosely on cosmological theories of parallel universes (Tegmark) and, within narrative theory, on Marie-Laure Ryan’s account of possible worlds in fiction (Ryan). In both cases, multiplicity depends upon separation. Distinct worlds coexist because they are ontologically divided. Media franchises have adopted this logic enthusiastically. As Henry Jenkins argues, transmedia storytelling builds expansive storyworlds that can sustain extension across platforms (Jenkins), while Mark Wolf describes world-building as the construction of environments capacious enough to host narrative growth (Wolf). Within this industrial framework, the multiverse guarantees longevity by allowing contradiction without collapse because it can house variation in alternate continuities. Yet this outward model is not the only way to understand multiplicity. Serial television complicates the assumption that new worlds are required to produce difference. Jason Mittell’s account of complex television shows how long-form seriality generates meaning through accumulation, revisitation, and retrospective reconfiguration (Mittell). The same events acquire new significance as the narrative context deepens. Multiplicity emerges not because the world fractures, but because time thickens within it. Umberto Eco’s distinction between repetition and innovation helps clarify this point. Repetition does not merely reproduce the same; it produces variation through altered conditions (Eco). Difference, in other words, can arise through return. This shift from divergence to recursion becomes even clearer when space is foregrounded. Henri Lefebvre insists that space is not a neutral backdrop but a social product that organises relations of power, labour, and meaning (Lefebvre). If space structures social experience, then re-entering the same space under altered circumstances can generate a different experiential world without altering the physical environment. A...
- Open Access
- 16 June 2025
- Published by Queensland University of Technology in M/C Journal
- Vol. 28 (2)
Mutating a Better Man
Michael Gracey's Better Man (2024) presents an innovative biographical representation of British pop star Robbie Williams through a radical visual strategy—depicting its subject as a CGI primate rather than through a human actor. Filmed in Australia and partially funded by the Australian Government, the film follows a relatively standard biopic narrative tracing Williams’s trajectory from his Stoke-on-Trent childhood through his tumultuous Take That tenure to solo stardom, mapping his struggles with addiction, familial relationships, and mental health crises. What distinguishes Better Man from conventional biopics is its deliberate disruption of mimetic representation, employing technological transformation not merely as stylistic choice but as conceptual foundation. This article argues that Williams's digital animalisation reconfigures the relationship between celebrity subjectivity and media representation by constructing him as an inherently Posthuman entity—simultaneously human memory and technological artefact. By rejecting the conventional biopic approach that prioritises mimetic resemblance through casting and makeup, Better Man positions itself as a meta-commentary on the constructed nature of celebrity representation, raising significant questions about identity, mediation, and the increasingly blurred boundaries between human agency and technological simulation. The film's primate depiction operates across multiple registers: as technological intervention demonstrating how digital effects transform biographical representation beyond approaches seen in recent films like Elvis (2022) and Rocketman (2019); as metaphorical framework extending Williams's self-description as a "performing monkey" into a comprehensive visual system; and as epistemological strategy potentially creating a “virtual cuckoo”, where hyperreal representations systematically displace authentic understandings of real-world subjects (Nolan et al. 189). Drawing on Posthumanist theory (Haraway; Hayles; Braidotti) and contemporary approaches to celebrity construction (Turner Approaching; Marshall Power), our analysis examines three distinct yet interconnected transformations: technological mutation through digital spectacle, where Williams becomes a hybrid human-technological construct at the production level; metaphorical mutation through animalisation, where his representation is filtered through animal semiotics; and perceptual mutation through synthetic representation, where these artificial constructions cognitively reshape how audiences understand and remember Williams. Through this analytical framework, we demonstrate how Better Man serves as a critical text illuminating the increasingly unstable nature of celebrity identity in our hypermediated era, where boundaries between human and non-human, authentic and artificial, become progressively permeable. The first mutation in Better Man transforms Williams's human identity into something distinctly Posthuman through digital intervention. Posthumanism fundamentally questions boundaries between human and non-human entities, unlike transhumanism's narrower focus on technological enhancement (Hayles 3-6). As Haraway argues in 1985 in her influential A Cyborg Manifesto, traditional divisions between human/animal, organism/machine, and physical/non-physical have collapsed into hybrid identities that challenge established ontological categories. The Posthuman subject emerges through this technological integration, characterised by "distributed cognition" and fluid, hybrid forms that transcend conventional human limitations (Hayles 3). Williams's digital representation exemplifies this theoretical framework, creating an identity that exists simultaneously as human memory and technological construct. Better Man embraces this Posthuman mutation by representing Williams through extensive digital imagery. The film's use of motion capture visual effects facilitates this transformation, embedding and building the digital-ape-Williams within archival footage and performances (Debruge). The result is an identity explicitly composite and technologically mediated—both historically grounded and digitally mutable. This technological mutation produces a celebrity identity that exists as a digital construct, always open to reconfiguration, reflecting how information patterns can potentially detach from material embodiment to create new hybrid forms beyond more conventional means of mediated celebrity artifice (Marshall Power). This technological mutation corresponds with scholarly understandings of celebrities as cultural products continuously transformed through media intervention. Celebrity is not merely an individual's accomplishment, but a discursive construction developed and sustained through media technologies and audience perceptions (Marshall Power). Williams's narrative in Better Man explicitly says the quiet part loud, demonstrating constructedness by intertwining authentic biographical events with overtly artificial spectacle. The digital techniques employed destabilise any claims to singular authenticity, positioning celebrity identity as fluid, shifting, and continuously mutating through technological reproduction. This constant mediation creates a unique relationship while simultaneously revealing the artificial constructs underlying celebrity status—a phenomenon where contemporary celebrity culture increasingly relies on technologies that obscure distinctions between original and reproduction, authenticity and artifice (Gamson 16). The Spectacle, as theorised by Debord, refers to the dominance of representation and image over lived reality—an alienation where authentic experience is replaced by mediated simulations (12). Better Man literalises this Spectacle through immersive visual effects and overt aestheticisation of Williams's personal narrative. The hyperrealistic re-imaginings of his musical performances serve not merely as nostalgic evocations but as mediated representations that transform their original context. Through this Spectacle-driven narrative, Williams himself undergoes a mutation into a spectacular commodity—a persona continuously remoulded to sustain audience engagement. The film constructs a hyperreal Williams—a simulation born from the interplay of memory, technology, and narrative that mutates beyond his original human form. Debord's concept of Spectacle is particularly relevant to understanding Williams's representation because it illuminates how the film transforms biographical events into commodified visual experiences. When Williams’s mental health crises and substance abuse struggles are rendered through spectacular primate imagery, these deeply personal experiences become aesthetic objects for consumption. Better Man continues to reveal how contemporary celebrity culture functions such that “humanity continually destroys our irrational yet actually existing relationships and replaces them with a synthetic copy” (Debord 24). This mutation through Spectacle finds resonance in the conception of celebrity as a public negotiation of private lives (Marshall Persona 157). The biopic's integration of synthetic visuals and cinematic fantasy, specifically the digitised depictions of Williams's public breakdowns and personal struggles, positions the Spectacle of mutation as central to contemporary celebrity narratives. Williams's identity is thus encoded within these spectacularised representations, forming a cultural object continually renegotiated and transformed through digital platforms and consumed by spectators who help create a new identity (sensu Lindemann). Yet, audiences are forced into a familiar position of “purgatory”, torn between believing the biopic and understanding the Posthuman fantasy (Marshall Persona 9) Posthumanist ideals of continuous adaptation and mutable embodiment characterise contemporary digital existence across society, not merely celebrity representation (Braidotti 64-67). While digital persistence now constitutes a fundamental condition of networked life, Better Man dramatises and commodifies this universal phenomenon through Williams’s spectacular transformations. His digital mutations throughout the film represent not ontologically unique experiences but commercially intensified versions of everyday digital persistence. The film's technological spectacle presents Williams transcending temporal boundaries through synthetic reproduction, yet this transcendence reflects an amplification of widely accessible digital afterlives rather than an exclusive privilege of fame. Contemporary visual technologies enable digital persistence where individuals exist perpetually in mediated forms, with celebrities like Williams representing the hyperbolic, high-production extreme on this continuum (Levitt 20-21). The digital Williams exemplifies not exceptional immortality but accelerated mutation—a mediated identity unbound from biology, infinitely reproducible and adaptable, distinguished primarily through its cultural visibility, circulation power, and commercial potential rather than its fundamental technological nature. His digital persistence differs from ordinary digital traces primarily in scale and deliberate construction rather than in kind. The second mutation evident in Better Man operates through a remarkable cinematic choice—the literal depiction of Robbie Williams as a CGI primate rather than using a human actor. This is not merely metaphorical but an actual representational strategy wherein Williams's celebrity identity undergoes literal animalisation within established semiotic systems. Animal representation functions as a powerful signifier within semiotic systems (de Saussure 65-70), where the relationship between signifier (the primate image) and signified (Williams's celebrity identity) creates meaning through cultural convention rather than inherent connection. As Barthes demonstrates in his analysis of cultural mythology, these signifiers carry connotations that extend beyond literal meaning to invoke broader cultural narratives and ideological frameworks (133-152). The monkey/ape imagery carries deliberate symbolic weight accumulated through cultural narratives. The film's approach originated from Williams’s frequent reference to himself as a "performing monkey" and a desire to approach yet another music biopic through "a different lens" (Paterson). However, the implications extend far beyond this initial inspiration, raising questions about how the film deploys this potent symbolism. As one online review noted, “like, I was aware that the character had the face of a chimpanzee, but he was also cheeky, charming and charismatic — like Williams” (Watson). This suggests the animalisation functions partly to capture perceived personality traits, potentially simplifying Williams into easily digestible characteristics associated with performing primates – charm, cheekiness, perhaps even an animalistic lack of agency. Regardless of directorial intent, these animal signifiers establish mediated metaphorical frameworks through which the audience processes celebrity identity separate from the actual person (Nolan et al.). This literal transformation creates a layered representation where Williams exists simultaneously as a human celebrity and an animal figure. By depicting him as a less evolved primate, the film invokes deeply rooted cultural associations—performance, imitation, vulnerability, aggression, and primitive drives—that can reshape how viewers perceive his humanity and interpret his identity and story, focussing