Vicente Bellver Capella
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Vicente Bellver Capella has a total of 21 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Alejandro Salcedo-Romo1 shared publication
Andrzej Grzybowski
University of Warmia and Mazury, Olsztyn, Poland
1 shared publication- Angela Aparisi Miralles
Universidad de Navarra
1 shared publication - Constantine Psimopoulos
Human Flourishing Program, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA
1 shared publication - Encarnación Fernández Ruiz-Gálvez
Universidad de Valencia
1 shared publication - Federico De Montalvo Jääskeläinen1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 November 2026
- Published by Universidad de Navarra in Persona y Derecho
- p. 13-48
El ser humano en el pensamiento de Jesús Ballesteros
La reflexión sobre el ser humano es una constante en la obra de Jesús Ballesteros. Sin embargo, no cuenta con un trabajo monográfico que la presente de manera orgánica y completa. Aquí nos proponemos identificar esos rasgos fundamentales de su antropología filosófica. Para lograr este objetivo hemos revisado la casi totalidad de su obra, si bien partimos de su libro Sobre el sentido del derecho, que cuenta con un epígrafe titulado “Antropología jurídica”. Después de presentar la definición de antropología filosófica que propone el profesor valenciano nos centramos en explicar las siete notas que, a nuestro parecer, sintetizan su concepción acerca del ser humano: existencia, indigencia-vulnerabilidad, alteridad, cuidado, temporalidad, re-sistencia y trascendencia.
- 10 November 2026
- Published by Universidad de Navarra in Persona y Derecho
- p. 13-48
Open AccessEl ser humano en el pensamiento de Jesús Ballesteros
La reflexión sobre el ser humano es una constante en la obra de Jesús Ballesteros. Sin embargo, no cuenta con un trabajo monográfico que la presente de manera orgánica y completa. Aquí nos proponemos identificar esos rasgos fundamentales de su antropología filosófica. Para lograr este objetivo hemos revisado la casi totalidad de su obra, si bien partimos de su libro Sobre el sentido del derecho, que cuenta con un epígrafe titulado “Antropología jurídica”. Después de presentar la definición de antropología filosófica que propone el profesor valenciano nos centramos en explicar las siete notas que, a nuestro parecer, sintetizan su concepción acerca del ser humano: existencia, indigencia-vulnerabilidad, alteridad, cuidado, temporalidad, re-sistencia y trascendencia.
- Open Access
- 10 November 2026
- Published by Universidad de Navarra in Persona y Derecho
- p. 7-10
Presentación. Jesús Ballesteros, el magisterio fecundo
- 10 November 2026
- Published by Universidad de Navarra in Persona y Derecho
- p. 7-10
Open AccessPresentación. Jesús Ballesteros, el magisterio fecundo
- Open Access
- 28 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Ethics
Best Practice Guidelines for Bioethical Use of Medical AI in Healthcare. An eDelphi Consensus Exercise
Introduction: Medical Artificial Intelligence (MAI) is transforming healthcare but raises significant ethical concerns. Despite emerging principles and regulations, to our knowledge, no standardized clinical bioethics framework exists to guide MAI practice. Objective: This Delphi study sought global expert agreement on ethical challenges, principles, guidelines, and practical tools for MAI use. Method: A four-round international eDelphi study, conducted under ACCORD and DELPHISTAR guidance, engaged multidisciplinary stakeholders identified through systematic review and targeted recruitment. Preliminary items were evidence-derived and iteratively refined. Consensus (≥ 80% agreement across two rounds) was predefined. Surveys were anonymized and randomized. Ethical approval and protocol registration were secured before study initiation. Results: The panel included 53 participants from 21 countries. Survey rounds started November 2025 and ended February 2026. 170 items were considered. 132 reached consensus. Items were classified into bioethical issues, values, principles, solutions, a checklist for clinicians, and report markers for risk management. Discussion: This study produced clinician-focused practice guidelines for the bioethical use of MAI. Ethical components aligned with prior literature, while no new bioethical principles met consensus. Limitations included geographic imbalance and stakeholder representation. Recommendations emphasized human responsibility, governance, and practical implementation tools. Conclusion: This Delphi consensus provides practical, ethics-based guidance for the responsible integration of MAI into clinical practice and institutional governance.
