ZOZiggy O'REilly

Ziggy O'REilly

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Ziggy O'REilly has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Justifications of Moral Responsibility Attribution towards a Humanoid Robot

    by Ziggy O'REilly, Serena Marchesi, Agnieszka Wykowska

    As robots increasingly participate in society it is crucial to understand which factors influence the degree to which individuals attribute moral responsibility towards them. In a previously reported study, participants read vignettes about a humanoid robot causing either a negative or a positive consequence. Participants rated the moral responsibility and intentionality of the robot, and explained the reasoning behind their ratings. In this paper we (1) conducted an exploratory cluster analysis on their textual justifications of their moral responsibility ratings using word-embeddings and (2) investigated the correlation between moral responsibility ratings and the proportion of words participants use from each cluster. We found that participants who used more words from the “event detection” cluster were more likely to attribute higher moral responsibility to the humanoid robot. Conversely, those who used more words from the “mechanistic properties” cluster tended to attribute less moral responsibility to the humanoid robot. These findings illustrate that moral responsibility attributions could be influenced by the proportion to which individuals refer to events and mechanistic properties.

  • Open Access

    The impact of action descriptions on attribution of moral responsibility towards robots

    by Ziggy O'REilly, Serena Marchesi, Agnieszka Wykowska

    In the era of renewed fascination with AI and robotics, one needs to address questions related to their societal impact, particularly in terms of moral responsibility and intentionality. In seven vignette-based experiments we investigated whether the consequences of a robot or human’s actions, influenced participant’s intentionality and moral responsibility ratings. For the robot, when the vignettes contained mentalistic descriptions, moral responsibility ratings were higher for negative action consequences than positive action consequences, however, there was no difference in intentionality ratings. Whereas, for the human, both moral responsibility and intentionality ratings were higher for negative action consequences. Once the mentalistic descriptions were removed from the vignettes and the moral responsibility question was clarified, we found a reversed asymmetry. For both robots and humans, participants attributed more intentionality and praise, for positive action consequences than negative action consequences. We suggest that this reversal could be due to people defaulting to charitable explanations, when explicit references to culpable mental states are removed from the vignettes.

  • Open Access

    Moral Narratives of Robots Increase the Likelihood of Adopting the Intentional Stance

    by Ziggy O'REilly, Serena Marchesi, Agnieszka Wykowska

    This study investigated whether mentalistic text-vignettes of a robot enhances participants’ tendency to adopt the intentional stance. We also investigated whether the valence of a robot's action consequence influences judgements of intentionality and moral responsibility. We presented participants with scenarios from the InStance Test before and after they read the mentalistic text-vignettes. We found that InStance scores were significantly higher after they read the text-vignettes, implying an increased likelihood of adopting the intentional stance. This effect may have arisen from the mentalistic description of the robot, which could have primed participants to mentally simulate its experiences. Additionally, we found that the valence of a robot's action consequence did not significantly affect ratings of intentionality, which replicates previous results. However, unlike previous studies the valence of the action consequence did not affect moral responsibility ratings. Future studies could investigate (1) how the appearance of a robot influences moral responsibility judgements and (2) if text-vignettes using mechanistic descriptions modulate the tendency to adopt the intentional stance.


  • Open Access

    Does Exposure to Technological Knowledge Modulate the Adoption of the Intentional Stance Towards Humanoid Robots in Children?

    by Ziggy O'REilly, Cecilia Roselli, Agnieszka Wykowska

    Humanoid robots are being increasingly employed in educational and therapeutic settings with children. Thus, it calls for examining whether exposure to technological knowledge about the mechanical workings of humanoid robots can affect children’s perception of robots as agents with intentionality (i.e., adoption of the Intentional Stance). In this study, we presented a group of school children with a two-hour theoretical and practical workshop focused on programming robotic components. In two sessions, namely before (Pre Session) and after the workshop (Post Session), we administered the InStance Test (IST), to assess whether children’s likelihood of adopting the Intentional Stance was modulated by the knowledge children acquired about robots during the workshop. Results showed no significant difference in the IST scores across sessions, indicating that exposure to technological knowledge did not modulate the likelihood of adopting the Intentional Stance across the sessions. These findings suggest that brief exposure to knowledge about the mechanisms behind a humanoid robot is not sufficient to modulate children’s perceptions of humanoid robots.


  • Open Access

    Does Embodiment and Interaction Affect the Adoption of the Intentional Stance Towards a Humanoid Robot?

    by Ziggy O'Reilly, Uma Prashant Navare, Serena Marchesi, Agnieszka Wykowska

    Humanoid robots are a useful research tool to understand which factors trigger the adoption of the Intentional Stance (i.e., the attribution of mental states). The InStance Test (IST), assesses this with the isolated robot subscale and the social robot subscale - where higher scores reflect a greater tendency to adopt the Intentional Stance. Previous work found that when a human interacts with an embodied robot exhibiting human-like behaviour, their IST scores in-crease. However, it is not yet known whether this effect is robust to changes in embodiment or interaction. Subsequently, we administered both subscales before and after participants witnessed a humanoid robot exhibiting human-like behav-iour. There was a significant increase in both scales after participants (1) inter-acted with the embodied robot, (2) watched a video of the robot interacting with a human and (3) watched a video of the robot without interaction. Secondly, to check there were no differences across the human-like experiments, we compared the differences of the magnitude of the IST score increase. We found no signifi-cant differences across the experiments. Additionally, we conducted follow-up control analyses’ with the robot exhibiting machine-like behaviour, to ensure the increases were not due to exposure effects. We found no significant difference in the IST after participants (1) interacted with the embodied robot or (2) watched a video of the robot interacting with a human. These results show that the in-creased IST scores after witnessing iCub behaving in a human-like way, is not due to mere exposure and is robust to changes in embodiment and interaction.


  • Open Access

    Modulating the Intentional Stance: Humanoid Robots, Narrative and Autistic Traits

    by Ziggy O'Reilly, Davide Ghiglino, Nicolas Spatola, Agnieszka Wykowska

    To enhance collaboration between humans and robots it might be important to trigger towards humanoid robots, similar social cognitive mechanisms that are triggered towards humans, such as the adoption of the intentional stance (i.e., explaining an agents behavior with reference to mental states). This study aimed (1) to measure whether a film modulates participants’ tendency to adopt the intentional stance toward a humanoid robot and; (2) to investigate whether autistic traits affects this adoption. We administered two subscales of the InStance Test (IST) (i.e. ‘isolated robot’ subscale and ‘social robot’ subscale) before and after participants watched a film depicting an interaction between a humanoid robot and a human. On the isolated robot subscale, individuals with low autistic traits were more likely to adopt the intentional stance towards a humanoid robot after they watched the film, but there was no effect on individuals with high autistic traits.On the social robot subscale (i.e.when the robot is interactingwith a human) both individuals with low and high autistic traits decreased in their adoption of the intentional stance after they watched the film. This suggests that the content of the narrative and an individual’s social cognitive abilities, affects the degree to which the intentional stance towards a humanoid robot is adopted.