on spectacle and simplified metaphor over nuanced personhood. The animalisation of Williams connects to Haraway’s concept of "simian orientalism", where primates have historically functioned as boundary objects between nature and culture, serving as mirrors through which humans define themselves (10-15). In Better Man, this boundary-crossing representation positions Williams as neither fully human nor fully animal, but as a mutated, hybrid figure that challenges conventional categories. This hybridity is particularly significant in the context of celebrity culture, where stars have traditionally functioned as idealised human specimens rather than cross-species constructs (Keswani). By rendering Williams as a primate, the film disrupts this tradition, suggesting that contemporary celebrity increasingly operates through Posthuman transformations that transcend biological categories while simultaneously reinforcing the myth of primates. Williams’s animalisation represents one point along a spectrum of human-animal hybridities that includes subcultural practices like furry fandom (Bernstein et al.) and digital transformations like Posthuman holographic animal filters in Years and Years (Lewis). These phenomena share a cultural preoccupation with boundaries between human and animal identities, though they manifest through different contexts and purposes. Furry communities participate in Posthuman identity expression through deliberate community-building and self-expression (Bernstein et al.), while Better Man employs animalisation as a narrative technique within commercial filmmaking (Paterson). The distinction highlights how similar Posthuman imagery operates differently: identity exploration versus biographical storytelling. The animalisation in Better Man reflects broader patterns where the celebrity becomes a cultural text open to transformation (Turner Approaching). The animal body becomes a site where celebrity identity is mediated through established cultural symbolism. This transformation risks creating a “virtual cuckoo”, where such hyperreal representations ultimately displace authentic understanding (Nolan et al. 189). The celebrity-as-animal representation infiltrates cultural consciousness as a Posthuman spectacle, potentially overtaking genuine comprehension of the human. Importantly, this process operates regardless of whether the film itself fully recognises the complex semiotic system it employs, or the subsequent displacement of truth. The third major transformative mutation in Better Man operates through epistemological displacement, a process whereby artificially enhanced representations fundamentally alter the conditions through which audiences understand Williams’s celebrity identity. This transformation differs from both technological mutation and metaphorical framing as it concerns not merely representation but the cognitive frameworks through which Williams’s identity exists in the cultural imagination. This transformation operates through a process of simulation where representations generate their own reality detached from their origin (Baudrillard 1-7). A virtual cuckoo displaces authentic understanding by manipulating human-focussed supernormal stimuli using synthetic representations (Nolan et al.189). Like the cuckoo laying eggs in another bird's nest, these hyperreal representations infiltrate cultural consciousness, ultimately shaping public perception more powerfully than direct engagement with the original subject. Williams’s digital primate functions as a powerful mnemonic device that becomes a dominant framework through which audiences process his biographical narrative. This effect extends beyond visual novelty to fundamentally reconfigure how his celebrity identity is constructed, circulated, and consumed. By rendering him in Posthuman form, the film simultaneously claims to reveal essential truths about his experience while acknowledging the constructed nature of all celebrity representation. The "celebrity-commodity" circulates independently of the actual person, reshaping cultural understanding as an elaborate sign system continuously reframed and reinterpreted by a changing cultural landscape (Turner Economy 193; Marshall Persona). In Better Man, past, present, and imagined versions of Williams coexist and commingle, characteristic of postmodern temporalities (Jameson). This collapse of linear temporality through technological transformation enables the film to function across multiple cultural registers, inserting its synthetic vision into ongoing discourses about Williams’s legacy. Biopics typically evoke sympathy (Smith Jr. 227), and the CGI Williams uses the extant semiotic systems to shorthand many of the stimuli necessary for eliciting desired emotions, all filtered through animal representation. This memorable abstraction risks overshadowing more complex realities of embodied celebrity (and animal) subjectivities. By literalising the myth of Williams’s self-described "performing monkey" identity (Watson), Better Man deliberately exposes the manufactured nature of celebrity representation through its conspicuous artifice. This visual approach employs a form of selective transparency, acknowledging fictional components precisely to reinforce the perceived truthfulness of its unacknowledged constructions. Rather than undermining the film's truth claims, this partial disclosure strengthens audience trust in the narrative's unforegrounded elements. The biopic thus exemplifies how "mythology is camouflaged with abstractions" such as celebrity, truth, and biopic authenticity (Rothwell 170), using transparent fiction to construct a more compelling impression of authenticity. The manipulation of truth claims reflects a contemporary understanding of identity construction. For public figures especially, identity manifests not as a stable essence but as a networked assemblage—a dynamic configuration emerging from countless connections, portrayals, disclosures, and interpretations (Braidotti 69; Lindemann). Within this framework, personal identity operates fundamentally as a "social practice" rather than an intrinsic property, continuously negotiated through interactions with others and cultural frameworks (Lindemann 222-223). Better Man thus intervenes directly in this assemblage, inserting a visually arresting component that reconfigures Williams’s public persona by transforming how audiences perceive, remember, and integrate his biographical narrative into cultural memory. This cinematic representation becomes another node potentially reshaping his cultural legacy through its mediated contribution. Williams’s engagement with this technological mutation demonstrates his participation in the Posthuman construction of his celebrity identity. Rather than merely being subjected to transformation, Williams becomes an agent in his own mutation, collaborating in creating a Posthuman version transcending conventional biographical representation. This collaboration highlights how contemporary celebrity increasingly functions through "intercommunication" between public persona and private self, where technological mediation does not simply obscure authenticity but fundamentally reconstitutes its meaning in a hypermediated context (Marshall Persona 39). Better Man reconstructs celebrity identity through its radical visual mutation strategy. By transforming Williams into a digital primate, the film exposes the fundamentally unstable nature of contemporary fame, creating a representation that exists simultaneously as human narrative, technological simulation, and cultural symbol. This mutation operates across three critical dimensions that collectively transform our understanding of celebrity: technologically, Williams becomes a Posthuman...
- 16 June 2025
- Published by Queensland University of Technology in M/C Journal
- Vol. 28 (2)
Open AccessMutating a Better Man
Michael Gracey's Better Man (2024) presents an innovative biographical representation of British pop star Robbie Williams through a radical visual strategy—depicting its subject as a CGI primate rather than through a human actor. Filmed in Australia and partially funded by the Australian Government, the film follows a relatively standard biopic narrative tracing Williams’s trajectory from his Stoke-on-Trent childhood through his tumultuous Take That tenure to solo stardom, mapping his struggles with addiction, familial relationships, and mental health crises. What distinguishes Better Man from conventional biopics is its deliberate disruption of mimetic representation, employing technological transformation not merely as stylistic choice but as conceptual foundation. This article argues that Williams's digital animalisation reconfigures the relationship between celebrity subjectivity and media representation by constructing him as an inherently Posthuman entity—simultaneously human memory and technological artefact. By rejecting the conventional biopic approach that prioritises mimetic resemblance through casting and makeup, Better Man positions itself as a meta-commentary on the constructed nature of celebrity representation, raising significant questions about identity, mediation, and the increasingly blurred boundaries between human agency and technological simulation. The film's primate depiction operates across multiple registers: as technological intervention demonstrating how digital effects transform biographical representation beyond approaches seen in recent films like Elvis (2022) and Rocketman (2019); as metaphorical framework extending Williams's self-description as a "performing monkey" into a comprehensive visual system; and as epistemological strategy potentially creating a “virtual cuckoo”, where hyperreal representations systematically displace authentic understandings of real-world subjects (Nolan et al. 189). Drawing on Posthumanist theory (Haraway; Hayles; Braidotti) and contemporary approaches to celebrity construction (Turner Approaching; Marshall Power), our analysis examines three distinct yet interconnected transformations: technological mutation through digital spectacle, where Williams becomes a hybrid human-technological construct at the production level; metaphorical mutation through animalisation, where his representation is filtered through animal semiotics; and perceptual mutation through synthetic representation, where these artificial constructions cognitively reshape how audiences understand and remember Williams. Through this analytical framework, we demonstrate how Better Man serves as a critical text illuminating the increasingly unstable nature of celebrity identity in our hypermediated era, where boundaries between human and non-human, authentic and artificial, become progressively permeable. The first mutation in Better Man transforms Williams's human identity into something distinctly Posthuman through digital intervention. Posthumanism fundamentally questions boundaries between human and non-human entities, unlike transhumanism's narrower focus on technological enhancement (Hayles 3-6). As Haraway argues in 1985 in her influential A Cyborg Manifesto, traditional divisions between human/animal, organism/machine, and physical/non-physical have collapsed into hybrid identities that challenge established ontological categories. The Posthuman subject emerges through this technological integration, characterised by "distributed cognition" and fluid, hybrid forms that transcend conventional human limitations (Hayles 3). Williams's digital representation exemplifies this theoretical framework, creating an identity that exists simultaneously as human memory and technological construct. Better Man embraces this Posthuman mutation by representing Williams through extensive digital imagery. The film's use of motion capture visual effects facilitates this transformation, embedding and building the digital-ape-Williams within archival footage and performances (Debruge). The result is an identity explicitly composite and technologically mediated—both historically grounded and digitally mutable. This technological mutation produces a celebrity identity that exists as a digital construct, always open to reconfiguration, reflecting how information patterns can potentially detach from material embodiment to create new hybrid forms beyond more conventional means of mediated celebrity artifice (Marshall Power). This technological mutation corresponds with scholarly understandings of celebrities as cultural products continuously transformed through media intervention. Celebrity is not merely an individual's accomplishment, but a discursive construction developed and sustained through media technologies and audience perceptions (Marshall Power). Williams's narrative in Better Man explicitly says the quiet part loud, demonstrating constructedness by intertwining authentic biographical events with overtly artificial spectacle. The digital techniques employed destabilise any claims to singular authenticity, positioning celebrity identity as fluid, shifting, and continuously mutating through technological reproduction. This constant mediation creates a unique relationship while simultaneously revealing the artificial constructs underlying celebrity status—a phenomenon where contemporary celebrity culture increasingly relies on technologies that obscure distinctions between original and reproduction, authenticity and artifice (Gamson 16). The Spectacle, as theorised by Debord, refers to the dominance of representation and image over lived reality—an alienation where authentic experience is replaced by mediated