- 28 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Ethics
Open AccessBest Practice Guidelines for Bioethical Use of Medical AI in Healthcare. An eDelphi Consensus Exercise
Introduction: Medical Artificial Intelligence (MAI) is transforming healthcare but raises significant ethical concerns. Despite emerging principles and regulations, to our knowledge, no standardized clinical bioethics framework exists to guide MAI practice. Objective: This Delphi study sought global expert agreement on ethical challenges, principles, guidelines, and practical tools for MAI use. Method: A four-round international eDelphi study, conducted under ACCORD and DELPHISTAR guidance, engaged multidisciplinary stakeholders identified through systematic review and targeted recruitment. Preliminary items were evidence-derived and iteratively refined. Consensus (≥ 80% agreement across two rounds) was predefined. Surveys were anonymized and randomized. Ethical approval and protocol registration were secured before study initiation. Results: The panel included 53 participants from 21 countries. Survey rounds started November 2025 and ended February 2026. 170 items were considered. 132 reached consensus. Items were classified into bioethical issues, values, principles, solutions, a checklist for clinicians, and report markers for risk management. Discussion: This study produced clinician-focused practice guidelines for the bioethical use of MAI. Ethical components aligned with prior literature, while no new bioethical principles met consensus. Limitations included geographic imbalance and stakeholder representation. Recommendations emphasized human responsibility, governance, and practical implementation tools. Conclusion: This Delphi consensus provides practical, ethics-based guidance for the responsible integration of MAI into clinical practice and institutional governance.
- Open Access
- 13 November 2023
- Published by Universidad de Navarra in Persona y Derecho
- Vol. 89, 153-201
Los derechos de la persona mayor y dependiente: entre la vulnerabilidad existencial y la vulnerabilidad construida
El cruce entre envejecimiento y progresiva dependencia da lugar a uno de los estadios de mayor vulnerabilidad en la existencia de todo ser humano. En este trabajo me pregunto en qué medida la perspectiva de los derechos humanos está siendo correctamente aplicada a este colectivo de personas mayores y altamente dependientes. Para responder a esta pregunta empiezo distinguiendo entre los conceptos de vulnerabilidad existencial y vulnerabilidad construida. Mientras que la primera debe ser asumida por los individuos y cuidada por la sociedad, la segunda debe ser combatida. A continuación, hago una revisión de las políticas públicas que se vienen impulsando a nivel mundial y regional en relación con el reconocimiento de los derechos de las personas mayores que se van volviendo crecientemente dependientes. Ese repaso me lleva a advertir cierta desproporción entre la insistencia en garantizar los derechos del mayor que puede actuar autónomamente frente a quienes, siendo altamente dependientes y estando próximos a morir, apenas pueden llevar una vida independiente. Ese hincapié en el envejecimiento activo y saludable, si no integra los cuidados de larga duración y de final de vida, puede acabar volviéndose contra las personas mayores cuando son más frágiles porque, al basarse en un desconocimiento de la vulnerabilidad existencial del ser humano, acaba generando vulnerabilidad construida.