simulations (12). Better Man literalises this Spectacle through immersive visual effects and overt aestheticisation of Williams's personal narrative. The hyperrealistic re-imaginings of his musical performances serve not merely as nostalgic evocations but as mediated representations that transform their original context. Through this Spectacle-driven narrative, Williams himself undergoes a mutation into a spectacular commodity—a persona continuously remoulded to sustain audience engagement. The film constructs a hyperreal Williams—a simulation born from the interplay of memory, technology, and narrative that mutates beyond his original human form. Debord's concept of Spectacle is particularly relevant to understanding Williams's representation because it illuminates how the film transforms biographical events into commodified visual experiences. When Williams’s mental health crises and substance abuse struggles are rendered through spectacular primate imagery, these deeply personal experiences become aesthetic objects for consumption. Better Man continues to reveal how contemporary celebrity culture functions such that “humanity continually destroys our irrational yet actually existing relationships and replaces them with a synthetic copy” (Debord 24). This mutation through Spectacle finds resonance in the conception of celebrity as a public negotiation of private lives (Marshall Persona 157). The biopic's integration of synthetic visuals and cinematic fantasy, specifically the digitised depictions of Williams's public breakdowns and personal struggles, positions the Spectacle of mutation as central to contemporary celebrity narratives. Williams's identity is thus encoded within these spectacularised representations, forming a cultural object continually renegotiated and transformed through digital platforms and consumed by spectators who help create a new identity (sensu Lindemann). Yet, audiences are forced into a familiar position of “purgatory”, torn between believing the biopic and understanding the Posthuman fantasy (Marshall Persona 9) Posthumanist ideals of continuous adaptation and mutable embodiment characterise contemporary digital existence across society, not merely celebrity representation (Braidotti 64-67). While digital persistence now constitutes a fundamental condition of networked life, Better Man dramatises and commodifies this universal phenomenon through Williams’s spectacular transformations. His digital mutations throughout the film represent not ontologically unique experiences but commercially intensified versions of everyday digital persistence. The film's technological spectacle presents Williams transcending temporal boundaries through synthetic reproduction, yet this transcendence reflects an amplification of widely accessible digital afterlives rather than an exclusive privilege of fame. Contemporary visual technologies enable digital persistence where individuals exist perpetually in mediated forms, with celebrities like Williams representing the hyperbolic, high-production extreme on this continuum (Levitt 20-21). The digital Williams exemplifies not exceptional immortality but accelerated mutation—a mediated identity unbound from biology, infinitely reproducible and adaptable, distinguished primarily through its cultural visibility, circulation power, and commercial potential rather than its fundamental technological nature. His digital persistence differs from ordinary digital traces primarily in scale and deliberate construction rather than in kind. The second mutation evident in Better Man operates through a remarkable cinematic choice—the literal depiction of Robbie Williams as a CGI primate rather than using a human actor. This is not merely metaphorical but an actual representational strategy wherein Williams's celebrity identity undergoes literal animalisation within established semiotic systems. Animal representation functions as a powerful signifier within semiotic systems (de Saussure 65-70), where the relationship between signifier (the primate image) and signified (Williams's celebrity identity) creates meaning through cultural convention rather than inherent connection. As Barthes demonstrates in his analysis of cultural mythology, these signifiers carry connotations that extend beyond literal meaning to invoke broader cultural narratives and ideological frameworks (133-152). The monkey/ape imagery carries deliberate symbolic weight accumulated through cultural narratives. The film's approach originated from Williams’s frequent reference to himself as a "performing monkey" and a desire to approach yet another music biopic through "a different lens" (Paterson). However, the implications extend far beyond this initial inspiration, raising questions about how the film deploys this potent symbolism. As one online review noted, “like, I was aware that the character had the face of a chimpanzee, but he was also cheeky, charming and charismatic — like Williams” (Watson). This suggests the animalisation functions partly to capture perceived personality traits, potentially simplifying Williams into easily digestible characteristics associated with performing primates – charm, cheekiness, perhaps even an animalistic lack of agency. Regardless of directorial intent, these animal signifiers establish mediated metaphorical frameworks through which the audience processes celebrity identity separate from the actual person (Nolan et al.). This literal transformation creates a layered representation where Williams exists simultaneously as a human celebrity and an animal figure. By depicting him as a less evolved primate, the film invokes deeply rooted cultural associations—performance, imitation, vulnerability, aggression, and primitive drives—that can reshape how viewers perceive his humanity and interpret his identity and story, focussing on spectacle and simplified metaphor over nuanced personhood. The animalisation of Williams connects to Haraway’s concept of "simian orientalism", where primates have historically functioned as boundary objects between nature and culture, serving as mirrors through which humans define themselves (10-15). In Better Man, this boundary-crossing representation positions Williams as neither fully human nor fully animal, but as a mutated, hybrid figure that challenges conventional categories. This hybridity is particularly significant in the context of celebrity culture, where stars have traditionally functioned as idealised human specimens rather than cross-species constructs (Keswani). By rendering Williams as a primate, the film disrupts this tradition, suggesting that contemporary celebrity increasingly operates through Posthuman transformations that transcend biological categories while simultaneously reinforcing the myth of primates. Williams’s animalisation represents one point along a spectrum of human-animal hybridities that includes subcultural practices like furry fandom (Bernstein et al.) and digital transformations like Posthuman holographic animal filters in Years and Years (Lewis). These phenomena share a cultural preoccupation with boundaries between human and animal identities, though they manifest through different contexts and purposes. Furry communities participate in Posthuman identity expression through deliberate community-building and self-expression (Bernstein et al.), while Better Man employs animalisation as a narrative technique within commercial filmmaking (Paterson). The distinction highlights how similar Posthuman imagery operates differently: identity exploration versus biographical storytelling. The animalisation in Better Man reflects broader patterns where the celebrity becomes a cultural text open to transformation (Turner Approaching). The animal body becomes a site where celebrity identity is mediated through established cultural symbolism. This transformation risks creating a “virtual cuckoo”, where such hyperreal representations ultimately displace authentic understanding (Nolan et al. 189). The celebrity-as-animal representation infiltrates cultural consciousness as a Posthuman spectacle, potentially overtaking genuine comprehension of the human. Importantly, this process operates regardless of whether the film itself fully recognises the complex semiotic system it employs, or the subsequent displacement of truth. The third major transformative mutation in Better Man operates through epistemological displacement, a process whereby artificially enhanced representations fundamentally alter the conditions through which audiences understand Williams’s celebrity identity. This transformation differs from both technological mutation and metaphorical framing as it concerns not merely representation but the cognitive frameworks through which Williams’s identity exists in the cultural imagination. This transformation operates through a process of simulation where representations generate their own reality detached from their origin (Baudrillard 1-7). A virtual cuckoo displaces authentic understanding by manipulating human-focussed supernormal stimuli using synthetic representations (Nolan et al.189). Like the cuckoo laying eggs in another bird's nest, these hyperreal representations infiltrate cultural consciousness, ultimately shaping public perception more powerfully than direct engagement with the original subject. Williams’s digital primate functions as a powerful mnemonic device that becomes a dominant framework through which audiences process his biographical narrative. This effect extends beyond visual novelty to fundamentally reconfigure how his celebrity identity is constructed, circulated, and consumed. By rendering him in Posthuman form, the film simultaneously claims to reveal essential truths about his experience while acknowledging the constructed nature of all celebrity representation. The "celebrity-commodity" circulates independently of the actual person, reshaping cultural understanding as an elaborate sign system continuously reframed and reinterpreted by a changing cultural landscape (Turner Economy 193; Marshall Persona). In Better Man, past, present, and imagined versions of Williams coexist and commingle, characteristic of postmodern temporalities (Jameson). This collapse of linear temporality through technological transformation enables the film to function across multiple cultural registers, inserting its synthetic vision into ongoing discourses about Williams’s legacy. Biopics typically evoke sympathy (Smith Jr. 227), and the CGI Williams uses the extant semiotic systems to shorthand many of the stimuli necessary for eliciting desired emotions, all filtered through animal representation. This memorable abstraction risks overshadowing more complex realities of embodied celebrity (and animal) subjectivities. By literalising the myth of Williams’s self-described "performing monkey" identity (Watson), Better Man deliberately exposes the manufactured nature of celebrity representation through its conspicuous artifice. This visual approach employs a form of selective transparency, acknowledging fictional components precisely to reinforce the perceived truthfulness of its unacknowledged constructions. Rather than undermining the film's truth claims, this partial disclosure strengthens audience trust in the narrative's unforegrounded elements. The biopic thus exemplifies how "mythology is camouflaged with abstractions" such as celebrity, truth, and biopic authenticity (Rothwell 170), using transparent fiction to construct a more compelling impression of authenticity. The manipulation of truth claims reflects a contemporary understanding of identity construction. For public figures especially, identity manifests not as a stable essence but as a networked assemblage—a dynamic configuration emerging from countless connections, portrayals, disclosures, and interpretations (Braidotti 69; Lindemann). Within this framework, personal identity operates fundamentally as a "social practice" rather than an intrinsic property, continuously negotiated through interactions with others and cultural frameworks (Lindemann 222-223). Better Man thus intervenes directly in this assemblage, inserting a visually arresting component that reconfigures Williams’s public persona by transforming how audiences perceive, remember, and integrate his biographical narrative into cultural memory. This cinematic representation becomes another node potentially reshaping his cultural legacy through its mediated contribution. Williams’s engagement with this technological mutation demonstrates his participation in the Posthuman construction of his celebrity identity. Rather than merely being subjected to transformation, Williams becomes an agent in his own mutation, collaborating in creating a Posthuman version transcending conventional biographical representation. This collaboration highlights how contemporary celebrity increasingly functions through "intercommunication" between public persona and private self, where technological mediation does not simply obscure authenticity but fundamentally reconstitutes its meaning in a hypermediated context (Marshall Persona 39). Better Man reconstructs celebrity identity through its radical visual mutation strategy. By transforming Williams into a digital primate, the film exposes the fundamentally unstable nature of contemporary fame, creating a representation that exists simultaneously as human narrative, technological simulation, and cultural symbol. This mutation operates across three critical dimensions that collectively transform our understanding of celebrity: technologically, Williams becomes a Posthuman...
- Open Access
- 16 March 2025
- Published by Queensland University of Technology in M/C Journal
- Vol. 28 (1)
All the Pretty Noir Horses
Introduction The fusion of noir and Western elements in All the Pretty Horses (McCarthy) presents an anomalous hybrid, bridging the fatalism and existential despair of noir with the rugged individualism and pastoral decline of the Western. This relationship complicates traditional narrative boundaries, inviting readers to reconsider the archetypes and thematic constructs at play. Situated within a frontier grappling with industrial encroachment, All the Pretty Horses presents a world caught between preservation and progress. By focussing on the role of horses, this article explores their symbolic and material roles, highlighting the ideological fissures in rural and cowboy identities. This study addresses a critical gap in noir scholarship, by examining how noir texts can help in understanding the myth-making process, and the role of animals in these narratives. The article examines how horses in All the Pretty Horses are transformed into mythic constructs that intertwine freedom with entrapment, mirroring the fatalistic cycles of noir protagonists. Further, the objectified horses can replace the femmes fatales as seductive catalysts of noir stories. Drawing on Barthes’s theory of myth, the article interrogates how these constructs naturalise cultural contradictions, capable of transforming acts of control and violence into symbols of nobility and authenticity. Noir and the Western: A Hybrid Aesthetic The noir and the Western are noted as having an anomalous hybrid (sensu Monticone). That is, noir’s preoccupation with fatalism, moral ambiguity, and existential despair aligns with the Western’s exploration of individualism, frontier ethics, and the erosion of pastoral ideals (Kaminsky; Springhall; Conard). All the Pretty Horses presents the Western landscape as the site of noir’s entrapment and disillusionment, where characters grapple with the fatalistic loss of both personal and cultural identity. While noir traditionally thrives in urban environments, its themes resonate powerfully in McCarthy’s rural settings. The sale of the Grady family ranch, prompted by modern economic pressures, signals the encroachment of industrialisation and the demise of the agrarian heritage John Grady Cole values so deeply. As Somogyi observes, McCarthy’s descriptions of environmental decay and cultural erosion reflect broader concerns about humanity’s impact on the natural world. Grady’s journey to Mexico, ostensibly a boy’s quest for freedom, instead becomes an encounter with the dystopian underbelly of the romanticised frontier, aligning with Owens’s portrayal of McCarthy’s Mexico as a perilous and lawless space (65). The fated end of the cowboy myth and the taming of the wild has been prophesised in fiction for over one hundred years. John Ford’s 1924 film The Iron Horse chronicles Davy Brandon’s (George O’Brien) quest to fulfil his father’s dream of taming the wilderness through the construction of a transcontinental railroad. Dedicated to the memory of Abraham Lincoln and the pioneers of a “greater nation”, the film positions industrial progress as a civilising force. More recently, the rural noir series Yellowstone echoes this fatalism when career cowboy Rip Wheeler (Cole Hauser) observes, “you know, in 30 years from now … nobody’s gonna be doing this, nobody” (Voros). Grady’s character combines the archetypes of the noir antihero and the Western cowboy. His adherence to a personal moral code, even in the face of betrayal and violence, evokes noir’s thematic exploration of agency and fate. Lee suggests that Grady’s actions, though noble, are rendered futile by the overwhelming forces of modernity and corruption that define his surroundings. The violent episodes he endures, from reclaiming Blevins’s horse to his survival in the penitentiary, highlight noir’s fatalistic motif of constrained choice. Pippin argues that noir protagonists are often trapped by the illusion of agency – their fates seemingly predetermined by a world beyond their control (49). The combination of noir and western themes reframes the conceptualisation of the cowboy and the frontier, exposing the coexisting but competing ideals of preservation and progress extant in many western narratives (Lee). Grady’s ideals repeatedly clash with the harsh realities of survival and human fallibility as the romanticised veneer of the authentic cowboy life progressively deteriorates. Horses occupy a central role in this dynamic, embodying both the promise of an unspoiled past and the inevitability of its demise (Hoy; Somogyi). Their presence in the narrative bridges the expansive romanticism of the Western with the pessimistic determinism of noir. As the novel unfolds, the layered significance of the horses deepens. They become not just symbols of freedom or nostalgia but also objects of ideological tension, reflecting a broader human tendency to mythologise nature (sensu Nolan, Hackett, and Coghlan). This clash between the romanticised and the real, when viewed through the noir lens, provides a unique perspective from which to explore human interactions with horses and the myth of horses. Barthesian Myths and the Equestrian Allure Roland Barthes’s theory of myth provides a critical lens for examining the portrayal of horses in All the Pretty Horses (Barthes). Barthes defines myth as a system of meaning that naturalises cultural constructs, transforming historical realities into self-evident truths. In All the Pretty Horses, horses are romanticised as symbols of freedom, authenticity, and the cowboy ethos, yet their depiction simultaneously reveals inherent contradictions and violence underpinning these ideals (Kaminsky; Somogyi). Horses thus become sites where myth and materiality collide, highlighting a human tendency to mythologise the goodness of nature while...
- 16 March 2025
- Published by Queensland University of Technology in M/C Journal
- Vol. 28 (1)
Open AccessAll the Pretty Noir Horses
Introduction The fusion of noir and Western elements in All the Pretty Horses (McCarthy) presents an anomalous hybrid, bridging the fatalism and existential despair of noir with the rugged individualism and pastoral decline of the Western. This relationship complicates traditional narrative boundaries, inviting readers to reconsider the archetypes and thematic constructs at play. Situated within a frontier grappling with industrial encroachment, All the Pretty Horses presents a world caught between preservation and progress. By focussing on the role of horses, this article explores their symbolic and material roles, highlighting the ideological fissures in rural and cowboy identities. This study addresses a critical gap in noir scholarship, by examining how noir texts can help in understanding the myth-making process, and the role of animals in these narratives. The article examines how horses in All the Pretty Horses are transformed into mythic constructs that intertwine freedom with entrapment, mirroring the fatalistic cycles of noir protagonists. Further, the objectified horses can replace the femmes fatales as seductive catalysts of noir stories. Drawing on Barthes’s theory of myth, the article interrogates how these constructs naturalise cultural contradictions, capable of transforming acts of control and violence into symbols of nobility and authenticity. Noir and the Western: A Hybrid Aesthetic The noir and the Western are noted as having an anomalous hybrid (sensu Monticone). That is, noir’s preoccupation with fatalism, moral ambiguity, and existential despair aligns with the Western’s exploration of individualism, frontier ethics, and the erosion of pastoral ideals (Kaminsky; Springhall; Conard). All the Pretty Horses presents the Western landscape as the site of noir’s entrapment and disillusionment, where characters grapple with the fatalistic loss of both personal and cultural identity. While noir traditionally thrives in urban environments, its themes resonate powerfully in McCarthy’s rural settings. The sale of the Grady family ranch, prompted by modern economic pressures, signals the encroachment of industrialisation and the demise of the agrarian heritage John Grady Cole values so deeply. As Somogyi observes, McCarthy’s descriptions of environmental decay and cultural erosion reflect broader concerns about humanity’s impact on the natural world. Grady’s journey to Mexico, ostensibly a boy’s quest for freedom, instead becomes an encounter with the dystopian underbelly of the romanticised frontier, aligning with Owens’s portrayal of McCarthy’s Mexico as a perilous and lawless space (65). The fated end of the cowboy myth and the taming of the wild has been prophesised in fiction for over one hundred years. John Ford’s 1924 film The Iron Horse chronicles Davy Brandon’s (George O’Brien) quest to fulfil his father’s dream of taming the wilderness through the construction of a transcontinental railroad. Dedicated to the memory of Abraham Lincoln and the pioneers of a “greater nation”, the film positions industrial progress as a civilising force. More recently, the rural noir series Yellowstone echoes this fatalism when career cowboy Rip Wheeler (Cole Hauser) observes, “you know, in 30 years from now … nobody’s gonna be doing this, nobody” (Voros). Grady’s character combines the archetypes of the noir antihero and the Western cowboy. His adherence to a personal moral code, even in the face of betrayal and violence, evokes noir’s thematic exploration of agency and fate. Lee suggests that Grady’s actions, though noble, are rendered futile by the overwhelming forces of modernity and corruption that define his surroundings. The violent episodes he endures, from reclaiming Blevins’s horse to his survival in the penitentiary, highlight noir’s fatalistic motif of constrained choice. Pippin argues that noir protagonists are often trapped by the illusion of agency – their fates seemingly predetermined by a world beyond their control (49). The combination of noir and western themes reframes the conceptualisation of the cowboy and the frontier, exposing the coexisting but competing ideals of preservation and progress extant in many western narratives (Lee). Grady’s ideals repeatedly clash with the harsh realities of survival and human fallibility as the romanticised veneer of the authentic cowboy life progressively deteriorates. Horses occupy a central role in this dynamic, embodying both the promise of an unspoiled past and the inevitability of its demise (Hoy; Somogyi). Their presence in the narrative bridges the expansive romanticism of the Western with the pessimistic determinism of noir. As the novel unfolds, the layered significance of the horses deepens. They become not just symbols of freedom or nostalgia but also objects of ideological tension, reflecting a broader human tendency to mythologise nature (sensu Nolan, Hackett, and Coghlan). This clash between the romanticised and the real, when viewed through the noir lens, provides a unique perspective from which to explore human interactions with horses and the myth of horses. Barthesian Myths and the Equestrian Allure Roland Barthes’s theory of myth provides a critical lens for examining the portrayal of horses in All the Pretty Horses (Barthes). Barthes defines myth as a system of meaning that naturalises cultural constructs, transforming historical realities into self-evident truths. In All the Pretty Horses, horses are romanticised as symbols of freedom, authenticity, and the cowboy ethos, yet their depiction simultaneously reveals inherent contradictions and violence underpinning these ideals (Kaminsky; Somogyi). Horses thus become sites where myth and materiality collide, highlighting a human tendency to mythologise the goodness of nature while...