- 13 November 2023
- Published by Universidad de Navarra in Persona y Derecho
- Vol. 89, 153-201
Open AccessLos derechos de la persona mayor y dependiente: entre la vulnerabilidad existencial y la vulnerabilidad construida
El cruce entre envejecimiento y progresiva dependencia da lugar a uno de los estadios de mayor vulnerabilidad en la existencia de todo ser humano. En este trabajo me pregunto en qué medida la perspectiva de los derechos humanos está siendo correctamente aplicada a este colectivo de personas mayores y altamente dependientes. Para responder a esta pregunta empiezo distinguiendo entre los conceptos de vulnerabilidad existencial y vulnerabilidad construida. Mientras que la primera debe ser asumida por los individuos y cuidada por la sociedad, la segunda debe ser combatida. A continuación, hago una revisión de las políticas públicas que se vienen impulsando a nivel mundial y regional en relación con el reconocimiento de los derechos de las personas mayores que se van volviendo crecientemente dependientes. Ese repaso me lleva a advertir cierta desproporción entre la insistencia en garantizar los derechos del mayor que puede actuar autónomamente frente a quienes, siendo altamente dependientes y estando próximos a morir, apenas pueden llevar una vida independiente. Ese hincapié en el envejecimiento activo y saludable, si no integra los cuidados de larga duración y de final de vida, puede acabar volviéndose contra las personas mayores cuando son más frágiles porque, al basarse en un desconocimiento de la vulnerabilidad existencial del ser humano, acaba generando vulnerabilidad construida.
- Open Access
- 27 February 2023
- Published by Servicio de Publicaciones de la Universidad Autonoma de Madrid in Relaciones Internacionales
- No. 52,p. 153-171
Sobre la obligatoriedad de las vacunas en tiempos de covid-19: aproximación contextual y análisis desde el Derecho y las políticas comparadas
The most important and effective action to combat the COVID-19 pandemic, once it was verified that the initial immunity due to contagion or generalized confinements did not solve the problem in the medium term, has been vaccination. The success of vaccines is nothing new. Throughout the history of humankind, vaccines have served to reduce and even eliminate some serious communicable diseases. It is not an exaggeration to say that, together with the purification of water and penicillin, the vaccination of the population against certain diseases is one of the greatest achievements both in the fields of public health and the health of individuals. However, the success of vaccines, not only in this pandemic, but throughout history, has always been in doubt. Despite the evidence of the preventative effect of vaccines, the anti-vaccine movement has endured over time and has even grown in recent decades. Such opposition has not diminished with the efficiency and safe results that the new vaccines against Covid-19 have produced using mRNA technology; on the contrary, it has continued to expand. After the development and authorization of vaccines against covid-19 in record time, the first challenge faced by vaccination campaigns around the world was to determine the priority in access to the resource when the availability of vaccines was still scarce. The criteria followed at this point were, at least in Europe, quite uniform, prioritizing the vaccination of those most in need. That is, the elderly, who are the most prone to suffering serious illnesses. Access to vaccines was very unequal worldwide and, to avoid this, different strategies were proposed, including the suspension of patent rights or the creation of the COVAX vaccine initiative to supply countries that could not buy them. Once a greater number of vaccines were available, and prioritizing access to them was no longer the main ethical-legal issue, the debate arose in many countries about the opportunity to incorporate vaccination as a legal duty. This involved changing the majority opinion in the world; although already the subject of discussion before the pandemic, it was argued to be a moral duty to receive the recommended vaccines to preserve public health and that of others. World public opinion was very attentive to this issue of compulsory vaccination, perhaps due to the rejection that vaccines aroused in certain sectors of the population and, in particular, the vaccine against Covid-19. The discussion about the balance between the freedom of individuals and the achievement of a collective interest as important as public and individual health was resolved at the legal level by the courts of justice. Specifically, the rulings of the Supreme Court in the United States and the European Court of Human Rights in Europe established criteria that were basically convergent. Both courts understand that states have the competency to oblige the population to be vaccinated in order to safeguard their health as long as certain requirements are met: a serious risk of a pandemic, a safe and effective vaccine to combat the disease exists, and the absence of less invasive measures to achieve the same result. These rulings have served to support the specific legal measures that were adopted during the pandemic by both the different states of the United States and the member states of the Council of Europe. Necessarily