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Intellect in The Australasian Journal of Popular Culture
- Vol. 13 (2) , 177-195
Ethics and post-evolution: The role of hyperreal adaptations in shaping popular cultural perceptions of animals
In A Theory of Adaptation, Linda Hutcheon considers Darwinist claims that some animal stories survive more readily than others. Just as natural selection drives evolution, genetic selection and memetic cultural transmission drive the evolution, mutation and flourishing of adaptations in ever-changing narratives and technological environments. In the telling and retelling of stories, it invites a state of hyperreality, where copies of copies are believed to be real. Jean Baudrillard’s concept of hyperreality describes a condition wherein the boundaries between reality and its simulated representations become indistinguishable. He states that ‘[i]t is the generation by models of a real without origin or reality’. In a state of hyperreality, adaptations and representations can assume greater significance and authenticity than the actual reality they depict. Consequently, the simulated experiences and images are perceived as more real and authentic than the tangible reality from which they originate. The hyperreality of film adaptations has been explored through the telling of historical narratives, nation-building and authenticity. Modern adaptations of historical events, especially when delivered through a contemporary lens, have the ability to reshape our understanding of the past. Art and entertainment permeate our consciousness, moulding our identities. Consequently, we become a reflection of what we engage with, and in a dialectical process, we subsequently reshape the world according to our transformed selves. Thus, entertainment facilitates tangible changes in the real world. These are the key ideas examined in this article.
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Intellect in The Australasian Journal of Popular Culture
- Vol. 13 (2) , 177-195
Ethics and post-evolution: The role of hyperreal adaptations in shaping popular cultural perceptions of animals
In A Theory of Adaptation, Linda Hutcheon considers Darwinist claims that some animal stories survive more readily than others. Just as natural selection drives evolution, genetic selection and memetic cultural transmission drive the evolution, mutation and flourishing of adaptations in ever-changing narratives and technological environments. In the telling and retelling of stories, it invites a state of hyperreality, where copies of copies are believed to be real. Jean Baudrillard’s concept of hyperreality describes a condition wherein the boundaries between reality and its simulated representations become indistinguishable. He states that ‘[i]t is the generation by models of a real without origin or reality’. In a state of hyperreality, adaptations and representations can assume greater significance and authenticity than the actual reality they depict. Consequently, the simulated experiences and images are perceived as more real and authentic than the tangible reality from which they originate. The hyperreality of film adaptations has been explored through the telling of historical narratives, nation-building and authenticity. Modern adaptations of historical events, especially when delivered through a contemporary lens, have the ability to reshape our understanding of the past. Art and entertainment permeate our consciousness, moulding our identities. Consequently, we become a reflection of what we engage with, and in a dialectical process, we subsequently reshape the world according to our transformed selves. Thus, entertainment facilitates tangible changes in the real world. These are the key ideas examined in this article.
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Intellect in The Australasian Journal of Popular Culture
- Vol. 13 (2) , 119-124
Adaptations, reboots and remakes in popular culture: Crime, noir, horror, heroes, beasts and bodies
Intellect Discover is the platform where Intellect's content lives: Browse publications for scholars and practitioners teaching and researching in the arts, media and creative industries.
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Intellect in The Australasian Journal of Popular Culture
- Vol. 13 (2) , 119-124
Adaptations, reboots and remakes in popular culture: Crime, noir, horror, heroes, beasts and bodies
Intellect Discover is the platform where Intellect's content lives: Browse publications for scholars and practitioners teaching and researching in the arts, media and creative industries.
- Open Access
- 11 June 2024
- Published by Queensland University of Technology in M/C Journal
- Vol. 27 (3)
Barbie
The story of Barbie is a tapestry woven with threads of cultural significance, societal shifts, and corporate narratives. It’s a tale that encapsulates the evolution of American post-war capitalism, mirroring the changing tides of social norms, aspirations, and identities. Barbie’s journey from Germany to Los Angeles, along the way becoming a global icon, is a testament to the power of Ruth Handler’s vision and Barbie’s marketing. Barbie embodies and reflects the rise of mass consumption and the early days of television advertising, where one doll could become a household name and shape the dreams of children worldwide. The controversies and criticisms surrounding Barbie – from promoting a ‘thin ideal’ to perpetuating gender and racial stereotypes – highlight the complexities of representation in popular culture. Yet, Barbie’s enduring message, “You can be anything”, continues to inspire and empower, even as it evolves to embrace a more inclusive and diverse portrayals of power, beauty, and potential. Barbie’s story is not just about a doll; it’s about the aspirations she represents, the societal changes she’s witnessed, and the ongoing conversation about her impact on gender roles, body image, and consumer culture. It’s a narrative that continues to unfold, as Barbie adapts to the times and remains a symbol of possibility. “It is impossible to conceive of the toy industry as being anything other than dependent on a popular culture which shapes and structures the meanings carried by toys” (Fleming 40). The relationship between toys and popular culture is symbiotic. While popular culture influences the creation of toys, toys also contribute to the spread and longevity of cultural icons and narratives. Today, one of the most influential, popular, and contested toys of the twentieth century is Mattel’s Barbie doll. Her launch at the New York Toy Fair on 9 March 1959 by Mattel co-founder Ruth Handler was a game-changer in the toy industry. Her adult appearance, symbolised by her fashionable swimsuit and ponytail, was a bold move by Mattel. Despite the doubts from the toy industry which thought nobody would want to play with a doll that had breasts (Tamkin) and Mattel’s skepticism of its commercial success (Westenhouser 14), Barbie was a success, selling over 350,000 units in her first year, and she quickly became an iconic figure, paving the way for other male and female adult dolls. For the first time in mid-century America, Barbie meant children could play with a doll that looked like a woman, not a little girl or a baby. In a 1965 interview, Ruth Handler argued that American girls needed a doll with a “teen-age figure and a lot of glorious, imaginative, high-fashion clothes” (cited in Giacomin and Lubinski 3). In a 1993 interview, Handler said it was “important that Barbie allowed play situations that little girls could project themselves into … to imagine, pretend and to fantasize”. Hence Ruth Handler’s Barbie could be an “avatar for girls to project their dreams onto” (Southwell). Barbie hit the market with a “sassy ponytail, heavy eyeliner, a healthy dose of side-eye and a distinctly adult body” (Blackmore). Her arched eyebrows were matched with a coy sideways glance reflecting her sexual origins (Thong). Mattel did not reveal that Ruth Handler’s Barbie was inspired by a German novelty men’s toy, Bild Lilli, which Handler had purchased on a European holiday in 1955. Mattel fought several lawsuits and eventually secured the rights to Bild Lilli in 1964, which required the German maker of the Bild Lilli doll to not make her again. Barbie dolls, both blonde and brunette, changed little until 1967, when Mattel launch the ‘new’ Barbie doll which is the foundation for today’s Stereotypical Barbie. The same size as the original, thanks to Mattel engineer Jack Ryan she could twist and turn at the waist. Her facial features were softened, she had ‘real’ eyelashes’ and took on an ‘outdoor look’. The new 1967 version of Barbie originally retailed for US$3.00. Mattel, assuming consumers may not want to buy a new Barbie when they already had one, offered buyers the new Barbie at US$1.50 if they traded in their old 1950s Barbie. The television advertising campaign for the new Barbie featured Maureen McMormick (who would go on to play Marcia Brady in the TV series The Brady Bunch from 1969 to 1974). The original #1 Barbie today sells for over US$25,000 (Reinhard). The most expensive Barbie sold to date was a Stefano Canturi-designed Barbie that sold in 2010 for US$302,500 at Christies in New York (Clarendon). Barbie has been described as “the most successful doll in history”, “the most popular toy in history”, the “empress of fashion dolls” (Rogers 86), the “most famous doll in the world” (Ferorelli), the biggest-selling fashion doll in history (Green and Gellene), and is one if the world’s “most commercially successful toys” (Fleming 41). Barbie is both “idealistic and materialistic” and characterises an “American fantasy” (Tamkin). More so, she is a popular culture icon and “a unique indicator of women’s history” (Vander Bent). The inclusion of Barbie in America’s twentieth-century Time Capsule “cemented her status as a true American icon” (Ford), as did Andy Warhol when he iconised Barbie in his 1968 painting of her (Moore). During the 1950s and 1960s, Barbie’s name was licenced to over 100 companies; while a strategic move that expanded Barbie’s brand presence, it also provided Mattel with substantial royalty payments for decades. This approach helped solidify Barbie’s status as a cultural icon and enabled her to become a lucrative asset for Mattel (Rogers). Sixty-five years later, Barbie has 99% global brand awareness. In 2021, Mattel shipped more than 86 million Barbies globally, manufacturing 164 Barbies a minute (Tomkins). In 2022, Barbie generated gross sales of US$1.49 billion (Statista 2023). With this fiscal longevity and brand recognition, the success of the Barbie film is not surprising. The 2023 film, directed by Greta Gerwig and starring Australian Margot Robbie as Barbie and Canadian Ryan Gosling as Ken, as of March 2024 has a global box office revenue of US$1.45 billion, making it the 14th most successful movie of all time and the most successful movie directed by a woman (Statista 2024). Despite her popularity, Barbie has been the subject of controversy. Original Barbie’s proportions have been criticised for promoting an unrealistic body image (Thong). Barbie’s appearance has received numerous critiques for “representing an unrealistic beauty standard through its former limited skin tone and hair combination” (Lopez). The original Barbie’s measurements, if scaled to life-size, would mean Barbie is unusually tall and has a slim figure, with a height of 5 feet 9 inches, a waist of just 18 inches, and hips of approximately 33 inches. Her bust would measure around 32 inches with an under-bust of 22 inches, and her shoulder width would be approximately 28 inches. Original Barbie’s legs, which are proportionally longer than an average human’s, would make up more than half her height (Thong). A 1996 Australian study scaled Barbie and Ken to adult sizes and compared this with the physical proportions of a range of women and men. They found that the likelihood of finding a man of comparable shape to Ken was 1 in 50. Barbie was more problematic. The chance of a woman being the same proportion as Barbie was 1 in 100,000 (Norton et al. 287). In 2011, The Huffington Post’s Galia Slayen built a life-sized Barbie based on Barbie’s body measurements for National Eating Disorder Awareness Week. Slayen concluded that “if Barbie was a real woman, she’d have to walk on all fours due to her proportions”. One report found that if Barbie’s measurements were those of a real woman her “bones would be so frail, it would be impossible for her to walk, and she would only have half a liver” (Golgowski). A 2006 study found that Barbie is a “possible cause” for young girls’ “body dissatisfaction”. In this study, 162 girls from age 5 to 8 were exposed to images of a thin doll (Barbie), a plus-size doll (US doll Emme, size 16), or no doll, and then completed assessments of body image. Girls exposed to Barbie reported “lower body esteem and greater desire for a thinner body shape than girls in the other exposure conditions”. The study concluded that “early exposure to dolls epitomizing an unrealistically thin body ideal may damage girls' body image, which would contribute to an increased risk of disordered eating and weight cycling” (Dittman and Halliwell 283). Another study in 2016 found that “exposure to Barbie” led to “higher thin-ideal internalization”, but found that Barbie had no “impact on body esteem or body dissatisfaction” (Rice et al. 142). In response to such criticism, Mattel slowly introduced a variety of Barbie dolls with more diverse body types, including tall, petite, and curvy models (Tamkin). These changes aim to reflect a broader range of beauty standards and promote a more positive body image. Barbie has always had to accommodate social norms. For this reason, Barbie always must have underpants, and has no nipples. One of the reasons why Ruth Handler’s husband Elliott (also a co-founder of Mattel) was initially against producing the Barbie doll was that she had breasts, reportedly saying mothers would not buy their daughters a doll with breasts (Gerber). Margot Robbie, on playing Barbie, told one news outlet that while Barbie is “sexualized”, she “should never be sexy” (Aguirre). Early prototypes of Barbie made in Japan in the 1950s sexualised her body, leaving her to look like a prostitute. In response, Mattel hired film make-up artist Bud Westmore to redo Barbie’s face and hair with a softer look. Mattel also removed the nipples from the prototypes (Gerber). Barbie’s body and fashion have always seemed to “replicate history and show what was what was happening at the time” (Mowbray), and they also reflect how the female body is continually surveilled. Feminists have had a long history of criticism of Barbie, particularly her projection of the thin ideal. At the 1970 New York Women’s Strike for Equality, feminists shouted “I am not a Barbie doll!” Such debates exemplify the role and impact of toys in shaping and reforming societal norms and expectations. Even the more recent debates regarding the 2023 Barbie film show that Barbie is still a “lightning rod for the messy, knotty contradictions of feminism, sexism, misogyny and body image” (Chappet). Decades of criticism about Barbie, her meaning and influence, have left some to ask “Is Barbie a feminist icon, or a doll which props up the patriarchy?” Of course, she’s both, because “like all real women, Barbie has always been expected to conform to impossible standards” (Chappet). Over the decades Mattel has slowly changed Barbie’s body, including early versions of a black Barbie-like dolls in the 1960s and 1970s such as Francie, Christie, Julia, and Cara. However, it was not until 1980 that Mattel introduced the first black Barbie. African American fashion designer Kitty Black-Perkins, who worked for Mattel from 1971, was the principal designer for black Barbie, saying that “there was a need for the little Black girl to really have something she could play with that looked like her” (cited in Lafond). Black Barbie was marketed as She’s black! She’s beautiful! She’s dynamite! The following year, Asian Barbie was introduced. She was criticised for her nondescript country of origin and dressed in an “outfit that was a mishmash of Chinese, Korean and Japanese ethnic costumes” (Wong). More recently, the Asian Barbies were again criticised for portraying stereotypes, with a recent Asian Barbie dressed as a veterinarian caring for pandas, and Asian violinist Barbie with accompanying violin props, reflecting typical stereotypes of Asians in the US (Wong). In 2016, Mattel introduced a range of Barbie and Ken dolls with seven body types, including more curvy body shapes, 11 skin tones and 28 hairstyles (Siazon). In 2019, other Barbie body types appeared, with smaller busts, less defined waist, and more defined arms. The 2019 range also included Barbies with permanent physical disabilities, one using a wheelchair and one with a prosthetic leg (Siazon). Wheelchair Barbie comes with a wheelchair, and her body has 22 joints for body movement while sitting in the wheelchair. The Prosthetic Barbie comes with a prosthetic leg which can be removed, and was made in collaboration with Jordan Reeve, a 13-year-old disability activist born without a left forearm. In 2020, a No Hair Barbie and a Barbie with the skin condition vitiligo were introduced, and in 2022, Hearing Aid Barbie was also launched. In 2022 other changes were made to Barbie’s and Ken’s bodies, with bodies that became fuller figured and Kens with smaller chests and less masculine body shapes (Dolan). Down Syndrome Barbie was released in 2023, designed in collaboration with the US National Down Syndrome Society to ensure accurate representation. By 2024, Barbie dolls come in 35 skin tones, 97 hairstyles, and nine body types (Mattel 2024). Spanning hundreds of iterations, today the Barbie doll is no longer a homogenous, blond-haired, blue-eyed toy, but rather an evolving social phenomenon, adapting with the times and the markets Mattel expands into. With dolls of numerous ethnicities and body types, Barbie has also embraced inclusivity, catering to the plethora of different consumers across the world (Green and Gellene 1989). While not dismissing Barbie’s problematic place in feminist, gender and racial critiques, Barbie has always been a social influencer. Her early years were marked by a variety of makeovers and modernisations, as have recent changes to Barbie’s body, reflecting the changing social norms of the times. Stereotypical Barbie had her first major makeover in 1961, with her ponytail swapped for a short ‘Bubble Bob’ hairstyle inspired by Jackie Kennedy and Marilyn Monroe, reflecting women’s emerging social independence (Foreman). In the early 1970s, Barbie’s original demure face with averted eyes was replaced by a new one that “depicted confidence and a forward-facing gaze” (Vander Bent). Her “soft look” was a departure from the mature image of the original 1959 Barbie (Lafond). The ‘soft look’ on Malibu Barbie with her newly sculpted face featured an open smile for the first time, as well as sun-tanned, make-up free skin and sun-kissed blonde hair. The disappearance of Barbie’s coy, sideways glance and the introduction of forward-looking eyes was a development “welcomed by feminists” (Ford). Barbie’s early makeovers, along with her fashion and accessories, including her homes, cars, and pets, contributed to shaping her image as a fashionable and independent woman. Barbie’s various careers and roles have been used to promote ideas of female empowerment. From astronaut to presidential candidate, Barbie has broken barriers in traditionally male-dominated fields. However, the effectiveness of these efforts in promoting female empowerment is a topic of debate. The post-war period in America saw a significant shift in the pattern of living, with a move from urban areas to the suburbs. This was facilitated by a robust post-war economy, favourable government policies like the GI Bill, and increasing urbanisation. The GI Bill played a crucial role by providing low-interest home loans to veterans, making home ownership accessible to a large segment of the population. It was a significant transformation of the American lifestyle and shaped the country’s socio-economic landscape. It is in this context that Barbie’s first Dreamhouse was introduced in the early 1960s, with its mid-century modern décor, hi-fi stereo, and slim-line furniture. This was at a time when most American women could not get a mortgage. Barbie got her first car in 1962, a peach-colored Austin-Healey 3000 MKII convertible, followed short afterwards by a Porsche 911. She has also owned a pink Jaguar XJS, a pink Mustang, a red Ferrari, and a Corvette. Barbie’s car choices of luxurious convertibles spoke to Barbie’s social and economic success. In 1998, Barbie became a NASCAR driver and also signed up to race in a Ferrari in the Formula 1. Barbie’s ‘I Can Be Anything’ range from 2008 was designed to draw kids playing with the dolls toward ambitious careers; one of those careers was as a race car driver (Southwell). While Barbie’s first job as a baby-sitter was not as glamourous or well-paying as her most of her other over 250 careers, it does reflect the cultural landscape Barbie was living in in the 1960s. Babysitter Barbie (1963) featured Barbie wearing a long, pink-striped skirt with ‘babysitter’ emblasoned along the hem and thick-framed glasses. She came with a baby in a crib, a telephone, bottles of soda, and a book. The book was called How to Lose Weight and had only two words of advice, ‘Don’t Eat’. Even though there was a backlash to the extreme dieting advice, Mattel included the book in the 1965 Slumber Party Barbie. Barbie wore pink silk pajamas with a matching robe and came prepared for her sleepover with toiletries, a mirror, the controversial diet book, and a set of scales permanently set at 110 pounds (approx. 50kg), which caused further backlash (Ford). Barbie’s early careers were those either acceptable or accessible to women of the era, such as the Fashion Designer Barbie (1960), Flight Attendant Barbie (1961), and Nurse Barbie (1962). However, in 1965 Barbie went into space, two years after cosmonaut Valentina Tereshkova became the first woman in space, and four years before the American moon landing. Barbie’s career stagnated in the 1970s, and she spends the decade being sports Barbie, perhaps as a response to her unpopularity among vocal second wave feminists and reflecting the economic downturn of the era. America’s shift to the right in the 1980s saw in the introduction of the Yuppie, the young urban professional who lived in the city, had a high-powered career, and was consumption-driven. More women were entering the workforce than ever before. Barbie also entered the workforce, spending less time doing the passive leisure of her earlier self (Ford). It also signals the beginning of neoliberalism in America, and a shift to individualism and the rise of the free market ethos. In 1985, Day-to-Night Barbie was sold as the first CEO Barbie who “could go from running the boardroom in her pink power suit to a fun night out on the town”. For Mattel she “celebrated the workplace evolution of the era and showed girls they could have it all”. But despite Barbie’s early careers, the focus was on her "emphasized femininity”, meaning that while she was now a career woman, her appearance and demeanor did not reflect her job. Astronaut Barbie (1985) is a...