different concepts have been confused in the debate, in particular those of mandatory and forced vaccination, which do not belong to the same category because they limit different fundamental rights and do so with different levels of intensity. When speaking of mandatory vaccination, reference is made to a duty whose non-compliance determines a legal consequence, be it an economic sanction or a limitation of a right. Thus, the individual who neglects the obligation to be vaccinated will be fined, have their freedom of movement restricted, their working conditions altered or their employment and salary suspended. The legal consequence is not the forced vaccination of those who resist the vaccine, but generally an economic fine. On the contrary, when it comes to forced vaccination, the individual who disregards the obligation will be legally compelled to be vaccinated, resorting even to force if necessary. In other words, the right affected directly by the measure here is the integrity of the individual. These are, therefore, two measures of different significance, from the perspective of the rights ultimately affected by the limitation, and this difference must be taken into account from the principle of proportionality. In this paper we offer an overview of the various responses adopted by different States in relation to whether or not vaccination is mandatory, which have ranged from mandatory for certain groups or even for the entire population. Among those measures of indirect persuasion for vaccination are “covid passports”. Our work identifies a broad agreement in the international community on the compatibility between mandatory vaccination and the safeguarding of fundamental rights when certain conditions are met. It is also recognized that proportionality in the adoption of measures is the most effective way to achieve the desired objective of reaching high levels of vaccination in the population. In any case, it would have been desirable to have advanced formulas of persuasion that would have gone beyond information and training, without incurring in the adoption of measures that strongly restrict personal liberty, such as compulsory vaccination. Faced with this international agreement, we do not find shared criteria in other areas related to vaccines: their development and authorization, their fair distribution, or information about them. This absence of shared visions and cooperation gives rise to rivalries that reinforce the traditional clashes between powers. As the purpose of the work is to compare the...
- 27 February 2023
- Published by Servicio de Publicaciones de la Universidad Autonoma de Madrid in Relaciones Internacionales
- No. 52,p. 153-171
Open AccessSobre la obligatoriedad de las vacunas en tiempos de covid-19: aproximación contextual y análisis desde el Derecho y las políticas comparadas
The most important and effective action to combat the COVID-19 pandemic, once it was verified that the initial immunity due to contagion or generalized confinements did not solve the problem in the medium term, has been vaccination. The success of vaccines is nothing new. Throughout the history of humankind, vaccines have served to reduce and even eliminate some serious communicable diseases. It is not an exaggeration to say that, together with the purification of water and penicillin, the vaccination of the population against certain diseases is one of the greatest achievements both in the fields of public health and the health of individuals. However, the success of vaccines, not only in this pandemic, but throughout history, has always been in doubt. Despite the evidence of the preventative effect of vaccines, the anti-vaccine movement has endured over time and has even grown in recent decades. Such opposition has not diminished with the efficiency and safe results that the new vaccines against Covid-19 have produced using mRNA technology; on the contrary, it has continued to expand. After the development and authorization of vaccines against covid-19 in record time, the first challenge faced by vaccination campaigns around the world was to determine the priority in access to the resource when the availability of vaccines was still scarce. The criteria followed at this point were, at least in Europe, quite uniform, prioritizing the vaccination of those most in need. That is, the elderly, who are the most prone to suffering serious illnesses. Access to vaccines was very unequal worldwide and, to avoid this, different strategies were proposed, including the suspension of patent rights or the creation of the COVAX vaccine initiative to supply countries that could not buy them. Once a greater number of vaccines were available, and prioritizing access to them was no longer the main ethical-legal issue, the debate arose in many countries about the opportunity to incorporate vaccination as a legal duty. This involved changing the majority opinion in the world; although already the subject of discussion before the pandemic, it was argued to be a moral duty to receive the recommended vaccines to preserve public health and that of others. World public opinion was very attentive to this issue of compulsory vaccination, perhaps due to the rejection that vaccines aroused in certain sectors of the population and, in particular, the vaccine against Covid-19. The discussion about the balance between the freedom of individuals and the achievement of a collective interest as important as public and individual health was resolved at the legal level by the courts of justice. Specifically, the rulings of the Supreme Court in the United States and the European Court of Human Rights in Europe established criteria that were basically convergent. Both courts understand that states have the competency to oblige the population to be vaccinated in order to safeguard their health as long as certain requirements are met: a serious risk of a pandemic, a safe and effective vaccine to combat the disease exists, and the absence of less invasive measures to achieve the same result. These rulings have served to support the specific legal measures that were adopted during the pandemic by both the different states of the United States and the member states of the Council of Europe. Necessarily different concepts have been confused in the debate, in particular those of mandatory and forced vaccination, which do not belong to the same category because they limit different fundamental rights and do so with different levels of intensity. When speaking of mandatory vaccination, reference is made to a duty whose non-compliance determines a legal consequence, be it an economic sanction or a limitation of a right. Thus, the individual who neglects the obligation to be vaccinated will be fined, have their freedom of movement restricted, their working conditions altered or their employment and salary suspended. The legal consequence is not the forced vaccination of those who resist the vaccine, but generally an economic fine. On the contrary, when it comes to forced vaccination, the individual who disregards the obligation will be legally compelled to be vaccinated, resorting even to force if necessary. In other words, the right affected directly by the measure here is the integrity of the individual. These are, therefore, two measures of different significance, from the perspective of the rights ultimately affected by the limitation, and this difference must be taken into account from the principle of proportionality. In this paper we offer an overview of the various responses adopted by different States in relation to whether or not vaccination is mandatory, which have ranged from mandatory for certain groups or even for the entire population. Among those measures of indirect persuasion for vaccination are “covid passports”. Our work identifies a broad agreement in the international community on the compatibility between mandatory vaccination and the safeguarding of fundamental rights when certain conditions are met. It is also recognized that proportionality in the adoption of measures is the most effective way to achieve the desired objective of reaching high levels of vaccination in the population. In any case, it would have been desirable to have advanced formulas of persuasion that would have gone beyond information and training, without incurring in the adoption of measures that strongly restrict personal liberty, such as compulsory vaccination. Faced with this international agreement, we do not find shared criteria in other areas related to vaccines: their development and authorization, their fair distribution, or information about them. This absence of shared visions and cooperation gives rise to rivalries that reinforce the traditional clashes between powers. As the purpose of the work is to compare the...
- Open Access
- 24 June 2021
- Published by Cadernos Ibero-Americanos de Direito Sanitario in CADERNOS IBERO-AMERICANOS DE DIREITO SANITÁRIO
- Vol. 10 (2) , 233-252
Educar para la salud en tiempos de pandemia
The experience of the pandemic that we are living requires rethinking health education. In this paper we do it based on two ideas from the Universal Declaration of Human Rights: first, that the aim of education is the full development of the person; and second, that duties towards the community contribute to that development. Based on them, we defend a conception of health education based on the relational nature of the human being, on the relevance of the social determinants of health and on the dangers of the digital environment, despite the enormous benefits it has brought during the pandemic.
- 24 June 2021
- Published by Cadernos Ibero-Americanos de Direito Sanitario in CADERNOS IBERO-AMERICANOS DE DIREITO SANITÁRIO
- Vol. 10 (2) , 233-252
Open AccessEducar para la salud en tiempos de pandemia
The experience of the pandemic that we are living requires rethinking health education. In this paper we do it based on two ideas from the Universal Declaration of Human Rights: first, that the aim of education is the full development of the person; and second, that duties towards the community contribute to that development. Based on them, we defend a conception of health education based on the relational nature of the human being, on the relevance of the social determinants of health and on the dangers of the digital environment, despite the enormous benefits it has brought during the pandemic.
- Open Access
- 17 June 2021
- Published by Universidad de Navarra in Persona y Derecho
- p. 17-53
Transhumanismo, discurso transgénero y digitalismo: ¿exigencias de justicia o efectos del espíritu de abstracción?