- 11 June 2024
- Published by Queensland University of Technology in M/C Journal
- Vol. 27 (3)
Open AccessBarbie
The story of Barbie is a tapestry woven with threads of cultural significance, societal shifts, and corporate narratives. It’s a tale that encapsulates the evolution of American post-war capitalism, mirroring the changing tides of social norms, aspirations, and identities. Barbie’s journey from Germany to Los Angeles, along the way becoming a global icon, is a testament to the power of Ruth Handler’s vision and Barbie’s marketing. Barbie embodies and reflects the rise of mass consumption and the early days of television advertising, where one doll could become a household name and shape the dreams of children worldwide. The controversies and criticisms surrounding Barbie – from promoting a ‘thin ideal’ to perpetuating gender and racial stereotypes – highlight the complexities of representation in popular culture. Yet, Barbie’s enduring message, “You can be anything”, continues to inspire and empower, even as it evolves to embrace a more inclusive and diverse portrayals of power, beauty, and potential. Barbie’s story is not just about a doll; it’s about the aspirations she represents, the societal changes she’s witnessed, and the ongoing conversation about her impact on gender roles, body image, and consumer culture. It’s a narrative that continues to unfold, as Barbie adapts to the times and remains a symbol of possibility. “It is impossible to conceive of the toy industry as being anything other than dependent on a popular culture which shapes and structures the meanings carried by toys” (Fleming 40). The relationship between toys and popular culture is symbiotic. While popular culture influences the creation of toys, toys also contribute to the spread and longevity of cultural icons and narratives. Today, one of the most influential, popular, and contested toys of the twentieth century is Mattel’s Barbie doll. Her launch at the New York Toy Fair on 9 March 1959 by Mattel co-founder Ruth Handler was a game-changer in the toy industry. Her adult appearance, symbolised by her fashionable swimsuit and ponytail, was a bold move by Mattel. Despite the doubts from the toy industry which thought nobody would want to play with a doll that had breasts (Tamkin) and Mattel’s skepticism of its commercial success (Westenhouser 14), Barbie was a success, selling over 350,000 units in her first year, and she quickly became an iconic figure, paving the way for other male and female adult dolls. For the first time in mid-century America, Barbie meant children could play with a doll that looked like a woman, not a little girl or a baby. In a 1965 interview, Ruth Handler argued that American girls needed a doll with a “teen-age figure and a lot of glorious, imaginative, high-fashion clothes” (cited in Giacomin and Lubinski 3). In a 1993 interview, Handler said it was “important that Barbie allowed play situations that little girls could project themselves into … to imagine, pretend and to fantasize”. Hence Ruth Handler’s Barbie could be an “avatar for girls to project their dreams onto” (Southwell). Barbie hit the market with a “sassy ponytail, heavy eyeliner, a healthy dose of side-eye and a distinctly adult body” (Blackmore). Her arched eyebrows were matched with a coy sideways glance reflecting her sexual origins (Thong). Mattel did not reveal that Ruth Handler’s Barbie was inspired by a German novelty men’s toy, Bild Lilli, which Handler had purchased on a European holiday in 1955. Mattel fought several lawsuits and eventually secured the rights to Bild Lilli in 1964, which required the German maker of the Bild Lilli doll to not make her again. Barbie dolls, both blonde and brunette, changed little until 1967, when Mattel launch the ‘new’ Barbie doll which is the foundation for today’s Stereotypical Barbie. The same size as the original, thanks to Mattel engineer Jack Ryan she could twist and turn at the waist. Her facial features were softened, she had ‘real’ eyelashes’ and took on an ‘outdoor look’. The new 1967 version of Barbie originally retailed for US$3.00. Mattel, assuming consumers may not want to buy a new Barbie when they already had one, offered buyers the new Barbie at US$1.50 if they traded in their old 1950s Barbie. The television advertising campaign for the new Barbie featured Maureen McMormick (who would go on to play Marcia Brady in the TV series The Brady Bunch from 1969 to 1974). The original #1 Barbie today sells for over US$25,000 (Reinhard). The most expensive Barbie sold to date was a Stefano Canturi-designed Barbie that sold in 2010 for US$302,500 at Christies in New York (Clarendon). Barbie has been described as “the most successful doll in history”, “the most popular toy in history”, the “empress of fashion dolls” (Rogers 86), the “most famous doll in the world” (Ferorelli), the biggest-selling fashion doll in history (Green and Gellene), and is one if the world’s “most commercially successful toys” (Fleming 41). Barbie is both “idealistic and materialistic” and characterises an “American fantasy” (Tamkin). More so, she is a popular culture icon and “a unique indicator of women’s history” (Vander Bent). The inclusion of Barbie in America’s twentieth-century Time Capsule “cemented her status as a true American icon” (Ford), as did Andy Warhol when he iconised Barbie in his 1968 painting of her (Moore). During the 1950s and 1960s, Barbie’s name was licenced to over 100 companies; while a strategic move that expanded Barbie’s brand presence, it also provided Mattel with substantial royalty payments for decades. This approach helped solidify Barbie’s status as a cultural icon and enabled her to become a lucrative asset for Mattel (Rogers). Sixty-five years later, Barbie has 99% global brand awareness. In 2021, Mattel shipped more than 86 million Barbies globally, manufacturing 164 Barbies a minute (Tomkins). In 2022, Barbie generated gross sales of US$1.49 billion (Statista 2023). With this fiscal longevity and brand recognition, the success of the Barbie film is not surprising. The 2023 film, directed by Greta Gerwig and starring Australian Margot Robbie as Barbie and Canadian Ryan Gosling as Ken, as of March 2024 has a global box office revenue of US$1.45 billion, making it the 14th most successful movie of all time and the most successful movie directed by a woman (Statista 2024). Despite her popularity, Barbie has been the subject of controversy. Original Barbie’s proportions have been criticised for promoting an unrealistic body image (Thong). Barbie’s appearance has received numerous critiques for “representing an unrealistic beauty standard through its former limited skin tone and hair combination” (Lopez). The original Barbie’s measurements, if scaled to life-size, would mean Barbie is unusually tall and has a slim figure, with a height of 5 feet 9 inches, a waist of just 18 inches, and hips of approximately 33 inches. Her bust would measure around 32 inches with an under-bust of 22 inches, and her shoulder width would be approximately 28 inches. Original Barbie’s legs, which are proportionally longer than an average human’s, would make up more than half her height (Thong). A 1996 Australian study scaled Barbie and Ken to adult sizes and compared this with the physical proportions of a range of women and men. They found that the likelihood of finding a man of comparable shape to Ken was 1 in 50. Barbie was more problematic. The chance of a woman being the same proportion as Barbie was 1 in 100,000 (Norton et al. 287). In 2011, The Huffington Post’s Galia Slayen built a life-sized Barbie based on Barbie’s body measurements for National Eating Disorder Awareness Week. Slayen concluded that “if Barbie was a real woman, she’d have to walk on all fours due to her proportions”. One report found that if Barbie’s measurements were those of a real woman her “bones would be so frail, it would be impossible for her to walk, and she would only have half a liver” (Golgowski). A 2006 study found that Barbie is a “possible cause” for young girls’ “body dissatisfaction”. In this study, 162 girls from age 5 to 8 were exposed to images of a thin doll (Barbie), a plus-size doll (US doll Emme, size 16), or no doll, and then completed assessments of body image. Girls exposed to Barbie reported “lower body esteem and greater desire for a thinner body shape than girls in the other exposure conditions”. The study concluded that “early exposure to dolls epitomizing an unrealistically thin body ideal may damage girls' body image, which would contribute to an increased risk of disordered eating and weight cycling” (Dittman and Halliwell 283). Another study in 2016 found that “exposure to Barbie” led to “higher thin-ideal internalization”, but found that Barbie had no “impact on body esteem or body dissatisfaction” (Rice et al. 142). In response to such criticism, Mattel slowly introduced a variety of Barbie dolls with more diverse body types, including tall, petite, and curvy models (Tamkin). These changes aim to reflect a broader range of beauty standards and promote a more positive body image. Barbie has always had to accommodate social norms. For this reason, Barbie always must have underpants, and has no nipples. One of the reasons why Ruth Handler’s husband Elliott (also a co-founder of Mattel) was initially against producing the Barbie doll was that she had breasts, reportedly saying mothers would not buy