Los tres grandes desafíos existenciales para el ser humano en el tiempo presente son el transhumanismo, el discurso transgénero y el digitalismo. Estos tres fenómenos contienen demandas de justicia y emancipación dirigidas a acabar con formas de discriminación muy arraigadas. Pero están sostenidos sobre una base filosófica que niega la inteligibilidad de la realidad y la condición teleológica de la existencia humana proponiendo, en su lugar, la hegemonía del deseo individual. El capitalismo contemporáneo ha hecho de la satisfacción de ese deseo su razón de ser. Y lo hace desarrollando una tecnología potencialmente capaz de satisfacer un deseo sin límites. Ese desarrollo tecnológico se sustenta en el espíritu de abstracción. Es la expresión más sofisticada del capitalismo porque, en lugar de suscitar la oposición de sus víctimas, genera su completa adhesión. La inevitable consecuencia es que las demandas de justicia son engullidas por la lógica del tecno-capitalismo y acaban convertidas en el maquillaje de las nuevas formas de (auto)explotación.
- 17 June 2021
- Published by Universidad de Navarra in Persona y Derecho
- p. 17-53
Open AccessTranshumanismo, discurso transgénero y digitalismo: ¿exigencias de justicia o efectos del espíritu de abstracción?
Los tres grandes desafíos existenciales para el ser humano en el tiempo presente son el transhumanismo, el discurso transgénero y el digitalismo. Estos tres fenómenos contienen demandas de justicia y emancipación dirigidas a acabar con formas de discriminación muy arraigadas. Pero están sostenidos sobre una base filosófica que niega la inteligibilidad de la realidad y la condición teleológica de la existencia humana proponiendo, en su lugar, la hegemonía del deseo individual. El capitalismo contemporáneo ha hecho de la satisfacción de ese deseo su razón de ser. Y lo hace desarrollando una tecnología potencialmente capaz de satisfacer un deseo sin límites. Ese desarrollo tecnológico se sustenta en el espíritu de abstracción. Es la expresión más sofisticada del capitalismo porque, en lugar de suscitar la oposición de sus víctimas, genera su completa adhesión. La inevitable consecuencia es que las demandas de justicia son engullidas por la lógica del tecno-capitalismo y acaban convertidas en el maquillaje de las nuevas formas de (auto)explotación.
- 1 May 2020
- Vol. 31 (102) , 167-182
BIOETHICS, HUMAN RIGHTS AND COVID-19
In this paper present, from a bioethical perspective, a reflection on how to reconcile efforts to combat the COVID-19 pandemic with the safeguard of human rights. To do this, I develop three points. First, the regulatory framework that justifies the restriction or suspension of rights in the face of serious threats to public health. Second, the declarations of the international bioethics committees on the way in which human rights should be protected during public health crisis. And third, a review of the main rights threatened both by the public health crisis and by the means adopted to combat it. Before going into each of these points, I offer a preliminary note to clarify certain legal concepts and underline the need to overcome disjunctive approaches in considering human rights.
- 1 May 2020
- Vol. 31 (102) , 167-182
BIOETHICS, HUMAN RIGHTS AND COVID-19
In this paper present, from a bioethical perspective, a reflection on how to reconcile efforts to combat the COVID-19 pandemic with the safeguard of human rights. To do this, I develop three points. First, the regulatory framework that justifies the restriction or suspension of rights in the face of serious threats to public health. Second, the declarations of the international bioethics committees on the way in which human rights should be protected during public health crisis. And third, a review of the main rights threatened both by the public health crisis and by the means adopted to combat it. Before going into each of these points, I offer a preliminary note to clarify certain legal concepts and underline the need to overcome disjunctive approaches in considering human rights.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 277-300
From Eunomia to Paideia: The Educating Nature of Law
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 277-300
From Eunomia to Paideia: The Educating Nature of Law
- 2 November 2019
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 181-189
Ecological Justice in the Anthropocene: A Proposal
- 2 November 2019
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 181-189
Ecological Justice in the Anthropocene: A Proposal