their daughters a doll with breasts (Gerber). Margot Robbie, on playing Barbie, told one news outlet that while Barbie is “sexualized”, she “should never be sexy” (Aguirre). Early prototypes of Barbie made in Japan in the 1950s sexualised her body, leaving her to look like a prostitute. In response, Mattel hired film make-up artist Bud Westmore to redo Barbie’s face and hair with a softer look. Mattel also removed the nipples from the prototypes (Gerber). Barbie’s body and fashion have always seemed to “replicate history and show what was what was happening at the time” (Mowbray), and they also reflect how the female body is continually surveilled. Feminists have had a long history of criticism of Barbie, particularly her projection of the thin ideal. At the 1970 New York Women’s Strike for Equality, feminists shouted “I am not a Barbie doll!” Such debates exemplify the role and impact of toys in shaping and reforming societal norms and expectations. Even the more recent debates regarding the 2023 Barbie film show that Barbie is still a “lightning rod for the messy, knotty contradictions of feminism, sexism, misogyny and body image” (Chappet). Decades of criticism about Barbie, her meaning and influence, have left some to ask “Is Barbie a feminist icon, or a doll which props up the patriarchy?” Of course, she’s both, because “like all real women, Barbie has always been expected to conform to impossible standards” (Chappet). Over the decades Mattel has slowly changed Barbie’s body, including early versions of a black Barbie-like dolls in the 1960s and 1970s such as Francie, Christie, Julia, and Cara. However, it was not until 1980 that Mattel introduced the first black Barbie. African American fashion designer Kitty Black-Perkins, who worked for Mattel from 1971, was the principal designer for black Barbie, saying that “there was a need for the little Black girl to really have something she could play with that looked like her” (cited in Lafond). Black Barbie was marketed as She’s black! She’s beautiful! She’s dynamite! The following year, Asian Barbie was introduced. She was criticised for her nondescript country of origin and dressed in an “outfit that was a mishmash of Chinese, Korean and Japanese ethnic costumes” (Wong). More recently, the Asian Barbies were again criticised for portraying stereotypes, with a recent Asian Barbie dressed as a veterinarian caring for pandas, and Asian violinist Barbie with accompanying violin props, reflecting typical stereotypes of Asians in the US (Wong). In 2016, Mattel introduced a range of Barbie and Ken dolls with seven body types, including more curvy body shapes, 11 skin tones and 28 hairstyles (Siazon). In 2019, other Barbie body types appeared, with smaller busts, less defined waist, and more defined arms. The 2019 range also included Barbies with permanent physical disabilities, one using a wheelchair and one with a prosthetic leg (Siazon). Wheelchair Barbie comes with a wheelchair, and her body has 22 joints for body movement while sitting in the wheelchair. The Prosthetic Barbie comes with a prosthetic leg which can be removed, and was made in collaboration with Jordan Reeve, a 13-year-old disability activist born without a left forearm. In 2020, a No Hair Barbie and a Barbie with the skin condition vitiligo were introduced, and in 2022, Hearing Aid Barbie was also launched. In 2022 other changes were made to Barbie’s and Ken’s bodies, with bodies that became fuller figured and Kens with smaller chests and less masculine body shapes (Dolan). Down Syndrome Barbie was released in 2023, designed in collaboration with the US National Down Syndrome Society to ensure accurate representation. By 2024, Barbie dolls come in 35 skin tones, 97 hairstyles, and nine body types (Mattel 2024). Spanning hundreds of iterations, today the Barbie doll is no longer a homogenous, blond-haired, blue-eyed toy, but rather an evolving social phenomenon, adapting with the times and the markets Mattel expands into. With dolls of numerous ethnicities and body types, Barbie has also embraced inclusivity, catering to the plethora of different consumers across the world (Green and Gellene 1989). While not dismissing Barbie’s problematic place in feminist, gender and racial critiques, Barbie has always been a social influencer. Her early years were marked by a variety of makeovers and modernisations, as have recent changes to Barbie’s body, reflecting the changing social norms of the times. Stereotypical Barbie had her first major makeover in 1961, with her ponytail swapped for a short ‘Bubble Bob’ hairstyle inspired by Jackie Kennedy and Marilyn Monroe, reflecting women’s emerging social independence (Foreman). In the early 1970s, Barbie’s original demure face with averted eyes was replaced by a new one that “depicted confidence and a forward-facing gaze” (Vander Bent). Her “soft look” was a departure from the mature image of the original 1959 Barbie (Lafond). The ‘soft look’ on Malibu Barbie with her newly sculpted face featured an open smile for the first time, as well as sun-tanned, make-up free skin and sun-kissed blonde hair. The disappearance of Barbie’s coy, sideways glance and the introduction of forward-looking eyes was a development “welcomed by feminists” (Ford). Barbie’s early makeovers, along with her fashion and accessories, including her homes, cars, and pets, contributed to shaping her image as a fashionable and independent woman. Barbie’s various careers and roles have been used to promote ideas of female empowerment. From astronaut to presidential candidate, Barbie has broken barriers in traditionally male-dominated fields. However, the effectiveness of these efforts in promoting female empowerment is a topic of debate. The post-war period in America saw a significant shift in the pattern of living, with a move from urban areas to the suburbs. This was facilitated by a robust post-war economy, favourable government policies like the GI Bill, and increasing urbanisation. The GI Bill played a crucial role by providing low-interest home loans to veterans, making home ownership accessible to a large segment of the population. It was a significant transformation of the American lifestyle and shaped the country’s socio-economic landscape. It is in this context that Barbie’s first Dreamhouse was introduced in the early 1960s, with its mid-century modern décor, hi-fi stereo, and slim-line furniture. This was at a time when most American women could not get a mortgage. Barbie got her first car in 1962, a peach-colored Austin-Healey 3000 MKII convertible, followed short afterwards by a Porsche 911. She has also owned a pink Jaguar XJS, a pink Mustang, a red Ferrari, and a Corvette. Barbie’s car choices of luxurious convertibles spoke to Barbie’s social and economic success. In 1998, Barbie became a NASCAR driver and also signed up to race in a Ferrari in the Formula 1. Barbie’s ‘I Can Be Anything’ range from 2008 was designed to draw kids playing with the dolls toward ambitious careers; one of those careers was as a race car driver (Southwell). While Barbie’s first job as a baby-sitter was not as glamourous or well-paying as her most of her other over 250 careers, it does reflect the cultural landscape Barbie was living in in the 1960s. Babysitter Barbie (1963) featured Barbie wearing a long, pink-striped skirt with ‘babysitter’ emblasoned along the hem and thick-framed glasses. She came with a baby in a crib, a telephone, bottles of soda, and a book. The book was called How to Lose Weight and had only two words of advice, ‘Don’t Eat’. Even though there was a backlash to the extreme dieting advice, Mattel included the book in the 1965 Slumber Party Barbie. Barbie wore pink silk pajamas with a matching robe and came prepared for her sleepover with toiletries, a mirror, the controversial diet book, and a set of scales permanently set at 110 pounds (approx. 50kg), which caused further backlash (Ford). Barbie’s early careers were those either acceptable or accessible to women of the era, such as the Fashion Designer Barbie (1960), Flight Attendant Barbie (1961), and Nurse Barbie (1962). However, in 1965 Barbie went into space, two years after cosmonaut Valentina Tereshkova became the first woman in space, and four years before the American moon landing. Barbie’s career stagnated in the 1970s, and she spends the decade being sports Barbie, perhaps as a response to her unpopularity among vocal second wave feminists and reflecting the economic downturn of the era. America’s shift to the right in the 1980s saw in the introduction of the Yuppie, the young urban professional who lived in the city, had a high-powered career, and was consumption-driven. More women were entering the workforce than ever before. Barbie also entered the workforce, spending less time doing the passive leisure of her earlier self (Ford). It also signals the beginning of neoliberalism in America, and a shift to individualism and the rise of the free market ethos. In 1985, Day-to-Night Barbie was sold as the first CEO Barbie who “could go from running the boardroom in her pink power suit to a fun night out on the town”. For Mattel she “celebrated the workplace evolution of the era and showed girls they could have it all”. But despite Barbie’s early careers, the focus was on her "emphasized femininity”, meaning that while she was now a career woman, her appearance and demeanor did not reflect her job. Astronaut Barbie (1985) is a...